XML 1134 R15.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v2.4.1.9
Employee Retirement Plans
12 Months Ended
Mar. 31, 2015
Employee Retirement Plans
(6)   EMPLOYEE RETIREMENT PLANS

U.S. Defined Benefit Pension Plan

The company has a defined benefit pension plan (pension plan) that covers certain U.S. citizen employees and other employees who are permanent residents of the United States. Benefits are based on years of service and employee compensation. In December 2009, the Board of Directors amended the pension plan to discontinue the accrual of benefits once the plan was frozen on December 31, 2010. On that date, previously accrued pension benefits under the pension plan were frozen for the approximately 60 active employees who participated in the plan. As of March 31, 2015, approximately 45 employees are covered by this plan. This change did not affect benefits earned by participants prior to January 1, 2011. Active employees who previously accrued benefits under the pension plan continue to accrue benefits as participants in the company’s defined contribution retirement plan effective January 1, 2011. The transfer of employee benefits from a defined benefit pension plan to a defined contribution plan have provided the company with more predictable retirement plan costs and cash flows. The company’s future benefit obligations and requirements for cash contributions for the frozen pension plan have also been reduced. Losses associated with the curtailment of the pension plan were immaterial. No amounts were contributed to the defined benefit pension plan during fiscal 2015 and 2014. Management is working with its actuary to determine if a contribution will be necessary during fiscal 2016.

 

Supplemental Executive Retirement Plan

The company also offers a non-contributory, defined benefit supplemental executive retirement plan (supplemental plan) that provides pension benefits to certain employees in excess of those allowed under the company’s tax-qualified pension plan. A Rabbi Trust has been established for the benefit of participants in the supplemental plan. The Rabbi Trust assets, which are invested in a variety of marketable securities (but not Tidewater stock) are recorded at fair value with unrealized gains or losses included in other comprehensive income. Effective March 4, 2010, the supplemental plan was closed to new participation. The supplemental plan is a non-qualified plan and, as such, the company is not required to make contributions to the supplemental plan. The company did not contribute to the supplemental plan during fiscal 2015 and 2014. Management has not made any decision on funding the plan during fiscal 2016.

As a result of the May 31, 2012 retirement of Dean E. Taylor, former President and Chief Executive Officer of Tidewater Inc., Mr. Taylor received in December 2012 a $13 million lump sum distribution in full settlement and discharge of his supplemental executive retirement plan benefit. A settlement loss of $5.2 million related to this distribution was recorded in general and administrative expenses during the quarter ended December 31, 2012. The settlement loss is the result of the recognition of previously unrecognized actuarial losses that were being amortized over time from accumulated other comprehensive income to pension expense. As a result of the December 2012 lump sum distribution, a portion of the previously unrecognized actuarial losses was required to be recognized in earnings in the current quarter in accordance with ASC 715.

Investments held in a Rabbi Trust in the supplemental plan are included in other assets at fair value. The following table summarizes the carrying value of the trust assets, including unrealized gains or losses at March 31:

 

(In thousands)    2015      2014        

Investments held in Rabbi Trust

   $         9,915         10,285      

Unrealized (loss) gains in carrying value of trust assets

     235         92      

Unrealized (loss) gains in carrying value of trust assets are net of income tax expense of

     126         49      

Obligations under the supplemental plan

     25,510         21,918        

The unrealized gains or losses in the carrying value of the trust assets, net of income tax expense, are included in accumulated other comprehensive income (other stockholders’ equity). To the extent that trust assets are liquidated to fund benefit payments, gains or losses, if any, will be recognized at that time. The company’s obligations under the supplemental plan are included in ‘accrued expenses’ and ‘other liabilities and deferred credits’ on the consolidated balance sheet.

Postretirement Benefit Plan

Qualified retired employees currently are covered by a program which provides limited health care and life insurance benefits. Costs of the program are based on actuarially determined amounts and are accrued over the period from the date of hire to the full eligibility date of employees who are expected to qualify for these benefits. This plan is funded through payments as benefits are required.

Investment Strategies

Pension Plan

The obligations of our pension plan are supported by assets held in a trust for the payment of future benefits. The company is obligated to adequately fund the trust. For the pension plan assets, the company has the following primary investment objectives: (1) closely match the cash flows from the plan’s investments from interest payments and maturities with the payment obligations from the plan’s liabilities; (2) closely match the duration of plan assets with the duration of plan liabilities and (3) enhance the plan’s investment returns without taking on undue risk by industries, maturities or geographies of the underlying investment holdings.

 

If the plan assets are less than the plan liabilities, the pension plan assets will be invested exclusively in fixed income debt securities. Any investments in corporate bonds shall be at least investment grade, while mortgage and asset-backed securities must be rated “A” or better. If an investment is placed on credit watch, or is downgraded to a level below the investment grade, the holding will be liquidated, even at a loss, in a reasonable time period. The plan will only hold investments in equity securities if the plan assets exceed the estimated plan liabilities.

The cash flow requirements of the pension plan will be analyzed at least annually. Portfolio repositioning will be required when material changes to the plan liabilities are identified and when opportunities arise to better match cash flows with the known liabilities. Additionally, trades will occur when opportunities arise to improve the yield-to-maturity or credit quality of the portfolio.

The company’s policy for the pension plan is to contribute no less than the minimum required contribution by law and no more than the maximum deductible amount. The plan does not invest in Tidewater stock.

Supplemental Plan

The investment policy of the supplemental plan is to assess the historical returns and risk associated with alternative investment strategies to achieve an expected rate of return on plan assets. The objectives of the plan are designed to maximize total returns within prudent parameters of risk for a retirement plan of this type. The below table summarizes the supplemental plan’s minimum and maximum rate of return objectives for plan assets:

 

      Minimum
Expected
Rate of Return
on Plan Assets
  Maximum
Expected
Rate of Return
on Plan Assets
    

Equity securities

   5%   7%  

Debt securities

   1%   3%  

Cash and cash equivalents

   0%   1%    

Whereas fluctuating rates of return are characteristic of the securities markets, the investment objective of the supplemental plan is to achieve investment returns sufficient to meet the actuarial assumptions. This is defined as an investment return greater than the current actuarial discount rate assumption of 4.00%, which is subject to annual upward or downward revisions.

The below table summarizes the supplemental plan’s minimum and maximum market value objectives for plan assets, which are based upon a five to ten year investment horizon:

 

      Minimum
Market Value
Objective for
Plan Assets
  Maximum
Market Value
Objective for
Plan Assets
    

Equity securities

   55%   75%  

Debt securities

   25%   45%  

Percentage of debt securities allowed in below investment grade bonds

     0%   20%  

Cash and cash equivalents

     0%   10%    

Equity holdings shall be restricted to issues of corporations that are actively traded on the major U.S. exchanges and NASDAQ. Debt security investments may include all securities issued by the U.S. Treasury or other federal agencies and investment grade corporate bonds. When a particular asset class exceeds its minimum or maximum allocation ranges, rebalancing will be addressed upon review of the quarterly performance reports and as cash contributions and withdrawals are made.

 

Pension and Supplemental Plan Asset Allocations

The following table provides the target and actual asset allocations for the pension plan and the supplemental plan:

 

      Target     Actual as of
2015
    Actual as of
2014
      

Pension plan:

        

Equity securities

                       

Debt securities

     100     95     96  

Cash and other 

            5     4    

Total

     100     100     100  

 

Supplemental plan:

        

Equity securities

     65     58     60  

Debt securities

     35     39     37  

Cash and other

            3     3    

Total

     100     100     100  

 

Significant Concentration Risks

The pension plan and the supplemental plan assets are periodically evaluated for concentration risks. As of March 31, 2015, the company did not have any individual asset investments that comprised 10% or more of each plan’s overall assets.

The pension plan assets are primarily invested in debt securities with no more than the greater of 5% of the fixed income portfolio or $2.5 million being invested in the securities of a single issuer, except investments in U.S. Treasury and other federal agency obligations. In the event that plan assets exceed the estimated plan liabilities for the pension plan, up to two times the difference between the plan assets and plan liabilities may be invested in equity securities, and so long as equities do not exceed 15% of the market value of the assets. The investment policy sets forth that the maximum single investment of the equity portfolio is 5% of the portfolio market value. Further, investments in foreign securities are restricted to American Depository Receipts (ADR) and stocks listed on the U.S. stock exchanges and may not exceed 10% of the equity portfolio.

The current diversification policy for the supplemental plan sets forth that equity securities in any single industry sector shall not exceed 25% of the equity portfolio market value and shall not exceed 10% market value of the equity portfolio for equity holdings in any single corporation. Additionally, debt securities should be diversified between issuers within each sector with no one issuer comprising more than 10% of the aggregate fixed income portfolio, excluding issues of the U.S. Treasury or other federal agencies.

 

Fair Value of Pension Plan and Supplemental Plan Assets

The fair value hierarchy for the pension plan and supplemental plan assets measured at fair value as of March 31, 2015, are as follows:

 

(In thousands)    Fair Value    

Quoted prices in
active

markets

(Level 1)

    Significant
observable
inputs
(Level 2)
     Significant
unobservable
inputs
(Level 3)
       

Pension plan measured at fair value:

            

Debt securities:

            

Government securities

   $ 3,116        3,116                     

Collateralized mortgage securities

     400               400              

Corporate debt securities

     51,758               51,758              

Foreign debt securities

     1,529               1,529              

Cash and cash equivalents

     1,816               1,816                

Total

   $ 58,619        3,116        55,503              

Accrued income

     866        866                       

Total fair value of plan assets

   $ 59,485        3,982        55,503              

 

Supplemental plan measured at fair value:

            

Equity securities:

            

Common stock

   $ 3,859        3,859                     

Preferred stock

                                

Foreign stock

     201        201                     

American depository receipts

     1,685        1,685                     

Preferred American depository receipts

     15        15                     

Real estate investment trusts

     59        59                     

Debt securities:

            

Government debt securities

     1,926        1,377        549              

Open ended mutual funds

     1,916        1,916                     

Cash and cash equivalents

     377        72        305                

Total

   $ 10,038        9,184        854              

Other pending transactions

     (123     (123                    

Total fair value of plan assets

   $         9,915        9,061        854              

 

 

The following table provides the fair value hierarchy for the pension plan and supplemental plan assets measured at fair value as of March 31, 2014:

 

(In thousands)    Fair Value    

Quoted prices in
active

markets

(Level 1)

    Significant
observable
inputs
(Level 2)
     Significant
unobservable
inputs
(Level 3)
       

Pension plan measured at fair value:

            

Debt securities:

            

Government securities

   $ 2,935        2,935                     

Corporate debt securities

     50,113               50,113              

Foreign debt securities

     1,443               1,443              

Cash and cash equivalents

     1,511               1,511                

Total

   $ 56,002        2,935        53,067              

Accrued income

     894        894                       

Total fair value of plan assets

   $ 56,896        3,829        53,067              

 

Supplemental plan measured at fair value:

            

Equity securities:

            

Common stock

   $ 4,141        4,141                     

Preferred stock

                                

Foreign stock

     231        231                     

American depository receipts

     1,809        1,809                     

Preferred American depository receipts

     15        15                     

Real estate investment trusts

     38        38                     

Debt securities:

            

Government debt securities

     1,975        1,363        612              

Open ended mutual funds

     1,797        1,797                     

Cash and cash equivalents

     369        57        312                

Total

   $ 10,375        9,451        924              

Other pending transactions

     (90     (90                    

Total fair value of plan assets

   $ 10,285        9,361        924              

 

 

Plan Assets and Obligations

Changes in plan assets and obligations during the years ended March 31, 2015 and 2014 and the funded status of the U.S. defined benefit pension plan and the supplemental plan (referred to collectively as “Pension Benefits”) and the postretirement health care and life insurance plan (referred to as “Other Benefits”) at March 31, are as follows:

 

     Pension Benefits     Other Benefits
(In thousands)    2015     2014     2015     2014       

Change in benefit obligation:

          

Benefit obligation at beginning of year

   $       84,067        88,238        24,114        29,006     

Service cost

     825        790        273        405     

Interest cost

     3,873        3,581        904        1,048     

Participant contributions

                   430        436     

ERRP reimbursement

                          (26  

Plan settlement

                              

Benefits paid

     (4,405     (4,250     (863     (962  

Actuarial (gain) loss

     11,948        (4,292     (932     (5,793    

Benefit obligation at end of year

     96,308        84,067        23,926        24,114     

 

Change in plan assets:

          

Fair value of plan assets at beginning of year

   $ 56,896        59,431                   

Actual return

     6,069        776                   

Employer contributions

     925        939        433        552     

Participant contributions

                   430        436     

ERRP reimbursement

                          (26  

Plan settlement

                              

Benefits paid

     (4,405     (4,250     (863     (962    

Fair value of plan assets at end of year

     59,485        56,896                   

 

Reconciliation of funded status:

          

Fair value of plan assets

   $ 59,485        56,896                   

Benefit obligation

     96,308        84,067        23,926        24,114       

Unfunded status

   $ (36,823     (27,171     (23,926     (24,114  

 

Net amount recognized in the balance sheet consists of:

          

Current liabilities

   $ (1,306     (1,162     (908     (1,129  

Noncurrent liabilities

     (35,517     (26,009     (23,018     (22,985    

Net amount recognized

   $ (36,823     (27,171     (23,926     (24,114  

 

The following table provides the projected benefit obligation and accumulated benefit obligation for the pension plans:

 

(In thousands)    2015      2014        

Projected benefit obligation

   $       96,308         84,067      

Accumulated benefit obligation

     92,808         81,223        

 

The following table provides information for pension plans with an accumulated benefit obligation in excess of plan assets (includes both the pension plan and supplemental plan):

 

(In thousands)    2015      2014        

Projected benefit obligation

   $       96,308         84,067      

Accumulated benefit obligation

     92,808         81,223      

Fair value of plan assets

     59,485         56,896        

Net periodic benefit cost for the pension plan and the supplemental plan for the fiscal years ended March 31 include the following components:

 

(In thousands)    2015     2014     2013       

Service cost

   $ 825        790        983     

Interest cost

     3,873        3,581        4,098     

Expected return on plan assets

     (2,741     (2,871     (2,748  

Amortization of prior service cost

     50        50        50     

Recognized actuarial loss

     988        1,103        1,648     

Settlement loss

                   5,161       

Net periodic pension cost

   $         2,995        2,653        9,192     

 

Net periodic benefit cost for the postretirement health care and life insurance plan for the fiscal years ended March 31 include the following components:

 

(In thousands)    2015     2014     2013       

Service cost

   $             273        405        475     

Interest cost

     904        1,048        1,235     

Amortization of prior service cost

     (2,032     (2,032     (2,032  

Recognized actuarial loss

     (1,299     (396           

Net periodic postretirement benefit

   $ (2,154     (975     (322  

 

Other changes in plan assets and benefit obligations recognized in other comprehensive income for the fiscal years ended March 31 include the following components:

 

     Pension Benefits     Other Benefits      
(In thousands)    2015     2014     2015     2014       

Change in benefit obligation

          

Net loss (gain)

     $    8,621        (2,196     (932     (5,793  

Settlement loss

                              

Amortization of prior service cost

     (50     (50     2,032        2,032     

Amortization of net (loss) gain

     (988     (1,103     1,299        395     

Other

                          197       

Total recognized in other comprehensive income (loss)

     $    7,583        (3,349     2,399        (3,169    

Net of tax

     7,583        (2,177     1,559        (2,060  

 

Amounts recognized as a component of accumulated other comprehensive (income) loss as of March 31, 2015 are as follows:

 

(In thousands)    Pension Benefits      Other Benefits       

Unrecognized actuarial (gain) loss

     $      21,781         (6,620  

Unrecognized prior service cost (benefit)

     36         (4,588    

Pre-tax amount included in accumulated other comprehensive loss (income)

     $      21,817         (11,208  

 

The company expects to recognize the following amounts as a component of net periodic benefit costs during the next fiscal year:

 

(In thousands)    Pension Benefits      Other Benefits        

Unrecognized actuarial loss

     $        (2,213)         582      

Unrecognized prior service cost (benefit)

     (36)         2,041        

 

Assumptions used to determine net benefit obligations for the fiscal years ended March 31, are as follows:

 

     Pension Benefits      Other Benefits       
      2015      2014      2015      2014        

Discount rate

     4.00%         4.75%         4.00%         4.75%      

Rates of annual increase in compensation levels

     3.00%         3.00%         N/A         N/A        

Assumptions used to determine net periodic benefit costs for the fiscal years ended March 31, are as follows:

 

     Pension Benefits      Other Benefits       
      2015      2014      2013      2015      2014      2013        

Discount rate

     4.75%         4.25%         4.75%         4.75%         4.25%         4.75%      

Expected long-term rate of return on assets

     5.00%         5.00%         5.00%         N/A         N/A         N/A      

Rates of annual increase in compensation levels

     3.00%         3.00%         3.00%         N/A         N/A         N/A        

To develop the expected long-term rate of return on assets assumption, the company considered the current level of expected returns on various asset classes. The expected return for each asset class was then weighted based on the target asset allocation to develop the expected return on plan assets assumption for the portfolio.

Based upon the assumptions used to measure the company’s qualified pension and postretirement benefit obligations at March 31, 2015, including pension and postretirement benefits attributable to estimated future employee service, the company expects that benefits to be paid over the next ten years will be as follows:

 

     (In thousands)       
Year ending March 31,    Pension
Benefits
     Other
Benefits
       

2016

     $        5,578         908          

2017

     5,818         982          

2018

     6,077         1,046          

2019

     6,343         1,128          

2020

     7,419         1,187          

2021 – 2025

     33,918         6,501            

Total 10-year estimated future benefit payments

     $      65,153         11,752          

 

Health Care Cost Trends

The following table discloses the assumed health care cost trends used in measuring the accumulated postretirement benefit obligation and net periodic postretirement benefit cost at March 31, 2015 for pre-65 medical and prescription drug coverage and for post-65 medical coverage, including expected future trend rates.

 

      Pre-65     Post-65       

Year ending March 31, 2015

      

Accumulated postretirement benefit obligation

     7.9     6.9  

Net periodic postretirement benefit obligation

     8.2     6.9  

Ultimate health care cost trend

     4.5     4.5  

Ultimate year health care cost trend rate is achieved

     2029        2029     

Year ending March 31, 2016

      

Net periodic postretirement benefit obligation

     7.9     6.9    

A one-percentage rate increase (decrease) in the assumed health care cost trend rates has the following effects on the accumulated postretirement benefit obligation as of March 31:

 

(In thousands)    1%
Increase
     1%
Decrease
       

Accumulated postretirement benefit obligation

   $       3,702         2,978      

Aggregate service and interest cost

     170         138        

 

Defined Contribution Plans

Prior to February 2013, the company maintained the below two defined contribution plans. The plans were merged in February 2013 to provide administrative efficiencies, potential savings on service provider fees and to simplify the participant experience. Following the merger, the provisions of the two plans remained substantially similar with the exception of cost neutral changes that were approved to simplify the administration of the combined plan.

Retirement Contributions

All eligible U.S. fleet personnel, along with all new eligible employees of the company hired after December 31, 1995 are eligible to receive retirement contributions. Effective January 1, 2011, the active employees who participated in the now frozen defined benefit pension plan also became eligible for retirement contributions. This benefit is noncontributory by the employee, but the company contributes, in cash, 3% of an eligible employee’s compensation to a trust on behalf of the employees. The active employees who participated in the now frozen defined benefit pension plan may receive an additional 1% to 8% depending on age and years of service. Company contributions vest over five years.

401(k) Savings Contribution

Upon meeting various citizenship, age and service requirements, employees are eligible to participate in a defined contribution savings plan and can contribute from 2% to 75% of their base salary to an employee benefit trust. The company matches with company common stock 50% of the first 8% of eligible compensation deferred by the employee. Company contributions vest over five years.

The plan held the following number of shares of Tidewater common stock as of March 31:

 

      2015      2014        

Number of shares of Tidewater common stock held by 401(k) plan

     299,256         273,662        

The amounts charged to expense related to the above defined contribution plans, for the fiscal years ended March 31, are as follows:

 

(In thousands)    2015      2014      2013        

Defined contribution plans expense, net of forfeitures

     $        4,216         3,854         3,356      

Defined contribution plans forfeitures

     52         82         115        

Other Plans

A non-qualified supplemental savings plan is provided to executive officers who have the opportunity to defer up to 50% of their eligible compensation that cannot be deferred under the existing 401(k) plan due to IRS limitations. A company match may be provided on these contributions equal to 50% of the first 8% of eligible compensation deferred by the employee to the extent the employee is not able to receive the full amount of company match to the 401(k) plan due to IRS limitations. The plan also allows participants to defer up to 100% of their bonuses. In addition, an amount equal to any refunds that must be made due to the failure of the 401(k) nondiscrimination test may be deferred into this plan.

Effective March 4, 2010, the non-qualified supplemental savings plan was modified to allow the company to contribute restoration benefits to eligible employees. Employees who do not accrue a benefit in the supplemental executive retirement plan and who are eligible for a contribution in the defined contribution retirement plan automatically become eligible for the restoration benefit when the employee’s eligible retirement compensation exceeds the section 401(a)(17) limit. The restoration benefit is noncontributory by the employee, but the company contributes, in cash, 3% of an eligible employee’s compensation above the 401(a)(17) limit to a trust on behalf of the employees. The active employees who participated in the now frozen defined benefit pension plan may receive an additional 1% to 8% depending on age and years of service.

 

The company also provides a multinational savings plan to eligible non-U.S. citizen employees working outside their respective country of origin and who have been employed for one year of continuous service with the company. Participants of the plan may contribute 1% to 15% of their base salary. The company matches, in cash, 50% of the first 6% of eligible compensation deferred by the employee. Company contributions vest over six years.

The amounts charged to expense related to the multinational pension savings plan contributions, for the fiscal years ended March 31, are as follows:

 

(In thousands)    2015      2014      2013        

Multinational pension savings plan expense

   $         494         465         420        

The company also provides certain benefits programs which are maintained in several other countries that provide retirement income for covered employees.