XML 31 R24.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.25.1
Rate Matters and Regulation
3 Months Ended
Mar. 31, 2025
Regulated Operations [Abstract]  
Rate Matters and Regulation

13. Rate Matters and Regulation

 

Except as disclosed below, the circumstances set forth in Note 14 to the financial statements included in the Registrants' 2024 Form 10-K appropriately represent, in all material respects, the current status of the Registrants' regulatory matters.

 

Completed Regulatory Matters

 

OCC Proceedings

 

2023 Oklahoma General Rate Review

 

In December 2023, OG&E filed a general rate review in Oklahoma seeking a rate increase of $332.5 million and a 10.5 percent return on equity based on a common equity percentage of 53.50 percent. The rate review sought recovery of $1.3 billion of capital investment since the last general rate review. Prior to the hearing on the merits, on June 12, 2024, OG&E entered into an uncontested settlement agreement, which was also executed by the OCC Public Utility Division Staff, the Oklahoma Attorney General, the OG&E Shareholders Association, Oklahoma Industrial Energy Consumers and other intervenors. This settlement agreement resulted in an annual revenue requirement increase of $126.7 million. OG&E had the right to implement interim rates subject to refund beginning July 1, 2024 (180 days after the filing of its application on December 29, 2023). On July 1, 2024, OG&E implemented an annual interim rate increase in line with the settlement agreement, subject to refund based on final approval by the OCC.

 

On November 26, 2024, the OCC issued an interim order approving the settlement agreement. In addition to the annual base rate revenue increase of 126.7 million, other key terms of the uncontested settlement agreement, as approved in the interim order by the OCC, include, among others:

 

All recorded plant-in-service through March 31, 2024 is prudent and should be included in rate base;
There will be no change in OG&E's current return on equity of 9.5 percent, and OG&E's requested capital structure based on a common equity percentage of 53.50 percent would be approved;
OG&E will utilize depreciation rates based on the recommendations of the Federal Executive Agencies for production plant accounts, the Public Utility Division for transmission plant accounts, Oklahoma Industrial Energy Consumers for intangible plant accounts, and no change to existing rates for distribution and general plant accounts; and
OG&E will include in expense any Oklahoma vegetation management operation and maintenance expenses up to $38.2 million annually and defer to a regulatory asset or liability the total level of expense less than or greater than the $38.2 million annual base level of expense. The regulatory asset will be up to $7.5 million in excess of the base rate level and no carrying charge will accrue on the regulatory asset/liability. The costs booked to the regulatory asset or liability will be subject to a prudence review in OG&E’s next general rate review.

 

Due to the November 26, 2024 OCC interim order approving the settlement agreement, no refund of interim rates was deemed necessary. On March 27, 2025, the OCC issued a final order in this matter, which affirmed its previous order approving the settlement agreement and approved the ALJ report on the remaining one MW issue with one exception. The one exception stated that in its next general rate review, OG&E shall directly assign the costs of transmission radials to new competitive load customers that are added to the system after November 1, 2023. No other changes were made to rates implemented effective July 1, 2024 after the November 26, 2024 interim order. While the OCC’s final order has been appealed, the rates will remain in effect.

 

2023 Oklahoma Fuel Prudency

 

On June 10, 2024, the Public Utility Division Staff filed their application initiating the prudence review of the 2023 fuel adjustment clause. The OCC issued an order on April 22, 2025 finding that OG&E's 2023 fuel costs and generation operations were prudent.

 

Pending Regulatory Matters

 

Various proceedings pending before state or federal regulatory agencies are described below. Unless stated otherwise, the Registrants cannot predict when the regulatory agency will act or what action the regulatory agency will take. The Registrants' financial results are dependent in part on timely and constructive decisions by the regulatory agencies that set OG&E's rates.

 

APSC Proceedings

 

Arkansas Prudence of Horseshoe Lake and Tinker Generation Facilities

 

On December 30, 2024, pursuant to orders in the generation construction notice filings, OG&E filed an application requesting a determination of prudence of action and initial contract costs for the generating units being constructed at Horseshoe Lake and Tinker Air Force Base. On March 10, 2025, at the request of APSC Staff, OG&E filed supplemental testimony detailing the contracts and additional information about initial costs of the projects.

 

FERC Proceedings

 

Order for Sponsored Transmission Upgrades within SPP

 

Under Attachment Z2 of the SPP Open Access Transmission Tariff, costs of participant-funded, or "sponsored," transmission upgrades may be recovered from other SPP customers whose transmission service depends on capacity enabled by the upgrade. The SPP tariff required the SPP to charge for these upgrades beginning in 2008, but the SPP did not begin charging its customers for these upgrades until 2016 due to information system limitations. The FERC approved a waiver of a time limitation in the SPP tariff to allow the SPP to bill after this delay for the 2008 through 2015 period, and the SPP then both billed OG&E as a user and credited OG&E as a sponsor for Z2 charges during the period. OG&E refunded most of the net credits to customers through its various rate riders that include SPP activity with the remaining amounts retained by OG&E.

 

Net payers of Z2 credits challenged the waiver, and the FERC ultimately reversed itself, denied the waiver and ordered the SPP to refund the payments made for 2008 through 2015 charges. OG&E and other net creditors challenged this reversal, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit upheld the reversal in August 2021. Meanwhile, OG&E and other creditors filed complaints with the FERC against the SPP, contending that the SPP and not OG&E should bear the cost of any refunds resulting from the SPP's tariff violations and that SPP’s actions also violated its contracts. In June 2023, the FERC issued a final order granting the complaints in part but awarding no relief. OG&E and other complainants appealed this order to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, which heard arguments on March 14, 2024 and on September 16, 2024, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit denied relief and upheld the FERC's decision.

 

If the FERC proceeds to order refunds in full, OG&E estimates it would be required to refund $14.0 million, which is net of amounts paid to other utilities for upgrades, plus interest at the FERC-approved rate. Payment of refunds would shift recovery of these upgrade credits to future periods. The SPP has submitted filings to the FERC outlining a refund process but stating some issues need the FERC's clarification before refunds can proceed. OG&E and other parties have commented on the filings and the matter remains pending before the FERC. Of the $14.0 million, the Registrants would be impacted by $4.0 million in expense that initially benefited the Registrants in 2016, and OG&E customers would incur a net impact of $10.0 million in expense through rider mechanisms or the FERC formula rate. As of March 31, 2025, the Registrants have reserved $14.0 million plus estimated interest for a potential refund.

 

Effective July 1, 2020, the FERC approved an SPP proposal to eliminate Attachment Z2 revenue crediting and replace it with a different rate mechanism that would provide project sponsors, such as OG&E, the same level of recovery. This elimination of the Attachment Z2 revenue crediting would only prospectively impact OG&E and its recovery of any future upgrade costs that it may incur as a project sponsor subsequent to July 2020. All of the existing projects that are eligible to receive revenue credits under Attachment Z2 will remain eligible, which includes the $14.0 million related to the refunds.

 

OCC Proceedings

 

Oklahoma Retail Electric Supplier Certified Territory Act Causes

 

As previously disclosed, several rural electric cooperative electricity suppliers filed complaints with the OCC alleging that OG&E, because it was providing service to large loads in another supplier's territory, had violated the Oklahoma Retail Electric Supplier Certified Territory Act. OG&E believes it is lawfully serving customers under specific exemptions under this act that allow it to serve customers having a load of one MW or greater. There were five complaint cases initiated at the OCC, and the OCC issued decisions on each of them. The OCC ruled in favor of the electric cooperatives in three of those cases under statutory interpretation and ruled in favor of OG&E in two of those cases under injunctive theory. All five of those cases were appealed to the Oklahoma Supreme Court.

 

On April 4, 2023, the Oklahoma Supreme Court issued its opinion which vacated the OCC's injunctions with respect to four of the cases and held that the Oklahoma Retail Electric Supplier Certified Territory Act does not limit the mechanism by which OG&E may provide service to large loads in another supplier's territory pursuant to the one MW exception. The one pending legal issue left for the Oklahoma Supreme Court to resolve is a statutory interpretation on how a supplier calculates "connected load for initial full operation" for purposes of the exemption under the act. If the Oklahoma Supreme Court ultimately were to find that the customers being served in this single case are not exempted from the Oklahoma Retail Electric Supplier Certified Territory Act, OG&E would have to evaluate the recoverability of some plant investments made to serve these customers and may also be required to reimburse the certified territory supplier in this case for an amount of lost revenue. Such amounts would not be expected to be material to the Registrants' results of operations.

 

On March 4, 2025, the Oklahoma Supreme Court issued a decision in one of the other companion cases and reversed itself, finding that OG&E may not “extend service” from third-party transmission facilities. This ruling was prospective in nature, which means OG&E may still serve the customers subject to the ruling, but in the future, OG&E may not extend services off of third-party transmission facilities.

 

2024 Oklahoma Fuel Prudency

 

On April 1, 2025, the Public Utility Division Staff filed their application initiating the prudence review of the 2024 fuel adjustment clause. OG&E expects to file its minimum filing requirements and direct testimony no later than June 1, 2025, in accordance with OCC rules.

 

SPP Proceedings

 

Resource Capacity Accreditation

 

In July 2022, the SPP Board of Directors approved a new unit accreditation methodology for conventional generation which requires submittal to and approval from the FERC prior to becoming effective. On March 2, 2023, the FERC rejected the SPP’s proposed capacity accreditation methodology for wind and solar generators. Following the FERC’s rejection, the SPP began an extensive review of both the methodology proposed for thermal resources which had not yet been submitted to the FERC, and the accreditation methodology for wind and solar generators. These methodologies were reviewed and approved by both the Regional State Committee and the SPP Board of Directors in late October 2023 and were submitted to the FERC for approval on February 23, 2024. On January 16, 2025, the FERC accepted the SPP's proposed tariff revisions for each accreditation methodology to become effective October 1, 2025. OG&E is evaluating the impact of the FERC's acceptance of these accreditation methods, which may contribute to OG&E’s capacity needs.