-----BEGIN PRIVACY-ENHANCED MESSAGE-----
Proc-Type: 2001,MIC-CLEAR
Originator-Name: webmaster@www.sec.gov
Originator-Key-Asymmetric:
 MFgwCgYEVQgBAQICAf8DSgAwRwJAW2sNKK9AVtBzYZmr6aGjlWyK3XmZv3dTINen
 TWSM7vrzLADbmYQaionwg5sDW3P6oaM5D3tdezXMm7z1T+B+twIDAQAB
MIC-Info: RSA-MD5,RSA,
 K66F6LQjvSxa5uO3q+UoHcKsrTa/hwsMt2D7+yjE4WczDhEa3/Qak+NtTL5GmYrf
 6eYPWSA/KRKYAalzcRo7mw==

<SEC-DOCUMENT>0000891092-05-001931.txt : 20060828
<SEC-HEADER>0000891092-05-001931.hdr.sgml : 20060828
<ACCEPTANCE-DATETIME>20051005120158
<PRIVATE-TO-PUBLIC>
ACCESSION NUMBER:		0000891092-05-001931
CONFORMED SUBMISSION TYPE:	CORRESP
PUBLIC DOCUMENT COUNT:		1
FILED AS OF DATE:		20051005

FILER:

	COMPANY DATA:	
		COMPANY CONFORMED NAME:			GROUP SIMEC SA DE CV
		CENTRAL INDEX KEY:			0000887153
		STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATION:	STEEL WORKS, BLAST FURNACES  ROLLING MILLS (COKE OVENS) [3312]
		IRS NUMBER:				000000000
		FISCAL YEAR END:			1231

	FILING VALUES:
		FORM TYPE:		CORRESP

	BUSINESS ADDRESS:	
		STREET 1:		CALZADA LAZARO CARDENAS 601
		CITY:			44910 GUADALAJARA JA
		STATE:			O5
		ZIP:			10022

	MAIL ADDRESS:	
		STREET 1:		CALZADA LAZARO CARDENAS
		CITY:			GUADALAJARA JALISCO
		STATE:			O5
		ZIP:			999999999
</SEC-HEADER>
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>CORRESP
<SEQUENCE>1
<FILENAME>filename1.htm
<TEXT>
<HTML>
<HEAD>
<TITLE></TITLE>
</HEAD>
<BODY>




<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Center Head 2 no bold" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P ALIGN=CENTER><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>October 5, 2005 </FONT></P>




<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>Securities and Exchange Commission<BR>
Division of Corporation Finance <BR>100 F Street NE <BR>Washington, D.C. 20549 <BR>Attn: Patricia
Armelin </FONT></P>


<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Hang 15" FSL="Workstation" -->
<TABLE WIDTH=100% CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0>
<TR VALIGN=TOP>
<TD WIDTH=10%><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2> &nbsp; </FONT></TD>
<TD WIDTH=5%><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>
                           Re:  </FONT></TD>
<TD WIDTH=85%><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>Grupo
Simec, S.A. de C.V. <BR>                                    Form 20-F for the year ended
December 31, 2004    <BR>                                 Filed July 12, 2005<BR>
                                    File # 1-11176 </FONT></TD>
</TR>
</TABLE>
<BR>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>Dear Sirs: </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;This
is in response to the letter of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the &#147;Commission&#148;)
dated September 8, 2005, pursuant to which the staff of the Commission has raised one
comment with respect to our Annual Report on Form 20-F referenced above. With respect to
Note 18 of Grupo Simec&#146;s consolidated financial statements, &#147;Differences between Mexican
and United States accounting principles,&#148; included in the above-referenced Annual Report,
the comment of the staff is as follows: &#147;We note that holders of your variable capital
common stock may require you to redeem those shares. Please provide us with a
comprehensive discussion of how you considered FRP 211 and concluded that those shares
did not need to be classified outside permanent equity under U.S. GAAP.&#148; </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;We
believe that, notwithstanding FRP 211, it is appropriate under U.S. GAAP to classify our
variable common stock as permanent capital. We further believe that separately presenting
variable common stock and fixed common stock on our balance sheet and including the full
range of additional disclosures contemplated by FRP 211 would not provide meaningful
information to investors and as a practical matter would be confusing and potentially
misleading. We note that FRP 211 appears to apply only to redeemable preferred stock and
not to common stock (while the text of FRP 211 indicates that its coverage is limited to
preferred stock, the definition of &#147;Redeemable Preferred Stock&#148; contained in Section
211.02 is ambiguous as to whether only preferred stock or all classes of stock are within
the definition). Nonetheless, we believe that our variable common stock is disguishable
from the type of redeemable security upon which FRP 211 is focused such that the
treatment called for by FRP 211 with respect to redeemable preferred stock is not
applicable to our variable common stock. </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE="2">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Under
Mexican law, all Mexican companies organized as a <I>sociedad anonima de capital variable
</I>may have both fixed and variable common stock. The variable portion of the capital stock
of a Mexican company organized as a <I>sociedad anonima de capital variable </I>which is listed
on the Mexican Stock Exchange may never exceed ten times the amount represented by the
fixed </FONT> </P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Page Break LEFT (Pro)" FSL="Workstation" -->
<BR>&nbsp;
<TABLE WIDTH=100%><TR><TD WIDTH=10% ALIGN=left><FONT SIZE=1></FONT></TD>
<TD WIDTH=80% ALIGN=center>
<FONT SIZE="1">  </FONT>
</TD>
<TD WIDTH=10% ALIGN=right><FONT SIZE="1">&nbsp;</FONT>
</TD></TR></TABLE><HR SIZE=5 NOSHADE WIDTH=100% ALIGN=LEFT>




<!-- *************************************************************************** -->
<!-- MARKER PAGE="sheet: 1; page: 1" -->

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>Securities and Exchange Commission<BR>
Division of Corporation Finance<BR>October 5, 2005 <BR>Page 2 </FONT></P>


<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>portion. At December 31, 2004, Grupo
Simec&#146;s total share capital was consisted of 133,542,984 shares, comprised of 15,283,350
shares of fixed capital stock (all of which are held by Grupo Simec&#146;s controlling
shareholder Industrias CH, S.A. de C.V.) and 118,259,634 shares of variable capital
stock. The fixed and variable capital stock are identical in all respects in the hands of
investors, economically and otherwise, other than with respect to the redemption feature
attendant to the variable capital stock. </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;The
redemption right which exists with respect to our variable common stock is a right
granted stockholders under Mexican law and is not a term of the common stock itself. On
the other hand, preferred stock may have a redemption feature made part of its terms
pursuant to negotiations with investors. The distinction is important in that negotiated
redemption provisions of preferred stock issuances are terms investors have bargained
for, and are an element of an investment decision which investors expect to be able to
avail themselves of when circumstances warrant (e.g., the redemption terms offer a
superior return on investment than a sale of the security or there is inadequate
liquidity for the sale of the security). The provisions of Mexican law relating to the
redemption features of variable common stock on the other hand are provisions which are
applicable to the variable common stock of all Mexican issuers and, accordingly, are not
terms investors deem as integral to their investment decision and do not view as
substantive. These redemption provisions, presumably designed to give minority investors
the opportunity to dispose of a security in the absence of a liquid capital market, have
existed in Mexico since 1934 and have not been amended since their enactment. </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Notwithstanding
that Mexican law does afford investors redemption rights with respect to variable common
stock, as a practical matter the timing and pricing mechanism provided under Mexican law
are so unwieldy as to make the redemption feature impractical. As outlined on pages F-45
through F-46 of our consolidated financial statements and page 39 of the Annual Report,
there are significant practical limitations on the utility of the redemption right.
First, investors must give ample advance notice of a redemption: (A) if the notice is
given in the first three quarters of a fiscal year, such redemption is effective with
respect to that fiscal year, with payment to be made subsequent to the annual
shareholders&#146; meeting at which the relevant annual financial statements (and, if agreed
by the shareholders, the redemption) are approved (typically approximately 120 days or so
after the end of the fiscal year), thus payment would occur no earlier than seven months
after notice is given and (B) if the notice is given in the fourth quarter of a fiscal
year, such redemption is effective with respect to the subsequent fiscal year, with
payment to be made subsequent to the annual shareholders&#146; meeting at which the relevant
annual financial statements of such subsequent fiscal year (and, if agreed by the
shareholders, the redemption) are approved (typically approximately 120 days or so after
the end of such fiscal year), thus payment would occur no earlier than sixteen months
after notice is given. Secondly, upon giving notice, the investor will not know and will
not be able to determine or estimate with any significant degree of certainty the
redemption price to be received, which would be the lower of (i) 95% of the average
market value of the shares on the Mexican Stock Exchange for the final 30 trading days of
the subject fiscal year and (ii) the book value of the shares at the end of subject
fiscal year. Accordingly, in addition to a substantial time delay in effecting redemption </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="5 pt rule no space" FSL="Workstation" -->
<HR SIZE=5 NOSHADE WIDTH=100% ALIGN=LEFT>




<!-- *************************************************************************** -->
<!-- MARKER PAGE="sheet: 2; page: 2" -->

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>Securities and Exchange Commission<BR>
Division of Corporation Finance<BR>October 5, 2005 <BR>Page 3 </FONT></P>





<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>subsequent to giving notice thereof,
the redemption price will be determined subsequent to notice based on the formula
outlined above which will yield a result which can not reasonably be anticipated. A
rational economic decision of an investor wishing to liquidate his holdings would be to
simply sell his shares in the market. Accordingly, we believe that the possibility that a
stockholder would ever exercise the redemption right afforded under Mexican law is remote. </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;We
note that Simec&#146;s shares are traded on the Mexican Stock Exchange and its ADRs
representing common shares are traded on the American Stock Exchange; we believe these
markets provide ample liquidity for any investor wishing to liquidate his share position.
We note no holder of variable common stock of Simec has ever attempted to exercise the
redemption rights afforded under Mexican law and we are not aware of such redemption
provision otherwise being used with respect to any other Mexican company with publicly
traded shares. We are not aware of any other Mexican company filing annual reports on
Form 20-F that presents its variable common stock as other than permanent capital under
U.S. GAAP. </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Accordingly,
we have concluded that, for the reasons set forth above, our variable common stock is as
a practical matter indistinguishable from our fixed capital stock, and, therefore, is
appropriately presented as permanent capital under U.S. GAAP. </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;We
acknowledge that: </FONT></P>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Bullet 10" FSL="Workstation" -->
<TABLE WIDTH=100%>
  <TR>
    <TD WIDTH=5%></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=2% VALIGN=top><FONT SIZE=3>&#149;</FONT></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=3%></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=90%><FONT SIZE=2>we
are responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in our filings with the
Securities and Exchange                            Commission;</FONT></TD></TR></TABLE>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Bullet 10" FSL="Workstation" -->
<TABLE WIDTH=100%>
  <TR>
    <TD WIDTH=5%></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=2% VALIGN=top><FONT SIZE=3>&#149;</FONT></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=3%></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=90%><FONT SIZE=2>comments
of the staff of the Commission or changes to                            our disclosure in
response to comments of the staff                            of the Commission do not
foreclose the Commission                            from taking any action with respect
to the subject                            filing; and</FONT></TD></TR></TABLE>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Bullet 10" FSL="Workstation" -->
<TABLE WIDTH=100%>
  <TR>
    <TD WIDTH=5%></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=2% VALIGN=top><FONT SIZE=3>&#149;</FONT></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=3%></TD>
    <TD WIDTH=90%><FONT SIZE=2>Simec
may not assert the comments of the staff of the                            Commission as
a defense in any proceeding initiated                            by the Commission or any
person under the federal                            securities laws of the United States.</FONT></TD></TR></TABLE>

<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Indent 00" FSL="Workstation" -->
<P><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;If
you have any questions regarding this letter, please contact the undersigned at
011-52-33-1057-5734. </FONT></P>



<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="Para Flush 20" FSL="Workstation" -->
<TABLE WIDTH=100% CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0>
<TR VALIGN=TOP>
<TD WIDTH=50%><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>&nbsp; </FONT></TD>
<TD WIDTH=50%><FONT FACE="Times New Roman, Times, Serif" SIZE=2>
Sincerely,<BR><BR>
                                                          /s/ Jose Flores Flores<BR><BR>
                               Jose Flores Flores<BR>
                                                          Chief Financial Officer </FONT></TD>
</TR>
</TABLE>
<BR>
<!-- MARKER FORMAT-SHEET="5 pt rule no space" FSL="Workstation" -->
<HR SIZE=5 NOSHADE WIDTH=100% ALIGN=LEFT>
</BODY>
</HTML>
</TEXT>
</DOCUMENT>
</SEC-DOCUMENT>
-----END PRIVACY-ENHANCED MESSAGE-----
