<SEC-DOCUMENT>0001623632-16-004077.txt : 20161110
<SEC-HEADER>0001623632-16-004077.hdr.sgml : 20161110
<ACCEPTANCE-DATETIME>20161110140615
ACCESSION NUMBER:		0001623632-16-004077
CONFORMED SUBMISSION TYPE:	13F-HR
PUBLIC DOCUMENT COUNT:		2
CONFORMED PERIOD OF REPORT:	20160930
FILED AS OF DATE:		20161110
DATE AS OF CHANGE:		20161110
EFFECTIVENESS DATE:		20161110

FILER:

	COMPANY DATA:	
		COMPANY CONFORMED NAME:			FEDERATED INVESTORS INC /PA/
		CENTRAL INDEX KEY:			0001056288
		STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATION:	INVESTMENT ADVICE [6282]
		IRS NUMBER:				251111467
		STATE OF INCORPORATION:			PA
		FISCAL YEAR END:			1231

	FILING VALUES:
		FORM TYPE:		13F-HR
		SEC ACT:		1934 Act
		SEC FILE NUMBER:	028-04375
		FILM NUMBER:		161987283

	BUSINESS ADDRESS:	
		STREET 1:		FEDERATED INVESTORS TOWER
		STREET 2:		1001 LIBERTY AVENUE
		CITY:			PITTSBURGH
		STATE:			PA
		ZIP:			15222
		BUSINESS PHONE:		4122881900

	MAIL ADDRESS:	
		STREET 1:		FEDERATED INVESTORS TOWER
		STREET 2:		1001 LIBERTY AVENUE
		CITY:			PITTSBURGH
		STATE:			PA
		ZIP:			15222
</SEC-HEADER>
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>13F-HR
<SEQUENCE>1
<FILENAME>primary_doc.xml
<TEXT>
<XML>
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<edgarSubmission xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/thirteenffiler eis_13F_Filer.xsd" xmlns="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/thirteenffiler" xmlns:ns1="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/common" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
  <headerData>
    <submissionType>13F-HR</submissionType>
    <filerInfo>
      <liveTestFlag>LIVE</liveTestFlag>
      <flags>
        <confirmingCopyFlag>false</confirmingCopyFlag>
        <returnCopyFlag>true</returnCopyFlag>
        <overrideInternetFlag>false</overrideInternetFlag>
      </flags>
      <filer>
        <credentials>
          <cik>0001056288</cik>
          <ccc>XXXXXXXX</ccc>
        </credentials>
      </filer>
      <periodOfReport>09-30-2016</periodOfReport>
    </filerInfo>
  </headerData>
  <formData>
    <coverPage>
      <reportCalendarOrQuarter>09-30-2016</reportCalendarOrQuarter>
      <isAmendment>false</isAmendment>
      <filingManager>
        <name>FEDERATED INVESTORS INC /PA/</name>
        <address>
          <ns1:street1>FEDERATED INVESTORS TOWER</ns1:street1>
          <ns1:street2>1001 LIBERTY AVENUE</ns1:street2>
          <ns1:city>Pittsburgh</ns1:city>
          <ns1:stateOrCountry>PA</ns1:stateOrCountry>
          <ns1:zipCode>15222</ns1:zipCode>
        </address>
      </filingManager>
      <reportType>13F HOLDINGS REPORT</reportType>
      <form13FFileNumber>028-04375</form13FFileNumber>
      <provideInfoForInstruction5>Y</provideInfoForInstruction5>
      <additionalInformation>Federated Investors, Inc. ("Investors") is affiliated with the institutional investment managers listed on the summary page of this Form 13F in the manner described below.  By virtue of Rule 13F-1(b) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, Investors is deemed to share investment discretion over all investments reported herein.  This filing does not constitute an admission that such investment discretion does in fact exist, but is made solely to comply with applicable law. The information set forth below is numbered to correspond with the names of the other parties with respect to which this schedule is filed as listed at the bottom of the cover page hereof:  1.  Federated Investment Counseling ("FIC") is an Investment Adviser to certain Federated Funds, Federated International Funds, PLC, Federated Unit Trust, and certain private investment accounts.  FIC is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Investors.  Investors exercises investment discretion over certain investments as reported by FIC.  FIC exercises investment discretion over the investments identified with the number "1" under Item 7 in the attached tables.  This filing is made on behalf of FIC with respect to all investments over which it exercises investment discretion.  2.  Federated Investment Management Company ("FIM") is the Investment Adviser to certain Federated Funds.  FIM is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Investors.  Subject to guidelines established by the Boards of Trustees or Directors of the aforementioned Funds, FIM exercises investment discretion over the investments identified with the number "2" under Item 7 in the attached tables.  This filing is made on behalf of FIM with respect to all investments over which it exercises investment discretion.  4.  Passport Research Ltd. ("PR") is the Investment Adviser to certain money market funds. PR is 50.5% owned subsidiary of FIM. Subject to guidelines established by the Boards of Trustees of the aforementioned investment company, PR exercises investment discretion over the investments identified with the number "4" under Item 7 in the attached tables.  This filing is made on behalf of PR with respect to all investments over which it exercises investment discretion.  8.  Federated Advisory Services Company ("FASC") is an Investment Adviser that provides investment advice and other services to related advisers.  9.  Federated Equity Management Company of Pennsylvania ("FEMCOPA") is the Investment Adviser to certain Federated Funds.  FEMCOPA is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Investors.  Subject to guidelines established by the Boards of Trustees or Directors of the aforementioned Funds, FEMCOPA exercises investment discretion over the investments identified with the number "9" under Item 7 in the attached tables.  This filing is made on behalf of FEMCOPA with respect to all investments over which it exercises investment discretion.  21.  Federated Global Investment Management Corp. ("Global") is the Investment Adviser to certain Federated Funds and certain private investment accounts.  Global is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Investors.  Subject to guidelines established by the Board of Trustees or Directors of the aforementioned Funds, Global exercises investment discretion over the investments identified with the number "21" under Item 7 in the attached tables.  This filing is made on behalf of Global with respect to all investments over which it exercises investment discretion.  22.  Federated MDT Advisers ("MDT") is the Investment Adviser to certain Federated Funds and certain private investment accounts.  MDT is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Investors.  Subject to guidelines established by the Boards of Trustees or Directors of the aforementioned Funds, MDT exercises investment discretion over the investments identified with the number "22" under Item 7 in the attached tables.  This filing is made on behalf of MDT with respect to all investments over which it exercises investment discretion.</additionalInformation>
    </coverPage>
    <signatureBlock>
      <name>Megan Dolan</name>
      <title>Senior Investment Management Compliance Officer</title>
      <phone>412-288-6518</phone>
      <signature>/s/Megan Dolan</signature>
      <city>Pittsburgh</city>
      <stateOrCountry>PA</stateOrCountry>
      <signatureDate>11-10-2016</signatureDate>
    </signatureBlock>
    <summaryPage>
      <otherIncludedManagersCount>7</otherIncludedManagersCount>
      <tableEntryTotal>3377</tableEntryTotal>
      <tableValueTotal>34750533</tableValueTotal>
      <otherManagers2Info>
        <otherManager2>
          <sequenceNumber>01</sequenceNumber>
          <otherManager>
            <cik>0000819684</cik>
            <form13FFileNumber>028-01454</form13FFileNumber>
            <name>FEDERATED INVESTMENT COUNSELING</name>
          </otherManager>
        </otherManager2>
        <otherManager2>
          <sequenceNumber>02</sequenceNumber>
          <otherManager>
            <cik>0001086433</cik>
            <form13FFileNumber>028-04377</form13FFileNumber>
            <name>FEDERATED INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT CO</name>
          </otherManager>
        </otherManager2>
        <otherManager2>
          <sequenceNumber>04</sequenceNumber>
          <otherManager>
            <cik>0000850365</cik>
            <form13FFileNumber>028-02491</form13FFileNumber>
            <name>PASSPORT RESEARCH LTD</name>
          </otherManager>
        </otherManager2>
        <otherManager2>
          <sequenceNumber>08</sequenceNumber>
          <otherManager>
            <cik>0001279010</cik>
            <form13FFileNumber>028-10899</form13FFileNumber>
            <name>FEDERATED ADVISORY SERVICES CO</name>
          </otherManager>
        </otherManager2>
        <otherManager2>
          <sequenceNumber>09</sequenceNumber>
          <otherManager>
            <cik>0001279012</cik>
            <form13FFileNumber>028-10900</form13FFileNumber>
            <name>FEDERATED EQUITY MANAGEMENT CO OF PENNSYLVANIA</name>
          </otherManager>
        </otherManager2>
        <otherManager2>
          <sequenceNumber>21</sequenceNumber>
          <otherManager>
            <cik>0001086431</cik>
            <form13FFileNumber>028-04379</form13FFileNumber>
            <name>FEDERATED GLOBAL INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT CORP</name>
          </otherManager>
        </otherManager2>
        <otherManager2>
          <sequenceNumber>22</sequenceNumber>
          <otherManager>
            <cik>0001056508</cik>
            <form13FFileNumber>028-06902</form13FFileNumber>
            <name>FEDERATED MDTA LLC</name>
          </otherManager>
        </otherManager2>
      </otherManagers2Info>
    </summaryPage>
  </formData>
</edgarSubmission>
</XML>
</TEXT>
</DOCUMENT>
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>INFORMATION TABLE
<SEQUENCE>2
<FILENAME>infotable.xml
<TEXT>
<XML>
<?xml version="1.0" ?>
<informationTable xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/document/thirteenf/informationtable eis_13FDocument.xsd" xmlns="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/document/thirteenf/informationtable" xmlns:n1="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/document/thirteenf/informationtable" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>000361105</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1903</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1903</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>000361105</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACCO BRANDS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00081T108</cusip>
    <value>2180</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>226179</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>155141</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>71038</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABM INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>000957100</cusip>
    <value>29</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>738</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>738</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AFLAC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>001055102</cusip>
    <value>34401</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>478662</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>478662</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AFLAC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>001055102</cusip>
    <value>36292</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>504962</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>481804</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>23158</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AGCO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>001084102</cusip>
    <value>1409</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28563</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28563</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AGCO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>001084102</cusip>
    <value>4350</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>88209</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>87832</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>377</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00130H105</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1251</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1251</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00130H105</cusip>
    <value>444</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34582</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34582</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00130H105</cusip>
    <value>1646</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>128097</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>128067</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>30</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AK STL HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>001547108</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4979</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4979</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMC NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00164V103</cusip>
    <value>1654</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31901</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31901</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMC NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00164V103</cusip>
    <value>348</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6702</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6702</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMC NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00164V103</cusip>
    <value>4391</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>84674</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78407</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6267</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMC ENTMT HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00165C104</cusip>
    <value>3401</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>109400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>109400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMN HEALTHCARE SERVICES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>001744101</cusip>
    <value>119</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3733</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3733</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANI PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00182C103</cusip>
    <value>657</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9903</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9903</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARC DOCUMENT SOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00191G103</cusip>
    <value>201</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53874</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>53874</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AT&amp;T INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00206R102</cusip>
    <value>286868</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7063971</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5175744</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1888227</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AT&amp;T INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00206R102</cusip>
    <value>724594</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17842745</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17842745</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AT&amp;T INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00206R102</cusip>
    <value>28575</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>703654</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>699716</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3938</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AT&amp;T INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00206R102</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>486</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>460</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATYR PHARMA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002120103</cusip>
    <value>1778</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>558969</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>558969</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATYR PHARMA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002120103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>327</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>327</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>A10 NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002121101</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>570</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AXT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00246W103</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1631</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1631</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AARONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.50</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002535300</cusip>
    <value>1315</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51748</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51748</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AARONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.50</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002535300</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABBOTT LABS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002824100</cusip>
    <value>2651</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62692</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1917</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>60775</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABBOTT LABS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002824100</cusip>
    <value>1302</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30777</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30777</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABBOTT LABS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002824100</cusip>
    <value>12680</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>299833</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>296397</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3436</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABBVIE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00287Y109</cusip>
    <value>246183</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3903326</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2888060</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1015266</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABBVIE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00287Y109</cusip>
    <value>688059</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10909457</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10909457</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABBVIE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00287Y109</cusip>
    <value>427</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6769</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABBVIE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00287Y109</cusip>
    <value>9058</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>143626</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>130800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12826</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABERCROMBIE &amp; FITCH CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002896207</cusip>
    <value>618</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38911</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38911</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABERCROMBIE &amp; FITCH CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002896207</cusip>
    <value>4878</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>307000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>307000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABERCROMBIE &amp; FITCH CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>002896207</cusip>
    <value>2537</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>159642</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>133597</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>26045</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABIOMED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>003654100</cusip>
    <value>2842</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22101</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22101</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ABIOMED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>003654100</cusip>
    <value>13840</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>107640</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>96790</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10850</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACACIA RESH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ACACIA TCH COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>003881307</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1292</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1292</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACADIA HEALTHCARE COMPANY IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00404A109</cusip>
    <value>25189</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>508350</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>508350</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACADIA PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>004225108</cusip>
    <value>11924</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>374860</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>374860</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACI WORLDWIDE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>004498101</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2494</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2494</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACI WORLDWIDE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>004498101</cusip>
    <value>1186</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61185</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61185</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACORDA THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00484M106</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>81</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>81</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACTIVISION BLIZZARD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00507V109</cusip>
    <value>727</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16417</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16417</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACTIVISION BLIZZARD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00507V109</cusip>
    <value>326</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7357</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7357</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACTIVISION BLIZZARD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00507V109</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>128</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>128</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACTUANT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00508X203</cusip>
    <value>943</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40575</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40575</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACTUANT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00508X203</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2154</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2154</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACTUANT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00508X203</cusip>
    <value>8369</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>360118</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>354733</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5385</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACTUANT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00508X203</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACUITY BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00508Y102</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACUITY BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00508Y102</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>218</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>218</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACUITY BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00508Y102</cusip>
    <value>94039</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>355400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>350200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5200</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACUITY BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00508Y102</cusip>
    <value>1974</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7462</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7399</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>63</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACXIOM CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>005125109</cusip>
    <value>1107</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41532</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41532</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADESTO TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00687D101</cusip>
    <value>1316</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>598351</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>598351</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADOBE SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00724F101</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>63</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADOBE SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00724F101</cusip>
    <value>1349</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12430</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12430</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADOBE SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00724F101</cusip>
    <value>14641</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>134891</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>134891</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCE AUTO PARTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00751Y106</cusip>
    <value>42</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>281</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>281</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVISORY BRD CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00762W107</cusip>
    <value>1725</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38547</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38547</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AECOM</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00766T100</cusip>
    <value>2412</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>81116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>81116</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AECOM</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00766T100</cusip>
    <value>121</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4083</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4083</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AEGERION PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00767E102</cusip>
    <value>328</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110280</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110280</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AEGION CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00770F104</cusip>
    <value>169</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8882</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8882</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AERIE PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00771V108</cusip>
    <value>89</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2357</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2357</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AEROCENTURY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>007737109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCEPIERRE FOODS HLDGS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00782L107</cusip>
    <value>5512</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>200000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>007903107</cusip>
    <value>74</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10742</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10742</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>007903107</cusip>
    <value>2320</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>335742</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>335742</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>007903107</cusip>
    <value>10365</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1500000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1500000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>007903107</cusip>
    <value>1761</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>254859</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>199825</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>55034</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCED DRAIN SYS INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00790R104</cusip>
    <value>9047</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>376000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>376000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCED ACCELERATOR APPLIC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00790T100</cusip>
    <value>4065</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>106760</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>106760</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AEGON N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>NY REGISTRY SH</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>007924103</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>675</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCED ENERGY INDS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>007973100</cusip>
    <value>64</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1352</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1352</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ADVANCED ENERGY INDS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>007973100</cusip>
    <value>3358</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70962</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3362</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AES TR III</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>PFD CV 6.75%</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00808N202</cusip>
    <value>13346</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>261689</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>261689</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AETNA INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00817Y108</cusip>
    <value>68</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>593</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>593</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AETNA INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00817Y108</cusip>
    <value>11203</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97042</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97042</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AETNA INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00817Y108</cusip>
    <value>438</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3790</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3790</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AETNA INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00817Y108</cusip>
    <value>163</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1408</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1211</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>197</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AFFILIATED MANAGERS GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>008252108</cusip>
    <value>169</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1169</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1169</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AFFILIATED MANAGERS GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>008252108</cusip>
    <value>30387</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>210000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>210000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AGILENT TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00846U101</cusip>
    <value>390</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8285</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8285</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AGILENT TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00846U101</cusip>
    <value>14480</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>307500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>307500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AGNICO EAGLE MINES LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>008474108</cusip>
    <value>1571</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AGIOS PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00847X104</cusip>
    <value>656</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12411</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12411</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AGIOS PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00847X104</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>94</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>94</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AIR METHODS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $.06</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>009128307</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AIR LEASE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00912X302</cusip>
    <value>70810</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2477600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2477600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AIR PRODS &amp; CHEMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>009158106</cusip>
    <value>1041</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6921</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6921</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AIR PRODS &amp; CHEMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>009158106</cusip>
    <value>428</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2844</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2844</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AIR T INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>009207101</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>170</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AKAMAI TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>00971T101</cusip>
    <value>209</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3948</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3948</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AKORN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>009728106</cusip>
    <value>1344</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49310</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49310</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALAMOS GOLD INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>011532108</cusip>
    <value>410</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALARM COM HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>011642105</cusip>
    <value>5657</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>196000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>196000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALARM COM HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>011642105</cusip>
    <value>178</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6172</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6172</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALASKA AIR GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>011659109</cusip>
    <value>78</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1178</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1178</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALASKA AIR GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>011659109</cusip>
    <value>21693</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>329375</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>329375</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALASKA AIR GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>011659109</cusip>
    <value>303</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4595</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4595</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALASKA AIR GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>011659109</cusip>
    <value>11091</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>168407</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>153422</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14985</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALASKA COMMUNICATIONS SYS GR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>01167P101</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6160</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6160</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALBEMARLE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>012653101</cusip>
    <value>202</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2362</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2362</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALCOA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>013817101</cusip>
    <value>3155</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>311149</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>311149</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALEXANDER &amp; BALDWIN INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>014491104</cusip>
    <value>59</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1532</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1532</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALEXANDER &amp; BALDWIN INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>014491104</cusip>
    <value>1036</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26965</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26965</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALEXANDRIA REAL ESTATE EQ IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>015271109</cusip>
    <value>4215</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38750</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38750</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALEXION PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>015351109</cusip>
    <value>3216</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26246</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26246</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALEXION PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>015351109</cusip>
    <value>645</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5263</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5263</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALEXION PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>015351109</cusip>
    <value>60530</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>493962</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>482102</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11860</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALIBABA GROUP HLDG LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>01609W102</cusip>
    <value>115226</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1089191</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1074700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14491</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALIGN TECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>016255101</cusip>
    <value>3885</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41441</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41441</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALIGN TECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>016255101</cusip>
    <value>10063</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>107339</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97721</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9618</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLEGHANY CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>017175100</cusip>
    <value>4018</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7653</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7653</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLEGHANY CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>017175100</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLEGHENY TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>01741R102</cusip>
    <value>613</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33924</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33924</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLEGIANT TRAVEL CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>01748X102</cusip>
    <value>620</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4694</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4694</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLETE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>018522300</cusip>
    <value>25</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>415</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>0</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>415</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLIANCE DATA SYSTEMS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>018581108</cusip>
    <value>3894</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLIANCE DATA SYSTEMS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>018581108</cusip>
    <value>265</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1235</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1235</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLIANCE DATA SYSTEMS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>018581108</cusip>
    <value>5909</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27542</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27542</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLISON TRANSMISSION HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>01973R101</cusip>
    <value>1564</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>54531</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36055</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18476</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLSCRIPTS HEALTHCARE SOLUTN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>01988P108</cusip>
    <value>1754</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>133156</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>133156</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLSCRIPTS HEALTHCARE SOLUTN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>01988P108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLSTATE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>020002101</cusip>
    <value>34175</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>493995</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>493995</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLSTATE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>020002101</cusip>
    <value>560</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLSTATE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>020002101</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>390</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>287</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>103</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLY FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02005N100</cusip>
    <value>679</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34895</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34895</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLY FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02005N100</cusip>
    <value>3003</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>154213</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>154213</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLY FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02005N100</cusip>
    <value>354</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18196</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18196</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLY FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02005N100</cusip>
    <value>7294</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>374627</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>337408</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>37219</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALNYLAM PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02043Q107</cusip>
    <value>678</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALNYLAM PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02043Q107</cusip>
    <value>34</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>503</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>503</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALON USA ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>020520102</cusip>
    <value>315</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39038</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38128</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>910</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALPHABET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CAP STK CL C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02079K107</cusip>
    <value>3994</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5139</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5139</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALPHABET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CAP STK CL C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02079K107</cusip>
    <value>8347</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10738</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10738</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALPHABET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CAP STK CL C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02079K107</cusip>
    <value>4149</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5338</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5338</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALPHABET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CAP STK CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02079K305</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALPHABET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CAP STK CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02079K305</cusip>
    <value>8574</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10664</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10664</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALPHABET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CAP STK CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02079K305</cusip>
    <value>85712</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>106599</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>103749</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2850</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALPHABET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CAP STK CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02079K305</cusip>
    <value>3106</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3863</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3838</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>25</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALTRA INDL MOTION CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02208R106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALTRIA GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02209S103</cusip>
    <value>211963</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3352261</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2476690</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>875571</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALTRIA GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02209S103</cusip>
    <value>546800</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8647793</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8647793</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALTRIA GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02209S103</cusip>
    <value>100</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1576</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1576</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALTRIA GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02209S103</cusip>
    <value>330</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5218</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5218</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMAZON COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023135106</cusip>
    <value>2526</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3017</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3017</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMAZON COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023135106</cusip>
    <value>12319</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14713</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14713</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMAZON COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023135106</cusip>
    <value>145898</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>174246</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>171715</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2531</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMAZON COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023135106</cusip>
    <value>9735</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11627</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11461</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>166</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMBAC FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023139884</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>524</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>524</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMBAC FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023139884</cusip>
    <value>1403</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76290</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>69148</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7142</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMBER RD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02318Y108</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>465</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>465</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMBEV SA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02319V103</cusip>
    <value>4187</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>687592</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>155969</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>531623</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMBEV SA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02319V103</cusip>
    <value>8552</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1404224</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1404224</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMBEV SA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02319V103</cusip>
    <value>332</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>54500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>54500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMCON DISTRG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02341Q205</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMEDISYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023436108</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1013</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1013</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMEDISYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023436108</cusip>
    <value>76</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1603</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1567</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>36</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMEREN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>023608102</cusip>
    <value>291</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5917</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5917</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN AIRLS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02376R102</cusip>
    <value>249</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6805</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6805</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN AXLE &amp; MFG HLDGS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>024061103</cusip>
    <value>727</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42208</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42208</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN AXLE &amp; MFG HLDGS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>024061103</cusip>
    <value>3412</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>198116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>198116</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN AXLE &amp; MFG HLDGS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>024061103</cusip>
    <value>946</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>54944</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>54803</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>141</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN CAMPUS CMNTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>024835100</cusip>
    <value>5014</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>98569</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>98569</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN CAMPUS CMNTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>024835100</cusip>
    <value>158</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN CAP MTG INVT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02504A104</cusip>
    <value>47</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2754</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2754</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN ELEC PWR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025537101</cusip>
    <value>88760</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1382340</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>760096</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>622244</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN ELEC PWR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025537101</cusip>
    <value>151693</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2362449</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2362449</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN ELEC PWR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025537101</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS NE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02553E106</cusip>
    <value>13915</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>779099</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>779099</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS NE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02553E106</cusip>
    <value>1894</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>106040</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>105532</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>508</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN EQTY INVT LIFE HLD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025676206</cusip>
    <value>255</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14360</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13540</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>820</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN EXPRESS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025816109</cusip>
    <value>11471</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>179123</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>179123</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN EXPRESS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025816109</cusip>
    <value>67</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1045</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1045</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN FINL GROUP INC OHIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025932104</cusip>
    <value>29</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>387</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>387</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN FINL GROUP INC OHIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025932104</cusip>
    <value>2951</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39352</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39352</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN FINL GROUP INC OHIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>025932104</cusip>
    <value>608</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8102</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8102</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN INTL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>026874784</cusip>
    <value>5050</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>85100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42491</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>42609</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN INTL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>026874784</cusip>
    <value>3239</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>54578</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>54578</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN INTL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>026874784</cusip>
    <value>175316</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2954428</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2922074</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>32354</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN NATL BANKSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>027745108</cusip>
    <value>33</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1196</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>554</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>642</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN PUBLIC EDUCATION IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>02913V103</cusip>
    <value>103</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5186</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4346</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>840</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN SHARED HOSPITAL SVC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>029595105</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1762</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1762</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN STS WTR CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>029899101</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1287</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1287</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN TOWER CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03027X100</cusip>
    <value>2451</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21626</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21626</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN TOWER CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03027X100</cusip>
    <value>283</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN TOWER CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>DEP PFD CONV SE</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03027X407</cusip>
    <value>18806</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>171600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>171600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN WTR WKS CO INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>030420103</cusip>
    <value>1048</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14007</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14007</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERICAS CAR MART INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03062T105</cusip>
    <value>672</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18463</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9018</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9445</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERISAFE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03071H100</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>197</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>197</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERISOURCEBERGEN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03073E105</cusip>
    <value>581</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7197</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7197</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERISOURCEBERGEN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03073E105</cusip>
    <value>482</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5970</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5970</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERISERV FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03074A102</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>957</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>957</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERIPRISE FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03076C106</cusip>
    <value>8086</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>81049</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>81049</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERIPRISE FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03076C106</cusip>
    <value>587</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5883</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5883</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMERIPRISE FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03076C106</cusip>
    <value>30685</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>307553</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>279336</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>28217</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMETEK INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>031100100</cusip>
    <value>293</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6123</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6123</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>031162100</cusip>
    <value>76</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>457</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>457</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>031162100</cusip>
    <value>44658</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>267720</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>267720</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>031162100</cusip>
    <value>1118</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6702</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6702</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>031162100</cusip>
    <value>23288</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>139605</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>129228</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10377</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMKOR TECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>031652100</cusip>
    <value>59</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6051</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6051</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMKOR TECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>031652100</cusip>
    <value>114</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11686</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6337</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5349</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMPHENOL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>032095101</cusip>
    <value>543</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8366</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8366</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMPHASTAR PHARMACEUTICALS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03209R103</cusip>
    <value>28163</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1484617</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1484617</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMPIO PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03209T109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>242</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>242</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMPLIFY SNACK BRANDS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03211L102</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1298</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1298</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMSURG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03232P405</cusip>
    <value>644</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMSURG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03232P405</cusip>
    <value>2028</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30245</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30245</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMSURG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03232P405</cusip>
    <value>5823</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86842</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>85552</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1290</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMTECH SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.01N</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>032332504</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>397</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>397</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANADARKO PETE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>032511107</cusip>
    <value>1055</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16655</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16655</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANALOG DEVICES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>032654105</cusip>
    <value>530</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8218</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8218</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANDERSONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>034164103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANDERSONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>034164103</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>392</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>392</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANHEUSER BUSCH INBEV SA/NV</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03524A108</cusip>
    <value>2204</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16775</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4005</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12770</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANHEUSER BUSCH INBEV SA/NV</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03524A108</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANIKA THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>035255108</cusip>
    <value>1580</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33029</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33029</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANSYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03662Q105</cusip>
    <value>4820</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52041</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52041</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANTHEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>036752103</cusip>
    <value>30</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>241</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>241</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANTHEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>036752103</cusip>
    <value>23682</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>188990</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>188990</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANTHEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>036752103</cusip>
    <value>580</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4631</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4631</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANTHEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>036752103</cusip>
    <value>26113</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>208386</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>201155</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7231</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ANTHEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT 05/01/20188</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>036752202</cusip>
    <value>25883</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>595429</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>595429</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APACHE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037411105</cusip>
    <value>14191</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>222189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>222189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APACHE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037411105</cusip>
    <value>431</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6749</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6749</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APACHE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037411105</cusip>
    <value>2824</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44208</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32244</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11964</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APARTMENT INVT &amp; MGMT CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03748R101</cusip>
    <value>204</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4443</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4443</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APOGEE ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037598109</cusip>
    <value>11820</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>264488</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>264488</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APOLLO ED GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037604105</cusip>
    <value>33</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4155</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4155</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037833100</cusip>
    <value>2168</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19176</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19176</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037833100</cusip>
    <value>58752</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>519701</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>519701</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037833100</cusip>
    <value>4770</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42196</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42196</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>037833100</cusip>
    <value>20217</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>178833</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>165349</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13484</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLIED INDL TECHNOLOGIES IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03820C105</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>204</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>204</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLIED MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>038222105</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>215</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>215</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLIED MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>038222105</cusip>
    <value>29295</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>971634</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>971634</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLIED MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>038222105</cusip>
    <value>952</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31564</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31564</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPLIED MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>038222105</cusip>
    <value>28488</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>944861</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>852319</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>92542</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APTARGROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>038336103</cusip>
    <value>2625</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33910</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33910</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>APPROACH RESOURCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03834A103</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1163</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1163</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AQUA AMERICA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03836W103</cusip>
    <value>1435</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47075</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47075</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AQUA AMERICA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03836W103</cusip>
    <value>3987</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>130791</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>130791</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AQUA AMERICA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03836W103</cusip>
    <value>12784</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>419416</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>413156</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6260</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARATANA THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03874P101</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>713</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>713</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARCHER DANIELS MIDLAND CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>039483102</cusip>
    <value>49</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1153</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1153</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARCHER DANIELS MIDLAND CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>039483102</cusip>
    <value>589</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13956</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13956</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARCHER DANIELS MIDLAND CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>039483102</cusip>
    <value>204</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4847</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4847</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARCHER DANIELS MIDLAND CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>039483102</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>493</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>475</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARCHROCK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>03957W106</cusip>
    <value>1858</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>142032</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80084</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>61948</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARGAN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>04010E109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARIAD PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>04033A100</cusip>
    <value>558</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40744</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40744</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARRAY BIOPHARMA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>04269X105</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>362</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>362</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARROW ELECTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>042735100</cusip>
    <value>3107</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48566</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48566</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARROW ELECTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>042735100</cusip>
    <value>3398</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53124</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47130</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5994</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARROW FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>042744102</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1461</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1027</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>434</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARROWHEAD PHARMACEUTICALS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>04280A100</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>773</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>773</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARTESIAN RESOURCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>043113208</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASBURY AUTOMOTIVE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>043436104</cusip>
    <value>1202</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASBURY AUTOMOTIVE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>043436104</cusip>
    <value>39</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>704</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>704</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASBURY AUTOMOTIVE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>043436104</cusip>
    <value>10414</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>187070</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>184200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2870</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASBURY AUTOMOTIVE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>043436104</cusip>
    <value>19</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>333</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>333</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASCENA RETAIL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>04351G101</cusip>
    <value>495</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>88564</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>88564</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASCENT CAP GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>043632108</cusip>
    <value>41</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1766</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1721</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>45</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASHFORD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>044104107</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASHLAND GLOBAL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>044186104</cusip>
    <value>39</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>337</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>337</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASHLAND GLOBAL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>044186104</cusip>
    <value>3860</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33287</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33287</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASSOCIATED BANC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>045487105</cusip>
    <value>1563</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>79761</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>79761</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASSURANT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>04621X108</cusip>
    <value>36</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>389</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>389</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASTORIA FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>046265104</cusip>
    <value>54</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3702</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3702</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASTRAZENECA PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>046353108</cusip>
    <value>128867</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3921700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2019719</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1901981</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASTRAZENECA PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>046353108</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATKORE INTL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>047649108</cusip>
    <value>5009</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>267300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>267300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATLANTIC PWR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>04878Q863</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>163</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>163</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATLAS AIR WORLDWIDE HLDGS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>049164205</cusip>
    <value>1217</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28426</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7276</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATMOS ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>049560105</cusip>
    <value>4192</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>56297</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>56297</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATMOS ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>049560105</cusip>
    <value>567</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7617</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7617</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATWOOD OCEANICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>050095108</cusip>
    <value>669</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76951</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45645</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>31306</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AUTODESK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>052769106</cusip>
    <value>324</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4473</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4473</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AUTOMATIC DATA PROCESSING IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053015103</cusip>
    <value>764</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8660</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8660</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AUTONATION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05329W102</cusip>
    <value>47</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>956</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>956</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AUTOZONE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053332102</cusip>
    <value>600</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>781</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>781</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVALONBAY CMNTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053484101</cusip>
    <value>6987</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39286</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39286</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVANGRID INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05351W103</cusip>
    <value>465</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11124</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11124</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVERY DENNISON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053611109</cusip>
    <value>44</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>568</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>568</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVERY DENNISON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053611109</cusip>
    <value>19297</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>248061</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>248061</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVERY DENNISON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053611109</cusip>
    <value>455</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5848</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5848</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVERY DENNISON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053611109</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>267</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>267</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVID TECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05367P100</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>497</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>497</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVIS BUDGET GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053774105</cusip>
    <value>1780</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52042</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52042</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVIS BUDGET GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053774105</cusip>
    <value>278</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8116</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVISTA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05379B107</cusip>
    <value>2790</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66754</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42762</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>23992</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVNET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053807103</cusip>
    <value>34</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>826</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>826</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVNET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053807103</cusip>
    <value>2774</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>67555</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67555</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVNET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>053807103</cusip>
    <value>1739</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42357</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39033</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3324</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVIVA PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05382A104</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>201</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>201</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVON PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>054303102</cusip>
    <value>1338</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>236397</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>236397</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVON PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>054303102</cusip>
    <value>1590</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>280916</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>247078</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>33838</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BB&amp;T CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>054937107</cusip>
    <value>11038</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>292633</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>292633</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05534B760</cusip>
    <value>246817</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5344670</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3803127</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1541543</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05534B760</cusip>
    <value>31873</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>690195</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>690195</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BGC PARTNERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05541T101</cusip>
    <value>1156</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>132100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>132100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BGC PARTNERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05541T101</cusip>
    <value>10026</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1145878</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1127958</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17920</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BG STAFFING INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05544A109</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>437</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>437</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>055622104</cusip>
    <value>124011</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3527054</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2420102</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1106952</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>055622104</cusip>
    <value>17234</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>490161</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>490161</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>055622104</cusip>
    <value>49862</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1418152</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1412768</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5384</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOFI HLDG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05566U108</cusip>
    <value>28</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1236</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1236</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BWX TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05605H100</cusip>
    <value>322</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8388</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8388</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BWX TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05605H100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BABCOCK &amp; WILCOX ENTERPRIS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05614L100</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3010</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3010</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BAIDU INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR REP A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>056752108</cusip>
    <value>146</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BAKER HUGHES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>057224107</cusip>
    <value>28</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>564</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>564</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BAKER HUGHES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>057224107</cusip>
    <value>27458</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>544051</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>544051</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BALL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>058498106</cusip>
    <value>113</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1379</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1379</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANCFIRST CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05945F103</cusip>
    <value>29</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>403</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>403</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANCO BRADESCO S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SP ADR PFD NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>059460303</cusip>
    <value>207</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22792</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22792</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANCO SANTANDER SA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05964H105</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>792</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>792</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANCORPSOUTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>059692103</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2243</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2243</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANCORPSOUTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>059692103</cusip>
    <value>1064</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45867</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45867</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANCORPSOUTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>059692103</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>869</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>869</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANC OF CALIFORNIA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>05990K106</cusip>
    <value>44</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2520</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2520</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK AMER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>060505104</cusip>
    <value>6452</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>412261</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>245681</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>166580</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK AMER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>060505104</cusip>
    <value>27027</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1726949</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1726949</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK AMER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>060505104</cusip>
    <value>38017</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2429207</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2425231</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3976</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK AMER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>060505104</cusip>
    <value>11506</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>735222</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>693567</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>41655</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK AMER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>7.25%CNV PFD L</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>060505682</cusip>
    <value>10209</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8362</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8362</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK HAWAII CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>062540109</cusip>
    <value>1284</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17685</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17685</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK OF MARIN BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>063425102</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>260</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>193</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK MONTREAL QUE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>063671101</cusip>
    <value>6525</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>99508</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22683</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>76825</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK MUTUAL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>063750103</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1298</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1298</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK OF THE OZARKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>063904106</cusip>
    <value>1501</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39084</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39084</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK NEW YORK MELLON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>064058100</cusip>
    <value>4014</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100640</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3445</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>97195</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK NEW YORK MELLON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>064058100</cusip>
    <value>8765</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>219790</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>219790</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK NEW YORK MELLON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>064058100</cusip>
    <value>44472</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1115140</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1109314</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5826</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK NEW YORK MELLON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>064058100</cusip>
    <value>19307</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>484123</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>457384</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>26739</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANK COMM HLDGS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>06424J103</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>210</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>210</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BANKRATE INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>06647F102</cusip>
    <value>34</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4010</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4010</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BAR HBR BANKSHARES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>066849100</cusip>
    <value>32</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>861</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>527</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>334</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARD C R INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>067383109</cusip>
    <value>177</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>790</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>790</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARD C R INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>067383109</cusip>
    <value>4578</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20411</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15179</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5232</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARCLAYS PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>06738E204</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>443</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>443</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARNES &amp; NOBLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>067774109</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>325</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>325</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARNES &amp; NOBLE ED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>06777U101</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>628</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>628</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARNES GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>067806109</cusip>
    <value>1786</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>44050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARNES GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>067806109</cusip>
    <value>15439</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>380729</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>374844</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5885</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARRACUDA NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>068323104</cusip>
    <value>164</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6435</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6435</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARRETT BUSINESS SERVICES IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>068463108</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BARRETT BILL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>06846N104</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2208</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2208</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BASIC ENERGY SVCS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>06985P100</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9019</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8310</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>709</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BASSETT FURNITURE INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>070203104</cusip>
    <value>197</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8485</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7825</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>660</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BAXTER INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>071813109</cusip>
    <value>23394</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>491471</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>491471</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BAXTER INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>071813109</cusip>
    <value>314</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6594</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6594</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BAXTER INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>071813109</cusip>
    <value>36154</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>759545</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>722929</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>36616</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>B/E AEROSPACE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>073302101</cusip>
    <value>2955</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>57206</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57206</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>B/E AEROSPACE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>073302101</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BEAZER HOMES USA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>07556Q881</cusip>
    <value>102</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8783</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4325</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4458</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BECTON DICKINSON &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>075887109</cusip>
    <value>1181</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6569</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6569</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BED BATH &amp; BEYOND INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>075896100</cusip>
    <value>134</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3103</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3103</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BED BATH &amp; BEYOND INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>075896100</cusip>
    <value>22201</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>514981</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>468667</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>46314</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BELDEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>077454106</cusip>
    <value>1545</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22395</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22395</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BELDEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>077454106</cusip>
    <value>2933</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42510</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42288</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>222</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BEMIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>081437105</cusip>
    <value>2659</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52132</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52132</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BENCHMARK ELECTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>08160H101</cusip>
    <value>2075</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>83175</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83175</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BENCHMARK ELECTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>08160H101</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2275</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2275</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BENCHMARK ELECTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>08160H101</cusip>
    <value>16095</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>645075</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>634150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10925</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BENEFITFOCUS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>08180D106</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>133</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>133</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BERKLEY W R CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>084423102</cusip>
    <value>3055</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52899</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52899</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>084670702</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>084670702</cusip>
    <value>18531</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>128271</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>128271</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>084670702</cusip>
    <value>880</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6090</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6090</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BERKSHIRE HILLS BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>084680107</cusip>
    <value>1488</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53701</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35252</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18449</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BERRY PLASTICS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>08579W103</cusip>
    <value>945</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21561</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21561</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BERRY PLASTICS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>08579W103</cusip>
    <value>4398</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100306</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100306</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BERRY PLASTICS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>08579W103</cusip>
    <value>80</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1830</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1830</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BEST BUY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>086516101</cusip>
    <value>493</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12915</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12915</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BEST BUY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>086516101</cusip>
    <value>43</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1135</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1135</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BEST BUY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>086516101</cusip>
    <value>3907</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>102329</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>98286</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4043</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIG 5 SPORTING GOODS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>08915P101</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>749</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>749</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIG LOTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>089302103</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>409</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>409</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIG LOTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>089302103</cusip>
    <value>4143</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86754</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86754</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIG LOTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>089302103</cusip>
    <value>2847</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>59613</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>59607</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIO RAD LABS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>090572207</cusip>
    <value>1934</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11805</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11805</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOCRYST PHARMACEUTICALS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09058V103</cusip>
    <value>357</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80852</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>79497</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1355</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOMARIN PHARMACEUTICAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09061G101</cusip>
    <value>1480</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09062X103</cusip>
    <value>1230</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3930</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3930</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09062X103</cusip>
    <value>4186</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13374</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13374</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09062X103</cusip>
    <value>2007</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6412</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6412</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09062X103</cusip>
    <value>29</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>93</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>93</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOTELEMETRY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>090672106</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1096</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>969</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>127</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOSCRIP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09069N108</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2963</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2963</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIOAMBER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09072Q106</cusip>
    <value>85</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20039</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20039</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BIO TECHNE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09073M104</cusip>
    <value>2314</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21131</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21131</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACK BOX CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>091826107</cusip>
    <value>458</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32963</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29674</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3289</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACK DIAMOND INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09202G101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACK HILLS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>092113109</cusip>
    <value>63</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1025</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1025</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACK HILLS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>092113109</cusip>
    <value>1322</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21592</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21592</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACK KNIGHT FINL SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09214X100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACKBAUD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09227Q100</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACKROCK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09247X101</cusip>
    <value>866</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2390</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2390</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACKROCK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09247X101</cusip>
    <value>170098</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>469287</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>464405</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4882</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACKROCK LTD DURATION INC T</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09249W101</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLACKSTONE MTG TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09257W100</cusip>
    <value>574</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLOCK H &amp; R INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>093671105</cusip>
    <value>12928</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>558464</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>491546</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>66918</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLONDER TONGUE LABS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>093698108</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2851</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2851</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLOOMIN BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>094235108</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3042</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3042</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLUE BIRD CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>095306106</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>526</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>526</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLUE BUFFALO PET PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09531U102</cusip>
    <value>31867</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1341218</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1341218</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLUE BUFFALO PET PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09531U102</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>395</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>355</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>40</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLUEBIRD BIO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09609G100</cusip>
    <value>813</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BLUEPRINT MEDICINES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09627Y109</cusip>
    <value>572</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19262</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19262</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOB EVANS FARMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>096761101</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>77</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>77</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOEING CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>097023105</cusip>
    <value>101</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>764</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>764</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOEING CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>097023105</cusip>
    <value>16570</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>125777</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>125777</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOEING CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>097023105</cusip>
    <value>1783</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13535</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13519</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOISE CASCADE CO DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>09739D100</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2037</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2037</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOOZ ALLEN HAMILTON HLDG COR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>099502106</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>421</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>421</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BORGWARNER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>099724106</cusip>
    <value>891</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25332</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25332</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOSTON BEER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>100557107</cusip>
    <value>1154</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7435</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7435</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOSTON PRIVATE FINL HLDGS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>101119105</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4463</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4463</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOSTON PROPERTIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>101121101</cusip>
    <value>1927</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14142</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14142</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>101137107</cusip>
    <value>786</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33044</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33044</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>101137107</cusip>
    <value>55792</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2344222</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2311900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>32322</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>10316T104</cusip>
    <value>8432</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>535000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>535000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BOYD GAMING CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>103304101</cusip>
    <value>107</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5424</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2181</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3243</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRADY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>104674106</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>789</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>789</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRADY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>104674106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRIDGEPOINT ED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>10807M105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>85</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>85</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRIGGS &amp; STRATTON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>109043109</cusip>
    <value>865</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46399</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25049</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21350</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRIGHTCOVE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>10921T101</cusip>
    <value>1244</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>95346</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>95085</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>261</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRINKER INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>109641100</cusip>
    <value>9030</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>179062</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>179062</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRISTOL MYERS SQUIBB CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>110122108</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>112</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>112</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRISTOL MYERS SQUIBB CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>110122108</cusip>
    <value>4113</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76279</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>76279</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRISTOL MYERS SQUIBB CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>110122108</cusip>
    <value>603</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRISTOL MYERS SQUIBB CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>110122108</cusip>
    <value>944</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRISTOW GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>110394103</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1291</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1291</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRITISH AMERN TOB PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>110448107</cusip>
    <value>11212</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>87832</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20420</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>67412</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRITISH AMERN TOB PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>110448107</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRIXMOR PPTY GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>11120U105</cusip>
    <value>575</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20684</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20684</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROADSOFT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>11133B409</cusip>
    <value>63640</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1367128</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1367128</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROADSOFT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>11133B409</cusip>
    <value>159</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3424</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3424</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROADRIDGE FINL SOLUTIONS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>11133T103</cusip>
    <value>4463</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65841</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65841</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROADRIDGE FINL SOLUTIONS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>11133T103</cusip>
    <value>95</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1405</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1405</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROCADE COMMUNICATIONS SYS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>111621306</cusip>
    <value>2064</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>223625</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>223625</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROCADE COMMUNICATIONS SYS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>111621306</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1105</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1105</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROOKLINE BANCORP INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>11373M107</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>449</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>449</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROOKS AUTOMATION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>114340102</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>781</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>781</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROWN &amp; BROWN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>115236101</cusip>
    <value>2425</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64297</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64297</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROWN FORMAN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>115637209</cusip>
    <value>262</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5517</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5517</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRUKER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>116794108</cusip>
    <value>421</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18599</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18599</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRUKER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>116794108</cusip>
    <value>940</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41519</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28163</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13356</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRUNSWICK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>117043109</cusip>
    <value>2350</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48183</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48183</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRUNSWICK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>117043109</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>204</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>15</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BRYN MAWR BK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>117665109</cusip>
    <value>465</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14547</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13667</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>880</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BUCKLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>118440106</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>496</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>496</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BUFFALO WILD WINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>119848109</cusip>
    <value>1416</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10064</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10064</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BUILD A BEAR WORKSHOP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>120076104</cusip>
    <value>182</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17612</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16153</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1459</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BUILDERS FIRSTSOURCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12008R107</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>297</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>297</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BURLINGTON STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>122017106</cusip>
    <value>169</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2090</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2090</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BURLINGTON STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>122017106</cusip>
    <value>2010</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24810</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24788</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>C &amp; F FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12466Q104</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>128</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>128</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CBL &amp; ASSOC PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>124830100</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>731</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>731</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CBS CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>124857202</cusip>
    <value>529</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9660</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9660</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CBS CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>124857202</cusip>
    <value>14648</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>267601</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>248253</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>19348</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CBOE HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12503M108</cusip>
    <value>2959</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45629</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45629</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CBRE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12504L109</cusip>
    <value>179</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6382</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6382</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CBRE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12504L109</cusip>
    <value>91339</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3264456</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3208900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>55556</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CDK GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12508E101</cusip>
    <value>4290</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>74784</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>74784</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CDK GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12508E101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CEB INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>125134106</cusip>
    <value>993</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18230</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18230</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CDW CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12514G108</cusip>
    <value>921</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20143</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20143</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CDW CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12514G108</cusip>
    <value>4302</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>94071</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>94071</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CDW CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12514G108</cusip>
    <value>5762</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>125992</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>112763</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13229</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>C H ROBINSON WORLDWIDE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12541W209</cusip>
    <value>275</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIGNA CORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>125509109</cusip>
    <value>4398</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33751</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23391</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10360</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIGNA CORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>125509109</cusip>
    <value>838</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6428</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6428</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIGNA CORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>125509109</cusip>
    <value>8858</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>67968</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67396</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>572</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CME GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12572Q105</cusip>
    <value>2487</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23797</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23797</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CMS ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>125896100</cusip>
    <value>244</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5805</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5805</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CMS ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>125896100</cusip>
    <value>495</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11774</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11774</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CNA FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126117100</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CNB FINL CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126128107</cusip>
    <value>154</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7296</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5595</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1701</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CNO FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12621E103</cusip>
    <value>1647</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>107850</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>107850</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CNO FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12621E103</cusip>
    <value>64</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4214</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4214</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CNO FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12621E103</cusip>
    <value>1416</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>92762</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>92762</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CNO FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12621E103</cusip>
    <value>14326</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>938156</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>922851</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>15305</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRH PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12626K203</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>247</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>247</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CSG SYS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126349109</cusip>
    <value>150</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3635</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3635</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CPI CARD GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12634H101</cusip>
    <value>1439</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>238185</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>176657</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>61528</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CSX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126408103</cusip>
    <value>3528</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>115661</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3171</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>112490</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CSX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126408103</cusip>
    <value>4341</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>142331</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>142331</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CSX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126408103</cusip>
    <value>49103</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1609926</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1602813</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7113</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CST BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12646R105</cusip>
    <value>1943</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40413</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40413</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CSRA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12650T104</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>892</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>892</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CSRA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12650T104</cusip>
    <value>471</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17502</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17502</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVB FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126600105</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3195</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3195</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVR ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12662P108</cusip>
    <value>31</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2258</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2258</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVR ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12662P108</cusip>
    <value>95</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6880</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5790</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1090</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVR REFNG LP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COMUNIT REP LT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12663P107</cusip>
    <value>835</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>95210</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>95210</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVR REFNG LP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COMUNIT REP LT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12663P107</cusip>
    <value>3859</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>440026</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>440026</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVS HEALTH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126650100</cusip>
    <value>1892</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21263</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21263</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVS HEALTH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126650100</cusip>
    <value>4172</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46879</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46879</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVS HEALTH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126650100</cusip>
    <value>76417</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>858710</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>841590</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17120</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVS HEALTH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126650100</cusip>
    <value>872</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9702</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>98</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CYS INVTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12673A108</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6430</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6430</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12673P105</cusip>
    <value>297</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8976</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8976</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12673P105</cusip>
    <value>8664</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>261918</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>244235</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17683</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CABELAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>126804301</cusip>
    <value>1520</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27673</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27673</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CABLE ONE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>12685J105</cusip>
    <value>1444</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2473</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2473</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CABOT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>127055101</cusip>
    <value>10332</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>197143</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>197143</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CABOT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>127055101</cusip>
    <value>261</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4986</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4986</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CABOT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>127055101</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>173</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>173</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CABOT OIL &amp; GAS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>127097103</cusip>
    <value>533</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20667</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20667</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CACI INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>127190304</cusip>
    <value>208</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2065</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2063</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CADENCE DESIGN SYSTEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>127387108</cusip>
    <value>4091</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>160251</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>160251</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAESARS ENTMT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>127686103</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3249</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3249</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAL MAINE FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>128030202</cusip>
    <value>40</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1034</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1034</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAL MAINE FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>128030202</cusip>
    <value>720</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18686</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>116</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALAMP CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>128126109</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>968</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>968</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALAMP CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>128126109</cusip>
    <value>3418</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>245000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>245000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALATLANTIC GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>128195104</cusip>
    <value>2304</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68909</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68909</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALAVO GROWERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>128246105</cusip>
    <value>53</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>805</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>805</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALERES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>129500104</cusip>
    <value>49</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1927</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1927</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALERES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>129500104</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>116</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALIFORNIA RES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>13057Q206</cusip>
    <value>265</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21162</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19391</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1771</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALIFORNIA WTR SVC GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>130788102</cusip>
    <value>802</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALLAWAY GOLF CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>131193104</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4332</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4332</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALLON PETE CO DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>13123X102</cusip>
    <value>3533</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>225000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>225000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALPINE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>131347304</cusip>
    <value>1374</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>108724</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3403</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>105321</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALPINE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>131347304</cusip>
    <value>6662</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>527095</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>521054</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6041</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CALPINE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>131347304</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>157</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>157</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAMBREX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>132011107</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1355</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1355</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAMBREX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>132011107</cusip>
    <value>310</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6962</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6962</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAMBIUM LEARNING GRP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>13201A107</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1999</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1999</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAMDEN PPTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>133131102</cusip>
    <value>4034</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48177</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48177</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAMPBELL SOUP CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>134429109</cusip>
    <value>8819</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>161224</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>161224</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAMPBELL SOUP CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>134429109</cusip>
    <value>13104</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>239553</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>234212</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5341</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CDN IMPERIAL BK COMM TORONTO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>136069101</cusip>
    <value>5061</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65278</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15219</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>50059</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CANADIAN NAT RES LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>136385101</cusip>
    <value>21791</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>680125</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>680125</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CANADIAN PAC RY LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>13645T100</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAPELLA EDUCATION COMPANY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>139594105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAPITAL ONE FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14040H105</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>279</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>279</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAPITAL ONE FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14040H105</cusip>
    <value>1131</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15748</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15748</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAPITAL ONE FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14040H105</cusip>
    <value>540</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7517</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7431</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>86</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAPITAL SR LIVING CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>140475104</cusip>
    <value>722</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42975</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42975</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAPITAL SR LIVING CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>140475104</cusip>
    <value>6534</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>388939</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>383444</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5495</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAPSTEAD MTG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NO PAR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14067E506</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5507</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5507</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARBONITE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>141337105</cusip>
    <value>282</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18328</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18328</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARDINAL HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14149Y108</cusip>
    <value>46</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>597</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>597</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARDINAL HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14149Y108</cusip>
    <value>595</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7661</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7661</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARDINAL HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14149Y108</cusip>
    <value>98</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1261</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1261</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARDIOVASCULAR SYS INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>141619106</cusip>
    <value>2083</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>87727</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>87391</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>336</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARE CAP PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>141624106</cusip>
    <value>901</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31617</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31617</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARE COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>141633107</cusip>
    <value>359</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36070</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36070</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAREER EDUCATION CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>141665109</cusip>
    <value>65</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9583</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9557</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>26</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARLISLE COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>142339100</cusip>
    <value>6544</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63801</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>63801</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARLISLE COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>142339100</cusip>
    <value>244</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2379</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2343</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>36</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARMAX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>143130102</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>703</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>703</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARNIVAL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT 99/99/9999</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>143658300</cusip>
    <value>539</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11032</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11032</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARNIVAL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT 99/99/9999</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>143658300</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>410</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>303</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>107</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARPENTER TECHNOLOGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>144285103</cusip>
    <value>970</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23502</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23502</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARROLS RESTAURANT GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14574X104</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1005</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1005</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CARTER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>146229109</cusip>
    <value>5241</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60446</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60446</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CASELLA WASTE SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>147448104</cusip>
    <value>31</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2974</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2974</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CASEYS GEN STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>147528103</cusip>
    <value>2604</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21671</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21671</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CASEYS GEN STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>147528103</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>71</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>71</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CASTLE A M &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>148411101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1205</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1205</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATABASIS PHARMACEUTICALS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14875P107</cusip>
    <value>679</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATALENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>148806102</cusip>
    <value>67</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2585</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2585</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATALENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>148806102</cusip>
    <value>1841</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>71263</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>71263</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATALENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>148806102</cusip>
    <value>20466</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>792031</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>792031</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATERPILLAR INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149123101</cusip>
    <value>3169</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35703</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1011</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>34692</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATERPILLAR INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149123101</cusip>
    <value>1034</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11652</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11652</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATERPILLAR INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149123101</cusip>
    <value>43385</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>488732</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>486823</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1909</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATERPILLAR INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149123101</cusip>
    <value>101</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1134</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1095</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>39</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATHAY GEN BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149150104</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1834</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1834</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATHAY GEN BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149150104</cusip>
    <value>1257</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40852</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40852</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATHAY GEN BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149150104</cusip>
    <value>881</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28638</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20569</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8069</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATO CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149205106</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>405</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>405</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CATO CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>149205106</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>240</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>240</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAVIUM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>14964U108</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>367</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>367</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CELANESE CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>150870103</cusip>
    <value>17109</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>257053</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>254584</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2469</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CELGENE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>151020104</cusip>
    <value>3018</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28875</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28875</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CELGENE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>151020104</cusip>
    <value>3012</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28818</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28818</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CELGENE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>151020104</cusip>
    <value>6150</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58835</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58835</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CELLDEX THERAPEUTICS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>15117B103</cusip>
    <value>1828</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>452366</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>380019</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>72347</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CEMEX SAB DE CV</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>151290889</cusip>
    <value>1498</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>188700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>188700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTENE CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>15135B101</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>118</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>118</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTENE CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>15135B101</cusip>
    <value>1393</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20810</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20810</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTERPOINT ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>15189T107</cusip>
    <value>483</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20782</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20782</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTERSTATE BANKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>15201P109</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTERSTATE BANKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>15201P109</cusip>
    <value>1922</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>108397</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82986</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>25411</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTRAL GARDEN &amp; PET CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NON-VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>153527205</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>132</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>132</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTRAL GARDEN &amp; PET CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NON-VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>153527205</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>449</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>449</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTRAL PAC FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>154760409</cusip>
    <value>301</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11959</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7854</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4105</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTRAL VALLEY CMNTY BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>155685100</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>336</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>336</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTURY ALUM CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>156431108</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1812</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1757</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>55</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTRUS ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>15643U104</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTURYLINK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>156700106</cusip>
    <value>31</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1117</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1117</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTURYLINK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>156700106</cusip>
    <value>29147</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1062609</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1062609</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CENTURYLINK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>156700106</cusip>
    <value>29618</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1079751</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1023570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>56181</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CEPHEID</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>15670R107</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>987</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>987</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CERNER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>156782104</cusip>
    <value>466</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7548</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7548</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CEVA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>157210105</cusip>
    <value>497</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14163</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14163</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHANNELADVISOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>159179100</cusip>
    <value>4464</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>345210</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>345210</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHANNELADVISOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>159179100</cusip>
    <value>207</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15989</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15817</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>172</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHARLES RIV LABS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>159864107</cusip>
    <value>2238</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26856</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26856</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHARLES RIV LABS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>159864107</cusip>
    <value>4042</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48501</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39334</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9167</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHART INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>16115Q308</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>719</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>705</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS INC N</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>16119P108</cusip>
    <value>1438</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5326</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5326</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEESECAKE FACTORY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163072101</cusip>
    <value>1306</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26084</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26084</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEESECAKE FACTORY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163072101</cusip>
    <value>53</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEGG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163092109</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1014</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1014</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMBIO DIAGNOSTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163572209</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>724</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>724</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMED CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>16359R103</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>72</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMICAL FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163731102</cusip>
    <value>2243</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50836</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50836</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMICAL FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163731102</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1092</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1092</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMICAL FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163731102</cusip>
    <value>1671</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37865</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37865</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMICAL FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163731102</cusip>
    <value>20601</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>466829</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>459108</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7721</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMICAL FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163731102</cusip>
    <value>202</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4588</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1133</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3455</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMOCENTRYX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>16383L106</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1402</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1402</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMOURS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163851108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>54</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>54</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEMTURA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>163893209</cusip>
    <value>43</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1313</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1313</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHESAPEAKE ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>165167107</cusip>
    <value>64</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10169</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10169</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHESAPEAKE ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>165167107</cusip>
    <value>492</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78453</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78427</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>26</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHESAPEAKE UTILS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>165303108</cusip>
    <value>17</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>278</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>111</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>167</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEVRON CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>166764100</cusip>
    <value>147552</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1433655</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>811823</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>621832</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEVRON CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>166764100</cusip>
    <value>497729</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4836081</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4836081</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHEVRON CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>166764100</cusip>
    <value>1613</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15673</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15673</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHICAGO BRIDGE &amp; IRON CO N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>167250109</cusip>
    <value>95</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3382</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3382</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHICOS FAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>168615102</cusip>
    <value>1255</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>105433</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>105433</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHICOS FAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>168615102</cusip>
    <value>55</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4639</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4639</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHILDRENS PL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>168905107</cusip>
    <value>1929</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24157</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22454</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1703</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHIMERA INVT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>16934Q208</cusip>
    <value>52895</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3316300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3316300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHIMERIX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>16934W106</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2779</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2751</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>28</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHINA MOBILE LIMITED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>16941M109</cusip>
    <value>228</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHINA PETE &amp; CHEM CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR H SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>16941R108</cusip>
    <value>15441</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>209080</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>209080</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHIPOTLE MEXICAN GRILL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>169656105</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHIPOTLE MEXICAN GRILL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>169656105</cusip>
    <value>70</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>166</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>166</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHURCH &amp; DWIGHT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171340102</cusip>
    <value>352</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7345</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7345</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHURCH &amp; DWIGHT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171340102</cusip>
    <value>64</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1340</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1340</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHURCHILL DOWNS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171484108</cusip>
    <value>915</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6255</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6255</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIENA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171779309</cusip>
    <value>2209</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>101350</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>101350</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIENA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171779309</cusip>
    <value>1225</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>56170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>56170</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIENA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171779309</cusip>
    <value>12927</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>592971</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>584806</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8165</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIMAREX ENERGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171798101</cusip>
    <value>275</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIMAREX ENERGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171798101</cusip>
    <value>24213</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>180196</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>178293</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1903</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CINCINNATI BELL INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>171871106</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11813</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6620</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5193</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CINCINNATI FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172062101</cusip>
    <value>283</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3746</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3746</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CINCINNATI FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172062101</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CINEMARK HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>17243V102</cusip>
    <value>2132</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55685</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55685</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIRRUS LOGIC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172755100</cusip>
    <value>1811</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34081</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34081</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIRRUS LOGIC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172755100</cusip>
    <value>958</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18019</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18019</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CISCO SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>17275R102</cusip>
    <value>142</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4468</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4468</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CISCO SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>17275R102</cusip>
    <value>47353</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1492832</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1492832</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CISCO SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>17275R102</cusip>
    <value>15016</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>473394</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>473394</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CISCO SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>17275R102</cusip>
    <value>19573</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>617050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>587159</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>29891</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CINTAS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172908105</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>102</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>102</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CINTAS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172908105</cusip>
    <value>179</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1588</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1588</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CINTAS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172908105</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>204</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>204</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITIGROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172967424</cusip>
    <value>3217</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68120</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68120</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITIGROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172967424</cusip>
    <value>23910</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>506251</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>506251</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITIGROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172967424</cusip>
    <value>3154</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66774</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>66774</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITIGROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>172967424</cusip>
    <value>14130</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>299181</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>296255</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2926</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITI TRENDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>17306X102</cusip>
    <value>188</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9419</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2421</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6998</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITIZENS FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>174610105</cusip>
    <value>311</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12597</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12597</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITIZENS FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>174610105</cusip>
    <value>148</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5985</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4931</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1054</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITRIX SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>177376100</cusip>
    <value>325</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3810</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3810</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITRIX SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>177376100</cusip>
    <value>38434</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>451001</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>412242</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>38759</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CITY HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>177835105</cusip>
    <value>31</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>607</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>379</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>228</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIVEO CORP CDA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>17878Y108</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3685</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3685</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CIVISTA BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NO PAR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>178867107</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1030</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1030</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLARCOR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>179895107</cusip>
    <value>2165</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33306</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33306</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLEAN HARBORS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>184496107</cusip>
    <value>1330</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27728</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27728</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLEAN ENERGY FUELS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>184499101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>188</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>188</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLEAR CHANNEL OUTDOOR HLDGS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18451C109</cusip>
    <value>248</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42407</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42407</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLEARFIELD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18482P103</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>293</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>293</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLEARWATER PAPER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18538R103</cusip>
    <value>859</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13281</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13281</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLEARWATER PAPER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18538R103</cusip>
    <value>4174</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64546</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64546</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLEARWATER PAPER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18538R103</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLIFFS NAT RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18683K101</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>838</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>838</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLOROX CO DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>189054109</cusip>
    <value>418</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3338</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3338</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLOROX CO DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>189054109</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>77</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>77</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLOUD PEAK ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18911Q102</cusip>
    <value>885</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>162634</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>137887</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>24747</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLUBCORP HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18948M108</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>848</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>848</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CLUBCORP HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>18948M108</cusip>
    <value>6885</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>475800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>475800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COACH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>189754104</cusip>
    <value>244</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6684</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6684</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COBALT INTL ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19075F106</cusip>
    <value>136</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>109496</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43576</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>65920</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COCA COLA BOTTLING CO CONS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>191098102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COCA COLA CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>191216100</cusip>
    <value>156609</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3700581</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2079667</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1620914</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COCA COLA CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>191216100</cusip>
    <value>342464</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8092252</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8092252</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COCA COLA CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>191216100</cusip>
    <value>656</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15507</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15507</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COEUR MNG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>192108504</cusip>
    <value>22</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1827</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1827</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COEUR MNG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>192108504</cusip>
    <value>35</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2997</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2950</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>47</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COGENT COMMUNICATIONS HLDGS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19239V302</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>389</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>389</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COGNEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>192422103</cusip>
    <value>2891</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>54700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>54700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COGNEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>192422103</cusip>
    <value>143</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2704</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>408</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2296</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COGNIZANT TECHNOLOGY SOLUTIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>192446102</cusip>
    <value>1685</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35325</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35325</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COHERENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>192479103</cusip>
    <value>1108</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10026</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10026</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COHU INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>192576106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLFAX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>194014106</cusip>
    <value>1523</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48450</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLFAX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>194014106</cusip>
    <value>13615</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>433180</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>426600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6580</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLFAX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>194014106</cusip>
    <value>9812</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>312176</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>309480</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2696</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLGATE PALMOLIVE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>194162103</cusip>
    <value>13345</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>179994</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>179994</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLGATE PALMOLIVE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>194162103</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>695</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>695</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLONY BANKCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19623P101</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>635</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>635</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLONY CAP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19624R106</cusip>
    <value>1512</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>82950</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82950</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLONY CAP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19624R106</cusip>
    <value>62</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3401</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3401</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLONY CAP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19624R106</cusip>
    <value>12915</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>708460</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>697395</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11065</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLONY STARWOOD HOMES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19625X102</cusip>
    <value>955</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33290</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33290</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLONY STARWOOD HOMES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19625X102</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>326</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>326</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COLONY STARWOOD HOMES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>19625X102</cusip>
    <value>8704</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>303259</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>298994</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4265</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMFORT SYS USA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>199908104</cusip>
    <value>1755</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>59893</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>59840</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>53</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMCAST CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20030N101</cusip>
    <value>982</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14801</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14801</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMCAST CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20030N101</cusip>
    <value>23520</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>354536</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>354536</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMCAST CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20030N101</cusip>
    <value>1879</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28318</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28318</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMERICA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>200340107</cusip>
    <value>191</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4043</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4043</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMERICA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>200340107</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>120</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMERCE BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>200525103</cusip>
    <value>2250</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45674</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45674</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMERCEHUB INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20084V306</cusip>
    <value>491</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30851</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30851</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMERCIAL METALS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>201723103</cusip>
    <value>1069</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>66050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMERCIAL METALS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>201723103</cusip>
    <value>53</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3280</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3280</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMERCIAL METALS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>201723103</cusip>
    <value>1454</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>89802</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>89802</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMERCIAL METALS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>201723103</cusip>
    <value>9809</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>605864</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>596959</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8905</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMERCIAL METALS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>201723103</cusip>
    <value>2190</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>135268</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>88292</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>46976</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMERCIAL VEH GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>202608105</cusip>
    <value>456</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78808</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78808</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMSCOPE HLDG CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20337X109</cusip>
    <value>695</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23098</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23098</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMSCOPE HLDG CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20337X109</cusip>
    <value>3139</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>104250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>104250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMSCOPE HLDG CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20337X109</cusip>
    <value>6707</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>222760</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>190731</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>32029</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMUNICATIONS SALES&amp;LEAS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20341J104</cusip>
    <value>2320</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>73849</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73849</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMUNITY HEALTH SYS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>203668108</cusip>
    <value>605</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52467</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52467</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMUNITY HEALTH SYS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>203668108</cusip>
    <value>2778</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>240702</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>240702</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMUNITY HEALTH SYS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>203668108</cusip>
    <value>704</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61014</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61014</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMUNITY HEALTH SYS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>203668108</cusip>
    <value>4936</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>427762</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>412839</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14923</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMUNITY TR BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>204149108</cusip>
    <value>1022</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27534</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21413</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6121</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMVAULT SYSTEMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>204166102</cusip>
    <value>1203</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22639</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22639</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMMVAULT SYSTEMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>204166102</cusip>
    <value>280</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5268</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5268</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMPASS MINERALS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20451N101</cusip>
    <value>937</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12707</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12707</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMPUTER SCIENCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>205363104</cusip>
    <value>47</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>905</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>905</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMPUTER SCIENCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>205363104</cusip>
    <value>3567</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68318</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68318</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMPUTER SCIENCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>205363104</cusip>
    <value>340</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6519</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6519</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COMSCORE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20564W105</cusip>
    <value>1167</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38061</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38061</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONAGRA FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>205887102</cusip>
    <value>38297</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>812918</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>812918</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONAGRA FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>205887102</cusip>
    <value>690</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14642</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14642</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONAGRA FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>205887102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONCHO RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20605P101</cusip>
    <value>1993</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14514</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14514</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONCHO RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20605P101</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>193</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>191</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONOCOPHILLIPS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20825C104</cusip>
    <value>1381</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31777</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31777</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONSOL ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20854P109</cusip>
    <value>1381</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>71948</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>71948</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONSOL ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>20854P109</cusip>
    <value>62</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3237</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3237</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONSOLIDATED EDISON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>209115104</cusip>
    <value>86526</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1149080</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>637881</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>511199</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONSOLIDATED EDISON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>209115104</cusip>
    <value>180252</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2393790</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2393790</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONSOLIDATED EDISON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>209115104</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONSTELLATION BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21036P108</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONSTELLATION BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21036P108</cusip>
    <value>500</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3003</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3003</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONSTELLATION BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21036P108</cusip>
    <value>928</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5574</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2454</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3120</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONTAINER STORE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>210751103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>95</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>95</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONTANGO OIL &amp; GAS COMPANY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21075N204</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1526</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1526</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONTINENTAL BLDG PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>211171103</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2276</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2276</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONTINENTAL BLDG PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>211171103</cusip>
    <value>4910</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>233900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>233900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONTINENTAL RESOURCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>212015101</cusip>
    <value>122</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2340</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2340</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONTINENTAL RESOURCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>212015101</cusip>
    <value>767</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14762</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14282</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>480</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONTRAFECT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>212326102</cusip>
    <value>4960</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2000000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2000000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONTROL4 CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21240D107</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>803</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>803</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONVERGYS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>212485106</cusip>
    <value>1547</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50857</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50857</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CONVERGYS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>212485106</cusip>
    <value>478</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15706</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12978</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2728</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COOPER COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>216648402</cusip>
    <value>216</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1205</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1205</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COOPER COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>216648402</cusip>
    <value>22</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>122</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>122</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COOPER STD HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21676P103</cusip>
    <value>3229</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32685</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26918</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5767</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COOPER TIRE &amp; RUBR CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>216831107</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>371</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>371</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COOPER TIRE &amp; RUBR CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>216831107</cusip>
    <value>2030</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53398</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40242</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13156</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COPART INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>217204106</cusip>
    <value>2415</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45084</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45084</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COPART INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>217204106</cusip>
    <value>4148</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>77447</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61031</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16416</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORCEPT THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>218352102</cusip>
    <value>90220</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13879968</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13879968</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORE MARK HOLDING CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>218681104</cusip>
    <value>47</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1318</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1318</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORE MARK HOLDING CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>218681104</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>258</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>258</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORESITE RLTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21870Q105</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>289</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>289</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORESITE RLTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21870Q105</cusip>
    <value>111</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORELOGIC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21871D103</cusip>
    <value>2296</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58536</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58536</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORELOGIC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21871D103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORNERSTONE ONDEMAND INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>21925Y103</cusip>
    <value>66</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1441</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1441</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORNING INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>219350105</cusip>
    <value>21296</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>900477</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>900477</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORNING INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>219350105</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>768</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>754</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORPORATE OFFICE PPTYS TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22002T108</cusip>
    <value>8034</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>283398</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>283398</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CORRECTIONS CORP AMER NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22025Y407</cusip>
    <value>943</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>67995</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67995</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COSTCO WHSL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22160K105</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COSTCO WHSL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22160K105</cusip>
    <value>1423</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9331</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9331</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COSTAR GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22160N109</cusip>
    <value>81090</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>374500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>374500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COTIVITI HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22164K101</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>215</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>215</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COTY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>222070203</cusip>
    <value>40</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1713</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1713</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COTY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>222070203</cusip>
    <value>202</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8593</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8593</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COUSINS PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>222795106</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>612</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>612</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRACKER BARREL OLD CTRY STOR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22410J106</cusip>
    <value>1345</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10170</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRACKER BARREL OLD CTRY STOR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22410J106</cusip>
    <value>25175</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>190400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>190400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRACKER BARREL OLD CTRY STOR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22410J106</cusip>
    <value>638</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4829</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4814</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>15</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRAFT BREW ALLIANCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>224122101</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>786</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>786</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRANE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>224399105</cusip>
    <value>1695</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26905</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26905</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRANE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>224399105</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>238</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>102</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>136</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRAWFORD &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>224633107</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>880</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>880</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRAY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>225223304</cusip>
    <value>147</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6264</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6264</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CREDIT ACCEP CORP MICH</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>225310101</cusip>
    <value>160</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>796</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>796</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CREDIT SUISSE GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>225401108</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>457</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>457</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CREE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>225447101</cusip>
    <value>1419</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55154</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55154</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRITEO S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONS ADS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>226718104</cusip>
    <value>1573</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44811</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>44811</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CROCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>227046109</cusip>
    <value>37</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4444</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4444</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CROSS CTRY HEALTHCARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>227483104</cusip>
    <value>1140</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>96748</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>94232</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2516</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CROWN CASTLE INTL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22822V101</cusip>
    <value>113990</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1209961</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>674108</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>535853</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CROWN CASTLE INTL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22822V101</cusip>
    <value>312340</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3315357</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3315357</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CROWN CASTLE INTL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22822V101</cusip>
    <value>106662</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1132170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1115404</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16766</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CROWN HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>228368106</cusip>
    <value>489</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8565</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8565</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CROWN HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>228368106</cusip>
    <value>12693</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>222337</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>198110</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>24227</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CRYOLIFE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>228903100</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>608</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>608</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CTRIP COM INTL LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>AMERICAN DEP SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>22943F100</cusip>
    <value>2329</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CULLEN FROST BANKERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>229899109</cusip>
    <value>14970</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>208094</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>208094</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CULP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>230215105</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>481</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>324</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>157</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CUMMINS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>231021106</cusip>
    <value>493</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3849</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3849</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CUMMINS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>231021106</cusip>
    <value>6022</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46989</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45789</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1200</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CURTISS WRIGHT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>231561101</cusip>
    <value>1317</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14450</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CURTISS WRIGHT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>231561101</cusip>
    <value>2642</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28998</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28998</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CURTISS WRIGHT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>231561101</cusip>
    <value>11800</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>129518</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>127578</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1940</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CUTERA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>232109108</cusip>
    <value>61</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5158</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5158</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CVENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>23247G109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CYNOSURE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>232577205</cusip>
    <value>53</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1046</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1046</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CYPRESS SEMICONDUCTOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>232806109</cusip>
    <value>3249</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>267222</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>88988</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>178234</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CYPRESS SEMICONDUCTOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>232806109</cusip>
    <value>1716</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>141107</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>141107</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CYPRESS SEMICONDUCTOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>232806109</cusip>
    <value>20263</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1666379</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1643689</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22690</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CYTOKINETICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>23282W605</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>483</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>483</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CYRUSONE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>23283R100</cusip>
    <value>6284</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>132100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>132100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DBX ETF TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>XTRAK MSCI JAPN</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>233051507</cusip>
    <value>3214</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97694</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>85234</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12460</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DCT INDUSTRIAL TRUST INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>233153204</cusip>
    <value>3796</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DCT INDUSTRIAL TRUST INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>233153204</cusip>
    <value>126</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>D R HORTON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>23331A109</cusip>
    <value>208</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6873</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6873</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>D R HORTON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>23331A109</cusip>
    <value>9814</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>324973</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>284615</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>40358</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DST SYS INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>233326107</cusip>
    <value>2101</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17813</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17813</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DTE ENERGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>233331107</cusip>
    <value>11317</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120819</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>120819</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DTE ENERGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>233331107</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DXP ENTERPRISES INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>233377407</cusip>
    <value>391</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13877</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12026</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1851</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DANA INCORPORATED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>235825205</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3695</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3695</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DANA INCORPORATED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>235825205</cusip>
    <value>1219</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78174</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78174</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DANA INCORPORATED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>235825205</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>368</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>368</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DANAHER CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>235851102</cusip>
    <value>1225</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15627</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15627</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DANAHER CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>235851102</cusip>
    <value>40523</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>516936</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>516936</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DARDEN RESTAURANTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>237194105</cusip>
    <value>1041</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16984</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16984</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DARDEN RESTAURANTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>237194105</cusip>
    <value>79051</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1289163</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1289163</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DARDEN RESTAURANTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>237194105</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>258</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>258</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DARLING INGREDIENTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>237266101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>165</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>165</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DARLING INGREDIENTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>237266101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>175</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>175</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DAVE &amp; BUSTERS ENTMT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>238337109</cusip>
    <value>46699</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1191900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1191900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DAVITA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>23918K108</cusip>
    <value>507</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7674</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7674</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DAWSON GEOPHYSICAL CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>239360100</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1298</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>962</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>336</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEAN FOODS CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>242370203</cusip>
    <value>45</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2764</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2764</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEAN FOODS CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>242370203</cusip>
    <value>834</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50855</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50855</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEAN FOODS CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>242370203</cusip>
    <value>43</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2595</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2595</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEAN FOODS CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>242370203</cusip>
    <value>4598</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>280366</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>261097</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>19269</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DECKERS OUTDOOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>243537107</cusip>
    <value>1041</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17474</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17474</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DECKERS OUTDOOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>243537107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEERE &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>244199105</cusip>
    <value>579</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6780</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6780</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEERE &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>244199105</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELEK US HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>246647101</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3267</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3267</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELL TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL V</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>24703L103</cusip>
    <value>22</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>467</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>467</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELL TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL V</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>24703L103</cusip>
    <value>128</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2677</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2677</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELTA AIR LINES INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>247361702</cusip>
    <value>15172</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>385466</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>385466</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELTA AIR LINES INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>247361702</cusip>
    <value>383</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9733</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9733</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELTA AIR LINES INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>247361702</cusip>
    <value>9475</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>240717</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>227026</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13691</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELTA APPAREL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>247368103</cusip>
    <value>141</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8542</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6756</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1786</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DENBURY RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>247916208</cusip>
    <value>681</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>210773</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>210773</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DENBURY RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>247916208</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2483</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2483</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELUXE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>248019101</cusip>
    <value>77</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1157</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1157</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELUXE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>248019101</cusip>
    <value>4319</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64632</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64632</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELUXE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>248019101</cusip>
    <value>5338</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>79885</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>79065</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>820</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DENNYS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>24869P104</cusip>
    <value>49</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4553</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4553</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DENTSPLY SIRONA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>24906P109</cusip>
    <value>376</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6325</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6325</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DERMA SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>249827502</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1455</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1455</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEVON ENERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25179M103</cusip>
    <value>522</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11828</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11828</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEVRY ED GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>251893103</cusip>
    <value>1122</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48660</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48660</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEVRY ED GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>251893103</cusip>
    <value>1090</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47277</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42235</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5042</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DEXCOM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>252131107</cusip>
    <value>218928</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2497465</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2478665</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18800</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAGEO P L C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25243Q205</cusip>
    <value>12938</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111492</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38805</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>72687</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAGEO P L C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25243Q205</cusip>
    <value>2321</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAGEO P L C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25243Q205</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAMOND OFFSHORE DRILLING IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25271C102</cusip>
    <value>620</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35216</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35216</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAMOND OFFSHORE DRILLING IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25271C102</cusip>
    <value>205</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11662</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11662</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAMOND OFFSHORE DRILLING IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25271C102</cusip>
    <value>1098</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62348</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62313</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>35</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAMONDROCK HOSPITALITY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>252784301</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2188</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2188</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAMONDBACK ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25278X109</cusip>
    <value>1352</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIAMONDBACK ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25278X109</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>275</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>275</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DICERNA PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>253031108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>217</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>217</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DICKS SPORTING GOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>253393102</cusip>
    <value>2776</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48948</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48948</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIEBOLD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>253651103</cusip>
    <value>609</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24559</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24559</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIGITAL RLTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>253868103</cusip>
    <value>6054</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62336</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48191</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14145</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIGITAL RLTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>253868103</cusip>
    <value>147578</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1519546</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1519546</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIGITAL RLTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>253868103</cusip>
    <value>155</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIGITALGLOBE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25389M877</cusip>
    <value>63</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2275</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2275</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIGITALGLOBE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25389M877</cusip>
    <value>1245</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45266</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39544</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5722</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIME CMNTY BANCSHARES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>253922108</cusip>
    <value>647</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38604</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31561</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7043</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DILLARDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>254067101</cusip>
    <value>7798</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>123754</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>118300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5454</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISNEY WALT CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM DISNEY</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>254687106</cusip>
    <value>30</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>327</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>327</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISNEY WALT CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM DISNEY</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>254687106</cusip>
    <value>3442</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37063</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37063</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISNEY WALT CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM DISNEY</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>254687106</cusip>
    <value>34268</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>369027</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>359297</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9730</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISCOVER FINL SVCS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>254709108</cusip>
    <value>2880</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50926</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2766</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>48160</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISCOVER FINL SVCS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>254709108</cusip>
    <value>50502</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>893047</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>893047</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISCOVER FINL SVCS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>254709108</cusip>
    <value>35659</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>630578</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>627696</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2882</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISCOVER FINL SVCS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>254709108</cusip>
    <value>1725</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30509</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30485</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>24</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISCOVERY COMMUNICATNS NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25470F104</cusip>
    <value>75</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2792</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2792</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISCOVERY COMMUNICATNS NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25470F104</cusip>
    <value>15008</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>557490</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>492103</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>65387</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DISCOVERY COMMUNICATNS NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25470F302</cusip>
    <value>171</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6514</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6514</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DIXIE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>255519100</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1170</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOLLAR GEN CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>256677105</cusip>
    <value>422</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6031</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6031</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOLLAR GEN CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>256677105</cusip>
    <value>64</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>910</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>910</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOLLAR GEN CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>256677105</cusip>
    <value>273</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3895</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3808</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>87</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOLLAR TREE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>256746108</cusip>
    <value>681</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8630</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8630</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOMINION RES INC VA NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25746U109</cusip>
    <value>156338</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2104997</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1145502</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>959495</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOMINION RES INC VA NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25746U109</cusip>
    <value>333350</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4488352</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4488352</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOMINION RES INC VA NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT 08/15/2019</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25746U836</cusip>
    <value>15719</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>315016</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>315016</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOMINOS PIZZA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25754A201</cusip>
    <value>3985</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26242</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26242</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOMTAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>257559203</cusip>
    <value>1268</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34162</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34162</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOMTAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>257559203</cusip>
    <value>3253</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>87620</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>87611</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DONALDSON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>257651109</cusip>
    <value>2791</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>74763</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>74763</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DONNELLEY R R &amp; SONS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>257867101</cusip>
    <value>1624</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>103300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>103300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DONNELLEY R R &amp; SONS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>257867101</cusip>
    <value>5492</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>349364</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>349364</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DONNELLEY R R &amp; SONS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>257867101</cusip>
    <value>14834</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>943654</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>929794</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13860</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DONNELLEY R R &amp; SONS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>257867101</cusip>
    <value>5827</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>370694</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>320730</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>49964</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOUGLAS EMMETT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25960P109</cusip>
    <value>3291</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>89833</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>89833</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOUGLAS EMMETT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>25960P109</cusip>
    <value>165</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOVER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>260003108</cusip>
    <value>17</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>229</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>229</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOVER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>260003108</cusip>
    <value>298</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4052</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4052</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOVER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>260003108</cusip>
    <value>19</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>259</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>259</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOW CHEM CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>260543103</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>735</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>735</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOW CHEM CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>260543103</cusip>
    <value>20055</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>386931</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>386931</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DOW CHEM CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>260543103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DR PEPPER SNAPPLE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26138E109</cusip>
    <value>465</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5094</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5094</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DR PEPPER SNAPPLE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26138E109</cusip>
    <value>15449</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>169196</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>156514</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12682</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DREW INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26168L205</cusip>
    <value>62</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>634</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>634</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DREW INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26168L205</cusip>
    <value>2671</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27217</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>33</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DRIL-QUIP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>262037104</cusip>
    <value>1145</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20533</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20533</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DU PONT E I DE NEMOURS &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>263534109</cusip>
    <value>1472</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21977</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21977</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DU PONT E I DE NEMOURS &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>263534109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUCOMMUN INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>264147109</cusip>
    <value>944</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41311</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28408</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12903</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUKE REALTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>264411505</cusip>
    <value>2375</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86889</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2318</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>84571</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUKE REALTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>264411505</cusip>
    <value>5270</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>192824</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>192824</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUKE REALTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>264411505</cusip>
    <value>11144</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>407765</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>402859</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4906</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUKE ENERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26441C204</cusip>
    <value>256347</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3202733</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1779454</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1423279</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUKE ENERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26441C204</cusip>
    <value>547527</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6840670</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6840670</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DULUTH HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26443V101</cusip>
    <value>5302</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>200000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUN &amp; BRADSTREET CORP DEL NE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26483E100</cusip>
    <value>1021</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7475</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7475</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUN &amp; BRADSTREET CORP DEL NE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26483E100</cusip>
    <value>3151</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23062</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23062</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUN &amp; BRADSTREET CORP DEL NE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26483E100</cusip>
    <value>9344</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68396</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67401</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>995</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DUNKIN BRANDS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>265504100</cusip>
    <value>2680</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51464</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51464</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DYCOM INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>267475101</cusip>
    <value>989</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12094</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12094</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DYCOM INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>267475101</cusip>
    <value>58811</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>719140</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>719140</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DYCOM INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>267475101</cusip>
    <value>5052</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61775</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60406</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1369</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DYNAVAX TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>268158201</cusip>
    <value>31048</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2959800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2959800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DYNEGY INC NEW DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26817R108</cusip>
    <value>787</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>63500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DYNEGY INC NEW DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26817R108</cusip>
    <value>6616</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>533995</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>525685</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8310</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DYNEGY INC NEW DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>PFD CONV SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26817R207</cusip>
    <value>13715</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>299651</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>299651</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>E L F BEAUTY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26856L103</cusip>
    <value>6327</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>225000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>225000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENI S P A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26874R108</cusip>
    <value>31024</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1074626</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1074626</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENI S P A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26874R108</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>108</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>108</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EOG RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26875P101</cusip>
    <value>2429</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25114</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25114</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EOG RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26875P101</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EP ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>268785102</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>586</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>586</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26884L109</cusip>
    <value>322</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4429</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4429</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EPR PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26884U109</cusip>
    <value>2822</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35843</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35843</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQT MIDSTREAM PARTNERS LP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT LTD PARTN</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26885B100</cusip>
    <value>1524</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>E TRADE FINANCIAL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>269246401</cusip>
    <value>186</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6387</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6387</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>E TRADE FINANCIAL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>269246401</cusip>
    <value>343</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11789</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11789</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EAGLE BANCORP MONT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26942G100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EAGLE MATERIALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26969P108</cusip>
    <value>2072</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26811</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26811</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EAGLE MATERIALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>26969P108</cusip>
    <value>46929</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>607107</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>607107</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EARTHLINK HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>27033X101</cusip>
    <value>39</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6212</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6212</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EARTHLINK HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>27033X101</cusip>
    <value>696</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>112300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>112080</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>220</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EAST WEST BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>27579R104</cusip>
    <value>18490</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>503674</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>503674</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EAST WEST BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>27579R104</cusip>
    <value>178</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4846</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4846</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EASTGROUP PPTY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>277276101</cusip>
    <value>213</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EASTMAN CHEM CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>277432100</cusip>
    <value>294</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4345</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4345</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EASTMAN CHEM CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>277432100</cusip>
    <value>530</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7830</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7736</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>94</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EATON VANCE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NON VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>278265103</cusip>
    <value>2504</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64118</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64118</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EBAY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>278642103</cusip>
    <value>835</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25390</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25390</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EBAY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>278642103</cusip>
    <value>614</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18672</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18672</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EBAY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>278642103</cusip>
    <value>22235</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>675837</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>621900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>53937</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EBIX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>278715206</cusip>
    <value>1675</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29471</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28391</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1080</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ECOLAB INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>278865100</cusip>
    <value>837</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6879</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6879</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ECOLOGY &amp; ENVIRONMENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>278878103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ECOPETROL S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>279158109</cusip>
    <value>35</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EDGEWELL PERS CARE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28035Q102</cusip>
    <value>2509</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31551</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31551</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EDISON INTL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>281020107</cusip>
    <value>592</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8194</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8194</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EDUCATION RLTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28140H203</cusip>
    <value>2522</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58470</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58470</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EDWARDS LIFESCIENCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28176E108</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EDWARDS LIFESCIENCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28176E108</cusip>
    <value>398</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3303</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3303</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EDWARDS LIFESCIENCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28176E108</cusip>
    <value>38940</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>322995</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>292296</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>30699</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EGALET CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28226B104</cusip>
    <value>15776</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2073000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2073000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EHEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28238P109</cusip>
    <value>184</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16443</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16216</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>227</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>8X8 INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>282914100</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1148</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1148</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>8X8 INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>282914100</cusip>
    <value>863</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55925</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55925</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EL PASO ELEC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>283677854</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ELDORADO RESORTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28470R102</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>111</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ELECTROMED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>285409108</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>422</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>422</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ELECTRONIC ARTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>285512109</cusip>
    <value>400</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4687</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4687</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ELECTRONIC ARTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>285512109</cusip>
    <value>8213</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>96169</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86087</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10082</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ELLIE MAE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>28849P100</cusip>
    <value>776</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7365</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7365</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ELLIS PERRY INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>288853104</cusip>
    <value>220</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11434</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9084</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2350</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMCOR GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29084Q100</cusip>
    <value>2068</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34686</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34686</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMERGENT BIOSOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29089Q105</cusip>
    <value>877</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMERGENT BIOSOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29089Q105</cusip>
    <value>43</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1354</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1354</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMERGENT BIOSOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29089Q105</cusip>
    <value>8052</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>255390</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>251670</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3720</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMERGENT BIOSOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29089Q105</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>332</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>332</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMERSON ELEC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>291011104</cusip>
    <value>4706</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86333</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86333</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMERSON ELEC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>291011104</cusip>
    <value>34</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>619</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>619</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMPIRE ST RLTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>292104106</cusip>
    <value>1739</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>83000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EMPLOYERS HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>292218104</cusip>
    <value>927</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31071</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29054</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2017</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENCORE CAP GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>292554102</cusip>
    <value>446</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19818</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19776</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>42</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERGEN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29265N108</cusip>
    <value>3085</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53447</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>53447</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERGEN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29265N108</cusip>
    <value>78</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1343</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1343</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERGY RECOVERY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29270J100</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>205</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>205</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENDURANCE INTL GROUP HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29272B105</cusip>
    <value>36</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4139</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4139</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERGIZER HLDGS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29272W109</cusip>
    <value>1043</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20875</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20875</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERGIZER HLDGS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29272W109</cusip>
    <value>20266</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>405649</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>405649</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERGIZER HLDGS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29272W109</cusip>
    <value>9647</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>193100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>190270</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2830</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERSYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29275Y102</cusip>
    <value>2056</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29719</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29719</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERSYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29275Y102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENERNOC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>292764107</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1517</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1517</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENGILITY HLDGS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29286C107</cusip>
    <value>37</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1186</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>511</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>675</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENNIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>293389102</cusip>
    <value>567</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33678</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19577</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14101</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENPRO INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29355X107</cusip>
    <value>40</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>696</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>696</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENOVA INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29357K103</cusip>
    <value>1024</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>105754</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>102834</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2920</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTEGRIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29362U104</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>638</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>638</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTERCOM COMMUNICATIONS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>293639100</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>195</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>195</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTELLUS MED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29363K105</cusip>
    <value>4882</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>220100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>220100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29364G103</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>658</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>658</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29364G103</cusip>
    <value>113</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1471</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1471</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29364G103</cusip>
    <value>15901</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>207229</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>201853</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5376</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTERPRISE BANCORP INC MASS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>293668109</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>128</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>128</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTERPRISE FINL SVCS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>293712105</cusip>
    <value>2698</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86322</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64480</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21842</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENTERPRISE PRODS PARTNERS L</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>293792107</cusip>
    <value>1796</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENVESTNET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29404K106</cusip>
    <value>4374</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>120000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENZO BIOCHEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>294100102</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1891</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1891</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENVISION HEALTHCARE HLDGS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29413U103</cusip>
    <value>606</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27225</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27225</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENVISION HEALTHCARE HLDGS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29413U103</cusip>
    <value>2666</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>119709</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>119709</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EPLUS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>294268107</cusip>
    <value>1433</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15175</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15175</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EPLUS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>294268107</cusip>
    <value>12133</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>128510</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>126475</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2035</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EPLUS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>294268107</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQUIFAX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>294429105</cusip>
    <value>167</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1243</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1243</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQUIFAX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>294429105</cusip>
    <value>38766</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>288050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>288050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQUIFAX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>294429105</cusip>
    <value>8414</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62524</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>53553</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8971</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQUINIX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.001</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29444U700</cusip>
    <value>401</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1114</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1114</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQUINIX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.001</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29444U700</cusip>
    <value>162</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>450</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQUITY LIFESTYLE PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29472R108</cusip>
    <value>162</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQUITY ONE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>294752100</cusip>
    <value>1575</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51456</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51456</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EQUITY RESIDENTIAL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29476L107</cusip>
    <value>352</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5476</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5476</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ESPERION THERAPEUTICS INC NE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29664W105</cusip>
    <value>413</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29855</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29632</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>223</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ESSENDANT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>296689102</cusip>
    <value>434</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21168</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18366</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2802</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ESSEX PPTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>297178105</cusip>
    <value>329</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1478</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1478</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ESTERLINE TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>297425100</cusip>
    <value>1635</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21505</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21505</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ESTERLINE TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>297425100</cusip>
    <value>136</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1792</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>222</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ETHAN ALLEN INTERIORS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>297602104</cusip>
    <value>1660</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53083</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42293</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10790</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ETSY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29786A106</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1004</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1004</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ETSY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29786A106</cusip>
    <value>1668</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>116805</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>116125</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>680</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVERBANK FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29977G102</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3097</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3097</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVERBANK FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>29977G102</cusip>
    <value>45148</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2332000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2332000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVERI HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30034T103</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8312</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8249</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>63</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVERTEC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30040P103</cusip>
    <value>1240</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>73875</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73875</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVERTEC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30040P103</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3310</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3310</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVERTEC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30040P103</cusip>
    <value>10154</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>605135</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>595390</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9745</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVERTEC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30040P103</cusip>
    <value>813</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48431</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48431</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVERSOURCE ENERGY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30040W108</cusip>
    <value>379</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6992</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6992</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>300614500</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>260</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>260</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXACT SCIENCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30063P105</cusip>
    <value>396</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21310</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21310</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>300645108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXACTECH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30064E109</cusip>
    <value>28</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1037</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1037</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXELON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30161N101</cusip>
    <value>6976</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>209567</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>209567</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXELON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30161N101</cusip>
    <value>93</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2783</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2783</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXELON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT 99/99/9999</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30161N127</cusip>
    <value>15825</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>338570</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>338570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXELIXIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30161Q104</cusip>
    <value>1044</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>81614</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>81111</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>503</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXONE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302104104</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>140</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>140</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXPEDIA INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30212P303</cusip>
    <value>109</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>930</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>930</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXPEDITORS INTL WASH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302130109</cusip>
    <value>278</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5388</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5388</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXPRESS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30219E103</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>284</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>284</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXPRESS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30219E103</cusip>
    <value>1084</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>91908</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>91198</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>710</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXPRESS SCRIPTS HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30219G108</cusip>
    <value>1329</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18844</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18844</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXPRESS SCRIPTS HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30219G108</cusip>
    <value>456</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6468</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6468</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXPRESS SCRIPTS HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30219G108</cusip>
    <value>15074</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>213722</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>198151</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>15571</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXTRA SPACE STORAGE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30225T102</cusip>
    <value>268</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3377</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3377</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXTRA SPACE STORAGE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30225T102</cusip>
    <value>103</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXTREME NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30226D106</cusip>
    <value>584</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>129998</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>122949</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7049</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EZCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NON VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302301106</cusip>
    <value>964</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>87171</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73764</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13407</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXXON MOBIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30231G102</cusip>
    <value>269674</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3089759</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1689051</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1400708</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXXON MOBIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30231G102</cusip>
    <value>375175</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4298523</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4298523</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXXON MOBIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30231G102</cusip>
    <value>2308</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26440</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26440</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EXXON MOBIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30231G102</cusip>
    <value>11937</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>136766</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>136527</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>239</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLIR SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302445101</cusip>
    <value>128</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4082</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4082</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>F M C CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302491303</cusip>
    <value>169</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3502</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3502</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FMC TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30249U101</cusip>
    <value>205</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6894</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6894</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FNB CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302520101</cusip>
    <value>2082</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>169300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>169300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FNB CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302520101</cusip>
    <value>54</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4352</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4352</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FNB CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302520101</cusip>
    <value>999</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>81254</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>81254</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FNB CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302520101</cusip>
    <value>17752</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1443262</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1420562</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22700</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FCB FINL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30255G103</cusip>
    <value>31</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>808</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>350</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>458</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FTD COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30281V108</cusip>
    <value>463</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22506</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19234</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3272</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FTI CONSULTING INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>302941109</cusip>
    <value>1457</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32702</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32702</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FACEBOOK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30303M102</cusip>
    <value>1438</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11208</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11208</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FACEBOOK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30303M102</cusip>
    <value>9937</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>77467</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>77467</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FACEBOOK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30303M102</cusip>
    <value>83320</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>649571</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>632571</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17000</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FACEBOOK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30303M102</cusip>
    <value>21457</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>167282</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>154868</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12414</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FACTSET RESH SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>303075105</cusip>
    <value>3664</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22605</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22605</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FAIR ISAAC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>303250104</cusip>
    <value>2819</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22629</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22629</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FAIRPOINT COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>305560302</cusip>
    <value>1835</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>122106</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>121185</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>921</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FAMOUS DAVES AMER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>307068106</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1724</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1724</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FANG HLDGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>30711Y102</cusip>
    <value>1280</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>284995</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>284995</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FARMERS CAP BK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>309562106</cusip>
    <value>70</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2351</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>740</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1611</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FASTENAL CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>311900104</cusip>
    <value>264</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6327</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6327</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FEDERAL REALTY INVT TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>313747206</cusip>
    <value>316</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FEDERAL REALTY INVT TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>313747206</cusip>
    <value>560</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3640</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3640</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FEDERATED INVS INC PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>314211103</cusip>
    <value>1566</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52861</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52861</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FEDERATED NATL HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31422T101</cusip>
    <value>54</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2904</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1634</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1270</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FEDEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31428X106</cusip>
    <value>1016</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5819</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5819</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FEDEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31428X106</cusip>
    <value>45883</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>262670</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>255500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7170</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FEDEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31428X106</cusip>
    <value>105</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>603</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>565</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>38</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FELCOR LODGING TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31430F101</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1060</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1060</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>F5 NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>315616102</cusip>
    <value>208</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1668</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1668</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>F5 NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>315616102</cusip>
    <value>8335</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66871</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60272</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6599</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIBROGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31572Q808</cusip>
    <value>67</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3230</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3230</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIDELITY NATL INFORMATION SV</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31620M106</cusip>
    <value>604</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7844</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7844</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIDELITY NATIONAL FINANCIAL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>FNFV GROUP COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31620R402</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1228</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1228</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIDELITY SOUTHERN CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>316394105</cusip>
    <value>355</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19297</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10597</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8700</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIFTH THIRD BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>316773100</cusip>
    <value>421</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20556</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20556</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIFTH THIRD BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>316773100</cusip>
    <value>99</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4860</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4860</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIFTH THIRD BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>316773100</cusip>
    <value>8134</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>397569</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>390251</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7318</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FINANCIAL INSTNS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>317585404</cusip>
    <value>29</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1074</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1074</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FINISAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31787A507</cusip>
    <value>86</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2897</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2897</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FINISAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31787A507</cusip>
    <value>337</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11305</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8371</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2934</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FINISH LINE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>317923100</cusip>
    <value>70</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3036</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2998</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>38</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST AMERN FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31847R102</cusip>
    <value>1212</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30850</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30850</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST AMERN FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31847R102</cusip>
    <value>2410</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61343</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61343</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST AMERN FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31847R102</cusip>
    <value>10997</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>279975</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>275865</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4110</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST BANCORP P R</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>318672706</cusip>
    <value>231</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44445</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35691</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8754</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST BANCORP N C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>318910106</cusip>
    <value>72</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3629</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1691</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1938</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST BANCSHARES INC MS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>318916103</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>201</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>201</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST BUS FINL SVCS INC WIS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>319390100</cusip>
    <value>973</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41390</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24615</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16775</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST COMWLTH FINL CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>319829107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>83</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST CMNTY BANCSHARES INC N</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>31983A103</cusip>
    <value>260</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10492</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7271</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3221</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST DEFIANCE FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>32006W106</cusip>
    <value>2051</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45943</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31038</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14905</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST FINL CORP IND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>320218100</cusip>
    <value>861</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21153</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12320</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8833</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST HORIZON NATL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>320517105</cusip>
    <value>1900</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>124732</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>124732</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST HORIZON NATL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>320517105</cusip>
    <value>3929</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>257945</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>257269</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>676</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST INDUSTRIAL REALTY TRUS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>32054K103</cusip>
    <value>1766</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62568</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62568</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST INTST BANCSYSTEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>32055Y201</cusip>
    <value>928</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29455</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16002</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13453</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST MERCHANTS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>320817109</cusip>
    <value>502</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18779</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18072</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>707</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST MIDWEST BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>320867104</cusip>
    <value>55</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2858</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2858</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST MIDWEST BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>320867104</cusip>
    <value>202</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10414</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7014</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3400</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST NBC BK HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>32115D106</cusip>
    <value>828</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>87675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57505</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>30170</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST POTOMAC RLTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>33610F109</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>672</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>672</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST SOLAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>336433107</cusip>
    <value>1316</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33317</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33248</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>69</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST SOUTH BANCORP INC VA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>33646W100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>112</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>112</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>1ST SOURCE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>336901103</cusip>
    <value>101</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2843</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2260</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>583</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRST UTD CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>33741H107</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>564</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>564</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FISERV INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>337738108</cusip>
    <value>562</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5647</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5647</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLAGSTAR BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR .001</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>337930705</cusip>
    <value>767</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27625</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27625</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLAGSTAR BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR .001</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>337930705</cusip>
    <value>6239</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>224823</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>221098</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3725</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRSTENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>337932107</cusip>
    <value>11777</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>356002</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>356002</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIRSTENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>337932107</cusip>
    <value>4243</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>128260</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>127899</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>361</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FITBIT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>33812L102</cusip>
    <value>10487</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>706700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>706700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIVE9 INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>338307101</cusip>
    <value>2372</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>151300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>150146</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1154</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIVE PRIME THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>33830X104</cusip>
    <value>17</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>330</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>330</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FIVE PRIME THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>33830X104</cusip>
    <value>1332</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25378</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25118</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>260</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLEXSTEEL INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>339382103</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>126</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>126</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLOTEK INDS INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>343389102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLUOR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>343412102</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>381</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>381</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLUOR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>343412102</cusip>
    <value>415</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8095</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8095</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLOWERS FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>343498101</cusip>
    <value>1585</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>104822</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>104822</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLOWERS FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>343498101</cusip>
    <value>754</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49870</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49794</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>76</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLOWSERVE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>34354P105</cusip>
    <value>145</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3012</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3012</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLUIDIGM CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>34385P108</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>344</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>344</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLUSHING FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>343873105</cusip>
    <value>894</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37675</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLUSHING FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>343873105</cusip>
    <value>6156</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>259535</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>254650</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4885</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLUSHING FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>343873105</cusip>
    <value>1175</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49539</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32731</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16808</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOMENTO ECONOMICO MEXICANO S</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR UNITS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>344419106</cusip>
    <value>1859</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FONAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>344437405</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>151</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>151</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOOT LOCKER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>344849104</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>243</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>243</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOOT LOCKER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>344849104</cusip>
    <value>3387</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50009</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50009</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOOT LOCKER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>344849104</cusip>
    <value>7893</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>116555</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>104198</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12357</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FORD MTR CO DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>345370860</cusip>
    <value>18719</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1550829</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1550829</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FORD MTR CO DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>345370860</cusip>
    <value>602</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49917</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49917</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FORD MTR CO DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>345370860</cusip>
    <value>8782</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>727618</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>696874</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>30744</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOREST CITY RLTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>345605109</cusip>
    <value>211</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9130</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9130</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FORTINET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>34959E109</cusip>
    <value>4096</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110912</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110912</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FORTIVE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>34959J108</cusip>
    <value>339</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6661</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6661</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FORTUNE BRANDS HOME &amp; SEC IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>34964C106</cusip>
    <value>175</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3013</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3013</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOSSIL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>34988V106</cusip>
    <value>1056</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38030</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38030</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOSSIL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>34988V106</cusip>
    <value>1751</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63064</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62053</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1011</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOSTER L B CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>350060109</cusip>
    <value>22</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1838</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1783</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>55</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOUR CORNERS PPTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>35086T109</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRANCESCAS HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>351793104</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>298</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>298</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRANKLIN FINL NETWORK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>35352P104</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>611</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>0</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>611</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRANKLIN RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>354613101</cusip>
    <value>323</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9092</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9092</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FREEPORT-MCMORAN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>35671D857</cusip>
    <value>583</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53681</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>53681</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>35906A108</cusip>
    <value>1694</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>407113</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12012</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>395101</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>35906A108</cusip>
    <value>91</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21943</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21943</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>35906A108</cusip>
    <value>8077</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1941644</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1919661</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21983</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FULTON FINL CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>360271100</cusip>
    <value>1316</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>90609</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>90609</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FULTON FINL CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>360271100</cusip>
    <value>297</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20470</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8217</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12253</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GAMCO INVESTORS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>361438104</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>154</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>154</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GATX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>361448103</cusip>
    <value>547</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12285</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12285</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GNC HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>36191G107</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>686</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>686</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GNC HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>36191G107</cusip>
    <value>9737</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>476831</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>428129</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>48702</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GW PHARMACEUTICALS PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>36197T103</cusip>
    <value>38184</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>287680</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>287680</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>G-III APPAREL GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>36237H101</cusip>
    <value>28</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>975</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>975</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GTT COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>362393100</cusip>
    <value>8706</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>370000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>370000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>36251C103</cusip>
    <value>4522</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>203400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>203400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GALAPAGOS NV</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>36315X101</cusip>
    <value>71305</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1102773</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1102773</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GALLAGHER ARTHUR J &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>363576109</cusip>
    <value>244</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4798</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4798</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GAMESTOP CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>36467W109</cusip>
    <value>1154</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41815</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41815</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GAMESTOP CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>36467W109</cusip>
    <value>1556</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>56380</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51959</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4421</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GAP INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>364760108</cusip>
    <value>81</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3655</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3655</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GAP INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>364760108</cusip>
    <value>6730</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>302593</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>277820</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>24773</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GARTNER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>366651107</cusip>
    <value>3914</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44255</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>44255</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAC HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>368736104</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>204</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>204</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL CABLE CORP DEL NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369300108</cusip>
    <value>2114</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>141098</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>129450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11648</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL COMMUNICATION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369385109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>125</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>125</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL COMMUNICATION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369385109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>158</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>158</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL DYNAMICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369550108</cusip>
    <value>104</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>670</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>670</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL DYNAMICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369550108</cusip>
    <value>16660</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>107371</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>107371</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL DYNAMICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369550108</cusip>
    <value>322</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2074</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2074</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL DYNAMICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369550108</cusip>
    <value>22039</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>142038</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>132851</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9187</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL ELECTRIC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369604103</cusip>
    <value>1781</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60128</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60128</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL ELECTRIC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369604103</cusip>
    <value>9298</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>313916</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>313916</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL ELECTRIC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369604103</cusip>
    <value>4123</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>139192</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>139192</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL ELECTRIC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>369604103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL GROWTH PPTYS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>370023103</cusip>
    <value>18523</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>671134</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>671134</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL GROWTH PPTYS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>370023103</cusip>
    <value>285</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10308</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10308</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL MLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>370334104</cusip>
    <value>70236</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1099497</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>604522</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>494975</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL MLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>370334104</cusip>
    <value>138491</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2167990</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2167990</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL MTRS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37045V100</cusip>
    <value>883</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27780</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27780</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENERAL MTRS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37045V100</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>174</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>174</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENESCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>371532102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENESEE &amp; WYO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>371559105</cusip>
    <value>2082</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30190</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30190</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENESIS HEALTHCARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37185X106</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5421</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5370</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>51</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENTEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>371901109</cusip>
    <value>2778</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>158213</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>158213</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENTEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>371901109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENOMIC HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37244C101</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2014</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2014</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENUINE PARTS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>372460105</cusip>
    <value>418</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4157</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4157</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GENWORTH FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37247D106</cusip>
    <value>1754</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>353662</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>353662</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GEOSPACE TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37364X109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>87</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>87</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GERMAN AMERN BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>373865104</cusip>
    <value>34</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>872</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>308</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>564</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GERON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>374163103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GIGAMON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37518B102</cusip>
    <value>73</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1328</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1328</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GIGAMON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37518B102</cusip>
    <value>1210</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22077</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21959</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>118</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GILEAD SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>375558103</cusip>
    <value>1367</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17279</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>694</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16585</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GILEAD SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>375558103</cusip>
    <value>46068</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>582261</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>582261</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GILEAD SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>375558103</cusip>
    <value>6932</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>87611</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86436</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1175</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GILEAD SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>375558103</cusip>
    <value>3275</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41391</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38625</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2766</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLATFELTER</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>377316104</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>119</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>119</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLAUKOS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>377322102</cusip>
    <value>35532</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>941492</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>941492</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLAUKOS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>377322102</cusip>
    <value>1566</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41498</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41225</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>273</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLAXOSMITHKLINE PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37733W105</cusip>
    <value>206092</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4778384</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3362775</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1415609</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLAXOSMITHKLINE PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37733W105</cusip>
    <value>35925</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>832950</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>832950</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLOBALSTAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>378973408</cusip>
    <value>25</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20754</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20754</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLOBAL NET LEASE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>379378102</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1491</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1491</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLOBAL PMTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37940X102</cusip>
    <value>265</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3446</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3446</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLOBAL PMTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37940X102</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>127</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>127</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLOBAL BRASS &amp; COPPR HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>37953G103</cusip>
    <value>1240</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42908</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42908</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GODADDY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>380237107</cusip>
    <value>34375</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>995513</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>995513</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOLDCORP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>380956409</cusip>
    <value>1156</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOLDCORP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>380956409</cusip>
    <value>35</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2140</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2140</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOLDFIELD CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>381370105</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1354</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1354</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>38141G104</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>353</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>353</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>38141G104</cusip>
    <value>22847</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>141671</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>141671</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOODYEAR TIRE &amp; RUBR CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>382550101</cusip>
    <value>756</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23397</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23397</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOODYEAR TIRE &amp; RUBR CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>382550101</cusip>
    <value>3458</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>107051</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>107051</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOODYEAR TIRE &amp; RUBR CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>382550101</cusip>
    <value>12515</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>387452</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>387452</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOODYEAR TIRE &amp; RUBR CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>382550101</cusip>
    <value>30801</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>953594</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>874464</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>79130</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRACO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>384109104</cusip>
    <value>1845</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24931</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24931</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAHAM HLDGS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>384637104</cusip>
    <value>1145</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2379</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2379</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAINGER W W INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>384802104</cusip>
    <value>321</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1427</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1427</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAINGER W W INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>384802104</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>167</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>167</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRANITE CONSTR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>387328107</cusip>
    <value>635</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12769</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAPHIC PACKAGING HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>388689101</cusip>
    <value>965</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68981</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68981</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAPHIC PACKAGING HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>388689101</cusip>
    <value>4447</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>317881</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>317881</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAPHIC PACKAGING HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>388689101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAPHIC PACKAGING HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>388689101</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>747</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>747</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAY TELEVISION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>389375106</cusip>
    <value>942</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>90960</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>90960</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRAY TELEVISION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>389375106</cusip>
    <value>4469</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>431409</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>431409</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREAT SOUTHN BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>390905107</cusip>
    <value>1243</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30541</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20063</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10478</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREAT PLAINS ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>391164100</cusip>
    <value>3008</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110211</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110211</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREAT WESTN BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>391416104</cusip>
    <value>1389</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREAT WESTN BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>391416104</cusip>
    <value>46</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1368</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1368</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREAT WESTN BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>391416104</cusip>
    <value>12652</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>379698</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>373888</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5810</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREAT WESTN BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>391416104</cusip>
    <value>1275</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38269</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26718</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11551</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREEN DOT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>39304D102</cusip>
    <value>356</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15443</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1767</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13676</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREEN PLAINS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>393222104</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2291</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2291</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREENBRIER COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>393657101</cusip>
    <value>382</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10817</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10692</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>125</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREIF INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>397624107</cusip>
    <value>63</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1271</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1271</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREIF INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>397624107</cusip>
    <value>676</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13625</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13625</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GREIF INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>397624107</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>395</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>395</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRIDSUM HLDG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR REPSG CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>398132100</cusip>
    <value>5055</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>300000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>300000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GROUP 1 AUTOMOTIVE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>398905109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GROUPON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>399473107</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5171</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>79</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRUBHUB INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>400110102</cusip>
    <value>3303</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76825</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>76825</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRUBHUB INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>400110102</cusip>
    <value>658</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15316</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15316</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRUPO AEROPORTUARIO DEL SURE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR SER B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40051E202</cusip>
    <value>3977</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27160</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27160</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GRUPO FINANCIERO SANTANDER M</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR SHS B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40053C105</cusip>
    <value>2062</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>234300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>234300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GUESS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>401617105</cusip>
    <value>100</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6874</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6874</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GUESS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>401617105</cusip>
    <value>318</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21787</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21783</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GULFMARK OFFSHORE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>402629208</cusip>
    <value>42</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25075</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25070</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GULFPORT ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>402635304</cusip>
    <value>1529</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>54107</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>54107</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HCA HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40412C101</cusip>
    <value>2358</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31184</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31184</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HCA HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40412C101</cusip>
    <value>356</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4701</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4701</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HCA HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40412C101</cusip>
    <value>27080</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>358059</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>328306</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>29753</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HCP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40414L109</cusip>
    <value>670</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17642</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17642</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HCI GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40416E103</cusip>
    <value>749</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24663</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14136</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10527</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HD SUPPLY HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40416M105</cusip>
    <value>807</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25245</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25245</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HD SUPPLY HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40416M105</cusip>
    <value>3805</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>118980</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>118980</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HD SUPPLY HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40416M105</cusip>
    <value>13842</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>432822</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>370929</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>61893</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HFF INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40418F108</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1822</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1822</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HMN FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40424G108</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>538</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>538</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HNI CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>404251100</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>387</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>387</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HNI CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>404251100</cusip>
    <value>961</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24148</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24148</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HNI CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>404251100</cusip>
    <value>33</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>836</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>836</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HMS HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40425J101</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>584</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>584</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HSN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>404303109</cusip>
    <value>773</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19410</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19410</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HSN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>404303109</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>271</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>271</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40434L105</cusip>
    <value>28</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1782</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1782</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40434L105</cusip>
    <value>25267</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1626960</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1626960</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40434L105</cusip>
    <value>36609</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2357312</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2325628</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>31684</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HACKETT GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>404609109</cusip>
    <value>1089</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65893</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65893</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAEMONETICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>405024100</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1591</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1591</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAIN CELESTIAL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>405217100</cusip>
    <value>2039</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>57304</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57304</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAIN CELESTIAL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>405217100</cusip>
    <value>454</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12756</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12756</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HALLADOR ENERGY COMPANY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40609P105</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>913</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>913</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HALLIBURTON CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>406216101</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HALLIBURTON CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>406216101</cusip>
    <value>709</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15804</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15804</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HALLIBURTON CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>406216101</cusip>
    <value>314</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6989</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6989</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HALOZYME THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40637H109</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2004</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2004</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HALYARD HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40650V100</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1661</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1661</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HALYARD HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>40650V100</cusip>
    <value>1292</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37268</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37268</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HANCOCK HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>410120109</cusip>
    <value>1354</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41762</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41762</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HANCOCK HLDG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>410120109</cusip>
    <value>293</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9032</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7315</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1717</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HANESBRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>410345102</cusip>
    <value>201</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7969</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7969</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HANESBRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>410345102</cusip>
    <value>15905</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>629900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>629900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HANNON ARMSTRONG SUST INFR C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>41068X100</cusip>
    <value>5576</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>238600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>238600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HANOVER INS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>410867105</cusip>
    <value>1831</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24284</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24284</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HANOVER INS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>410867105</cusip>
    <value>450</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5971</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5971</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARLEY DAVIDSON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>412822108</cusip>
    <value>205</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3892</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3892</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARLEY DAVIDSON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>412822108</cusip>
    <value>4030</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76632</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>69542</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7090</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARMAN INTL INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>413086109</cusip>
    <value>136</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1605</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1605</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARRIS CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>413875105</cusip>
    <value>11939</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>130320</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>130320</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARSCO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>415864107</cusip>
    <value>1248</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>125695</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>125490</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>205</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARTE-HANKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>416196103</cusip>
    <value>17</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10474</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5378</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5096</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARTFORD FINL SVCS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>416515104</cusip>
    <value>2260</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52788</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4812</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>47976</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARTFORD FINL SVCS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>416515104</cusip>
    <value>35677</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>833185</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>833185</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARTFORD FINL SVCS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>416515104</cusip>
    <value>9535</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>222675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>220190</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2485</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HARTFORD FINL SVCS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>416515104</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>249</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>249</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HASBRO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>418056107</cusip>
    <value>255</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3218</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3218</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HASBRO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>418056107</cusip>
    <value>79</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>996</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>996</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAVERTY FURNITURE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>419596101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAWAIIAN ELEC INDUSTRIES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>419870100</cusip>
    <value>1847</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61890</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61890</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAWAIIAN ELEC INDUSTRIES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>419870100</cusip>
    <value>274</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9175</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9175</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAWAIIAN HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>419879101</cusip>
    <value>65</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1329</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1329</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAWAIIAN HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>419879101</cusip>
    <value>3573</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>73526</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73326</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>200</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAWAIIAN TELCOM HOLDCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>420031106</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>125</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>125</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HAWAIIAN TELCOM HOLDCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>420031106</cusip>
    <value>177</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7883</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6331</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1552</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEALTHCARE RLTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>421946104</cusip>
    <value>1936</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>56850</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>56850</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEALTHCARE RLTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>421946104</cusip>
    <value>2197</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64498</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64498</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEALTHCARE RLTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>421946104</cusip>
    <value>17676</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>518968</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>511478</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7490</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEADWATERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42210P102</cusip>
    <value>47</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2756</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2756</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEADWATERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42210P102</cusip>
    <value>761</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44979</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>44979</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEALTHWAYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>422245100</cusip>
    <value>162</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6129</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6129</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEALTHCARE TR AMER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42225P501</cusip>
    <value>307</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9416</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9416</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEALTHEQUITY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42226A107</cusip>
    <value>508</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13425</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13425</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEARTLAND FINL USA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42234Q102</cusip>
    <value>1985</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55026</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40053</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14973</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HECLA MNG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>422704106</cusip>
    <value>1306</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>229191</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>118348</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>110843</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEICO CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>422806208</cusip>
    <value>355</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5867</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5867</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEIDRICK &amp; STRUGGLES INTL IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>422819102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HELMERICH &amp; PAYNE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>423452101</cusip>
    <value>199</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2953</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2953</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HENRY JACK &amp; ASSOC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>426281101</cusip>
    <value>3754</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43878</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43878</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HERITAGE FINL CORP WASH</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42722X106</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HERITAGE INS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42727J102</cusip>
    <value>850</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58993</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55363</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3630</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HERSHA HOSPITALITY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>PR SHS BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>427825500</cusip>
    <value>19</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1037</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1037</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HERSHEY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>427866108</cusip>
    <value>560</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5861</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5861</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HERSHEY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>427866108</cusip>
    <value>66</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>695</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>695</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HESKA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM RESTRC NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42805E306</cusip>
    <value>17</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>310</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>310</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HERTZ GLOBAL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42806J106</cusip>
    <value>89</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2212</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2212</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HESS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42809H107</cusip>
    <value>93</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1739</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1739</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HESS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42809H107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42824C109</cusip>
    <value>41</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1785</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1785</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42824C109</cusip>
    <value>20610</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>905947</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>905947</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42824C109</cusip>
    <value>11607</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>510200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>510200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HHGREGG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>42833L108</cusip>
    <value>82</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44642</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19571</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>25071</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HIBBETT SPORTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>428567101</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>92</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>92</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HIGHWOODS PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>431284108</cusip>
    <value>1845</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HIGHWOODS PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>431284108</cusip>
    <value>2390</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45864</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45864</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HIGHWOODS PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>431284108</cusip>
    <value>16753</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>321426</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>316671</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4755</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HILL ROM HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>431475102</cusip>
    <value>2104</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33948</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33948</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HILL ROM HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>431475102</cusip>
    <value>69</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1115</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1115</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HILLENBRAND INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>431571108</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1890</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1890</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HILLTOP HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>432748101</cusip>
    <value>1989</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>88575</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>88575</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HILLTOP HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>432748101</cusip>
    <value>15377</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>684619</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>673379</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11240</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HILTON WORLDWIDE HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>43300A104</cusip>
    <value>74734</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3259213</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3205800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>53413</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOLLYFRONTIER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>436106108</cusip>
    <value>1968</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80309</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80309</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOLLYFRONTIER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>436106108</cusip>
    <value>3591</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>146591</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>138083</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8508</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOLOGIC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>436440101</cusip>
    <value>502</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12939</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12939</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOLOGIC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>436440101</cusip>
    <value>1374</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35374</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>474</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOME BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>436893200</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2752</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2752</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOME DEPOT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>437076102</cusip>
    <value>62</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>482</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>482</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOME DEPOT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>437076102</cusip>
    <value>23770</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>184722</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>184722</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOME DEPOT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>437076102</cusip>
    <value>46291</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>359735</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>350430</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9305</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOME DEPOT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>437076102</cusip>
    <value>99</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>752</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HONDA MOTOR LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>AMERN SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>438128308</cusip>
    <value>1991</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68854</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68854</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HONDA MOTOR LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>AMERN SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>438128308</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HONEYWELL INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>438516106</cusip>
    <value>2240</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19216</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19216</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HONEYWELL INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>438516106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOPE BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>43940T109</cusip>
    <value>59</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3377</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3377</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOPE BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>43940T109</cusip>
    <value>44</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2551</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2469</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>82</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HORIZON BANCORP IND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>440407104</cusip>
    <value>234</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7961</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3825</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4136</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HORMEL FOODS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>440452100</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>428</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>428</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HORMEL FOODS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>440452100</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>244</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>244</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HORNBECK OFFSHORE SVCS INC N</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>440543106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOSPITALITY PPTYS TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44106M102</cusip>
    <value>76</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2545</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2545</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOSPITALITY PPTYS TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44106M102</cusip>
    <value>27261</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>917266</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>917266</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOST HOTELS &amp; RESORTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44107P104</cusip>
    <value>303</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19472</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19472</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOUGHTON MIFFLIN HARCOURT CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44157R109</cusip>
    <value>955</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>71200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>71200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOUGHTON MIFFLIN HARCOURT CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44157R109</cusip>
    <value>8712</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>649656</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>639976</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9680</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOULIHAN LOKEY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>441593100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HOUSTON WIRE &amp; CABLE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44244K109</cusip>
    <value>25</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3985</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>994</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2991</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUBBELL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>443510607</cusip>
    <value>2947</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27354</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27354</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUBSPOT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>443573100</cusip>
    <value>592</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10273</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10273</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUMANA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>444859102</cusip>
    <value>638</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3609</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3609</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUMANA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>444859102</cusip>
    <value>561</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3174</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3174</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNT J B TRANS SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>445658107</cusip>
    <value>181</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2232</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2232</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTINGTON BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>446150104</cusip>
    <value>307</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31142</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31142</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTINGTON BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>446150104</cusip>
    <value>445</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45110</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>44572</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>538</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTINGTON INGALLS INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>446413106</cusip>
    <value>33014</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>215188</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>215188</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTINGTON INGALLS INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>446413106</cusip>
    <value>606</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3951</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3951</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTINGTON INGALLS INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>446413106</cusip>
    <value>7067</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46061</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43545</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2516</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTSMAN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>447011107</cusip>
    <value>3329</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>204584</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83481</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>121103</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTSMAN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>447011107</cusip>
    <value>2907</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>178673</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>178673</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTSMAN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>447011107</cusip>
    <value>23233</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1427935</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1410164</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17771</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUNTSMAN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>447011107</cusip>
    <value>13545</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>832496</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>734979</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>97517</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HURON CONSULTING GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>447462102</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>160</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>160</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HUTTIG BLDG PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>448451104</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1803</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1803</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>448947507</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>688</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>688</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HYSTER YALE MATLS HANDLING I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>449172105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IAC INTERACTIVECORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44919P508</cusip>
    <value>404</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6472</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6472</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ICF INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44925C103</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>135</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>135</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ICU MED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44930G107</cusip>
    <value>37</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>291</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>291</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ICAD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44934S206</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1049</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1049</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IEC ELECTRS CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44949L105</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>930</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>930</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IPG PHOTONICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>44980X109</cusip>
    <value>1654</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20085</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20085</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISTAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45031U101</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1122</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1122</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IXIA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45071R109</cusip>
    <value>17</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1327</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1327</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IXIA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45071R109</cusip>
    <value>1447</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>115792</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>115661</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>131</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ITT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45073V108</cusip>
    <value>1672</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46638</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46638</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ITT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45073V108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IBERIABANK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>450828108</cusip>
    <value>1181</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IBERIABANK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>450828108</cusip>
    <value>7791</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>116075</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>113740</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2335</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IBERIABANK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>450828108</cusip>
    <value>588</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8767</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6561</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2206</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ICONIX BRAND GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>451055107</cusip>
    <value>976</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120163</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83043</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>37120</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDACORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>451107106</cusip>
    <value>67</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>860</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>860</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDACORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>451107106</cusip>
    <value>2240</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28616</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28616</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDACORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>451107106</cusip>
    <value>45</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>570</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45167R104</cusip>
    <value>3810</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40717</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40717</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDEXX LABS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45168D104</cusip>
    <value>5587</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49559</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49559</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDEXX LABS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45168D104</cusip>
    <value>129267</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1146700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1129400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17300</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDEXX LABS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45168D104</cusip>
    <value>21296</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>188913</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>167578</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21335</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IDERA PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45168K306</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2319</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2319</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ILLINOIS TOOL WKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>452308109</cusip>
    <value>961</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8018</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8018</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ILLINOIS TOOL WKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>452308109</cusip>
    <value>608</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5077</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5077</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ILLUMINA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>452327109</cusip>
    <value>654</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3598</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3598</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IMAGE SENSING SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45244C104</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1194</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1194</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IMATION CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45245A107</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2754</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2754</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IMMUNOGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45253H101</cusip>
    <value>171</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63751</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>63751</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IMPAX LABORATORIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45256B101</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1595</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1595</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IMPAX LABORATORIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45256B101</cusip>
    <value>349</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14705</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14705</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IMPINJ INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>453204109</cusip>
    <value>6062</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>162000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>162000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INC RESH HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45329R109</cusip>
    <value>62</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1394</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1394</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INC RESH HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45329R109</cusip>
    <value>563</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12635</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12635</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INCYTE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45337C102</cusip>
    <value>592</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6281</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6281</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INDEPENDENCE CONTRACT DRIL I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>453415309</cusip>
    <value>4200</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>800000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>800000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INDEPENDENCE HLDG CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>453440307</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>317</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>317</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INDEPENDENCE RLTY TR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45378A106</cusip>
    <value>225</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INDEPENDENT BANK CORP MASS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>453836108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INDEPENDENT BANK CORP MICH</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>453838609</cusip>
    <value>54</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3205</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1942</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1263</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INFINITY PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45665G303</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3641</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3641</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INFOBLOX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45672H104</cusip>
    <value>69</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2605</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2605</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INFOBLOX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45672H104</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>306</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>306</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INFORMATION SERVICES GROUP I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45675Y104</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>360</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>360</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INFOSYS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>456788108</cusip>
    <value>94</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5950</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5950</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ING GROEP N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>456837103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INFUSYSTEM HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45685K102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>159</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>159</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INFRAREIT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45685L100</cusip>
    <value>53</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2907</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2907</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGEVITY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45688C107</cusip>
    <value>17710</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>384175</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>384175</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGLES MKTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>457030104</cusip>
    <value>819</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20709</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12954</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7755</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGRAM MICRO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>457153104</cusip>
    <value>3336</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>93554</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>93554</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGRAM MICRO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>457153104</cusip>
    <value>484</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13573</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13573</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGREDION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>457187102</cusip>
    <value>23170</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>174135</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>174135</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGREDION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>457187102</cusip>
    <value>481</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3613</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3613</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGREDION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>457187102</cusip>
    <value>10799</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>81159</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>77910</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3249</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INSIGHT ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45765U103</cusip>
    <value>1919</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58970</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38421</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>20549</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INNOSPEC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45768S105</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INNERWORKINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45773Y105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>66</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INNOPHOS HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45774N108</cusip>
    <value>372</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9543</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8103</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1440</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INSTEEL INDUSTRIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45774W108</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>333</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>333</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INSPERITY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45778Q107</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>826</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>826</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INSPERITY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45778Q107</cusip>
    <value>25</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>342</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>342</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INOGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45780L104</cusip>
    <value>840</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14028</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13995</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>33</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INNOVIVA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45781M101</cusip>
    <value>829</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75431</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75431</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INSTRUCTURE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45781U103</cusip>
    <value>9258</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>364900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>364900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTEGRA LIFESCIENCES HLDGS C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>457985208</cusip>
    <value>1026</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12425</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12425</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTEGRA LIFESCIENCES HLDGS C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>457985208</cusip>
    <value>9106</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110314</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>108669</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1645</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTEGRATED DEVICE TECHNOLOGY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>458118106</cusip>
    <value>1709</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>73985</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73985</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTEGRATED DEVICE TECHNOLOGY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>458118106</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTEL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>458140100</cusip>
    <value>17</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>458</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>458</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTEL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>458140100</cusip>
    <value>10321</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>273410</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>273410</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTEL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>458140100</cusip>
    <value>442</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11699</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11699</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTEL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>458140100</cusip>
    <value>30104</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>797459</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>755410</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>42049</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INSYS THERAPEUTICS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45824V209</cusip>
    <value>1242</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>105331</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>104936</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>395</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTELIQUENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45825N107</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>202</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>202</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTELIQUENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45825N107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERCEPT PHARMACEUTICALS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45845P108</cusip>
    <value>514</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3122</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3122</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERCONTINENTAL HOTELS GROU</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR NW 2016</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45857P608</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>53</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERFACE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>458665304</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2276</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2276</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERFACE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>458665304</cusip>
    <value>717</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42984</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42984</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERCONTINENTAL EXCHANGE IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45866F104</cusip>
    <value>3531</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13109</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13109</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERDIGITAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45867G101</cusip>
    <value>72</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>907</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>907</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERDIGITAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45867G101</cusip>
    <value>1910</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24116</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERDIGITAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45867G101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERNAP CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $.001</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>45885A300</cusip>
    <value>185</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111851</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>111851</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL BANCSHARES COR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>459044103</cusip>
    <value>1362</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45731</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45731</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>459200101</cusip>
    <value>5594</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35218</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35218</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>459200101</cusip>
    <value>149</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>938</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>938</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>459200101</cusip>
    <value>30667</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>193055</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>181569</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11486</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL FLAVORS&amp;FRAGRA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>459506101</cusip>
    <value>330</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2308</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2308</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTL PAPER CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>460146103</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>309</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>309</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTL PAPER CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>460146103</cusip>
    <value>4266</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>88916</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>88916</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTL PAPER CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>460146103</cusip>
    <value>28596</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>596000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>596000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTL PAPER CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>460146103</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>214</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>214</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL SPEEDWAY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>460335201</cusip>
    <value>394</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11788</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11788</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERSIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46069S109</cusip>
    <value>1649</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75204</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75204</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERSECT ENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46071F103</cusip>
    <value>28937</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1826803</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1826803</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTRAWEST RESORTS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46090K109</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>877</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>877</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERVAL LEISURE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46113M108</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>247</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>247</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTL FCSTONE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46116V105</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>277</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>277</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTRALINKS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46118H104</cusip>
    <value>147</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14649</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13590</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1059</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTUIT</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>461202103</cusip>
    <value>704</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6398</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6398</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTUIT</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>461202103</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVACARE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>461203101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTUITIVE SURGICAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46120E602</cusip>
    <value>694</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>957</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>957</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTUITIVE SURGICAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46120E602</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTREPID POTASH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46121Y102</cusip>
    <value>19</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16691</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8252</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8439</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INUVO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46122W204</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2643</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2643</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVENSENSE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46123D205</cusip>
    <value>33</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4509</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4509</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVESCO MORTGAGE CAPITAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46131B100</cusip>
    <value>1538</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>101000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>101000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVESCO MORTGAGE CAPITAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46131B100</cusip>
    <value>59</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3888</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3888</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVESCO MORTGAGE CAPITAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46131B100</cusip>
    <value>13971</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>917337</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>904297</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13040</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVESTORS BANCORP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46146L101</cusip>
    <value>66</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5522</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5522</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IONIS PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>462222100</cusip>
    <value>733</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IRADIMED CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46266A109</cusip>
    <value>239</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14060</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14060</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IROBOT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>462726100</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>IRON MTN INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46284V101</cusip>
    <value>194</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5181</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5181</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>MSCI JAPAN ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464286848</cusip>
    <value>3614</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>288200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>288200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SELECT DIVID ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464287168</cusip>
    <value>1132</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13208</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13208</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>IBOXX INV CP ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464287242</cusip>
    <value>849</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6896</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6896</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>IBOXX INV CP ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464287242</cusip>
    <value>312</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2534</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2534</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>IBOXX INV CP ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464287242</cusip>
    <value>575</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4665</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4665</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>MSCI EAFE ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464287465</cusip>
    <value>5676</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>96000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>96000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>NASDQ BIOTEC ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464287556</cusip>
    <value>31349</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>108300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>108300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>RUS 1000 VAL ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464287598</cusip>
    <value>30302</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>286900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>286900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>U.S. REAL ES ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464287739</cusip>
    <value>6216</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>77079</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>77079</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>JP MOR EM MK ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464288281</cusip>
    <value>1160</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>MBS ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464288588</cusip>
    <value>314</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2850</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2850</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>MBS ETF</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464288588</cusip>
    <value>877</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7970</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7970</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CORE MSCI EMKT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46434G103</cusip>
    <value>30010</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>657964</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>657964</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CORE MSCI EMKT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46434G103</cusip>
    <value>1368</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>HDG MSCI JAPAN</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46434V886</cusip>
    <value>3216</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>129791</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>113141</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16650</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ISLE OF CAPRI CASINOS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>464592104</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ITAU UNIBANCO HLDG SA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR REP PFD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>465562106</cusip>
    <value>189</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17277</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17277</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JPMORGAN CHASE &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46625H100</cusip>
    <value>671</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10075</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10075</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JPMORGAN CHASE &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46625H100</cusip>
    <value>60723</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>911888</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>911888</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JPMORGAN CHASE &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46625H100</cusip>
    <value>85934</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1290500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1263842</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>26658</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JPMORGAN CHASE &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>46625H100</cusip>
    <value>37486</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>562931</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>534044</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>28887</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JABIL CIRCUIT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>466313103</cusip>
    <value>1881</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86216</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86216</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JABIL CIRCUIT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>466313103</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>680</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>680</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JACK IN THE BOX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>466367109</cusip>
    <value>67</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JACK IN THE BOX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>466367109</cusip>
    <value>1709</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17813</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17813</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JACK IN THE BOX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>466367109</cusip>
    <value>701</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7307</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7307</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JACOBS ENGR GROUP INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>469814107</cusip>
    <value>392</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7579</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7579</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JACOBS ENGR GROUP INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>469814107</cusip>
    <value>658</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12724</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12683</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>41</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JAKKS PAC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>47012E106</cusip>
    <value>106</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12251</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9031</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3220</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JANUS CAP GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>47102X105</cusip>
    <value>1506</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>107496</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>107496</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JETBLUE AIRWAYS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>477143101</cusip>
    <value>3006</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>174384</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>174384</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JETBLUE AIRWAYS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>477143101</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>304</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>304</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JETBLUE AIRWAYS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>477143101</cusip>
    <value>5203</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>301819</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>284515</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17304</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JOHN BEAN TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>477839104</cusip>
    <value>622</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8812</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8812</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JOHNSON &amp; JOHNSON</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>478160104</cusip>
    <value>137305</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1162322</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>634884</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>527438</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JOHNSON &amp; JOHNSON</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>478160104</cusip>
    <value>247769</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2097423</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2097423</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JOHNSON &amp; JOHNSON</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>478160104</cusip>
    <value>1104</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9348</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9348</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JOHNSON &amp; JOHNSON</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>478160104</cusip>
    <value>3786</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32046</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31888</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>158</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JOHNSON OUTDOORS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>479167108</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>286</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>286</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JONES LANG LASALLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48020Q107</cusip>
    <value>2874</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25255</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25255</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JONES LANG LASALLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48020Q107</cusip>
    <value>93</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>815</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>815</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JOY GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>481165108</cusip>
    <value>1900</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68494</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68494</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>J2 GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48123V102</cusip>
    <value>1775</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26645</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26645</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>J2 GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48123V102</cusip>
    <value>2103</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31567</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31528</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>39</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JUNIPER NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48203R104</cusip>
    <value>222</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9221</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9221</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JUNIPER NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48203R104</cusip>
    <value>37</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1555</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1555</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JUNIPER NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48203R104</cusip>
    <value>12677</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>526873</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>504246</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22627</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JUNO THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48205A109</cusip>
    <value>900</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KAR AUCTION SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48238T109</cusip>
    <value>41731</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>966900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>966900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KAR AUCTION SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48238T109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KBR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48242W106</cusip>
    <value>1158</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76528</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>76528</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KBR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48242W106</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>157</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>157</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KCG HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48244B100</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3717</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3717</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KLA-TENCOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>482480100</cusip>
    <value>4338</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62224</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62224</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KLA-TENCOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>482480100</cusip>
    <value>542</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7777</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7777</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KLX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>482539103</cusip>
    <value>971</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27588</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27588</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KMG CHEMICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>482564101</cusip>
    <value>831</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29332</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28181</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1151</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>K12 INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48273U102</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>287</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>287</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KADANT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48282T104</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>229</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>229</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KAMAN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>483548103</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KANSAS CITY SOUTHERN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>485170302</cusip>
    <value>1652</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KANSAS CITY SOUTHERN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>485170302</cusip>
    <value>482</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5167</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5167</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KANSAS CITY SOUTHERN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>485170302</cusip>
    <value>1036</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KAPSTONE PAPER &amp; PACKAGING C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48562P103</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KATE SPADE &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>485865109</cusip>
    <value>1209</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70593</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70593</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KB HOME</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48666K109</cusip>
    <value>2043</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>126751</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>126751</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KB HOME</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48666K109</cusip>
    <value>417</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25896</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25896</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEARNY FINL CORP MD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48716P108</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>726</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>726</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEARNY FINL CORP MD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>48716P108</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>119</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>119</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KELLOGG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>487836108</cusip>
    <value>438</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5650</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5650</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KELLY SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>488152208</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>255</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>255</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEMPER CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>488401100</cusip>
    <value>1039</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26416</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26416</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEMPHARM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>488445107</cusip>
    <value>898</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>200000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KENNAMETAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>489170100</cusip>
    <value>1060</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36525</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36525</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KENNAMETAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>489170100</cusip>
    <value>1265</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43594</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43594</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KENNAMETAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>489170100</cusip>
    <value>9630</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>331855</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>327055</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4800</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KENNAMETAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>489170100</cusip>
    <value>1256</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43266</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43166</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>100</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KENNEDY-WILSON HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>489398107</cusip>
    <value>63</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2779</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2779</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEYCORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>493267108</cusip>
    <value>3248</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>266913</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7169</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>259744</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEYCORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>493267108</cusip>
    <value>371</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30474</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30474</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEYCORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>493267108</cusip>
    <value>24591</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2020624</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2006591</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14033</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEYCORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>493267108</cusip>
    <value>3649</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>299825</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>280866</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18959</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEYSIGHT TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49338L103</cusip>
    <value>2903</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>91619</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>91619</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEYSIGHT TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49338L103</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>99</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>99</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KEYW HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>493723100</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1047</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>992</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KFORCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>493732101</cusip>
    <value>373</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18180</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18180</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KILROY RLTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49427F108</cusip>
    <value>3557</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51297</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51297</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KIMBERLY CLARK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>494368103</cusip>
    <value>183861</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1457592</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>801386</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>656206</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KIMBERLY CLARK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>494368103</cusip>
    <value>279414</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2215112</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2215112</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KIMBERLY CLARK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>494368103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KIMCO RLTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49446R109</cusip>
    <value>69</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2395</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2395</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KINDER MORGAN INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49456B101</cusip>
    <value>1084</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46859</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46859</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KINDER MORGAN INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49456B101</cusip>
    <value>81</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3499</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2813</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>686</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KIRBY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>497266106</cusip>
    <value>1776</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28566</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28566</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KIRKLANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>497498105</cusip>
    <value>81</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6628</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6628</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KITE PHARMA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49803L109</cusip>
    <value>559</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KITE RLTY GROUP TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49803T300</cusip>
    <value>2220</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80075</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80075</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KITE RLTY GROUP TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49803T300</cusip>
    <value>20243</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>730250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>719815</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10435</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KNOLL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>498904200</cusip>
    <value>49</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2149</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2149</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KNOLL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>498904200</cusip>
    <value>2786</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>121909</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>121909</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KNOWLES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>49926D109</cusip>
    <value>674</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47954</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47954</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KOHLS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>500255104</cusip>
    <value>17298</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>395373</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>395373</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KOHLS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>500255104</cusip>
    <value>14329</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>327519</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>305384</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22135</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>NY REG SH NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>500472303</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>252</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>252</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KOPPERS HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>50060P106</cusip>
    <value>429</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13345</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13345</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KORN FERRY INTL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>500643200</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1131</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1131</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KRAFT HEINZ CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>500754106</cusip>
    <value>130144</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1453961</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>804485</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>649476</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KRAFT HEINZ CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>500754106</cusip>
    <value>342728</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3828932</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3828932</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KRAFT HEINZ CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>500754106</cusip>
    <value>683</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7626</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7626</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KRATOS DEFENSE &amp; SEC SOLUTIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>50077B207</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1298</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1298</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KRATON CORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>50077C106</cusip>
    <value>7782</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>222100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>222100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KROGER CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>501044101</cusip>
    <value>665</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22414</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22414</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KROGER CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>501044101</cusip>
    <value>30793</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1037490</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>942693</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>94797</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>L BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>501797104</cusip>
    <value>195</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2751</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2751</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>L BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>501797104</cusip>
    <value>221</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3117</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3117</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LHC GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>50187A107</cusip>
    <value>69</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1880</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1821</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>59</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LKQ CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>501889208</cusip>
    <value>41</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1167</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1167</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>L-3 COMMUNICATIONS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>502424104</cusip>
    <value>9622</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63834</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>63834</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>L-3 COMMUNICATIONS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>502424104</cusip>
    <value>508</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3371</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3371</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LA QUINTA HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>50420D108</cusip>
    <value>845</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75618</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75618</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LA QUINTA HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>50420D108</cusip>
    <value>4095</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>366239</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>366239</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LA Z BOY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>505336107</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1953</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1953</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LABORATORY CORP AMER HLDGS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>50540R409</cusip>
    <value>301</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LABORATORY CORP AMER HLDGS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>50540R409</cusip>
    <value>13372</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97267</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>89212</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8055</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAKELAND BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>511637100</cusip>
    <value>204</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14550</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11934</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2616</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAM RESEARCH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>512807108</cusip>
    <value>71</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>750</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>750</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAM RESEARCH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>512807108</cusip>
    <value>23299</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>246006</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>246006</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAM RESEARCH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>512807108</cusip>
    <value>321</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3394</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3394</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAM RESEARCH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>512807108</cusip>
    <value>77</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>813</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>810</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAMAR ADVERTISING CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>512816109</cusip>
    <value>2957</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45282</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45282</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAMAR ADVERTISING CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>512816109</cusip>
    <value>16719</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>256000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>256000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LANCASTER COLONY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>513847103</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LANCASTER COLONY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>513847103</cusip>
    <value>996</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7539</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7539</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LANDMARK BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>51504L107</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>191</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>191</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LANDSTAR SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>515098101</cusip>
    <value>1636</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24029</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24029</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LANDS END INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>51509F105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>91</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>91</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LANNET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>516012101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LANTHEUS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>516544103</cusip>
    <value>783</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>94624</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>94624</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAS VEGAS SANDS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>517834107</cusip>
    <value>27700</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>481400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>481400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LASALLE HOTEL PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>517942108</cusip>
    <value>767</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32125</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32125</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LASALLE HOTEL PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>517942108</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>744</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>744</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LASALLE HOTEL PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>517942108</cusip>
    <value>1543</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64662</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64662</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LASALLE HOTEL PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>517942108</cusip>
    <value>7049</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>295304</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>290864</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4440</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAUDER ESTEE COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>518439104</cusip>
    <value>530</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5987</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5987</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAUDER ESTEE COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>518439104</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>672</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>672</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAUDER ESTEE COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>518439104</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>521865204</cusip>
    <value>782</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6450</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>521865204</cusip>
    <value>3666</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30245</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30245</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>521865204</cusip>
    <value>338</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2787</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2787</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>521865204</cusip>
    <value>29921</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>246833</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>224793</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22040</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEE ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>523768109</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2042</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2042</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEGGETT &amp; PLATT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>524660107</cusip>
    <value>2871</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62985</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62985</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEGACY TEX FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>52471Y106</cusip>
    <value>1057</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33420</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24658</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8762</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEGG MASON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>524901105</cusip>
    <value>31</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>938</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>938</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEGG MASON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>524901105</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1780</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1780</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEIDOS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>525327102</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>870</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>870</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEIDOS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>525327102</cusip>
    <value>35072</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>810348</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>810348</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEMAITRE VASCULAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>525558201</cusip>
    <value>1990</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100292</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>96265</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4027</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LENNAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>526057104</cusip>
    <value>413</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9744</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9744</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LENNOX INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>526107107</cusip>
    <value>3354</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21357</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21357</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LENNOX INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>526107107</cusip>
    <value>341</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2173</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2173</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEUCADIA NATL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>527288104</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEUCADIA NATL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>527288104</cusip>
    <value>107</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5617</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5617</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEVEL 3 COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>52729N308</cusip>
    <value>340</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7334</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7334</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEXICON PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>528872302</cusip>
    <value>78</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4294</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4294</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEXINGTON REALTY TRUST</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>529043101</cusip>
    <value>996</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>96725</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>96725</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEXINGTON REALTY TRUST</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>529043101</cusip>
    <value>1082</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>105000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>105000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEXINGTON REALTY TRUST</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>529043101</cusip>
    <value>9134</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>886763</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>874303</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12460</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEXMARK INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>529771107</cusip>
    <value>1445</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36156</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36156</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEXMARK INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>529771107</cusip>
    <value>284</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7096</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7096</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LEXMARK INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>529771107</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>385</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>385</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBBEY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>529898108</cusip>
    <value>2805</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>157116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>156953</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>163</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY BROADBAND CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>530307107</cusip>
    <value>479</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6821</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6821</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY MEDIA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>DEB   3.500% 1/1</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>530715AN1</cusip>
    <value>14921</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28218000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>PRN</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28218000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY INTERACTIVE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>QVC GP COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53071M104</cusip>
    <value>73</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3664</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3664</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY INTERACTIVE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>QVC GP COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53071M104</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>0</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY PPTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>531172104</cusip>
    <value>3319</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>82244</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82244</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY MEDIA CORP DELAWARE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM C SIRIUSXM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>531229607</cusip>
    <value>26</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>787</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>787</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY MEDIA CORP DELAWARE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM C MEDIA GRP</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>531229854</cusip>
    <value>25</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>901</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>901</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY TAX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53128T102</cusip>
    <value>837</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65489</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65166</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>323</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIFEPOINT HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53219L109</cusip>
    <value>1374</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23190</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23190</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIFEVANTAGE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53222K205</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>598</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>598</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIFETIME BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53222Q103</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>385</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>385</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIFE STORAGE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53223X107</cusip>
    <value>1850</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20799</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20799</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIFELOCK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53224V100</cusip>
    <value>301</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17769</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LILLY ELI &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>532457108</cusip>
    <value>12009</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>149626</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>149626</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LILLY ELI &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>532457108</cusip>
    <value>614</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7656</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7656</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LINCOLN EDL SVCS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>533535100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>253</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>253</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LINCOLN ELEC HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>533900106</cusip>
    <value>2164</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34552</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34552</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LINCOLN NATL CORP IND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>534187109</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>808</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>808</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LINCOLN NATL CORP IND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>534187109</cusip>
    <value>44</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>937</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>937</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LINCOLN NATL CORP IND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>534187109</cusip>
    <value>350</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7441</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7441</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LINEAR TECHNOLOGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>535678106</cusip>
    <value>364</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6136</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6136</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LINEAR TECHNOLOGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>535678106</cusip>
    <value>522</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8797</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8797</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LINE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53567X101</cusip>
    <value>8179</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>168980</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>168980</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LION BIOTECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53619R102</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1221</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1221</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIONBRIDGE TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>536252109</cusip>
    <value>101</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20113</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20113</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIPOCINE INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53630X104</cusip>
    <value>364</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>81549</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>81131</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>418</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIQUIDITY SERVICES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>53635B107</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>690</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>690</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LITHIA MTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>536797103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIVE NATION ENTERTAINMENT IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>538034109</cusip>
    <value>1946</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIVE NATION ENTERTAINMENT IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>538034109</cusip>
    <value>906</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32980</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31430</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1550</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LOCKHEED MARTIN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>539830109</cusip>
    <value>1727</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7203</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7203</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LOEWS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>540424108</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LOEWS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>540424108</cusip>
    <value>512</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12442</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12442</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LOUISIANA PAC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>546347105</cusip>
    <value>1483</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78762</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78762</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LOWES COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>548661107</cusip>
    <value>913</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12648</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12648</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LOWES COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>548661107</cusip>
    <value>7367</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>102028</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>102028</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LOWES COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>548661107</cusip>
    <value>1427</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19764</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19764</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LOWES COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>548661107</cusip>
    <value>1617</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22396</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22295</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>101</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LUMBER LIQUIDATORS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55003T107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LYDALL INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>550819106</cusip>
    <value>347</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6779</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1079</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>M &amp; T BK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55261F104</cusip>
    <value>220</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1893</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1893</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MBIA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55262C100</cusip>
    <value>55</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7086</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7086</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MB FINANCIAL INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55264U108</cusip>
    <value>1793</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47125</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47125</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MB FINANCIAL INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55264U108</cusip>
    <value>1500</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39429</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39429</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MB FINANCIAL INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55264U108</cusip>
    <value>16243</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>426993</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>420833</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6160</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>M D C HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552676108</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>813</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>813</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>M D C HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552676108</cusip>
    <value>12324</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>477663</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>477663</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>M D C HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552676108</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>635</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>635</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MDU RES GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552690109</cusip>
    <value>3155</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>124022</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>124022</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MDC PARTNERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A SUB VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552697104</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2104</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2104</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MFRI INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552721102</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>328</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>328</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MGIC INVT CORP WIS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552848103</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6515</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6515</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MGIC INVT CORP WIS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552848103</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6990</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6990</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MGM RESORTS INTERNATIONAL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>552953101</cusip>
    <value>233</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8942</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8942</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MGM GROWTH PPTYS LLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55303A105</cusip>
    <value>391</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MGM GROWTH PPTYS LLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55303A105</cusip>
    <value>12887</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>494315</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>494315</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>M/I HOMES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55305B101</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>455</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>455</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MKS INSTRUMENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55306N104</cusip>
    <value>1810</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MKS INSTRUMENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55306N104</cusip>
    <value>16434</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>330472</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>325597</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4875</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MRC GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55345K103</cusip>
    <value>1280</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>77900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>77900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MRC GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55345K103</cusip>
    <value>65</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3930</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3930</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MRC GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55345K103</cusip>
    <value>10653</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>648370</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>637955</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10415</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MRC GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55345K103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MSA SAFETY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>553498106</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>315</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>315</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MSA SAFETY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>553498106</cusip>
    <value>556</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9573</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9573</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MSC INDL DIRECT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>553530106</cusip>
    <value>1820</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24793</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24793</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MSCI INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55354G100</cusip>
    <value>4741</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>56485</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>56485</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MSG NETWORK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>553573106</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1257</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1257</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MSG NETWORK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>553573106</cusip>
    <value>29505</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1585427</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1369381</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>216046</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MACOM TECH SOLUTIONS HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55405Y100</cusip>
    <value>43</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1012</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1012</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MACERICH CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>554382101</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>111</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MACK CALI RLTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>554489104</cusip>
    <value>1276</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46876</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46876</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MACROGENICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>556099109</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>676</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>676</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MACROGENICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>556099109</cusip>
    <value>7696</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>257300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>257300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MACYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55616P104</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>273</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>273</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MACYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55616P104</cusip>
    <value>3226</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>87069</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>87069</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MACYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>55616P104</cusip>
    <value>16939</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>457191</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>420578</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>36613</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAGELLAN HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>559079207</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1052</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1052</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAGELLAN HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>559079207</cusip>
    <value>100</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1853</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1648</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>205</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAINSOURCE FINANCIAL GP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>56062Y102</cusip>
    <value>1694</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>67877</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47778</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>20099</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANHATTAN ASSOCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>562750109</cusip>
    <value>2266</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39319</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39319</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANHATTAN ASSOCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>562750109</cusip>
    <value>449</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7788</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7788</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANITOWOC FOODSERVICE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>563568104</cusip>
    <value>1077</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>66400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANITOWOC FOODSERVICE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>563568104</cusip>
    <value>9855</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>607563</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>598783</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8780</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANITOWOC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>563571108</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2836</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2836</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANITOWOC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>563571108</cusip>
    <value>2332</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>486833</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>323076</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>163757</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANNATECH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>563771203</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANNING &amp; NAPIER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>56382Q102</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5324</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5324</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANPOWERGROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>56418H100</cusip>
    <value>17631</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>243989</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>243989</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANPOWERGROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>56418H100</cusip>
    <value>549</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7591</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7591</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MANPOWERGROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>56418H100</cusip>
    <value>32</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>446</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>446</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARATHON OIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>565849106</cusip>
    <value>1709</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>108097</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2978</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>105119</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARATHON OIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>565849106</cusip>
    <value>310</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19617</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19617</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARATHON OIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>565849106</cusip>
    <value>7861</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>497239</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>491442</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5797</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARATHON PETE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>56585A102</cusip>
    <value>51</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1263</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1263</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARATHON PETE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>56585A102</cusip>
    <value>3425</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>84371</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>84371</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARATHON PETE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>56585A102</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>30</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARCUS &amp; MILLICHAP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>566324109</cusip>
    <value>53</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2027</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2027</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARINEMAX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>567908108</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1166</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1166</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARINE PRODS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>568427108</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1147</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1147</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARKEL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>570535104</cusip>
    <value>89</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>96</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>96</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARKETAXESS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57060D108</cusip>
    <value>3431</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20720</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20720</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARKETAXESS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57060D108</cusip>
    <value>23854</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>144052</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>129908</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14144</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARLIN BUSINESS SVCS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>571157106</cusip>
    <value>605</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31243</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17942</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13301</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARRIOTT VACATIONS WRLDWDE C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57164Y107</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>781</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>781</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARRIOTT VACATIONS WRLDWDE C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57164Y107</cusip>
    <value>783</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10646</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>29</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARSH &amp; MCLENNAN COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>571748102</cusip>
    <value>908</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13508</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13508</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARRIOTT INTL INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>571903202</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>215</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>215</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARRIOTT INTL INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>571903202</cusip>
    <value>753</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11184</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11184</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARTIN MARIETTA MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>573284106</cusip>
    <value>235</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1311</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1311</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MARTIN MARIETTA MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>573284106</cusip>
    <value>111795</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>624170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>618060</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6110</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MASCO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>574599106</cusip>
    <value>15822</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>461138</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>461138</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MASCO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>574599106</cusip>
    <value>652</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18991</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18991</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MASIMO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>574795100</cusip>
    <value>2497</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41968</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41610</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>358</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MASTEC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>576323109</cusip>
    <value>63</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2109</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2109</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MASTEC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>576323109</cusip>
    <value>769</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25841</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25841</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MASTERCARD INCORPORATED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57636Q104</cusip>
    <value>2461</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24178</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24178</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MASTERCARD INCORPORATED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57636Q104</cusip>
    <value>62360</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>612755</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>596321</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16434</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MATTEL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>577081102</cusip>
    <value>249</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8217</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8217</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MATTEL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>577081102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAXIM INTEGRATED PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57772K101</cusip>
    <value>5315</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>133099</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>133099</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAXLINEAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57776J100</cusip>
    <value>1034</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAXLINEAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57776J100</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1178</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1178</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAXLINEAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57776J100</cusip>
    <value>9440</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>465715</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>458800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6915</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAXLINEAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>57776J100</cusip>
    <value>194</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9562</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9562</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAXIMUS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>577933104</cusip>
    <value>1598</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28254</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28254</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MBT FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>578877102</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>747</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>747</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCCORMICK &amp; CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NON VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>579780206</cusip>
    <value>251</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2508</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2508</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCDERMOTT INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>580037109</cusip>
    <value>1163</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>232175</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>232175</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCDERMOTT INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>580037109</cusip>
    <value>46</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9256</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9256</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCDERMOTT INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>580037109</cusip>
    <value>10577</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2111103</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2080133</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>30970</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCDERMOTT INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>580037109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>399</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>399</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCDONALDS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>580135101</cusip>
    <value>242493</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2102058</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1170237</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>931821</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCDONALDS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>580135101</cusip>
    <value>423048</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3667201</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3667201</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCDONALDS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>580135101</cusip>
    <value>932</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8080</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8080</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCKESSON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58155Q103</cusip>
    <value>895</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5365</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5365</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCKESSON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58155Q103</cusip>
    <value>77</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>461</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>461</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MCKESSON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58155Q103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEAD JOHNSON NUTRITION CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>582839106</cusip>
    <value>324</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4097</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4097</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDICAL PPTYS TRUST INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58463J304</cusip>
    <value>1955</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>132350</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>132350</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDICINES CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>584688105</cusip>
    <value>904</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23950</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23950</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDICINES CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>584688105</cusip>
    <value>8381</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>222077</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>218922</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3155</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDIFAST INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58470H101</cusip>
    <value>2474</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65457</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64894</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>563</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDNAX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58502B106</cusip>
    <value>3393</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51212</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51212</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDPACE HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58506Q109</cusip>
    <value>2240</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEETME INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>585141104</cusip>
    <value>47</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7591</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7591</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MENTOR GRAPHICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>587200106</cusip>
    <value>71</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2685</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2685</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MENTOR GRAPHICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>587200106</cusip>
    <value>1567</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>59249</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>59249</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MENTOR GRAPHICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>587200106</cusip>
    <value>1187</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44889</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39476</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5413</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERCANTILE BANK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>587376104</cusip>
    <value>630</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23476</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15235</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8241</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERCK &amp; CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58933Y105</cusip>
    <value>253445</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4060972</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3010825</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1050147</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERCK &amp; CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58933Y105</cusip>
    <value>772219</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12373321</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12373321</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERCK &amp; CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58933Y105</cusip>
    <value>1039</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16646</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16646</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERCK &amp; CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58933Y105</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>436</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>351</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>85</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERCURY GENL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>589400100</cusip>
    <value>1177</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21463</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21463</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEREDITH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>589433101</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>170</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEREDITH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>589433101</cusip>
    <value>1055</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20285</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20285</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEREDITH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>589433101</cusip>
    <value>81</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1566</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1543</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>23</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERIDIAN BANCORP INC MD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>58958U103</cusip>
    <value>80</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5114</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2055</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3059</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERIT MED SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>589889104</cusip>
    <value>45</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1855</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1855</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERIT MED SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>589889104</cusip>
    <value>360</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14837</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11425</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3412</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERITOR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59001K100</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4990</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4990</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERITOR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59001K100</cusip>
    <value>78</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7043</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6417</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>626</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MERRIMACK PHARMACEUTICALS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>590328100</cusip>
    <value>635</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>META FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59100U108</cusip>
    <value>1118</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18451</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11764</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6687</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>METLIFE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59156R108</cusip>
    <value>2580</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58075</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58075</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>METLIFE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59156R108</cusip>
    <value>29559</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>665302</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>665302</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>METLIFE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59156R108</cusip>
    <value>2103</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47341</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47341</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>METLIFE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59156R108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>METTLER TOLEDO INTERNATIONAL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>592688105</cusip>
    <value>270</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>643</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>643</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICHAELS COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59408Q106</cusip>
    <value>1649</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68240</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67452</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>788</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROSOFT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>594918104</cusip>
    <value>3264</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>56666</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>56666</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROSOFT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>594918104</cusip>
    <value>44823</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>778185</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>778185</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROSOFT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>594918104</cusip>
    <value>69587</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1208113</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1177113</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>31000</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROSTRATEGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>594972408</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROCHIP TECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>595017104</cusip>
    <value>1165</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18755</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18755</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICRON TECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>595112103</cusip>
    <value>421</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23686</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23686</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICRON TECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>595112103</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>769</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROSEMI CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>595137100</cusip>
    <value>797</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18990</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18990</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROSEMI CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>595137100</cusip>
    <value>3875</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>92308</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>92308</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROSEMI CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>595137100</cusip>
    <value>2621</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62427</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62427</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICROSEMI CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>595137100</cusip>
    <value>70317</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1675000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1675000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MID-AMER APT CMNTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59522J103</cusip>
    <value>3963</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42168</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42168</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MID-AMER APT CMNTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>59522J103</cusip>
    <value>150</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MIDSOUTH BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>598039105</cusip>
    <value>185</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17807</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6291</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11516</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MILLER HERMAN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>600544100</cusip>
    <value>51</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1774</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1774</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MILLER HERMAN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>600544100</cusip>
    <value>918</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32104</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32104</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MILLER HERMAN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>600544100</cusip>
    <value>32</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1116</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MIMEDX GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>602496101</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6031</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6031</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MINDBODY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60255W105</cusip>
    <value>2961</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>150600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>150600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MINDBODY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60255W105</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>522</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>522</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MINERALS TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>603158106</cusip>
    <value>1787</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25286</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25286</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MINERVA NEUROSCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>603380106</cusip>
    <value>89752</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6358642</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6358642</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MIRNA THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60470J103</cusip>
    <value>650</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>330000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>330000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MISTRAS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60649T107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MITCHAM INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>606501104</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3005</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3005</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MITEK SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>606710200</cusip>
    <value>280</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33776</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33714</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>62</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOCON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>607494101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MODINE MFG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>607828100</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>377</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>377</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOHAWK INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>608190104</cusip>
    <value>311</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1553</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1553</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOHAWK INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>608190104</cusip>
    <value>38564</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>192492</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>192492</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOHAWK INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>608190104</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOLINA HEALTHCARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60855R100</cusip>
    <value>916</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOLINA HEALTHCARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60855R100</cusip>
    <value>1788</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30652</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30652</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOLINA HEALTHCARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60855R100</cusip>
    <value>7486</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>128365</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>126265</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2100</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOLINA HEALTHCARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60855R100</cusip>
    <value>219</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3762</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3762</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOLSON COORS BREWING CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60871R209</cusip>
    <value>1572</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14321</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14321</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOLSON COORS BREWING CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>60871R209</cusip>
    <value>585</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5332</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5332</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONARCH CASINO &amp; RESORT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>609027107</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>438</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>438</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONDELEZ INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>609207105</cusip>
    <value>2046</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONDELEZ INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>609207105</cusip>
    <value>1736</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39538</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39538</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONDELEZ INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>609207105</cusip>
    <value>1466</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONOLITHIC PWR SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>609839105</cusip>
    <value>1666</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20701</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20701</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONSANTO CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>61166W101</cusip>
    <value>1331</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13023</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13023</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONSTER BEVERAGE CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>61174X109</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONSTER BEVERAGE CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>61174X109</cusip>
    <value>494</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3367</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3367</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MONSTER BEVERAGE CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>61174X109</cusip>
    <value>507</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3454</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3454</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOODYS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>615369105</cusip>
    <value>464</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4285</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4285</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOOG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>615394202</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>246</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>246</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOOG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>615394202</cusip>
    <value>45</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>750</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>750</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MORGAN STANLEY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>617446448</cusip>
    <value>788</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24580</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24580</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MORGAN STANLEY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>617446448</cusip>
    <value>32088</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1000887</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1000887</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MORGAN STANLEY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>617446448</cusip>
    <value>1123</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35039</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35039</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MORGAN STANLEY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>617446448</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>223</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>223</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOSAIC CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>61945C103</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>377</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>377</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>620076307</cusip>
    <value>355</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4651</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4651</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>620076307</cusip>
    <value>21013</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>275466</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>244789</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>30677</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOVADO GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>624580106</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>832</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>814</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MUELLER INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>624756102</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1793</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1793</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MUELLER WTR PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>624758108</cusip>
    <value>1041</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>82975</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82975</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MUELLER WTR PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>624758108</cusip>
    <value>64</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5089</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5089</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MUELLER WTR PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>624758108</cusip>
    <value>9495</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>756562</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>745552</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11010</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MURPHY OIL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>626717102</cusip>
    <value>2263</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>74447</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>74278</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>169</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MURPHY USA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>626755102</cusip>
    <value>1383</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19380</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19380</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MURPHY USA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>626755102</cusip>
    <value>2137</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29953</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29898</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>55</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MYRIAD GENETICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62855J104</cusip>
    <value>78</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3805</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3805</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NCI BUILDING SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>628852204</cusip>
    <value>120</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8216</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8216</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NCR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62886E108</cusip>
    <value>803</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24945</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24945</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NCR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62886E108</cusip>
    <value>3883</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120634</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>120634</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NCR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62886E108</cusip>
    <value>2588</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80404</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80404</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NCR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62886E108</cusip>
    <value>7438</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>231060</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>199525</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>31535</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NII HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.001</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62913F508</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8178</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7730</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>448</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NIC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62914B100</cusip>
    <value>32766</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1394300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1394300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NMI HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>629209305</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>629337106</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NRG ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>629377508</cusip>
    <value>318</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28375</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28375</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NRG ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>629377508</cusip>
    <value>566</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50492</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50333</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>159</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NRG YIELD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62942X306</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>462</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>462</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NRG YIELD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62942X405</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2954</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2954</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NVR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62944T105</cusip>
    <value>3327</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2029</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2029</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NVR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62944T105</cusip>
    <value>384</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>234</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>234</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NVR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>62944T105</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NACCO INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>629579103</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>233</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>233</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NANOMETRICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>630077105</cusip>
    <value>2258</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>101063</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97130</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3933</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NANOSTRING TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>63009R109</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>583</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>583</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NASDAQ INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>631103108</cusip>
    <value>227</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3366</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3366</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL FUEL GAS CO N J</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>636180101</cusip>
    <value>2579</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47694</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47694</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL GRID PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>636274300</cusip>
    <value>237781</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3343848</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2346777</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>997071</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL INSTRS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>636518102</cusip>
    <value>1722</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60626</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60626</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL OILWELL VARCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>637071101</cusip>
    <value>378</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10277</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10277</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL OILWELL VARCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>637071101</cusip>
    <value>8726</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>237506</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>228144</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9362</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL RETAIL PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>637417106</cusip>
    <value>5671</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111532</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82632</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>28900</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL RETAIL PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>637417106</cusip>
    <value>121532</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2390005</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2390005</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL STORAGE AFFILIATES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SHS BEN IN</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>637870106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONAL STORAGE AFFILIATES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SHS BEN IN</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>637870106</cusip>
    <value>1466</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATIONSTAR MTG HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>63861C109</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3355</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3355</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NAVIGATORS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>638904102</cusip>
    <value>287</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2966</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>316</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2650</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATURES SUNSHINE PRODUCTS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>639027101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>142</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>142</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATUS MEDICAL INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>639050103</cusip>
    <value>41</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1047</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1047</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NATUS MEDICAL INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>639050103</cusip>
    <value>94</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2404</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2366</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>38</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NAVISTAR INTL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>63934E108</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NAVISTAR INTL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>63934E108</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>485</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>485</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NAVIENT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>63938C108</cusip>
    <value>354</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24431</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24431</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NAVIENT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>63938C108</cusip>
    <value>400</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27633</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27633</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NAVIENT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>63938C108</cusip>
    <value>2307</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>159417</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>159149</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>268</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEFF CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>640094207</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>175</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>175</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEFF CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>640094207</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>673</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>673</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEKTAR THERAPEUTICS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>640268108</cusip>
    <value>17597</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1024300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1024300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NELNET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64031N108</cusip>
    <value>1492</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36964</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18444</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18520</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEOGENOMICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64049M209</cusip>
    <value>4499</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>547300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>547300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEOPHOTONICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64051T100</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3684</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2379</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1305</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETAPP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64110D104</cusip>
    <value>481</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13438</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13438</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETAPP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64110D104</cusip>
    <value>11666</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>325686</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>309095</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16591</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETFLIX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64110L106</cusip>
    <value>813</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8246</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8246</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETFLIX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64110L106</cusip>
    <value>392</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3978</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3978</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETEASE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64110W102</cusip>
    <value>337</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETGEAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64111Q104</cusip>
    <value>43</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>704</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>704</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETGEAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64111Q104</cusip>
    <value>2220</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36694</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27141</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9553</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETSCOUT SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64115T104</cusip>
    <value>1064</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36385</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36385</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NETSUITE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64118Q107</cusip>
    <value>36774</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>332228</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>332228</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEUSTAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64126X201</cusip>
    <value>1206</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45371</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45371</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEUSTAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64126X201</cusip>
    <value>2277</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>85638</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80403</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5235</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEVRO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64157F103</cusip>
    <value>31660</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>303285</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>303285</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW JERSEY RES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>646025106</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>96</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>96</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW JERSEY RES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>646025106</cusip>
    <value>1140</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34691</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34691</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW ORIENTAL ED &amp; TECH GRP I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>647581107</cusip>
    <value>176</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW RESIDENTIAL INVT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64828T201</cusip>
    <value>1836</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>132925</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>132925</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW RESIDENTIAL INVT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64828T201</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1334</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1334</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW RESIDENTIAL INVT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64828T201</cusip>
    <value>16807</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1217047</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1198745</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18302</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW RESIDENTIAL INVT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64828T201</cusip>
    <value>608</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>44000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW SR INVT GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>648691103</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>927</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>927</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW YORK CMNTY BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>649445103</cusip>
    <value>3392</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>238352</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>238352</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW YORK CMNTY CAP TR V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT 11/01/2051</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64944P307</cusip>
    <value>10859</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>216747</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>216747</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW YORK REIT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>64976L109</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>440</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>440</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW YORK TIMES CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>650111107</cusip>
    <value>52</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4359</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4359</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEW YORK TIMES CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>650111107</cusip>
    <value>761</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63710</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>63710</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWELL BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651229106</cusip>
    <value>2162</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41064</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41064</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWFIELD EXPL CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651290108</cusip>
    <value>165</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3798</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3798</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWFIELD EXPL CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651290108</cusip>
    <value>15442</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>355314</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>355314</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWFIELD EXPL CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651290108</cusip>
    <value>222</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5115</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4869</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>246</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWLINK GENETICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651511107</cusip>
    <value>1811</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120580</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>119997</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>583</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWMARKET CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651587107</cusip>
    <value>2203</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5132</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5132</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWMARKET CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651587107</cusip>
    <value>217</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>506</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>506</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWMONT MINING CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651639106</cusip>
    <value>1281</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32599</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32599</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWMONT MINING CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651639106</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>257</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>257</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWPARK RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $.01NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>651718504</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1072</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1072</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWS CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65249B109</cusip>
    <value>108</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7730</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7730</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEWS CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65249B208</cusip>
    <value>33</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2299</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2299</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEXSTAR BROADCASTING GROUP I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65336K103</cusip>
    <value>2431</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42117</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42117</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEXSTAR BROADCASTING GROUP I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65336K103</cusip>
    <value>4096</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70977</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70977</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEXSTAR BROADCASTING GROUP I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65336K103</cusip>
    <value>14708</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>254869</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>251139</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3730</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEXTERA ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65339F101</cusip>
    <value>13928</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>113862</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>113862</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEXTERA ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65339F101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NEXTERA ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT 09/01/2019</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65339F820</cusip>
    <value>15337</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>307977</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>307977</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NICE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>653656108</cusip>
    <value>1798</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26863</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26863</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NIKE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>654106103</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>98</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>98</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NIKE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>654106103</cusip>
    <value>1538</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29212</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29212</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NISOURCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65473P105</cusip>
    <value>426</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17669</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17669</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NISOURCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>65473P105</cusip>
    <value>18343</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>760793</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>756627</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4166</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOKIA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>654902204</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>503</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>503</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOBLE ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>655044105</cusip>
    <value>622</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17391</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17391</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORDSON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>655663102</cusip>
    <value>2812</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28228</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28228</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORDSTROM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>655664100</cusip>
    <value>379</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7311</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7311</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORDSTROM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>655664100</cusip>
    <value>20579</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>396663</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>346685</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>49978</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>655844108</cusip>
    <value>11186</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>115253</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>115253</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHERN TR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>665859104</cusip>
    <value>813</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11961</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11961</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>666807102</cusip>
    <value>12338</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>57669</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57669</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>666807102</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>95</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHSTAR RLTY FIN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>66704R803</cusip>
    <value>351</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26680</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26680</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHSTAR ASSET MGMT GROUP I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>66705Y104</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHWEST BANCSHARES INC MD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>667340103</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3835</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3835</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHWEST NAT GAS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>667655104</cusip>
    <value>402</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6680</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5306</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1374</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHWESTERN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>668074305</cusip>
    <value>1513</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26293</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26293</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORTHWESTERN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>668074305</cusip>
    <value>1266</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22006</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11365</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10641</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOVARTIS A G</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>66987V109</cusip>
    <value>4462</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>56510</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12964</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>43546</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOVO-NORDISK A S</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>670100205</cusip>
    <value>5444</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>130900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>130900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOW INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67011P100</cusip>
    <value>1048</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48925</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48925</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOW INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67011P100</cusip>
    <value>40</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1873</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1873</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOW INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67011P100</cusip>
    <value>1709</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>79742</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>79742</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOW INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67011P100</cusip>
    <value>9609</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>448400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>441830</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6570</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NU SKIN ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67018T105</cusip>
    <value>269</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4147</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4147</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NU SKIN ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67018T105</cusip>
    <value>4328</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66818</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>59162</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7656</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NUANCE COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67020Y100</cusip>
    <value>122</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8409</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8380</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>29</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NUCOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>670346105</cusip>
    <value>340</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6868</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6868</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NUCOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>670346105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NVIDIA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67066G104</cusip>
    <value>870</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NVIDIA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67066G104</cusip>
    <value>842</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12290</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12290</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NVIDIA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67066G104</cusip>
    <value>23406</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>341599</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>303707</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>37892</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NUTRI SYS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67069D108</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1875</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1875</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NUTRI SYS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67069D108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NUVASIVE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>670704105</cusip>
    <value>1822</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27329</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27329</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NUVASIVE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>670704105</cusip>
    <value>1429</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21430</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21430</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NXSTAGE MEDICAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67072V103</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1066</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1066</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OGE ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>670837103</cusip>
    <value>3535</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111782</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>111782</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>O REILLY AUTOMOTIVE INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67103H107</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>O REILLY AUTOMOTIVE INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67103H107</cusip>
    <value>664</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2371</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2371</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>O REILLY AUTOMOTIVE INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67103H107</cusip>
    <value>18569</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66293</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58972</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7321</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OFG BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67103X102</cusip>
    <value>946</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>93557</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58025</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>35532</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OAK VALLEY BANCORP OAKDALE C</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>671807105</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>463</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>463</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OCCIDENTAL PETE CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>674599105</cusip>
    <value>1038</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14240</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14240</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OCCIDENTAL PETE CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>674599105</cusip>
    <value>130604</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1791064</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1791064</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OCCIDENTAL PETE CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>674599105</cusip>
    <value>7326</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100461</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100219</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>242</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OCEANEERING INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>675232102</cusip>
    <value>8809</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>320201</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>320201</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OCEANFIRST FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>675234108</cusip>
    <value>102</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5319</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2122</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3197</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OCLARO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67555N206</cusip>
    <value>1423</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>166461</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>128150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>38311</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OCWEN FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>675746309</cusip>
    <value>2229</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>607331</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>477915</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>129416</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OCULAR THERAPEUTIX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>67576A100</cusip>
    <value>1798</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>261700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>261700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OFFICE DEPOT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>676220106</cusip>
    <value>1469</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>411503</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>411503</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OFFICE DEPOT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>676220106</cusip>
    <value>697</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>195278</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>115848</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>79430</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OIL STS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>678026105</cusip>
    <value>895</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28344</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28344</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OIL STS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>678026105</cusip>
    <value>628</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLD DOMINION FGHT LINES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>679580100</cusip>
    <value>2639</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38460</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38460</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLD NATL BANCORP IND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>680033107</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLD NATL BANCORP IND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>680033107</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>777</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>777</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLD REP INTL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>680223104</cusip>
    <value>35405</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2009367</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2009367</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLD REP INTL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>680223104</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>174</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>174</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLD SECOND BANCORP INC ILL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>680277100</cusip>
    <value>166</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19916</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17440</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2476</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLIN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $1</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>680665205</cusip>
    <value>3371</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>164284</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78077</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>86207</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLIN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $1</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>680665205</cusip>
    <value>1411</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68780</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68780</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLIN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $1</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>680665205</cusip>
    <value>22451</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1094115</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1079244</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14871</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLLIES BARGAIN OUTLT HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>681116109</cusip>
    <value>40</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1519</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1519</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OLYMPIC STEEL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68162K106</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>601</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>601</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OMNICOM GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>681919106</cusip>
    <value>543</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6392</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6392</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OMEGA HEALTHCARE INVS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>681936100</cusip>
    <value>112</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3164</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3113</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>51</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OMEGA HEALTHCARE INVS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>681936100</cusip>
    <value>96636</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2725977</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2725977</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OMEGA PROTEIN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68210P107</cusip>
    <value>393</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16806</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15199</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1607</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OMNOVA SOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>682129101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>121</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>121</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OMNICELL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68213N109</cusip>
    <value>28</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>741</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>741</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ON ASSIGNMENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>682159108</cusip>
    <value>316</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8720</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8720</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ON SEMICONDUCTOR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>682189105</cusip>
    <value>64</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5202</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5202</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ONE GAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68235P108</cusip>
    <value>62</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1007</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1007</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ONE GAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68235P108</cusip>
    <value>1705</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27578</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27578</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ONE GAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68235P108</cusip>
    <value>22</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>363</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>334</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>29</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ONEOK INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>682680103</cusip>
    <value>237</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4617</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4617</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORACLE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68389X105</cusip>
    <value>3474</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>88435</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>88435</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORACLE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68389X105</cusip>
    <value>7471</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>190189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>190189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORACLE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68389X105</cusip>
    <value>2892</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>73637</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73637</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORANGE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>684060106</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>520</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>520</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORASURE TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68554V108</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1012</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1012</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORBITAL ATK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68557N103</cusip>
    <value>2018</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26476</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26476</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORGANOVO HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68620A104</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>963</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>963</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OSHKOSH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>688239201</cusip>
    <value>1842</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32887</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32887</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OSHKOSH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>688239201</cusip>
    <value>1178</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21028</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21020</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OSIRIS THERAPEUTICS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68827R108</cusip>
    <value>127</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25694</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25694</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OTELCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>688823301</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>938</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>938</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OTONOMY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>68906L105</cusip>
    <value>55946</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3075629</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3075629</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS &amp; MINOR INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690732102</cusip>
    <value>1137</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32750</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32750</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS &amp; MINOR INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690732102</cusip>
    <value>765</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22028</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22028</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS &amp; MINOR INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690732102</cusip>
    <value>10457</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>301090</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>296730</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4360</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS CORNING NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690742101</cusip>
    <value>30100</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>563781</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>563781</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS CORNING NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690742101</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>139</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>54</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>85</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS ILL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690768403</cusip>
    <value>1982</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>107755</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>107755</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS ILL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690768403</cusip>
    <value>4438</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>241318</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>241318</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS ILL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690768403</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1456</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1456</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS ILL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690768403</cusip>
    <value>24057</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1308153</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1299708</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8445</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OWENS ILL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>690768403</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>208</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>208</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>OXFORD INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>691497309</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>P &amp; F INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>692830508</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>315</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>315</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PBF ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69318G106</cusip>
    <value>3254</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>143712</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51895</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>91817</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PBF ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69318G106</cusip>
    <value>272</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PBF ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69318G106</cusip>
    <value>21052</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>929858</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>917393</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12465</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PC CONNECTION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69318J100</cusip>
    <value>1291</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48854</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28682</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>20172</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PDC ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69327R101</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>111</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PDL BIOPHARMA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69329Y104</cusip>
    <value>3087</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>921458</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>654514</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>266944</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PG&amp;E CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69331C108</cusip>
    <value>714</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11671</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11671</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHI INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NON VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69336T205</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>548</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>548</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PNC FINL SVCS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693475105</cusip>
    <value>69</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>761</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>761</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PNC FINL SVCS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693475105</cusip>
    <value>26673</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>296068</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>296068</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PNC FINL SVCS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693475105</cusip>
    <value>419</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4647</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4647</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PNC FINL SVCS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693475105</cusip>
    <value>33081</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>367200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>346621</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>20579</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PNM RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69349H107</cusip>
    <value>1005</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30729</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30729</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PPG INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693506107</cusip>
    <value>19</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>184</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>184</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PPG INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693506107</cusip>
    <value>1667</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16132</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16132</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PPG INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693506107</cusip>
    <value>159</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1539</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1539</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PPG INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693506107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PPL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69351T106</cusip>
    <value>128394</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3714022</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2755538</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>958484</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PPL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69351T106</cusip>
    <value>385265</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11144487</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11144487</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PPL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69351T106</cusip>
    <value>551</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15935</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15935</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRA HEALTH SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69354M108</cusip>
    <value>65</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1143</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1143</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRA HEALTH SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69354M108</cusip>
    <value>456</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8077</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8077</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRA GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69354N106</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>583</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>583</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRGX GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69357C503</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>921</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>921</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PVH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693656100</cusip>
    <value>455</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4119</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4119</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PVH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693656100</cusip>
    <value>14050</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>127150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>113616</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13534</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PTC THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69366J200</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PTC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69370C100</cusip>
    <value>2785</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62843</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62843</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PACCAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693718108</cusip>
    <value>747</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PACCAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>693718108</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>82</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PACIFIC CONTINENTAL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69412V108</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>437</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>437</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PACKAGING CORP AMER</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>695156109</cusip>
    <value>4236</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52135</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52135</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PACWEST BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>695263103</cusip>
    <value>2874</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66989</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>66989</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAIN THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69562K100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1038</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1038</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PALO ALTO NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>697435105</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PANERA BREAD CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>69840W108</cusip>
    <value>2385</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12247</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12247</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAREXEL INTL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>699462107</cusip>
    <value>73</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1044</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1044</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAREXEL INTL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>699462107</cusip>
    <value>1988</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28623</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28623</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARK OHIO HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>700666100</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARK OHIO HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>700666100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARKE BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>700885106</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>245</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>245</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARKER HANNIFIN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>701094104</cusip>
    <value>20380</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>162348</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>162348</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARKWAY PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70159Q104</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>564</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>564</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARSLEY ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>701877102</cusip>
    <value>227</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6769</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARSLEY ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>701877102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARTY CITY HOLDCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>702149105</cusip>
    <value>697</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40686</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40686</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PARTY CITY HOLDCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>702149105</cusip>
    <value>3174</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>185413</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>185413</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PATTERSON COMPANIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>703395103</cusip>
    <value>74</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1603</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1603</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PATTERSON UTI ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>703481101</cusip>
    <value>1740</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>77797</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>77797</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAYCHEX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>704326107</cusip>
    <value>504</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8713</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8713</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAYCOM SOFTWARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70432V102</cusip>
    <value>1056</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21063</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21063</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAYLOCITY HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70438V106</cusip>
    <value>154</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3467</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3467</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAYPAL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70450Y103</cusip>
    <value>2713</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66211</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1706</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>64505</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAYPAL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70450Y103</cusip>
    <value>1911</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46637</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46637</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PAYPAL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70450Y103</cusip>
    <value>29575</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>721877</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>717795</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4082</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEAPACK-GLADSTONE FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>704699107</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>428</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>428</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEBBLEBROOK HOTEL TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70509V100</cusip>
    <value>34</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1263</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1263</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEGASYSTEMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>705573103</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>89</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>89</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PENN NATL GAMING INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>707569109</cusip>
    <value>1000</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>73680</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73680</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PENN NATL GAMING INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>707569109</cusip>
    <value>4768</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>351398</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>351398</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PENNEY J C INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>708160106</cusip>
    <value>1553</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>168440</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>168440</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PENNYMAC MTG INVT TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70931T103</cusip>
    <value>36</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2310</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2310</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PENSKE AUTOMOTIVE GRP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70959W103</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PENSKE AUTOMOTIVE GRP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70959W103</cusip>
    <value>474</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9844</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9844</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PENUMBRA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>70975L107</cusip>
    <value>25840</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>340050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>340050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEOPLES BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>709789101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEOPLES BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>709789101</cusip>
    <value>357</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14514</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6136</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8378</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEOPLES BANCORP N C INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>710577107</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>318</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>318</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEPSICO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>713448108</cusip>
    <value>88246</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>811310</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>449595</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>361715</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEPSICO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>713448108</cusip>
    <value>129260</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1188381</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1188381</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEPSICO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>713448108</cusip>
    <value>215</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1980</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1980</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PEPSICO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>713448108</cusip>
    <value>6261</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>57558</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51370</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6188</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PERFICIENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>71375U101</cusip>
    <value>244</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12127</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12127</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PERFORMANCE FOOD GROUP CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>71377A103</cusip>
    <value>40</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1623</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1623</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PERFORMANCE SPORTS GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>71377G100</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1858</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1858</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PERKINELMER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>714046109</cusip>
    <value>65</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1160</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1160</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PETMED EXPRESS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>716382106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>67</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PETROLEO BRASILEIRO SA PETRO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SP ADR NON VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>71654V101</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PETROQUEST ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>716748306</cusip>
    <value>36</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10374</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10374</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PFIZER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>717081103</cusip>
    <value>5491</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>162106</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>81103</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>81003</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PFIZER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>717081103</cusip>
    <value>11877</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>350667</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>350667</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PFIZER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>717081103</cusip>
    <value>37676</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1112358</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1107314</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5044</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PFIZER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>717081103</cusip>
    <value>33721</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>995599</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>946779</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>48820</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHARMERICA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>71714F104</cusip>
    <value>61</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2172</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2172</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHARMERICA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>71714F104</cusip>
    <value>66</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2355</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2355</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHILIP MORRIS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>718172109</cusip>
    <value>333507</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3430441</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1884062</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1546379</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHILIP MORRIS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>718172109</cusip>
    <value>719870</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7404551</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7404551</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHILIP MORRIS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>718172109</cusip>
    <value>816</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8396</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8396</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHILLIPS 66</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>718546104</cusip>
    <value>908</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11275</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11275</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHILLIPS 66</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>718546104</cusip>
    <value>42</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>521</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>521</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHOTRONICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>719405102</cusip>
    <value>116</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11242</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11242</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PHYSICIANS RLTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>71943U104</cusip>
    <value>1723</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PIEDMONT NAT GAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>720186105</cusip>
    <value>473</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7878</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7878</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PIEDMONT OFFICE REALTY TR IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>720190206</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PIER 1 IMPORTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>720279108</cusip>
    <value>882</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>208116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>207077</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1039</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PILGRIMS PRIDE CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>72147K108</cusip>
    <value>41</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1959</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1959</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PILGRIMS PRIDE CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>72147K108</cusip>
    <value>2196</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>103976</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>103575</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>401</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PINNACLE WEST CAP CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>723484101</cusip>
    <value>240</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3161</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3161</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PINNACLE FOODS INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>72348P104</cusip>
    <value>334</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6667</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6667</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PINNACLE ENTMT INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>72348Y105</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1319</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1319</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PIONEER ENERGY SVCS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>723664108</cusip>
    <value>399</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>98646</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>98542</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>104</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PIONEER NAT RES CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>723787107</cusip>
    <value>1845</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9938</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9938</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PIONEER NAT RES CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>723787107</cusip>
    <value>44183</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>237989</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>231500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6489</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PIONEER NAT RES CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>723787107</cusip>
    <value>2037</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10973</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10972</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PIPER JAFFRAY COS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>724078100</cusip>
    <value>438</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9073</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6832</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2241</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PITNEY BOWES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>724479100</cusip>
    <value>70</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3833</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3833</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PITNEY BOWES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>724479100</cusip>
    <value>10299</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>567124</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>518889</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>48235</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PLANET FITNESS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>72703H101</cusip>
    <value>5921</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>295000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>295000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PLANTRONICS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>727493108</cusip>
    <value>1025</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19733</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19733</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PLANTRONICS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>727493108</cusip>
    <value>618</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11891</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11891</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PLATFORM SPECIALTY PRODS COR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>72766Q105</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PLY GEM HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>72941W100</cusip>
    <value>922</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>69032</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>69032</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POLARIS INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>731068102</cusip>
    <value>2506</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32358</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32358</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POLYONE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>73179P106</cusip>
    <value>1561</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46164</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46164</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POOL CORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>73278L105</cusip>
    <value>2091</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22121</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22121</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POPULAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>733174700</cusip>
    <value>2196</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>57450</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POPULAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>733174700</cusip>
    <value>20482</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>535890</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>528250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7640</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POPULAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>733174700</cusip>
    <value>3229</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>84482</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80134</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4348</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PORTLAND GEN ELEC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>736508847</cusip>
    <value>1958</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45975</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45975</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PORTLAND GEN ELEC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>736508847</cusip>
    <value>17885</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>419942</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>413807</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6135</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PORTLAND GEN ELEC CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>736508847</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>477</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>0</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>477</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POST HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>737446104</cusip>
    <value>3120</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40433</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40433</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POST HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>737446104</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>139</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>139</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POST PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>737464107</cusip>
    <value>2348</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35513</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35513</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POTLATCH CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>737630103</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1549</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1549</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POTLATCH CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>737630103</cusip>
    <value>1295</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33299</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33299</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POWERSHARES DB CMDTY IDX TRA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>73935S105</cusip>
    <value>4205</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>280117</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>280117</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>POWERSHARES ETF TRUST II</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SENIOR LN PORT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>73936Q769</cusip>
    <value>27272</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1175000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1175000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRAXAIR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74005P104</cusip>
    <value>1087</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8995</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8995</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PREFERRED BK LOS ANGELES CA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>740367404</cusip>
    <value>662</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18521</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16560</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1961</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PREMIER FINL BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74050M105</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>292</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>292</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PREMIER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74051N102</cusip>
    <value>513</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15872</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15872</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRESTIGE BRANDS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74112D101</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>136</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>136</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRESTIGE BRANDS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74112D101</cusip>
    <value>1819</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37676</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37676</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRESS GANEY HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74113L102</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1381</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1381</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRICE T ROWE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74144T108</cusip>
    <value>1514</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22763</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22763</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRICELINE GRP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>741503403</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRICELINE GRP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>741503403</cusip>
    <value>3281</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2230</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2230</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRIMERICA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74164M108</cusip>
    <value>61</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1159</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1159</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRIMERICA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74164M108</cusip>
    <value>962</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18133</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18133</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRIMERICA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74164M108</cusip>
    <value>1888</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35605</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27624</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7981</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRIMO WTR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74165N105</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1669</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1669</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRINCIPAL FINL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74251V102</cusip>
    <value>373</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7241</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7241</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROCTER AND GAMBLE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>742718109</cusip>
    <value>299524</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3337318</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1850888</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1486430</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROCTER AND GAMBLE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>742718109</cusip>
    <value>567128</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6318979</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6318979</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROCTER AND GAMBLE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>742718109</cusip>
    <value>42482</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>473336</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>471876</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1460</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRIVATEBANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>742962103</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1251</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1251</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRIVATEBANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>742962103</cusip>
    <value>1973</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42956</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42956</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROGENICS PHARMACEUTICALS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743187106</cusip>
    <value>79566</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12569690</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12569690</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROGRESS SOFTWARE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743312100</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1780</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1780</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROGRESSIVE CORP OHIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743315103</cusip>
    <value>686</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21772</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21772</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROGRESSIVE CORP OHIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743315103</cusip>
    <value>517</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16406</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16406</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROLOGIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74340W103</cusip>
    <value>2050</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38295</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38295</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROLOGIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74340W103</cusip>
    <value>308</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5749</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5749</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROOFPOINT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743424103</cusip>
    <value>2581</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34482</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34299</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>183</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROSPERITY BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743606105</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROSPERITY BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743606105</cusip>
    <value>2019</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36779</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36779</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROSPERITY BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743606105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROTALIX BIOTHERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>NOTE  4.500% 9/1</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74365AAB7</cusip>
    <value>3637</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5330000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>PRN</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5330000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PROVIDENT FINL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>743868101</cusip>
    <value>642</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32830</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15529</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17301</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRUDENTIAL FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>744320102</cusip>
    <value>31</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>382</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>382</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRUDENTIAL FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>744320102</cusip>
    <value>3565</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43660</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43660</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRUDENTIAL FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>744320102</cusip>
    <value>36488</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>446887</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>423815</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>23072</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PRUDENTIAL PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74435K204</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>88</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>88</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PSYCHEMEDICS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>744375205</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>143</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>143</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PUBLIC SVC ENTERPRISE GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>744573106</cusip>
    <value>41</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>989</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>989</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PUBLIC SVC ENTERPRISE GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>744573106</cusip>
    <value>295</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7043</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7043</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PUBLIC SVC ENTERPRISE GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>744573106</cusip>
    <value>424</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10118</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10118</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PUBLIC SVC ENTERPRISE GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>744573106</cusip>
    <value>93</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2215</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1747</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>468</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PUBLIC STORAGE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74460D109</cusip>
    <value>1061</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4756</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4756</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PUBLIC STORAGE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74460D109</cusip>
    <value>593</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2656</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2656</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PULTE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>745867101</cusip>
    <value>1202</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PUMA BIOTECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74587V107</cusip>
    <value>936</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13965</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13965</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QCR HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74727A104</cusip>
    <value>507</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15966</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11898</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4068</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUAD / GRAPHICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>747301109</cusip>
    <value>3071</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>114939</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>92071</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22868</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QEP RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74733V100</cusip>
    <value>2564</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>131262</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>131262</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QEP RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74733V100</cusip>
    <value>326</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16703</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16703</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QEP RES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74733V100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QORVO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74736K101</cusip>
    <value>160</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2876</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2876</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QORVO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74736K101</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>106</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>106</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>Q2 HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74736L109</cusip>
    <value>783</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27325</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27325</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>Q2 HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74736L109</cusip>
    <value>29763</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1038494</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1034834</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3660</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUALCOMM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>747525103</cusip>
    <value>12576</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>183595</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>183595</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUALCOMM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>747525103</cusip>
    <value>76</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1111</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1111</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUALCOMM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>747525103</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUALITY SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>747582104</cusip>
    <value>46</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4028</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4028</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUALYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74758T303</cusip>
    <value>95</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2475</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2475</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUANTA SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74762E102</cusip>
    <value>362</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12936</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12936</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUANTA SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74762E102</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>274</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>261</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUANTUM CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM DSSG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>747906204</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5559</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5559</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUEST DIAGNOSTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74834L100</cusip>
    <value>4993</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58995</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58995</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUEST DIAGNOSTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74834L100</cusip>
    <value>30</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>349</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>341</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>QUINTILES TRANSNATIO HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74876Y101</cusip>
    <value>503</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6211</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6211</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RCI HOSPITALITY HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74934Q108</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>243</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>243</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RLJ LODGING TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74965L101</cusip>
    <value>27</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1306</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1306</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RPC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>749660106</cusip>
    <value>254</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15124</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15124</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RPM INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>749685103</cusip>
    <value>5586</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>103977</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>103977</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RTI SURGICAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>74975N105</cusip>
    <value>116</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37026</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37026</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RACKSPACE HOSTING INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>750086100</cusip>
    <value>1852</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58450</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RADIAN GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>750236101</cusip>
    <value>2198</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>162225</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>162225</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RADIAN GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>750236101</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4193</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4193</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RADIAN GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>750236101</cusip>
    <value>20267</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1495694</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1473409</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22285</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RADIO ONE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL D NON VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75040P405</cusip>
    <value>744</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>245705</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>245705</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RADIO ONE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL D NON VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75040P405</cusip>
    <value>3746</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1236202</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1236202</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RADIO ONE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL D NON VTG</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75040P405</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>457</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>457</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RADISYS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>750459109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>101</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>101</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RALPH LAUREN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>751212101</cusip>
    <value>107</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1055</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1055</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RANGE RES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75281A109</cusip>
    <value>135</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3484</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3484</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RANGE RES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75281A109</cusip>
    <value>260</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6709</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6661</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>48</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RAPID7 INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>753422104</cusip>
    <value>5613</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>318000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>318000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RAYMOND JAMES FINANCIAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>754730109</cusip>
    <value>3991</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68563</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68563</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RAYONIER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>754907103</cusip>
    <value>2826</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>106462</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>106462</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RAYONIER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>754907103</cusip>
    <value>450</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16972</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16972</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RAYONIER ADVANCED MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75508B104</cusip>
    <value>476</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35566</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10111</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>25455</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RAYTHEON CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>755111507</cusip>
    <value>1039</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7632</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7632</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RAYTHEON CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>755111507</cusip>
    <value>614</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4509</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4509</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RAYTHEON CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>755111507</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>171</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>171</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RE MAX HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75524W108</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1318</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1318</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REALPAGE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75606N109</cusip>
    <value>3691</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>143600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>143600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REALPAGE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75606N109</cusip>
    <value>597</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23216</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23216</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REALTY INCOME CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>756109104</cusip>
    <value>82383</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1230889</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>661072</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>569817</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REALTY INCOME CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>756109104</cusip>
    <value>5299</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>79169</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>79169</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RED HAT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>756577102</cusip>
    <value>2230</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27593</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27593</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REGAL BELOIT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>758750103</cusip>
    <value>1876</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31542</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31542</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REGAL ENTMT GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>758766109</cusip>
    <value>11321</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>520509</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>520509</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REGENCY CTRS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>758849103</cusip>
    <value>4493</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>57980</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57980</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REGENERON PHARMACEUTICALS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75886F107</cusip>
    <value>979</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2436</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2436</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REGENERON PHARMACEUTICALS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75886F107</cusip>
    <value>301</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>748</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>748</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REGIONS FINL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>7591EP100</cusip>
    <value>327</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33134</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33134</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REGIONS FINL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>7591EP100</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1136</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1136</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REINSURANCE GROUP AMER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>759351604</cusip>
    <value>5270</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48827</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48827</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REINSURANCE GROUP AMER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>759351604</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RELIANCE STEEL &amp; ALUMINUM CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>759509102</cusip>
    <value>5818</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80769</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RELIANCE STEEL &amp; ALUMINUM CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>759509102</cusip>
    <value>840</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11659</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11640</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>19</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RENEWABLE ENERGY GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>75972A301</cusip>
    <value>78</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9257</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5113</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4144</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REPLIGEN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>759916109</cusip>
    <value>55</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1823</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1823</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REPLIGEN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>759916109</cusip>
    <value>25459</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>843300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>843300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REPLIGEN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>759916109</cusip>
    <value>51</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1692</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>319</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1373</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RENT A CTR INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76009N100</cusip>
    <value>1429</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>113063</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75874</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>37189</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RENTECH INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>760112201</cusip>
    <value>263</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>90047</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>90047</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REPUBLIC BANCORP KY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>760281204</cusip>
    <value>334</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10761</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8898</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1863</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REPUBLIC SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>760759100</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>462</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>462</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REPUBLIC SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>760759100</cusip>
    <value>337</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6679</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6679</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RESMED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>761152107</cusip>
    <value>5064</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78163</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78163</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RESTORATION HARDWARE HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>761283100</cusip>
    <value>318</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9185</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9185</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RESTORATION HARDWARE HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>761283100</cusip>
    <value>425</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12291</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12291</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RETAIL OPPORTUNITY INVTS COR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76131N101</cusip>
    <value>132</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RETAIL PPTYS AMER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76131V202</cusip>
    <value>6274</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>373469</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>373469</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RETAILMENOT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER 1</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76132B106</cusip>
    <value>383</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38771</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38228</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>543</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REVANCE THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>761330109</cusip>
    <value>324</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REX AMERICAN RESOURCES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>761624105</cusip>
    <value>721</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8512</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4969</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3543</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REXNORD CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76169B102</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2792</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2792</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REXNORD CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76169B102</cusip>
    <value>15903</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>742800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>742800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REXNORD CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76169B102</cusip>
    <value>474</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22147</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22147</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REYNOLDS AMERICAN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>761713106</cusip>
    <value>157496</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3340321</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2486103</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>854218</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REYNOLDS AMERICAN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>761713106</cusip>
    <value>411026</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8717415</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8717415</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>REYNOLDS AMERICAN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>761713106</cusip>
    <value>4930</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>104550</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>104550</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RICE ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>762760106</cusip>
    <value>36554</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1400000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1400000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RICE ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>762760106</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>249</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>249</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RIGNET INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>766582100</cusip>
    <value>272</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17969</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17919</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>50</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RINGCENTRAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76680R206</cusip>
    <value>4259</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>180000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>180000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RIO TINTO PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>767204100</cusip>
    <value>1570</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROADRUNNER TRNSN SVCS HLDG I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>76973Q105</cusip>
    <value>177</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22208</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22147</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>61</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROBERT HALF INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>770323103</cusip>
    <value>3509</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>92688</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>92688</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROBERT HALF INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>770323103</cusip>
    <value>2632</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>69525</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68945</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>580</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROCKET FUEL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>773111109</cusip>
    <value>238</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>90171</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49826</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>40345</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROCKWELL AUTOMATION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>773903109</cusip>
    <value>440</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3598</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3598</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROCKWELL COLLINS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>774341101</cusip>
    <value>36</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>426</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>426</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROFIN SINAR TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>775043102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROGERS COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>775109200</cusip>
    <value>5192</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>122395</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25806</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>96589</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROLLINS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>775711104</cusip>
    <value>1620</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55315</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55315</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROPER TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>776696106</cusip>
    <value>504</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2764</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2764</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROSS STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>778296103</cusip>
    <value>2155</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33512</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33512</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROYAL DUTCH SHELL PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONS ADR A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>780259206</cusip>
    <value>15262</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>304804</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>304804</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROYAL DUTCH SHELL PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONS ADR A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>780259206</cusip>
    <value>4235</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>84577</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>84577</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROYAL GOLD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>780287108</cusip>
    <value>2346</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30304</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30304</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROYAL GOLD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>780287108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RUBICON PROJ INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78112V102</cusip>
    <value>337</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40725</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40725</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RUBICON PROJ INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78112V102</cusip>
    <value>414</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RUBICON PROJ INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78112V102</cusip>
    <value>3044</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>367625</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>362800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4825</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RUDOLPH TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>781270103</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>456</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>456</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RUSH ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>781846209</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RYDER SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>783549108</cusip>
    <value>41</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>628</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>628</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RYERSON HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>783754104</cusip>
    <value>269</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23861</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20257</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3604</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RYMAN HOSPITALITY PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78377T107</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RYMAN HOSPITALITY PPTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78377T107</cusip>
    <value>42342</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>879200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>879200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SBA COMMUNICATIONS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78388J106</cusip>
    <value>501</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4467</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4467</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>S&amp;P GLOBAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78409V104</cusip>
    <value>827</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6533</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6533</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEI INVESTMENTS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>784117103</cusip>
    <value>3460</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75865</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75865</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SK TELECOM LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78440P108</cusip>
    <value>2174</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>96200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>96200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SL GREEN RLTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78440X101</cusip>
    <value>493</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4556</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4556</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SLM CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78442P106</cusip>
    <value>1701</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>227646</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>227646</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SM ENERGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78454L100</cusip>
    <value>1815</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47045</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47045</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SM ENERGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78454L100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>784635104</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>889</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>889</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>784635104</cusip>
    <value>7093</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>352169</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>304780</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>47389</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPDR SERIES TRUST</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>BRC HGH YLD BD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78464A417</cusip>
    <value>1139</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31020</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31020</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPDR SERIES TRUST</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>BRC HGH YLD BD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78464A417</cusip>
    <value>222</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6040</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6040</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPDR SERIES TRUST</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>BRC HGH YLD BD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78464A417</cusip>
    <value>308</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8395</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8395</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPX FLOW INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78469X107</cusip>
    <value>817</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26425</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26425</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPX FLOW INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78469X107</cusip>
    <value>5363</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>173445</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>169955</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3490</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SVB FINL GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78486Q101</cusip>
    <value>3096</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28011</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28011</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SVB FINL GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78486Q101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SABRA HEALTH CARE REIT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78573L106</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>401</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>401</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SABRE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78573M104</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>185</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>185</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SABRE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78573M104</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>133</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>133</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SAFEGUARD SCIENTIFICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>786449207</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>357</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>357</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SAGE THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>78667J108</cusip>
    <value>56374</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1224200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1224200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ST JOE CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>790148100</cusip>
    <value>54</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2951</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2951</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ST JUDE MED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>790849103</cusip>
    <value>533</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6678</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6678</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SALESFORCE COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>79466L302</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>82</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SALESFORCE COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>79466L302</cusip>
    <value>1357</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19026</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19026</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SALESFORCE COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>79466L302</cusip>
    <value>97293</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1363990</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1340890</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>23100</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SALESFORCE COM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>79466L302</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SALLY BEAUTY HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>79546E104</cusip>
    <value>2049</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>79794</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>79794</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SALLY BEAUTY HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>79546E104</cusip>
    <value>532</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20716</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20691</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>25</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SANCHEZ ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>79970Y105</cusip>
    <value>35</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3951</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3951</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SANDERSON FARMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>800013104</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SANDERSON FARMS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>800013104</cusip>
    <value>2767</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28721</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28297</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>424</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SANDY SPRING BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>800363103</cusip>
    <value>124</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4065</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2682</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1383</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SANFILIPPO JOHN B &amp; SON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>800422107</cusip>
    <value>72</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1407</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1366</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>41</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SANMINA CORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>801056102</cusip>
    <value>1967</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>69085</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46985</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22100</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SANOFI</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>80105N105</cusip>
    <value>217695</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5700324</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4025808</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1674516</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SANOFI</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>80105N105</cusip>
    <value>8860</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>232000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>232000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SAP SE</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>803054204</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SAREPTA THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>803607100</cusip>
    <value>239</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3887</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3887</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCANA CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>80589M102</cusip>
    <value>209</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2888</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2888</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCANSOURCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>806037107</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCHEIN HENRY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>806407102</cusip>
    <value>364</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2235</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2235</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCHLUMBERGER LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>806857108</cusip>
    <value>29</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>364</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>364</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCHLUMBERGER LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>806857108</cusip>
    <value>13020</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>165566</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>165566</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCHLUMBERGER LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>806857108</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>264</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>264</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCHNITZER STL INDS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>806882106</cusip>
    <value>29</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1373</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1373</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCHWAB CHARLES CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>808513105</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>191</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>191</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCHWAB CHARLES CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>808513105</cusip>
    <value>944</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29914</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29914</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCHWEITZER-MAUDUIT INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>808541106</cusip>
    <value>130</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3382</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3380</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCIENCE APPLICATNS INTL CP N</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>808625107</cusip>
    <value>72</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1038</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1038</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCIENCE APPLICATNS INTL CP N</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>808625107</cusip>
    <value>1728</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24903</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24903</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCIENTIFIC GAMES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>80874P109</cusip>
    <value>494</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43864</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43864</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCOTTS MIRACLE GRO CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>810186106</cusip>
    <value>729</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8750</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8750</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCOTTS MIRACLE GRO CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>810186106</cusip>
    <value>1638</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19668</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19668</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCOTTS MIRACLE GRO CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>810186106</cusip>
    <value>7005</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>84125</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82965</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1160</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCRIPPS NETWORKS INTERACT IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>811065101</cusip>
    <value>3247</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51149</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51149</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCRIPPS NETWORKS INTERACT IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>811065101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SCYNEXIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>811292101</cusip>
    <value>13190</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3408360</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3408360</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEABOARD CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>811543107</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEACOAST BKG CORP FLA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>811707801</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>137</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>137</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEALED AIR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81211K100</cusip>
    <value>748</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16315</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16315</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEALED AIR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81211K100</cusip>
    <value>3452</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75333</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75333</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEALED AIR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81211K100</cusip>
    <value>2959</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64585</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64585</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEALED AIR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81211K100</cusip>
    <value>309</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6749</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6749</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEALED AIR CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81211K100</cusip>
    <value>6398</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>139643</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>120439</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>19204</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEARS HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>812350106</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>379</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>379</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEAWORLD ENTMT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81282V100</cusip>
    <value>149</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SBI INT-FINL</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81369Y605</cusip>
    <value>3860</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>200000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SBI INT-INDS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81369Y704</cusip>
    <value>3503</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SECURITY NATL FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>814785309</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>568</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>568</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SELECTIVE INS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>816300107</cusip>
    <value>1620</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40650</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27398</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13252</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEMGROUP CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81663A105</cusip>
    <value>1351</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEMGROUP CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81663A105</cusip>
    <value>12195</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>344870</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>339820</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5050</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEMGROUP CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81663A105</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>174</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>174</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEMTECH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>816850101</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>144</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>144</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEMPRA ENERGY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>816851109</cusip>
    <value>9307</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86826</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86826</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEMPRA ENERGY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>816851109</cusip>
    <value>369</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3439</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3439</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SENIOR HSG PPTYS TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81721M109</cusip>
    <value>3034</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>133583</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>133583</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SENSIENT TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81725T100</cusip>
    <value>1815</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23948</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23948</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SERES THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81750R102</cusip>
    <value>25116</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2043578</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2043578</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SERITAGE GROWTH PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81752R100</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>151</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>151</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SERVICE CORP INTL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>817565104</cusip>
    <value>2892</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>108966</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>108966</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SERVICEMASTER GLOBAL HLDGS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81761R109</cusip>
    <value>4838</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>143636</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>124947</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18689</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SERVICENOW INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81762P102</cusip>
    <value>113493</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1433900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1433900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SERVICESOURCE INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>81763U100</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>852</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>852</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHAW COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B CONV</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82028K200</cusip>
    <value>6294</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>307608</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65164</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>242444</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHENANDOAH TELECOMMUNICATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82312B106</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>302</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>302</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHERWIN WILLIAMS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>824348106</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHERWIN WILLIAMS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>824348106</cusip>
    <value>3478</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12572</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12572</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHERWIN WILLIAMS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>824348106</cusip>
    <value>178000</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>643390</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>637040</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6350</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHILOH INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>824543102</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>785</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>785</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHINHAN FINANCIAL GROUP CO L</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPN ADR RESTRD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>824596100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHINHAN FINANCIAL GROUP CO L</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPN ADR RESTRD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>824596100</cusip>
    <value>1221</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHIRE PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82481R106</cusip>
    <value>28704</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>148064</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>138237</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9827</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHOPIFY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82509L107</cusip>
    <value>18378</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>428200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>428200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHORE BANCSHARES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>825107105</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>767</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>767</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHORETEL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>825211105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHUTTERFLY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82568P304</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHUTTERFLY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82568P304</cusip>
    <value>2495</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHUTTERFLY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82568P304</cusip>
    <value>334</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7484</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7484</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHUTTERSTOCK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>825690100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIERRA BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82620P102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIERRA BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82620P102</cusip>
    <value>101</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5370</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2904</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2466</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIGMA DESIGNS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>826565103</cusip>
    <value>10127</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1300000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1300000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIGMA DESIGNS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>826565103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>138</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>138</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIGNATURE BK NEW YORK N Y</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82669G104</cusip>
    <value>3401</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28714</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28714</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SILICON LABORATORIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>826919102</cusip>
    <value>1363</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23172</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23172</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SILGAN HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>827048109</cusip>
    <value>1098</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21706</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21706</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SILICON MOTION TECHNOLOGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82706C108</cusip>
    <value>5966</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>115200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>115200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIMON PPTY GROUP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>828806109</cusip>
    <value>7341</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35461</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35461</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIMON PPTY GROUP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>828806109</cusip>
    <value>269</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SINCLAIR BROADCAST GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>829226109</cusip>
    <value>1176</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40725</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40725</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SINCLAIR BROADCAST GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>829226109</cusip>
    <value>10712</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>370904</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>365569</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5335</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SINCLAIR BROADCAST GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>829226109</cusip>
    <value>3223</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111612</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>111339</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>273</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SITEONE LANDSCAPE SUPPLY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>82982L103</cusip>
    <value>1904</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>53000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIX FLAGS ENTMT CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>83001A102</cusip>
    <value>25979</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>484600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>484600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SKECHERS U S A INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>830566105</cusip>
    <value>492</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SKECHERS U S A INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>830566105</cusip>
    <value>1672</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>73023</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73023</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SKECHERS U S A INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>830566105</cusip>
    <value>4504</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>196670</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>193805</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2865</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SKECHERS U S A INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>830566105</cusip>
    <value>2516</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>109886</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>101321</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8565</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SKYLINE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>830830105</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>541</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>541</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SKYWEST INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>830879102</cusip>
    <value>54</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2043</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2043</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SKYWEST INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>830879102</cusip>
    <value>486</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18389</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14607</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3782</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SKYWORKS SOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>83088M102</cusip>
    <value>126</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1658</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1658</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SMITH &amp; WESSON HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>831756101</cusip>
    <value>48</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1797</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1797</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SMITH &amp; WESSON HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>831756101</cusip>
    <value>3027</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>113842</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>113315</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>527</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SMITH A O</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>831865209</cusip>
    <value>4052</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41015</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41015</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SMITH A O</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>831865209</cusip>
    <value>73</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>738</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>738</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SMUCKER J M CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>832696405</cusip>
    <value>461</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SMUCKER J M CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>832696405</cusip>
    <value>48547</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>358176</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>358176</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SMUCKER J M CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>832696405</cusip>
    <value>30700</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>226500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>226500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SMUCKER J M CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>832696405</cusip>
    <value>32192</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>237506</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>231722</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5784</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SNAP ON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>833034101</cusip>
    <value>265</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1746</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1746</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SNYDERS-LANCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>833551104</cusip>
    <value>1560</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46450</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SNYDERS-LANCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>833551104</cusip>
    <value>1651</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49170</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SNYDERS-LANCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>833551104</cusip>
    <value>14197</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>422784</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>416789</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5995</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SONIC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>835451105</cusip>
    <value>41</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1557</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1557</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SONIC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>835451105</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SONOCO PRODS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>835495102</cusip>
    <value>2977</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>56354</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>56354</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOTHEBYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>835898107</cusip>
    <value>1005</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26428</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26428</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SONUS NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>835916503</cusip>
    <value>130</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16741</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16741</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHERN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>842587107</cusip>
    <value>189564</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3695211</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2751575</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>943636</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHERN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>842587107</cusip>
    <value>604479</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11783218</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11783218</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHERN NATL BANCORP OF VA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>843395104</cusip>
    <value>26</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2027</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2027</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHWEST AIRLS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>844741108</cusip>
    <value>2560</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65822</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65822</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHWEST AIRLS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>844741108</cusip>
    <value>582</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14968</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14968</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHWEST AIRLS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>844741108</cusip>
    <value>16972</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>436415</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>384846</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>51569</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHWEST GAS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>844895102</cusip>
    <value>1789</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25607</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25607</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHWEST GA FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84502A104</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>220</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>220</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHWESTERN ENERGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>845467109</cusip>
    <value>140</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10083</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10083</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SOUTHWESTERN ENERGY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>845467109</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>459</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>459</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPAN AMER MED SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>846396109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>83</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPARK THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84652J103</cusip>
    <value>721</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPARK THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84652J103</cusip>
    <value>97411</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1621900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1621900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPARTAN MTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>846819100</cusip>
    <value>598</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62374</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61178</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1196</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPARTANNASH CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>847215100</cusip>
    <value>1358</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46974</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25109</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21865</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPECTRA ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>847560109</cusip>
    <value>509</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11905</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11905</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPECTRA ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>847560109</cusip>
    <value>461</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10783</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10783</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPECTRUM PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84763A108</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1944</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1944</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPECTRUM BRANDS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84763R101</cusip>
    <value>824</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5985</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5985</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPECTRUM BRANDS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84763R101</cusip>
    <value>3686</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26772</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26772</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPECTRUM BRANDS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84763R101</cusip>
    <value>4793</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34811</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34811</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPIRIT AEROSYSTEMS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>848574109</cusip>
    <value>26747</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>600523</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>538499</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>62024</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPIRE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84857L101</cusip>
    <value>1898</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29775</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29775</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPIRE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84857L101</cusip>
    <value>17322</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>271768</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>267873</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3895</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPIRE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84857L101</cusip>
    <value>203</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3180</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1151</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2029</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPIRIT RLTY CAP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84860W102</cusip>
    <value>86</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6455</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6455</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPIRIT RLTY CAP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84860W102</cusip>
    <value>165</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPLUNK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>848637104</cusip>
    <value>27228</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>464000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>464000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPLUNK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>848637104</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>149</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>149</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPORTSMANS WHSE HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>84920Y106</cusip>
    <value>3156</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>300000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>300000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPROTT PHYSICAL GOLD TRUST</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85207H104</cusip>
    <value>3285</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>300000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>300000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPROTT PHYSICAL GOLD TRUST</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85207H104</cusip>
    <value>905</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>82615</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>82615</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPROTT PHYSICAL SILVER TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>TR UNIT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85207K107</cusip>
    <value>739</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPROUTS FMRS MKT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85208M102</cusip>
    <value>1562</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75628</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75628</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SPROUTS FMRS MKT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85208M102</cusip>
    <value>102</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4959</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4959</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STAAR SURGICAL CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>852312305</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>167</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>167</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STAGE STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85254C305</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1017</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1017</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STAG INDL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85254J102</cusip>
    <value>162</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STANDARD MTR PRODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>853666105</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>66</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STANLEY BLACK &amp; DECKER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>854502101</cusip>
    <value>3458</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28115</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28115</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STANLEY BLACK &amp; DECKER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>854502101</cusip>
    <value>375</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3052</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3052</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STANLEY BLACK &amp; DECKER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>854502101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STANLEY BLACK &amp; DECKER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT 11/17/20166</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>854502804</cusip>
    <value>21963</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>173869</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>173869</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STAPLES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>855030102</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1261</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1261</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STAPLES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>855030102</cusip>
    <value>93</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10896</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10896</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STAPLES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>855030102</cusip>
    <value>1662</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>194444</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>173661</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>20783</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STARBUCKS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>855244109</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>115</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>115</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STARBUCKS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>855244109</cusip>
    <value>2193</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40513</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40513</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STARBUCKS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>855244109</cusip>
    <value>132008</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2438266</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2409086</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>29180</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STARRETT L S CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>855668109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>161</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>161</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STARZ</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85571Q102</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>298</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>298</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STATE NATL COS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85711T305</cusip>
    <value>98</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8841</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2220</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6621</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STATE STR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>857477103</cusip>
    <value>4340</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>62328</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>62328</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STATE STR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>857477103</cusip>
    <value>4037</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>57978</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57936</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>42</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STEEL DYNAMICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>858119100</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>957</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>957</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STEEL DYNAMICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>858119100</cusip>
    <value>6864</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>274667</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>274667</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STEEL DYNAMICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>858119100</cusip>
    <value>326</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13028</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7105</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5923</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STEELCASE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>858155203</cusip>
    <value>42</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3046</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3046</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STEELCASE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>858155203</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>71</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>71</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STEMLINE THERAPEUTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85858C107</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>481</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>481</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STERICYCLE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>858912108</cusip>
    <value>138</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1723</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1723</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STERLING BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85917A100</cusip>
    <value>58</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3317</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3317</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STERLING BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>85917A100</cusip>
    <value>255</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14599</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12781</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1818</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STIFEL FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>860630102</cusip>
    <value>981</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25511</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25511</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STILLWATER MNG CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>86074Q102</cusip>
    <value>334</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STONERIDGE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>86183P102</cusip>
    <value>860</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46742</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33876</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12866</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STORE CAP CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>862121100</cusip>
    <value>589</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STRAIGHT PATH COMMUNICATNS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>862578101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STRAYER ED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>863236105</cusip>
    <value>1425</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30532</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28479</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2053</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STRYKER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>863667101</cusip>
    <value>659</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5662</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5662</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STRYKER CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>863667101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STURM RUGER &amp; CO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>864159108</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>364</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>364</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUBURBAN PROPANE PARTNERS L</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT LTD PARTN</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>864482104</cusip>
    <value>796</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23894</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23894</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUBURBAN PROPANE PARTNERS L</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT LTD PARTN</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>864482104</cusip>
    <value>3768</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>113149</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>113149</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUCAMPO PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>864909106</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>424</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>424</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUMMIT FINANCIAL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>86606G101</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>284</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>284</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUMMIT HOTEL PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>866082100</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>713</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>713</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUMMIT MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>86614U100</cusip>
    <value>915</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49344</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49344</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUMMIT MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>86614U100</cusip>
    <value>36</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1931</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1931</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUMMIT MATLS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>86614U100</cusip>
    <value>8131</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>438339</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>432411</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5928</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUN CMNTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>866674104</cusip>
    <value>9130</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>116332</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>116332</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUN LIFE FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>866796105</cusip>
    <value>25419</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>781176</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>781176</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUNCOR ENERGY INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>867224107</cusip>
    <value>2162</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>77838</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2271</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>75567</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUNCOR ENERGY INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>867224107</cusip>
    <value>16239</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>584570</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>584570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUNCOR ENERGY INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>867224107</cusip>
    <value>24941</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>897822</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>893630</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4192</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUNESIS PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>867328700</cusip>
    <value>481</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUNSTONE HOTEL INVS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>867892101</cusip>
    <value>24</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1873</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1873</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUNTRUST BKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>867914103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUNTRUST BKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>867914103</cusip>
    <value>575</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13139</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13139</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUNTRUST BKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>867914103</cusip>
    <value>21445</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>489610</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>475824</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13786</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUPERIOR ENERGY SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>868157108</cusip>
    <value>1467</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>81937</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>81937</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUPERIOR ENERGY SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>868157108</cusip>
    <value>986</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55068</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55068</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUPERNUS PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>868459108</cusip>
    <value>64</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2598</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2598</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUPERVALU INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>868536103</cusip>
    <value>961</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>192626</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>107847</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>84779</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUPREME INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>868607102</cusip>
    <value>621</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32194</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32194</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SURGICAL CARE AFFILIATES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>86881L106</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SURGICAL CARE AFFILIATES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>86881L106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SUSSEX BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>869245100</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>562</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>562</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SWIFT TRANSN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87074U101</cusip>
    <value>1287</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>59945</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1733</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>58212</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SWIFT TRANSN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87074U101</cusip>
    <value>45</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2101</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2101</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SWIFT TRANSN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87074U101</cusip>
    <value>6100</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>284106</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>280906</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3200</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYKES ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871237103</cusip>
    <value>456</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16228</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2496</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13732</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYMANTEC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871503108</cusip>
    <value>3372</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>134327</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3439</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>130888</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYMANTEC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871503108</cusip>
    <value>2661</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>106000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>106000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYMANTEC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871503108</cusip>
    <value>29945</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1193032</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1184687</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8345</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYMANTEC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871503108</cusip>
    <value>1496</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>59616</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58805</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>811</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNCHRONOSS TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87157B103</cusip>
    <value>536</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13016</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13016</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNAPTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87157D109</cusip>
    <value>1518</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25909</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25909</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNAPTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87157D109</cusip>
    <value>1600</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27321</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27201</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>120</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNOPSYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871607107</cusip>
    <value>5325</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>89720</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>89720</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNOPSYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871607107</cusip>
    <value>492</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8285</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8285</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNOPSYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871607107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNOVUS FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87161C501</cusip>
    <value>2349</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>72214</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>72214</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNOVUS FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87161C501</cusip>
    <value>2592</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>79688</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>79688</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNOVUS FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87161C501</cusip>
    <value>21560</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>662769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>653137</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9632</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNNEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87162W100</cusip>
    <value>1007</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8825</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8825</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNNEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87162W100</cusip>
    <value>1755</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15376</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15376</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNNEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87162W100</cusip>
    <value>8935</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78298</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>77213</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1085</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNNEX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87162W100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNCHRONY FINL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87165B103</cusip>
    <value>518</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18486</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18486</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNCHRONY FINL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87165B103</cusip>
    <value>359</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12828</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12828</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYNCHRONY FINL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87165B103</cusip>
    <value>1066</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38086</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37918</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>168</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYSCO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871829107</cusip>
    <value>46751</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>953914</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>953914</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SYSCO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>871829107</cusip>
    <value>539</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10988</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10988</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TCF FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>872275102</cusip>
    <value>1766</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>121685</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>121685</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TCF FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>872275102</cusip>
    <value>100</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6878</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6878</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TD AMERITRADE HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87236Y108</cusip>
    <value>523</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14843</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14843</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TJX COS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>872540109</cusip>
    <value>18364</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>245578</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>245578</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TJX COS INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>872540109</cusip>
    <value>58106</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>777023</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>755893</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21130</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>T MOBILE US INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>872590104</cusip>
    <value>72439</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1550500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1509048</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>41452</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRI POINTE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87265H109</cusip>
    <value>1139</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86417</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86417</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TTM TECHNOLOGIES  INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87305R109</cusip>
    <value>730</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63766</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57497</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6269</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TABLEAU SOFTWARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87336U105</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>104</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>104</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TAILORED BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87403A107</cusip>
    <value>1894</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120651</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>114566</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6085</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TAKE-TWO INTERACTIVE SOFTWAR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>874054109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TALEN ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87422J105</cusip>
    <value>658</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47508</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47508</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TANGER FACTORY OUTLET CTRS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>875465106</cusip>
    <value>2050</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52612</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52612</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TARGET CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87612E106</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>239</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>239</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TARGET CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87612E106</cusip>
    <value>958</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13954</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13954</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TARGET CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87612E106</cusip>
    <value>27187</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>395847</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>379849</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>15998</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TAUBMAN CTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>876664103</cusip>
    <value>2867</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38532</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38532</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TAYLOR MORRISON HOME CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87724P106</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>110</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEAM HEALTH HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87817A107</cusip>
    <value>556</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17090</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17090</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEAM HEALTH HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87817A107</cusip>
    <value>2619</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80446</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80446</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TECH DATA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>878237106</cusip>
    <value>1221</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14411</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14411</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TECH DATA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>878237106</cusip>
    <value>2966</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35010</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34945</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>65</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEGNA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87901J105</cusip>
    <value>2208</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100993</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3234</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>97759</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEGNA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87901J105</cusip>
    <value>119</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5459</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5459</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEGNA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87901J105</cusip>
    <value>11023</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>504236</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>498523</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5713</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEGNA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87901J105</cusip>
    <value>35</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1619</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1584</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>35</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TELEDYNE TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>879360105</cusip>
    <value>2015</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18667</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18667</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TELEFLEX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>879369106</cusip>
    <value>3967</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23606</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23606</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TELEPHONE &amp; DATA SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>879433829</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TELEPHONE &amp; DATA SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>879433829</cusip>
    <value>1300</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>47834</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>47834</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TELEPHONE &amp; DATA SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>879433829</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TELIGENT INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87960W104</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>502</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>502</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TELUS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>87971M103</cusip>
    <value>5918</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>179332</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>38242</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>141090</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEMPUR SEALY INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88023U101</cusip>
    <value>1589</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28001</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28001</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEMPUR SEALY INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88023U101</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>67</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEMPUR SEALY INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88023U101</cusip>
    <value>1373</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24197</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18541</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5656</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TENARIS S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88031M109</cusip>
    <value>1886</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66410</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1862</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>64548</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TENARIS S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88031M109</cusip>
    <value>8790</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>309507</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>305912</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3595</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TENET HEALTHCARE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88033G407</cusip>
    <value>696</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30695</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30695</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TENET HEALTHCARE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88033G407</cusip>
    <value>3272</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>144415</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>144415</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TENET HEALTHCARE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88033G407</cusip>
    <value>1012</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44652</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>44652</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TENNECO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>880349105</cusip>
    <value>1302</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22350</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22350</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TENNECO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>880349105</cusip>
    <value>11900</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>204224</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>201364</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2860</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TENNECO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>880349105</cusip>
    <value>1189</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20410</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20299</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>111</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TERADATA CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88076W103</cusip>
    <value>337</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10866</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10866</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TERADATA CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88076W103</cusip>
    <value>13332</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>430057</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>380256</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>49801</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TERADYNE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>880770102</cusip>
    <value>2809</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>130171</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>130171</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TERADYNE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>880770102</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>98</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>98</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEREX CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>880779103</cusip>
    <value>1484</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58397</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58397</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TERRITORIAL BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88145X108</cusip>
    <value>827</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28866</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15482</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13384</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TERRENO RLTY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88146M101</cusip>
    <value>1871</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TESARO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>881569107</cusip>
    <value>86698</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>864900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>864900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TESORO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>881609101</cusip>
    <value>65</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>815</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>815</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TESORO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>881609101</cusip>
    <value>6346</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>79760</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>79760</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TESORO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>881609101</cusip>
    <value>2900</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36451</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28434</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8017</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEVA PHARMACEUTICAL INDS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>881624209</cusip>
    <value>1276</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27735</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2628</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>25107</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEVA PHARMACEUTICAL INDS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>881624209</cusip>
    <value>35244</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>766015</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>766015</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEVA PHARMACEUTICAL INDS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>881624209</cusip>
    <value>5147</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>111858</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>110541</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1317</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TETRA TECH INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88162G103</cusip>
    <value>182</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5129</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1607</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3522</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TESSERA TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88164L100</cusip>
    <value>7688</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>200000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TESSERA TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88164L100</cusip>
    <value>581</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15125</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14901</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>224</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TETRAPHASE PHARMACEUTICALS I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88165N105</cusip>
    <value>496</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>129483</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>104704</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>24779</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEXAS INSTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>882508104</cusip>
    <value>58473</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>833188</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>833188</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEXAS INSTRS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>882508104</cusip>
    <value>309</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4398</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4398</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEXAS ROADHOUSE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>882681109</cusip>
    <value>1421</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36409</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36409</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEXTRON INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>883203101</cusip>
    <value>269</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6758</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6758</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>THE ONE GROUP HOSPITALITY IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88338K103</cusip>
    <value>2250</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>900000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>900000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>THERMO FISHER SCIENTIFIC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>883556102</cusip>
    <value>1308</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8221</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8221</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>THOR INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>885160101</cusip>
    <value>2219</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26199</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26199</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>THOR INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>885160101</cusip>
    <value>5430</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64104</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55908</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8196</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>3-D SYS CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88554D205</cusip>
    <value>1060</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>59044</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>59044</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>3-D SYS CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88554D205</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>157</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>157</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>3M CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88579Y101</cusip>
    <value>2680</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15208</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15208</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>3M CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88579Y101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIDEWATER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>886423102</cusip>
    <value>51</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18257</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18123</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>134</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIFFANY &amp; CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>886547108</cusip>
    <value>174</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2399</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2399</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TILE SHOP HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88677Q109</cusip>
    <value>42</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2512</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2512</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TILLYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>886885102</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>853</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>853</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIMBERLAND BANCORP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>887098101</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>204</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>204</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIME INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>887228104</cusip>
    <value>389</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26862</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26862</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIME INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>887228104</cusip>
    <value>104</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIME WARNER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>887317303</cusip>
    <value>15221</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>191194</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>191194</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIME WARNER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>887317303</cusip>
    <value>388</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4872</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4872</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIMKEN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>887389104</cusip>
    <value>1795</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51078</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51078</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIMKEN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>887389104</cusip>
    <value>54</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1548</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1548</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIMKENSTEEL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>887399103</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>750</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>750</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TITAN INTL INC ILL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88830M102</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1163</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1124</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>39</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TITAN MACHY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88830R101</cusip>
    <value>127</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12239</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8372</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3867</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TIVO CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>88870P106</cusip>
    <value>71</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3656</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3656</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOLL BROTHERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>889478103</cusip>
    <value>1839</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61591</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1730</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>59861</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOLL BROTHERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>889478103</cusip>
    <value>2052</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>68713</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68713</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOLL BROTHERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>889478103</cusip>
    <value>27576</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>923507</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>920238</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3269</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOLL BROTHERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>889478103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOMPKINS FINANCIAL CORPORATI</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>890110109</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>130</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>130</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TORCHMARK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>891027104</cusip>
    <value>402</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6298</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6298</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TORO CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>891092108</cusip>
    <value>2717</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58014</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58014</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TORO CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>891092108</cusip>
    <value>458</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9780</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9780</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOTAL S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89151E109</cusip>
    <value>6586</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>138077</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32030</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>106047</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOTAL S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89151E109</cusip>
    <value>17529</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>367483</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>367483</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOWER INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>891826109</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>133</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>133</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOTAL SYS SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>891906109</cusip>
    <value>167</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3544</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3544</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOWN SPORTS INTL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89214A102</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1376</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1376</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOWNEBANK PORTSMOUTH VA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89214P109</cusip>
    <value>19</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>781</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>337</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>444</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOWNSQUARE MEDIA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>892231101</cusip>
    <value>982</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>105169</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>105169</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOWNSQUARE MEDIA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>892231101</cusip>
    <value>4805</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>514413</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>514413</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOWNSQUARE MEDIA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>892231101</cusip>
    <value>850</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>91000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>91000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRACTOR SUPPLY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>892356106</cusip>
    <value>245</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3641</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3641</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRACTOR SUPPLY CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>892356106</cusip>
    <value>21136</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>313818</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>305285</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8533</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRANSCANADA CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89353D107</cusip>
    <value>5874</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>123513</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26353</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>97160</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRANSDIGM GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>893641100</cusip>
    <value>125</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>431</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>431</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRANSUNION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89400J107</cusip>
    <value>2984</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86489</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73783</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12706</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRAVELERS COMPANIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89417E109</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRAVELERS COMPANIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89417E109</cusip>
    <value>38338</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>334685</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>334685</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRAVELERS COMPANIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89417E109</cusip>
    <value>37516</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>327508</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>312067</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>15441</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRAVELZOO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89421Q205</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>760</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>760</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TREEHOUSE FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89469A104</cusip>
    <value>523</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TREEHOUSE FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89469A104</cusip>
    <value>2671</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30635</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30635</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TREEHOUSE FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89469A104</cusip>
    <value>5170</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>59294</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58499</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>795</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIBUNE MEDIA CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896047503</cusip>
    <value>2605</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>71325</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>71325</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIBUNE MEDIA CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896047503</cusip>
    <value>13104</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>358804</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>354019</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4785</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRICO BANCSHARES</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896095106</cusip>
    <value>371</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13848</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10646</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3202</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIMAS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896215209</cusip>
    <value>54</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2881</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2881</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIMAS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896215209</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>102</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>102</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIMBLE NAVIGATION LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896239100</cusip>
    <value>4329</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>151587</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>151587</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIMBLE NAVIGATION LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896239100</cusip>
    <value>360</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12609</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12609</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRINITY INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896522109</cusip>
    <value>1592</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65837</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65837</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRINITY INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896522109</cusip>
    <value>7345</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>303765</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>285683</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18082</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIPLE-S MGMT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896749108</cusip>
    <value>401</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18268</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7990</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10278</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRISTATE CAP HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89678F100</cusip>
    <value>13</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>835</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>142</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>693</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIUMPH GROUP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896818101</cusip>
    <value>760</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27247</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27247</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIUMPH GROUP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896818101</cusip>
    <value>498</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17859</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17841</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRIPADVISOR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>896945201</cusip>
    <value>178</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2817</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2817</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRUEBLUE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>89785X101</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>184</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>184</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRUPANION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>898202106</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1357</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1357</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRUSTMARK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>898402102</cusip>
    <value>28</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1012</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1012</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRUSTMARK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>898402102</cusip>
    <value>1036</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37608</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37608</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRUSTMARK CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>898402102</cusip>
    <value>145</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5279</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4789</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>490</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TUPPERWARE BRANDS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>899896104</cusip>
    <value>1889</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28894</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28894</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TUPPERWARE BRANDS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>899896104</cusip>
    <value>21484</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>328654</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>287758</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>40896</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TURKCELL ILETISIM HIZMETLERI</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>900111204</cusip>
    <value>37</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TUTOR PERINI CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>901109108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>67</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>67</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TWENTY FIRST CENTY FOX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90130A101</cusip>
    <value>3656</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>150937</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>150937</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TWENTY FIRST CENTY FOX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90130A200</cusip>
    <value>321</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12990</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12990</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TWILIO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90138F102</cusip>
    <value>5052</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TWITTER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90184L102</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TWITTER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90184L102</cusip>
    <value>807</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TWO HBRS INVT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90187B101</cusip>
    <value>154</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>II VI INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902104108</cusip>
    <value>1617</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66450</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>66450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>II VI INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902104108</cusip>
    <value>12646</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>519755</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>511160</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8595</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>II VI INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902104108</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>119</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>119</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>2U INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90214J101</cusip>
    <value>3496</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>91300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>91300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>2U INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90214J101</cusip>
    <value>87</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2271</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2271</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TYLER TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902252105</cusip>
    <value>2688</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15699</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15699</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TYLER TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902252105</cusip>
    <value>129895</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>758600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>758600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TYSON FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902494103</cusip>
    <value>782</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10474</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10474</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TYSON FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902494103</cusip>
    <value>412</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5520</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5520</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TYSON FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902494103</cusip>
    <value>24531</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>328520</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>309140</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>19380</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UDR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902653104</cusip>
    <value>248</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6883</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6883</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UGI CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902681105</cusip>
    <value>4691</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>103687</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>103687</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UGI CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902681105</cusip>
    <value>82</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1812</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1812</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UMB FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902788108</cusip>
    <value>601</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10102</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6878</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3224</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>US BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902973304</cusip>
    <value>12773</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>297811</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>297811</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>US BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902973304</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>272</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>272</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>US BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>902973304</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>80</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>80</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>USANA HEALTH SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90328M107</cusip>
    <value>35</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>251</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>251</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>USANA HEALTH SCIENCES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90328M107</cusip>
    <value>725</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5237</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5237</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U S G CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>903293405</cusip>
    <value>806</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31189</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31189</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U S G CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>903293405</cusip>
    <value>3780</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>146214</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>146214</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U S CONCRETE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90333L201</cusip>
    <value>33</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>721</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>721</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U S CONCRETE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90333L201</cusip>
    <value>6094</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>132300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>132300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U S GEOTHERMAL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90338S102</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U.S. AUTO PARTS NETWORK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90343C100</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2886</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2886</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U S SILICA HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90346E103</cusip>
    <value>1172</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25175</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25175</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U S SILICA HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90346E103</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>201</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>201</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>U S SILICA HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90346E103</cusip>
    <value>75946</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1631150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1627860</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3290</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UBIQUITI NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90347A100</cusip>
    <value>47</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>886</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>886</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UBIQUITI NETWORKS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90347A100</cusip>
    <value>804</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15033</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15033</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ULTA SALON COSMETCS &amp; FRAG I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90384S303</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ULTA SALON COSMETCS &amp; FRAG I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90384S303</cusip>
    <value>317</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1333</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1333</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ULTA SALON COSMETCS &amp; FRAG I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90384S303</cusip>
    <value>49598</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>208414</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>202824</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5590</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ULTA SALON COSMETCS &amp; FRAG I</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90384S303</cusip>
    <value>17363</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>72962</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65293</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7669</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ULTIMATE SOFTWARE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90385D107</cusip>
    <value>2828</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13835</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13835</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ULTIMATE SOFTWARE GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90385D107</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>76</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ULTRA CLEAN HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90385V107</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>130</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>130</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ULTRAGENYX PHARMACEUTICAL IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90400D108</cusip>
    <value>31398</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>442600</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>442600</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UMPQUA HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>904214103</cusip>
    <value>2213</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>147060</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>147060</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UMPQUA HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>904214103</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1228</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>0</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1228</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNDER ARMOUR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>904311107</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1561</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1561</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNDER ARMOUR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>904311206</cusip>
    <value>40</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1171</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1171</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIFIRST CORP MASS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>904708104</cusip>
    <value>1750</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13275</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13275</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIFIRST CORP MASS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>904708104</cusip>
    <value>15870</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120354</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>118644</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1710</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNILEVER PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>904767704</cusip>
    <value>149545</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3154954</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2172860</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>982094</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNILEVER N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>N Y SHS NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>904784709</cusip>
    <value>1844</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNION BANKSHARES CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90539J109</cusip>
    <value>1058</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39512</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26569</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12943</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNION PAC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>907818108</cusip>
    <value>9545</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97872</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97872</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNION PAC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>907818108</cusip>
    <value>104954</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1076116</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1062748</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13368</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED BANCSHARES INC OHIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>909458101</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>225</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>225</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED CMNTY FINL CORP OHIO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>909839102</cusip>
    <value>77</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10764</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4668</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6096</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED CMNTY BKS BLAIRSVLE G</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>90984P303</cusip>
    <value>110</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5233</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5227</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED CONTL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>910047109</cusip>
    <value>359</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6851</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6851</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED CONTL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>910047109</cusip>
    <value>9223</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>175769</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>163579</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12190</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED FINL BANCORP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>910304104</cusip>
    <value>16</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1137</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1137</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED INS HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>910710102</cusip>
    <value>38</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2230</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>320</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1910</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED NAT FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>911163103</cusip>
    <value>1081</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27010</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27010</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED NAT FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>911163103</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>911312106</cusip>
    <value>1684</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>911312106</cusip>
    <value>1823</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16668</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16668</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>911312106</cusip>
    <value>2169</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19835</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19835</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED RENTALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>911363109</cusip>
    <value>394</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5024</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5024</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED RENTALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>911363109</cusip>
    <value>15928</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>202927</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>182197</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>20730</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>US FOODS HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>912008109</cusip>
    <value>768</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32514</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32514</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>US FOODS HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>912008109</cusip>
    <value>3550</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>150366</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>150366</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED STATES NATL GAS FUND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>UNIT PAR $0.001</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>912318201</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>365</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>365</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED STATES STL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>912909108</cusip>
    <value>1716</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>90973</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>90973</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED STATES STL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>912909108</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>913017109</cusip>
    <value>25929</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>255211</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>255211</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>913017109</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED THERAPEUTICS CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91307C102</cusip>
    <value>2412</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20430</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20430</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITED THERAPEUTICS CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91307C102</cusip>
    <value>24440</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>206979</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>188179</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18800</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91324P102</cusip>
    <value>3069</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21922</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>864</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21058</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91324P102</cusip>
    <value>4998</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35702</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35702</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91324P102</cusip>
    <value>42969</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>306923</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>305745</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1178</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91324P102</cusip>
    <value>371</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2652</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2617</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>35</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIVAR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91336L107</cusip>
    <value>49</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2247</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2247</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIVERSAL DISPLAY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91347P105</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>902</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>902</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIVERSAL INS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91359V107</cusip>
    <value>21</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>827</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>827</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIVERSAL INS HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91359V107</cusip>
    <value>1539</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61079</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60722</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>357</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIVERSAL STAINLESS &amp; ALLOY</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>913837100</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>614</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>614</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIVERSAL HLTH SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>913903100</cusip>
    <value>264</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2145</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2145</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIVERSAL HLTH SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>913903100</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNIVEST CORP PA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>915271100</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>202</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>202</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>UNUM GROUP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91529Y106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>URBAN OUTFITTERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>917047102</cusip>
    <value>294</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8512</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8512</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>URBAN OUTFITTERS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>917047102</cusip>
    <value>84</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2431</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2420</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>URBAN EDGE PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91704F104</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>263</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>263</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>URBAN EDGE PPTYS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91704F104</cusip>
    <value>1364</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48464</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48464</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VCA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>918194101</cusip>
    <value>3129</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44713</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>44713</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VCA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>918194101</cusip>
    <value>17476</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>249725</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>249725</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VCA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>918194101</cusip>
    <value>1943</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27762</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22334</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5428</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>V F CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>918204108</cusip>
    <value>498</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8885</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8885</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VOXX INTL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91829F104</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VWR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91843L103</cusip>
    <value>1257</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>44313</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34887</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9426</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VAIL RESORTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91879Q109</cusip>
    <value>6612</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42148</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>42148</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VAIL RESORTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91879Q109</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALEANT PHARMACEUTICALS INTL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91911K102</cusip>
    <value>567</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23115</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23115</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALEANT PHARMACEUTICALS INTL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91911K102</cusip>
    <value>2596</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>105748</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>105748</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALERO ENERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91913Y100</cusip>
    <value>82</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1541</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1541</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALERO ENERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91913Y100</cusip>
    <value>30642</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>578154</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>578154</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALERO ENERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>91913Y100</cusip>
    <value>33549</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>633002</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>598309</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>34693</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALLEY NATL BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>919794107</cusip>
    <value>929</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>95458</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>95458</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALMONT INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>920253101</cusip>
    <value>1745</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12965</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12965</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALMONT INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>920253101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALSPAR CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>920355104</cusip>
    <value>4295</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40496</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40496</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALVOLINE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92047W101</cusip>
    <value>45935</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1955500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1955500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VANDA PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>921659108</cusip>
    <value>98</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5902</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5902</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD SCOTTSDALE FDS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>MORTG-BACK SEC</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92206C771</cusip>
    <value>804</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VANTIV INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92210H105</cusip>
    <value>124544</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2213332</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2181088</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>32244</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VANTIV INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92210H105</cusip>
    <value>6502</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>115558</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>105198</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10360</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VARONIS SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>922280102</cusip>
    <value>502</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16690</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16481</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>209</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VASCULAR SOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92231M109</cusip>
    <value>443</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9185</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9185</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VECTREN CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92240G101</cusip>
    <value>2290</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>45612</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>45612</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VECTOR GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92240M108</cusip>
    <value>866</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40228</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40228</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VECTOR GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92240M108</cusip>
    <value>7823</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>363365</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>358204</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5162</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VEEVA SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>922475108</cusip>
    <value>159952</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3874800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3874800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VEEVA SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>922475108</cusip>
    <value>15079</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>365279</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>324265</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>41014</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VENTAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92276F100</cusip>
    <value>149944</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2122944</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1168875</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>954069</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VENTAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92276F100</cusip>
    <value>253671</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3591550</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3591550</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VENTAS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92276F100</cusip>
    <value>292</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4139</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4139</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERA BRADLEY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92335C106</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>178</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>178</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERASTEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92337C104</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1293</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1293</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERACYTE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92337F107</cusip>
    <value>3995</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>525000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>525000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VEREIT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92339V100</cusip>
    <value>271</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26119</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26119</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERIFONE SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92342Y109</cusip>
    <value>962</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61134</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61134</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERIFONE SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92342Y109</cusip>
    <value>2271</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>144307</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>124952</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>19355</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERISIGN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92343E102</cusip>
    <value>412</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5269</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5269</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92343V104</cusip>
    <value>259609</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4994400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3703431</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1290969</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92343V104</cusip>
    <value>758219</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14586748</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14586748</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92343V104</cusip>
    <value>914</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17591</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17591</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92343V104</cusip>
    <value>38561</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>741844</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>706564</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>35280</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERINT SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92343X100</cusip>
    <value>49</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1291</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1291</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERINT SYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92343X100</cusip>
    <value>142</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3784</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3784</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERITIV CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>923454102</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>85</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>85</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERISK ANALYTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92345Y106</cusip>
    <value>313</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3849</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3849</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERISK ANALYTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92345Y106</cusip>
    <value>30805</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>379000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>379000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERSARTIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92529L102</cusip>
    <value>613</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERSARTIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92529L102</cusip>
    <value>17544</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1432150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1432150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERSARTIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92529L102</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1147</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1147</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERTEX PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92532F100</cusip>
    <value>2801</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32120</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32120</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERTEX PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92532F100</cusip>
    <value>1621</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18592</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18592</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VERTEX PHARMACEUTICALS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92532F100</cusip>
    <value>4695</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53840</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>53840</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VIASAT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92552V100</cusip>
    <value>1435</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19228</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19228</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VIACOM INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92553P201</cusip>
    <value>712</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18700</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VIACOM INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92553P201</cusip>
    <value>93</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2432</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2432</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VIACOM INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92553P201</cusip>
    <value>21560</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>565890</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>565080</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>810</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VIACOM INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92553P201</cusip>
    <value>9593</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>251774</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>234414</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17360</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VIAVI SOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>925550105</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1884</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1884</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VIAVI SOLUTIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>925550105</cusip>
    <value>26</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3474</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3474</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VILLAGE SUPER MKT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>927107409</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>291</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>291</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VINCE HLDG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92719W108</cusip>
    <value>12</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2170</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2170</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VIRTU FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928254101</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>159</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>159</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92826C839</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>93</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>93</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92826C839</cusip>
    <value>5281</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>63858</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>63858</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92826C839</cusip>
    <value>61786</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>747115</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>727140</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>19975</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISHAY INTERTECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928298108</cusip>
    <value>61</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4351</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4351</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISHAY INTERTECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928298108</cusip>
    <value>1058</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75111</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75111</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISHAY INTERTECHNOLOGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928298108</cusip>
    <value>4574</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>324638</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>322641</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1997</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISTA OUTDOOR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928377100</cusip>
    <value>1739</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43620</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>43620</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISTA OUTDOOR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928377100</cusip>
    <value>47</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1191</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1191</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VISTEON CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92839U206</cusip>
    <value>70</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>981</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>963</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>18</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VMWARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928563402</cusip>
    <value>1467</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VMWARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928563402</cusip>
    <value>478</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6522</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6522</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VMWARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>928563402</cusip>
    <value>481</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6559</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6554</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VOCERA COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92857F107</cusip>
    <value>10</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>578</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>578</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VODAFONE GROUP PLC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPNSR ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92857W308</cusip>
    <value>244044</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8372021</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5926910</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2445111</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VODAFONE GROUP PLC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPNSR ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92857W308</cusip>
    <value>14178</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>486393</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>486393</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VODAFONE GROUP PLC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPNSR ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92857W308</cusip>
    <value>59</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2024</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2024</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VONAGE HLDGS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92886T201</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3499</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3499</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VORNADO RLTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929042109</cusip>
    <value>398</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3931</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3931</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VORNADO RLTY TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929042109</cusip>
    <value>101</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VULCAN MATLS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929160109</cusip>
    <value>341</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2997</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2997</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VULCAN MATLS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929160109</cusip>
    <value>48479</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>426266</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>426266</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WD-40 CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929236107</cusip>
    <value>20</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>177</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>177</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WCI CMNTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92923C807</cusip>
    <value>840</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35425</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35425</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WCI CMNTYS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $0.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92923C807</cusip>
    <value>7098</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>299253</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>294553</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4700</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WGL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92924F106</cusip>
    <value>56</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>899</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>899</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WGL HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92924F106</cusip>
    <value>1329</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21194</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>21194</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WSFS FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929328102</cusip>
    <value>1954</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>53550</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>53550</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WSFS FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929328102</cusip>
    <value>14991</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>410837</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>403732</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7105</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WSFS FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929328102</cusip>
    <value>794</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>21770</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12814</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8956</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WNS HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPON ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92932M101</cusip>
    <value>45</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WPP PLC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92937A102</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>27</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>27</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEC ENERGY GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>92939U106</cusip>
    <value>494</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8245</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8245</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WABASH NATL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929566107</cusip>
    <value>2791</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>195983</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>190250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>5733</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WABTEC CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>929740108</cusip>
    <value>4029</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49348</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49348</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WADDELL &amp; REED FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>930059100</cusip>
    <value>413</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22741</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22741</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WADDELL &amp; REED FINL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>930059100</cusip>
    <value>6371</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>350819</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>308910</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>41909</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WAL-MART STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>931142103</cusip>
    <value>25000</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>346645</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>346645</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WAL-MART STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>931142103</cusip>
    <value>927</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12854</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12854</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WAL-MART STORES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>931142103</cusip>
    <value>2961</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41055</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41019</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>36</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>931427108</cusip>
    <value>1794</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22257</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>615</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21642</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>931427108</cusip>
    <value>2915</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36159</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36159</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>931427108</cusip>
    <value>8295</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>102893</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>101703</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1190</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>931427108</cusip>
    <value>11954</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>148271</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>141980</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6291</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WALKER &amp; DUNLOP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>93148P102</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>696</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>696</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WALTER INVT MGMT CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>93317W102</cusip>
    <value>238</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58607</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55468</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3139</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WASHINGTON FED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>938824109</cusip>
    <value>1735</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65046</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65046</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WASHINGTON FED INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>938824109</cusip>
    <value>1369</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51301</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29700</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21601</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WASHINGTON PRIME GROUP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>93964W108</cusip>
    <value>33</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2647</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2647</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WASHINGTON PRIME GROUP NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>93964W108</cusip>
    <value>1676</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>135348</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>135348</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WASTE MGMT INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94106L109</cusip>
    <value>15108</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>236946</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>236946</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WASTE MGMT INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94106L109</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>935</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>935</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WASTE MGMT INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94106L109</cusip>
    <value>1686</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26440</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26337</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>103</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WATERS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>941848103</cusip>
    <value>355</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2242</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2242</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WATERS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>941848103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WATERSTONE FINL INC MD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94188P101</cusip>
    <value>32</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1868</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1868</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WATSCO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>942622200</cusip>
    <value>1921</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13634</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13634</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEB COM GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94733A104</cusip>
    <value>40</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2329</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2329</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEB COM GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94733A104</cusip>
    <value>594</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34373</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34093</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>280</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEBMD HEALTH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94770V102</cusip>
    <value>30</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>606</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>606</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEBMD HEALTH CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94770V102</cusip>
    <value>672</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13528</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13528</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEBSTER FINL CORP CONN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>947890109</cusip>
    <value>1412</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37150</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37150</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEBSTER FINL CORP CONN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>947890109</cusip>
    <value>1925</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50652</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50652</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEBSTER FINL CORP CONN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>947890109</cusip>
    <value>12824</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>337388</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>332548</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4840</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEIGHT WATCHERS INTL INC NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>948626106</cusip>
    <value>1015</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>98337</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97850</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>487</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEINGARTEN RLTY INVS</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SH BEN INT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>948741103</cusip>
    <value>2556</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65570</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLCARE HEALTH PLANS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94946T106</cusip>
    <value>782</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6675</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLCARE HEALTH PLANS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94946T106</cusip>
    <value>4670</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39884</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39884</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLCARE HEALTH PLANS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94946T106</cusip>
    <value>7121</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60813</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>59943</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>870</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLCARE HEALTH PLANS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>94946T106</cusip>
    <value>964</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8232</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8157</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>75</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLS FARGO &amp; CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>949746101</cusip>
    <value>5415</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>122301</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>122301</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLS FARGO &amp; CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>949746101</cusip>
    <value>1185</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26754</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26754</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLS FARGO &amp; CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>949746101</cusip>
    <value>129</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2906</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2906</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLS FARGO &amp; CO NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>PERP PFD CNV A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>949746804</cusip>
    <value>10174</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7775</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7775</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLTOWER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95040Q104</cusip>
    <value>105256</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1407733</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1012018</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>395715</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WELLTOWER INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95040Q104</cusip>
    <value>13486</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>180373</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>180373</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WENDYS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95058W100</cusip>
    <value>794</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>73560</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>73560</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WERNER ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>950755108</cusip>
    <value>1396</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>60000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>60000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WERNER ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>950755108</cusip>
    <value>595</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25570</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25570</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WERNER ENTERPRISES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>950755108</cusip>
    <value>12047</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>517724</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>509629</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8095</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESCO AIRCRAFT HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>950814103</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>95</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>95</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESCO AIRCRAFT HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>950814103</cusip>
    <value>585</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>43532</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14307</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>29225</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESCO INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95082P105</cusip>
    <value>1897</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30850</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30850</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESCO INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95082P105</cusip>
    <value>17369</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>282465</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>278305</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4160</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESCO INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95082P105</cusip>
    <value>1961</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31894</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31839</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>55</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEST BANCORPORATION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CAP STK</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95123P106</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>237</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>237</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEST CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>952355204</cusip>
    <value>4418</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>200113</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>155995</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>44118</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEST PHARMACEUTICAL SVSC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>955306105</cusip>
    <value>2612</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>35063</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>35063</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEST PHARMACEUTICAL SVSC INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>955306105</cusip>
    <value>3699</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49650</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49650</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTAR ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95709T100</cusip>
    <value>4480</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78945</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78945</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTAR ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>95709T100</cusip>
    <value>496</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8745</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8745</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN ALLIANCE BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>957638109</cusip>
    <value>1855</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>49425</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>49425</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN ALLIANCE BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>957638109</cusip>
    <value>17042</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>453961</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>447331</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6630</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN ALLIANCE BANCORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>957638109</cusip>
    <value>204</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5435</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2389</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3046</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN DIGITAL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>958102105</cusip>
    <value>361</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6169</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6169</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN REFNG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>959319104</cusip>
    <value>60</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2284</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2284</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN REFNG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>959319104</cusip>
    <value>750</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28357</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28357</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN REFNG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>959319104</cusip>
    <value>11</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>426</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>426</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN UN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>959802109</cusip>
    <value>205</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9830</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9830</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTERN UN CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>959802109</cusip>
    <value>21869</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1050406</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>933613</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>116793</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTMORELAND COAL CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>960878106</cusip>
    <value>128</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14496</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14070</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>426</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTPAC BKG CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>961214301</cusip>
    <value>2745</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>120715</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25144</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>95571</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTROCK CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>96145D105</cusip>
    <value>953</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19655</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19655</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTROCK CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>96145D105</cusip>
    <value>4706</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97071</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97071</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WESTROCK CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>96145D105</cusip>
    <value>292</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6021</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6021</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>96208T104</cusip>
    <value>2693</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24911</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24911</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEYERHAEUSER CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>962166104</cusip>
    <value>1306</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>40888</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>40888</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WEYERHAEUSER CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>962166104</cusip>
    <value>327</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10250</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10250</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WHIRLPOOL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>963320106</cusip>
    <value>1571</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9687</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>278</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9409</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WHIRLPOOL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>963320106</cusip>
    <value>299</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1841</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1841</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WHIRLPOOL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>963320106</cusip>
    <value>99427</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>613140</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>605558</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7582</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WHIRLPOOL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>963320106</cusip>
    <value>5587</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34454</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>34453</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WHITEWAVE FOODS CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>966244105</cusip>
    <value>5253</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>96510</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>96510</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WHOLE FOODS MKT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>966837106</cusip>
    <value>236</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8331</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8331</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WHOLE FOODS MKT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>966837106</cusip>
    <value>46</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1635</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1635</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WHOLE FOODS MKT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>966837106</cusip>
    <value>898</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31669</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31669</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILEY JOHN &amp; SONS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>968223206</cusip>
    <value>1687</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>32697</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>32697</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLDAN GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>96924N100</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>498</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>498</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLIAMS COS INC DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>969457100</cusip>
    <value>482</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15676</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15676</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLIAMS CLAYTON ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>969490101</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLIAMS PARTNERS L P NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM UNIT LTD PAR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>96949L105</cusip>
    <value>945</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>25397</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>25397</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLIAMS PARTNERS L P NEW</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM UNIT LTD PAR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>96949L105</cusip>
    <value>4384</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>117872</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>117872</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLIAMS SONOMA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>969904101</cusip>
    <value>2374</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>46481</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>46481</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLIAMS SONOMA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>969904101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLIS LEASE FINANCE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>970646105</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>277</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>277</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WINDSTREAM HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>97382A200</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>207</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>207</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WINDSTREAM HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>97382A200</cusip>
    <value>158</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15722</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13002</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2720</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WINGSTOP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>974155103</cusip>
    <value>8351</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>285000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>285000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WINTRUST FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>97650W108</cusip>
    <value>1723</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WINTRUST FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>97650W108</cusip>
    <value>15640</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>281455</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>277470</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3985</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WINTRUST FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>97650W108</cusip>
    <value>485</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8727</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4741</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3986</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WISDOMTREE INVTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>97717P104</cusip>
    <value>676</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65710</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>65710</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WISDOMTREE TR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>JAPN HEDGE EQT</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>97717W851</cusip>
    <value>3368</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78492</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68952</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9540</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WOLVERINE WORLD WIDE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>978097103</cusip>
    <value>28</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1206</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1206</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WOODWARD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>980745103</cusip>
    <value>993</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>15900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>15900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WOODWARD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>980745103</cusip>
    <value>1909</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30554</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30554</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WOODWARD INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>980745103</cusip>
    <value>9238</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>147854</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>145734</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2120</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WORKDAY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98138H101</cusip>
    <value>93909</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1024200</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1024200</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WORKIVA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98139A105</cusip>
    <value>89</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4926</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4926</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WORLD ACCEP CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>981419104</cusip>
    <value>879</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17927</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17808</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>119</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WORLD FUEL SVCS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>981475106</cusip>
    <value>1834</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>39642</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>39642</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WORLD FUEL SVCS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>981475106</cusip>
    <value>484</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10452</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>10452</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WORLD FUEL SVCS CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>981475106</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WORTHINGTON INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>981811102</cusip>
    <value>21874</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>455425</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>455425</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WORTHINGTON INDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>981811102</cusip>
    <value>1348</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28057</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28011</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>46</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WPX ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98212B103</cusip>
    <value>1118</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>84725</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>84725</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WPX ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98212B103</cusip>
    <value>2479</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>187949</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>187949</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WPX ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98212B103</cusip>
    <value>9911</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>751383</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>739998</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11385</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WYNDHAM WORLDWIDE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98310W108</cusip>
    <value>145</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2156</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2156</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WYNDHAM WORLDWIDE CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98310W108</cusip>
    <value>33915</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>503709</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>456196</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>47513</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WYNN RESORTS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>983134107</cusip>
    <value>150</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1541</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1541</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XPO LOGISTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>983793100</cusip>
    <value>544</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14825</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14825</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XPO LOGISTICS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>983793100</cusip>
    <value>4525</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>123405</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>121450</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1955</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XACTLY CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98386L101</cusip>
    <value>607</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41236</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41236</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XCEL ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98389B100</cusip>
    <value>562</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13656</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13656</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XILINX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>983919101</cusip>
    <value>5562</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>102364</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>102364</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XENIA HOTELS &amp; RESORTS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>984017103</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1014</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1014</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XENCOR INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98401F105</cusip>
    <value>923</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37675</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XEROX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>984121103</cusip>
    <value>169</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16732</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16732</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XEROX CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>984121103</cusip>
    <value>522</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51529</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51483</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>46</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XERIUM TECHNOLOGIES INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98416J118</cusip>
    <value>490</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61628</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61432</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>196</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XYLEM INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98419M100</cusip>
    <value>486</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9263</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9263</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>YRC WORLDWIDE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM PAR $.01</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>984249607</cusip>
    <value>150</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12182</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3423</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8759</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>YAHOO INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>984332106</cusip>
    <value>1158</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26872</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26872</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>YELP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>985817105</cusip>
    <value>4432</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>106283</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>91674</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>14609</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>YORK WTR CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>987184108</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>YUM BRANDS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>988498101</cusip>
    <value>823</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9066</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9066</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>YUME INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98872B104</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2140</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2140</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZAGG INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98884U108</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>230</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>230</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZAFGEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98885E103</cusip>
    <value>338</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>102128</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>85943</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>16185</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZAYO GROUP HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98919V105</cusip>
    <value>16130</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>542900</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>542900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZEBRA TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>989207105</cusip>
    <value>809</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11620</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11620</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZEBRA TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>989207105</cusip>
    <value>3888</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55861</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55861</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZEBRA TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>989207105</cusip>
    <value>2032</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29188</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29188</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZEBRA TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>989207105</cusip>
    <value>284</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4079</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4070</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZENDESK INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98936J101</cusip>
    <value>374</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12183</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12183</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZILLOW GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL C CAP STK</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98954M200</cusip>
    <value>23780</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>686300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>686300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZIMMER BIOMET HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98956P102</cusip>
    <value>595</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4579</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4579</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZIMMER BIOMET HLDGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98956P102</cusip>
    <value>13791</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>106071</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97978</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8093</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZIONS BANCORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>989701107</cusip>
    <value>12400</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>399727</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>399727</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZIONS BANCORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>989701107</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>126</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>113</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>13</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZOGENIX INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98978L204</cusip>
    <value>12302</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1076300</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1076300</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZOETIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98978V103</cusip>
    <value>402</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7720</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7720</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZOETIS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98978V103</cusip>
    <value>64124</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1232923</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1200000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>32923</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZOES KITCHEN INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98979J109</cusip>
    <value>4105</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>185000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>185000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZUMIEZ INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>989817101</cusip>
    <value>22</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1231</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1231</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ZYNGA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>98986T108</cusip>
    <value>492</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>168955</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>168955</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALKERMES PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G01767105</cusip>
    <value>37817</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>804100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>804100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALKERMES PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G01767105</cusip>
    <value>19</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>398</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>398</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLEGION PUB LTD CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0176J109</cusip>
    <value>400</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5804</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5804</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLERGAN PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0177J108</cusip>
    <value>4344</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>18861</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18861</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLERGAN PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0177J108</cusip>
    <value>55835</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>242436</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>235908</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>6528</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLERGAN PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>PFD CONV SER A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0177J116</cusip>
    <value>16422</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19987</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19987</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AMBARELLA INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G037AX101</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>83</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AON PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0408V102</cusip>
    <value>769</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6840</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6840</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARCH CAP GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0450A105</cusip>
    <value>2429</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30640</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30640</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARGO GROUP INTL HLDGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0464B107</cusip>
    <value>2049</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36309</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36309</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARGO GROUP INTL HLDGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0464B107</cusip>
    <value>5</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>83</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARGO GROUP INTL HLDGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0464B107</cusip>
    <value>16600</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>294217</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>289386</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4831</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARGO GROUP INTL HLDGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0464B107</cusip>
    <value>18</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>315</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>315</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASPEN INSURANCE HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G05384105</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>75</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASPEN INSURANCE HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G05384105</cusip>
    <value>1448</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31077</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31077</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASPEN INSURANCE HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G05384105</cusip>
    <value>365</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7835</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7835</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASPEN INSURANCE HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G05384105</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>88</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>88</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARRIS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0551A103</cusip>
    <value>1036</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36575</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36575</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARRIS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0551A103</cusip>
    <value>2960</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>104477</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>104477</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ARRIS INTL INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0551A103</cusip>
    <value>9501</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>335355</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>330665</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4690</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASSURED GUARANTY LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0585R106</cusip>
    <value>6710</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>241797</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>238073</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3724</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATLASSIAN CORP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G06242104</cusip>
    <value>2577</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>86000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AXIS CAPITAL HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0692U109</cusip>
    <value>87</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1595</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1595</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AXIS CAPITAL HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0692U109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ATLANTICA YIELD PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G0751N103</cusip>
    <value>37</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1971</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1971</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACCENTURE PLC IRELAND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS CLASS A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G1151C101</cusip>
    <value>1628</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13325</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13325</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ACCENTURE PLC IRELAND</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS CLASS A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G1151C101</cusip>
    <value>25</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>201</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>201</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BELMOND LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G1154H107</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>726</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>726</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MIMECAST LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G14838109</cusip>
    <value>8795</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>459735</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>459735</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BUNGE LIMITED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G16962105</cusip>
    <value>428</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7223</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4877</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2346</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELPHI AUTOMOTIVE PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G27823106</cusip>
    <value>23</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>326</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>326</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DELPHI AUTOMOTIVE PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G27823106</cusip>
    <value>523</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7340</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7340</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EATON CORP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G29183103</cusip>
    <value>2499</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>38030</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1096</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>36934</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EATON CORP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G29183103</cusip>
    <value>21312</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>324338</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>324338</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EATON CORP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G29183103</cusip>
    <value>35049</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>533396</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>531438</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1958</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EATON CORP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G29183103</cusip>
    <value>847</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12885</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12351</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>534</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENDURANCE SPECIALTY HLDGS LT</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G30397106</cusip>
    <value>1883</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>28772</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>28772</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENDO INTL PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G30401106</cusip>
    <value>66</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3282</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3282</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENDO INTL PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G30401106</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>347</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>325</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENSCO PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS CLASS A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G3157S106</cusip>
    <value>1897</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>223228</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>223228</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ENSCO PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS CLASS A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G3157S106</cusip>
    <value>3644</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>428758</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>425338</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3420</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ESSENT GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G3198U102</cusip>
    <value>798</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVEREST RE GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G3223R108</cusip>
    <value>4326</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22772</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22772</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>EVEREST RE GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G3223R108</cusip>
    <value>12546</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>66043</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>63272</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>2771</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FABRINET</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G3323L100</cusip>
    <value>447</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>10021</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8137</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1884</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FERROGLOBE PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G33856108</cusip>
    <value>45</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5021</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5021</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FLEETMATICS GROUP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G35569105</cusip>
    <value>25189</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>419956</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>419956</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRESH DEL MONTE PRODUCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G36738105</cusip>
    <value>36</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>593</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>593</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRESH DEL MONTE PRODUCE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G36738105</cusip>
    <value>819</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>13675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>13664</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HELEN OF TROY CORP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G4388N106</cusip>
    <value>1265</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14676</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14676</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HELEN OF TROY CORP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G4388N106</cusip>
    <value>1462</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16971</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16549</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>422</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HERBALIFE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM USD SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G4412G101</cusip>
    <value>75</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1212</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1212</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HERBALIFE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM USD SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G4412G101</cusip>
    <value>6348</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>102396</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>91538</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10858</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>HORIZON PHARMA PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G4617B105</cusip>
    <value>1276</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>70403</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>70403</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGERSOLL-RAND PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G47791101</cusip>
    <value>2912</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>42854</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1772</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>41082</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGERSOLL-RAND PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G47791101</cusip>
    <value>20020</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>294665</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>294665</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGERSOLL-RAND PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G47791101</cusip>
    <value>74860</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1101850</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1080885</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>20965</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INGERSOLL-RAND PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G47791101</cusip>
    <value>14</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>201</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>201</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL GAME TECHNOLOG</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS USD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G4863A108</cusip>
    <value>493</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20235</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20235</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVESCO LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G491BT108</cusip>
    <value>1129</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>36100</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>36100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVESCO LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G491BT108</cusip>
    <value>83</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2665</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2665</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INVESCO LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G491BT108</cusip>
    <value>32440</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1037420</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1027020</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>10400</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JAZZ PHARMACEUTICALS PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS USD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G50871105</cusip>
    <value>1944</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>JOHNSON CTLS INTL PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G51502105</cusip>
    <value>10440</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>224382</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>224382</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LAZARD LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G54050102</cusip>
    <value>464</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>12773</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>12773</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY GLOBAL PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS CL C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5480U120</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>30</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIBERTY GLOBAL PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>LILAC SHS CL C</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5480U153</cusip>
    <value>11569</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>412445</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>411510</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>935</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIVANOVA PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5509L101</cusip>
    <value>1612</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>26815</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>26815</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIVANOVA PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5509L101</cusip>
    <value>1039</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17288</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17288</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LIVANOVA PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5509L101</cusip>
    <value>5971</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>99328</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>99328</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAIDEN HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5753U112</cusip>
    <value>1559</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>122850</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>122850</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAIDEN HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5753U112</cusip>
    <value>12783</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1007296</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>991381</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>15915</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MAIDEN HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5753U112</cusip>
    <value>45</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3569</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3569</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MALLINCKRODT PUB LTD CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5785G107</cusip>
    <value>376</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5390</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5390</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MALLINCKRODT PUB LTD CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5785G107</cusip>
    <value>1645</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23567</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23567</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MALLINCKRODT PUB LTD CO</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5785G107</cusip>
    <value>396</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5672</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5672</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDTRONIC PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5960L103</cusip>
    <value>1481</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17138</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17138</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDTRONIC PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5960L103</cusip>
    <value>5070</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>58678</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>58678</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MEDTRONIC PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G5960L103</cusip>
    <value>113935</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1318688</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1295938</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>22750</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICHAEL KORS HLDGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G60754101</cusip>
    <value>421</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8992</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8992</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MICHAEL KORS HLDGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G60754101</cusip>
    <value>5511</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>117788</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100409</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>17379</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALPHA &amp; OMEGA SEMICONDUCTOR</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G6331P104</cusip>
    <value>374</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17213</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14151</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3062</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MULTI PACKAGING SOLUTIONS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G6331W109</cusip>
    <value>793</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>55036</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>55036</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MULTI PACKAGING SOLUTIONS IN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G6331W109</cusip>
    <value>3760</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>260914</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>260914</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NABORS INDUSTRIES LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G6359F103</cusip>
    <value>1867</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>153574</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>153574</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NABORS INDUSTRIES LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G6359F103</cusip>
    <value>1217</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100086</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100075</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>11</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NIELSEN HLDGS PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS EUR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G6518L108</cusip>
    <value>4084</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>76232</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>76232</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOBLE CORP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS USD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G65431101</cusip>
    <value>1318</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>207819</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>207819</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOBLE CORP PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS USD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G65431101</cusip>
    <value>2844</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>448619</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>447661</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>958</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORDIC AMERICAN TANKERS LIMI</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G65773106</cusip>
    <value>36</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3569</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3569</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORDIC AMERICAN TANKERS LIMI</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G65773106</cusip>
    <value>8</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>809</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>809</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NORD ANGLIA EDUCATION INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G6583A102</cusip>
    <value>2516</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>115500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>115500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NOVOCURE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G6674U108</cusip>
    <value>427</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RENAISSANCERE HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G7496G103</cusip>
    <value>3825</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>31832</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>31832</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RENAISSANCERE HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G7496G103</cusip>
    <value>563</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4683</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4683</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROWAN COMPANIES PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G7665A101</cusip>
    <value>1527</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>100745</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>100745</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROWAN COMPANIES PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G7665A101</cusip>
    <value>1196</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78880</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>78740</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>140</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEADRILL LIMITED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G7945E105</cusip>
    <value>123</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>51867</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>51867</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SEAGATE TECHNOLOGY PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G7945M107</cusip>
    <value>253</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>6558</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>6558</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PENTAIR PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G7S00T104</cusip>
    <value>514</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8009</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8009</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SHIP FINANCE INTERNATIONAL L</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G81075106</cusip>
    <value>3</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>237</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>237</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIGNET JEWELERS LIMITED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G81276100</cusip>
    <value>96</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1289</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1289</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SIGNET JEWELERS LIMITED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G81276100</cusip>
    <value>5820</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>78093</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>68429</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>9664</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STERIS PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS USD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G84720104</cusip>
    <value>3018</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>41288</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>41288</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRAVELPORT WORLDWIDE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9019D104</cusip>
    <value>2091</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>139140</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3571</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>135569</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRAVELPORT WORLDWIDE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9019D104</cusip>
    <value>53</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3544</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3544</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRAVELPORT WORLDWIDE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9019D104</cusip>
    <value>9312</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>619570</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>610906</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>8664</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRAVELPORT WORLDWIDE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9019D104</cusip>
    <value>1293</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>86056</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>85609</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>447</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALIDUS HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9319H102</cusip>
    <value>1170</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>23475</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>23475</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALIDUS HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9319H102</cusip>
    <value>10658</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>213935</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>210870</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3065</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>VALIDUS HOLDINGS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9319H102</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>118</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>92</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>26</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOLAR LNG LTD BERMUDA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9456A100</cusip>
    <value>1119</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52800</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52800</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GOLAR LNG LTD BERMUDA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G9456A100</cusip>
    <value>10289</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>485313</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>478038</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7275</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WILLIS TOWERS WATSON PUB LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G96629103</cusip>
    <value>183</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1376</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1376</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PERRIGO CO PLC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G97822103</cusip>
    <value>282</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3056</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3056</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XL GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G98294104</cusip>
    <value>73</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2184</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2115</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>69</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XL GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G98294104</cusip>
    <value>183</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>5446</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>5446</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>XL GROUP LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>G98294104</cusip>
    <value>11223</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>333732</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>329835</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3897</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALLIED WRLD ASSUR COM HLDG A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>H01531104</cusip>
    <value>15</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>382</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>382</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHUBB LIMITED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>H1467J104</cusip>
    <value>51</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>406</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>406</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHUBB LIMITED</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>H1467J104</cusip>
    <value>1462</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11639</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11639</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GARMIN LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>H2906T109</cusip>
    <value>369</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7675</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7675</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TE CONNECTIVITY LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>REG SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>H84989104</cusip>
    <value>1577</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>24500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>24500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TE CONNECTIVITY LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>REG SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>H84989104</cusip>
    <value>20933</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>325151</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>325151</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TE CONNECTIVITY LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>REG SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>H84989104</cusip>
    <value>1252</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19445</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>19445</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ALTISOURCE PORTFOLIO SOLNS S</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>REG SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>L0175J104</cusip>
    <value>1086</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>33525</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>33414</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>111</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLOBANT S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>L44385109</cusip>
    <value>6423</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>152500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>152500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>GLOBANT S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>L44385109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>4</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>4</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>INTELSAT S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>L5140P101</cusip>
    <value>1666</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>614839</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>386172</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>228667</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRINSEO S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>L9340P101</cusip>
    <value>50</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>883</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>883</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TRINSEO S A</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>L9340P101</cusip>
    <value>4291</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>75874</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>72342</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3532</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAESARSTONE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M20598104</cusip>
    <value>1128</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>29912</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>29912</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CAMTEK LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M20791105</cusip>
    <value>4906</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1630000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1630000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHECK POINT SOFTWARE TECH LT</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M22465104</cusip>
    <value>106</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1370</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1370</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHECK POINT SOFTWARE TECH LT</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M22465104</cusip>
    <value>1552</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CHECK POINT SOFTWARE TECH LT</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M22465104</cusip>
    <value>14311</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>184400</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>184400</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>CYBERARK SOFTWARE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M2682V108</cusip>
    <value>694</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>14000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>14000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FOAMIX PHARMACEUTICALS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M46135105</cusip>
    <value>463</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>50000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>50000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>KORNIT DIGITAL LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M6372Q113</cusip>
    <value>6097</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>650000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>650000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORBOTECH LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M75253100</cusip>
    <value>592</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>20000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>RADWARE LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M81873107</cusip>
    <value>24480</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1781650</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1781650</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SILICOM LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M84116108</cusip>
    <value>4</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>97</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>97</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STEADYMED LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M84920103</cusip>
    <value>12130</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3455044</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1573100</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>STRATASYS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M85548101</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>22</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>22</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TARO PHARMACEUTICAL INDS LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M8737E108</cusip>
    <value>9</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>83</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>83</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOWER SEMICONDUCTOR LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M87915274</cusip>
    <value>731</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>48126</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>48126</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TOWER SEMICONDUCTOR LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>M87915274</cusip>
    <value>3360</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>221321</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>221321</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AERCAP HOLDINGS NV</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N00985106</cusip>
    <value>57759</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1500626</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1460000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>40626</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ASML HOLDING N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>N Y REGISTRY SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N07059210</cusip>
    <value>1863</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>17000</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>17000</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>AVG TECHNOLOGIES N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N07831105</cusip>
    <value>57</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2284</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2284</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>FRANKS INTL N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N33462107</cusip>
    <value>7919</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>609181</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>609181</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MOBILEYE N V AMSTELVEEN</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N51488117</cusip>
    <value>65409</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1536500</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1536500</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LYONDELLBASELL INDUSTRIES N</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS - A -</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N53745100</cusip>
    <value>652</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>8079</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>8079</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>LYONDELLBASELL INDUSTRIES N</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS - A -</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N53745100</cusip>
    <value>19870</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>246343</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>226388</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>19955</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>MYLAN N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS EURO</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N59465109</cusip>
    <value>644</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>16907</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>16907</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NXP SEMICONDUCTORS N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N6596X109</cusip>
    <value>6</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>61</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>61</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NXP SEMICONDUCTORS N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N6596X109</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>2</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>2</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>NXP SEMICONDUCTORS N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N6596X109</cusip>
    <value>186882</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1831994</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1810900</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>21094</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ORTHOFIX INTL N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N6748L102</cusip>
    <value>1460</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>34127</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>30799</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>3328</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>SAPIENS INTL CORP N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N7716A151</cusip>
    <value>93</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>7305</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>7305</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WRIGHT MED GROUP N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD SHS 0.03 PAR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N96617118</cusip>
    <value>1419</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>57830</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>57830</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WRIGHT MED GROUP N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD SHS 0.03 PAR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N96617118</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>64</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>02</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>64</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>WRIGHT MED GROUP N V</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>ORD SHS 0.03 PAR</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>N96617118</cusip>
    <value>12829</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>522983</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>515428</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>7555</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COPA HOLDINGS SA</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>P31076105</cusip>
    <value>3306</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>37595</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>37591</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>4</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>PLANET PAYMENT INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>U72603118</cusip>
    <value>7</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>1926</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>1926</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROYAL CARIBBEAN CRUISES LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>V7780T103</cusip>
    <value>288</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>3847</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>3847</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>ROYAL CARIBBEAN CRUISES LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>V7780T103</cusip>
    <value>3901</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>52050</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52050</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROADCOM LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>Y09827109</cusip>
    <value>2</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>11</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>11</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROADCOM LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>Y09827109</cusip>
    <value>1653</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>9579</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>09</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>9579</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>BROADCOM LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>Y09827109</cusip>
    <value>165831</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>961225</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>21</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>949071</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12154</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>COSTAMARE INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>Y1771G102</cusip>
    <value>180</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>19669</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>18307</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>1362</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DHT HOLDINGS INC</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS NEW</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>Y2065G121</cusip>
    <value>273</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>65058</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>52614</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>12444</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>DORIAN LPG LTD</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>SHS USD</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>Y2106R110</cusip>
    <value>1</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>125</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>01</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>125</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>0</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
  <infoTable>
    <nameOfIssuer>TEEKAY CORPORATION</nameOfIssuer>
    <titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass>
    <cusip>Y8564W103</cusip>
    <value>1318</value>
    <shrsOrPrnAmt>
      <sshPrnamt>170996</sshPrnamt>
      <sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType>
    </shrsOrPrnAmt>
    <investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion>
    <otherManager>22</otherManager>
    <votingAuthority>
      <Sole>115526</Sole>
      <Shared>0</Shared>
      <None>55470</None>
    </votingAuthority>
  </infoTable>
</informationTable>
</XML>
</TEXT>
</DOCUMENT>
</SEC-DOCUMENT>
