EX-99.1 2 v146407_ex99-1.htm
Exhibit 99.1

Investor Contact:       Valda Colbart, 419-784-2759, rfcinv@rurban.net

RURBAN FINANCIAL CORP. REPORTS CONSISTENT FIRST QUARTER 2009 EARNINGS

DEFIANCE, Ohio, April 15, 2009 — Rurban Financial Corp. (NASDAQ: RBNF), a leading provider of full-service community banking, investment management, trust services and bank data and item processing, reported first quarter 2009 earnings of $1.10 million, or $0.23 per diluted share, compared to the $1.11 million, or $0.22 per diluted share, reported in first quarter 2008.  The earnings reflected additional reserve building of $300 thousand and a write-down of mortgage servicing rights of $150 thousand due to declining interest rates.

Rurban’s on-going investments in its franchise will continue to mature during 2009 and are projected to continue to bring added value to the bottom line. These initiatives include the acquisition of National Bank of Montpelier (“NBM”), recruitment of a Toledo Regional President, and expanding our Columbus Loan Production Office to include an experienced Mortgage Banking team. The investment costs for these initiatives, coupled with a very difficult banking environment requiring additional reserves, are the underlying factors for the flat quarterly earnings in comparison to the year-ago quarter.

“We are pleased we were able to report consistent earnings despite an increase in our provision for loan losses as compared to the year-ago quarter,” commented Kenneth A. Joyce, President and CEO of Rurban Financial Corp.

“In the current environment of deteriorating economic conditions, we took a prudent and appropriate $300 thousand of additional provision for loan losses, compared to the year-ago quarter, for a total of $495 thousand. We experienced an increase in our non-performing assets of 37 basis points compared to the year-ago quarter and 59 basis points to our linked quarter totals. Approximately 22 percent of the increase in non-performers was due to the NBM acquisition as we aggressively classified these loans. This did not increase our reserves for the current quarter, as we addressed setting appropriate reserves at the time of the acquisition.  The increase in the reserve was primarily due to a large commercial credit going past due ninety days, and our election to reserve for potential losses on this credit. Our experience has shown that using conservative lending practices and collateral positioning ultimately yields relatively minor net charge-offs. Despite the economic challenges faced by all community banks as unemployment grows and local businesses are affected, we believe we continue to be well-positioned for the current economic environment and the opportunities going forward,” stated Mr. Joyce.

Highlights of Rurban’s consolidated 2009 first quarter performance include:

·
Successful integration of our recent acquisition of NBM with approximately $1.0 million in expense savings on an annualized basis since the merger date from a total expense base of $3.0 million. Also in connection with the merger, State Bank has announced the closure of two banking centers, one each in Montpelier and Ney, Ohio, which will occur by the end of the second quarter, further improving the profitability of this acquisition.
 


·
Emphasis on building mortgage loan production was rewarded as loan production was $67.0 million during the quarter compared to $18.0 million from the year-ago quarter. With few exceptions, these loans were sold into the secondary market with servicing retained.  The result is an increased mortgage loan servicing portfolio that now totals $122.0 million. This retention of mortgage servicing rights is building an on-going revenue stream into the future, although adding some earnings volatility due to the process of quarterly receiving a valuation of the value of mortgage servicing rights.

·
The State Bank and Trust Company has experienced strong core deposits growth as transaction accounts have grown by $12.8 million, or 5.3 percent, from the year-end balances. This growth is a reflection of customer confidence in Rurban’s stability during a difficult banking environment and the success of our marketing programs. Part of that growth is the positive public perception resulting from not needing, or requesting, the TARP funds.

·
RDSI continued to build franchise value during the first quarter.  The first quarter of 2009 net income was $768 thousand, compared with $800 thousand in the 2008 first quarter and $715 thousand for the linked quarter. Last year’s first quarter contained a significant one-time termination fee.

The following chart and narrative reflect the combined results of Rurban across both of its business segments, banking and data / item processing:

CONSOLIDATED – FIRST QUARTER RESULTS
(Dollars in thousands except per share data)

Earnings:
 
1Q 2009
   
4Q 2008
   
1Q 2008
 
Net interest income
 
$
5,016
   
$
4,830
   
$
3,817
 
Non-interest income
   
7,448
     
6,755
     
7,516
 
Revenue
   
12,464
     
11,585
     
11,333
 
Provision (credit) for loan losses
   
495
     
138
     
192
 
Non-interest expense
   
10,475
     
9,566
     
9,601
 
Net income
   
1,104
     
1,328
     
1,109
 
Diluted EPS
 
$
0.23
   
$
0.27
   
$
0.22
 

Net interest income increased to $5.0 million for the quarter, compared to $3.8 million for the first quarter of 2008. This 31.4 percent increase is due primarily to the acquisition of the five banking centers in Williams County coupled with a 48 basis point improvement in State Bank’s net interest margin for the year-over-year period. Further margin improvement appears possible, as during the first quarter the banking segment was provided with excess liquidity from two sources. Excess cash remained from the December, 2008 acquisition and an unprecedented increase in customer deposits from external sources. Throughout the first quarter, management invested approximately $32.9 million of these funds into higher-yielding investment securities at a spread comparable to the average bank net interest margin and the impact of that investment will be fully realized in the second quarter.



Non-interest income was essentially flat at $7.45 million for 2009 compared to $7.52 million for 2008 resulting from a number of offsetting items.  Mortgage Banking revenue increased by $803 thousand (an increase of loan production from $18 million to $67 million), but this increase was partially offset by declines in trust fees of $271 thousand and Data Processing fees of $292 thousand. The reductions in trust fees were due to the decline in the equity market valuations. The Data Processing revenue decrease was partially due to de-conversion fees included within the first quarter of 2008 which totaled $150 thousand. The 2008 first quarter also included one-time income items resulting from the VISA IPO offering of $132 thousand and recoveries of $197 thousand on WorldCom bonds.

Non-interest expense for the year-over-year first quarter increased $874 thousand, or 9.10 percent. As previously mentioned, the growth initiatives detailed above were the primary drivers.  The NBM acquisition’s normal operating expenses contributed approximately $488 thousand of this increase.  Also, during the quarter the company recorded $150 thousand in impairment charges on mortgage servicing rights associated with the company’s serviced loan portfolio resulting from the decline in mortgage interest rates. Incentive payments on mortgage banking activities also increased by $265 thousand for the current quarter compared to the year-ago first quarter, as a result of the increase in mortgage banking production.

CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET

Total assets were $665.8 million on March 31, 2009, up $94.1 million from 12 months ago and up $8.2 million, or an annualized 5.0 percent, from the linked quarter.  Net loans were $434.1 million at March 31, 2009, up $42.1 million from twelve months ago and down $16.1 million, or 3.6 percent, from December 31, 2008. Total deposits were $487.6 million at March 31, 2009, up $70.9 million from twelve months ago and up $3.41 million, or 0.70 percent, from December 31, 2008. Total available for sale securities increased by $25.3 million to $127.9 million at March 31, 2009 compared to the year-end balance of $102.6 million. Total shareholder’s equity increased to $63.6 million at March 31, 2009, compared to $59.9 million at March 31, 2008 and $61.7 million at December 31, 2008.

BANK OPERATING RESULTS

The Banking Segment reported earnings of $863 thousand for the first quarter of 2009, compared to $917 thousand for the first quarter of 2008. The current quarter’s one-time charges were somewhat offset by the additional earnings from the recent acquisition and the improvement in Mortgage Banking earnings.

Mr. Joyce further commented, “It is pleasing to see a report of consistent earnings within our banking segment, despite having recorded a larger than normal provision for loan losses and mortgage servicing rights impairment charges. Our banking model continues improving as we integrate the recent acquisition and expect further improvement from closing two associated banking centers during the second quarter. As we have stated previously in press releases, we would expect to realize the full benefits of the efficiencies within this acquisition by the third quarter of 2009. These incremental earnings may be an offset to the challenges we are facing within the banking industry, including our trust division, as equity balances decline. We expect to continue to build our deposit balances in 2009 in our various markets, and maintain tight control on expenses and aggressively address any asset quality issues.”



Total loans were $434.1 million at March 31, 2009, down $16.1 million from year-end levels. We received approximately $8.3 million in pay-offs during the first quarter from mortgages refinancing out of our residential loan portfolio. We also had several large pay downs and pay-offs of commercial credits where the borrower was deleveraging, or sold a portion of their company. The overall yield on our loan portfolio has declined to 6.20 percent compared to 7.04 percent for the year-ago quarter, but by aggressive margin management, we have significantly increased net interest income.

Total deposits at March 31, 2009 were $487.6 million compared to $484.2 million at December 31, 2008 and $416.7 million for the year-ago quarter-end. The cost of deposits dropped to 1.56 percent for the first quarter 2009, compared to the year-ago quarter cost of 2.97 percent. Rurban’s deposit mix continues to shift toward core transaction deposits (DDA, NOW, SAV & MMA), which accounted for 52.2 percent of total deposits for first quarter 2009, compared with 47.6 percent for the year-ago first quarter.

“Maintaining this reduction in funding costs remains key to future profitability as some of our earning assets price downward, as a result of the rate cuts implemented in late 2008. However, we have not fully realized our aggressive repricing of deposit products initiated during the first quarter in response to general rate reductions. This will have a positive influence on our margin as we leverage this low cost money into higher yielding loans. Our loan production remains consistent, although we have certainly become more cautious in our lending practices. We believe that we manage our asset/liability process prudently and proactively. For example, we are now moving to become more “asset sensitive” in anticipation of rising rates over the next twelve to eighteen months. We have also maintained adequate liquidity from our acquisition and core deposit growth to fund our loan growth for the near future,” continued Mr. Joyce.

ASSET QUALITY

Provision for Loan Losses was $495 thousand in the first quarter of 2009, compared to $192 thousand in the first quarter of 2008 and $138 thousand for the linked quarter. For the first quarter of 2009, net charge-offs totaled $167 thousand, or 0.15 percent of average loans on an annualized basis, compared to $166 thousand, or 0.17 percent of average loans for the year-ago quarter. Non-performing assets increased to 1.59 percent of assets, versus 1.22 percent for the year-ago quarter and 1.00 percent for year-end. Our reserve for loan losses increased to 1.23 percent of loans, compared to 1.02 percent for the year-ago quarter and 1.12 percent for year-end. The following chart and narrative summarizes the asset quality picture:

 
 

 

(Dollars in thousands except percent data)

ASSET QUALITY
   
1Q 2009
      4Q 2008       1Q 2008  
                         
Net charge-offs
  $ 167     $ 280     $ 166  
                         
Net charge-offs to avg. loans (Annualized)
    0.15 %     0.27 %     0.17 %
                         
Non-performing loans
  $ 9,163     $ 5,178     $ 5,305  
                         
OREO + OAO
  $ 1,426     $ 1,409     $ 1,662  
                         
Non-performing assets (NPA’s)
  $ 10,589     $ 6,587     $ 6,967  
                         
NPA / Total assets
    1.59 %     1.00 %     1.22 %
                         
Allowance for loan losses
  $ 5,349     $ 5,020     $ 4,016  
                         
Allowance for loan losses / Loans
    1.23 %     1.12 %     1.02 %

Non-performing assets (loans + OREO + OAO=NPA) were $10.6 million, or 1.59 percent, of total assets at March 31, 2009, an increase of $3.6 million from a year-ago and $4.00 million from the linked quarter. The acquisition of NBM has increased non-performing assets, adding 28 basis points to our ratio compared to the linked quarter. We have been aggressive in classifying and collecting these problem loans. It will take a year to work these problem loans through the pipeline and either get the borrowers onto a timely payment methodology, or collect the loans through more aggressive action. We also had a $1.8 million loan go ninety days past due and we moved it into non-performing status. We aggressively reserved what we see as the potential loss for this credit during the first quarter, although some recovery on this loan is certainly possible. In addition to the above mentioned non-performers, management was very proactive in reaching out to customers to restructure loans. During the first quarter, approximately $6.8 million in loans were restructured and are currently paying under the new terms.

The economic challenges facing the banking industry are increasing, as evidenced by the number of established customers who are struggling to make their payments. We believe that any resultant losses associated with our identified non-performing assets is covered by our current allowance; however, until there is general improvement in the economy, we will continue to see stress on our loan portfolio. We believe our underwriting and collateral positioning will result in relatively minor losses well covered by our reserve. The Company has very successfully managed through a difficult 2008, but we are not insulated from the economic factors facing the financial industry in 2009, and an economic recovery is critical to our industry, as is true of all industries.

RDSI OPERATING RESULTS

Revenue for the Data and Item Processing Segment was $5.3 million, down $258 thousand, or 4.6 percent, below the $5.6 million reported for first quarter of 2008. A portion of this decrease was due to $150 thousand of one-time, de-conversion fees received in the year-ago quarter. The decline in revenues represents continuing pressure on pricing and declining account volumes among most banks because the banking environment continues to be challenged. Responding to these declines in revenue, RDSI has reacted by decreasing its operating expenses. Operating expenses totaled $4.2 million in the first quarter of 2009, compared to $4.4 in the year-ago quarter, reflecting a $209 thousand, or 4.8 percent, decrease.

 
 

 

Net Income for the first quarter was $768 thousand, compared to $800 thousand for the year-ago first quarter and $715 thousand for the linked quarter. RDSI has been able to maintain its profit margins by the introduction of new products and cost controls during this period of economic shrinkage. “RDSI experienced solid growth in 2008, and we continue to have strong sales, as six bank conversions have been completed, or are scheduled for the remainder of 2009. We also have a strong pipeline of prospects, but this will be a challenging year, as we expect to have offsetting client losses as banks seek to lower their costs and the game of musical chairs is being played. Offsetting our projected new business is the loss of our largest client bank in the fourth quarter of this year. We remain optimistic, in recognition that the current economic conditions will also challenge RDSI; however, we are positioning RDSI for a strong recovery on the other side of this economic downturn,” said Mr. Joyce.

Mr. Joyce concluded, “We believe that our consistent earnings are reflective of our prudent standards and our commitment to high quality lending practices.  We are confident of our position for future growth and we look forward to overcoming any challenges that may present themselves.”

ABOUT RURBAN FINANCIAL CORP.

Rurban Financial Corp. is a publicly-held financial services holding company based in Defiance, Ohio.  Rurban’s wholly-owned subsidiaries are The State Bank and Trust Company, including Reliance Financial Services and RDSI Banking Systems (RDSI), including DCM.  The State Bank and Trust Company offers financial services through its 22 banking centers in Allen, Defiance, Fulton, Lucas, Paulding, Williams and Wood Counties, Ohio and Allen County, Indiana and a Loan Production Office in Franklin County, Ohio.  Reliance Financial Services, a division of the Bank, offers a diversified array of trust and financial services to customers throughout the Midwest.  RDSI and DCM provide data and item processing services to community banks in Arkansas, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Michigan, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, Ohio and Wisconsin.  Rurban’s common stock is quoted on the NASDAQ Global Market under the symbol RBNF.  The Company currently has 10,000,000 shares of stock authorized and 4,870,573 shares outstanding.  The Company's website is http://www.rurbanfinancial.net.

FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS
Certain statements within this document, which are not statements of historical fact, constitute forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995.  Forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties and actual results may differ materially from those predicted by the forward-looking statements.  These risks and uncertainties include, but are not limited to, risks and uncertainties inherent in the national and regional banking, insurance and mortgage industries, competitive factors specific to markets in which Rurban and its subsidiaries operate, future interest rate levels, legislative and regulatory actions, capital market conditions, general economic conditions, geopolitical events, the loss of key personnel and other factors.

Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date on which they are made, and Rurban undertakes no obligation to update any forward-looking statement to reflect events or circumstances after the date on which the statement is made, except as required by law.  All subsequent written and oral forward-looking statements attributable to Rurban or any person acting on our behalf are qualified by these cautionary statements.

 
 

 

RURBAN FINANCIAL CORP.
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS
March 31, 2009 and December 31, 2008 and March 31, 2008

   
March
   
December
   
March
 
   
2009
   
2008
   
2008
 
   
(Unaudited)
         
(Unaudited)
 
ASSETS
                 
Cash and due from banks
  $ 14,814,685     $ 18,059,532     $ 15,758,593  
Federal funds sold
    8,200,000       10,000,000       6,400,000  
Cash and cash equivalents
    23,014,685       28,059,532       22,158,593  
Available-for-sale securities
    127,879,529       102,606,475       94,378,377  
Loans held for sale
    9,095,776       3,824,499       2,464,643  
Loans, net of unearned income
    434,051,854       450,111,653       391,962,691  
Allowance for loan losses
    (5,348,952 )     (5,020,197 )     (4,016,230 )
Premises and equipment, net
    17,159,167       17,621,262       15,180,760  
Purchased software
    5,741,678       5,867,395       4,149,202  
Federal Reserve and Federal Home Loan Bank Stock
    3,544,100       4,244,100       4,062,100  
Foreclosed assets held for sale, net
    1,393,155       1,384,335       1,572,644  
Accrued interest receivable
    2,864,190       2,964,663       2,752,252  
Goodwill
    21,414,790       21,414,790       13,940,618  
Core deposits and other intangibles
    5,614,025       5,835,936       4,961,846  
Cash value of life insurance
    12,734,983       12,625,015       12,276,003  
Other assets
    6,653,626       6,079,451       5,889,849  
                         
Total assets
  $ 665,812,606     $ 657,618,909     $ 571,733,348  
                         
LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY
                       
Deposits
                       
Non interest bearing demand
  $ 49,968,772     $ 52,242,626     $ 41,748,793  
Interest bearing NOW
    77,058,528       73,123,095       59,547,916  
Savings
    37,150,700       34,313,586       24,289,198  
Money Market
    90,318,191       82,025,074       72,676,846  
Time Deposits
    233,137,761       242,516,203       218,449,515  
Total deposits
    487,633,952       484,220,584       416,712,268  
Notes payable
    2,500,000       1,000,000       817,584  
Advances from Federal Home Loan Bank
    36,059,017       36,646,854       23,000,000  
Repurchase Agreements
    47,894,843       43,425,978       43,536,570  
Trust preferred securities
    20,620,000       20,620,000       20,620,000  
Accrued interest payable
    1,724,525       1,965,842       2,481,629  
Other liabilities
    5,759,759       8,077,647       4,694,986  
                         
Total liabilities
    602,192,096       595,956,905       511,863,037  
                         
Shareholders' Equity
                       
Common stock
    12,568,583       12,568,583       12,568,583  
Additional paid-in capital
    15,072,847       15,042,781       14,944,315  
Retained earnings
    36,449,912       35,785,317       32,956,244  
Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss)
    1,222,435       (121,657 )     432,429  
Treasury stock
    (1,693,267 )     (1,613,020 )     (1,031,260 )
                         
Total shareholders' equity
    63,620,510       61,662,004       59,870,311  
                         
Total liabilities and shareholders' equity
  $ 665,812,606     $ 657,618,909     $ 571,733,348  
 
 
 

 

RURBAN FINANCIAL CORP.
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME - UNAUDITED

   
First Quarter
   
First Quarter
 
   
2009
   
2008
 
Interest income
           
Loans
           
  Taxable
  $ 6,814,633     $ 6,808,196  
  Tax-exempt
    25,457       21,350  
Securities
               
  Taxable
    1,079,497       1,039,894  
  Tax-exempt
    227,884       158,367  
Other
    132       97,409  
Total interest income
    8,147,603       8,125,216  
                 
Interest expense
               
Deposits
    1,898,304       3,091,902  
Other borrowings
    14,392       17,506  
Retail Repurchase Agreements
    427,487       460,552  
Federal Home Loan Bank advances
    392,572       302,336  
Trust preferred securities
    398,985       435,704  
Total interest expense
    3,131,740       4,308,000  
                 
Net interest income
    5,015,863       3,817,216  
                 
Provision for loan losses
    495,142       192,218  
                 
Net interest income after provision
               
  for loan losses
    4,520,721       3,624,998  
                 
Non-interest income
               
Data service fees
    4,972,549       5,264,565  
Trust fees
    583,623       855,107  
Customer service fees
    574,699       586,207  
Net gain on sales of loans
    1,078,047       274,603  
Net realized gain on sales of securities
    53,807       -  
Net proceeds from VISA IPO
    -       132,106  
Investment securities recoveries
    -       197,487  
Loan servicing fees
    67,873       62,940  
Gain (loss) on sale of assets
    (58,655 )     (71,032 )
Other income
    175,562       213,530  
Total non-interest income
    7,447,505       7,515,513  
                 
Non-interest expense
               
Salaries and employee benefits
    4,924,122       4,438,764  
Net occupancy expense
    672,401       566,016  
Equipment expense
    1,613,393       1,567,637  
Data processing fees
    135,736       96,567  
Professional fees
    498,055       570,687  
Marketing expense
    188,746       181,747  
Printing and office supplies
    214,542       186,052  
Telephone and communication
    406,393       421,929  
Postage and delivery expense
    609,022       602,634  
State, local and other taxes
    232,896       180,768  
Employee expense
    259,938       230,611  
Other expenses
    719,780       557,948  
Total non-interest expense
    10,475,024       9,601,360  
                 
Income before income tax expense
    1,493,202       1,539,151  
Income tax expense
    389,649       429,795  
                 
Net income
  $ 1,103,553     $ 1,109,356  
                 
Earnings per common share:
               
Basic
  $ 0.23     $ 0.22  
Diluted
  $ 0.23     $ 0.22  
 
 
 

 

RURBAN FINANCIAL CORP.
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS
(Unaudited)
 
   
1st Qtr
   
4th Qtr
   
3rd Qtr
   
2nd Qtr
   
1st Qtr
 
(dollars in thousands except per share data)
 
2009
   
2008
   
2008
   
2008
   
2008
 
                               
EARNINGS
                             
Net interest income
  $ 5,016     $ 4,830     $ 4,448     $ 4,432     $ 3,817  
Provision for loan loss
  $ 495     $ 138     $ 146     $ 213     $ 192  
Non-interest income
  $ 7,448     $ 6,755     $ 6,989     $ 6,801     $ 7,516  
Revenue (net interest income plus non-interest income)
  $ 12,464     $ 11,585     $ 11,437     $ 11,233     $ 11,333  
Non-interest expense
  $ 10,475     $ 9,566     $ 9,279     $ 9,111     $ 9,601  
Net income
  $ 1,104     $ 1,328     $ 1,424     $ 1,356     $ 1,109  
                                         
PER SHARE DATA
                                       
Basic earnings per share
  $ 0.23     $ 0.27     $ 0.29     $ 0.28     $ 0.22  
Diluted earnings per share
  $ 0.23     $ 0.27     $ 0.29     $ 0.28     $ 0.22  
Book value per share
  $ 13.06     $ 12.63     $ 12.25     $ 12.08     $ 12.11  
Tangible book value per share
  $ 7.24     $ 7.06     $ 8.65     $ 8.41     $ 8.10  
Cash dividend per share
  $ 0.09     $ 0.09     $ 0.09     $ 0.08     $ 0.08  
                                         
PERFORMANCE RATIOS
                                       
Return on average assets
    0.66 %     0.88 %     0.99 %     0.94 %     0.78 %
Return on average equity
    7.04 %     8.75 %     9.54 %     9.09 %     7.50 %
Net interest margin (tax equivalent)
    3.67 %     3.83 %     3.56 %     3.55 %     3.26 %
Net interest margin (Bank Only)
    3.93 %     4.06 %     3.84 %     3.83 %     3.45 %
Non-interest expense / Average assets
    6.29 %     6.31 %     6.44 %     6.29 %     6.77 %
Efficiency Ratio - bank (non-GAAP)
    77.41 %     73.15 %     71.13 %     69.85 %     75.90 %
                                         
MARKET DATA PER SHARE
                                       
Market value per share -- Period end
  $ 7.90     $ 7.60     $ 9.00     $ 9.52     $ 10.24  
Market as a % of book
    60 %     60 %     73 %     79 %     85 %
Cash dividend yield
    4.56 %     4.74 %     4.00 %     3.36 %     3.13 %
Period-end common shares outstanding (000)
    4,871       4,881       4,906       4,914       4,942  
Common stock market capitalization ($000)
  $ 38,484     $ 37,099     $ 44,154     $ 46,781     $ 50,605  
                                         
CAPITAL & LIQUIDITY
                                       
Equity to assets
    9.6 %     9.4 %     10.3 %     10.3 %     10.5 %
Period-end tangible equity to tangible assets
    5.5 %     6.6 %     7.5 %     7.4 %     7.2 %
Total risk-based capital ratio (Estimate)
    13.5 %     14.2 %     16.2 %     15.7 %     15.8 %
                                         
ASSET QUALITY
                                       
Net charge-offs / (Recoveries)
  $ 167     $ 280     $ 336     $ (18 )   $ 166  
Net loan charge-offs (Ann.) / Average loans
    0.15 %     0.27 %     0.33 %     (0.02 )%     0.17 %
Non-performing loans
  $ 9,163     $ 5,178     $ 4,659     $ 5,141     $ 5,305  
OREO / OAOs
  $ 1,426     $ 1,409     $ 1,611     $ 1,566     $ 1,662  
Non-performing assets
  $ 10,589     $ 6,587     $ 6,270     $ 6,707     $ 6,967  
Non-performing assets / Total assets
    1.59 %     1.00 %     1.07 %     1.16 %     1.22 %
Allowance for loan losses / Total loans
    1.23 %     1.12 %     1.01 %     1.04 %     1.02 %
Allowance for loan losses / Non-performing Assets
    50.5 %     76.2 %     64.7 %     63.3 %     57.6 %
                                         
END OF PERIOD BALANCES
                                       
Total loans, net of unearned income
  $ 434,052     $ 450,112     $ 399,910     $ 404,435     $ 391,963  
Allowance for loan loss
  $ 5,349     $ 5,020     $ 4,057     $ 4,247     $ 4,016  
Total assets
  $ 665,813     $ 657,619     $ 585,022     $ 576,513     $ 571,733  
Deposits
  $ 487,634     $ 484,221     $ 406,454     $ 402,558     $ 416,712  
Stockholders' equity
  $ 63,621     $ 61,662     $ 60,117     $ 59,362     $ 59,870  
Full-time equivalent employees
    306       306       271       273       272  
                                         
AVERAGE BALANCES
                                       
Loans
  $ 448,271     $ 412,222     $ 401,790     $ 404,756     $ 389,917  
Total earning assets
  $ 561,566     $ 518,707     $ 506,760     $ 510,521     $ 498,731  
Total assets
  $ 666,292     $ 606,655     $ 576,774     $ 579,004     $ 567,129  
Deposits
  $ 490,526     $ 431,076     $ 403,064     $ 412,080     $ 412,424  
Stockholders' equity
  $ 62,692     $ 60,686     $ 59,717     $ 59,671     $ 59,149  

 
 

 

Rurban Financial Corp.
Segment Reporting
First Quarter Ended March 31, 2009
($ in Thousands)
 
Income Statement Measures
 
Total
Banking
   
Data
Processing
   
Parent
Company
and Other
   
Elimination
Entries
   
Rurban
Financial
Corp.
 
Interest Income
  $ 8,159     $ -     $ -     $ (11 )   $ 8,148  
                                         
Interest Expense
    2,719       25       399       (11 )   $ 3,132  
                                         
Net Interest Income
    5,440       (25 )     (399 )     -     $ 5,016  
                                         
Provision For Loan Loss
    495       -       -             $ 495  
                                         
Non-interest Income
    2,502       5,373       400       (827 )   $ 7,448  
                                         
Non-interest Expense
    6,309       4,185       808       (827 )   $ 10,475  
                                         
Net Income QTD
  $ 863     $ 768     $ (527 )   $ -     $ 1,104  
                                         
Performance Measures
                                       
Average  Assets -QTD
  $ 645,365     $ 20,256     $ 85,313     $ (84,642 )   $ 666,292  
                                         
ROAA
    0.53 %     15.17 %     -       -       0.66 %
                                         
Average Equity - QTD
  $ 66,532     $ 14,529     $ 62,692     $ (81,061 )   $ 62,692  
                                         
ROAE
    5.19 %     21.14 %     -       -       7.04 %
                                         
Efficiency Ratio - %
    77.41 %     -       -       -       82.42 %
                                         
Average Loans - QTD
  $ 449,426     $ -     $ -     $ (1,155 )   $ 448,271  
                                         
Average Deposits - QTD
  $ 492,951     $ -     $ -     $ (2,425 )   $ 490,526  
 
 
 

 

Rurban Financial Corp.
Proforma Performance Measurement
Quarterly Comparison - First Quarter 2009
($ in Thousands)

   
Total Banking
   
Data Processing
   
Parent Company
and Other
   
Elimination
Entries
   
Rurban Financial
Corp.
 
Revenue
                             
1Q09
  $ 7,942     $ 5,348     $ 1     $ (827 )   $ 12,464  
4Q08
  $ 7,007     $ 5,381     $ (18 )   $ (785 )   $ 11,585  
3Q08
  $ 6,877     $ 5,294     $ 5     $ (738 )   $ 11,438  
2Q08
  $ 6,729     $ 5,285     $ (15 )   $ (766 )   $ 11,233  
1Q08
  $ 6,464     $ 5,606     $ (27 )   $ (710 )   $ 11,333  
1st Quarter Comparison
  $ 1,478     $ (258 )   $ 28     $ -     $ 1,131  
                                         
Non-interest Expenses
                                       
1Q09
  $ 6,309     $ 4,185     $ 808     $ (827 )   $ 10,475  
4Q08
  $ 5,254     $ 4,299     $ 798     $ (785 )   $ 9,566  
3Q08
  $ 5,003     $ 4,286     $ 728     $ (738 )   $ 9,279  
2Q08
  $ 4,812     $ 4,316     $ 748     $ (766 )   $ 9,110  
1Q08
  $ 5,018     $ 4,394     $ 899     $ (710 )   $ 9,601  
1st Quarter Comparison
  $ 1,240     $ (209 )   $ (63 )   $ -     $ 851  
                                         
Net Income
                                       
1Q09
  $ 863     $ 768     $ (527 )   $ -     $ 1,104  
4Q08
  $ 1,146     $ 715     $ (533 )   $ -     $ 1,328  
3Q08
  $ 1,233     $ 664     $ (473 )   $ -     $ 1,424  
2Q08
  $ 1,217     $ 640     $ (501 )   $ -     $ 1,356  
1Q08
  $ 917     $ 800     $ (608 )   $ -     $ 1,109  
1st Quarter Comparison
  $ (54 )   $ (32 )   $ 81     $ -     $ (5 )
                                         
Average Assets
                                       
1Q09
  $ 645,365     $ 20,256     $ 85,313     $ (84,642 )   $ 666,292  
4Q08
  $ 596,469     $ 19,804     $ 82,775     $ (92,393 )   $ 606,655  
3Q08
  $ 557,306     $ 20,344     $ 81,707     $ (82,583 )   $ 576,774  
2Q08
  $ 560,223     $ 20,214     $ 81,579     $ (83,011 )   $ 579,004  
1Q08
  $ 547,502     $ 20,103     $ 81,297     $ (81,773 )   $ 567,129  
1st Quarter Comparison
  $ 97,863     $ 153     $ 4,016     $ -     $ 99,163  
                                         
ROAA
                                       
1Q09
    0.53 %     15.17 %     -       -       0.66 %
4Q08
    0.77 %     14.44 %     -       -       0.88 %
3Q08
    0.88 %     13.06 %     -       -       0.99 %
2Q08
    0.87 %     12.66 %     -       -       0.94 %
1Q08
    0.67 %     15.92 %     -       -       0.78 %
1st Quarter Comparison
    (0.14 )%     (0.75 )%     -       -       (0.12 )%
                                         
Average Equity
                                       
1Q09
  $ 66,532     $ 14,529     $ 62,692     $ (81,061 )   $ 62,692  
4Q08
  $ 63,224     $ 15,816     $ 60,686     $ (79,040 )   $ 60,686  
3Q08
  $ 59,899     $ 16,063     $ 59,717     $ (75,962 )   $ 59,717  
2Q08
  $ 59,395     $ 15,861     $ 59,671     $ (75,256 )   $ 59,671  
1Q08
  $ 59,044     $ 15,282     $ 59,149     $ (74,326 )   $ 59,149  
1st Quarter Comparison
  $ 7,488     $ (753 )   $ 3,543     $ -     $ 3,543  
                                         
ROAE
                                       
1Q09
    5.19 %     21.14 %     -       -       7.04 %
4Q08
    7.25 %     18.08 %     -       -       8.75 %
3Q08
    8.23 %     16.53 %     -       -       9.54 %
2Q08
    8.20 %     16.14 %     -       -       9.09 %
1Q08
    6.21 %     20.94 %     -       -       7.50 %
1st Quarter Comparison
    (1.02 )%     0.20 %     -       -       (0.46 )%
                                         
Efficiency Ratio
                                       
1Q09
    77.41 %     77.48 %     -       -       82.24 %
4Q08
    73.15 %     73.15 %     -       -       80.92 %
3Q08
    71.13 %     79.79 %     -       -       79.60 %
2Q08
    69.85 %     80.50 %     -       -       79.56 %
1Q08
    75.90 %     77.28 %     -       -       83.19 %
1st Quarter Comparison
    1.51 %     0.20 %     -       -       (0.95 )%