XML 32 R19.htm IDEA: XBRL DOCUMENT v3.8.0.1
Note 12 - Share-based Compensation
12 Months Ended
Sep. 30, 2017
Notes to Financial Statements  
Disclosure of Compensation Related Costs, Share-based Payments [Text Block]
1
2
. SHARE-BASED COMPENSATION
 
Stock Option Plans
 
At
September 30,
201
7,
the Company had
two
equity incentive plans. The
2005
Equity Incentive Plan (
“2005
Equity Plan”) was terminated with respect to new grants in
March 2015,
but remains in effect for grants issued prior to that time. The Amended and Restated
2015
Equity Incentive Plan (
“2015
Equity Plan”) was approved by the Company’s Board of Directors on
December 6, 2016
and by the Company’s stockholders on
March 14, 2017.
The amendment to the Equity Incentive Plan was approved in
2015
authorizes for issuance as stock options, restricted stock, stock appreciation rights, restricted stock units and performance awards, an aggregate of
5,000,000
new shares of common stock to employees, directors, advisors or consultants. At
September 30, 2017,
there were options outstanding covering
2,377,502
and
2,411,000
shares of common stock under the
2005
Equity Plan and
2015
Equity Plan, respectively, and
2,330,667
shares of common stock available for grant for a total of
7,119,169
currently available under the
two
equity plans.
 
Share-Based Compensation
 
The Company
’s employee stock options have various restrictions that reduce option value, including vesting provisions and restrictions on transfer and hedging, among others, and are often exercised prior to their contractual maturity.
 
The Company recorded
$1,116,400
and
$605,426
of stock compensation expense for the years ended
September 
30,
2017
and
2016,
respectively. The weighted average estimated fair value of employee stock options granted during the year ended
September 
30,
2017
and
2016
was calculated using the Black-Scholes option-pricing model with the following weighted average assumptions (annualized percentages):
 
   
2017
   
2016
 
Volatility
   
42.6%
-
53.7%
     
49.0%
-
52.0%
 
Risk-free interest rate
   
1.73%
-
2.01%
     
1.0%
-
1.7%
 
Forfeiture rate
   
 
10.0%
 
     
 
10.0%
 
 
Dividend yield
   
 
0.0%
 
     
2.2%
-
2.7%
 
Expected life in years
   
3.8
-
4.6
     
3.2
-
4.6
 
Weighted average fair value of options granted during the period
   
 
$0.71
 
     
 
$0.70
 
 
 
The Company
did
not
pay a dividend in fiscal
2017
but did pay a dividend during the year ended
September 30, 2016.
Expected volatility is based on the historical volatility of the Company’s common stock over the period commensurate with the expected life of the options. The risk-free interest rate is based on rates published by the Federal Reserve Board. The contractual term of the options was
seven
years. The expected life is based on observed and expected time to post-vesting exercise. The expected forfeiture rate is based on past experience and employee retention data. Forfeitures are estimated at the time of the grant and revised in subsequent periods if actual forfeitures differ from those estimates. Such revision adjustments to expense will be recorded as a cumulative adjustment in the period in which the estimate is changed.
 
As of
September
 
30,
2017,
there was approximately
$683,000
of total unrecognized compensation costs related to outstanding employee stock options. This amount is expected to be recognized over a weighted average period of
2.2
years. To the extent the forfeiture rate is different from what the Company anticipated, stock-based compensation related to these awards will be different from the Company’s expectations.
 
Performance-Based Stock Options
 
On
August 1, 2016,
the
Company awarded a performance-based stock option (PVO) to purchase
750,000
shares of the Company’s common stock to a key executive, with a contractual term of
seven
years. Vesting is based upon the achievement of certain performance criteria for each of fiscal
2019
and
2020
(
375,000
shares for each year) including a minimum Free Cash Flow margin and Net Revenue targets at
four
different target levels for each of the years.
Additionally, vesting is subject to the executive being employed by the Company at the time the Company achieves such financial targets.
 
The Company determined that it is probable that the performance condition will be achieved at the low end of the expected revenue level for each of the years
, and therefore assumed that
187,500
shares of the PVO would vest. The weighted average grant date fair value for the PVO was
$0.81
per share, which was estimated on the date of grant using the Black-Scholes option pricing model. Non-cash share-based compensation expense related to this award is recognized on a straight line basis and was
$42,363
and
$4,774
for the years ended
September 30, 2017
and
2016
respectively. The Company will continue to review these targets each quarter and will adjust the expected outcome as needed, recognizing compensation expense cumulatively in such period for the difference in expense. The Company did
not
grant any PVOs in the year ended
September 30, 2017.
 
Restricted
Stock
Units
 
In
the quarter ended
December 31, 2016,
the Board of Directors approved an amendment to the Company’s compensation program for non-employee directors that provides for the grant of
25,000
restricted stock units (“RSUs”) to each of the Company’s non-employee directors at each annual meeting of the Company’s stockholders, subject to stockholder approval of the
Amended and Restated
2015
Equity Incentive Plan at the
2017
Annual Meeting of Stockholders. These RSUs were granted as replacements for
20,000
stock options that would have been granted on the date of the
2016
Annual Meeting of Stockholders and would have vested on the
first
anniversary of the
2016
Annual Meeting of Stockholders, which was
May 17, 2017.
As a result of the stockholders approval of the Amended and Restated
2015
Equity Incentive Plan at the
2017
Annual Meeting of Stockholders on
March 14, 2017,
the RSUs previously granted were made effective at a market value of
$197,500
and were expensed on a straight line basis through the
May 17, 2017
vest date.
 
O
n
March 14, 2017,
non-employee directors of the Company received
25,000
RSUs that will vest on the
first
anniversary of the grant date. These were also issued at a market value of
$197,500,
which will be expensed on a straight line basis through the
March 14, 2018
vest date.
 
A summary of activity of the Company
’s restricted stock plan as of
September 30, 2017
and
2016
is presented below:
 
   
Number
 
   
of Shares
 
Balance, September 30, 2016
   
-
 
Granted
   
250,000
 
Released
   
(125,000
)
Forfeited/cancelled
   
-
 
Balance, September 30, 2017
   
125,000
 
 
Stock Option Summary Information
 
A summary of activity for the Company
’s stock option plans as of
September 
30,
2017
and
2016
is presented below:
 
 
   
Number
   
Weighted Average
 
   
of Shares
   
Exercise Price
 
Outstanding October 1, 2016
   
4,404,002
    $
2.18
 
Granted
   
574,500
    $
2.09
 
Forfeited/expired
   
(81,667
)   $
2.51
 
Exercised
   
(233,333
)   $
1.60
 
Outstanding September 30, 2017
   
4,663,502
    $
2.16
 
Exercisable September 30, 2017
   
3,329,437
    $
2.25
 
 
The aggregate intrinsic value for options outstanding and options exercisable at
September
 
30,
2017
was
$869,955
and
$673,225,
respectively. The aggregate intrinsic value represents the difference between the Company’s closing stock price on the last day of trading during the year, which was
$2.13
per share, and the exercise price multiplied by the number of applicable options. The total intrinsic value of stock options exercised during the year ended
September 30, 2017
was
$72,709
and proceeds from these exercises was
$373,228.
The total intrinsic value of stock options exercised during the year ended
September 30, 2016
was
$288
and cash received from these exercises was
$2,200.
The Company recognized
$72,709
and
$288
as a tax benefit in the income tax provision for the years ended
September 30, 2017
and
2016,
respectively.
 
The following table summarizes information about stock options outstanding at
September
 
30,
2017:
 
               
Weighted
                         
               
Average
   
Weighted
           
Weighted
 
Range of
         
Remaining
   
Average
           
Average
 
Exercise
 
Number
   
Contractual
   
Exercise
   
Number
   
Exercise
 
Prices
 
Outstanding
   
Life
   
Price
   
Exercisable
   
Price
 
$0.93
-
$1.76
   
1,332,752
     
4.35
    $
1.65
     
1,036,036
    $
1.63
 
$1.77
-
$1.99
   
1,654,500
     
4.63
    $
1.93
     
626,526
    $
1.89
 
$2.00
-
$2.85
   
905,000
     
2.31
    $
2.57
     
902,500
    $
2.57
 
$2.86
-
$3.13
   
761,250
     
1.29
    $
3.00
     
757,500
    $
3.00
 
$3.14
-
$3.17
   
10,000
     
4.14
    $
3.17
     
6,875
    $
3.17
 
$0.93
-
$3.17
   
4,663,502
     
3.41
    $
2.18
     
3,329,437
    $
2.25
 
 
 
The Company recorded non-cash share-based compensation expense for employees, directors and consultants for
the fiscal years ended
September 
30,
2017
and
2016.
The amounts of share-based compensation expense are classified in the Consolidated Statements of Operations as follows:
 
Years Ended September 30,
 
2017
   
2016
 
Cost of revenues
  $
24,151
    $
24,092
 
Selling, general and administrative
   
998,540
     
478,695
 
Research and development
   
93,709
     
102,639
 
Total
  $
1,116,400
    $
605,426