
7.2.6.9 Contingent assets
and liabilities
a) Wetteren (Belgium)
In the production plant of Wetteren (Belgium) a historic
asbestos pollution was found in the course of 2021. In 2022
the soil investigations and provisional remediation plans
have been concluded. The total provision amounts to
EUR 1.0 million at the end of 2023. This site has been
transferred with the legal entity Recticel Engineered Foams
Belgium BV to the Carpenter Group on 12 June 2023.
A further small part of the site, leased out to Ascorium
Belgium NV, will be transferred shortly to Carpenter as well.
The clean-up responsibility remains partly with Recticel
and will partly transfer to Carpenter.
b) Litigations
The Group has been the subject of an antitrust
investigation at European level. Recticel announced on
29 January 2014 that a settlement was reached with
the European Commission in the polyurethane foam
investigation. The case was closed after payment of the
last instalment of the effective overall fine in April 2016.
Various claims have been issued by one or more
customers, in which these entities allege harm with regard
to the conduct covered by the European Commission’s
cartel decision. Only one court procedure is still ongoing in
Germany linked to the former Eurofoam joint venture. No
additional new claims can be launched as these have all
become time-barred. Recticel has carefully reviewed and
evaluated the merits for this case with its legal advisors
to determine the appropriate defensive strategy and has
recognised, where appropriate, a provision to cover any
legal costs.
Regarding the ongoing litigation no considered judgment
can at this stage be formed on the outcome of this
procedure or on the amount of any potential loss for the
company.
One of our Group entities in the United Kingdom
was the subject of a HSE investigation following the
accidental death of one of its employees in 2015. After
a very fact-finding phase, the HSE had initially made
certain allegations against Recticel Ltd for breach of HSE
regulations. Recticel has replied to these allegations. In
October 2021, the HSE had confirmed that it had taken
an enforcement decision. At the end of 2022, the HSE
indicated that it would no longer take enforcement
actions against the company in absence of evidence. The
provision that was established for this case has hence
been taken back. The procedure itself has still not been
terminated for administrative reasons.
One of the former Group’s entities in France is implicated
in a labour law case following the closure of a production
site, whereby the former employees have launched a
claim to obtain additional compensations, on the basis
that the economic reasons for the closure were invalid.
The court proceedings have so far confirmed the position
of the employees, with one procedure ongoing. A provision
has been established to cover the potential negative
outcome. The respective entity has been transferred
to Carpenter on 12 June 2023, but the risk on this issue
remains with Recticel and remains provisioned.
Following the fire incident in Most (Czech Republic), the
involved Group entity has been temporarily unable to
supply the contractually agreed quantities of products,
leading to production interruptions at the direct customers
and the car manufacturers. While the Group entity
involved have claimed Force Majeure in this respect, this
has been put in question or even contested by a number
of customers, with indication that further claims could be
raised to obtain damage compensation. While the Group
is insured in this regard in line with industrial standards,
it cannot be excluded that such claims could lead to
financial losses for the companies involved. One customer
has launched a legal proceeding in France in the course
of the first semester of 2019 and this procedure continues
and is expected to be concluded only by the end of 2024
or early 2025.
Recticel signed a preliminary purchase agreement with
the Gór-Stal shareholders to acquire Gór-Stal’s insulation
board business located in Bochnia, Poland, for an
enterprise value of EUR 30 million. The sale required a prior
carve-out of these activities into a new legal entity. Both
parties cooperated well to finalise the due diligence and
to realise this carve-out by July 2021, but then, the sellers
came back to request a price adjustment, citing changed
market conditions. Recticel requested more information
before considering such a request, which was contrary
to the agreement. The sellers did not provide such
information and in October 2021, they informed Recticel
that they did no longer want to continue the transaction.
Recticel notified the sellers at the end of the year that they
breached their obligations under the agreement and that
Recticel would launch legal proceedings to enforce the
preliminary agreement or obtain damage compensation.
These legal proceedings were launched in 2022 and
continue to this date, with no conclusion expected before
2025.
During the year 2023, a number of claims were received by
our French Insulation entity concerning quality issues with
regard to insulation boards produced in 2018-2019 linked
to a shift in formulation at the time. Also in 2019, certain
claims had been received and were solved at the time.
While the Group is insured for product liability in this regard
in line with industrial standards, it cannot be excluded that
such claims could lead to financial losses for the Group.
As of 31 December 2023, total overall provisions and
accruals for other litigations, environmental risk and other
risks on Recticel Group level amounted to EUR 29.9 million
in the consolidated financial statements. With reference to
the prejudicial exemption in IAS 37 §92, the Group will not
disclose any further information about the assumptions
for the provision, including any details about current and
the expected number of lawsuits and claims.
The disclosure of such information is believed to be
detrimental to the Group in connection with the ongoing
confidential negotiations and could inflict financial losses
on Recticel and its shareholders.
Recticel Group - 2023 Annual Report 229
Introduction
About Recticel
Group
Our commitment
to sustainability
Our value
creation model
Business
performance
Risk and
opportunity
Sustainability
report
Financial
report
Appendix