Strategic report
Annual Report and Financial Statements 2024
12
Some companies didn’t fare as well. Kering, the parent
of luxury brands like Gucci and Saint Laurent, suffered
from weaker Chinese demand which affected most of
its peers to varying degrees. This downturn has been
especially tough as Gucci’s extraordinary growth of
recent years came to an end and those who led it left
the business. We think the turnaround will take longer
than expected so we sold our position.
HelloFresh, which we noted as another sale in the
interim report, also provided a drag to performance.
Its core meal kit business appeared to be more
mature than expected and we were not convinced
on the attractions of its new ready-to-eat business.
Soitec, a manufacturer of engineered substrates or
wafers for semiconductors used in mobile phones,
cars and connected devices, didn’t perform like
many other semiconductor companies. It is still
dealing with excess inventories at its customers so
is yet to see orders rebound. We believe this is just
a matter of time, and with almost all its customers
now making positive comments, we’ve been
adding to our position during this period of share
priceweakness.
Private companies
At the end of the financial year, our five private
companies accounted for around 5.7% of total
investments. We are very pleased with the
operational progress at three of them.
Bending Spoons, the Italian software company
which owns mobile digital applications like Evernote,
Splice, and Meetup, continues to both improve the
growth and profitability of the apps it owns, and
acquire new apps at attractive prices.
sennder, the digital freight-forwarder, recently
acquired CH Robinson’s European ground
transportation business, effectively doubling its
revenue and accelerating its path to profitability.
Flix, the global travel-tech business which manages
bus operations like FlixBus and Greyhound, also
continues to grow profitably. It had been exploring a
summer IPO but decided to remain private and team
up with a consortium of investors including EQT, the
listed Swedish private equity business which we also
own directly, which acquired a significant stake. We
think this structure increases the probability of an
excellent long-term outcome even if it deprives us of
the opportunity for external validation in the nearterm.
Our other two private companies – Northvolt and
McMakler – have faced highly contrasting fortunes.
We have been forced to take significant write-
downs in both investments. McMakler, the German
real-estate broker, has, much like Hypoport, been
operating against a tough economic backdrop in
Germany. That the entire investment was written
off reflects the precarious position the company
found itself in and the conservative approach
we take to valuation. Helped by our relationship
with the company, we were able to support its
recapitalisation and give it the cash runway to see it
through to better times. This was done on extremely
favourable terms, and if business continues to
improve as it has for Hypoport, we would expect the
value of our new investment to risematerially.
Northvolt, the Swedish battery company, is a
much bigger and higher profile company. While
confidentiality agreements limit what we can
disclose about all our private companies, there have
been numerous newspaper articles reporting on
Northvolt’s recent troubles. Operational progress
is not where it should be, and its customers are
increasingly facing Chinese competition. The
scaling back of European subsidies has also
resulted in weaker demand, making fundraising
for any business involved with electric battery
production much more difficult. Northvolt’s ambition
is admirable, but while it remains of strategic
importance to Europe, there are still significant
challenges to overcome. It also seems clear now
that this ambition caused them to overreach. The
company has been forced to reduce the size of
its workforce by around 20% and focus almost
exclusively on the first phase of its Swedish
gigafactory. This will have a significant impact on
Northvolt’s output by the end of the decade, and its
ability to generate cash. Given these difficulties, it
was decided to make a substantial write-down on
the value of our investment. Since the end of our
financial year however, Northvolt has continued to
face liquidity problems and has filed for Chapter 11
reorganisation. It’s CEO, Peter Carlsson, has also
resigned. While companies can often emerge from
this process in a much stronger position, we have
decided to write this investment down to zero. From
such a promising start, this has been incredibly
frustrating and disappointing for us as managers,
our fellow shareholders, and for Europe.
With two of our five private company investments in
distress, it is fair to ask whether we ought to stick to
public markets. We have tended to be selective in our
private company investments, but always cognisant
that over time, some would produce great returns, and
some would not. Fundamentally, we believe strongly
that this is an area where we can offer something
quite unique with the potential for worthwhile and
asymmetric payoffs. If anything, our long-termism and
privileged access to companies, mean that we should
have an even stronger advantage in private markets.