213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31iso4217:GEL213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31iso4217:GELxbrli:shares213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31ifrs-full:AdditionalPaidinCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31ifrs-full:OtherReservesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31ifrs-full:CapitalRedemptionReserveMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31ifrs-full:EquityAttributableToOwnersOfParentMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31ifrs-full:NoncontrollingInterestsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532020-12-31213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31ifrs-full:AdditionalPaidinCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31ifrs-full:OtherReservesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31ifrs-full:CapitalRedemptionReserveMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31ifrs-full:EquityAttributableToOwnersOfParentMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-01-012021-12-31ifrs-full:NoncontrollingInterestsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31ifrs-full:AdditionalPaidinCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31ifrs-full:OtherReservesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31ifrs-full:CapitalRedemptionReserveMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31ifrs-full:EquityAttributableToOwnersOfParentMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532021-12-31ifrs-full:NoncontrollingInterestsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:AdditionalPaidinCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:OtherReservesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:CapitalRedemptionReserveMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:EquityAttributableToOwnersOfParentMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-01-012022-12-31ifrs-full:NoncontrollingInterestsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31ifrs-full:AdditionalPaidinCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31ifrs-full:OtherReservesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31ifrs-full:CapitalRedemptionReserveMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31ifrs-full:EquityAttributableToOwnersOfParentMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532022-12-31ifrs-full:NoncontrollingInterestsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:AdditionalPaidinCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:OtherReservesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:CapitalRedemptionReserveMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:EquityAttributableToOwnersOfParentMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-01-012023-12-31ifrs-full:NoncontrollingInterestsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31ifrs-full:IssuedCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31ifrs-full:AdditionalPaidinCapitalMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31ifrs-full:TreasurySharesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31ifrs-full:OtherReservesMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31ifrs-full:CapitalRedemptionReserveMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31ifrs-full:RetainedEarningsMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31ifrs-full:EquityAttributableToOwnersOfParentMember213800XKDG12NQG8VC532023-12-31ifrs-full:NoncontrollingInterestsMember
BANK OF GEORGIA GROUP PLC Annual Report 2023
1
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
2023
2
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
About us
Helping people achieve
more of their potential
Bank of Georgia Group PLC is a FTSE 250 holding
company whose subsidiaries provide banking
and financial services focused in the high-growth
Georgian and Armenian markets through leading,
customer-centric, universal banks – Bank of
Georgia in Georgia and Ameriabank in Armenia.
By building on our competitive strengths, we are
committed to driving business growth, sustaining
high profitability, and generating strong returns,
while creating opportunities for our stakeholders
and making a positive contribution in the
communities where we operate.
As at 31 December 2023, the main operating subsidiary of Bank of Georgia Group PLC was JSC Bank of Georgia (constituting 95.3% of the Group’s total assets). The Group also
included other smaller subsidiaries, including Belarusky Narodny Bank, a banking subsidiary in Belarus.
3
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Contents
Governance
184-253
Governance at a Glance 185
Board Independence 187
Directors’ Governance Statement 188
Board of Directors 198
Management Team 201
Nomination Committee Report 206
Audit Committee Report 214
Risk Committee Report 224
Directors’ Remuneration Report 229
Statement of Directors’ Responsibilities 248
Directors’ Report 249
Financial
Statements
254-362
Independent Auditor’s Report 255
Consolidated Statement of Financial Position 263
Consolidated Income Statement 264
Consolidated Statement of Comprehensive Income 265
Consolidated Statement of Changes in Equity 266
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows 267
Separate Statement of Financial Position 268
Separate Statement of Changes in Equity 269
Separate Statement of Cash Flows 270
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements 271
Additional
Information
363-371
GRI Index 364
References 368
Glossary 369
Shareholder Information 371
Strategic Report
1-183
Overview
History 5
Track record of strong
performance since demerger 6
Track record of capital distribution 7
Financial highlights 8
Strategic and ESG highlights 8
Georgia in key figures 9
Acquisition of Ameriabank CJSC 13
Chairman’s statement 15
Chief Executive Officer’s statement 16
Strategy and Performance
Our purpose and strategy framework 18
Key performance indicators 21
Addressing financial and
lifestyle needs of our customers 25
Fulfilling business customer needs 40
Digital Area snapshot 50
Section 172(1) statement 52
Sustainable Business
Empowering people by
creating sustainable opportunities 61
Governance and integrity 66
Financial inclusion 86
Sustainable finance 92
TCFD 99
Empowering employees 119
Empowering communities 133
Non-financial and sustainability
information statement 141
Risk Management
Risk management 144
Principal risks and uncertainties 150
Going Concern and
Viability Statements
Going concern 170
Viability statement 170
Overview of
Financial Results
Overview of financial results 172
4
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
OVERVIEW
5
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
History
Before IPO
Listing on LSE
After demerger
BGEO demerges into
two separately listed
and independently
managed public
companies – Bank of
Georgia Group PLC, the
banking business, and
Georgia Capital PLC,
the investment business
Bank of Georgia Group PLC
has a new management
and develops a new
strategy – focused on
accelerating digitalisation
and embedding customer-
centricity across the
business
The Group successfully
recovers from the pandemic
Bank of Georgia launches
PLUS card – the first debit
card project with American
Express in the EMEA region
The Group redefines its
Environmental, social and
governance (ESG) strategy
and produces its first Task
Force on Climate-related
Financial Disclosures
(TCFD) report
Bank of Georgia rolls
out sCoolApp, the
first financial mobile
application for school
students in Georgia
Bank of Georgia’s
digital monthly active
users (Digital MAU)
exceed one million retail
customers
Bank of Georgia
is established
Bank of Georgia issues the
first plastic card
Bank of Georgia installs the
first ATM in Georgia
The European Bank for
Reconstruction and
Development (EBRD)
becomes a shareholder of
the Group
Bank of Georgia acquires
TbilUniversalBank, the
ninth largest bank, and
Georgian Card, a card
processing platform
1994
2018
1996
2019
1998
2021
2004
Bank of Georgia is listed on
the London Stock Exchange
(LSE), in the form
of Global Depositary
Receipts (GDRs)
Bank of Georgia launches
internet banking (iBank)
and mobile banking
(mBank)
2006
Bank of Georgia issues
US$ 200 million Eurobond,
the first international bond
offering from Georgia
2007
Bank of Georgia launches
SOLO, a premium banking
brand to serve the mass
affluent customer base
2009
BGEO moves to the
premium listing on the
LSE and becomes part
of the FTSE 250, being
the first public company
from the Caucasus
region in the list
2012
2022
6
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
1,357
1,121
853
699
520
355
Dec-18 Dec-19 Dec-20 Dec-21 Dec-22 Dec-23
30.7% CAGR
39
37
46
55
58
59
Dec-18 Dec-19 Dec-20 Dec-21 Dec-22 Dec-23
26.4%
26.1%
13.0%
25.8%
32.4%
29.9%
2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
20.2
16.9
16.2
14.2
11.9
9.4
Dec-18 Dec-19 Dec-20 Dec-21 Dec-22 Dec-23
16.6% CAGR
1,375
1,132
727
295
514
435
2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
25.9% CAGR
20.5
18.3
14.014.0
10.1
8.1
Dec-18 Dec-19 Dec-20 Dec-21 Dec-22 Dec-23
20.3% CAGR
Track record of strong performance since
Demerger in 2018
When describing the development of
the Group over the past few years,
two adjectives come to mind: digital
and customer-centric. The Group has
achieved significant progress in becoming
a digital banking leader in Georgia and
a truly customer-centric organisation
with a high-level Net Promoter Score
(NPS). This progress has translated into
loan and deposit portfolio growth and
ultimately into strong profit generation
and profitability. This strong foundation
will support ongoing growth and value-
creation by the Group.
Digital MAU
(thousands)
Loan portfolio
(GEL billions)
Profit (adjusted for one-off items)
1
(GEL millions)
NPS
Deposit portfolio
(GEL billions)
Adjusted return on average equity (ROAE)
1
1. 2023 figures have been adjusted for a one-off GEL 22.6 million other income due to the fair value revaluation of the receivable as part of the settlement of a legacy claim.
2022 figures have been adjusted for a one-off GEL 391.1 million other income due to the settlement of a legacy claim, and a one-off GEL 79.3 million tax expense due to an
amendment to the corporate taxation model applicable to financial institutions in Georgia.
2019 figures have been adjusted for GEL 14.2 million (net of income tax) termination costs of a former CEO and executive management.
2018 figures have been adjusted for GEL 30.3 million demerger-related costs, GEL 8.0 million demerger-related corporate income tax gain, GEL 30.3m one-off impact of
remeasurement of deferred tax balances and GEL 3.9 million (net of income tax) termination costs of a former CEO.
7
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Total dividend paid for the year (GEL millions)
Share buyback and cancellation (GEL millions)
124
122
102
98
80
72
73
188
162
347
352
2
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
535
514
257
184
No dividend
paid due to
Covid-19
pandemic
PAYOUT
RATIO
1
36% 33% 34% 32% 30% 30% 35% 37% 37%
45.8
47.5
49.2
Dec-21 Dec-22
Dec-23
Track record of capital distribution
Number of shares outstanding
(period-end)
3
(millions)
1. For the purpose of total payout ratio calculation, total buyback amount is divided by outstanding shares before the beginning of the respective programme.
2. This includes a final dividend of GEL 4.94 per share that the Board intends to recommend at the 2024 AGM.
3. The final dividend of GEL 4.94 per share that the Board intends to recommend at the 2024 AGM.
GEL 3.06
dividend per share
GEL 62M
share buyback
programme
GEL 4.94
dividend per share
GEL 100M
share buyback
programme
Interim dividend and buyback Final dividend and buyback
3
Capital distribution for 2023
Share buyback and cancellation programme
6.9%
The Company’s issued share capital cancelled as of
31 December 2023
Since the beginning of the first share buyback and
cancellation programme in 2022, the Company has
cancelled 3,403,135 ordinary shares, representing 6.9%
of ordinary shares before the start of the programme.
8
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Profit (adjusted)
1
GEL 1,374.7M
+21.4% y-o-y
Profit (reported)
GEL 1,397.3M
-3.2% y-o-y
Digital MAU
1,357.2K
+21.0% y-o-y
Monthly active individual clients
1,808.9K
+10.8% y-o-y
Net loans
2
GEL 20,232.7M
+20.0% y-o-y
Share of products activated through
digital channels
3
(4Q23)
70.3%
+25.1 ppts y-o-y
Client deposits
GEL 20,522.7M
+12.4% y-o-y
Acquiring market share (Dec-23)
54.9%
+3.7 ppts y-o-y
ROAE (adjusted)
1
29.9%
-2.5 ppts y-o-y
NPS
4
59
58 in 4Q22
Self-employed borrowers
6
54.7K
+14.9% y-o-y
ROAE (reported)
30.4%
-11.0 ppts y-o-y
Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS)
5
56
53 in 4Q22
sCoolApp MAU
89.6K
+170.3% y-o-y
Financial highlights 2023
Strategic and ESG highlights 2023
Figures given for JSC Bank of Georgia standalone
1. 2023 figures have been adjusted for a one-off GEL 22.6 million other income due to the fair value revaluation of the receivable as part of the settlement of a legacy claim.
The comparatives are also adjusted for one-off items.
2. Throughout the Strategic Report, gross loans to customers and respective allowance for impairment are presented net of expected credit loss (ECL) on contractually
accrued interest income. These do not have an effect on the net loans to customers balance. Management believes that netted-off balances provide the best representation
of the Groups loan portfolio position.
3. In 2Q23, we changed the methodology of calculating the share of products sold digitally and currently include all types of products sold by Bank of Georgia.
The previous periods have been restated.
4. Based on external research by IPM Georgia.
5. Based on internal survey.
6. Individuals whose share of income from self-employment exceeds 50% and who do not own a business/are not registered as individual entrepreneurs.
9
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Georgia in key figures
Duty-free access to 2.3 billion-person market: Free Trade Agreements with the European Union
(EU), China, Turkey, EFTA, the UK, Ukraine and CIS
Business bribery ranking
(2023)
#35
Out of 194 countries
Source: TRACE Association
Estimated fiscal deficit as %
of GDP in 2023
2.4%
-0.6 ppts y-o-y
Source: Ministry of Finance of Georgia
Estimated public debt as %
of GDP in 2023
39.0%
-0.2 ppts y-o-y
Source: Ministry of Finance of Georgia
Gross international reserves
in months of goods and
services imports in 2023
3.4 months
+29.3% y-o-y growth in net reserves
Source: National Bank of Georgia, Geostat
Economic freedom ranking
(2023)
#35
Out of 176 countries
Source: The Heritage Foundation
Corruption perception ranking
(2023)
#49
Out of 180 countries
Source: Transparency International
Agency: Fitch
Rating: BB
Outlook: Positive
Date: January 2024
Agency: S&P
Rating: BB
Outlook: Stable
Date: February 2024
Agency: Moody’s
Rating: Ba2
Outlook: Stable
Date: March 2024
Business friendly environment
Steady ratings with improved outlook from global rating agencies
Prudent macroeconomic policy
10
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
The Georgian economy continued to demonstrate resilience in 2023 amid the
turbulent macroeconomic environment of tighter global financial conditions and
unresolved regional conflicts.
Georgia managed to navigate and
adapt to the major changes in the region
triggered by Russia’s war in Ukraine. The
surge in external sector inflows caused
by relocation of capital and rerouting of
trade flows in 2022 started to stabilise
in mid-2023, with a gradual slowdown
afterwards. The slowing external sector
inflows were swiftly substituted by robust
domestic demand, enabling the economy
to maintain a strong growth momentum.
Georgia’s economy grew by 7.5% in
2023 after double-digit growth rates in
2021-2022.
Macro overview
External merchandise trade slowed in 2023 given the record-high base of the
previous year and declining global commodity prices.
Export of services continued to deliver
strong growth due to the ongoing
recovery in international tourism and
impressive gains in information and
communication technology (ICT) and
transport services benefiting from the
relocation of international companies
to Georgia and the rerouting of trade
flows. Money transfers weakened, posting
a 5.7% y-o-y decline in 2023, reflecting
the conclusion of capital relocation
from regional economies. The decline
was partially offset by strong growth
in remittances from EU countries and
the US. Overall, the external balance
improved further in 2023 with a
historically low current account deficit
of 4.3% of GDP. As the slowdown in
external sector inflows was gradual and
anticipated given the extraordinarily high
numbers of the previous year, this has
not caused any undue pressures on the
exchange rate.
In 2023, the Georgian Lari strengthened
against the US Dollar by an additional
0.5% on top of the 12.5% appreciation in
2022.
Strong domestic demand underpinned by
consumption and investment spending
balanced the slowing external sector
inflows in 2023. As inflation eased, real
incomes of households started to recover,
boosting consumption expenditure.
Meanwhile, investment spending
remained robust due to the positive
growth outlook and the proven track
record in sound macroeconomic policies.
Georgia’s favourable geographical
location in the Middle Corridor
and business-friendly environment
also contributed to its investment
attractiveness with equity foreign direct
investment (FDI) inflows increasing
by 68.3% y-o-y in 2023. Transport and
logistics, ICT and education sectors have
demonstrated strong growth and export
potential. Investment activity was also
supported by domestic bank lending with
business loans issued to legal entities up
19.9% y-o-y in constant currency terms in
2023.
Overall, the current mix of Georgia’s
growth drivers, including consumption
and investment spending coupled with
service exports, provides a solid basis for
sustaining the current growth momentum
in the medium term.
The European Council granting Georgia
EU candidate status in December 2023 is
expected to provide an additional boost
to the economy by improving sentiment
among consumers and investors. Sustained
geopolitical instability in the region and
tight global financial conditions pose
downside risks to the outlook. However,
increased fiscal space and replenished
international reserves cushion the economy
from possible shocks.
Amid strong economic growth in 2023, labour market conditions continued to
improve with decreasing unemployment and rising participation rate, while
nominal wage pressures subsided thanks to slower growth in consumer prices.
Inflation declined substantially
throughout the year with a persistent
decrease in import prices and a slowdown
in domestic price growth. Headline
Consumer Prices Index (CPI) inflation
retreated to 0.4% in December 2023
and averaged 2.5% for the full year,
driven by falling global commodity prices,
strong GEL and tight monetary policy.
Given the improved inflation outlook, the
NBG started a gradual exit from tight
monetary policy in mid-2023, cutting the
refinancing rate by a total of 1.5 ppts
throughout the year.
Thanks to favourable macroeconomic conditions, the build-up of policy buffers
continued in 2023.
The National Bank of Georgia (NBG)
took advantage of strong external
sector inflows in the first half of the
year by purchasing record-high amounts
of foreign currency. As a result, net
international reserves reached US$ 2.8
billion by end-2023, increasing by US$
0.6 billion during the year. Meanwhile,
the Government continued fiscal
consolidation supported by strong tax
revenue growth. In 2023, the estimated
fiscal deficit improved by an additional
0.6 ppts versus 2022 to 2.4% of GDP,
while the total public debt reached an
estimated 39.0% of GDP, decreasing by
an additional 0.2 ppts throughout the
year. The adequate level of international
reserves, coupled with declining public-
debt-to-GDP ratio, will help protect the
economy against possible external shocks
down the road.
11
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
2019
5.4%
2020 2021 2022 2023
-6.3%
10.6%
11.0%
7.5%
5.7%
5.2%
5.0%
4.4%
3.2%
3.1%
2.6%
2.3%
Georgia
Uzbekistan
Armenia
Kyrgyz Rep.
Türkiye
Kazakhstan
Russia
Azerbaijan
The banking sector is one of the main
drivers of the Georgian economy – fully
privately owned, with the two largest
banks accounting for 76.9% of total
banking assets at 31 December 2023.
Prudent supervision by the NBG ensured
the resilience of the banking system to
previous external shocks. Along with
strong economic activity in 2023, demand
for credit remained robust. However,
globally increasing interest rates resulted
in higher cost of credit in foreign currency.
A prudently managed banking sector
To mitigate the adverse impact of global tightening and ensure uninterrupted access to credit, the NBG made several amendments
to the macroprudential regulations in 2023:
Composition of real GDP growth by types of
expenditure in Georgia
Consumption
Net export
Investment
Real GDP
2023E 2024F
Source: GeoStat, Bank of Georgia
Source: Latest country reports by International Monetary Fund (IMF) as at
31 March 2024
Real GDP growth forecasts by IMF in regional
economies
Changes in macroprudential regulations in 2023
Effective: 1-Jan-24
Effective: 1-Jan-24
Effective: 15-Mar-24
Effective: 1-Nov-23
Effective: 1-Jan-24
Effective: 7-Dec-23
Introduction of the minimum requirement
for own funds and eligible liabilities
(MREL) for systematically important
commercial banks
Minimum foreign exchange (FX) loan
limit increased from GEL 200,000 (≈US$
74,000) to GEL 300,000 (≈US$ 111,000)
Extension of the accumulation period for
neutral countercyclical buffer from one
year to four years
Maturity limit on unsecured consumer
loans increased back to four years (after
reduction to three years in August 2022)
Currency-hedged borrowers exempt from
minimum FX loan limit
Reduction in the upper limit of the
minimum reserve requirement on short-
term foreign currency liabilities from 25%
to 20%
12
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
20.0%
16.2%
9.6%
17.6%
17.1%
10.1%
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023E
Lithuania
Estonia
Czech Rep.
Türkiye
Georgia
Slovenia
Slovakia
Latvia
Azerbaijan
Armenia
Romania
Poland
North Macedonia
Hungary
Uzbekistan
Croatia
Bulgaria
Bosnia & Herz.
Belarus
Russia
Cyprus
Montenegro
Moldova
Greece
7.0%
6.7%
6.6%
5.9%
5.3%
5.3%
4.1%
3.8%
3.5%
3.5%
3.3%
2.7%
2.6%
2.5%
2.5%
2.5%
2.4%
2.0%
1.5%
1.5%
1.4%
1.2%
1.0%
0.4%
Thanks to the strong economic activity and
recent easing of prudential regulations,
bank lending growth remained healthy
in 2023, accelerating to 17.1% y-o-y on a
constant currency basis after a 12.1% y-o-y
growth in the previous year. Local currency
and foreign currency lending contributed
equally to overall credit growth, leading to
a roughly unchanged loan dollarisation of
45.2% as at 31 December 2023. In contrast,
deposit dollarisation continued to decrease
to 50.7% (-5.4 ppts y-o-y). The banking
sector maintained high profitability with a
24.7% return on equity (ROE) in 2023, while
loan book quality remained sound with
non-performing loan (NPL) ratio at 1.5%.
The Georgian banking sector remains
committed to complying with relevant
anti-money laundering (AML) regulations
and the sanctions adopted by the UK, US,
and EU against Russia. The international
credibility and sound performance of the
Georgian financial sector has made it one
of the largest FDI recipients in recent years,
according to Geostat.
Macro outlook
Nominal GDP growth, y-o-y
Bank credit growth, y-o-y
Bank credit growth in constant currency terms, y-o-y
Source: GeoStat, NBG
NPLs to total gross loans in selected countries,
end-2023 or latest available
Source: IMF
We expect strong economic growth to be
sustained in 2024, underpinned by robust
consumption and investment spending
We anticipate a stable GEL/US$ exchange
rate, supported by resilient external sector
inflows and positive growth outlook
We expect that inflation will remain close
to the NBG’s 3.0% target, supported by
the prudent monetary policy and stable
GEL
We do not rule out additional interest
rate cuts throughout the year amid the
improved inflation outlook
Bank lending growth in Georgia
13
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Ameriabank at a glance
Key financial and non-financial highlights
On 19 February 2024, Bank of Georgia
Group PLC announced that it and its
subsidiary, JSC Bank of Georgia, had
conditionally agreed to acquire 100%
of the total issued share capital of
Ameriabank, a leading universal bank in
Armenia offering a broad suite of retail
and corporate and investment banking
services.
Having received all necessary shareholder
and regulatory approvals as of 29 March
2024, Bank of Georgia Group PLC
acquired 60% and JSC Bank of Georgia
acquired 30% of issued share capital.
EBRD retained a 10% shareholding in
Ameriabank’s total issued share capital,
subject to the Shareholders’ Put and Call
Option Agreement as disclosed in the
class 1 circular published by the Company
on 19 February 2024.
We believe Ameriabank is a good
strategic fit to the Group and that the
Acquisition is attractive as it is expected
to provide significant commercial and
financial benefits.
Ameriabank is a highly attractive
franchise displaying many complementary
characteristics to the Group. Ameriabank
is the market leader in Armenia by
total loan portfolio (19.6% market
share as at 31 December 2023) and the
second largest bank by total deposits
(17.3% market share as at December
2023), with a strong loan and deposit
portfolio growth. Over the last few years
Ameriabank has significantly expanded
its loan portfolio, especially in retail,
with its mortgages and consumer loan
portfolio exhibiting high growth rates
(combined CAGR of 24.1% in 2020-2022).
Ameriabank also has a particularly strong
foothold in the corporate segment, being
a market leader with a market position
(22.5% market share) in loans to legal
entities as at 31 December 2023. We
believe that Ameriabank has significant
growth potential and further scope
to improve commercial performance,
particularly in retail. This is expected to
be achieved by combining Ameriabank’s
existing franchise strengths with the
Groups expertise, stemming from
the Groups proven track record and
leading digital products and payments
capabilities. Although Ameriabank is
a leading player in its own market, it
had fewer than 420,000 individual
customers as at 31 December 2023
(out of a population of approximately
3.0 million). We believe that there is a
significant scope for growth in this area,
Acquisition of Ameriabank CJSC
A leading universal bank in Armenia with #1 rank by loans and #2 by deposits
The leading corporate and investment banking franchise and #1 in mortgages in the retail segment
Strong brand in the local market – the “top-of-mind” bank in Armenia
Delivering double-digit ROAE in four out of five prior years
Experienced management team and strong governance with focus on ESG principles
Ameriabank is one of the leading universal banks in Armenia and has an
attractive franchise with significant upside potential from leveraging BOGG’s
customer focus and digital capabilities.
GEL 309M 24.9%
Net income (FY23) ROAE
2
(FY23)
19.6%/#1 #1 419K
Loans market share (Dec-23) Armenian bank by brand
awareness
1
Individual customers (Dec-23)
1,812 GEL 9,378M GEL 1,303M
Employees (Dec-23) Total assets (Dec-23) Shareholder’s equity (Dec-23)
1. Based on 4Q23 research by Invia CJSC.
2. Calculated based on average shareholder’s equity as at December 31, 2022 and as at December 31, 2023 based on IFRS financial statements of the bank converted to GEL.
36%
Share of Digital MAU in total
individual customers (Dec-23)
14
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
and that the Group’s existing assets and
infrastructure will enable it to realise
these potential growth benefits, as the
Group has already proven in Georgia.
Ameriabank is also one of the leading
payments acquirers in Armenia, with
further potential upside on the back
of the Group’s strong expertise in this
area, as well as supported by favourable
market fundamentals, as the Armenian
economy is predicted to become
increasingly cashless over the next
fewyears.
We believe the acquisition will create
strong value for our shareholders. It is
expected to provide immediate EPS and
ROAE uplift, no dilution for shareholders
as the acquisition was fully funded by
cash
3
. In addition, the acquisition had
a limited negative impact of 1.0%-1.1%
on Bank of Georgia’s capital ratios,
which remained comfortably above
the minimum regulatory requirements.
The Company’s dividend and capital
distribution policy and payout ratio of
30-50% has not changed following the
acquisition.
Macroeconomic overview of Armenia
The Armenian economy and banking sector have certain attractive characteristics
similar to those in our current principal operating country, Georgia.
Armenia’s banking sector remains sound with robust credit growth, decent asset quality and high capitalisation
In 2023, bank lending growth accelerated
to approximately 21% y-o-y in constant
currency basis supported by favourable
economic conditions. In the meantime,
asset quality remained high with non-
performing loans to total loans at 2.4%
as of December 2023. This healthy credit
growth resulted in robust profitability of
estimated 20% return on adjusted equity
in 2023. Armenian banks maintained
solid capital buffers with 19.9% capital
adequacy ratio as at end-2023. Similar
to Georgia, the Armenian banking sector
is distinguished by relatively high, albeit
decreasing, dollarisation. Loan and
deposit dollarisation stood at 35.6%
and 50.5% at end-2023, respectively
(vs.36.3% and 55.1% at end-2022).
Giventhe positive economic outlook and
bank lending to GDP ratio below its long-
term trend in Armenia, strong lending
growth isexpected to be sustained in the
following years.
Armenia is one of the fastest growing economies in the region distinguished by prudent macroeconomic policies,
lowinflation and stable exchange rate
In 2023, Armenia maintained strong
growth momentum after a surge in
economic growth in 2022 driven by
increased inflows of capital, inbound
migration, and relocation of businesses,
particularly from Russia, triggered by
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. These
developments bolstered domestic
demand and strengthened the local
currency. The Armenian economy
registered 8.7% real GDP growth in 2023,
on top of 12.6% expansion in the previous
year, driven by trade, information and
communication, and construction sectors.
Armenia also benefited from increased
transit trade resulting from rerouted
trade flows in the region.
The elevated inflation in previous years
receded in 2023 due to tight monetary
policy, strong Armenian Dram and
declining global commodity prices.
In the first half of 2023, the central bank
of Armenia (CBA) maintained tight
monetary policy with the historically high
policy rate at 10.75%. As inflation eased,
it gradually reduced rates by 1.5 ppts by
end-2023. The Armenian currency remains
stable after gaining byapproximately
16% in value against theUS dollar during
2022-2023.
The regional security risks have receded substantially at the end of 2023. However, the geopolitical landscape
remains fragile in the region as border issues between Armenia and Azerbaijan are still unresolved.
In late 2023, Azerbaijan assumed full
control of Nagorno-Karabakh, prompting
approximately 100,000 ethnic Armenians
to flee into Armenia. The government
of Armenia swiftly implemented policy
measures to address the refugees’ urgent
needs, which created short-lived fiscal
pressures. In the medium term, however,
the refugees can provide additional boost
to the economy by integrating in the
local labour market. Meanwhile, Armenia
is actively seeking to negotiate a peace
agreement with Azerbaijan, which could
unlock new opportunities for Armenia and
for the overall region in terms of greater
connectivity encouraging more trade and
capital movements.
In recent years, Armenia has intensified
efforts to strengthen relations with the
European Union, which has also been
actively involved in the resolution of the
conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan.
In March 2024, European Parliament
passed resolution proposing consideration
of EU membership candidacy for
Armenia. These developments reflect
Armenia’s attempts to reduce economic
and security dependence on a single
country, particularly Russia. Stronger
integration in the EU can open up vast
opportunities for Armenia resulting in
improved medium-term growth prospects
and more resilient economy.
Despite slowing inflows from Russia since the second half of 2023, Armenia is expected to maintain strong growth
momentum supported by resilient private consumption coupled with government spending and investment.
Strong focus on the IT sector as well
as ongoing reforms in the education
system can help Armenia transform into
a service-based and export-led economy.
Sound macroeconomic policies and the
fiscal reform agenda supported by the
ongoing IMF programme reinforce the
growth outlook. Despite strong current
performance, the Armenian economy
remains constrained by structural
challenges including low productivity in
manufacturing and agriculture, narrow
export base and high dependence
on inflows from Russia (40.6% of
Armenian export proceeds and 65.9%
ofremittances were sourced from
Russiain 2023).
3. The sole instance of possible share issuance is previewed in Put and Call Option Agreement where BOGG has discretion to pay the Put and/or Call price either in cash or via
issuance of shares in the Company.
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
15
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Mel Carvill
Board Chairman
Chairman’s Statement
2023 was a pivotal year in the Group’s
strategic development, as it laid the
groundwork for the acquisition of
Ameriabank in the first quarter of 2024,
a significant and immediately earnings
accretive transaction for the Group.
I spoke about the attractiveness of
Armenia and Ameriabank in my letter
to shareholders ahead of the General
Meeting and shareholder vote on the
acquisition, but I want to reiterate a
few points. Armenia and Georgia are
neighbouring countries with significant
cross-border links, and both are attractive
high-growth economies in the EMEA
region, pivoting towards the EU. Georgia
has already made significant progress. A
major leap forward was the achievement
of EU candidacy status at the end of
2023, and Armenia is voicing its intentions
to further deepen its relationship with
the EU. Ameriabank is a leading banking
franchise in the country, the largest
bank by loans, with 20% market share
as of year-end 2023, and the capacity to
double down on its customer franchise
growth, especially in the mass retail and
SME segments. We expect it to deliver
strong results and market share gains in
the years to come. We believe Bank of
Georgia’s experience and best practices
can be shared with Ameriabank to
support its growth and development.
The Board was very pleased to see
100.0% support for this transaction from
our shareholders, and the very positive
shareholder feedback.
In March 2024, in accordance with our
succession planning, we announced a
change to the composition of the Board.
Al Breach, a Non-executive Director of
the Company from 28 February 2018,
stepped down. We are very grateful
for his substantial contributions to the
Board during a significant period of
change throughout his tenure. A new
Non-executive Director, Andrew McIntyre,
has been appointed. I am confident that
Andrew’s rich experience and range of
skills will further strengthen the Board
and support the Groups continued
progress. You can read more about
Andrew and the appointment process in
the Nomination Committee Report on
pages 206 to 213.
During 2023, the Board was focused
on understanding the impact of new
technologies and operating models in
financial services, as well as on exploring
potential new horizons for growth. The
Group has continued to deliver on its
strategic priorities, generating strong
top- and bottom-line growth, maintaining
high profitability levels, and rewarding
shareholders with a robust capital
distribution strategy. The Board has seen
significant improvements in the quality of
the organisation, with people-centricity
– be it customer-centricity or employee-
centricity –embedded throughout the
business in policies and processes, and
with relevant metrics meticulously
monitored by the management team,
which are regularly reported to, and
discussed at, the Board. The substantial
progress is visible in the figures, and you
can read significantly more about this
progress throughout this Report.
Throughout the year, the Board received
regular updates on how the management
continued to create opportunities for our
different stakeholders. Overall, Bank of
Georgia has taken great strides towards
a truly customer-centric culture, focused
on outcomes rather than processes,
with the right systems in place to
identify customer pain points, rectify any
mistakes along the way, and improve
the overall customer experience. The
Board continued to hear first-hand from
employees about their work experiences
in Employee Voice meetings. We saw
Employee NPS improve during 2023, and
employee engagement scores remained
at high levels during the year.
The Board also continued to be fully
engaged in the ESG practices across the
organisation, approving a number of new
policies, including a Responsible Supply
Chain and Environmental Policy, reflecting
our commitment to sustainability across
operations. The Groups approach to
ESG has been informed by the views of
our key stakeholders through a formal
materiality assessment. In response to
stakeholder feedback during the second
formal ESG materiality assessment
in 2023, the Board approved a revised
ESG strategy, with Sustainable Finance
added as one of the main pillars and
green lending KPIs introduced for the
first time. Climate change is a global
challenge, and we understand that
leading financial institutions have a lot to
contribute to mitigate risks and support
sustainable economies alongside their
customers, communities, governments,
and regulators. The Group is making good
progress on understanding and managing
climate-related risks and opportunities
and improving data collection and
assessment capabilities. The Board
will focus closely on the progress the
Group is making in light of the external
environment, emerging regulatory
requirements, and, of course, the
expectations of our key stakeholders. We
remain committed to fostering diversity
and inclusion on the Board as well as
across the organisation and are pleased
to see that the Group has been ranked
#2 in the banking sector in the latest
FTSE Women Leaders Review on female
representation, with 49% of the Executive
Committee and their direct reports
being women. You can read more about
diversity and our sustainability practices
in the Sustainable Business section on
pages 120 to 122.
In conclusion, I’d like to thank fellow Board
members, the CEO and his team and
all employees across the Group for their
commitment and efforts throughout the
year. I’m confident about the Group’s
strengths and its ability to maintain
its strong track record of excellent
performance.
Mel Carvill
Chairman
24 April 2024
Section 172 Statement
In discharging its duty to act
in good faith and in a way that
is the most likely to promote
the long-term success of the
Company, Directors must take
into consideration the interests
of the various stakeholders
of the Company. Throughout
this report, we detail how
we have identified and given
consideration to our various
stakeholders. See pages 52-59
for our Section 172 statement
(which is incorporated to the
Strategic Report by reference),
and on how the Board has
engaged with our stakeholders.
16
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Archil Gachechiladze
Chief Executive Officer
Chief Executive Officers statement
As I write this letter, the Group looks
different to what it was at the end of
2023. With the acquisition of Ameriabank
going through successfully, we now operate
two leading, top-of-mind banks in two
high-growth neighbouring economies,
Georgia and Armenia. Both Georgia and
Armenia are attractive emerging markets,
of similar sizes and structures, delivering
and expected to continue to deliver one
of the highest, more than 5%, real GDP
growth rates in EMEA. Both Georgia
and Armenia are prudently managed,
with distinguished fiscal discipline and
effective monetary policy enabling them
to navigate through the uncertain and
volatile global environment. During the
past two years, Georgia’s role in the middle
corridor between Europe and Asia has
been amplified, and the entry of a number
of multinational companies reflects
increased investor interest which, I believe,
will be sustained and reinforced, especially
with the EU candidacy status granted to
Georgia in December last year. I am very
optimistic about Armenia as well, as we
see increasing engagement with the EU
and a strong focus on diversification, with
geopolitical risks substantially reduced.
From a banking sector perspective, lower
credit penetration and a fragmented
banking sector in Armenia present growth
opportunities that we intend to capture
in the coming years. You can read the
Georgian and Armenian macroeconomic
and banking sector highlights on pages 9
to 14.
Over the past few years, we have been
significantly focused on elevating the
1. Digital monthly active users – individuals who logged in to Bank of Georgia’s retail mobile applicable (BOG APP), internet banking platform (iBank) or mobile application for
school students (sCoolApp) at least once within the past month.
2. 2023 figures were adjusted for a one-off GEL 22.6 million other income related to the fair value revaluation of the receivable related to the settlement of a legacy claim.
quality of our Georgian banking franchise,
devoting significant resources to new
product development, digital channels,
and enhancing customer experience.
Our efforts, which are always ongoing,
contributed to Bank of Georgia’s
leadership in daily banking, and strong
results across our key performance
metrics. We ended 2023 with close to
1.4 million Digital MAU
1
among retail
customers, representing 75.0% of our
total monthly active retail customers,
compared to 68.7% a year ago. Our
customer Net Promoter Score of 59,
which was broadly stable during the year,
is an excellent score for a universal bank,
and, with customer-centricity embedded
in organisation’s DNA, we will remain
focused on our customers, anticipating
their wants and needs and delivering
an excellent customer experience. Our
payments business continues to grow,
with the volume of merchant acquiring
transactions in Georgia up 46.5% year-on-
year in 2023, achieving a 54.9% market
share in December 2023. In addition, more
than 1.2 million individuals used Bank of
Georgia’s cards to make a payment in-
store or online at least once in December
2023, a 20.1% increase over the same
period in 2022.
All of the above translated into strong
core revenue growth in 2023, with net
interest income up 36.6% year-on-year
and net fee and commission income up
36.8% year-on-year, translating into
full year profit (adjusted for one-off
items) of GEL 1,374.7 million
2
, up 21.4%
year-on-year, and an adjusted ROAE of
29.9%
2
. On the portfolio side, loan book
growth increased 19.6% year-on-year on
a constant currency basis in 2023, while
deposit growth was 12.2% year-on-year
on a constant currency basis, building on
the significant inflows during 2022. Going
forward, we expect our double-digit
balance sheet growth to more than offset
any margin impact of deposit re-pricing
and lower policy rates.
We acquired Ameriabank with our
surplus capital and cash resources,
with no significant effect on Bank of
Georgia’s capital ratios, no dilution for
existing shareholders and no change
to our dividend and capital distribution
policy and payout range of 30-50% of
earnings. Considering the Group’s strong
performance during 2023 and robust
capital and liquidity positions, the Board
intends to recommend, at the 2024
Annual General Meeting, a final dividend
for 2023 of GEL 4.94 per share, making
a total dividend for 2023 of GEL 8.00
per share. This is a 5% increase on the
dividend for 2022 – a year boosted by
significant one-offs and FX income which
broadly normalised in 2023. In addition,
the total buyback and cancellation
programme for 2023 totalled GEL 162
million, bringing the total dividend and
buyback payout ratio 2023 of 37%, the
same as in 2022.
Having acquired Ameriabank, the Group
has turned a new page. We are no longer
Georgia-focused only, as we used to say,
but we remain focused on delivering
strong growth and high profitability in
Georgia. In Armenia, we will work with
the local management team to build on
the existing strengths of Ameriabank
to drive strong customer franchise
growth. No matter where we are, we
aim to grow strongly and profitably. We
expect Ameriabank to deliver higher
lending growth, above 20%, over the
next few years as the market presents
opportunities for both strong systemic
growth and further market share gains
for the leading player. In light of this
expectation, we are revising our medium-
term lending growth target for the whole
Group from c.10% to 15%+.
Great customer experience starts with
engaged and empowered employees.
Our people are critical enablers of
the Groups enduring success, and we
continue to listen to our employees to
improve the organisation together and
deliver better outcomes for all. Bank of
Georgia’s employee net promoter score
(eNPS) was 56 at year-end, higher than
throughout 2022-2023. The dynamics
of work continue to evolve globally,
with younger generations coming with
different expectations and needs. We
may not always get everything right,
but the whole organisation is committed
to being a great place to work for top
talent, creating equal opportunities that
help our employees achieve more of
their potential. I want to thank all of our
employees for constantly supporting our
customers and each other.
We have an interesting year ahead,
with new upsides and goals. I am
confident we have the necessary
capabilities to manage the challenges
we may face on our way and continue
creating opportunities and value for our
stakeholders.
Archil Gachechiladze
Chief Executive Officer
24 April 2024
This Strategic Report, as set out
on pages 5 to 183, was approved
by the Board of Directors on
24 April 2024 and signed on its
behalf by
Archil Gachechiladze
Chief Executive Officer
24 April 2024
17
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
STRATEGY AND
PERFORMANCE
18
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
AI
We are guided by our purpose
Helping people achieve more of their potential
We regularly engage with our
key stakeholders and consider
their views and feedback
Our strategic priorities
We are enabled by
We create positive impact
through our main focus areas
Key medium-term targets
Our purpose and strategy framework
c.15%
Loan book growth
1
20%+
ROAE
30-50%
Dividend and share
buyback payout ratio
CUSTOMER-
CENTRICITY
PEOPLE AND
CULTURE
BRAND
STRENGTH
EFFECTIVE RISK
MANAGEMENT
DATA AND AI
Employees
Financial inclusion
Sustainable finance
Employee empowerment
Communities
Customers Regulators
Investors
Being the main bank in
customers’ daily lives by
leveraging the digital and
payments ecosystems
Anticipating customer needs
and wants and providing
relevant products and services
Growing the balance sheet
profitably and tapping
segments with high growth
potential
The main bank
Excellent customer
experience
Profitable growth
1. We have revised the loan book growth target upwards following the Acquisition of Ameriabank.
19
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Our key enablers
The success and resilience of our organisation rely on maintaining a positive
customer experience across all interactions with Bank of Georgia and driving
positive outcomes for our customers. Through the implementation of comprehensive
organisation-wide processes, including regular customer experience reviews at
management level and the use of key performance indicators (KPIs) to actively
respond to customer feedback, we have evolved into a truly customer-centric
company.
CUSTOMER-
CENTRICITY
NPS
59
58 (2022)
Unsecured
consumer loan
disbursement
enabled by AI
22%
N/A
eNPS
56
53 (2022)
Top-of-mind
1
50%
48% (2022)
Cost of credit
risk ratio
0.7%
0.8% (2022)
We aim to attract, retain and motivate skilled and talented individuals with
diverse outlooks, life experiences and career paths. Our goal is to establish a secure
and welcoming environment that fosters personal and professional growth and
teamwork, and contributes to our sustained success.
PEOPLE AND
CULTURE
We are the top-of-mind and the most trusted bank in Georgia. Our brand strength
enables us to acquire clients and maintain relationships with them. Robust brand
name fosters credibility, cultivates confidence and attracts customers, contributing
to the Bank’s overall success.
BRAND
STRENGTH
Identifying, assessing and mitigating risks not only safeguards the financial health
of the institution but also instils confidence among stakeholders. By navigating
potential pitfalls and uncertainties with a proactive approach, we build resilience,
sustain growth and ensure long-term stability.
EFFECTIVE RISK
MANAGEMENT
In 2023, we enhanced the Bank’s advanced analytics and artificial intelligence (AI)
capabilities for improved decision-making, efficiency and customer satisfaction.
Our machine learning models anticipate individual financial and lifestyle needs,
enabling us to provide personalised services for positive experiences across various
touchpoints. We have made good progress in these areas, but we see enormous
room for improvement, to become a truly data-driven organisation leveraging AI use
cases to their full potential.
AI
DATA AND AI
1. Based on independent research conducted by IPM Georgia. ‘Top-of-mind’ refers to the first brand that comes to a person’s mind when they are asked an unprompted
question about a particular industry or category. The figure presented is as of 4Q23.
20
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Retail Banking
JSC Bank of Georgia business model
Mass Retail Banking
We provide a comprehensive range of daily banking, payments,
and related financial products and services to a broad spectrum
of mass segment customers through a digitally-led user
experience via our award-winning mobile application and one of
the largest distribution networks in Georgia.
Premium Banking
We provide exclusive premium banking products coupled with
a broad range of lifestyle offerings to mass affluent customers
through the SOLO brand and high-net-worth individuals through
the Wealth Management (WM) direction.
Net loans
GEL 4.5B
Deposits
GEL 5.1B
Corporate Banking
Market share – customer depositsMarket share – total gross loans
FY21 FY22 FY23FY21 FY22 FY23
35.7%
36.1%
36.8%
36.4%
38.9%
39.0%
Market share – loans to individuals Market share – deposits of individuals
FY21 FY22 FY23
39.0%
38.8%
39.5%
FY21 FY22 FY23
40.3%
44.4%
45.3%
Bank of Georgia has maintained strong competitive positions.*
Deposits Net loans
GEL 4.0B GEL 7.5B
SOLO is a unique banking
concept in one space,
combining privileged financial
and advisory services and
tailored and exclusive lifestyle
experiences.
Wealth Management serves
high-net-worth individuals. WM
services include a dedicated
private banker, a dedicated
personal concierge, exclusive
financial products and lifestyle
experiences on top of those
offered to SOLO customers.
* Market share data are based on standalone accounts as published by the National Bank of Georgia.
+8.9% y-o-y +10.3% y-o-y +26.1% y-o-y
Net loans Deposits
GEL 6.5B GEL 5.3B
We provide the expertise and tailored solutions needed by large
corporate organisations. Skilled relationship managers provide a
one-to-one dedicated support to our customers.
+31.2% y-o-y +8.9%y-o-y
We provide a broad range of banking and payment products and
value-added services to small- and medium-sized businesses,
including individual entrepreneurs.
SME Banking
Net loans
GEL 4.6B
Deposits
GEL 1.9B
+12.0% y-o-y +24.4% y-o-y
+19.1% y-o-y
21
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
2023
2
022
2
021
1,374.7
1,132.2
727.1
Profit (adjusted)
1
(GEL millions)
Definition
Profit is calculated in accordance with International
Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and represents
operating income and profit/(loss) from associates less
operating expenses, cost of risk, non-recurring items
and income tax expense. Profit is adjusted for one-off
items.
Why do we measure?
This measure reflects the Group‘s performance for the
period and is one of the KPIs for the Group’s businesses.
Performance
In 2023, the Group reported a 21.4% y-o-y increase in
adjusted profit, driven by strong top line growth.
We monitor and analyse a broad range
of financial and non-financial measures
(so-called strategic measures) that reflect
our strategic priorities to assess how well we
execute our strategy and ensure we remain
aligned with our medium-term targets.
Some of these performance measures
are also linked to the way we pay our
employees, including at Executive
Management level. The Board ensures
the most relevant KPIs are included in the
Executive Management’s remuneration to
better align their interests with those of
our different stakeholders.
Financial measures are presented for the
Group as a whole, while non-financial
measures (strategic and ESG KPIs)
are presented for JSC Bank of Georgia
standalone.
In 2023, we reviewed the KPIs against
our strategic priorities, including ESG
objectives. The changes were made to
reflect the ways in which both the Executive
Management analyses the Group’s
performance as well as how this is reflected
in the remuneration practices. The changes
are presented in the table below:
Added KPIs Removed KPIs
Financial KPIs N/A Profit (reported)
ROAE (reported)
Basic earnings per share
Cost:income ratio (reported)
Net loan book growth (nominal)
Deposit growth (nominal)
NPL ratio
CET1 capital adequacy ratio
Leverage (times)
Liquidity coverage ratio
Net stable funding ratio
Strategic and ESG KPIs sCoolApp MAU
Number of self-employed borrowers
Daily active users (DAU)
DAU/MAU
Share of products activated through digital channels
Share of transactions through mBank and iBank
Acquiring market share
Number of clients who exchanged loyalty points
Number of active business clients
Business MAU
Key performance indicators
Financial KPIs
2023
2
022
2
021
29.9%
32.4%
25.8%
ROAE (adjusted)
1
Definition
Profit (adjusted) attributable to shareholders, adjusted
for one-off items, divided by monthly average total
equity attributable to shareholders. Total equity
attributable to shareholders comprises share capital,
additional paid-in capital, treasury shares, retained
earnings, capital redemption reserve and other reserves.
Why do we measure?
20%+ ROAE is one of the key medium-term targets of
the Group communicated to investors. ROAE reflects
our ability to generate return on equity.
Performance
Adjusted ROAE stood at 29.9% in FY23
(32.4% in FY22), significantly higher than the 20%+
medium-term target.
1. 2023 figures have been adjusted for a one-off GEL 22.6 million of other income related to the settlement of a legacy claim. Reported profit for 2023 was GEL 1,397.3 million
and ROAE based on reported profit was 30.4%.
2022 figures have been adjusted for a one-off GEL 391.1 million other income due to the settlement of a legacy claim, and a one-off GEL 79.3 million tax expense due to an
amendment to the corporate taxation model applicable to financial institutions in Georgia. Reported profit for 2022 was GEL 1,444.0 million and ROAE based on reported
profit was 41.4%.
22
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
2023
2
022
2
021
6.5%
5.4%
4.9%
Net interest margin (NIM)
Definition
Net interest income for the year divided by monthly
average interest-earning assets, excluding cash
and cash equivalents and corporate shares, for the
same year.
Why do we measure?
NIM reflects the profitability of our core banking
operations by taking the difference between the
interest income we earn on loans and other assets
and the interest expense we pay on deposits
and other liabilities. NIM is one of the key ratios
regularly monitored by Executive Management and
communicated to investors.
Performance
NIM stood at 6.5% in FY23 (up 110 bps y-o-y). The
increase in NIM versus the prior year was driven by a
combination of higher loan yield and lower cost of funds.
2023
2
022
2
021
19.6%
12.9%
19.8%
Net loan book growth
(constant currency basis)
Definition
Net loans to customers and finance lease receivables at
the end of the year divided by net loans to customers
and finance lease receivables at the end of the previous
year minus one. To calculate the change on a constant
currency basis, net loans to customers and finance lease
receivables in currencies other than GEL at the end of
the year are converted to GEL using the exchange rates
at the end of the previous year.
Why do we measure?
c.10% loan portfolio growth was one of the key
medium-term targets of the Group communicated
to investors. Following the Acquisition of Ameriabank,
we have revised this target up to c.15%.
Performance
Net loans and finance lease receivables amounted to
GEL 20,232.7 million at 31 December 2023, up 19.6%
y-o-y on a constant currency basis.
2
023
2
022
2
021
12.2%
43.2%
12.5%
Deposit growth
(constant currency basis)
Customer deposits at the end of the year divided by
customer deposits at the end of the previous year minus
one. To calculate the change on a constant currency
basis, customer deposits in currencies other than GEL
at the end of the year are converted to GEL using the
exchange rates at the end of the previous year.
Definition
Maintaining a strong deposit franchise reflects the
Group‘s ability to attract and maintain a loyal customer
base and underpins its ongoing resilience.
Why do we measure?
Performance
Client deposits and notes amounted to GEL 20,522.7
million as at 31 December 2023 (up 12.2% y-o-y on a
constant currency basis) driven by both current/demand
and time deposits.
2
023
2
022
2
021
0.7%
0.8%
0.0%
Definition
Cost of credit risk ratio equals expected credit loss on
loans to customers and finance lease receivables for the
year divided by monthly average gross loans to customers
and finance lease receivables for the same year.
Why do we measure?
Prudently managing credit risk is one of the critical
components of the Group’s enterprise risk management
(ERM) framework. Cost of credit risk ratio is one of
the key financial metrics regularly communicated to
investors with guidance of 1.0-1.2% as the Group’s
normalised range. This KPI has also been included in the
CEO’s KPIs.
Performance
The cost of credit risk ratio stood at 0.7% in FY23
versus 0.8% in FY22. The decrease was mainly driven
by improved performance of the Retail Banking loan
portfolio.
Cost of credit risk ratio
2
023
2
022
2
021
29.8%
32.0%
37.2%
Cost:income ratio (adjusted)
1
Definition
Operating expenses divided by operating income,
adjusted for one-off items.
Why do we measure?
This reflects our efficiency in managing operating
expenses relative to our income generation, providing
insight into our operational efficiency and financial
performance.
Performance
In 2023, the Group delivered positive operating leverage,
with the cost:income ratio at 29.8% versus 32.0% for
the full year of 2022.
1. 2023 figure has been adjusted for a one-off GEL 22.6 million of other income related to the settlement of a legacy claim. Reported cost:income ratio for 2023 was 29.5%.
2022 figure has been adjusted for a one-off GEL 391.1 million other income due to the settlement of a legacy claim, and a one-off GEL 79.3 million tax expense due to an
amendment to the corporate taxation model applicable to financial institutions in Georgia. Reported cost:income ratio for 2022 was 26.8%.
Financial KPIs
23
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
2023
2
022
2
021
1,357.2
1,121.4
852.7
Definition
An individual who logged into BOG APP, sCoolApp or
iBank at least once within the past month.
Why do we measure?
Increasing the use of Bank of Georgia’s digital channels
has been one of the top priorities during the past
few years. Digital MAU is one of the key strategic
metrics that we have communicated to the Company’s
investors and that is regularly monitored by Executive
Management.
Performance
In December 2023, Digital MAU was up 21.0% y-o-y to
c.1.4 million individuals.
Digital MAU
(thousands)
2023
2
022
2
021
14,965.2
10,212.8
6,858.7
Definition
GEL value of all payment transactions executed in
BOG’s physical POS and online acquiring network for
the period.
Why do we measure?
Growing the payments business is one of the
Group’s strategic priorities, and volume of payment
transactions is one of the key strategic metrics that we
have communicated to the Company’s investors and
that is regularly monitored by Executive Management.
Performance
The volume of payment transactions executed through
BOG’s physical and online POS terminals reached GEL
15.0 billion in 2023, a 46.5% increase versus 2022.
Volume of payment
transactions in BOG’s acquiring
(GEL millions)
2
023
2
022
2
021
1,248.7
1,039.8
781.9
Definition
An individual who used a BOG card for payments at
least once within the past month.
Why do we measure?
Our clients want a fast and frictionless payments
experience and we believe cashless payments benefit
people. Payments are also our daily touchpoint with
customers and we aim to be the main daily banking
relationship for our customers.
Performance
In December 2023, BOG’s cards were used for payments
at least once by more than 1.2 million individuals (up
20.1% y-o-y), an important progress towards a more
cashless economy in Georgia.
Payments MAU
(thousands)
Strategic and ESG KPIs
2
023
2
022
2
021
56
53
61
eNPS
2
Definition
To calculate eNPS, we ask employees “How likely are
you to recommend Bank of Georgia to others as a place
of work?” and answers are scored on a zero-to-ten
scale. eNPS is simply the percentage of employees who
are promoters (those who scored 9 or 10) minus the
percentage who are detractors (those who scored 0 to 6).
Why do we measure?
Engaged and committed employees are critical for
the success of the Group. eNPS, measured internally,
offers valuable insights into Company culture,
employee engagement and satisfaction and is one of
the main non-financial KPIs for the CEO and Executive
Management.
Performance
The Bank’s eNPS score increased to 56 by year-end
(from 53 at the end of 2022), and was within our target
range, reflecting our efforts to improve employee
experience throughout 2023.
2023
2
022
2
021
59
58
55
Definition
To calculate NPS, people are asked “How likely are you
to recommend Bank of Georgia to a friend or colleague?”
and answers are scored on a zero-to-ten scale. NPS is
simply the percentage of customers who are promoters
(those who scored 9 or 10) minus the percentage who are
detractors (those who scored 0 to 6).
Why do we measure?
Customer-centricity is one of the key enablers of the
Group‘s success in the longer term. Overall customer
satisfaction, measured by a third-party, is one of the
main non-financial KPIs for the CEO and Executive
Management.
Performance
NPS remained at a high level throughout 2023 and
stood at 59 at year-end, broadly stable versus prior
year.
NPS
1
1. Based on external research by IPM Georgia.
2. Based on internal survey.
24
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
2023
2
022
2
021
89.6
33.2
N/A
Definition
An individual who logged into sCoolApp at least once
within the past month.
Why do we measure?
Developing sCoolApp, a special mobile application for
school children, reflects our commitment to onboarding
and engaging more young people, making sure they
become part of the formal financial system, teaching
them financial literacy skills, and supporting them with
simple daily banking solutions. sCoolApp MAU is one
of the non-financial KPIs for the CEO and Executive
Management.
Performance
We surpassed the 2023 year-end target of sCoolApp
MAU of 70,000, having reached 89.6 thousand school
students by December 2023.
sCoolApp MAU
(thousands)
2023
2
022
2
021
54.7
47.6
N/A
Number of self-employed
borrowers
1
(thousands)
Definition
An individual, with a credit from Bank of Georgia, whose
share of income from self-employment exceeds 50%
and who does not own a business/is not registered as
an individual entrepreneur.
Why do we measure?
We are committed to removing barriers that prevent
people from accessing credit. One such barrier used to
be lack of formal income. Over the past two years we
have focused on supporting self-employed individuals
with a range of retail lending products, and this
metric has been one of the ESG KPIs for the CEO and
Executive Management.
Performance
We have simplified the lending process to support
self-employed borrowers, ending the year with 54.7
thousand individuals. The loan portfolio of self-
employed borrowers amounted to GEL 531.7 million
as at 31 December, 2023, up 45.9% y-o-y. The 2022
figure has been recalculated based on updated
business criteria.
In 2023, the number of self-employed borrowers was
slightly short of the target (57K), despite the fact that
the loan portfolio itself grew significantly. The Retail
Banking team continues to be focused on reaching this
segment, especially outside of the capital city, Tbilisi,
and simplifying the user experience to attract more
customers into the formal banking system.
1. Individuals whose share of income from self-employment exceeds 50% and who do not own a business/are not registered as individual entrepreneurs.
Strategic and ESG KPIs
25
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Addressing financial and lifestyle needs of
our customers
Our retail customer base is diverse,
encompassing individuals ranging from
school students to high-net-worth
individuals. To stay relevant to our clients,
we have developed distinct offerings
tailored to various needs.
In Mass Retail Banking, the majority of
our clients use subscription packages
called S, M, or L, with L being the
most comprehensive package with
higher available limits. In 2023, in
Premium Banking, we introduced a
new subscription option – SOLO X –
designed for customers who appreciate
the SOLO lifestyle and banking services
but do not require a personal banker.
This differentiation in packages has
successfully attracted more customers.
Through the BOG APP – Bank of
Georgia’s retail financial superapp, we
not only provide core banking products
to our clients, but also offer non-banking
products, including investment accounts,
public transport cards, and insurance
marketplace. This diverse product range
enhances the variety of our offerings,
fostering increased client engagement.
Despite offering different services
to various customer segments, our
commitment to delivering the best
customer experience and ensuring high
levels of customer satisfaction remains
consistent.
As of December 2023, the number of
monthly active retail clients reached 1.8
million, a y-o-y increase of 10.8%. Notably,
75% of active retail clients are monthly
active digital users. This reflects the
extensive adoption of Bank of Georgia’s
market-leading retail digital channels.
Credit
Savings
Payments
Daily banking
Lifestyle
Rewards
Investments
Insurance
1.8M monthly active individuals
+10.8% y-o-y
Mass Retail Banking: 1.7M
+9.2% y-o-y
Premium Banking: 127K
+38.6% y-o-y
WM
SOLO
Club
SOLO
Premium
SOLO
X
L
Package
M
Package
S
Package
26
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Our digital ecosystem
The cornerstone of our digital ecosystem
is a global award-winning financial
superapp – BOG APP. We aim to use
other digital channels for client acquisition
and then migrate our customers to BOG
APP because we envision BOG APP as the
go-to channel for our increasingly digital
customer base.
We aim to transform the everyday
experiences of our customers by enabling
them to effortlessly discover and secure
daily banking services and relevant
products with a single touch, all within our
financial superapp.
BOG APP has evolved during the past
two years, often in response to customer
feedback that we continuously track,
analyse and share monthly with Executive
Management. For example, in 2023, we
added the possibility to cancel or prolong
deposits to the app. Previously, customers
whose deposits were about to expire
had to contact a banker or come to a
branch if they did not wish the deposit
to be prolonged. This issue came up in
customer surveys as a pain point, and now
customers can see in the app when their
deposit is about to expire shortly and they
can take action themselves directly from
the app. If they wish to prolong it, they can
prolong it on similar or different terms, or
they can cancel it so that the money saved
will be transferred to the current account
after expiry.
When Bank of Georgia was in the initial
stages of digital transformation, we
focused on making sure that more and
more transactional activity happens
outside of branches and moves to BOG
APP. Lately, more focus has been directed
towards moving product sales to digital
channels by designing straightforward
digital journeys for different products.
We have achieved good levels of
digitalisation in unsecured consumer
loans, and saw improvements in deposits
digitalisation during 2023. Digitising card
sales has been a challenge mainly because
we lacked a simple and efficient card
delivery process. We are in the process
of designing the card delivery process to
make it more efficient for the Bank as
well as for the customers.
Seamless and consistent user
experience (UX)
Personalisation, navigation, exploration Banking products, non-banking products
and more
Effortlessly discover
Relevant products and
services Single touch
Three pillars of the BOG APP
iBank
sCoolApp
BOGPAY.ge
BOG.GE & SOLO.GE
BOG APP
27
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Our financial superapp
What we did in 2023
We launched instant peer-to-peer (P2P) payments
to other banks in BOG APP – enabling users to
transfer and receive money instantly, 24/7, from
any Georgian bank.
24/7 P2P transfers to other Georgian banks
We introduced ‘Stories’, offering customers access
to both financial and non-financial content. In 2023
more than 1M customers engaged with the stories,
accumulating 738M views in total.
Stories
We revamped BOG APP’s navigation style to give
it more flair and functionality, broadening its focus
beyond banking offers and services. We reimagined
two pages: Hub and My Space.
Superapp navigation
We added gamification to BOG APP. 527K
customers played the game and 805K products
were sold during the gamification campaign,
boosting digital product sales to 70.3% of total
product sales in the fourth quarter of 2023. Many
customers also became acquainted with the services and
products that we offer in BOG APP. Gamification was the first
major product implemented on public cloud.
Gamification
We provide personalised financial and non-financial
offers to our clients, enabled by machine learning
and AI.
Next Best Offer (NBO) with reasonings
In December we introduced gift cards in BOG
APP that customers can purchase for themselves
or their friends. This feature not only enhances
the customer experience but also empowers our
merchants to boost sales.
Gift cards
Credit
Savings Daily banking
Investments
Insurance
marketplace
Personal finance
management
Gamification
End-to-end unsecured
consumer lending
Pre-approved credit limits
Loyalty and
lifestyle
Dedicated space with offers
from partner merchants
Gift cards
Stories
End-to-end online deposit
activation
Activation of ‘piggy bank’
Transactions
Payments & BNPL
Subscriptions
Remittances
Bill split & money request
Chat and chat-bot support
Automatic payments
and transfers
Digital debit card and
physical debit card ordering
Instant P2P payments
to other banks
Opening investment account
Managing investment
portfolio
Motor Third Party Liability
insurance (MTPL)
Travel insurance
Daily spend view and
personal budget management
PLAY STORE 4.7/5
APP STORE 4.8/5
CSAT
92% in 4Q23
(89% in 4Q22)
28
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Best Consumer
Bill Payment and Presentment
Best in Consumer Lending AI – Natural Language
Understanding Tool for
Georgian Speech Technologies
Best Consumer Digital Bank Best Consumer Mobile
Banking App
Best Consumer Online
Product Offerings
Best Consumer Innovation and
Transformation
Best Consumer Bill Payment and
Presentment
Best in Consumer Lending
How we measure success
1,357K
+21.0% y-o-y
Digital MAU (Dec-23)
50.9%
+3.3 ppts y-o-y
Digital DAU/Digital MAU (Dec-23)
70.3%
+25.1 ppts y-o-y
Share of products sold digitally (4Q23)
1
75.0%
+6.3 ppts y-o-y
Share of Digital MAU in total active
retail customers (Dec-23)
2023 was a successful year for our
retail digital channels. The number of
digital MAU increased to 1,357K (up
21.0% y-o-y) and Digital DAU reached
691K (up 29.5% y-o-y) as at December
2023. It is noteworthy that our clients
are becoming more engaged with our
financial superapp, as reflected by the
increasing Digital DAU:Digital MAU
ratio – which stood at 50.9% (up 3.3 ppts
y-o-y) – and the share of Digital MAU
in total active retail customers, which
increased to 75.0% (up 6.3 ppts y-o-y)
as at December 2023.
In the fourth quarter the percentage
of products sold digitally rose to
70.3% (up 25.1 ppts y-o-y), partly
boosted by gamification in BOG APP.
To maximise their points in the game,
customers were assigned tasks such
as purchasing a product via the app
or completing a digital transaction,
which significantly boosted digital sales.
Several improvements were implemented
throughout the year, including
streamlining the deposit prolongation
flow – further contributing to the
increased share of products sold digitally.
Customer satisfaction with our digital
channels remained at a high level – the
CSAT score was 92% for BOG APP and
84% for iBank as at December 2023. In
response to customer feedback we also
launched dark mode in BOG APP.
In 2024, we will focus on digital acquisition
of new clients, including the transition of
adults from sCoolApp to BOG APP, as well
as boosting the engagement of current
clients by reimagining the offers page and
using AI-generated offers. In addition,
we plan to streamline the card delivery
process for clients who prefer physical
cards. We strive to execute all projects
with UX consistency and high quality.
Considering the increasing pace of
digitalisation as well as the growing
share of transactional activity happening
outside of branches, Bank of Georgia’s
Retail Banking strategy entails a gradual
transformation of transactional branches
into full-scale branches where customers
will be offered a full spectrum of banking
products together with advice. This
transformation will result in a gradual
reduction of transactional branches. The
number of total branches at 31 December
2023 was 189 (207 at 31 December 2022).
Out of 189 branches, 98 were so-called
transactional branches (down 17.6% y-o-y).
Global awards by Global Finance
Regional awards in Central and Eastern Europe by Global
Finance
1. In 2Q23, we changed the methodology of calculating the share of products sold digitally and currently include all types of products sold by Bank of Georgia. The previous
periods have been restated.
29
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Payments – a daily touchpoint with our
retail customers
Payments are an integral part of retail customers’ daily experience – often so seamlessly embedded that they happen multiple times
a day without users giving too much thought to the process. Being relevant in customers’ daily lives for us means being the leader in
the payments business, with excellent customer experience and innovative payment methods listed below:
In-store BNPL process for customers who have BNPL limits
takes not more than a minute. Customers tap their payment
cards or digital wallets to Bank of Georgia’s POS terminals
and receive an SMS asking them to click on a link to see the
terms and conditions and confirm the purchase with BNPL.
Afterwards, customers can see the newly activated BNPL with
its repayment schedule in the BOG APP. If they wish, customers
can prepay the BNPL without any charge.
Our main competitor in the payments business is cash, which, despite increasing digitalisation, is still widely used for payments.
We believe cashless payments benefit people, not just because they are easier and safer, but also because they open up other
possibilities, including:
During the past few years, we have significantly increased the number of retail
customers who used Bank of Georgia’s cards to make at least one payment within
a month. We call this payment monthly active user or Payment MAU.
In 2023, Bank of Georgia launched BNPL
for in-store payments, on top of already
offering BNPL online. BNPL, available
at more than 500 merchants, allows
four equal payments spread across four
months to be paid back over time, with
no interest paid by the consumer. Our
customers can activate and see their
BNPL limits in our financial superapp.
A list of merchants where BNPL works
as a payment method is also displayed in
the app.
Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL)
1,249K
+20.1% y-o-y
Payment MAU (Dec-23)
43.5%
Repeat rate
1
35K
Customers used BNPL
in 2023
Rewards such as cashback, discounts and more loyalty points.
Greater visibility of our customers’ needs and preferences, enabling us to make
more personalised offers.
Greater control over personal finances, giving people a clear and full view of where and how they
spend their money, so that they can better manage personal finances. The Personal Finance Manager
is available in our financial superapp.
Contact and
contactless card
payments
Apple Pay/
Google Pay
Payment with
loyalty points
(PLUS and MR)
BNPL QR
1. Share of individuals who used BNPL more than once.
30
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Number of daily average payment
transactions: 677
We celebrate the PLUS birthday each
year. PLUS points that customers
accumulate throughout the year double
on this day, and, as a result, PLUS
birthday is recognised as a major sales
event in Georgia among both retail
customers as well as merchants. This
event highlights the benefits of Bank of
Georgia’s loyalty programme, translating
the accumulation of loyalty points into
more tangible rewards that help sustain
our retail customers’ interest in using
Bank of Georgia’s cards, and hence a high
growth in Payment MAU described on
page 29. We believe the PLUS birthday is
an extra driver for increased engagement
among customers. The strength of
Bank of Georgia’s loyalty feeds into the
strength of Bank of Georgia’s acquiring
business, with more active merchants
in the network and more payment
transactions going through Bank of
Georgia’s acquiring.
PLUS birthday
30K
Number of unique clients exchanging PLUS points on
PLUS birthday
52K
Number of PLUS payment
transactions on PLUS birthday
1,298
+75.9% y-o-y
Total offers
(excl. SOLO-specific offers)
695,367
+42.9% y-o-y
Unique customers who exchanged
PLUS points at least once
523
PLUS-card specific offers
GEL 47,856,812
+89.8% y-o-y
Value of PLUS points exchanged
Loyalty and lifestyle
Bank of Georgia’s loyalty programme is
a driving force behind increasing cashless
payments and customer loyalty. Our
different lifestyle offers are tailored to
the needs and preferences of specific
segments. Besides mass retail customers,
we have special offers for sCool Card
holders, Student Card holders and
Premium Banking (SOLO and WM) clients.
As clients make transactions within
BOG’s acquiring network (physical POS
and online), they accumulate either
PLUS points when using debit cards
or Membership Rewards (MR) points
when using American Express credit
cards. Mass Retail Banking clients attain
different status levels based on their
activity with the Bank, with higher levels
unlocking greater benefits. This approach
not only encourages cashless transactions
but also strengthens customer stickiness.
We changed the loyalty programme
mechanics in 2021, from product-based
upgrades to product- and payment-based
upgrades. We offer a variety of benefits
to our loyalty programme members,
including discounts, cashback and PLUS
points. One of the main aspects of the
value proposition is the personalisation of
lifestyle offers.
In 2023, we remained committed to
strengthening the Bank’s advanced
analytics and AI capabilities, aiming to
improve efficiency, customer satisfaction
and loyalty. We use machine learning
models to provide non-financial offers
tailored to each customers unique needs
across different physical and online
ecosystems.
In 2023, we introduced location-based
offers for all retail clients, delivered
through push notifications. Customers
are notified about relevant promotions
while being nearby partner merchants. By
clicking on the notification, the BOG APP
directs clients to Google Maps, allowing
them to see the precise location through
a pinned marker, ensuring a user-friendly
and interactive engagement. We elevated
our location-based offers by introducing
location-based bundled offers tailored
to specific areas with high merchant
concentrations. When clients find
themselves in these targeted locations,
they get push notifications with diverse
offers available within that area. This
approach ensures clients can access a
variety of offers grouped in one location,
enhancing their overall experience with
our services.
In 2021, we launched PLUS – the
first American Express debit card
project in EMEA and the second
globally. Our PLUS card enables our
customers to get more benefits,
especially in daily use categories, due
to lower transaction costs.
A snapshot of 2023 loyalty offers
31
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
In Premium Banking, we go beyond just
partnering with merchants for lifestyle
offers. We not only offer special deals,
but also create experiences in travel,
entertainment, education and wellbeing.
In 2023, in response to customer
feedback, we expanded our range of
SOLO offers to better reflect the diverse
preferences and requirements of our
customers. Additionally, we introduced
more specialised offers, tailored
specifically to individual tastes and
needs. Even though Offers Hub is already
integrated within our financial superapp,
we took additional steps to enhance
communication with our premium clients
in 2023. We increased the frequency of
informative text messages, ensuring
customers stay well informed about the
latest lifestyle offers. This commitment
reflects our dedication to making sure
our clients are aware of the advantages
and privileges available to them and can
maximise their benefits. As a result, 66K
unique customers used SOLO offers in
2023 (up 93.9% y-o-y).
During 2023, responding to high demand
from our customers, we significantly
expanded the number of SOLO events
and projects and we focused on
enhancing the quality of event content. As
a result, we achieved a remarkable 83.1%
y-o-y increase in attendance at these
events. We are committed to providing
enriching and engaging experiences for
our customers.
Lifestyle experiences for Premium Banking clients
920
+34.7% y-o-y
SOLO-specific offers FY23
66K
+93.9% y-o-y
Unique clients who used SOLO
offers FY23
SOLO Talks
53
Discussions and meetings
with various professionals
SOLO One to One
2
Individual meetings with
famous professionals
66
SOLO Events
17
Big art and culture events
financed by SOLO
SOLO Kids
Educational and entertaining
activities for our clients’ children
SOLO Hobby
11
Outdoor/indoor activities to
help our clients discover new
interests
SOLO Workshop
4
Interactive events for
collaborative learning
Organised by SOLO.
SOLO Tours
3
International/local tours with interesting travellers
SOLO X
In early 2023, we introduced SOLO X, in
response to the demand from customers
seeking to get the same value proposition
as SOLO, but without the necessity of
having a personal banker and at a lower
fee. SOLO X instantly gained popularity
due to its exclusive benefits, resulting in
26K monthly active customers and 11K
unique customers using SOLO X offers.
32
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Through SOLO we give access to exclusive
products and the finest concierge-style
environment at our 11 specially designed
SOLO lounges located across Georgia.
SOLO is not your usual banking brand
– it is a blend of tailored financial help,
exclusive lifestyle experiences and
luxury brands, all in one spot. At SOLO
lounges, our clients are attended by
personal bankers who not only deliver
banking solutions but also offer luxury
goods and exclusive lifestyle experiences,
encompassing everything from special
events and concerts to unique travel
tours and the latest product offerings
at the SOLO Boutique. Responding to
the evolving preferences of our clients in
2023, we expanded our SOLO Boutique
assortment by introducing ten new
brands and increasing the variety of
products. Moreover, recognising the
importance of accessibility and comfort,
four sales assistants were specifically
assigned to two SOLO lounges, ensuring
enhanced and personalised experience for
our SOLO customers.
This unique blend of banking and lifestyle
offerings sustains the strong interest
in the SOLO brand. As at 31 December
2023, SOLO served around 125,000 active
customers, up 39.1% y-o-y, reflecting
the ongoing popularity of this brand.
SOLO Club, the highest subscription level
within SOLO, launched in 2017, offers
additional exclusive financial products and
lifestyle experiences, at a higher fee. One
such exclusive product is the American
Express Platinum card, available only
to SOLO Club members. In 2023, SOLO
strengthened the customer experience
with its Personal Concierge Service. Club
members benefit from personalised
assistance through dedicated contact
persons, ensuring a tailored and
responsive lifestyle experience. This
premium service seamlessly assists with
travel arrangements, event planning,
dining reservations and more, providing
an unparalleled level of support and
convenience.
33
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Lending journey
Bank of Georgia’s core business activity
is lending. We are committed to being
a responsible lender that supports
customers on every step of their lending
journey and enables them to fulfil their
needs. Lending is at the heart of Bank of
Georgia’s role in supporting the Georgian
economy. Responsible lending for us
means increasing access to finance whilst
ensuring that prudent risk management
practices as well as customer protection
principles are followed during the loan
underwriting process and throughout
the lifecycle of a loan. We aim to create
simpler end-to-end customer journeys for
loans, eliminating unnecessary barriers
and roadblocks.
Moving product sales to digital channels
is one of the ongoing focus areas for Bank
of Georgia’s digital agenda. Digitalisation
of the lending process is a big part
of the current efforts to design more
efficient processes with excellent user
experience. Lending processes vary for
different retail customer sub-segments
and different products. Bank of Georgia’s
digital lending gained speed in 2021
when we redesigned the unsecured
consumer lending flow in digital channels.
Currently, unsecured consumer lending
is almost fully automated and relatively
straightforward. Eligible customers who
give consent to the use of their data for
personalised offers can check and get
information on available credit limits
for unsecured loan types (including
instalments) as well as conditional
limits for secured loan types, including
mortgages, through the BOG APP. When
limits are available in BOG APP, activating
an unsecured consumer loan takes
seconds. The digitalisation of this process
resulted a high share of total number of
loans activated digitally.
76.5%
-0.8 ppts y-o-y
Share of total number of loans
activated digitally (4Q23)
During 2022-2023, we focused on
supporting self-employed retail
customers and making sure they have
access to the same products and services
as other retail customers. However, their
irregular income posed challenges for
income validation, requiring detailed
questionnaires to determine credit
eligibility. In 2023, we redesigned the
income validation process to eliminate
the need for long questionnaires and
instead relied on advanced models in the
back to fill out and analyse the necessary
financial data.
We also upgraded our analytical models
to be more independent of direct
client input. By making these fields
independent, we enhanced the accuracy
and reliability of our assessment process.
This allowed us to better understand
the financial dynamics of self-employed
individuals and offer more tailored
solutions to meet their needs. Ultimately,
these improvements streamlined the
validation process, making it more
efficient and less intrusive for the end-
user. Professional activity of clients is
being validated by a video call or/and, if
necessary, a site visit and a more detailed
study of the field of activity.
These changes allowed us to extend the
credit offerings to self-employed clients in
2023, and they are now able to access all
the available credit products.
Reaching more self-employed borrowers
has been one of the KPIs for Executive
Management (in 2023 and currently
in 2024). In 2023, the number of self-
employed borrowers was slightly short
of the target despite the fact that the
loan portfolio itself grew significantly.
The Retail Banking team continues to
be focused on reaching this segment,
especially outside of the capital city,
Tbilisi, and simplifying the user experience
to attract more customers into the
formal banking system.
Self-employed borrowers
In 2024, we aim to optimise and further
advance digitalisation of existing lending
processes to increase the share of
products sold digitally.
Several notable projects are currently
being developed: a fully digital lending
processes for secured consumer loans;
a feature allowing customers to sign
mortgage and secured agreements
digitally; E2E digital lending processes
for self-employed customers (including
income validation processes remotely).
Bank of Georgia will continue to work
on improving the user experience for
customers who are applying for any type
of lending product.
34
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
54.7K GEL 531.7M
+14.9% y-o-y
Self-employed borrowers
(Dec-23)
1
+45.9% y-o-y
Loan portfolio of self-employed clients
(Dec-23)
Savings – encouraging a savings culture
As a leading organisation in Georgia,
fostering a robust savings culture within
our community is not just a financial
imperative, it is also a commitment to
empowering individuals and supporting
economic resilience as savings are a key
component of peoples financial health.
Bank of Georgia has the leading retail
franchise in the Georgian market, which
is reflected in its leading market share in
deposits of individuals, standing at 45.3%
as at 31 December 2023 (44.4% as at
31 December 2022). The deposit franchise
is a competitive strength of any bank,
and we believe our focus on leadership
in daily banking and excellent customer
experience has significantly contributed
to the retail deposit franchise.
We believe that by encouraging savings,
we help foster a sense of security and
empowerment among individuals.
By providing simple products and services
to promote savings and make savings
easier, we equip our retail customers
with the tools they need to face financial
uncertainties and achieve their small or
big goals.
During 2023, we made our savings
products more flexible and accessible
for our customers, with a focus on
encouraging the use of digital channels.
We provided employees at our branches
with an extra incentive to educate
customers on opening digital deposits
through BOG APP. We also continued to
offer higher rates on deposits opened
through BOG APP.
For Premium Banking (SOLO) customers,
we have an upgraded demand deposit,
‘Premium’. SOLO clients receive a higher
return on this deposit, with rates linked
to the monetary policy rate.
Throughout the year, more customers
used a digital piggy bank – accumulating
money by automatically transferring a
pre-defined amount after every purchase.
Towards the end of the year, an uptick
in customers with a digital piggy bank
was related to gamification in BOG APP,
however, even without gamification,
the trajectory of growth of customers
with a digital piggy bank was good, and
in December 2023, this figure stood at
304.2K. To read more about how Bank of
Georgia encourages young people to save
money, see page 37.
69.7% 313.7K 304.2K
+33.0 ppts y-o-y
The share of deposits
activated digitally
(4Q23)
+3.4% y-o-y
Retail customers with
an active saving deposit
(Dec-23)
+179.6% y-o-y
Retail customers with an
active piggy bank account
(Dec-23)
Savings highlights
1. Individuals whose share of income from self-employment exceeds 50% and who do not own a business/are not registered as individual entrepreneurs.
35
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Investments – an alternative
savings method
At the end of 2021 Bank of Georgia,
together with the Groups subsidiary JSC
Galt & Taggart (G&T) and in partnership
with a US brokerage house DriveWealth
LLC, launched a retail brokerage platform
– BOG Investments – in Bank of Georgia’s
financial superapp, giving Bank of
Georgia’s retail customers access to the
US stock market. BOG Investments offers
our retail customers low-cost trading and
fractional trading options.
Throughout 2023, we enhanced BOG
Investments by adding two new
functionalities:
Account reactivation – users can now
reactivate their deactivated accounts,
eliminating the need for them to
create new accounts, which previously
used to be a time-consuming process.
Instant cash-out – previously, users
needed two business days for
transferring funds to their bank
accounts, followed by additional
two days for cash-outs. In 2023, we
enhanced this process, making cash-outs
quicker and more efficient. Now, instead
of waiting for two additional business
days, users can enjoy immediate access
to their funds, up to $5,000, directly
from our investment platform as soon
as the funds become available in their
bank accounts.
In addition to BOG Investments, G&T
offers brokerage solutions through
two accounts: execution brokerage, an
offline brokerage account with personal
broker services, and G&T Trading solution
through trader.ge, a white-label solution
in partnership with Saxo Bank. Through
these accounts we provide access to more
complex products to affluent and high-net-
worth individuals and more experienced
investors, including legal entities.
In 2023, we focused on increasing
awareness of our investment platform
through gamification within BOG APP.
Additionally, we published educational
content to give users the knowledge
of fundamental investing concepts.
Consequently, our efforts led to a
significant increase in active users, with the
number reaching c.45K in 2023 compared
with c.19K in 2022. Going forward, our
priority will be to enhance user activity and
engagement within the platform.
1.1K 487 30+
200+ TV c.3.0M
We see potential in retail brokerage in
Georgia over the medium-to-long term,
however this type of product is new to
the market and currently our efforts are
focused on making sure more people
understand what investing is, and what
kind of risks and benefits it entails.
To promote investing and general
financial literacy in 2023, we primarily
used three channels: media, our own
social networks, and events. Through
collaborations with prominent business
media in Georgia, we actively provided
educational content and comprehensive
insights into financial and economic
developments, including updates on
global financial markets. During 2023 we
also hosted events, including SOLO Talks,
aimed at meaningful discussions around
investment strategies and financial
planning. Expanding on our educational
initiatives, we introduced a course on
investments on our educational platform,
businesscourse.ge, in 2023. Additionally,
a subsidiary of the Group, G&T, publishes
analyses of investment opportunities,
including analyses of global commodities
and assessments of global equity and
fixed income markets.
Media Social network Events
Written pieces Posts
Business channel visits People reached
c.45K
c.19K in 2022
Active users of BOG Investments
36
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Empowering
young people
We surpassed our 2023 year-end target of
70K sCoolApp MAU, reaching up to 90K school
students as at December 2023
A sketch from sCoolApp gamification
37
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
We believe that financial education
should start early in childhood to help kids
develop financial literacy skills and money
management habits that will set them up for
financial security and wellbeing later in life.
Bank of Georgia is focused on seamlessly
onboarding children and young people into
the formal financial system, equipping
them with critical financial literacy skills and
offering support through accessible daily
banking solutions and tailored offers that
respond to their needs.
We offer a free account and a daily
banking card, sCool Card, to school
students, and a free and specially
designed mobile app – sCoolApp.
When launched at the end of 2022,
sCoolApp was the first financial
application for children in Georgia, with
an average user aged 14. Launched in
October 2022, it keeps young people safe
with our end-to-end security, spending
alerts, custom limits and in-app card
controls. With necessary features as well
as sounds, haptics and fun elements,
sCoolApp is becoming a daily app for
young people.
In 2023 we added new features to sCoolApp to further enhance children’s financial journey and daily engagement.
Stories
Gamification – the Other Universe
We launched ‘Stories’, a captivating
addition to sCoolApp that puts financial
education in the spotlight for young users,
on the home screen.
Each week sCoolApps main dashboard
is refreshed with engaging content
on effective money management
principles, including saving, budgeting
and thoughtful spending from an early
age, cultivating positive money habits for
future financial wellbeing.
In October 2023 we launched ‘Other
Universe’ in sCoolApp – a game where
students embark on a captivating journey
by answering simple yet thought-provoking
questions from history, general knowledge,
financial education and logic. Correct
answers rewarded school students with
a unique currency – ‘glitters’ – allowing
users to discover and explore diverse ways
to use their rewards while navigating and
conquering missions within the alternate
realm. The purpose of the game was to
engage more school students in the app
and raise awareness of the apps features
and functionalities.
68K
Users who
started the game
Other Universe
In 2023, we built ChatGPT within sCoolApp, allowing users to get instant
information about any topic.
ChatGPT
In 2023, we added a Bill split feature to sCoolApp, empowering users to
effortlessly divide expenses.
Bill split
In 2023 we built PFM (Personal Financial Manager) within sCoolApp, allowing
users to manage their finances by providing a categorised breakdown of their
spending, revealing where they spend the most money.
PFM
We also added a digital
‘piggy bank’ to sCoolApp,
helping foster a savings
culture from an early age.
Piggy bank
sCoolApp
34K
+162.0% y-o-y
Active sCoolApp users with
an active piggy bank account
(Dec-23)
38
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
77%
Tbilisi
63%
Rustavi
41%
Batumi
52%
Zugdidi
sCool Card benefits
Can be ordered on our website or through the app
Free card
Free SMS, mobile and internet banking
Free public transportation in Tbilisi and Batumi;
discounts in Zugdidi and Rustavi
No fee on BOG ATM withdrawal
Loyalty programme: accumulation of sCool points
Growing engagement among school students in Georgia
To read more about financial education initiatives, see page 89-90
142K
61.0% y-o-y
Active sCool Card holders (Dec-23)
116K
82.5% y-o-y
Payment MAU (Dec-23)
Share of total number of pupils having a sCool Card
We understand that being financially
literate is more than just understanding
numbers – it is a skill that influences day-
to-day decisions and long-term financial
stability. To enhance financial literacy
among young people, we offered diverse
resources, programmes, workshops and
tools to school students in 2023.
Together with USAID and Georgian
Economic Literacy initiative (GELi), we
provided students with basic knowledge
of financial education and encouraged
interest in economy and finance. We also
supported the first financial education
Olympiad in the country. Students in
grades 7-12 participated in this event.
The Olympiad was a one-round event,
held remotely, thus allowing students
living in Georgia’s regions to participate
and test their knowledge. A series of
lectures were given to interested students
to prepare for the Olympiad. In 2024,
we will expand our focus on financial
education.
39
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Students
Can be ordered on our website or through the app
Free card
Free SMS, mobile and internet banking
Public transportation benefits
Loyalty programme: special offers and accumulation of
PLUS points
For years Bank of Georgia has focused on
onboarding and increasing engagement
with university students in Georgia.
According to an independent third-party
research, we are the most trusted and
top-of-mind bank for young people aged
18-24 in Georgia.
1
We believe everyone
in this age group is aware of Bank of
Georgia. Ten Georgian universities are
enrolled in Bank of Georgia’s payroll
programme.
Our partnerships with universities enable us to reach more students and involves different
activities, including:
1. Based on independent research conducted by IPM Georgia. ‘Top-of-Mind’ refers to the first brand that comes to a person’s mind when they are asked
an unprompted question about particular industry or category. Figure presented is as of 4Q23.
196K
15.9% y-o-y
Active Student Card
holders (Dec-23)
190K
18.1% y-o-y
Digital MAU (Dec-23)
153K
22.7% y-o-y
Payment MAU (Dec-23)
Distributing Student Cards directly from university buildings
Designing student spaces
Financial support in organising student graduations and anniversaries
Short-term internship programmes for students, along with ‘Leaderator’ – Bank of Georgia’s flagship
programme for motivated undergraduates
40
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Fulfilling business customer needs
Coverage of business clients
Daily business operations
Business growth and development
Sales
Process optimisation
We serve a broad spectrum of business
clients, including small and medium-sized
enterprises (SMEs) and large corporate
clients. We understand that each business
is a unique entity, influenced by its
own distinct characteristics – be it the
intricacies of its business model, the scale
of its operations, or the financial landscape
it navigates. Just like people, businesses
evolve and grow – and so do their needs.
Customer-centricity for us means listening
to different businesses and understanding
their needs to design financial solutions
that support our clients at different stages
of their business development journeys.
We strive to be more than just a provider
of banking products for our clients –
we want to be a trusted partner for
businesses, offering a comprehensive
suite of products and services including
value-added services such as personalised
advisory and access to business education
and insights. Deepening customer
relationships is one of our top priorities
and increasing engagement among
our business customers is a focus area
for both SME Banking and Corporate
Banking directions.
Our interaction with business clients
is multifaceted, including dedicated
relationship managers and dedicated
business branches, 4Bs. At the same time,
we pursue a digital strategy and continue
to develop separate digital channels for
businesses – Business mBank and iBank.
In 2023 we continued to improve
our processes and functionalities in
digital channels to enhance the overall
experience for our business clients. As
a result, the number of monthly active
business clients grew by 20.2% y-o-y as of
31 December 2023.
97.8K monthly active legal entities
+20.2% y-o-y
SME Banking: 93.9K
+20.2% y-o-y
Corporate and Investment Banking: 3.8K
+21.0% y-o-y
4B branch
We are committed to delivering excellent
customer service to our business
clients through various channels and
touchpoints, with a particular focus on
improving the digital experience.
Bank of Georgia has different coverage
models for SME and Corporate business
customers. SME clients can be served
in a variety of ways, including through
dedicated relationship managers who offer
personalised support and provide end-
to-end assistance, and remote bankers
who can handle client requests remotely.
Some customers are served fully through
digital channels. In 2020, Bank of Georgia
opened its first special business branch,
4B, in Tbilisi. In 2023, a second 4B branch
opened in Tbilisi – further strengthening
our commitment to the SME segment. 4B
serves as a hub for fostering networking
opportunities among businesses, and it
is a special place where business clients
can meet their relationship managers,
hold meetings, and participate in different
events that Bank of Georgia hosts
throughout the year.
41
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
4B
Call centre
and chat
Retail
branches
Remote
bankers
Business
bankers
Relationship
managers
Digital
channels
MAIN TOUCHPOINTS
WITH BUSINESS
CLIENTS
Manufacturing
17.1%
Real estate
20.3%
Trade
10.2%
Agriculture,
hunting and
forestry
9.0%
Construction
1.5%
Electricity, gas
and water supply
10.1%
Hospitality
11.2%
Other
16.1%
Financial
intermediation
4.5%
Individual
entrepreneurs
54.7%
Other
9.0%
Trade
12.9%
Manufacturing
6.1%
Construction
6.0%
Real estate
3.9%
Agriculture, hunting
and forestry
2.5%
Hospitality
4.9%
Our customer coverage model for
Corporate clients is led by skilled
relationship managers equipped with
advanced financial tools and sector-
specific expertise. Strengthening industry
knowledge is our top priority, reflecting
our commitment to staying ahead of
market trends.
In 2023, we restructured our teams into
new sectors, enabling us to deliver
personalised financial solutions and
guidance tailored to the unique needs
of our Corporate clients. This approach
ensures our clients receive high-quality,
customised support.
We prioritise enhancing our digital
platforms to help our business clients
efficiently manage their daily tasks quickly
and independently – freeing up valuable
time for personalised guidance and
business support from the Bank.
Alongside in-person assistance, our big
Corporate clients can also benefit from
specialised advisory services offered by
the Groups wholly-owned subsidiary G&T.
JSC Bank of Georgia has well-diversified
Corporate Banking and SME Banking
loan portfolios. As at 31 December 2023,
top 10 borrowers in Corporate Banking
accounted for 7.3% of the Groups gross
loan portfolio (vs 5.9% as at 31 December
2022). The y-o-y increase in concentration
was driven by loans disbursed to a large
corporate client towards the end of the
year, however, the concentration risk
remains prudently managed by the Bank.
Corporate Banking continues to
focus on strengthening its position in
high-growth economic sectors and
deepening relationships with customers
in key sectors where Bank of Georgia
holds lower market shares. Further
improvement of customer coverage and
relationship management is one of the
main focus areas across both CB and
SME Banking directions.
Corporate Banking gross loans by sector: SME Banking gross loans by sector:
42
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Our business digital ecosystem
Business iBank
BOG.GE/Business
Business mBank
Business Manager
Central to our dedication to operational
excellence through digitalisation are
our award-winning digital channels for
business clients – a mobile app called
Business mBank and an internet banking
platform called Business iBank.
Since the launch of Business iBank and
mBank, we have continually refined and
improved these platforms to provide simple
and user-friendly digital experiences to our
business customers and support them in
managing daily operations as well as in
making more informed business decisions.
Our business mobile and internet bank
Credit
Savings
Daily
banking
For merchants
Digital confirmation of loans (available
for some types)
Pre-approved credit limits
activation
Credit line management
Credit leads
Loan prepayment
Tender guarantee
1
Factoring
1
Business
support
Collection of third-
party offers tailored
to business needs
End-to-end deposit
activation
Transactions
Payments
Business card: ordering
and management
Digital business card:
ordering and
management
Currency exchange
Statements
Templates
Treasury transfers
Money request
1
Payroll management
1
Packaged transfers
1
User access
management
1
SMS bank
1
POS payments history
E-commerce payments history
PLAY STORE 4.9/5
APP STORE 4.9/5
CSAT
90% in 4Q23
(85% in 4Q22)
1. Available only in Business iBank.
43
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
While we consistently strive to enhance
digital channels and increase the range
of products available digitally, we see
more upside and room for further
improvement. While transactionally
business customers have become highly
digital, with more than 95% of daily
transactions happening outside of
physical branches, we still need to work
on designing end-to-end digital product
journeys. Unlike in retail, business lending
is still at an early stage of digitalisation,
and it will continue to be one of the main
focus areas going forward.
Our aspiration in SME Banking is to have
end-to-end digital lending, and some
of the ongoing consulting projects and
initiatives are directed at developing
appropriate models and redesigning
processes to enable the Bank to move to
a more digital business lending.
How we measure success
74K
+28.6% y-o-y
Digital MAU (Dec-23)
19.1M
+46.3% y-o-y
Number of transactions
in Business mBank and
iBank (2023)
Global awards by Global Finance 2023
Regional awards in Central and Eastern Europe by Global Finance 2023
Best Corporate Mobile
Banking App
Top Innovator in SME for
Api.bog.ge
Top Innovator in eCommerce
for Payment Manager
Best Corporate Mobile
Banking App
Best Corporate Innovation
and Transformation
Best Corporate Trade
Finance Services
What we did in 2023
Digitalisation of deposits
Digital activation of deposits was previously available only in
Business iBank, and in 2023 it was added to Business mBank
as well. In addition, we introduced a new deposit product
– collectable deposit, to promote a savings culture among
businesses. This deposit is currently available only in Business
iBank, but it is expected to be added to Business mBank during
the first half of 2024.
Digital tender guarantees
Customers can now activate a tender guarantee of up to GEL
15,000 in digital channels.
Digital signature
Once a loan is approved, borrowers can now digitally confirm
unsecured and secured loan contracts without visiting a branch,
thus activating a loan digitally. This process is currently available
for secured loans only if a borrower has already pledged
collateral to the Bank.
Fast loans
Fast loan is a pre-approved loan limit activation, available
instantly in digital channels.
Simplified onboarding and remote banking
A successful relationship with SMEs starts at the onboarding
stage, and a smooth and simple onboarding process is critical
for customer satisfaction. We simplified the onboarding process
to allow business account opening remotely, without a branch
visit. Customers can undergo this process independently or with
the help of a remote banker who can facilitate the onboarding
process via a call.
This process has contributed to more than 52% of customer
onboarding happening digitally in Dec-23 compared with just
around 13.0% in Dec-22.
Offers Hub for businesses
Our business customers can see different third-party service
offerings in digital channels. These offerings include accounting
services, business consulting, marketing, HR services, among
others. Our clients can see different third-party offers in one
space and leave a request for a follow-up.
Tailored business sets
Following extensive preparation in 2023, in January 2024
we rolled out business sets, a packaged offering including
products as well as transactional services differentiated for
SME customers of different sizes and needs. Previously, all
SME customers had to pay a fixed monthly fee irrespective of
their needs. By tailoring sets to suit different business sizes and
needs, we strive to provide a more tailored banking experience
and make fees more transparent for our customers. Recognising
the unique needs of early-stage businesses, we also added
‘Startup’ subscription set, which includes free accounting service
for the first three months from our partner accounting firms.
Enabling local businesses, especially smaller ones, to implement
proper accounting practices continues to be one of our priorities.
44
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Bank of Georgia is the leading payments
acquirer in Georgia. By prioritising user
experience and service quality, the Bank
has been focused on increasing digital
payments by encouraging more individuals
to use cashless payment methods and
expanding the network of merchant clients.
We also empower merchants to embrace
digitalisation, driving the growth of
e-commerce businesses in Georgia.
Merchant solutions
18.3K
+26.4% y-o-y
Active merchants
Highlights of 2023
596
+27.6% y-o-y
Active e-commerce merchants
GEL 15.0B
54.9%
+46.5% y-o-y
Volume of transactions in Bank
of Georgia’s acquiring (2023)
+3.7 ppts y-o-y
Market share by volume
(Dec-23)
We offer a variety of online and offline payment solutions:
In-store
Online
Diversity of payment methods
including Apple Pay, Google
Pay, all international payment
cards, BNPL and loyalty points
(PLUS/MR)
POS terminal
(standard,
Android-based)
All international
cards
Loyalty points
(PLUS and MR)
BNPL Instalments
Recurring
payments
E-invoicing Apple Pay Google Pay
Two-in-one solution – cash
register is integrated with a
POS terminal
POS terminal with
cash register
Fully certified application
for any Android phone, with
‘PIN on glass’ functionality
and no monthly fee (we use a
transaction-based fee model)
Soft POS terminal on
any Android NFC device
45
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Business Manager is still at an early stage of use and development, and 2024 will be a year of focus on its uptake and technical
development.
In 2023 we introduced Business Manager
– a digital platform equipped with
merchant solutions vital for supporting
business operations and development.
Running the daily operations effectively
and growing sales are two of the few
critical questions that business customers
grapple with and need answers to. Bank
of Georgia’s Business Manager is a digital
platform combining three merchant
solutions that are designed to help
businesses answer these questions.
Business Manager – responding to business needs
Being able to accept a variety
of payment methods is a top
priority for lots of businesses.
With a single integration,
businesses can take all the payment
methods that Bank of Georgia offers,
in-store and online, including Google Pay,
Apple Pay, loyalty points, BNPL, and loan
instalments, among others. Users can
manage payments on this platform and
see transaction analytics – a significant
perk that allows businesses to have a full
view of what kind of customers they have,
when most of the activity happens, which
products are more popular, among others.
They can use this data to make more
informed business decisions and increase
operational efficiency by targeting the
right customers at the right time with the
right products.
Ads Manager combines
customer analytics with a
campaign management tool
to help businesses plan and
executive special campaigns targeting
different customer segments. The
campaign management tool allows
businesses to reach their target audience
through Bank of Georgia’s retail digital
channels, used by c.1.4 million monthly
digital active users. Previously, the
campaign management process was a
fully manual process coordinated with the
Bank. With Ads Manager, businesses can
initiate campaigns, which will be reviewed
and assessed in the back by the Bank, and
in case of agreement, launched with pre-
set criteria.
Combines all available API
services provided by Bank of
Georgia, granting access to
critical functionalities such
as Business iBank, Open Banking, and
BOG ID API services, enabling a seamless
integration of banking features into
digital platforms or software.
Payment Manager Ads Manager API Manager
Payment Manager
Ads Manager
API Manager
Payment aggregator with
one integration
Card payment
Online instalment
BNPL
Loyalty points
Google Pay
Apple Pay
Fully digital onboarding
Payment management
Reports
Transactional analytics
Create offers and
distribute through BOG
digital channels
Access to BOG’s c.1.4M
digital MAU
User analytics based on:
Demographic
Interests
Income
Behaviour
Detailed offer analytics
based on:
Number of sales
Expenses
List of transactions
BOG ID
Open Banking
Business Internet Bank
API
Billing
46
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Business education and support
Supporting businesses is vital for
economic growth, job creation, and
community development. We believe
that successful businesses contribute to
innovation. To best assist our SME clients,
we have a comprehensive approach
that combines financial support with
a range of value-added services aimed
at fostering success. Bank of Georgia’s
initiatives encompass various supportive
measures.
These include targeted capacity-
building programmes, focused on
specific skills, such as marketing
and leadership. Additionally, our
clients benefit from expert advice to
navigate the market effectively, as
well as valuable introductions and
networkingopportunities.
We believe that education, information
sharing, and the development of
professional networks play pivotal roles
throughout the entire business lifecycle.
By combining financial assistance with
these multifaced support mechanisms,
we aim to empower our SME clients and
contribute significantly to their sustained
growth and prosperity.
A critical challenge confronting SMEs
in their pursuit of financial support
is the absence of robust accounting
practices. Bank of Georgia’s Accounting
Development Programme is designed
to empower SMEs by addressing
critical accounting challenges and
fostering financial inclusion. Through
collaborations with local accounting firms,
this programme promotes increased
transparency and proper financial
management.
The Accounting Development Programme
focuses on three areas: comprehensive
accounting services, digitalisation and
quick financial information sharing.
Through partnerships with global entities
like Visa and leading accounting firms,
SMEs receive discounted accounting
services. This enables them to fully
outsource their accounting practices,
gain access to digital tools and automate
accounting-related processes. After
having improved accounting practices,
our clients become able to integrate their
accounting softwares with the Bank,
which streamlines loan applications
and allows us to offer tailored solutions
for SMEs. As part of the programme,
we also conduct workshops for our
clients, emphasising the significance of
implementing sound accounting practices
for sustainable growth and development.
In 2023, we conducted three regional
business forums, focusing on effective
strategies for accessing finance, and
seven masterclass workshops, focusing on
raising financial awareness.
We understand that businesses require
more than just financial support to
succeed. That is why we facilitate
access to different advisory services and
networking opportunities for our SME
clients. Spanning from in-depth market
analysis to crafting expansion strategies,
we help businesses make informed
decisions and overcome challenges.
Through our events and platforms, we
connect SMEs with partners, suppliers,
and customers, fostering collaboration
and growth.
Improving accounting and
financial literacy
Supporting women entrepreneurs
Advisory and networking
support
Providing essential business insights
and relevant research reports
We support businesses through
The following projects were executed throughout 2023, unless otherwise stated.
Improving accounting and financial literacy
Advisory and networking support
47
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
300+
Women entrepreneurs reached
GEL 1.0BN
Gross loan portfolio of women-owned SMEs
1
(Dec-23)
1. Small and medium-sized enterprises wherein more than 50% ownership is held by
women.
Business offers
We have collated a list of 80 third-party business consulting firms who can provide
marketing, accounting services, tax assurance, HR and business consulting, to our SME
clients, often at a discount. The list of different offerings is accessible through our
Business mBank and iBank.
Trade mission to Uzbekistan
We organised trade mission to Uzbekistan and facilitated B2B meetings for ICT
companies and construction materials manufacturing companies with local public and
private sector organisations, building strong connections that can lead to potential
business opportunities. We believe supporting international business collaboration can
lead to increased investments, job creation and overall economic development.
Advisory
Networking
B2B Forum and Agro B2B Forum
In partnership with the USAID Economic Security Program, we organised a B2B
forum for SMEs, connecting entrepreneurs and customer companies across various
sectors. The forum enabled businesses to make new connections and explore
potential partnerships for the future. We also organised a B2B agro-forum with the
USAID Agriculture Program and EFSE Entrepreneurship Academy, to support export
opportunities and market access for Georgian entrepreneurs.
Supporting women entrepreneurs
We are committed to empowering
women entrepreneurs and have crafted
specialised programmes and initiatives
to empower them. Recognising the
crucial role women play in economic
development, innovation and societal
progress, we believe financing and
supporting women-led businesses is
a key towards a more inclusive and
vibrant business ecosystem. By providing
educational resources, development
opportunities and networking
platforms, we aim to encourage women
entrepreneurs to excel and become
impactful leaders in the modern business
landscape.
Workshops for women entrepreneurs
In collaboration with the EFSE Entrepreneurship Academy, we
conducted a series of workshops designed to empower women
entrepreneurs who manage relatively small businesses. These
sessions covered a range of essential topics including digital
marketing strategies, employment practices, e-commerce
approaches, and change management in dynamic and uncertain
business landscapes.
School of women entrepreneurs
In partnership with the United Nations Development
Programme (UNDP) we established the School of Women
Entrepreneurs. This initiative supports women’s leadership in
business and successfully trained 170 women entrepreneurs
in 2023. It offers a comprehensive curriculum encompassing
hard and soft skills. It also facilitates access to financing
opportunities and a strong partnership network.
200+
Businesses took advantage
ofthis opportunity
16
Companies participated
up to 180
Companies and entrepreneurs
participated
48
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
AI
Providing relevant business insights and research reports
Improving access to information and
knowledge is one of the many ways
in which we strive to support local
businesses on their development journeys.
Our commitment involves developing
and maintaining a comprehensive
knowledge base covering industry trends,
market analysis, and best practices. We
customise the delivery of this knowledge
to meet the unique needs and goals
of different business clients, ensuring
relevance to customers operating in
diverse industries.
Throughout 2023, we continued to develop our educational
platform, Businesscourse.ge. In 2023, we curated and developed
12 additional business courses covering a range of diverse topics.
Currently, we have a collection of 43 business courses. Our goal
is to offer content that would be relevant to businesses from
different industries.
Expanding Businesscourse.ge
7,500+
Business representatives completed business
courses in 2023
3
Webinars
17
Meetings
Webinars and business meetings
In addition to self-paced courses, we hold webinars and
meetings throughout the year on diverse subjects, including
changes in different regulations that local businesses should
be aware of. Ourgoal is to keep SMEs informed about
developments that may affect them, be it economic trends or
upcoming regulatory changes and compliance needs. We also
organise interactive business meetings to foster networking and
knowledge sharing among entrepreneurs and industry experts.
ESG INVESTMENTS DIGITAL
MARKETING
FINANCE EXPORTS HUMAN CAPITAL
DEVELOPMENT
AI
49
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
100
Reports published on macro-
economic, capital markets,
and sector-specific topics
in 2023 (available at: www.gt.ge)
10,000+
Subscribers reached
in 2023
7
Conferences organised
in 2023
G&T publishes weekly, monthly and
quarterly insights and analyses related
to global and local macroeconomic
development as well as sector-specific
reports. G&T also provides reports
tailored to clients’ needs, including
analyses on investment opportunities. To
respond to the dynamic global and local
environment, G&T consistently refines
its products to meet market needs. In
2023, G&T added new research products
to the publication list, including monthly
analyses of global commodities and
assessments of the global equity and
fixed income markets. Additionally, G&T
has launched a series covering agricultural
products, driven by heightened interest
from the business community.
G&T expanded its custom research
client-base, undertaking projects
commissioned by international
development organisations. To engage
with our target audience, G&T uses social
media channels and maintains its TV
presence through regular macro updates
and sector-specific interviews on local
business media.
Galt & Taggart’s research products are
also available on leading proprietary
platforms, including Bloomberg,
ThomsonReuters, S&P Capital IQ,
FactSet, and Tellimer, bolstering our
international presence.
G&T provides financial advisory services
to private and public companies, private
equity houses and high-net-worth
individuals in both domestic and cross-
border transactions. G&T’s DCM/ECM
services include support in accessing local,
regional and international debt and equity
capital markets. G&T has participated
in the majority of FX-denominated local
bond issuances and during the past ten
years it has assisted local businesses and
International Financial Institutions (IFIs)
in raising GEL 4.2 billion in public bonds
through the local capital market. G&T
has also acted as a co-manager for more
than US$ 2.3 billion Eurobonds since 2016.
Throughout 2023, G&T acted as a
placement agent for 12 public corporate
bonds amounting to around GEL 787
million – six of these corporates were
Bank of Georgia’s Corporate Banking
clients – and an IFI bond of GEL 260
million. In 2023, G&T was also the only
Georgian investment bank that executed
a EUR-denominated issuance – the
transaction was the first of its kind
among non-financial corporates.
In 2022, G&T’s corporate advisory unit
was involved in the CMS Programme
funded by the EU and implemented by
the EBRD’s Capital & Financial Markets
Development team. Its aim was to
raise awareness of capital markets,
develop incentives for companies to
access capital markets, and implement a
mechanism to co-finance costs related to
capital markets access. The programme
concluded in August 2023, with 11 out
of 21 registered issuers successfully
placing securities, including six debut
issuers on the capital market. Introducing
innovation, the programme launched five
innovative securities, including the first
Green bond on the local market. The total
value of issued securities reached around
GEL 439 million.
The programme has also had a broad
positive impact through its educational
initiatives and public efforts.
In 2023, G&T became one of the
implementing partners of a five-year
programme to enhance the flow of
diversified investment resources and
innovative financial products to Georgia’s
private sector. Running until 2028 and
with a budget of US$ 18.9 million, the
programme aims to expand businesses,
create jobs and attract additional
privateinvestment.
Galt & Taggart research
Corporate advisory and DCM/ECM support through Galt & Taggart
Highlights of 2023
Capital Market Support (CMS) Programme
USAID Georgia Financial Innovation (FIP) Program
JSC Georgia Capital US$
150M sustainability-linked
bonds
The largest corporate bond
issuance on the Georgian
capitalmarket, with G&T
actingas a placement agent.
Tegeta Motors US$ 30M multi-
currency bond programme
As the exclusive arranger,
G&Tplayed a pivotal role in this
transaction, marking the first multi-
currency and Euro corporate bond
issuance inGeorgia.
GeoSteel US$ 30M
sustainability-linked bond
With exclusive support from
G&T, GeoSteel, the largest steel
producer in Georgia, successfully
issued and placed the first
sustainability-linked bonds on
the Georgian market.
50
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Digital Area snapshot
JSC Digital Area is a Groups subsidiary
comprising several portfolio companies,
focused predominantly on e-commerce
and merchant solutions. Digital Area
actively manages portfolio companies
to maturity, setting the strategy and
business plan of each business and driving
its execution.
Digital Area’s strategy is to build
interconnected digital services to fulfil the
needs of its customers in an integrated
experience.
Extra: e-marketplace
800+
Merchants
120+
Products
GEL 16.0M
Gross merchandise value
+77.0% y-o-y
accelerating early-
stage startups
lightweight POS
and inventory
management SaaS
on-demand
everyday goods
delivery service
online ticketing
marketplace
leading e-commerce
marketplace
70.8K
+120.1% y-o-y
Orders
Extra maintains a leading position
in Georgia, offering a wide variety of
products to its customers. The platform
focuses on facilitating B2C transactions,
efficiently connecting merchants with
a broad consumer base and enriching
the digital shopping experience with
integrated payment options. Extra has
positioned itself as an e-commerce
marketplace with a wide selection of
products and competitive prices.
Beyond catering to individual consumers,
Extra also extends its services to the
corporate sector, offering a robust B2B
solution for comprehensive procurement
needs. The company’s commitment to
accessibility and convenience is evident in
its nationwide delivery coverage.
With a wide array of product offerings,
Extra’s top categories by GMV include
electronics, home and garden, express
grocery services, sports and travel,
pet care, and beauty products. Extra
continues to focus on building its
reputation as a leader in Georgia’s
e-marketplace, driving the industry
forward through its commitment to
customer satisfaction.
In 2023, Extra’s service offering was
enhanced with the integration of
moitane.ge, a leading quick-commerce
platform, into its website and mobile
application. This has led to the launch of
‘Extra Express’, guaranteeing fast delivery,
within an hour, for a wide selection of
products across six categories, including
groceries and personal care items. Initially
operational in Tbilisi and Batumi, ‘Extra
Express’ is focused on ensuring a fast and
convenient shopping convenience.
Extra is dedicated to curating a diverse
shopping experience that caters to
various customer needs and preferences,
ranging from the latest trends and daily
essentials to unique finds. This dedication
is mirrored in its high NPS of 77, as
of 4Q23, reflecting a strong focus on
customer satisfaction.
Extra collaborates with leading financial
institutions in Georgia, including Bank of
Georgia. The partnership with Bank of
Georgia has facilitated the integration
of a variety of payment solutions,
including the BNPL option, thus
accommodating the diverse financial
needs of its customer base.
51
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Bank of Georgia Group PLC initiated the
500 Georgia acceleration programme
in 2020, in a strategic partnership with
500 Global and Georgia’s Innovation
and Technology Agency (GITA). This
collaboration was designed to fast-
track the development of both Georgian
and international early-stage startups
operating in the region. During 2020-2021,
28 companies from 11 business sectors
successfully completed the programme
and were integrated into the Digital Area
ecosystem.
Considering the traction of the first
rounds of acceleration, Bank of Georgia
Group PLC committed to a five-year
partnership with 500 Georgia and GITA.
In November 2022, Digital Area made a
substantial commitment of $5 million
to the $20 million 500 Georgia Fund.
An additional US$ 7 million has been
successfully secured, with the remaining
US$ 8 million slated for collection by the
end 2024. Over the course of our five-year
partnership, the fund aims to allocate
these resources towards fostering the
growth of up to 150 emerging startups.
In 2023, we celebrated a major
achievement: successfully graduating 30
regional startups from eight different
countries. We remain committed to
contributing to a vibrant, cross-border
startup ecosystem that empowers
businesses and fosters economic
development in Georgia.
Optimo is a digital inventory and
sales management software with an
integrated POS solution for traditional
retail and e-commerce businesses.
Optimo enables merchants to manage
inventory, accept online payments,
and access analytics on transactions,
inventory, revenues and profitability,
anytime and anywhere. Optimo covers
two main business lines: software as a
service (SaaS) and data monetisation.
In 2023, Optimo increased sales points
to 2,952, covering 39 cities in Georgia,
with an additional regional office opened
in Kutaisi. In addition to this, at the end
of 2023, Optimo increased value-added
services from different business verticals
up to 20 partners.
Furthermore, Optimo has started
partnerships with MasterCard, USAID
and EBRD. With these partnerships,
Optimo aims to support MSME
merchants by enabling digital
transformation.
In 2023, Optimo entered Uzbekistan and
opened an office in Tashkent. Optimo
product localisation has already been
completed and a growing Uzbekistan
team is focused on increasing sales
and customer acquisition. Optimo
strategically entered the Uzbekistan
market due to the latter’s size and
optimal growth conditions, leveraging
the first-mover advantage in a less
competitive environment. The Tashkent
office establishes a key operational hub
for localised products and targeted
marketing campaigns, aiming to build
brand awareness and trust. Optimo’s
commitment to innovation aligns with the
growing demand in Uzbekistan, marking
a significant milestone in its expansion
journey.
OPTIMO: lightweight POS and inventory management SaaS
In 2023, Digital Area acquired
Biletebi.ge, a major ticketing platform
in Georgia. Biletebi.ge, established in
2008, a major ticketing platform in
Georgia. Biletebi.ge, established in 2008,
is Georgia’s pioneering ticketing platform,
offering sales and distribution services
for various live events including concerts,
sports, theatre productions and more,
totalling around 800 events in 2023.
Biletebi.ge is currently in the process
of revamping its platform, with the
new version expected to be available in
June 2024.
Digital Area is committed to establishing
Biletebi.ge as the leading lifestyle
platform in Georgia, striving to elevate
the lifestyle experience of its users.
Biletebi.ge: online ticketing marketplace
500 Georgia
50.5M GEL 541.4M2,952
+301% y-o-y
GMV
+44.7% y-o-y
Merchants
+297.5%
Number of transactions
Startup participants
in 2023
Startup participants
since 2020
Non-Georgian startup
participants since 2020
22 63 37
52
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Section 172(1) statement
Stakeholder engagement is a key ingredient for long-term resilience and sustainability of the
Company and is central to how we set and execute our strategy. The needs and views of our
different stakeholders as well as the consequences of any decision in the long term are well
considered by the Board.
The Board is responsible for the long-term
success of the Company as a whole and
recognises that proactive and positive
engagement with stakeholders is a key
ingredient for long-term resilience and
sustainability of the Company.
By having a deep understanding of our
stakeholders, their concerns and priorities,
we are able to work closely alongside
them to achieve our mutual goals, create
value and, wherever possible, provide
proactive support.
Stakeholder engagement happens in a
variety of ways and through different
channels, both internal and external. The
Board welcomes and regularly reviews
feedback from stakeholders to shape
strategic decisions.
The Board considers any current risks
or emerging risks with regard to each
stakeholder group as part of the overall
principal risk assessment which is
described on pages 150 to 169.
Sometimes, different stakeholders have
competing priorities and the Board
has to make decisions balancing these
differences. Our stakeholder engagement
processes enable the Board to understand
what matters most to stakeholders and
consider the relevant factors to be able to
choose the course of action that ensures
the resilience and success of the Group in
the long term. You can read more about
stakeholder engagement on pages 54 to
57.
In performing their duties during 2023,
the Directors have had regard to the
matters set out in S172 of the Companies
Act 2006. You can read more on how the
Board had regard to each matter, during
the year, on pages 58 to 59.
This section of the Strategic Report
comprises the Company’s section 172(1)
statement. In this section, we describe
various considerations surrounding
our key stakeholders including their
importance to the business, engagement
methods, monitoring and decision
making, as well as how the Company
acted on stakeholder feedback
throughout the year.
The Board’s understanding of the needs
and views of different stakeholders
is at the heart of its responsibilities.
Stakeholder engagement takes place in
a variety of ways and through various
channels. The Board reviews stakeholder
feedback and uses this feedback when
defining strategic objectives and making
decisions. On the following pages, we
describe typical engagement methods,
the main topics that came up during
these engagements, including through
our regular customer and employee
surveys, as well as how we engaged
and acted on the feedback received
throughout the year.
How the Board fulfils its section 172 duties
Stakeholder engagement
S172 factor
The likely
consequences
of any long term
decision
The interests of
the Company’s
employees
The need to foster
the Company’s
business
relationships
with suppliers,
customers and
others
The impact of
the Company’s
operations on the
community and
the environment
The desirability
of the Company
maintaining a
reputation for
high standards of
business conduct
The need to act
fairly between
members of
the Company
Relevant disclosures
Strategic focus
pages 188,216 and 223
(Ameriabank)
Succession planning
pages
pages 195, 207-209
Financial
governance
changes
page 215
Culture
pages 191-193
Diversity and
inclusion
pages 207, 210-212
Workforce
engagement
page 210
Workforce
remuneration
pages 230-231
Engagement with
stakeholders
page 189
Meetings with the
auditors page
page 218
External Auditor
effectiveness
pages 220-221
FRC
correspondence
page 223
Engagement with
stakeholders
pages 189 and 220
Culture
pages 191-193
Whistleblowing
pages 222
Risk Report
pages 225-228
Conflicts of
interest
page 251
Code of conduct
and ethics
page 253
Significant
agreements
page 252
External
effectiveness
evaluation
page 196 and 212
Statement of Code
compliance
page 189
Strategic focus
page 188
Share capital and
rights attaching to
the shares
pages 250-251
Results and
dividends
page 251
53
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
EMPLOYEES
INVESTORS
CUSTOMERS
COMMUNITIES
GOVERNMENTS
AND REGULATORS
OUR KEY
STAKEHOLDERS
EMPLOYEES
INVESTORS
CUSTOMERS
COMMUNITIES
Who are our stakeholders?
Why are our stakeholders important to our business model?
Engagement performance key highlights of 2023
EMPLOYEES CUSTOMERS
Customer-centricity
begins with
employee-centricity.
We will not be able to
serve our customers
and communities
and deliver business
success without the
commitment, passion
and skills of our
employees. We strive
to be an employer
of choice that
attracts, develops
and retains top
talent and ensures
equal opportunities
and best employee
experience for all.
We are a customer-
centric organisation –
This means that we
design our products
and services with
customers in mind,
continuously review
and respond to
feedback, and
always strive to
anticipate customers’
wants and needs.
Our goal is to
maintain the trust
of our customers,
be relevant in their
daily lives with our
financial products
and serve as a
trusted partner
throughout their
financial journeys.
Attracting long-term
investment is key
to the Company’s
success and
sustainability. We
aim to maintain the
trust and support
of our investors by
ensuring we are
transparent, do
business ethically
and in line with the
highest standards
of corporate
governance, and
deliver strong
performance and
shareholder returns.
We are committed
to making a positive
impact in the
communities where
we live and work
and maintaining
our reputation as
a responsible and
sustainable business
that empowers
people to drive
positive change.
We operate in a
highly regulated
environment, and
we are committed
to acting as
governments
and regulators
expect and require,
following the
highest standards
of corporate
governance and
acting ethically in
everything we do.
INVESTORS COMMUNITIES GOVERNMENTS
AND REGULATORS
85% say “I have trust and
confidence in the Company’s
senior leadership.
eNPS stood at 56 at year-end
2023, an increase from 53 at
year-end 2022.
We ended the year with a
high NPS of 59 – up from 58
in 2022 and 55 in 2021. NPS
is measured quarterly and it
was broadly stable during the
whole year.
Interim dividend of GEL 3.06
per share paid in October
2023. The Board intends to
recommend a final dividend
of GEL 4.94 per share at the
AGM. GEL 162 million buyback
and cancellation programme
for 2023.
120K+ students reached with
Bank of Georgia’s educational
initiatives.
Strong employee engagement Maintaining high NPS levels Delivering high profitability
and returns
Focusing efforts on education
54
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Engagement
• eNPS surveys, engagement surveys, and employee working groups.
• Culture and values assessment surveys.
• Town hall meetings and quarterly product milestone reviews.
• CEO live updates with Q&A sessions, open to all through Workplace, our internal networking tool.
• A dedicated Non-Executive Director facilitating regular Employee Voice meetings with the Board (Mel Carvill,
Hanna Loikkanen and Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi undertook a series of Employee Voice meetings during 2023,
engaging with 61 employees; you can read more about this on page 210.
• Personal interviews with employees, including exit interviews with departing employees 360° performance and
competencies review (bi-annual).
Independent whistleblowing system.
• Group-wide communications through our networking tool, Workplace, and intranet for sharing news and
achievements.
Performance
information
provided to
Directors
• Bank of Georgia eNPS survey (bi-annually).
• Bank of Georgia Korn Ferry Employee Engagement and Enablement survey (annual).
• Whistleblowing and grievance mechanism review.
• Gender pay gap reporting.
• Diversity monitoring and reporting.
• Monitoring and reporting of compensation trends on the market.
Who
engages?
• The townhalls and quarterly product milestone reviews provide updates on business performance and employee
initiatives and are led by the CEO and other Executive Management members.
• The Senior Independent Director and other Non-executive Directors attend the Employee Voice meetings which
take place twice a year.
• The Human Capital Management (HCM) department is responsible for the overall employee experience and
feedback gathering.
Employees
What they tell us matters to them
• Professional development
opportunities.
• Recognition and appreciation.
• Career advancement.
• Compensation.
• Work-life balance.
• Teamwork, support and
positiveculture.
• Being part of a successful
organisation.
How we acted on their feedback this year
• In our 2022 Annual Report, we
mentioned that 29% of employees
would like to receive clear and regular
feedback on how well they do their
work. In 2023, we launched an updated
360° assessment in 2023 to strengthen
the feedback culture and make sure
employees have performance and
development-oriented conversations
with their managers. We made the
comment section of the assessment
mandatory for managers to complete. In
2023, the percentage of employees who
did not agree with the statement that
they receive clear and regular feedback
decreased by 5 ppts.
• Compensation tends to be one of
the main areas detractors (those
considered dissatisfied) mention in
eNPS surveys. The Board reviews
annual reports on Bank of Georgia’s
compensation practices and how those
compare with the market, including
average compensation earned at
different levels. The Bank continues
to monitor the market and adjusts its
pay practices if and where necessary
to remain a competitive employer. In
2023, in response to this feedback, the
Bank implemented a salary increase
for certain mass positions to ensure
alignment with the market.
Lack of appreciation and recognition
are one of the leading reasons for
dissatisfaction that employees
mentioned in eNPS surveys. The
Human Capital Development function
is currently designing a framework for
team engagement. In addition, the Bank
delivers trainings on team development
to help managers increase motivation
and teamwork. The Bank also awards the
Best Employee and the Best Team of the
Year to highlight our peoples contribution
to the success of the organisation.
These awards are performance-based,
primarily for front-office positions where
performance against targets can be more
easily compared.
Customers
Engagement
• Internal NPS and CSAT surveys.
• Telephone calls and interviews.
• Informal client feedback communicated by bankers and relationship managers.
• Third-party NPS survey, brand research and focus groups.
• Complaints management.
55
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Investors
Engagement
• Quarterly results announcements, the full and half-year results and the Annual Report.
• Regular announcements via RNS.
• Quarterly results conference calls with investors and analysts.
• Investor roadshows (1 roadshow in London in 2023, with the Chair of the Board attending some of the
meetings with major institutional shareholders).
• Investor conferences.
Engagement
• Individual investor meetings, virtual and face-to-face, including site visits in Tbilisi, Georgia.
• Engagement calls with proxy agencies.
• AGM (1 in 2023, attended by the Board).
Performance
information
provided to
Directors
• Investor Relations updates including roadshow feedback.
• Proxy ratings and reports (ISS, Glass Lewis, IVIS and PIRC).
• Reports on Remuneration Policy Review meetings and engagement.
• Share price dynamics updates provided quarterly.
Performance
information
provided to
Directors
• Net Promoter Scores (‘NPS’), both internal by segment and external, Bank-wide.
• Internal satisfaction scores for branches, call center and digital channels.
• Service-level Agreement (SLA) monitoring.
• Quarterly Board reports on information security and data protection.
Quarterly Whistleblowing reports to the Audit Committee.
Who
engages?
• Engagement takes place at various levels including with the Executive Directors and senior management.
• Non-Executive Directors review customer satisfaction measures and how they compare against main
competitors quarterly. In February 2023, at the Board’s Strategy Sessions, the Board engaged with Bank of
Georgia’s Corporate Banking and SME Banking clients via a zoom call, asking questions and receiving feedback
on the Bank’s value proposition for business clients and service quality.
• Data and information security is a key responsibility of the Group, and, therefore, key metrics regarding
performance are discussed quarterly at the Joint Audit and Risk Committee.
What they tell us matters to them
• Clear and transparent product & service
descriptions and fees.
• Uninterrupted access to digital and
payments services.
• Suitable product fees and rates.
• Timely and professional responses to
their queries as well as timely resolution
of issues.
How we acted on their feedback this year
• Queues in branches were one of the top
reasons of dissatisfaction among retail
customers during 2023. To solve this
problem, we change queue management
logic and changed the incentive
system so that employees in branches
focused on teaching digital skills to our
customers. As a result, the maximum
branch SLA of 89% was recorded in
December 2023.
• We launched P2P transfers in BOG APP
for instant interbank transfers within
Georgia. Previously, customers could
do instant P2P transfers only within
Bank of Georgia, and considering that
the speed of transactions is one of the
key elements of customer experience in
banking, we focused on making sure we
could offer instant P2P transfers to any
other Georgia bank.
• Lacking an efficient card delivery service
continues to be one of our pain points,
reflected in relatively lower share of
cards being sold digitally and customer
dissatisfaction when opting for card
delivery. Bank of Georgia has initiated
a partnership with new vendors to
improve its card delivery service in
Tbilisi and Georgia’s regions (the existing
service is not available outside of Tbilisi).
The project is ongoing and expected to
be implemented during the first half of
2024.
• Bank of Georgia cards can now be
used to pay in public transport in more
regions across Georgia. Previously, this
was possible only in Tbilisi and three
other cities.
• Dark mode in the financial superapp
was launched in 2023, after numerous
requests by customers.
56
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Communities
Engagement
• Involvement in various community activities such as voluntary work and the development of social impact
programmes with charity partners.
• Our employees participate as volunteers in various community projects.
• Attendance and participation at key sustainability events.
Performance
information
provided to
Directors
• Corporate responsibility, community activities and volunteering programmes are discussed at Board
meetings.
• ESG topics are regularly discussed at Board meetings.
• Sustainability sections of the Annual Report are reviewed and approved by the Board.
Who
engages?
• Engagement, on the whole, is delegated to the CEO and Executive Management.
What they tell us matters to them
• Local employment opportunities.
• Business support.
• Education.
• Financial contribution.
• Protection of the environment.
Who
engages?
• This continues to be a shared responsibility for all Directors of the Board. The engagement is predominantly led
by the CEO who is supported by the Investor Relations team. The Chairman attends the AGM as well as some
of the meetings during the roadshows, and the Chairs of the Committees make themselves available to meet
investors upon request or if needed.
• The Chair of the Remuneration Committee offers meetings on Remuneration Policy matters and proposed
changes to the Groups Policy.
What they tell us matters to them
• Strategy and business model,
particularly with regard to our
digitalisation programme, and customer
franchise development.
• Financial performance and returns.
• Strength of corporate governance.
• Macroeconomic and geopolitical risks.
• ESG performance and impact
measurement.
• Financial risk management.
How we delivered on their feedback this year
• The strength of the Group’s business
performance during 2023 has been
well received by investors, where we
have strong alignment on our strategic
direction and this has been evidenced
by the Groups strong share price
performance over the last 12 months.
• Many shareholders have been specific
that they want us to combine further
investment in our business to deliver
sustainable high returns, with a strong
capital distribution policy. Over the last
few years, we have specifically engaged
our shareholders on how we should
return excess capital to them, and this
has led to our combination of regular
dividend coupled with a share buyback
and cancellation programme. At the
same time, we have also continued our
investments in developing our financial
SuperApp, our payments business
and increasing product sales in digital
channels – which remains important to
our shareholders.
Many shareholders tell us they want
to see the ongoing strong growth of
our balance sheet which we continue
to deliver in a prudent manner while
ensuring strong levels of profitability.
This has enabled us to maintain a
robust capital distribution policy whilst,
at the same time, investing in organic
business growth, and understanding
shareholder views on potential
expansion outside Georgia – which has
specifically informed the Board in their
consideration of where they should focus
their prioritisation of various strategic
priorities.
• Our ESG strategy continues to have
increasing importance for us and our
investors and, in 2023, we conducted a
further ESG materiality assessment,
leading to the specific changes to
our ESG priorities and disclosures,
the details of which you can read on
pages 62 to 64. Specifically, given the
growing investor focus on climate and
sustainable finance, we have revised
the ESG strategy to include Sustainable
Finance as one of the four main
pillars and introduced green lending
KPIs for the CEO and the Executive
Management for 2024. We also regularly
liaise with shareholders on remuneration
policy issues and often adapt issues
in our remuneration disclosures and
policy – specifically in 2023 we adapted
share vesting timelines in our senior
management rewards policy vesting
schedules following investor feedback.
57
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
How we acted on their feedback this year?
• STEM (science, technology, engineering
and mathematics) education has
emerged as a critical component
of education, with STEM skills in
high demand and important for the
economic development of communities.
Georgia’s mean score in science is one
of the lowest among PISA-participating
countries and economies (383 PISA
Score, rank 70/75, 2018). During 2023,
Bank of Georgia prioritised STEM
in its community impact activities
and increased investments in STEM-
related projects, including, among
other projects, adding STEM corners
to libraries in Georgia’s regional public
schools and launching STEM Olympiad
in partnership Komarovi School, a
leading math- and physics-focused
school in Georgia.
• Financial literacy skills are not
specifically taught in Georgian schools
and the mean score in financial
literacy is one of the lowest among the
countries/economies participating in
the PISA financial literacy assessment.
(403 PISA Score, rank 18/19, 2018).
Focusing on financial education and
health is an extension of Bank of
Georgia’s core business activities as
financially literate customers increase
the resilience of the communities where
we operate as well as the resilience
of the financial system itself. During
2023, we prioritised financial education
and used sCoolApp, Bank of Georgia’s
financial mobile app for school children,
as one of the channels for spreading
educational content via weekly Stories
in the app. Given that sCoolApp had
90,000 MAUs in December 2023, we
will focus on using it as one of the key
tools for raising financial literacy among
Georgia’s youth.
• Lack of access to educational
opportunities in Georgia’s regions
(outside of big cities) has come out
as one of the key concerns of local
communities in the surveys Bank of
Georgia has conducted. In response,
Bank of Georgia has partnered with
Komarovi school to launch STEM School,
a year-long online programme in STEM
for school students in grades 7-11. Bank
of Georgia provided scholarships to
up to 100 school kids from Georgia’s
regions.
• Lack of financial support is another
roadblock in accessing quality education
in Georgia. For years Bank of Georgia
has financed several prestigious
international scholarships, giving
selected young people opportunities to
study abroad at the graduate level. In
2023 Bank of Georgia launched local
scholarships to increase the scale of
its financing efforts and make sure
more young people in Georgia have
access to undergraduate education
irrespective of their socioeconomic
status. Bank of Georgia Scholarship was
launched in 15 partner universities in
Georgia. Currently, the goal is to provide
scholarships to over 100 students
annually.
Governments & Regulators
Engagement
• To deepen Board-level understanding of our regulators, our Chair and Non-executive Directors formally meet
with the NBG during the year.
• Regular meetings with the NBG happen at the Executive Management level, with the CEO engaging directly on
key matters.
• The CEO participated in the policy dialogue in Georgia through different avenues, including the Banking
Association of Georgia and the Business Association of Georgia. In these matters, the CEO is often assisted by
other Executive Management members.
Performance
information
provided to
Directors
• Regulatory matters are regularly discussed by the Board. Regulatory updates are presented quarterly to the
Risk Committee and major changes or issues are reviewed and discussed at the Board level.
• Directors are informed of all material litigation and/or significant regulatory engagement via reporting from
the General Counsel UK and the Company Secretary, as well as Bank of Georgia’s Chief Legal Officer.
Who
engages?
• Engagement, on the whole, is delegated to the CEO and Executive Management. The Board usually engages
with the NBG if and when needed, and during their visits to Georgia.
Actions and outcomes during the year
• The Audit Committee took part in
the FRC’s consultation on changes to
the UK Corporate Governance Code
(‘Code’). The Audit Committee discussed
the proposed changes to the Code in
meetings, commissioned on ongoing
assessment of the Group’s preparedness
in respect of possible enhanced focus
on internal controls and discussed the
outcomes of this assessment.
• The Audit Committee received and
responded to a letter from the FRC
which raised no questions or queries
regarding the Company’s 2022 Annual
Report. The 2023 Annual Report has
been enhanced following suggestions
made by the FRC in the letter.
Further information regarding this
correspondence is available on page 223
of the Audit Committee Report.
• The Audit Committee and Risk
Committee received regular updates
on sanctions compliance and AML
and oversaw enhancements in
theseareas.
• The Risk Committee considered the
General Risk Assessment Programme
(GRAPE) assessment from the NBG and
discussed progress against the matters
raised by the NBG.
• The Nomination Committee and
Board remained cognisant of the NBG
independence requirements and the
impact of this on succession planning.
• The Directors received updates and
oversaw continued adherence to legal
and regulatory requirements.
58
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Principal decisions
Principal decisions are those decisions taken by the Board that are material, or have strategic importance to Bank of Georgia Group
PLC, or are significant to the Company’s key stakeholders.
This statement describes three examples of principal decisions taken by the Board during 2023.
Expansion to a new market
What was the decision?
During 2023, the Board considered
a potential opportunity in Armenia
presented by the management.
The Board agreed that value could be
derived from exploring this opportunity
in an adjacent high-growth economy and
agreed that the management engaged
with the potential target to gauge
detailed information and evaluate the
upside through a thorough due diligence
process.
How were stakeholders engaged and their interests considered?
In addition to discussions at regular Board
meetings, the Board held a two-day in-
person strategy meeting to review the
Company’s strategy and performance
and consider customer and investor
perspectives regarding the strategic
direction of the Company. Discussions
with key investors through roadshows
and meetings with the Board throughout
the year highlighted that there was
appetite and support for the Groups
excess capital to be carefully deployed
in growth opportunities. In addition, our
CEO met with a significant proportion of
our institutional shareholders ahead of
the Shareholder General Meeting, which
resulted in a 100.00% vote in favour of
the Ameriabank acquisition in March
2024.
Actions and outcomes
Following analysis, discussions with
advisors and other key parties, a potential
opportunity to acquire Ameriabank, a
leading universal bank in Armenia, one
of the fastest-growing economies in
the region, was identified as a leading
opportunity for international growth for
the Group.
Following extensive due diligence
and Board discussions with the
management and external advisors, the
Board unanimously recommended the
conditional acquisition of 100% of shares
of Ameriabank to the shareholders of the
Company in February 2023.
On 14 March 2024, at a General Meeting
of the Company, 83.60% of issued share
capital voted, with 100.00% votes
in favour of the acquisition. Further
information regarding this transaction
can be found on pages 13 to 14.
Approving capital distributions
What was the decision?
The Board recommended a final dividend
for the financial year 2022 and approved
an interim dividend in respect of the
period ended 30 June 2023. In February
2023, the Board approved an increase of
up to GEL 148 million in its share buyback
and cancellation programme.
In August 2023, the Board approved the
launch of a GEL 62 million share buyback
and cancellation programme.
The Board’s decisions were informed
by the Groups dividend and capital
distribution policy, which was announced
in September 2021, as well as regular
updates on the Group’s financial and
capital positions.
A key focus of Board-level discussions
throughout the year was the
management of excess capital whilst
balancing shareholder returns and
deployment for growth.
How were stakeholders engaged and their interests considered?
The Directors were mindful of their duties
under section 172 in respect of capital
distribution, and the Directors considered
whether the declaration of a dividend
and the share buyback and cancellation
programme would support the long-term
sustainable success of the Company and
align with investor expectations.
The financial implications of capital
distribution, including the ability of the
Company to continue supporting its
customers and maintaining financial
stability, were considered by the Board.
The Board received specific feedback from
shareholders regarding the importance of
dividends and share buyback, combined
with the importance of maintaining
strong capital ratios to ensure the Bank
is always adequately capitalised in
uncertain times.
The Board remained supportive of
keeping the dividend and buyback
payout ratio the same as in 2022 – a
year boosted by significant one-off gains
and FX inflows, and, going forward, the
Board plans to maintain both a regular
progressive dividend policy and a share
buyback and cancellation programme, as
and when appropriate, targeting a 30-
50% total capital distribution ratio. This
policy is expected to continue, following
the proposed acquisition of Ameriabank.
59
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Actions and outcomes
On 27 October 2023, the Company paid
an interim dividend of GEL 3.06 per
ordinary share in respect of the period
ended 30 June 2023.
In June 2023, the Company completed
its GEL 260.7 million buyback and
cancellation programme, having
repurchased and cancelled 3,254,705
ordinary shares, representing 6.6% of the
Company’s issued share capital.
At the 2024 AGM, the Board intends to
recommend for shareholder approval a
final dividend for 2023 of GEL 4.94 per
share payable in Pounds Sterling at the
prevailing rate. This would make a total
dividend paid in respect of the Group’s
2023 earnings of GEL 8.00 per share. In
addition, the Board has also approved
an extension of the share buyback and
cancellation programme by an additional
GEL 100 million.
The Board will continue to review
the Company’s dividend and capital
distribution policy and revise it if, and as,
required.
ESG strategy
What was the decision?
During 2023, the Group continued to
enhance its Climate Action Strategy
and ESG practices and related policies.
The Board approved the adoption
of two further ESG policies: the
Responsible Supply Chain Policy and
the Environmental Policy.
The Board also received an update on
the second formal ESG materiality
assessment conducted in 2023, building
on the first materiality assessment in
2021. Following a review of feedback
received from key stakeholders during
the materiality assessment, the Board
approved a revised
ESG strategy, which included Sustainable
Finance as one of the key pillars,
substituting Education in Communities
as the latter was considered to be less
relevant to the Group’s core business.
How were stakeholders engaged and their interests considered?
The Board recognises that sound ESG
policies and practices help generate
sustainable shareholder value and
contribute to the success of the whole
Group in the longer term.
The Responsible Supply Chain Policy
and the Environmental Policy were
developed following engagement, and
requests, from proxy voting agencies and
shareholders. These policies also comply
with legal and regulatory requirements
and are based on global best practice.
We recognise that our business activities
and daily operations may have a
significant impact on the environment,
the economy and the communities
where we operate. We seek to minimise
the negative environmental and social
impacts we may have, and we believe
sustainability is a journey and there is
always more we can do to promote
responsible business practices throughout
our organisation and beyond it, among
our communities and in our supply chain.
Actions and outcomes
The Board has committed to enhancing
the Company’s disclosures in line with
best practice and global sustainability
standards. This includes the requirement
for all premium-listed companies to state,
in their Annual Report, whether their
disclosures are consistent with the TCFD
recommendations, or to explain why not.
Considering the global challenge of
climate change, the Bank, the main
operating entity of the Group, has
committed to supporting Georgia’s
climate-related goals, currently focusing
on enhancing data collection and analysis
of climate-related risks and opportunities
that arise primarily from its lending
activities.
60
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
SUSTAINABLE
BUSINESS
61
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
KPI
Target Result
eNPS Min. 54
sCoolApp MAU 70K
Number of self-employed borrowers 57K
Seedetails on page 33
Empowering people by creating
sustainable opportunities
ESG governance
We believe in shared success.
Sustainability for us means acting in
ways that empower our customers, our
employees and our communities, and
doing business the right way, following
the highest standards of corporate
governance and robust risk management
practices. This ensures we effectively
mitigate the negative impacts we
may have, directly or indirectly, on the
economy, people, and the environment
and that we contribute to the sustainable
development of the communities where
we operate. Bank of Georgia is a leading
financial institution in Georgia, providing
innovative products and solutions to
more than 1.8 million active customers.
Innovation and responsibility go hand
in hand, and we recognise the role the
Bank can play in supporting sustainable
development and inclusion in all its forms.
We believe understanding and managing
ESG risks is crucial to maintaining our
financial strength, so our approach to
ESG has been integrated in the work we
do across the business. The management
of ESG-related issues is subject to the
governance and oversight of our Executive
Management team and the Board of
Directors. We continue to make progress
in understanding climate-related risks
and opportunities, and putting in place
practices to identify, assess, monitor and
manage climate-related issues, focusing
on the Bank’s loan portfolio, as the main
risks and impacts are associated with
lending. We continue to support our
business customers in their transition
towards greener and more sustainable
ways of doing business. Information in
this chapter is provided mainly for JSC
Bank of Georgia standalone, unless
otherwise stated.
Oversight of the majority of material
ESG topics and related impacts on the
economy, people, and the environment
is allocated to specific Board
Committees: Risk, Audit, Nomination and
Remuneration Committees.
While the Committees retain continued
responsibility for discrete ESG-related
matters, the full Board retains primary
responsibility for the Groups overarching
ESG strategy, which has been framed
around material ESG topics.
The Board ensures the alignment
of ESGstrategy with the business
strategy, receives updates on progress,
and oversees the Group’s overall
communications strategy around ESG
topics and impacts. The full Board also
retains the primary responsibility for
overseeing the management of climate
risks and opportunities, and it oversees
the management of other E&S risks and
opportunities that may arise in the Bank’s
loan portfolio. Updates on material ESG
topics are regularly reported to the full
Board or respective Committees.
The management of ESG topics is
delegated to the Bank’s Executive
Management team. Discrete ESG
matters are managed by individual
members of Executive Management.
Management-level Environmental and
Social Impact (ESI) Committee reviews
and discuss the Bank’s ESG-related
(including climate) matters and impacts.
Key developments in 2023
We updated and developed a number of ESG-related policies, which were approved by the Board of Directors
We conducted the second formal ESG Materiality Assessment and updated our ESG strategy
We created ESG and Sustainability function, which is responsible for Bank of Georgia’s sustainability practices
We updated internal sector classification system to NACE2, the European classification system used by the
NBG’s Sustainable Finance Taxonomy for identifying sectors and activities that are or could potentially be
green. We operationalised selected taxonomy criteria so bankers could determine whether our customers fit
the criteria under the taxonomy
1
2
3
4
2023 KPIs & results
62
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
2024 KPIs
Digital transactional MAU
1
1,291,000
2023 – 1,182,399
Self-employed borrower clients
60,000
2023 – 55K
Green portfolio (gross)
GEL 875M
2023 – GEL 752M
Cash withdrawals in total transactions
(byvolume)
25%
2023 – 28%
sCoolApp MAU
150,000
2023 – 90K
ESG materiality assessment
To formalise our ESG strategy, we
undertook our first formal ESG
materiality assessment in 2021. As a
result, we identified material issues
and defined commitments for each of
them. Building upon this groundwork,
we decided to undergo a reassessment
in2023.
The primary motivation for the 2023
materiality reassessment was to align
with best practices, considering the
recommended timeframe of 2-3 years for
updates. Furthermore, we aim to adhere
to the latest Global Reporting Initiative
(GRI) Standards.
The materiality reassessment conducted in 2023 allowed us to clearly identify our most significant
impacts on the economy, the environment and people, including on their human rights, and to
prioritise key material topics for our ESG Strategy. We considered the views of internal and external
stakeholders in this process.
Given that the relevant GRI Sector Standards were not available at the time of this assessment, the identification of impacts on
the economy, the environment and people, including on their human rights, was mainly done by drawing on our own and third-party
assessments:
Impact scoping – identifying actual and potential impacts
An analysis of material topics identified in previous reports and the 2022-2023 ESG Strategy,
outlining actual and potential, positive and negative impacts
A gap assessment of the current material topics against the topics deemed relevant for the industry,
using SASB materiality finder
An analysis of the main issues outlined in the latest ESG rating reports (gap assessment)
An assessment of the Bank’s main activities, markets, products, stakeholders and business
relationships as described in previous annual reports and validated by the Bank’s ESG project working
team and discussed with Executive Management
An assessment, mapping and expansion of Bank of Georgia’s contribution to the Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs), referring to the SDGs previously identified by the Bank in the previous
two annual reports
A review of currently available policies and grievance mechanisms at the Group level
The impact identification process, as required by GRI, was discussed with Executive Management during an in-person workshop.
Relevant definitions and updates to the GRI materiality assessment process were discussed. Executive Management contributed
with their views on the Bank’s actual, potential, negative and positive impacts. All identified positive and negative impacts were
summarised in a long list of impacts.
1. Number of users who made at least one transaction through digital channels within the past month.
63
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
The long list of impacts was classified
according to each impact’s significance
following the guidance presented in GRI 3
and consulting the OECD’s Due Diligence
Guidance for Responsible Business
Conduct. A consolidated list of impacts
was provided by the consultants and
approved by the Bank.
Assessing the significance of the impacts
ESG materiality assessment results
The least significant impacts were
eliminated from the consolidated list
and the remaining were clustered
into ‘preliminary material topics.’ The
preliminary list of material topics
was presented to various stakeholder
groups. Stakeholders were asked to rate
the topics according to their relevant
significance. The engagement happened
in the form of surveys and structured
interviews.
The ranked material topics were
presented to and validated by Bank of
Georgia’s Executive Management and the
Board of Directors.
Prioritising the most significant impacts for reporting
Combined ranking
Stakeholder groups
Business ethics
1
Customer protection and product
responsibility
2
Data security and privacy
3
Local economic development
4
Sustainable finance
5
Gender equality
11
Engagement with communities and
theenvironment
12
Fair working conditions and
employee well-being
8
Human capital development
9
Diversity, equity, and inclusion
10
Responsible supply chain
13
Internal environmental management
14
Product and service innovation
6
Sustainable financial inclusion and
empowerment
7
Structured interviews
Online questionnaire
Online questionnaire Online questionnaire Online questionnaire Online questionnaire
Investors IFIs Employees
Customers
SME
Customers
Corporate
The primary goal in presenting the preliminary list of material topics, and their respective definitions, to stakeholders was
to gather their perspectives on the relative importance of the topics identified during the impact scoping exercise.
This step aimed to validate the level of significance identified in the process.
64
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
ESG strategy
The aim of the materiality assessment
was to determine the relative priority of
relevant ESG topics and to define the
material topics to base our ESG strategy
on. Based on the materiality assessment
process described above, we updated our
ESG strategy. Our ESG priorities continue
to evolve, and we are committed to being
transparent about our practices and
progress.
Contributing to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals
Focus areas
Governance & Integrity Financial Inclusion
Sustainable Finance
(Integrated Risk
Management) Employee Empowerment
Objectives
To do business in line with
the highest standards of
corporate governance, highest
ethical principles and ensure
accountability, transparency,
fairness and responsibility in
every decision we make
To use the power of
technology and product
innovation to drive digital
financial inclusion and deliver
innovative financial services
To manage financial risks
stemming from climate
change and other E&S risks,
while fostering greater
transparency and long-term
focus
To be the employer of choice
for top talent, providing
equal opportunities for
development and ensuring
the best employee experience
based on our values and
business principles
Material topics
Business ethics
Customer protection and
product responsibility
Data security and privacy
Engagement with
communities and the
environment
Internal environmental
management
Responsible supply chain
Customer protection
andproduct responsibility
Data security and privacy
Local economic
development
Product and service
innovation
Sustainable financial
inclusion and
empowerment
Diversity, equity
andinclusion
Gender equality
Business ethics
Sustainable finance
Environmental and
social management of
loan portfolio;
Mitigating E&S risks
associated with client
financing
Local economic
development
Product and service
innovation
Local economic
development
Fair working conditions
andemployee well-being
Human capital
development
Diversity, equity and
inclusion
Gender equality
We remain committed to contributing to the five United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs) (highlighted below) we
linked to our strategy in 2020.
65
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
MSCI
3
Bank of Georgia falls into the highest scoring range relative
to global peers.
LAGGARD AVERAGE LEADER
CCC B BB BBB A AA AAA
ESG ratings
Memberships and external recognition
ISS
2
Environment 3
Social 2
Governance 6
1
As of April 2024, Bank of Georgia Group PLC received an ESG Risk Rating of 17.6 from Morningstar Sustainalytics and was assessed
to be at low risk of experiencing material financial impacts from ESG factors. In no event the Annual Report shall be construed as
investment advice or expert opinion as defined by the applicable legislation.
The Bank is a member of the UN Global Compact
The Bank became a signatory of the UN Women’s Empowerment
Principles in 2022
1. Copyright © 2023 Morningstar Sustainalytics. All rights reserved. This Annual Report contains information developed by Sustainalytics (www.sustainalytics.com). Such
information and data are proprietary of Sustainalytics and/or its third party suppliers (Third Party Data) and are provided for informational purposes only. They do not
constitute an endorsement of any product or project, nor an investment advice and are not warranted to be complete, timely, accurate or suitable for a particular purpose.
Their use is subject to conditions available at https://www.sustainalytics.com/legal-disclaimers.
2. ISS uses 1-10 scale. 1 indicates lower governance risk, while 10 indicates higher governance risk versus its index or region. 1 indicates higher E&S disclosure, while 10 indicates
lower E&S disclosure. Last governance data profile update – 19 March 2024; Last E&S data profile update – 13 March 2024.
3. As of 27 March 2023.
FTSE Russell (the trading name of FTSE International Limited and
Frank Russell Company) confirms that Bank of Georgia Group PLC
has been independently assessed according to the FTSE4Good
criteria, and has satisfied the requirements to become a constituent
of the FTSE4Good Index Series. Created by the global index provider
FTSE Russell, the FTSE4Good Index Series is designed to measure
the performance of companies demonstrating strong Environmental,
Social and Governance (ESG) practices. The FTSE4Good indices are
used by a wide variety of market participants to create and assess
responsible investment funds and other products.
66
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
GOVERNANCE
AND INTEGRITY
67
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Financial crime
Money laundering is one of the major threats to the international financial
services community and therefore to us. Our policies and procedures are designed
to ensure that we have robust systems and controls in place to mitigate the risk
of us being used to facilitate money laundering.
We ensure compliance with local
and relevant foreign legislation in all
jurisdictions where financial institutions
belonging to the Group conduct
operations and integrate international
standards and recommendations
developed by Financial Action Task Force,
the Office of Foreign Assets Control
(OFAC) of the U.S. Treasury Department,
the European Union, the UN Security
Council and HM Treasury within our
ventures.
To that end, we do business only with
clients who meet our strictest criteria
and are within our risk appetite.
During 2023, customer engagements
and transactional flows remained
steady, without significant disruptions or
turbulence.
Anti-money laundering and international sanctions
In 2023, we enhanced our cooperation with the NBG, other relevant Government authorities, the embassies of the United
States, United Kingdom, and European Union, as well as partner financial institutions to monitor and mitigate sanctions-related
risks at the sectorial and country levels.
ENHANCED COOPERATIONS
We adhere to the international sanctions regimes and ensure that all our activities are in line with applicable sanctions
requirements.
The Bank has been audited by one of the big four firms, whose report provided a favourable assessment of the Bank’s AML/
Sanctions control environment.
We follow regulatory measures and guidelines prescribed by the National Bank of Georgia targeting financial institutions with
respect to adherence to international sanctions regimes.
All Group subsidiaries comply with the requirements and obligations set out in Group policies.
ALIGNMENT WITH INTERNATIONAL SANCTIONS REGIMES
To address current challenges, we have updated our International Sanctions Compliance Policy and related procedures to align
the Group with the latest economic and financial measures implemented by the US (Office of Foreign Assets Control), EU, UK,
(HM Treasury) and United Nations Security Council.
The Bank has designated the Russian Federation and the Republic of Belarus as high-risk countries and all transactions and
clients from those countries are subject to enhanced due diligence.
UPDATED POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
We have invested significant resources to improve our money laundering (ML)/terrorism financing (TF) risk management
capabilities, including implementing advanced analytics and transaction monitoring solutions to conduct ongoing monitoring of
transactions and detect unusual and suspicious activity, and strengthening offline reporting tools. Additional offline monitoring
scenarios were implemented, which are tailored to the current risk and transaction typologies.
Enhancements have been applied to intensify the offline monitoring mechanisms.
The internal reporting for AML/Sanctions was significantly improved, resulting in the creation of multiple new dashboards and
metrics, which are used to continuously monitor existing trends and risk changes.
ML/FT RISK MANAGEMENT
We have a risk-based AML/CFT and international sanctions compliance programme, operating based on the three lines of
defence model.
Online and offline monitoring are ensured by the relevant teams serving as additional control mechanisms. The operational
processes are supported by the specifically dedicated teams dealing with high-risk countries.
Additionally, to enhance process control, as a secondary control tool, an assurance unit has been established, which focuses on
the regular assessment of the efficiency and compliance of the control system deployed within the Group.
AML/COMBATING THE FINANCING OF TERRORISM (CFT) AND INTERNATIONAL SANCTIONS
COMPLIANCE PROGRAMME
First line
Business direction
Second line
AML/Sanctions Compliance department
Third line
Internal Audit
68
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
To strengthen due diligence in response to prevailing sanctions regimes, we have revised and refined the transaction screening
and onboarding processes.
Customer and payment online screening is undertaken to identify sanctioned customers or goods and transactions prohibited
under applicable sanctions regimes.
TRANSACTION SCREENING AND ONBOARDING PROCESS
We possess an online solution that enables a fully automated screening of all transactions against sanctions lists (OFAC, the
EU, the UK, the United Nations and other similar bodies, including global news databases).
AUTOMATED SCREENING OF TRANSACTIONS
We invested resources in implementing additional tools for machine screening of respective documents accompanying
transactions. This has improved our capabilities for detecting possible sanctions violation scenarios.
Along with online screening, the Bank uses an offline monitoring tool and various offline scenarios, tailored for different products
and types of clients. Specifically, for trade restrictions, the Bank has developed several scenarios, which help AML/Sanctions
officers identify a pattern of transactions, when a company may be engaged in trading with the Russian Federation or other
high-risk countries. A special team has been established for managing and analysing offline monitoring scenarios.
TOOL FOR MACHINE SCREENING
We have a zero tolerance policy towards sanctioned persons, transactions, and funds related to sanctioned persons, as well as
towards international sanctions evasion and circumvention.
We have a zero-risk appetite for engaging in international operations involving crypto businesses.
We have restricted all transactions/onboarding of a client/provision of any service involving Russia’s military-industrial base.
We have tightened onboarding and transaction screening processes. In addition, the Bank continues to strengthen compliance
processes, with a particular focus on introducing additional control mechanisms on transactions coming from CIS countries.
ZERO TOLERANCE POLICY
To effectively address future external challenges posed by numerous and dynamically evolving sanctions regimes, the AML/
Sanctions Compliance department was redesigned and a more robust structure was established.
To comprehensively execute International Sanctions Compliance Programme, a dedicated unit has been created with the
responsibilities of analysing existing international sanctions regulations, elaborating and implementing the Bank’s international
sanctions compliance policy and internal control mechanisms, and providing informational updates and trainings to the relevant
staff of the Bank on a permanent basis.
STRENGTHENING AML/SANCTIONS COMPLIANCE DEPARTMENT
The Executive Management of the Bank promotes a culture of compliance and regularly emphasises the importance of AML/
sanctions compliance at all levels.
We conduct regular employee training and awareness-raising sessions regarding international sanctions compliance.
REGULAR TRAINING AND AWARENESS RAISING CAMPAIGNS
97% of our employees completed the mandatory training. We have intensified the focus on the mandatory training
programmes for our employees and target 100% training completion rates.
MANDATORY TRAINING
69
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Customer Risk Assessment is a fully
automated process and customer
risks are managed throughout the
relationship lifecycle
Information on a client’s ownership
structure, ultimate beneficial owners
and source of funds/wealth is
obtained during onboarding
Our existing clients are subject to
a regular due diligence process
The Bank has relevant policies, procedures and risk appetite to ensure compliance with applicable
domestic AML laws and regulations, as well as international sanctions frameworks implemented by
the US (Office of Foreign Assets Control), EU, UK (HM Treasury) and United Nations Security Council.
They are subject to regular reviews to ensure compliance with applicable sanctions regimes.
The Bank has strong Know Your Client and customer due diligence procedures:
The Bank has a strict Customer Acceptance Policy.
AML, CFT and sanctions topics are on the quarterly agenda of the Joint Audit and Risk Committee.
The Committee receives information on existing controls and implemented measures.
To strengthen our ability to detect and prevent financial crime and sanctions evasion, we continue to
enhance our ML/FT and sanctions risk management function.
Our policies
Our AML/CTF and International Sanctions Compliance programme comprises written policies, procedures, internal controls and
automated system monitoring tools.
70
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Anti-bribery and anti-corruption
The Group has zero tolerance towards bribery and corruption. We have in place
written policies, procedures and internal controls to comply with anti-bribery and
anti-corruption laws.
Our comprehensive programme, with a suite of measures to ensure compliance with relevant ethical standards, includes:
Our risk management processes encompass regular risk assessments according to key risk
indicators and pre-approval processes. These involve identification, assessment and mitigation of
potential threats to our organisation’s integrity. This comprehensive approach is an integral part
of our commitment to maintaining a culture of integrity, transparency and zero tolerance towards
bribery and corruption.
RISK MANAGEMENT PROCESSES
Prior to establishing any commercial relationship, we conduct a thorough due diligence on
potential business partners or third parties. This ensures alignment with our commitment to
ethical business practices, in compliance with anti-bribery and anti-corruption laws. The scope and
intensity of due diligence and monitoring vary based on the nature of the relationship, whether
with a legal entity or an individual. Additionally, customer due diligence is conducted in accordance
with anti-money laundering regulations.
THIRD-PARTY DUE DILIGENCE
Investigation protocol is a structured framework outlined in our policies that guides employees
on reporting and investigating potential policy breaches. Concerns can be reported through the
whistleblowing platform confidentially or anonymously.
INVESTIGATION PROTOCOL
We make and keep books, records and accounts that accurately, fairly and in reasonable detail
reflect all payments, expenses, transactions and disposition of the Bank’s assets.
RECORD-KEEPING
Communication efforts include using internal channels like memos or letters, while a structured
training programme ensures employees at all levels understand and adhere to the Anti-bribery and
Anti-corruption Policy. Awareness campaigns and refresher courses reinforce the key concepts.
ADOPTION, COMMUNICATION AND TRAINING
Combating bribery – policies, transparency and accountability
The Code of Conduct and Ethics, the
Conflict of Interest Policy, the Anti-bribery
and Anti-corruption Policy and Know
Your Employee procedures safeguard the
integrity of the Bank. The Anti-bribery
and Anti-corruption Policy and the Gift
Acceptance Policy provide employees
with guidance on how to recognise and
deal with bribery and corruption and
outline steps employees are required to
take when accepting or offering gifts,
hospitality and inducement to/from
external third parties. Transparency
is further ensured by implementing a
reporting requirement that encourages
the disclosure of any unethical behaviour.
We have established a systematic
recording system for documenting gifts
and other advantages. This structured
approach ensures thorough tracking and
accountability within our organisation.
71
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
How we govern
Enhancing controls and monitoring
The Bank’s Executive Management Team
and the Supervisory Board establish
a strong culture of ethics throughout
the organisation by setting the tone at
the top. Every anti-corruption initiative
is actively supported by the Executive
Management. This endorsement from the
highest levels provides a solid foundation
for our anti-corruption programme.
Employees in managerial positions
are critical for identifying corruption
risks. Their positions bear a special
responsibility for upholding ethical
standards and actively preventing
instances of corruption.
Internal Control and Compliance
departments serve as a second line
of defence in managing bribery and
corruption risks. Those departments
scrutinise red flag situations, known
for their elevated risk profile, such as
sponsorship, gifts, hospitality, political
and charitable donations. These high-risk
scenarios undergo a rigorous examination,
reflecting our commitment to proactive
risk mitigation and the establishment of
strong control mechanisms.
The Compliance department regularly
reviews the Anti-bribery and Anti-
corruption Policy and initiates changes
to reflect international best practice and
improve control design. An enhancement
programme to further improve our
bribery and corruption risk assessment,
controls and reporting is in progress.
We continue to further structurally
strengthen our response to bribery and
corruption risks in key areas. We have
developed online training modules on
bribery and corruption risks, including
on the Gift Acceptance Policy and the
whistleblowing platform. Annual training
is mandatory for all employees. 89% of
our employees completed the mandatory
training programme. We have intensified
the focus on the mandatory training
programmes for our employees and
target 100% completion rates going
forward.
First line
Business directions
Second line
Internal Control department
Compliance department
Third line
Internal Audit
Our training programme empowers every employee with the essential knowledge, skills, and expertise required to
uphold the integrity of the Bank. This comprehensive framework guarantees that our team operates with the highest
level of diligence, adhering to guidelines that enforce a zero tolerance policy towards bribery and corruption.
Employee monitoring Declaration process
Background check
In 2023, no bribery or corruption incidents were registered in the Bank, nor were any bribery or corruption
fines imposed on the Bank.
The Bank has in place the Know Your Employee procedure that includes:
The Bank’s Compliance Committee reviews any complaint related to bribery and corruption incidents.
The Audit Committee receives information on any reported incidents.
72
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Information security
Information security is a priority for the Group. As we develop new digital
products and services, we implement complementary measures to ensure the
robustness of our information security systems.
Information security risks represent one
of the global threats that organisations
worldwide face. The external threat
profile is dynamic, and these threats
continue to increase. The financial sector
remains a primary subject of a growing
number of attempts to compromise its
information security. We understand
that if these attempts are successful,
they could have a negative impact on
our customers and employees, as well
as on subsidiaries, partners, and, given
that the Bank is part of Georgia’s critical
infrastructure, the country as a whole.
We have relationships with customers
and partners from other countries as well,
and thus, the negative consequences of a
compromise of our information security
could extend beyond Georgia. Such
compromise could expose us to potential
contractual and regulatory liability, lead
to a loss of current and future customers
and partners, damage our brand and
reputation, and result in financial losses.
Our focus on information security risks
As we develop new digital products and services, we implement complementary measures to ensure the robustness of our
information security systems. To successfully deliver on our commitments, we undertake a number of initiatives.
The Bank’s commitment and initiatives
We devote significant human and financial resources
and engage globally-renowned technology companies
to respond to information security threats accordingly.
We recognise the importance of establishing
and maintaining a rigorous information security
management system that is compliant with
current business and regulatory requirements and
commensurate with existing and emerging threat
landscapes.
The Bank has a dedicated Information
Security department, responsible for
developing and maintaining the Bank’s
information security management system,
including policies and procedures that are
reviewed regularly and amended to reflect
any lessons learned. The Information
Security department is headed by the
Chief Information Security Officer (CISO)
who directly reports to the Deputy CEO,
Data and Information Technology.
The CISO presents regular updates to
the Joint Audit and Risk Committee.
As aresult, the Bank’s Executive
Management Team and the Supervisory
Board remain up-to-date on information
security risks.
The Bank follows a three lines of defence
model.
We employ highly qualified security professionals across multiple lines of business. Additionally, we run regular trainings to ensure
that they are aware of and clearly understand current security trends and issues.
Information security management system
First line
Business directions
IT department
Information Security department
Second line
Operational risks
Third line
Internal Audit
We engage with our customers on
information security-related matters
through multiple channels, including
our website, digital platforms and text
messages. We regularly create and share
content, including articles, interactive
games and questionnaires on various
media. As our organisation becomes
more digital and further relies on cloud
computing and third-party providers,
we are increasingly exposed to and a
target of cyber attacks, such as a supply
chain attack, or distributed denial of
service (DDoS), among others. We take
measures to mitigate the risks of a supply
chain attack (for more information please
see page 162 of this report). Despite the
increasing frequency of DDoS attacks on
the Bank, there have been no instances
of service disruption resulting from these
attacks since March 2023, following the
implementation of a new solution.
Customer engagement and risk mitigation
73
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Although the Bank was not involved in any
significant negative impact in 2023, we
maintain a thorough Information Security
Incident Response Policy to prevent an
information security incident, and if it
does occur, to limit its impact on our
stakeholders. This policy defines roles and
responsibilities throughout each phase of
an information security incident response
and enables effective cross-functional
collaboration and the management of
public and internal relations. Controls
and monitoring continue to be embedded
across the Bank as part of the overall
internal control framework and are
continuously reassessed. Each year,
the Bank is subject to at least 11 types
of security assessments to evaluate
the effectiveness of our actions and to
manage actual and potential impacts.
These assessments include:
These assessments give us insight into how effectively the policies and processes have been implemented.
As a result, the Bank sets goals and targets that may be mandatory (based on legislation) or voluntary, for example, for automation
or optimisation purposes.
Incident response and control measures
Penetration testing Breach and attack
simulation
Self-assessments Internal and external
audits
We support and contribute to the
development of information security
in Georgia. We regularly participate in
collaborative efforts with our financial
industry peers, law enforcement
authorities, regulatory bodies and the
Government to share knowledge and
prevent negative impacts.
Our goal is to enable more efficient
and effective information security
supervisory oversight, streamline and
align the fragmented information security
regulatory framework with international
standards, and help increase the overall
security and resilience in Georgia. The
Bank has a dedicated team to coordinate
threat intelligence sharing and develop
external relationships.
We are a member of the Financial
Services Information Sharing and Analysis
Centre through which the Bank has
access to a threat intelligence platform,
resilience resources and a trusted peer-
to-peer network of experts to anticipate,
mitigate, and respond to information
security threats specifically targeting
financial institutions.
Mandiant (now part of Google Cloud)
conducted an assessment of Bank of
Georgia’s cybersecurity programme in
November 2023. The purpose was to
validate existing capabilities, identify
areas for improvement, and offer
recommendations to enhance the
programme’s maturity.
Mandiant noted that the Bank generally
showcased higher maturity levels across
multiple facets compared to prevailing
industry standards in both European and
global financial sectors.
These strengths collectively contribute to the Bank’s robust cybersecurity posture, indicating a proactive and well-prepared
approach to handling potential threats and vulnerabilities.
Contributions to information security development
Cybersecurity programme assessment overview
The executive summary from the report highlighted several key strengths:
INFORMATION SECURITY TEAM
PROACTIVE CAPABILITIES
IMMUTABLE BACKUPS
DOCUMENTATION
TRAINING AND AWARENESS
Highly certified and skilled, with a strong focus on
continuous improvement.
Embracing proactive measures such as red teaming,
purple teaming, and honeypots to pre-emptively
address vulnerabilities.
Leveraging immutable storage solutions for secure
and resilient backups.
Comprehensive suite of documentation guiding the
organisation’s information security practices.
Implementing a robust awareness programme and
regular training to foster a culture of preparedness
among employees.
74
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
1
Information security metrics
Cross-functional team of employees Active professional certifications
2023 2023
2022 2022
28 50
25 40
Internal phishing campaigns conducted
Employees not deceived by
a phishing campaign (%)
2023 2023
2022 2022
98%
4 97%
6
Independent internal audit engagements
Third-party penetration testing
(external assurance)
2023 2023
2022 2022
3
4
Third-party cybersecurity programme
assessment (external assurance)
2023
2022
0
0
0
GEL loss
data breaches
security breaches
due to a cybersecurity incident or a regulatory fine
external intrusion into the Bank’s network or systems
personal or financial data leaked to the public
1
1
75
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Employee training and awareness programme
We take pride in our team members who
hold industry-recognised certifications,
including three individuals with CISSP,
two with OSEP, and one with CRTO.
We also run a Bank-wide information
security awareness programme to
ensure that our employees understand
information security matters and
their applicability to the Bank’s daily
operations. We view each employee as
a ‘human firewall,’ and therefore we
continuously refine our approach to
employee training and testing.
General information security training
is mandatory for all employees during
onboarding and afterwards, annually.
The purpose of the general training is to
raise awareness on key attack vectors
and proper responses to different types
of information security incidents (e.g.
ransomware). 97% of our employees
completed the training successfully.
The Information Security department
monitors the completion of mandatory
information security training and targets
100% completion rates going forward.
On a quarterly basis, the Information
Security department conducts a
comprehensive phishing campaign,
assessing all employees’ ability to detect
and respond effectively to phishing
attempts. In addition to the general
test, we executed two more targeted
phishing campaigns tailored to specific
groups. The department closely monitors
performance and provides additional
training to individuals who may have
fallen victim to phishing emails or were
unable to respond promptly.
Data privacy
As data collection and digital footprints continue to expand worldwide, it is
essential for us to be proactive in protecting clients’ most valuable asset –
personal information. We are committed to protecting and respecting the data
we hold and process, in accordance with the laws and regulations of the markets
in which we operate.
Information is one of our most valuable
assets, and data privacy is a top priority.
We have embedded good privacy
standards and practices within the
corporate operations and structure.
We fully comply with applicable data
protection legislation and adhere to the
information security standards.
Our approach rests on having the technology, systems, controls, policies and processes to ensure proper data governance, the
appropriate management of privacy risk and the fulfilment of our obligations.
Data governance and responsibility
We have appointed the Georgian banking industrys first Data Protection Officer who advises the
Bank and helps monitor compliance with the applicable data protection rules. The Data Protection
Officer reports to the Audit Committee semi-annually on the status of the Bank’s privacy strategy
implementation. As a result, the Bank’s Executive Management Team and the Supervisory Board
remain up-to-date on privacy matters.
PRIVACY GOVERNANCE
In our commitment to safeguarding privacy, we make sure all data subjects’ rights are strictly
observed. In 2023, the frequency of data subject access requests remained robust. Each request
is diligently fulfilled, ensuring comprehensive protection and empowerment for data subjects.
Importantly, none of the complaints regarding Data Subject’s Access Rights were communicated
to the personal data protection service of Georgia, further emphasising our commitment to
ensuring the proper protection of the rights of the data subjects.
INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS AND TRANSPARENCY
We prioritise robust security measures when engaging with third-party vendors. This involves
a thorough assessment of their security infrastructure. We conduct a comprehensive review
of regulatory compliance to ensure adherence to data protection. Prior to collaboration, clear
and detailed contractual agreements are established, outlining data protection responsibilities.
These practices ensure we maintain the highest standards of data protection and security in our
partnerships.
THIRD-PARTY DATA PROCESSING
76
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Further developments and the implementation of a new framework
In June 2023, the legal framework
governing data protection in Georgia was
amended. The new law is more closely
aligned with the General Data Protection
Regulation (GDPR) and introduces
obligations similar to those outlined in the
GDPR.
As GDPR applies to certain data
processing by the Bank, the amendments
introduced by the new law have already
been implemented. However, considering
that the majority of our clients are
Georgian citizens, we anticipate an
increase in complaints as citizens become
more aware of their rights and the
responsibilities of data controllers due to
awareness-raising campaigns carried out
by the Government. In response, we have
proactively initiated a comprehensive
review of our practices to ensure full
compliance with the requirements
stipulated by the new law and to enhance
our privacy standards.
Despite the current legislative changes
in Georgia, the Bank constantly tries to
improve data processing practices. This
enables us to properly identify, address
and mitigate the risks in advance,
significantly limiting the likelihood of a
negative impact on individuals as a result
of data processing.
The orders and instructions given by the regulatory body have already been fulfilled. The regulator deemed the measures taken by
the Bank to be sufficient and closed the supervision of the execution of these cases.
One of the major threats that financial services companies face are cyber incidents. Over the past
few years, we have witnessed a number of major organisations falling victim to cyber attacks.
Fortunately, our operations have not been materially affected, nor have we suffered a breach
to date. We have a thorough incident response policy which is aligned with the emerging threat
landscape as well as current business and regulatory requirements.
INCIDENT RESPONSE AND BREACH NOTIFICATION
Awareness raising is one of the key aspects of our privacy framework. As part of the privacy
programme, we conduct awareness campaigns to help our employees recognise privacy concerns
and respond accordingly. We provide continuous and role-based privacy training that keeps
employees abreast of privacy risks and clarifies their role in mitigating them. 97% of our employees
completed mandatory training successfully. We have intensified the focus on the mandatory
training programmes for our employees and target 100% completion rates going forward.
In 2024, the Bank will enhance data privacy and security through targeted face-to-face training
for employees who have direct communication with clients and access to significant volumes of
personal, including sensitive, data. The training will be customised for each department’s activities
and practices. This proactive approach aims to prevent potential breaches and emphasises the
importance of keeping our employees informed about their obligations under data protection
legislation, contributing to a culture of awareness and responsibility throughout the Bank.
EMPLOYEE TRAINING AND AWARENESS RAISING
In 2023, we received four individual complaints regarding breaches of customer privacy from the Personal Data Protection Service, a
regulatory body in Georgia. All four have been identified as substantiated complaints. None of them constitutes a systemic issue within
the Bank.
Regulatory cases overview
4
Substantiated complaints concerning
breaches of data privacy
0
Identified leaks, thefts or losses of data
In 2023, the regulatory body conducted a planned inspection on the legality of data processing through audio
recording. Within the inquiry, the regulator examined the lawfulness of obtaining, recording and holding data by the
Bank, as well as security measures applied to the data, including access, and physical security measures.
The regulatory body considered that the Bank complied with all the rules in the processing and storage of personal data
and did not find any violations.
77
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
The following measures have been carried out after the adoption of the new law:
UNDERSTANDING
THE LAW
INSPECTING THE
INFORMATION
WE HOLD
REVIEWING LEGAL
GROUNDS
UPDATING
PRIVACY POLICIES
To ensure transparency and
regulatory alignment, we
have engaged in ongoing
consultations with the
relevant supervisory
authority. Furthermore,
all stakeholders have been
informed to navigate the
compliance requirements
of the new law, and they
are actively engaged in the
process, contributing to both
compliance and successful
implementation.
We have conducted an
information audit, including
where it came from, who
it is shared with, where it
is kept. Additionally, the
retention period has been
reviewed to ensure that we
retain personal data for
the necessary and lawful
duration.
We have conducted a
thorough review of the legal
basis for data processing
within the Bank and the
way we seek, obtain and
determine consent. We have
reviewed all web forms, online
consents, and landing pages
to align them with legal
requirements.
We have reviewed and
updated our data protection
policies to reflect the latest
legal developments. These
revisions guarantee that
our policies fully comply
with data protection
legislation and reflect best
practices, ensuring they are
comprehensive and up-to-
date.
Customer protection
Customer-centricity is one of our business principles and one of the key enablers
of our success. We are committed to serving our customers responsibly,
considering their best interests, fulfilling a variety of their needs, delivering
positive experiences across touchpoints, and engaging with them regularly to
learn from their feedback.
We aim to maintain customer trust by
adhering to the highest ethical standards
in doing business. Customer protection
is not just a commitment. It is also a
fundamental aspect of our business ethos
that motivates us to continuously improve
our practices and set the bar high to
have excellence in customer care and
protection.
Fairness, transparency and integrity
are the main principles that underpin
customer-centricity across the entirety of
the customer relationship lifecycle. These
principles are reflected in our Code of
Conduct and Ethics and in the Customer
Protection Standard, which reflects local
regulatory requirements, international
best practices and control mechanisms
for effective execution.
We view each employee as our
ambassador, and, therefore, we
continuously refine our approach to
employee training and testing. 96% of our
employees completed mandatory training
successfully. We have intensified the focus
on the mandatory training programmes
for our employees and target 100%
completion rates going forward.
The training programme equips all employees involved in selling our products and services with the necessary
knowledge, skills and expertise to prioritise and safeguard customers’ interests. This framework ensures that our
team operates with the utmost diligence and integrity in all customer interactions.
We must ensure that our customers are
able to make well-informed decisions
on how to use our products and services
and understand the protection available
to them if something goes wrong. Our
principles aiming to ensure customer-
centricity are reflected in all product
development and sales activities. The
principles apply to all business lines and
customer types and are integrated in the
product approval processes.
The new product approval process
and related risks are managed based
on three lines of defence. The Bank’s
internal procedures define the scope and
responsibilities of all involved structural
units to ensure:
How we design and sell our products and services
Suitable product offering
We create and offer products and services tailored to our customers’ needs and
preferences.
Clear communications
We communicate information, including terms and conditions, on products and
services in a clear and non-misleading manner.
78
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Customer complaints are another source
of feedback that we aim to handle
effectively and use lessons learned for
continual improvement of our customer
service. We aim to be open and consistent
in how we track, record and manage
complaints. We measure the volume of
complaints and review root causes to
inform the changes we should make to
our products and services to improve
them for our customers. By doing this,
we hope to see improved customer
satisfaction and reputation, and reduced
costs.
We understand that it is important for
our customers to be able to address their
complaints through several channels or to
clarify the details of any issue.
As a result of claims processing, constant
changes are made to adapt services
and banking products to customers’
requests and needs as much as possible,
which makes the Bank more flexible in
the market, attractive and special for
customers.
The variety of recourse channels clearly
shows that it is possible for our customers
to file a complaint using any preferred
and available means. Submitted
complaints are then reviewed by the
Customer Complaints Management and
Support Centre.
How we listen – customer complaints
First line
Customer Complaints Management
and Support Centre
Second line
Customer Protection unit
Third line
Internal Audit
The Customer Complaints Management process and related risks are also managed based on three lines of defence.
Internal Audit as the third line of defence, is an independent assurance provider, and
performs audit engagements using a risk-based approach. The scope of work of Internal
Audit related to customer protection is to determine whether our risk management,
internal control, and governance processes, as designed and represented by management,
are adequate and functioning in a manner that reasonably ensures material regulatory
and compliance risks are appropriately identified, measured, assessed and managed
across the organisation.
WEBSITE
CONTACT
CENTRE
SOCIAL MEDIA
E-MAIL
WHISTLEBLOWING
CHANNEL
CHANCELLERY
BRANCHES
E-BANK AND
M-BANK
NATIONAL BANK
OF GEORGIA
Customers can leave complaints via various channels, including:
Robust control mechanism when
developing and/or reviewing a product
New products and services as well as changes to existing products are reviewed and
assessed by key control functions including the Legal department.
Responsible marketing
All mass communications in public channels as well as all personalised
communications are reviewed by the Legal department to make sure they are
compliant with applicable laws and regulations.
Advisory
We provide services and trusted advice through professionals with the necessary
knowledge and expertise.
Fair offering
We offer products and services at a fair price considering the market, costs and risks.
79
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Customer claims management
We have a consistent set of principles
that enable us to remain customer-
focused throughout the complaints
process. Our Customer Claims
Management procedure defines how to
handle customer complaints and concerns
in a timely and effective manner.
The Customer Claims Management and
Support Centre reviews and manages
all incoming claims. In case of a material
violation, the centre is obliged to escalate
the matter to the Bank’s Compliance
Committee.
A Customer Protection unit in the
Compliance function manages
communications with the NBG regarding
customers’ claims. The Customer
Protection unit also serves as a second
line of defence, reviewing and analysing
all complaints monthly to identify root
causes and systemic issues, any violation
of our Code of Conduct and Ethics or
Customer Protection Standard, and
offering remediation action plans if
necessary.
If the Customer Protection unit identifies
a systemic issue from customer
complaints or reports received through
the whistleblowing channel, it reports
such findings to the Joint Audit and Risk
Committee in its quarterly compliance
reports.
The Customer Complaint Management
and Support Centre reflects complaints
recorded with the Bank on a monthly
basis in its reports submitted to the NBG.
Step 1
Step 2 Step 5
Registered
complaint/request
Processing the
complaint/request
Appealed cases are
reported to the NBG
Step 3
Direct communication
with the customer
Step 4
Decision making/communicating
with the customer
PROCESS
How we handle complaints
Our principles Our actions
Making it easy for our customers
to complain
The Bank has a Customer Claims Management procedure that defines how to handle
customer complaints and concerns in a timely and effective manner. Customers can
complain via the channel that best suits them. We provide clear information about
our customer complaint mechanisms.
Keeping the customer up to date
We set clear expectations and keep customers informed throughout the complaint
resolution process via their preferred channel.
Ensuring fair resolution
The Customer Claims Management and Support Centre reviews and manages all
incoming claims. We thoroughly investigate all complaints to address concerns and
ensure the right outcome for our customers.
Providing available rights
We provide customers with information on their rights and the appeal process if they
are not satisfied with the outcome of the complaint.
Undertaking root cause analysis
Complaint causes are analysed on a regular basis to identify and address any
systemic issues and to inform process improvements.
80
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Registered complaints by category Resolution outcomes
13%
26%
34%
51%
19%
23%
11%
3%
2%
Plastic cards
In favour of customerLoans
Accounts, deposits
Digital channel and service
Other
Payment problem Consultation
Transactions
9%
9%
Breach of the process
Whistleblowing
We want to continue to foster a culture where our colleagues feel safe to speak up.
Our whistleblowing channel, WhistleB, is
one of our speak-up channels, which allows
our employees and other stakeholders
to raise concerns confidentially
and, if preferred, anonymously. The
correspondence process is managed
by WhistleB, an external, advanced,
independent whistleblowing reporting
channel and case management tool.
We promote a speak-up culture and aim
to ensure our employees and stakeholders
are aware of our whistleblowing
mechanism, and have full comfort
reporting potentially unethical practices
without fear of reprisal.
The Whistleblowing Policy is one of the
primary documents governing culture and
ethics, and therefore, responsibility for
the Whistleblowing Policy resides with the
Board who, together with the Joint Audit
and Risk Committee, receive reports on
its operation quarterly.
Over the past year, in response to the
challenge that the platform, in some
cases, was not used for its intended
purposes, the whistleblowing channel
has been redesigned and updated to
enhance its effectiveness, efficiency
and awareness. As a result, statistics
have improved, and irrelevant reports
decreased over the past months.
In the reporting year, we received
22 relevant reports on the WhistleB
platform. 19 reports dealt with the
same issue – organisational changes
(dissatisfaction caused by manager
rotation). 2 out of these 19 reports
included additional concerns about
unfavourable work environment. The
issue was investigated and violation was
not confirmed. Out of the remaining 3
reports, 2 hinted at favouritism/nepotism
whereas 1 was about communication
challenges. Violation was not observed
in any of the cases, nonetheless we
addressed the issue with all managers
underscoring their pivotal role in
cultivating a bias-free environment,
emphasising preventive measures for the
future. Furthermore, selection/promotion
criteria were standardised, and an action
plan, including an ongoing monitoring
mechanism, was drawn up to ensure
continuous attention to these matters.
Communication challenges were resolved
by establishing a streamlined process,
enabling open discussions with managers.
Reports received
1
17
4
Organisational change
Breach of Code of Conduct and
Ethics
TOTAL
22
Money retained in
the ATM
In favour of the Bank
81
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
AI
Working with our suppliers
Bank of Georgia is one of the largest purchasers in the country, with a variety
of suppliers in its supply chain. We are committed to dealing fairly with our
suppliers, acting with integrity, and ensuring a responsible supply chain.
We are committed to involving local suppliers in our supply chain and contributing to local business development. The majority of our
suppliers were local in 2023.
Total spend on suppliers
87%
13%
Local suppliers Others
Largest categories of suppliers by spend
28%
15%
9%
3%
22%
24%
Professional service
Renovation
Office supplies
Rents
IT
The Bank continues its commitment to strategic sourcing, emphasising the importance of selecting suppliers not only based on cost
but also based on factors such as quality, reliability and innovation. This approach ensures that procurement decisions align with the
Bank’s overall business strategy, fostering long-term partnerships and mitigating risks associated with the supply chain.
Meanwhile, cost efficiency still remains one of the main KPIs for the Procurement team.
Investing in advanced technologies
To enhance efficiency, reduce manual errors and provide valuable insights for better decision making, we are investing in advanced
technologies to streamline and automate various aspects of the procurement process. This includes the implementation of:
The Procurement department has
transitioned to electronic signatures,
implementing a paperless strategy that
enhances efficiency and sustainability.
This move not only aligns with our
commitment to innovation but also
underscores our dedication to reducing
environmental impact. Moving to
e-signature process and going paperless
means a significant reduction of paper
usage and a decrease of our operational
carbon footprint.
PROCUREMENT
SOFTWARE
AI TASK AND PROJECT
MANAGEMENT TOOLS
DATA
ANALYTICS
Banking products
82
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Sustainable procurement
Supplier screening
We are committed to conducting
business responsibly and to integrating
ESG criteria into our decision-making
processes. We want to promote
sustainability and responsible business
practices throughout our supply chain.
As one of the biggest groups in Georgia,
we recognise that our business activities,
operations and supply chain have a
significant impact on the environment,
the economy and society at large,
and we seek to minimise the negative
environmental impact of our operations
and supply chain by reducing our carbon
footprint, conserving natural resources,
and promoting circular economy
principles. We aim to uphold human
rights, promote fair labour practices
and support diversity and inclusion
throughout our supply chain. We believe
that sustainability is a journey and there
is always more we can do to promote
responsible business practices throughout
our supply chain.
To ensure that our supply chain aligns
with our values, commitments and the
expectations we have for our suppliers,
we have established the Supplier Code
of Conduct, which sets the principles
and guidelines for Groups supply chain
practices.
In 2023, we implemented supplier E&S
due diligence process. All of our suppliers
with turnover more than GEL 500K
must fill out an E&S questionnaire. This
evaluation involves examining suppliers’
E&S conduct, including but not limited
to labour conditions and environmental
impact. If there is a need, we also perform
an on-site assessment of supplier
premises to ensure that the provided
information is accurate.
Adherence to legal and ethical standards
remains a priority in the procurement
process. We have rigorous compliance
checks to avoid dealing with suppliers
who are not aligned with local laws and
regulations.
We have supplier screening processes and
policies, and all suppliers with more than
GEL 10K turnover with the Bank should
pass a qualification process (background
check).
Suppliers with access to the Bank’s IT
infrastructure or personal data are liable
to fulfil due diligence questionnaires. More
specifically:
Information security questionnaires.
Privacy due diligence questionnaires.
Operational risk due diligence
questionnaires.
General questions to all suppliers
regarding: child labour, illegal
immigrants, discrimination, minimum
salary, and modern slavery statement.
Operational environmental footprint
We are a service business, and our
direct environmental impact is less
significant than the impact we have on
the environment through our lending
activities. Nevertheless, we aim to be
a more resource-efficient company,
mitigating any negative impacts we
may have on the environment through
our operations. We undertake measures
to identify and monitor environmental
aspects relevant to our direct operations
and strive to adopt a ‘reduce, reuse,
and recycle’ approach. The direct
environmental impact of our business
activities arises from electricity, natural
gas and fuel consumption, water use,
paper use, as well as through other types
of waste produced.
The types of energy used by the Bank
include electricity, natural gas, and fuel
oil, the principal type being electricity
provided by the national grid. To be
more energy-efficient, our branches are
equipped with LED lighting. Remote
control lighting systems are installed in
new branches. Since 2018, the majority of
our newly opened branches have operated
remote heating and air conditioning
systems, ensuring efficient electricity
consumption during non-working hours.
For information on GHG emissions, please
see pages 115 to 116.
Energy consumption
2021 2022 2023
Electricity (kWh) 17,489,358 19,623,529 22,050,710
Gas (m
3
) 448,718 349,205 389,485
Gas (kWh, assuming that 1 m³ gas = 9.7 kWh) 4,352,565 3,387,285 3,778,003
Total energy consumption (kWh) 21,841,923 23,010,813 25,828,713
Total energy consumption (kWh)
per square metre of office space
243 238 267
Energy consumption data
83
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
59,316
67,649
107,415
2021
2022 2023
Water consumption (m
3
)
The increase in electricity and water
consumption versus prior year was mainly
driven by the increased office space to
accommodate the growing workforce
(the number of our employees increased
by 12.7% y-o-y). In addition, 2023 was the
first year after the COVID-19 pandemic
when employees moved into full-load
office space, which in turn led to an
increase in energy consumption.
Water consumption by the Bank is limited
to ‘domestic-type use’ and cleaning purposes.
Despite the increasing demand for resources, the organisation’s environmental vision and policy is to properly manage the resources
used, which involves waste prevention and recycling of waste generated.
Since 2023, the Bank has taken a number of positive steps to reduce its environmental footprint, namely:
Environmental management
An environmental manager position was created, responsible for minimising harmful environmental impacts and
overseeing processes in accordance with national and international environmental standards
1
Improved waste management practices have been implemented
2
The organisation’s waste management plan was updated
3
Clarification of the definition of waste within the organisation contributed to the improvement of the waste management system.
As a result, during the reporting period, we conducted an inventory of waste and separated two types of waste:
Waste management
Recyclable waste plastic, glass, cardboard, metal and electronic waste, which will be transferred to companies that have
the appropriate license for recycling
1
Non-recyclable waste will be transferred to those enterprises that ensure the destruction of waste by physical and
chemical methods, so that it does not harm the environment and human health
2
In the reporting period, generated waste was recycled in full compliance with
local environmental regulations.
Glass 60 tonnes
Mixed stationery and office supplies 250 m
3
Lead-acid batteries 6 tonnes
Recycled paper from the archive 70 tonnes
Recycled paper from offices 2 tonnes
Type of waste Amount (2023)
84
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Starting in 2023, we have maintained an inventory of equipment containing
ozone-depleting substances, which includes accounting for heating and cooling
systems throughout the Bank, monitoring each system to prevent the release of
ozone-depleting substances into the environment.
In addition to digital records, the
Bank retains paper records of some
transactions in line with regulatory
requirements. In all other cases, we aim
to reduce paper consumption by using
digital media and more efficient printing.
Some of the Bank’s departments, such as
branches and cash centres, are paper-
intensive. In these locations, we have
encouraged the use of two computer
monitors at work stations, resulting in
a reduction of paper waste.
Paper consumption
Paper use (kg) per employee
2023 30
2022 39
2021 35
Back-office paper from the Bank’s headquarters and several
large back-office locations is collected and shredded by a secure
paper recycling firm. In 2023, c.1.8 tonnes of paper were collected
for recycling in this way. Documentation from the Bank’s archive,
when retention period expires, is recycled annually.
The Bank uses a specialised third-party contractor for this
service based on the appropriate service agreement.
A responsible approach to tax
Our approach to responsible business conduct extends to our approach to
taxation. We understand that responsible tax practices are not just a legal
requirement but a vital aspect of our commitment to ethical business conduct
and sustainable development.
The Group must not use, encourage or
facilitate, nor cooperate with external
parties to facilitate products or services
that are in conflict with tax legislation.
We have a dedicated tax unit within the
Bank as well as policies and procedures
in place to ensure compliance with
applicable tax laws and regulations
related to our business. We seek to pay
our fair share of tax and minimise the
likelihood of customers using our products
and services to avoid tax. The Group
strives to maintain high standards for tax
governance, monitoring risks and ensuring
tax compliance. The Groups profits are
taxed at different rates depending on the
country or territory in which the profits
arise. We are privileged to play a central
role in the Georgian economy. Our tax
contributions are just one of the ways in
which we contribute to the communities
we serve. The table below shows taxes
paid during 2023.
Taxes paid in 2023, GEL million (BOGG PLC)
49%
51%
Corporate income tax
Other tax
GEL
327
Types of taxes paid in 2023, GEL million (BOG)
152.7
37.6
11.7
6.3
94.4
Corporate income tax
Property tax
Withholding tax
VAT
GEL
303
Payroll tax
85
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Company
Corporate income tax
(GEL)
Other tax (GEL) Total tax (GEL)
Georgia
BGEO Group 19,993 151,453 171,446
Bank of Georgia 152,446,136 150,312,817 302,758,953
Prime Leasing 975 975
Solo 32,660 1,218,479 1,251,139
Tree of Life Foundation 52,635 52,635
Georgian Leasing Company 1,529 4,481,876 4,483,405
Galt & Taggart 3,765 1,809,809 1,813,574
United Securities Registrar of Georgia 44,627 44,627
Express Technologies 92,500 92,500
Didi Digomi Research Center 12,021 16,266 28,287
Georgian Card 1,529 2,223,428 2,224,957
Direct Debit Georgia 469 1,688,406 1,688,875
Metro Service + 1,234,529 1,234,529
Digital Area 1,000,367 842,778 1,843,145
Area Extra 7,018 10,588 17,605
Easy Box LLC 104 290,199 290,302
Optimo Global 23,303 47 23,350
Deliveri 1,762 110,360 112,122
Total 153,550,656 164,581,772 318,132,428
Belarus
Belarusky Narodny Bank 4,268,726 7,861 4,276,587
BNB Leasing 44,891 570,524 615,415
Total 4,313,617 578,385 4,892,002
Hungary
Bank of Georgia Representative Office
Hungary
50,035 50,035
Israel
Georgia Financial Investments 14,519 93,810 108,329
Turkey
Representative Office of JSC Bank of
Georgia in Turkey
5,251 5,251
UK
Bank of Georgia Group PLC 2,056,004 2,126,021 4,182,025
Cyprus
Benderlock Investments Limited 106,468 106,468
Total 160,041,264 167,435,273 327,476,537
86
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION
87
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
We believe that improving access to
financial services is crucial for enhancing
people’s quality of life and fostering
economic growth. Lack of access to
financial services and finance poses a
significant barrier to sustainable and
inclusive socioeconomic development. In
2021, we identified financial inclusion as
one of our primary impact focus areas,
which is intertwined with our overall
business objectives.
We aim to foster financial inclusion by
offering people relevant, accessible, and
affordable services tailored to the diverse
needs of different customer segments
– spanning various socioeconomic
backgrounds and geographic locations,
from rural to urban communities.
In addition to our core business, we
actively engage in corporate social
responsibility (CSR) initiatives in the
communities where we live and operate,
providing educational resources,
workshops and tools to empower
individuals and businesses – equipping
them with the knowledge and skills they
need to effectively manage their finances.
We believe financial inclusion starts
with the use of digital channels for daily
banking and cashless payments. Through
our digital platforms, we provide easy
access to a formal financial system
to anyone across Georgia. Financial
technologies, be it mobile app or secure
online payments, empower people to
safely handle their money, carry out
transactions, and get necessary services
without relying on cash or visiting
traditional bank branches. We measure
the uptake of our mobile app and internet
banking platform through Digital MAU
and the use of cards for payments in-
store and online through Payment MAU.
Both metrics are key business metrics, but
we believe by focusing on these metrics
and reaching more people monthly
through our digital and payments
technologies, we contribute to stronger
communities.
Financial inclusion
To enhance financial inclusion, we focus on:
Financial inclusion focus
area
Where we are now
(December 2023)
Why we think it is
important
Use of digital
channels
Use of cashless
payments
Convenience and quick access
to our products and services
Visibility of personal
finances and access to tools
to manage money more
effectively
Ability to see all personalised
financial and lifestyle offers
Chatbot/chat available 24/7
Access to information and
educational content
Increased control over
personal finances, giving
people a full view of where
and how they spend their
money
More benefits – personalised
offers, ability to save
money through our loyalty
programme
Greater visibility of
customers’ financial history,
income and behaviour,
enabling banks to better
assess their creditworthiness
1.4 million
+21.0% y-o-y
Digital MAU
1.2 million
+20.1% y-o-y
Payment MAU
Increasing the use
of digital financial
products and services
Building financial
literacy among
young people
Building capabilities
of local businesses
with relevant tools
and information
88
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
How we ensure the accessibility of our products and services
Access to finance – removing barriers for self-employed and underserved people
Self-employed individuals
Underserved individuals
In Georgia, most of the economic activity
happens in big cities, leaving rural areas
feeling left out when it comes to financial
opportunities. Therefore, creating an
inclusive environment where everyone
regardless of their location or occupation,
feels empowered to access financial
tools requires addressing the disparity in
access to financial products and services
between urban and rural areas. Bank
of Georgia’s goal is to be accessible to
people living in locations beyond major
urban centres, in rural areas, and to those
of different socioeconomic backgrounds,
through a variety of financial services and
products.
For instance, we have strategically placed
ATMs and self-service terminals (BOG
Pay) in regions for individuals to gain
access to basic banking services without
needing to travel to urban centres. We
also have a number of branches in rural
communities providing residents with
access to a wider range of financial
services and personalised assistance.
The Mass Retail Banking strategy is
focused on encouraging people living
in Georgia’s regions to adopt digital
channels, particularly our financial
superapp for a fast, easy and seamless
daily banking experience. In 2023, we
focused on making sure our customer-
facing employees in regional branches
were equipped with the knowledge of
various digital tools and incentivised to
raise awareness of the benefits of using
digital channels among their customers.
Since 2022, we have been focused on
closing the gap between self-employed
individuals and the financial services
sector. We understand the challenges
faced by those with income from self-
employment or unofficial sources when
trying to access credit. That is why we
have worked on refining our lending
processes, removing the artificial barriers
that have long hindered their financial
inclusion.
In 2023, we improved the income
validation procedures for
self-employed clients and extended
the full spectrum of credit products,
previously unavailable to them. As a
result, we achieved a 14.9% y-o-y growth
in the number of self-employed borrowers
as of 31 December 2023.
54.7K
+14.9% y-o-y
Self-employed borrowers
(Dec-23)
479K
+9.1% y-o-y
Active customers
in Georgia’s regions
1
GEL 531.7M
+45.9% y-o-y
Loan portfolio of
self-employed clients (Dec-23)
You can read more about
self-employed clients on
pages 33 to 34 of this
report.
Customers can access BOG
APP’s full functionalities
without WiFi or mobile data.
Digital onboarding in our
mobile app and internet bank.
Tutorials and instructions
for new digital products are
available on our website.
Free or low-cost current
accounts and debit cards.
Free product bundles for
young people (sCool Card and
sCoolApp for school students
and Student Card and BOG
APP for university students).
Lower fees on payments
acceptance solutions for
smaller merchants.
A wide network of ATMs and
BOG Pay self-service terminals
across Georgia.
A digital version of our BOG
Pay terminals – bogpay.ge
rolled out in 2022, allowing
even non-BOG clients to make
payments anytime, anywhere.
1. Number of monthly active customers in Georgia excluding the top four large cities: Tbilisi, Batumi, Kutaisi and Rustavi.
89
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
You can read more about how we empower young people with
our products on pages 37 to 39 of this report.
Through our CSR initiatives, we aim
to provide resources, workshops and
tools that teach and explain financial
concepts and empower young people to
manage their money more effectively,
make informed decisions, and understand
the implications of economic policies on
their lives. We want to provide the tools
and skills so that more young people in
Georgia can be in control of their financial
futures because that will ultimately
benefit the whole communities around us.
Key financial education activities during 2023
TSU Envoy
The TSU Envoy project has been making a
significant impact in schools throughout
Georgia. University students, serving as
ambassadors, return to their schools to
share their experiences with over 10,000
school students annually – providing
invaluable insights into university life. In
2023, the project was supported by Bank
of Georgia for the first time. Through
this collaboration, ambassadors not only
talk about and give tips on university
life, but they also educate students
about the functions of sCoolApp and the
importance of banking products, focusing
on the products relevant for them. In
this way, the TSU Envoy project supports
financial literacy activities and awareness
raising across the whole country.
200+
Envoys participated
250+
Schools visited
In 2022, we launched sCoolApp – the first
financial mobile app for school students
in Georgia. The average age of sCoolApp
user is 14.
Our objective is to expand our reach to
school students and use sCoolApp as
one of the main avenues for teaching
essential financial literacy skills to children
from a young age.
In 2023, we developed sCoolApp with
innovative features aimed at promoting
financial inclusion and education among
school students.
Empowering school and university students in Georgia with daily banking solutions
Bill split
Educational
stories
Personal financial
manager (PFM)
Piggy bank
Financial literacy content and tools embedded in sCoolApp
90K
+170.3% y-o-y
sCoolApp MAU
90
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Teachers’ competition for integrating financial education in schools
Partnering with the NBG and the financial education platform
FinEdu, Bank of Georgia engaged in the teachers’ competition
for integrating financial education in schools. The primary
objective of the competition was to develop supplementary
financial educational materials aligned with the national
curriculum and enhance the effective teaching of financial
literacy concepts. We believe providing financial education to
children during their school years is essential for fostering their
future success.
Financial education exhibition
In 2023, for the first time, a space for financial education
was organised at the international education exhibition in
partnership with the NBG. Major banking sector organisations
were represented. We hosted students who participated in
entertaining financial education games while learning about
the resources offered by Bank of Georgia to promote financial
literacy.
Invite FinEdu to Class
In 2023, Bank of Georgia supported the ‘Invite FinEdu to Class
programme, a collaborative effort of the NBG and the financial
education platform FinEdu. The initiative aimed to enhance
financial and economic awareness among young people, with
representatives from partner financial institutions taking on
the role of ambassadors and visiting schools across Georgia.
Ambassadors from Bank of Georgia provided students with
insights into sCoolApp, which facilitates everyday transactions
for young people. Through these interactions, students gained
practical knowledge about the significance of prudent money
management and saving principles.
Improving the financial literacy of our
business clients is also an important
aspect of supporting local business
development. We aim to empower
business owners and managers with
the knowledge and skills necessary for
successful business operations, including
understanding fundamental concepts
such as budgeting, investing, and planning
for the future.
We believe that with this knowledge our
clients can navigate their businesses
more effectively, mitigating risks, seizing
opportunities, and ultimately achieving
their financial goals. Moreover, we believe
that by promoting financial education
and investing in our clients’ financial
literacy, we can not only contribute to
their prosperity but also strengthen the
overall resilience and stability of the
business ecosystem.
Building capabilities of local businesses with relevant tools and information
30+
Schools visited
900+
School students participated
26
Georgia’s regions
3,000+
Entrants
Accounting Development programme
500 Georgia
Workshops for female entrepreneurs
Businesscourse.ge
Bank of Georgia’s Accounting Development programme helps
SMEs overcome the hurdle of accessing finance by promoting
effective accounting practices. Through its partnerships with
local accounting firms, Bank of Georgia facilitates access to
affordable accounting software packages to help SMEs run their
businesses more effectively.
In collaboration with 500 startups and GITA, we launched the
country’s first international accelerator programme, fostering
entrepreneurship, nurturing the tech ecosystem, facilitating global
networking, and helping participating companies in fundraising.
Bank of Georgia regularly holds peer-to-peer trainings and
workshops specially developed for women entrepreneurs.
Through this online platform we provide educational content
and timely insights tailored to the needs of local SMEs.
Digitalisation
of accounting
Full accounting
services
Identifying
tax risk
Digital
marketing
E-commerce
Employment
practices
Quick sharing of financial information with the Bank Change management
Change Management
Read more on page 46
Read more on page 51
You can read more about our financial inclusion initiatives
for business clients on pages 46 to 49 of this report.
Read more on page 47
Read more on page 48
91
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
92
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
SUSTAINABLE
FINANCE
93
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Sustainable finance
Sustainable finance for us means
integrating ESG criteria into core
operations and decision-making
processes. This involves aligning
investment decisions, risk assessments
and lending practices with a commitment
to long-term sustainability.
As a leading lender and a reliable
partner for businesses of any size in
Georgia, Bank of Georgia is committed
to mobilising and prudently channelling
financing to support customers and
drive economic growth while reasonably
mitigating climate, environmental and
social (CE&S) risks in our financing. The
CE&S management of the Bank’s loan
portfolio is based on the Environmental
and Social Risk Management System
(ESMS) and Climate Risk Management
(CliRM) framework and encompasses a
systematic identification, assessment,
mitigation and monitoring of CE&S risks
associated with the projects that are
financed by the Bank’s Corporate Banking
and SME Banking segments.
We understand, that businesses can
no longer operate in isolation from the
impact they have on the planet and the
people, and, therefore, we are planning
to develop green products and create
green finance opportunities for the
businesses. This will help us identify
opportunities for sustainable growth
and, mitigate potential adverse impacts
and reduce risk of financial losses, and
foster the development of a resilient
and sustainable financial system and
businesses around us.
Environmental and social risk management
At Bank of Georgia, we are committed to prudently managing the risks
associated with our lending activities. Through our ESMS, we proactively identify
potential risks and promote mitigating actions by motivating our customers to
effectively manage these risks.
Environmental and social risks are risks of
negative materialisation of E&S factors
that affect our clients, borrowers, other
counterparties and the Bank itself.
The most common are environmental
risks – financial risks stemming from an
institution’s exposure to activities that
may be affected by or contribute to
the negative impacts of environmental
factors. Social risks are financial risks
arising from an institution’s exposure
to activities that may be affected by or
contribute to the negative impacts of
social factors.
E&S risk definition and management approach to the E&S risk appraisal
Risk level Definition E&S due diligence requirements E&S monitoring requirements
Low
Transactions with minimal or no
adverse E&S impact.
No in-depth assessment required. Monitoring visits not required.
Medium
Transactions with specific E&S
impacts that are few in number,
generally site-specific, largely
reversible, clearly evident at the
time of the assessment, and readily
addressed through mitigation
measures and international best
practice.
Gaps are identified and where appropriate
an E&S action plan is developed to minimise
the gap. When the total project exposure
is more than US$ 5 million, clients have
to comply with applicable International
Finance Corporation (IFC) Performance
Standards 1-8.
In case of non-compliance, monitoring visits
should be performed at least every two
years until major E&S issues are resolved
accordingly and properly monitored by the
customer.
High
Transactions with significant
adverse E&S impacts that are
sensitive, diverse or unprecedented.
In-depth assessment required. Gaps are
identified and, where appropriate, an E&S
action plan is developed to minimise the
gap.
If E&S issues are complex or outside the
in-house team’s competence, a qualified
external consultant(s) should be hired
to undertake an E&S assessment. When
the total project exposure is more than
US$ 5 million, clients have to comply with
applicable IFC Performance Standards 1-8.
Monitoring visits to poor E&S performance
clients on an annual basis. Monitoring visits
to all other clients should be performed
at least every two years until major E&S
issues are resolved accordingly and properly
monitored by the customer.
Category A
Developments on ‘greenfield’ land or
major extension or transformation-
conversion projects which may give
rise to significant or long-term E&S
risks and impacts.
In-depth assessment required. Gaps are
identified and where appropriate an E&S
action plan is developed to minimise the
gap. If E&S issues are complex or outside
the in-house team’s competence, a qualified
external consultant(s) should be hired
to undertake an E&S assessment. These
projects have to comply with applicable IFC
Performance Standards 1-8.
Customers should provide the Bank with
an annual E&S performance report and
monitoring visits should be performed every
year until major E&S issues are resolved
accordingly and properly monitored by the
customer.
The Bank focuses on higher-risk sectors and transactions. All cases that are identified as higher-risk and where specific or material
E&S risks or concerns are identified are subject to further review.
94
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Medium
High
Category A
Low
20%
60%
17%
3%
294
511
89
83
23
17
TOTAL
GEL 1,040M
23
387
176
123
111
45
9
400
TOTAL
GEL 1,251M
In 2023, our E&S risk management team conducted due
diligence of all new clients that may pose potential E&S risks
and/or high and very high climate-related transition and/or
physical risks. Out of GEL 1,040 million new loans screened, GEL
561 million was assessed against IFC Performance Standards,
while the rest was assessed against local legislation. The data
below shows the breakdown of the screened loans by sector as
at 31 December 2023.
In 2023, our E&S Risk Management team carried out E&S
monitoring of all Category A and High risk clients. Out of
GEL 1,251 million, GEL 918 million was assessed against IFC
Performance Standards, while the rest was assessed against
local legislation. The data below shows the breakdown of the
monitored loans by sector as at 31 December 2023.
E&S risk categorisation
(31 December 2023)
Category A projects constituted 3.1% of the Bank’s gross
SME Banking and Corporate and Investment Banking
loan portfolio, and 1.7% of the Bank’s total gross loan
portfolio as at 31 December 2023.
E&S due diligence data E&S monitoring data
*In ‘other’ we consider the following sectors: wholesale and retail trade; human health and social activities; education; transportation and storage; mining and quarrying;
production of trade of clothes, shoes and textiles; and other activities.
Construction/
development
Manufacturing,
except for food
products
Manufacture of food
products
Agriculture, forestry
and fishing
Energy
Energy
Other*
Other*
Agriculture, forestry
and fishing
Manufacture of food
products
Accommodation
and food service
activities
Accommodation
and food service
activities
Manufacturing,
except for food
products
Construction/
development
Sector
Exposure
GEL
million
Exposure
GEL
million
Share in
business
portfolio
Share in
business
portfolio
2022 2023 2022 2023
Industry 269.3 257.9 2.9% 2.3%
Construction
Materials
97.1 54.0 1.0% 0.5%
Consumer
Foods & Goods
33.5 31.7 0.4% 0.3%
Total 400.0 343.6 4.2% 3.1%
95
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigating E&S risks in Bank of Georgia’s loan portfolio
E&S risk framework
E&S risk management is integrated
into the underwriting process related to
business clients. There are procedures,
application forms and actions that
have been integrated into the Bank’s
credit procedures since 2013. E&S
risk management is based on IFC
Performance Standards and the EBRD
Performance Requirements – the
benchmarks for E&S risk assessments
in lending. A dedicated E&S team has
been in place since 2013, within the
Enterprise Risk Management function.
The ESMS and the associated E&S
procedures are periodically updated
and approved by the Environmental and
Social Impact (ESI) Committee and
the Supervisory Board of the Bank to
ensure they remain fit for purpose and
reflect the Bank’s strategic objectives
and current performance, expectations
of stakeholders, and changes in the
legal and regulatory environment. Our
ESMS aligns with our risk management
framework and provides additional clarity
and transparency regarding our approach
to E&S risks, including climate risk.
The Bank bases its E&S risk management on the following standards, regulations and policies:
The Groups Environmental Policy
The Bank’s CliRM framework
Georgia’s environmental, climate, social, health
and safety, and labour laws and regulations
International Labour Organization’s core
labour standards
Applicable international environmental, health
and safety (EHS) conventions that Georgia is
signatory to
IFC’s Performance Standards
The EBRD’s Performance Requirements
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Mitigating
AssessingIdentifying
Managing
E&S risk management of our loan portfolio involves systematically:
E&S and climate-related risks associated with projects financed by the
Bank’s Corporate Banking and SME Banking business directions.
96
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
The Bank’s ESI Committee and the Supervisory Board received updates on the implementation of
ESMS and approved the updated version of ESMS.
We started to assess climate-related risks for the Bank’s clients, based on a standardised E&S due
diligence process.
We provided Environmental Awareness trainings to SME Banking and Corporate and Investment
Banking clients and bankers.
We assessed E&S risks of more than 100 beneficiary companies, with exposure GEL 175 million as at
31 December 2023, delivering financing and guarantees via BOG within the framework of the World
Bank-supported Relief and Recovery (referred to as ‘Credit Guarantee Scheme’) for MSME Project
implemented by the economic development agency ‘Enterprise Georgia’, the governmental body
under the Ministry of Economy and Sustainable Development.
Activities in 2023:
The Supervisory Board will review E&S risk assessment reports for all large credit requests. These
reports provide information on current regulatory requirements and details on the client’s E&S
performance, potential risks and mitigation measures.
We are taking measures to fully comply with the NBG’s new ESG Guidelines, which are expected to
come into force from January 2025.
We will develop specific guidance for clients operating in oil and gas, agriculture, mining, forest and
biodiversity, recycling and heavy industry. These sectors are identified as those with potentially high
adverse E&S impacts.
Activities planned for 2024:
Employee and customer engagement
Employees are critical to our ability
to mitigate our indirect negative
impacts and effectively manage CE&S
risks and opportunities. To increase
the understanding of CE&S-related
issues and build internal capacity,
we hold training sessions for key risk
and banking personnel involved in
CE&S riskmanagement processes.
Thetrainingscover different topics,
including climate and sustainable finance,
ESG standards and the United Nations
Sustainable Development Goals, health
and safety, green taxonomy, renewable
energy investments, energy efficiency, and
green and affordable housing.
We engage with customers and
provide information on relevant laws
and regulations and the Bank’s ESMS
during our E&S due diligence processes.
By ensuring comprehensive E&S risk
assessment and action plans, the Bank
encourages customers to fulfil their
E&S obligations andachieve good E&S
standards.
During the E&S risk assessment, we work with our customers to:
Raise their awareness on EHS and climate
issues and regulations
Encourage companies to adopt best EHS
practices and challenge them on EHS risks
Make recommendations and measure
customers’ progress
Establish a framework for clients to
achieve good CE&S standards
Meet companies to better understand
sectorial EHS and climate risks, impacts
and opportunities
97
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Together with local sustainability third-party consultants, we provided Environmental Management
Awareness Trainings to SMEs and Corporate Banking clients on local environmental regulations and
requirements, as well as on mechanisms for ensuring compliance with these requirements, on legal
sanctions, state control mechanisms, and on the requirements and implementation mechanisms of
the international environmental management system standard ISO 14001:2015. The two-day training
series was conducted for 246 representatives of local companies from various sectors. Trainings were
supported by the GGF.
Together with external consultants, we prepared an electronic training module covering the same
topics that were offered to the training participants (mentioned above). The training module
is available on Bank of Georgia’s educational platform, businesscourse.ge, free of charge. The
development of this online module was supported by GGF.
An information leaflet on Bank of Georgia’s approach to managing customers’ E&S risks is available
on the Bank’s website.
2022-2023 customer engagement highlights:
Our impact through funding activities
In partnership with the European Investment Bank (EIB), we are
financing investment projects that support SMEs and MidCaps
in Georgia. We direct at least 30% of the funding to green loans
with better terms, thus giving Georgian businesses access to
better opportunities.
we direct at least 30%
of the funding to green
loans with better terms
offering our clients more
access to consulting
services and encouraging
businesses to invest in
energy efficiency
addressing environmental
challenges by reducing
global energy
consumption and CO₂
emissions through
promoting renewable
energy and energy
efficiency
In cooperation with GGF, Southeast Europe S.A., SICAV-SIF,
we have an opportunity to stimulate green financing of both
retail and business sectors in Georgia. A portfolio of combined
sub-loans is required to achieve at least 20% primary energy
and/or CO
2
savings. The Bank is expected to expand financing
for energy-efficient construction and green mortgages, while
encouraging businesses to invest in energy efficiency. Within
the framework of technical assistance, we can offer our clients
access to consulting services to make their businesses greener
and more focused on long-term sustainability.
With financing from the Global Climate Partnership Fund S.A
(GCPF), SICAV-SIF, the Bank has an opportunity to address
environmental challenges by reducing global energy consumption
and CO
2
emissions. The Bank, together with GCPF, is actively
involved in the promotion and support of renewable energy and
energy efficiency projects in the economies, which is expressed
by the fact that at least 75% of the amount of each sub-loan
reported by Bank of Georgia is directed to energy efficiency
renewable energy measures.
financial support, in
the form of cashbacks,
to help local SMEs
strengthen their
competitiveness and
compliance with
European standards
As part of an active cooperation with the EBRD, we use the
Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Area programme under
the EU4Business-EBRD credit line. Financial support, in the
form of a cashback, and technical assistance from international
advisors, allow us to help local MSMEs in strengthen their
competitiveness and compliance with European standards, and
especially to increase investments in green technologies and
promote green transformation.
98
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
The Groups wholly-owned subsidiary, an
investment bank G&T has been heavily
involved in advancing ESG objectives
through the local capital markets.
Having been the sole arranger of the first
sustainability-linked and social bonds
on the local market, as well as the co-
arranger of the first local green bonds,
G&T has pioneered ESG thematic bonds
in Georgia. The recent growth in local ESG
issuances has been incentivised by the
CMS Program in Georgia, supported by
the EU and the EBRD, and implemented
by G&T.
Supporting sustainability in the Georgian capital market
...with the help of a
technical assistance
component, we have
the ability to pay more
attention to business
sustainability and green
transformation...
...strengthening women-
owned businesses...
In partnership with the EBRD and Swedfund, we received a
Additional Tier 1 Capital Perpetual Subordinated Syndicated
Facility. Within the framework of the project, we should invest
an amount equal to the AT1 loan in green projects. This process
becomes even more effective with the grant received from the
EBRD, which provides technical assistance in the process of
identifying green loans. The Bank has the ability to pay more
attention to business sustainability and contribute to green
transformation.
In partnership with the European Fund for Southeast Europe
(EFSE), we have an opportunity to increase lending to MSMEs,
especially those engaged in sustainable activities. The funding
also aims to strengthen women-owned businesses to promote
gender equality and advance sustainable development.
Issuer Bond type Amount
Interest/
maturity
Subscribed
by
Second Party
Opinion issued by
Comment
Green US$ 80,000,000 7.00%;
5-year
EBRD, ADB,
IFC and FMO
First and largest
green bond locally
Sustainability-
linked
US$ 15,000,000 9.00%;
2-year
Mostly retail
subscribed
First ever
sustainability-
linked bond locally
Sustainability-
linked
US$ 5,000,000 8.50%;
2-year
Mostly retail
subscribed
First ever
sustainability-
linked bond locally
Sustainability-
linked
US$ 150,000,000 8.50%;
5-year
EBRD, ADB,
IFC and AIIB;
Pension Fund
and retail
investors;
Largest
sustainability-
linked bond locally
Social GEL 25,000,000 3m TIBR +
475 bps;
2-year
ADB
anchored
transaction
First social bond in
Georgia
99
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
TCFD
100
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Managing our transition to
a climate resilient future
Changing climate presents both risks and opportunities for Georgia, its
people and its companies, and thus for the financial services sector. The Group
recognises its role in addressing this global challenge, and initiated its climate
transition journey in 2021. We have considered our reporting obligations under
both the UK Financial Conduct Authoritys Listing Rules and Sections 414CA
and 414 CB of the UK Companies Act 2006, and confirm that we have made
disclosures consistent with the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended
disclosures. On the following pages we explain our current position, state our
expectations for the future, and identify where additional work is required for us
to disclose fully against all TCFD recommendations. This report focuses on the
Group’s main operating entity, JSC Bank of Georgia, which constituted 95.3% of
the Group’s total assets as at 31 December 2023.
Pillar Recommended disclosures Actions Page
GOVERNANCE
Disclose the organisation’s
governance around
climate-related risks and
opportunities
a) Describe the Board’s oversight of
climate-related risks and opportunities
Ensure governance structure is maintained 102-104
b) Describe management’s role in assessing
and managing climate-related risks and
opportunities
Executive KPIs to be aligned with green
loan portfolio target
114
STRATEGY
Disclose the actual and
potential impacts of
climate-related risks
and opportunities on the
organisation’s businesses,
strategy, and financial
planning where such
information is material
a) Describe the climate-related risks
and opportunities the organisation has
identified over the short, medium, and long
term
Annual review and further incorporation
into business strategy
105
b) Describe the impact of climate-
related risks and opportunities on the
organisation’s businesses, strategy, and
financial planning
Commitment to quantify the impacts on
our financial planning
105-107;
109
c) Describe the resilience of the
organisation’s strategy, taking into
consideration different climate-related
scenarios, including a 2°C or lower scenario
Develop robust scenario analyses to test
the resilience of the business
105-106
RISK MANAGEMENT
Disclose how the organisation
identifies, assesses, and
manages climate-related
risks
a) Describe the organisations processes
for identifying and assessing climate-
related risks
Review processes for identifying and
managing climate-related risks
111-113
b) Describe the organisation’s processes
for managing climate-related risks
Review processes for managing climate-
related risks
111-113
c) Describe how processes for identifying,
assessing, and managing climate-related
risks are integrated into the organisation’s
overall risk management
Review processes for integrating climate-
related risks
111
METRICS AND TARGETS
Disclose the metrics and
targets used to assess
and manage relevant
climate-related risks and
opportunities where such
information is material
a) Disclose the metrics used by the
organisation to assess climate-related risks
and opportunities in line with its strategy
and risk management process
Set, review and monitor targets 114
b) Disclose Scope 1, Scope 2, and, if
appropriate, Scope 3 greenhouse gas
(GHG) emissions, and the related risks
Disclose and monitor our GHG emissions 115-118
c) Describe the targets used by the
organisation to manage climate-related
risks and opportunities and performance
against targets
Set, review and monitor targets 114
101
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
In adherence to our responsibility outlined
in the Listing Rules of the UK’s Financial
Conduct Authority, we confirm that
our disclosures in this Annual Report
align with the recommendations and
recommended disclosures of the TCFD.
Our climate action and reporting are
in line with the four pillars defined by
the TCFD: Governance, Strategy, Risk
Management, and Metrics and Targets.
However, we note an exception: complete
disclosure of Scope 3 GHG emissions is
pending, as we are currently engaged
in a thorough analysis of our portfolio,
prioritising sectors with the highest
carbon intensity due to a lack of reliable
data and the absence of relevant
regulations to compel counterparties to
disclose emissions data in the country.
During 2023, we did not have any climate-
related targets. However, for 2024, green
loan portfolio targets will be included in
Executive Management KPIs and linked
to remuneration. Going forward, we may
consider developing additional sector-
specific targets.
Key messages
Climate-related taxonomy
Climate change
Long-term shifts in temperatures and weather patterns accelerated by the release
of GHGs into the atmosphere due to human activity such as burning of fossil fuels,
deforestation and agriculture
Climate risk
Risks that can impact financial institutions in different ways, from direct impacts on
the Bank’s buildings and operations to indirect impacts on client default rates and
portfolio riskiness.
Risk types:
Physical risk: Risks result from climate change. Acute physical risks arise from extreme
weather events such as floods, wildfires and droughts. Chronic physical risks arise
from gradual climate shifts such as rising sea levels, rising average temperatures and
loss of biodiversity.
Transition risk: Risks result from global efforts to prevent climate change. Risk drivers
can include climate-related policy or regulatory changes, such as the implementation
of a carbon tax or of country-wide climate targets, technology disruptions, such as
the development of a clean fuel source, and changes in consumer preferences.
Climate opportunity
Efforts to mitigate the impacts of climate change, adapt to changing conditions, and
transition towards a more sustainable and resilient future.
In 2015, 197 nations, including Georgia,
committed to the goals of the Paris
Agreement to limit global warming to 2°C
above preindustrial levels, while pursuing
the means to limit the increase to 1.5°C.
With its rich biodiversity and economic
dependence on climate-sensitive sectors
such as agriculture and tourism, Georgia
is vulnerable to the effects of climate
change. In 2017, Georgia’s GHG emissions
amounted to 17,766 Gg CO
2
e, or about
0.03% of the global total. With one of the
world’s highest shares of hydropower in
the electricity mix (75.3% in 2019), GHG
emissions from the electricity sector are
comparatively low. National emissions
are growing, however, particularly in
sectors such as transport and industry.
To address the impacts and meet the
objectives of the Paris Agreement,
Georgia has several climate action goals:
Climate change in Georgia at a glance
By 2030, to reduce total GHG emissions by 35% compared with the 1990 level and to limit emissions in sectors such as
energy and transportation
1
To support renewable energy generation and transmission
2
To support the development of low-carbon approaches in the building, industry, waste and agriculture sectors
3
To set national energy-saving targets in private and public sectors, particularly in relation to energy efficiency in buildings
4
In 2023, the Georgian Government
published the consulting document ‘Green
Book’ on Climate Change Law of Georgia.
The aim of the Green Book was to open
consultations and public discussions
on the implementation of the law on
climate change. Based on the public
consultations and analysis of the Green
Book, the ‘White Book’ was developed. A
public consultation on the White Book of
the Climate Change Law was held at the
end of 2023. The White Book includes the
main principles that should be reflected in
the Climate Change Law of Georgia.
As noted by the Prime Minister of Georgia
at COP28, Georgia has adopted the
long-term low emissions development
strategy, declaring ‘carbon neutrality
as an important goal by 2050. Georgia
has also committed to presenting a new
Nationally Determined Contribution
(NDC) in 2025.
102
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Governance
Board of Directors
The Board oversees the Groups operations and ensures it is being managed in accordance with its strategies and targets. Since
2022, the Board has been actively involved in ensuring the quality and efficacy of the Bank’s approach to climate change:
In 2022, the Board reviewed and approved the Bank’s Climate Action Strategy and CliRM framework (internal).
In 2023, the Board approved the Environmental Policy. The new policy sets the general principles and the key management and
control objectives to be followed by the Group in terms of environmental protection with a focus on climate change, E&S risk
management and sustainable finance.
The Board considers performance against the objectives defined in the Bank’s strategies.
The Board is responsible for reviewing the Group’s strategies, policies and budgets:
In 2023, the Board reviewed Bank of Georgia Group PLC’s 2022 Annual Report and provided feedback and guidance for enhancing
the Bank’s sustainability management, including climate risk and opportunity management.
In September 2023, the Board was also informed on the Bank’s progress on climate action during one of its quarterly Board
meetings.
From 2024, the Bank’s new climate-related due diligence, which was launched in 2023, will generate more detailed information on
climate risks and opportunities in the portfolio, the results of which will be reviewed by the Board. The Board receives quarterly
risk reporting that provides updates on the green portfolio.
In 2023, the Bank started preparing climate risk assessment reports for all large credit requests and presented to the Supervisory
Board for their review. These reports provide information on current regulatory requirements, including the country’s climate-
related strategy and action plan towards the specific sectors and details on clients’ climate transition plans.
The Board regularly examines opportunities and risks as well as the measures taken as a result:
The Supervisory Board of the Bank, as exemplified in its statute adopted in accordance with the NBG’s Corporate Governance
Code, bears the overall responsibility for the Bank’s ESG strategy and its implementation. This includes overseeing the Bank’s E&S
risk management framework and building governance structures to ensure proper attention to E&S issues, and fulfilment of the
Bank’s strategic goals in this regard.
In December 2021, the Supervisory Board decided to maintain the primary decision making and reporting on E&S matters at the
full Board level.
The Supervisory Board bears the overall responsibility for the Bank’s ESG strategy
Mandate/scope Membership Frequency
Bank of Georgia
Group PLC Board
Responsible for the long-term success of the Group as
a whole and the delivery of sustainable value to
shareholders. It oversees the Group’s operations
and ensures it is being managed in accordance with
its strategies and targets. Approval of the Company’s
climate-related financial disclosures.
Full Board At least quarterly.
Risk Committee
Primary responsibility for risk management at the
Board level, including overseeing climate change as an
emerging risk in the Banks loan portfolio.
At least three Independent Non-executive Directors.
CRO attends all the meetings. Other members
of Executive Management attend as and when
required. For more information about the Committee,
please see pages 224 to 228.
At least four times
a year.
Audit Committee
Assesses the quality of the Company’s disclosures,
including the quality of data and whether the
information provided is sufficient for stakeholders
to assess how the Group is managing climate-
related matters.
At least three Independent Non-executive Directors.
Attended by Internal Audit and External Audit. May also
be attended by Executive Management members and
senior managers as and when required. For more
information about the Committee, please see pages 214
to 223.
At least four times
a year.
Remuneration
Committee
May set climate-related targets for the CEO and
considers how the Bank’s management performs
against climate-related objectives and targets.
At least three Independent Non-executive Directors.
For more information about the Committee, please
see pages 229 to 247.
At least twice a
year.
ESI Committee
Reviews progress in the implementation of the
Bank’s Climate Action Strategy and the CLiRM
framework and stipulates appropriate measures.
CEO, CRO, COO, CFO, CLO, Head of HR, CMO,
Head of Investor Relations and Head of Funding.
Quarterly
Governance and accountability structure
103
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Board of Directors and senior management
At the instruction of the Supervisory
Board, to anchor climate change and
other sustainability-related topics, a
management-level ESI Committee
was established and held for the first
time in 2022, comprising the Executive
Management Team and senior managers,
including the Bank’s CEO, CRO, Head of
Operations, CFO, CLO, Head of HR, CMO,
Head of Investor Relations, and Head of
Funding. The Committee is appointed by
the Board and shall consist of a minimum
of three members. The Committee
Chairman is the CEO.
The Committee is responsible for
managing the Bank’s CE&S impacts,
focusing on those arising from its lending
and operational activities. It holds overall
responsibility for designing, implementing
and enhancing CE&S strategies and
policies, and for setting and monitoring
targets. The Committee intends to
further embed E&S risk management
into the Bank’s daily operations. The
Committee Chairman reports to the
Board on its proceedings and decisions
within its duties and responsibilities. The
final responsibility for the decisions made
by the ESI Committee rests with the
Supervisory Board.
ESI Committee meets quarterly. In 2023,
one meeting was focused on the revised
Environmental Policy which sets general
principles with a focus on climate change,
E&S risk management and sustainable
finance, and with one meeting focusing
on climate-related matters. In 2023, the
ESI Committee played an active role in
promoting the strategy and monitoring
the integration of sustainability into the
Bank’s business processes and activities.
Its work has been supported by a cross-
functional Climate Working Group
established in 2021, which continued to
work through 2022-2023 to develop Bank
of Georgia’s Climate Action Strategy,
design new climate and green finance
related processes and methodologies,
integrate climate-related risks into overall
risk management process, and contribute
to preparing climate-related disclosures.
In 2023, key people from the Bank’s
Corporate Banking and SME Banking
segments and Risk, Legal, ECRM, IT,
Operational Support and Funding
departments participated in meetings
to support critical processes related
to climate-related opportunities and
risks and related to the integration of
sustainability into day-to-day activity.
They report to the CEO and the Board of
Directors through the ESI Committee.
To achieve the best performance of its
functions in this area, the Board believes
it is necessary to have suitable knowledge
and experience in sustainability matters.
To this end, the Board continues to
receive the training on matters related to
sustainability.
The Groups sustainability governance
model allows the Board and its
Committees to have the necessary
information to make suitable decisions
and perform their supervisory and
control functions.
Our Senior Non-executive Director, Hanna Loikkanen, who serves as a member of the Audit Committee and the Nomination
Committee, has extensive experience in climate-related matters and has completed courses at the London Business School on
Sustainable Leadership and Corporate Responsibility and at GRI on Sustainability Reporting and GRI Standards. Currently, she
serves as the Chief Investment Officer of Finnfund, a Finnish state-owned development financier and impact investor that has
a focus on sectors that are critical to sustainable development, including renewable energy, sustainable forestry, sustainable
agriculture, financial institutions, and digital infrastructure and solutions, and where every investment decision is reviewed against a
detailed climate impact analysis and the board are given regular training on climate-related regulations. She has also been a board
member of Caucasus Nature Fund since 2020, a nature conservation trust that provides funding and management assistance to
protected areas in Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia. Additionally, Board members will receive climate-related training as part of
their ongoing development in 2024 and seek out further opportunities to build their skills and experience in this area.
Skills and competencies at the Board level
104
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Our climate-related governance
Board of Directors / Supervisory Board
Environmental and Social Impact Committee
Enterprise-wide risk Environmental & Climate Risk Lending, Credit Risk
ESG & Sustainability Investor Relations Operations Legal
Climate Working Group
Topic Responsibilities Overall
responsibility
ERM
Assesses the impact of specific climate scenarios on principal risks.
Ensures climate risks are well integrated into the Bank’s overall risk management framework and
management responses. In the future, this may entail coordination and/or implementation of
climate-related stress testing, and integration of climate-related considerations into the Bank’s
Risk Appetite Statement and policies.
CRO
ECRM
Conducts research on climate-related matters (policies, risk assessment methods, etc.).
Assesses climate-related risks for the Bank’s clients, based on a standardised due diligence process.
Together with Corporate Banking department, calculates financed emissions.
Supports other departments in conducting climate-related tasks.
Prepares climate-related disclosures.
CRO
Corporate and
Investment Banking
and SME Banking
departments
Collects data from clients for climate-related risk assessment and GHG calculation. CEO
Corporate and
Investment Banking
and SME Banking
departments Credit
Risk Management
departments
Checks whether information collected by bankers during initial climate-related screening is
reasonable before projects are submitted to the Credit Committee.
In the future, possibly conducts climate-related stress testing (alongside ERM).
CEO
Operational support
Department
Collects relevant data and calculates GHG emissions from the Bank’s own operations, including
Scope 1, 2 and 3 (except financed emissions).
Sets the Bank’s supply chain ESG policies and supplier ESG due diligence.
COO
Investor Relations
department
Notifies the ECRM department of climate-related requirements and/or expectations of investors
and stakeholders that could lead to reputational risks for the Group.
CEO
ESG and
Sustainability
direction
Is responsible for the Bank’s overall ESG strategy and sustainability agenda.
Leads and supports development of green lending products.
Is responsible for ESG policies.
CLO
Legal department
Conducts research on new climate-related regulation that could lead to legal risks for the Group. CLO
HR department
Ensures the relevant people have required skill sets to address sustainability and climate issues.
Ensures employee awareness and engagement actions on climate and sustainability.
Head of HR
105
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Strategy
Risks and opportunities for Bank of Georgia under different scenarios
Strengthening scenario analysis across multiple time horizons
Assessing the climate resilience of our business model and strategy
Climate-related risks may adversely impact
the Bank both directly and indirectly. Such
risks arise from the physical or transition
effects of climate change and manifest
through more common risk types, including
credit risk, market risk, operational risk and
reputational risk.
Physical risks result from climate and
weather-related events (such as floods
and droughts), while transition risks arise
from the move towards a low-carbon
economy (new climate policies or changes
in consumer preferences, for example).
The transition to a low-carbon,
climate-resilient economy also creates
opportunities for the financial sector to
support innovative green products and
services that meet growing sustainable
investment needs, such as climate-smart
agricultural technology or more energy-
efficient buildings. Bank of Georgia
continues to integrate these risks and
opportunities into its risk assessment and
management framework as part of an
ongoing commitment to building more
resilient and sustainable communities.
Climate risk identification informs Bank
of Georgia’s regular risk management
processes and considers our standard
time horizons. The short, medium- and
long-term time spans were defined to
reflect internal procedures and indicators,
such as financial planning, strategic
planning and average loan maturity.
The majority of our loans will be paid
back before 2030. Nevertheless, climate
change risks have to be mitigated before
they arise, making it necessary to expand
our horizons. We have defined a fourth
timeframe (‘very long’) to ensure climate
risks that may manifest over the longer
term are adequately identified and
managed.
To assess climate-related risks and
opportunities in the short, medium and
long term, we use scenario analysis to
consider how risks and opportunities may
evolve under different situations and
impact our business model and strategic
planning. Scenario analysis assists in the
identification, measurement and ongoing
assessment of climate risks, so we can
better evaluate potential threats to the
Bank’s strategic objectives and its ability
to create value over the longer term.
We started to use qualitative scenario
analysis in 2021, combining our research
on climate change and climate policies
in Georgia with selected terminology,
assumptions and narratives from the
scenarios developed by the Network for
Greening the Financial System.
Our scenario analysis capabilities are
evolving. Over the past two years, the
modelling of climate risk impact over
the short-, medium- and long-term time
spans have been hamstrung across
multiple dimensions, including scenario
data and pathways, availability of client-
specific data, missing national legislation
on climate change. We are constantly
revising our data strategy to bridge data
gaps. This is a multi-year endeavour
involving periodically working with external
consultants, use of proxies and engaging
clients to gather more information.
From 2023, the ‘top-down’ analysis of
our business portfolio is accompanied
by ‘bottom-up’ client-level assessments
through an updated due diligence process.
In-depth data collection helps us better
understand and model impacts which is
prerequisite for the scenario analysis and
stress-testing.
In 2024, we plan to progressively
strengthen our scenario analysis
capabilities with support from EIB
within the framework of Greening
Financial Systems Technical Assistance
Programme. Improving the Bank’s CliRM
framework requires identifying potential
gaps, conducting materiality assessment
of both climate risks and opportunities
against selected climate change
scenarios, and climate risk stress testing
and impacts on the Bank’s financial
position, financial performance and cash
flows. Our intention is to focus on how
climate risk management can inform
portfolio management and support
opportunity identification with clients on
their transition and adaptation pathways.
Short
<2 years
Medium
2-5 years
Long
5-7 years
Very long
>7 years
Transition risks, 2023-2030. ‘Nationally Determined Contribution’ scenario: The effects of climate change will become
more clearly tangible over the next decades but, in the meantime, it is important for Bank of Georgia to understand its
more immediate impacts. This period was assessed assuming the Georgian Government will drive action to achieve the
unconditional GHG reduction goals identified in its updated NDC (2021). The Georgian Government supports efforts to
reduce the countrys GHG emissions, especially by fostering renewable energy and low(er) carbon transportation.
1
Transition risks, 2030-2050. ‘Delayed Transition’ scenario: This period was assessed using the ‘Delayed Transition’
scenario, which assumes Georgia will initiate highly ambitious climate change mitigation and adaptation policies from
2030 onwards – building on and enhancing the climate policies described in the introductory part of this section. Global
ambitions to protect the climate drastically rise after 2030. Due to external and internal pressure, the Government of
Georgia also introduces more ambitious climate policy. After 2050, assuming most relevant technologies and systems are
low or zero carbon, the transition will slow down. Transition risks would be highest under this scenario.
2
Physical risks, from 2040 onwards. ‘Current Policies’ scenario: The world continues ‘Business as usual’ and no new
climate protection measures are introduced besides what is in place today. Projections show that, under the ‘Current
Policies’ scenario, temperatures and related physical risks will start to significantly rise in 2040 compared to the ‘Delayed
Transition’ scenario. The ‘Current Policies’ scenario assumes governments do not increase the level of ambition of their
climate policies beyond today’s level. Physical risks would be highest under this scenario.
3
Georgia’s NDC anchor the scenarios applied by the Bank for materiality analysis. Country NDCs are aligned with the Paris
Agreement which has a stated objective to keep global warming well below 2°C. As such, our scenario framework implicitly assumes
a 2°C scenario. We have, however, not modelled potential impacts across these scenarios on our financial position and capital
planning across multiple time horizons. We will continue to work on this in 2024.
106
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Type of risk Definition Drivers
(physical and transition risks)
Risk score
<2030 >2030 >2040
NDC Delayed
Transition
Current
Policies
Credit
The risk that the Bank incurs a
loss because its customers fail to
fulfil their contractual obligations.
Both climate policy (transition risks) and climate
change (physical risks) can negatively affect
borrowers’ repayment capacity and the value of
collateral. Risks are more pronounced in certain
sectors and geographies. At the same time, we
expect positive credit enhancements from clients
already aligned to a low carbon-transition (see
our NBG Taxonomy-aligned portfolio) or resilient
to physical risks.
Low Low/medium for many sectors
but high for others (such as
electricity generation and
agriculture – see heatmap on
the next page); location specific
risks to be determined from
2023.
Liquidity
The risk that the Bank is unable
to meet its payment obligations
when they fall due under normal
and stress circumstances.
Affected borrowers cannot pay back loans or they
withdraw deposits, reducing the Bank’s liquidity. If
sovereign or bank credit ratings are downgraded,
the availability of wholesale funding decreases
and cost of funding increases.
Low Medium Medium
Capital
The risk that the Bank fails
to meet the minimum capital
adequacy requirements set by the
regulator.
Borrowers’ repayment issues can negatively
affect the credit quality of the Bank’s portfolio,
requiring increased loan loss provision and
adjusted risk-weighted assets.
Low Medium Medium/High
Market
The risk that can manifest
through transition risk channels
through market value loss,
asset and liability management
impact due to societal, legal and
technological response to climate
change, particularly affecting
loans and equities. Physical
risk channels can also results
in market value loss and asset
liability management impact due
to weather impacts, particularly
affecting property and real
estate.
The Bank is mostly exposed to foreign exchange
and interest rate risks. Physical and transition
risks can cause global economic downturn and
an increase in market volatility affecting interest
rates and currencies. Both climate change and
ambitious climate policies can weaken growth
prospects and cause greater uncertainty over
economic development. However, effective
climate policy – involving, for example, public
investment in new technology – could also spur
growth. Both effects could have an influence on
markets, FX rates and interest rates. Climate
change is currently rather low on the Georgian
government’s agenda and does not have
significant effects on the economy yet. In the
middle-term perspective temporary economic
challenges caused by ambitious climate policy
could affect interest rates and currency value. In
the long-term perspective, Economic downturn
due to climate change could affect the Georgian
currency, especially compared to countries which
are less affected by climate change. In case of
fluctuation of the Georgian Lari or increased
volatility in local and global market interest rates
due to climate-related risks, the Bank’s financial
position may be adversely affected, proportional
to its open currency position and interest rate
gap. In addition, traditional methodologies of
market risk management and measurement,
such as Value at Risk, are limited to capture
climate-related shocks due to limited availability
of historical data.
Low Medium Medium
Operations
The risk of loss arising from
systems failure, human error,
fraud or external events.
Climate change can interrupt the Bank’s regular
operations and increase the cost of maintaining
effective business resilience (especially back office
processes and data centres). Affected borrowers
could potentially conduct fraud.
Low Low/Medium Medium
Reputation
The risk of damage occurring due
to failure to meet stakeholders’
expectations.
Lack of meaningful climate action could affect
the Bank’s reputation among investors and
customers. Reputation could also suffer if the
Bank struggles with other climate-induced
challenges that affect the continuity and quality
of its services.
Medium High Medium
We have identified Bank-wide climate-related risks over the short, medium, long and very long term
Notes on methodology: In 2023, climate-
related risks were assessed by answering
the following questions:
1. Identification of risk drivers and
transmission channels: How does climate
change interrelate with and increase
existing banking risks?
2. Assessment of impact: How strongly
will Bank of Georgia be affected by the
identified risk drivers if they emerge?
3. Assessment of likelihood: How likely is
it that the identified risk drivers emerge
under the three scenarios?
Impact and likelihood values range from
one (insignificant/remote) to five (critical/
almost certain), with the definition of
values differing between risk types. The
resulting risk scores can be low, medium,
high or critical, as shown below. In some
cases, risk scores can lie between these
categories (low/medium, medium/high,
high/critical), because the risk is judged
to be right on the border between two
categories, for example, or to illustrate
that different risk drivers lead to different
risk scores under the same scenario.
Theoretically, an important driver of the
likelihood of climate-related risks is the
likelihood of the scenario that is being
used. Yet, providers of climate-related
scenarios do not usually determine
the probability of individual scenarios
– they are simply considered plausible.
The likelihood of certain scenarios to
materialise of course changes over time,
as decisions are made and assumptions
become true or false. In our analysis
we have found that risks will not differ
significantly between the defined short-,
medium- and long-term timeframes –
that is, within the next seven years we
do not view significant movement in
the policy nor technology trends as risks
107
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Climate change can especially affect Bank of Georgia through its impact on the lending
portfolio. A preliminary, portfolio-level qualitative analysis of our corporate and SME portfolios
– making up 54.4% of the Bank’s (consolidated) total gross loan portfolio at 31 December 2023 –
has helped us understand hypothetical risks for different sectors.
nor do we view current assessment of
physical risk impacts as diverging from
business as usual which is why results are
presented together under ‘<2030’.
We will continue refining our approach
to Bank-wide climate-related risk
assessment going forward.
In BOG’s 2023 scenario analysis, an
orderly transition’ scenario was not used
given that there is currently not much
evidence of ‘immediate and smooth’
implementation of ambitious climate
policies, which is the key assumption of
such a scenario. For now, BOG could thus
assume that the three scenarios used so
far (Delayed Transition, NDCs, Current
Policies) are equally likely. This could be
reassessed when trends are becoming
clearer – at the latest in 2030, when many
NDCs end and when ambitious climate
policy should be initiated according to the
Delayed Transition scenario.
5
4
3
2
1
1 2 3 4 5
Our heat map for assessing inherent sector-based climate risks
<2030:
Transition risk
(NDC)
2030-2050:
Transition
risk (Delayed
Transition)
From 2040:
Physical risk
(Current Policies)
Agriculture and
forestry
Crop production
Animal husbandry
Fishing
Forestry & logging
Buildings – construction
Real estate
Energy/electricity
Gas-fired thermal power plants
Hydropower plants
Other renewable energy (currently no exposure)
Distribution and trade (currently no exposure)
Health
Hospitality
Manufacturing
Food & beverages
Textiles
Wood-based products
Chemicals
Cement and similar construction material
Metals
Other (incl. glass, plastics, etc.)
Refined petroleum products
Transport-related goods
Other
Mining & quarrying
Fossil energy carriers (currently no exposure)
Other
Sale
Agri/forestry-related goods
Other
Services
Related to agri/forestry
Related to construction
Related to transport
Other
Transport
Railways (electric) (currently no exposure)
On water (currently no exposure)
Other
Waste and water
Waste management
Water and wastewater (currently no exposure)
Individuals/unknown use
<2030:
TRANSITION
RISK CB
<2030:
TRANSITION
RISK MEDIUM
<2030:
TRANSITION
RISK SMALL
Potential risks in the 2023
business portfolio
1.3%
0.2%
0.2%
63.1%
57.0%
52.8%
45.9%
36.8%
42.8%
Low
Medium
High
Very high
Unknown
108
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Notes on methodology: Figures are as at
31 December 2023. Delayed Transition and
Current Policies are extreme scenarios for
transition and physical risks, respectively.
We assumed the structure of the
balance sheet stays the same to assess
long-term risks for our portfolio. The
assessment was conducted at the level
of more than 650 individual activities,
based on NACE2 codes, and aggregated
for the sectors presented above. For
transition risks, estimated GHG emissions
and potential contribution to their
efficient reduction were evaluated. For
physical risks, basic parameters such
as the activity’s dependence on water,
vulnerability against extreme weather
events and the need for raw materials
were considered. Results were compared
against the Climate-related Risk Radar
for Georgian Economic Sectors and its
possible Application for the Financial
Sector1, and were found to be in line.
Location-specific risks and individual
borrowers’ characteristics, such as
existing low-carbon transformation
plans or adaptive capacities, were not
considered in 2023 due to lack of data as
we started collection of relevant data and
understanding of risks at location- and
counterparty-level from 2023. Risks for
our Mass Retail and Premium Banking
portfolio have not yet been assessed in
detail, as they depend to a high degree
on individual borrowers’ characteristics
and the location of the activity or asset
financed. We aim to also understand
climate-related risks for our mortgage
portfolio, using location-specific data.
17.9%
1.9%
0%
% exposure to carbon-related
assets in the Bank’s gross
loan portfolio
% exposure to fossil fuel and
coal-related assets in the
Bank’s gross loan portfolio
No exposure to fossil fuel and
coal exploration and mining
assets in the Bank’s gross
loan portfolio
Exposure to carbon-related sectors
As at 31 December 2023 this equals GEL 3,670 million (GEL 3,018 million in 2022). We
define ‘carbon-related assets’ as those tied to the four non-financial groups identified
by the TCFD.
The following industries are included: oil and gas, coal, electric utilities, air freight,
passenger air transportation, maritime transportation, trucking services, automobiles
and components, metals and mining, chemicals, construction materials, real estate
management and development, beverages, agriculture, and food, paper and
forest products.
As at 31 December 2023 this equals GEL 395 million. (GEL 197 million in 2022). This
number includes exposures to wholesale of solid, liquid and gaseous fuels and related
products, retail sale of automotive fuel, electricity production from natural gas, and
cement production which uses coal as a fuel.
As at 31 December this equals to GEL 0. We have no exposure to prospection,
exploration and mining of fossil fuels or electric utilities using coal.
2022: 18.2%
2022: 1.2%
The uncertainties surrounding the timing
and impact of physical and transition
risks make it challenging for any tool
or methodology to accurately estimate
climate change risks, both currently and
in the future. Nevertheless, recognising
the urgency, we are actively developing
methodologies, collaborating with
clients, and integrating climate risk into
our core risk management practices
and assessments. We want to remain
adaptable, adjusting our approach as
the clarity on the impact of climate risk
increases and reliable data-gathering
tools and methodologies mature.
The data we started to gather in 2023
played a pivotal role in formulating client
specific climate-risk assessments for
both our existing and new clients. It also
contributed to enhancing our internal
climate capabilities and fortifying the
measurement and monitoring of portfolio
risks. These enhancements are expected
to be a gradual process. The scarcity of
data and the absence of historical data
related to transition or physical risks is
one of the main challenges for emerging
markets.
In 2024, we will advance our capabilities by enhancing the methodology on credit and
investments portfolio screening for climate-related transition and physical risks in line with IFRS
S2. Our ongoing engagement with high and very high risk SME Banking and Corporate Banking
clients remains a priority.
109
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Total outstanding green finance as at 31 December 2023 (GEL million)
Bank of Georgia works with its lenders
such as GGF, GCPF, EBRD, Swedfund,
and EIB to provide green finance. Through
our ‘Energy Credit’ initiative, we offer
companies credit to buy solar panels.
Other green finance is directed mostly
towards large-scale renewable energy
(hydropower plants) and green transport.
In 2022, we conducted a market
analysis to identify opportunities for
green financing. We analysed relevant
regulation, interviewed companies
from different sectors to determine
their interest in green investments and
green loans, and identified green service
providers in Georgia (for the installation
of energy-efficient equipment, for
example). The findings will be used to
expand our climate-friendly lending in the
years to come.
The analysis showed that solar panels,
material recycling, energy efficiency
measures, installation of air filters, and
adoption of electric and hybrid transport
vehicles are among the most attractive
investments for our clients. Products
and services to realise such measures
can be procured from local green service
providers, while more innovative or newly
marketed services and products must
be sourced from international markets.
Our work also showed that Bank of
Georgia’s visibility as a provider of green
loans is perceived as low, requiring better
marketing and communication in the
future.
Bank of Georgia also sees the opportunities in the transition
to a low-carbon economy
Energy efficiency
Bio/Eco
Climate smart agriculture
Waste
Green transport
Renewable energy
Green buildings
Total outstanding green portfolio is
3.7% (3.0% in 2022) of the Bank’s
gross loan portfolio. This includes
the portfolio identified based on the
NBG’s Green Taxonomy criteria.
Compliance with Sustainable Finance Taxonomy
462138
36
30 6 5
75
GEL 752
TOTAL
In 2022, the NBG published its Sustainable
Finance Taxonomies, covering green and
social topics. From January 2023, all
Georgian banks are required to report on
the amount of lending aligned with these
taxonomies. Bank of Georgia prepared
for implementing the taxonomy by
updating its internal classification system
to NACE2 – the European classification
system used by the NBG’s taxonomies
for identifying sectors and activities that
are or could potentially be green – and
by operationalising selected taxonomy
criteria so bankers can determine whether
clients are compliant. We started reporting
in January 2023. We may not be able
to assess compliance with all taxonomy
criteria yet – possibly leading to a situation
in which we report less taxonomy-
aligned lending than we might actually
have. This is due to several criteria being
highly complex (for example, referring to
European Directives that are implemented
differently in different Member States of
the EU), making it difficult or impossible to
check compliance during a standard loan
appraisal process.
In 2023, external consultants supported
us in operationalising technical screening
criteria of the NBG Green Taxonomy
for ease of use by the bankers within
the framework of Green Loan Quick
Opportunities Type Description Term Action
Need for
real sector
to adapt
to climate
change
Transition
& physical
Climate change is expected to cause a wider spread
of hazards and with higher intensities. It is therefore
necessary to continue raising awareness of clients and
support capacity building to manage climate risks.
Medium,
Long Term
Bank of Georgia will continue to use tools such
as our CliRM, financed emission calculator, and
heatmaps to pinpoint clients most exposed to
inherent risks and advise on adaptive capacities.
Technological
change
Transition More ambitious climate policies and favourable policy
environment for the uptake of low carbon technologies
have been developing. Technologies are also developing
accordingly. Additional investments will be needed across
the real economy to remain competitive and align with
the global transition to low carbon economic growth.
This shall create new lending opportunities for BOG.
Short,
Medium,
Long Term
Bank of Georgia monitors the market status,
needs and opportunities to develop products
and connect IFI credit lines for technological
development and investment in low carbon
technologies.
Opportunities from combating climate change
110
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
We acknowledge the fact that the financial sector is a crucial player in supporting the decarbonisation of economies, therefore the Bank
is committed to taking an active role in supporting Georgia’s climate-related goals. The Bank’s Climate Action Strategy is outlined below.
How climate change affects our strategy
We plan to meet our outlined ambition through the following commitments:
AmbitionCommitments
We commit to ensuring our actions support Georgia’s climate-related goals, including those specified in its updated
NDC (2021). As plans are updated, the Bank will update its own targets and policies with more detail
Anchoring climate expertise in our skill set.
Making climate change an integral part of capacity building.
Monitoring and managing
climate risks in the client base
Collecting data, raising clients’ awareness
and developing an approach to engaging
with high-risk clients.
Providing financing and solutions to
clients, and reducing the hurdles for
climate finance.
Supporting a low-carbon,
resilient economy
Incrementally expanding monitoring of our
operational carbon footprint and taking
relevant action.
Reducing our operational
carbon footprint
Monitoring and managing climate and environmental risks in the client base: Bank of Georgia will regularly assess climate-
related physical and transition risks across our portfolio. In 2022 we started collecting relevant data from borrowers to
understand their GHG emissions and related risks. In 2023 we began using this data to systematically identify clients
with the highest climate risks and discuss such risks with them. This will feed into our portfolio-level risk assessment and
allow us to continuously improve our understanding of sectors and clients that contribute to climate change through
GHG emissions, or that are vulnerable to the changing climate and associate impacts. We will ensure appropriate
management of our portfolio’s climate risk profile and new credit origination in line with our overall risk appetite.
1
Supporting the transition to a low-carbon, resilient economy: We strive to provide our clients with adequate climate
finance options to ensure they can implement credible, safe, innovative, high-quality climate solutions. We will actively
explore the opportunities to extend climate-related financing to different sectors and clients.
2
Reducing our operational carbon footprint: We are committed to monitoring emissions from our own operations (including
Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions, except financed emissions) and implementing measures that support their reduction. We also
commit to continuously improving our ability to measure our financed emissions and providing relevant figures in our
Annual Reports.
3
Anchoring climate expertise in our skill set: We are determined to invest in enhancing our climate-related capabilities
across the Bank, and to build a comprehensive toolkit for climate-related risk and opportunity management. The Bank’s
Climate Action Strategy will be implemented over the coming years, in line with a concrete action plan developed in 2022.
Risk and opportunity analysis will be repeated regularly and will inform any updates to the strategy.
4
Assessment programme funded by DEG
Impulse gGmbH (DEG). Additionally, the
NBG Taxonomy criteria were compared to
taxonomy criteria from DEG, EBRD and
GGF. As a result, we found that different
taxonomies were not fully aligned with
each other. In 2023 we strengthened our
capabilities across the Bank to identify,
capture and manage opportunities
regarding climate and green finance. We
will continue to address barriers in 2024
and beyond. In 2024, we plan to scrutinise
the Bank’s loan portfolio and screen market
opportunities for green investments. We
will review the Bank‘s loan portfolio and
lending practices, competitive landscape,
existing financing schemes and market
demand/investment opportunities for
green loans. We will define the key sector(s)
out of the ones identified in the materiality
assessment process and meaningful areas
of intervention with the greatest potential
to deploy dedicated green products. Based
on this assessment we will develop a Green
Finance Framework and Guidelines based
on national, EU and global standards.
External consultants will review and
suggest revisions to internal operations,
including credit policies and procedures
to integrate green lending considerations
into business processes. We will prioritise
sustainable finance products to clients in
high-carbon sectors to decarbonise their
business models.
111
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Bank of Georgia has developed a
complete training course and delivered ad
hoc trainings to ensure that its employees
can acquire the basic knowledge to be
able to address climate-related matters.
In 2023, we focused on educating
colleagues on climate and green finance.
A workshop on ESG impact scoping was
conducted for the Board of Directors and
senior management in July 2023. This
included discussions, among other topics,
on the actual and potential impacts
that the Bank has or could have on the
environment and climate. More than
200 colleagues across Corporate and
Investment Banking, SME Banking, Risk,
Legal and Trade Finance participated in
trainings on climate finance, the NBG’s
Green Taxonomy and climate change.
In 2024, we intend to embed climate
change and climate-related risk
management training material into the
Bank’s online learning platform.
Education and training
Number of
employees
Climate Finance and Green
Taxonomy
129
Green Finance Training
80
Green Trade Finance –
General concept
47
RENAC Academy Green Finance
Expert Course
2
UN Global Compact Climate
Ambition Accelerator
1
Training data
Risk management
Bank of Georgia is committed to addressing climate risks by integrating their identification,
evaluation and management within standard risk management procedures.
Beyond risk identification and assessment, Bank of Georgia has undertaken the following steps to manage climate-related risks
and opportunities:
Bank of Georgia has an ESMS in place, but climate is a complex topic that requires expertise from across the Bank and beyond.
To accelerate progress, we will continue to engage with third-party consultants in 2024.
Integrated risk management
Risk identification and evaluation
In 2023, we conducted the following exercises:
This framework describes climate-related responsibilities across the Bank and summarises all methods and processes for risk
assessment, evaluation and management. It includes detailed manuals for all climate-related activities, from Bank-wide climate risk
assessment to the calculation of financed emissions. The CliRM framework was approved by our ESI Committee and by the Board
in 2022. It is available to all staff via our intranet and will be reviewed regularly to ensure any changes in our approach to climate risk
and opportunity management are reflected.
Development of a CliRM framework:
In 2020, the Group identified climate change as an emerging risk for the first time, making climate-related risk an integral part of
our risk inventory. In 2021/22, an approach to understanding the magnifying effects of climate change on traditional banking risks
was developed and refined. Further steps to integrate climate into overall risk assessment and monitoring will be considered. This
could include reflecting climate risks in our Risk Appetite Statement and in our credit policies.
Integration of climate-related risks in our ERM framework:
In 2023, we continued to develop our climate-related due diligence process, to assess and address climate-related risks as part of our
loan appraisal and E&S monitoring. The process comprises four steps, as illustrated below. We started to implement steps one to
three in 2023, with step four to be introduced once we have gathered sufficient information on our existing client base and their risks
and when national regulation on climate change will be in place.
Integration of climate considerations in our due diligence process:
Based on the results of the 2022 Bank-wide climate risk analysis (see Annual Report 2022), we reassessed how the transition and
physical effects of climate change can drive credit, liquidity, market, capital, operational and reputational risk for the Bank over
varying time horizons and for different scenarios (see previous pages). Overall, our assessment of the magnifying effects of climate
change and climate-related transformations on Bank-wide risks remains similar to 2022 (please see more in the Strategy section).
Qualitative analysis of the effect of climate change on enterprise-wide risks:
Capacity building is crucial to ensure climate-related risks and opportunities are considered in every credit decision. For climate
risk specifically, in 2023, we developed a mandatory course on climate change and climate-related risk management, which will be
undertaken by the relevant staff across Corporate and Investment Banking, SME Banking, Risk, Trade Finance and Legal starting in
the first quarter of 2024.
Building climate-related risk management capacities
112
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Awareness raising
We make clients facing climate-related risks aware, so they can start to act
(see flyer - https://bankofgeorgia.ge/en/about/management#docs)
Additional data collection
We address high-risk clients to determine whether they actually face climate risks identified in step one.
In-depth climate risk assessment
We will engage with selected (corporate) clients to support their climate management.
Initial screening
We preliminarily assess clients’ climate-related risks by looking at their sector and location.
1
2
3
4
Bottom-up climate risk assessment at client level
The first step of this process is to identify
expected transition risks based on the
sector in which a clients generate their
income, and expected physical risks
based on the sector and location of
income generation. While we draw on the
heat map to assess risks per sector, the
analysis of risks for different locations
is based on our ‘hazard map’ developed
in 2022 – which shows physical risks for
different sectors across 64 Georgian
municipalities, taking up to 11 climate
hazards (from landslides to changes in
precipitation) into account for the overall
score. The analysis is based on publicly
available data, including from Georgian
and international sources.
Although our approach does not currently
allow for determining different risk
levels within the same municipality (for
example depending on the proximity
to high-risk zones such as rivers and
slopes), we expect the results to be
sufficiently detailed to allow us to engage
our clients on climate-related risks and
opportunities.
In 2023, we conducted an exposure
analysis of our portfolio against various
hazards across the country. Hazards we
have assessed include urban flood, river
flood, extreme heat, and wildfires. Our
team of experts qualitatively assessed
the level of risk from these hazards using
various sources including Thinkhazard.org.
For example, areas designated as high
river flood are ‘determined as potentially
damaging and life-threatening river
floods expected to occur at least once in
the next 10 years.’ The assessment has led
to low, medium, and high risk categories
following Thinkhazard methodologies.
1
Our portfolio demonstrated minimal exposure (1.6% of total loans as at 31 December 2023) to
areas designated as ‘high’ physical risk.
‘High’ physical risk hazards are found
in Batumi and Tbilisi mostly under real
estate and hotel activities. In Batumi
there is a ‘high’ risk of flooding according
to our hazard map. However, we deem
these exposures to have low residual risk
as they conform to national regulations
and laws on construction. We have
also begun incorporating historical
flood analysis in our due diligence. In
Tbilisi the ‘high’ risk hazard is extreme
temperatures. Hotels and real estate
activities are deemed to have low residual
risk given the compliance with national
laws and regulations on construction and
connectivity to electricity grid.
We are strengthening our assessment
of client adaptive capacities in material
sectors in 2024.
Approximately 30% of our portfolio is
exposed to ‘medium’ risk category. We are
actively assessing our clients’ vulnerability
to this medium risk category which is
dominated by hotels and real estate
activities as well as the agriculture sector.
Unsurprisingly, most exposure to various
hazards across risks are found in the
Tbilisi municipality – where most of our
financing activity is concentrated. Tbilisi
alone is 9.6% of our outstanding portfolio
under the medium risk category. Tbilisi
municipality is not exposed to many
hazards we deem ‘high’.
From 2023, the ‘top-down’ analysis of our business portfolio is accompanied by ‘bottom-up’ client-level assessments through an
updated due diligence process.
Based on the 2022 portfolio climate risk assessment, we reassessed transition and physical risks – on a scale from zero (no risk) to
four (very high risk) – for more than 640 activities conducted by our clients and aggregated risks for 25 sectors. The overall results
are very similar to those of 2022 and show that over half of our business portfolio is expected to face low transition risks over the
coming years. The remainder of the business portfolio could face medium risks (please see more in the Strategy section).
Qualitative analysis of climate-related risks in our portfolio:
Bottom-up climate risk assessment at client level:
113
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
We continue to revise our transition risk methodology. We have similarly carried
out an exposure analysis across sub-sectors and by very high, high, medium and
low emission profile categories. High emission-intensive activities in our portfolio
are dominated by buildings – (leased real estate and hotels). Very high activities
are dominated by few counterparties engaged in natural gas trade as well as
dairy farming. We have determined that despite the high emission profiles of
these clients we do not see material risk over our time horizons.
The second step of the process is
awareness raising. The booklet on climate
change and low-carbon, climate-resilient
development is sent to targeted business
clients. Moreover, the Environmental
and Social Covenant was updated. The
Covenant must be signed by all business
clients. They are also required to read the
climate booklet.
The fourth step of the process ensures in
depth engagement of ECRM department
to support clients in addressing risks. This
step will become more relevant in the
years to come, as the level of transition
and physical risks in Georgia rises. It will
thus be developed in more detail once
climate regulatory framework in Georgia
develops.
The third step of our climate-related due
diligence consists of collecting additional
data from clients that we expect to
face high or very high climate risks (as
identified in step one). This includes
information on GHG emissions, past
climate-related impacts, management
measures and a small number of
additional aspects. We started this
in-depth data collection in 2023 which
helps us assess clients’ awareness of
potential risks and preparedness for
addressing them. Analysis is done once
a year, per identified client, as part of
our regular E&S risk monitoring. Results
will be used to refine our portfolio-level
risk assessment (heat map) and identify
highly exposed and unprepared clients
with whom we intend to engage more
closely in the fourth step.
2
4
3
For STEP one we updated our credit
information software to enable
information collection on clients’ business
activities and locations, and evaluating
expected climate risk.
For STEP two a booklet on climate
change and low-carbon, climate-resilient
development is sent to high and very
high risk business clients. Moreover,
the updated Environmental and Social
Covenant with information on our climate
risk assessment process is signed by all
business clients and requires that they
read the climate booklet.
STEP three of our climate-related due
diligence is implemented alongside
our E&S risk management and
monitoring, allowing for more efficient
communication with our clients. We
have updated our ESMS framework
accordingly, also referring to the new
CliRM framework.
Our climate-related due diligence is integrated as much as possible into standard procedures.
We made the following changes in 2023:
Understanding the emissions we finance
is important for managing climate
risks in our portfolio and steering our
contribution to Georgia’s climate-related
transition goals. In 2022, we assessed
financed emissions for parts of our
business portfolio using the methodology
developed by the Partnership for Carbon
Accounting Financials (PCAF). We will
repeat this exercise annually, covering
more and more of our portfolio. The
necessary data will be collected as part
of the climate-related due diligence
process described above and on the
next page. Moreover, in 2023, we piloted
a methodology for assessing financed
emissions from larger parts of our
portfolio using a methodology developed
by IFIs. Please see the ‘Metrics and
targets’ section for further detail on the
results of the 2023 assessment and on
the methodologies for borrower-specific
and portfolio-level GHG assessment.
Measuring financed emissions
114
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
In 2021/22, we used the Paris Agreement
Capital Transition Assessment (PACTA)
tool to assess the alignment of selected
clients from the steel and cement
sectors with low-carbon development
pathways. However, the number of clients
in the PACTA database is very small,
rendering the results of such analysis
extremely limited. Starting in 2023, we
are discussing low-carbon development
and Paris Agreement alignment with
clients affected by transition risk as
part of our updated climate-related due
diligence process (step three and four, see
previous page). We will assess the results
to determine an approach to measuring
portfolio alignment in a standardised
manner.
Estimating alignment of selected clients with the goals of the Paris Agreement
Metrics and targets
Metric/KPI Rationale Target
GHG emissions: Absolute Scope 1, 2
and 3; emissions intensity
Measuring our GHG emissions helps us
understand our direct and indirect impact
on the climate.
In 2024 we aim to expand our coverage
of financed emissions calculation
across 40-45% of the Corporate and
Investment Banking portfolio. In 2024
we will analyse potential development
of sector-based targets per Science
Based Targets initiative methodology.
Percentage of lending vulnerable to
climate-related transition and physical
risks, relative to total lending
Climate-related risks for our borrowers can
present credit risks for Bank of Georgia,
so we manage our portfolio’s climate risk
profile and new credit origination in line
with our overall risk appetite. In 2023 we
have categorised our existing portfolio
across inherent climate related risks (see
table on page 107).
In 2024 we will be examining potential
upper limits to sectors considered
vulnerable to transition risks and
physical risks.
Percentage of carbon-related assets,
relative to total assets
Carbon-related assets are widely
understood as a proxy for the financial
sector’s exposures to climate-related
transition risks.
We are targeting green assets and
developing decarbonisation targets in
2024. These will have implications on the
carbon-related assets to total assets
ratio.
Amount of lending aligned with
climate-related opportunities, relative
to total assets
Seizing climate-related opportunities can
become a source of significant revenue
as the Government’s, economy’s and
society’s climate ambitions continue to
grow. From 2023, we monitor and report
the share of financing in line with Georgia’s
new Sustainable Finance Taxonomies and
explore the opportunities to expand such
climate-related lending. We have adhered
to strict criteria to categorise our green
allocations per various taxonomies.
We have set the initial climate-related
opportunity KPI to expand our green
portfolio and reach a minimum GEL
875 million outstanding in 2024 with
aspiration to reach GEL 1 billion.
Forward-looking metrics
Bank of Georgia is committed to using its
financed emissions calculations to develop
forward-looking climate-related metrics in
the coming years.
In 2023, we completed our baseline
analysis that will underpin revision to
targets in 2024 and beyond. These
include total financed emissions,
sector emission intensities, screening
of existing and new clients for
opportunities, green alignment ratios,
and decarbonisation targets.
Bank of Georgia uses metrics recommended by the TCFD to measure our
impact on climate, and the effects of climate change on our business model
and operations.
For all the metrics presented, there are challenges with availability and reliability
of data. As methodologies and learnings emerge, we intend to progressively
refine our approaches and measurements, covering a bigger portion of our client
and portfolio base.
115
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Since 2012, the Bank has reported GHG
emissions and energy use consistent
with the Companies Act 2006 (Strategic
Report and Directors’ Report) Regulations
2013 and the Companies (Directors’
Report) and Limited Liability Partnerships
(Energy and Carbon Report) Regulations
2018.
This data covers the Bank as the main
operating unit and the core entity of the
Group, including its offices and retail
branches where the Bank has operational
control. For the second time, our 2023
reporting also includes emissions for
three Bank subsidiaries (BNB Bank,
Georgian Leasing Company, Bank of
Georgia Representative Office UK Ltd)
and two Group subsidiaries (G&T, Digital
Area). Two of BOGG PLC’s subsidiaries
as at 31 December 2023 are UK-based:
(1) BGEO Group Limited and (2) Bank
of Georgia Representative Office UK
Limited. According to their financial
statements, both BGEO Group Limited
and Bank of Georgia Representative
Office UK Limited remain below the
thresholds stipulated in para 20B Part
7A Sch 7 LMCGAR 2008 (considering
employees/turnover/balance sheet total),
meaning that neither of them would be
required themselves to report (on SECR
emissions) under LMCGAR 2008. We
use a small shared office space in the UK
(total annual electricity consumption is
less than 5 MWh, at 3.3 MWh for 2023
and 3.5 MWh for 2022).
Our emissions data follows the guidelines
of the World Resources Institute/
World Business Council for Sustainable
Development Greenhouse Gas Protocol:
A Corporate Accounting and Reporting
Standard (revised edition 2016) as a
reference source. The control approach
was used for all operations of Bank of
Georgia.
GHG emissions: our operational footprint
Scope 1
Combustion of natural gas, petrol and diesel at owned and controlled sites (for heating and electricity generation).
Combustion of petrol and diesel in owned passenger vehicles.
Scope 2
Purchased electricity at owned and controlled sites.
Scope 3
Fuel-and energy-related activities; waste generated in operations; and purchased goods.
Air business travel; hotel accommodation; and land transportation by rental cars.
Employee commuting (for the second time in 2023).
Bank of Georgia GHG emissions 2021-2023 2021 2022 2023
Category Emission source category tCO
2
e tCO
2
e tCO
2
e
GHG Protocol standards: Corporate Scope 1 and 2,
Value Chain Scope 3
Scope 1
Direct emissions from owned or
controlled stationary sources
Fuels 907.6 957.3 1,026.2
Direct emissions from owned or
controlled mobile sources
Passenger vehicles 1,089.5 1,110.1 1,104.5
Scope 2
Location-based emissions from the
generation of purchased electricity,
heat, steam or cooling
Electricity 1,661.5 1,864.2 2,094.8
Scope 3
Fuel- and energy-related activities
All other fuel- and energy-related
activities
545.6 593.3 603.7
Transmission and distribution losses 350.7 347.1 414.5
Waste generated in operations
Waste water 42.0 18.4 29.2
Waste 0.1 0.1 0.5
Purchased goods
Water supplied 20.4 10.1 16.0
Material use 224.8 281.1 395.5
Business travel
All transportation by air 19.9 80.9 36.7
Hotel accommodation 2.1 6.8 13.6
Land transportation by outsourced
vehicles
615.0 565.2 566.1
Employees commuting 3,822.3 4,550.1
Scope 1 1,997.1 2,067.4 2,130.7
Scope 2 1,661.5 1,864.2 2,094.8
Scope 1 and 2 3,658.6 3,931.6 4,225.5
Scope 3 1,820.5 5,828.4 6,625.9
Total emissions 5,479.1 9,760.1 10,851.5
tCO
2
e/employee 0.9 1.5 1.5
BOG employees (year-end) 6,207 6,597 7,435
116
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Notes on methodology: We used the most
recent Georgia electricity conversion
factor provided by JRC. GHG emissions
from business flights were calculated
using the ICAO online calculator. GHG
emissions from overnight hotel stays
were calculated on a ‘room per night’
basis, with emission factors based
on the Cornell Hotel Sustainability
Benchmarking Index Tool,
version 2.
Further conversion factors were taken
from the 2023 UK Government GHG
reporting: conversion factors – and
updated against the 2020 version
used for our 2021 reporting. Given that
differences are mostly minor, and that
updated emission factors also reflect real
changes in different activities’ emissions
intensity, GHG emissions for 2021 and
2022 were not remodelled using the
updated emission factors.
Compared to 2021 and previous years, our
gas consumption significantly decreased
in 2022/23 as the result of major
improvements to our heating system. Our
petrol, diesel and electricity consumption,
in turn, rose due to growth of the car
fleet, office size and staff numbers, and
due to staff returning to the office.
In 2023, we assessed Scope 3 emissions
from ‘Employee commuting’ for the
second time. This was based on a survey
of employees’ mode of transportation,
distance travelled and – where known
fuel used. 22% of employees participated
in the survey and final figures were
calculated by extrapolating to all
employees. While we acknowledge this
approach is not fully accurate, the results
are sufficiently informative for the time
being, e.g. to estimate the approximate
share of commuting emissions in our
total emissions. It was not possible to
assess commuting emissions for 2021
due to a lack of data and irregularities
in commuting patterns throughout the
COVID-19 pandemic.
Bank of Georgia and Group subsidiaries’ GHG emissions 2023 Bank subsidiaries Group subsidiaries
2022 2023 2022 2023
Category Emission source category tCO
2
e tCO
2
e tCO
2
e tCO
2
e
GHG Protocol Standards: Corporate
Scope 1 and 2
Scope 1
Direct emissions arising from
owned or controlled stationary
sources
Fuels
Direct emissions from owned or
controlled mobile sources
Passenger vehicles 95.5 39.0 79.8 141.9
Scope 2
Location-based emissions from
the generation of purchased
electricity, heat, steam or cooling
Electricity 235.0 153.3 18.5 21.2
District heat 118.5 60.5
Scope 3
Fuel- and energy-related
activities
All other fuel- and energy-related
activities
24.6 10.0 19.8 34.8
Transmission and distribution losses 10.2 6.9 3.4 4.0
Waste generated in operations Waste water 1.1 0.2 1.0 1.0
Purchased goods Water supplied 0.6 0.1 0.5 0.5
Scope 1 95.5 39.0 79.8 141.9
Scope 2 353.4 213.8 18.5 21.2
Scope 1 and 2 448.9 252.8 98.3 163.1
Scope 3 36.6 17.2 24.7 40.2
Total emissions 485.5 270.0 123.0 203.3
tCO
2
e/employee 0.6 0.3 0.6 0.7
Total employees 833 830 210 295
Notes on methodology: Once again, we
used the most recent Georgia electricity
conversion factor provided by JRC to
calculate electricity emissions for all
Georgian Bank/Group subsidiaries. The
emission factor for electricity use by
BNB is specific to Belarus and was also
taken from JRC. Further conversion
factors were taken from the 2023 UK
Government GHG reporting: conversion
factors.
117
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Scope 3: Financed emissions
In 2023, Bank of Georgia analysed the GHG emissions of 35.7% of corporate portfolio across eight sectors:
Outstanding
loan amount
at 31 December
2022 (GEL) Scope 1 and 2 (tCO
2
e)
Scope 3
(tCO
2
e)
Emissions
intensity (tCO
2
e/
GEL million)
Cement, steel and other energy-
intensive manufacturing
849,631,652
Emissions from use of
electricity and fuels; emissions from
chemical processes not calculated
153,301 / 180
Hotels (running) 79,897,946 Emissions from use of electricity and fuels 588 / 7
Real estate management 252,431,198
Emissions from tenants’ building use,
calculated based on measured energy
consumption
1,286 / 5
Healthcare
84,890,734 Emissions from use of electricity and fuels 1,371 / 16
Mining (gold, copper)
98,316,423 Emissions from use of electricity and fuels 7,024 / 71
Transport 84,894,481 Emissions from use of fuels and electricity 18,618 / 219
Electricity generation
(from gas)
57,048,703
Emissions from electricity generation,
calculated based on gas consumed
78,199 / 1,371
Oil and gas (distribution, retail
sale)
263,353,300 Not calculated / 998,851 3,793
Total 1,770,464,438 260,387 998,851 711
Results: There is a wide variation between
sectors as some are more GHG-intensive
than others. Desk research showed that
our emissions intensities are generally in
line with those reported by other banks
from emerging economies and beyond.
The potential for emissions reduction
through energy efficiency improvements
is highest in energy-intensive
manufacturing such as cement and
steel making.
Improving building design can help avoid
future emissions from the building sector.
Despite methodological challenges, we
will use our findings to inform client
engagement and business management
decisions from a climate perspective.
This is the first year that we are
computing financed emissions for our oil
and gas exposure of which are entirely
comprised of downstream operators
(distributors of oil and gas products). We
have included in our calculation Scope 3
emissions from this exposure – eventual
combustion of oil and gas products by
their customers. The inclusion of these
figures significantly raises our portfolio
carbon footprint (i.e. financed emissions).
Methodology: The clients covered
by the assessment are considered
carbon-related through their Scope
1, 2 or 3 emissions, and account for
35.7% of our corporate portfolio (as at
31 December 2022). The analysis was
done for emissions generated in 2022,
given the required data to calculate
2023 emissions was not available at
the time of calculation. Particularly,
local companies are not obligated by
any national regulation to disclose
information regarding their annual energy
consumption, GHG emissions or related
data. As the World Bank Groups report
on Greening Firms in Georgia explores,
nearly half the firms they surveyed
through the World Bank Enterprise
Surveys reported monitoring energy
consumption.
To calculate financed emissions, we
applied the ‘Global GHG Accounting and
Reporting Standard for the Financial
Industry’ developed by the PCAF.
Our bankers collected the following data:
outstanding loan amount; total debt and
equity; and primary physical activity data
for the company’s energy consumption.
On a scale from one (best) to five (worst),
the quality of our data thus scores three.
Description of the data quality score
– Primary physical activity data for
the company’s energy consumption by
energy source (e.g., megawatt-hours of
electricity) plus any process emissions.
Emission factors specific to that primary
data.
Most clients do not yet report GHG
emissions, making it impossible for us
to reach the highest data quality score.
Scope 3 emissions were calculated and
reported separately where relevant.
Challenges and outlook: We experience
difficulties in obtaining sufficiently
reliable data. When it comes to efficient
and robust measurement of financed
emissions, one of the most prominent
hurdles is to ensure that clients provide
complete, consistent, reliable data. We
discussed individual data points with
clients whenever we detected possible
irregularities and, going forward, will
continue to monitor the quality of data
provided, engaging with clients to raise
awareness and improve results. We have
so far only calculated emissions from a
minor share of our portfolio.
In 2024 we aim to assess emissions for
approximately 40-45% of our Corporate
Banking portfolio using the PCAF
Standard.
Given the large number of clients in our
SME and Retail portfolios, we cannot
apply the PCAF Standard to these
segments.
/ = not calculated yet.
118
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
* BOG’s operational emissions were 9,760 tonnes of CO
2
e in 2022 (including commuting). That is 2.9% of client Scope 1 and 2 emissions, or 1% of client Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions.
Results of JIM: 2022 financed emissions (tCO
2
e)
CO
2
Non-CO
2
Scope 1 and 2
Scope 3 Total Operational
total*
TOTAL
244,900
475,400
720,300
988,000
91,838
165,800
257,600
10,000
During 2023, Bank of Georgia
implemented the Joint Impact Model
(JIM) as a new tool for modelling Bank
of Georgia’s financed GHG emissions in
the SME and CB portfolios. We piloted
the JIM as a potential solution. The JIM
is a methodology developed by several
development finance institutions to
conduct indirect impact modelling.
Using input data such as revenue and
power production from portfolios, the
JIM enables users to estimate financial
flows through the economy and its
resulting economic (value added), social
(employment) and environmental (GHG
emissions) impact. The JIM calculated the
Bank of Georgia funded GHG emissions
at about 1 million tCO
2
e for the 2022
financial year.
We are disclosing climate-related actions for the third time in 2023. We believe we have covered all TCFD recommendations and
recommended disclosures, providing information on relevant decisions and how we made them. Nevertheless, we acknowledge
we are only at the outset of our climate journey and plan to move from testing methodologies and preparing changes to fully
integrating climate-related risks and opportunities into relevant processes across the Bank. Climate-related disclosures will
incrementally become more detailed.
The way forward
Pillar Plans for 2024
Governance
The Board and management will continue to exercise their climate-related responsibilities as described in this Annual Report.
Training and upskilling colleagues across the Bank will continue to be a key priority. New e-learning materials will be developed.
KPIs will include green lending targets.
Strategy
We will continue to conduct climate-related risk and opportunity analysis and disclose relevant results.
We will conduct a materiality assessment of climate risks on the Bank’s portfolio against selected climate change scenarios.
We will strengthen our scenario analysis capabilities and develop our infrastructure and capabilities to incorporate climate risk into
data and analysis.
We will develop climate risk stress testing framework.
We will assess the financial impacts of climate-related risks on the Bank’s financial position, financial performance, and cash-
flows over short, medium and long term.
We will continue implementing our Climate Action Strategy.
Risk
management
To enhance credit risk assessment and manage risks, we will continue to collect data from business clients in a standardised
manner through an updated due diligence process. Moreover, we will continue to engage with our (very) high risk clients to
understand their transition and physical risks, as well as their plans to prepare for climate change.
We will strive to conduct sectoral case studies to better understand climate risks and management responses for selected high-
risk sectors and clients (conditional upon external technical and financial support).
We will continue to refine and expand our risk assessment methodologies with feedback from the due diligence process and,
possibly, sectoral case studies.
We will collect data to help identify climate finance opportunities in line with the NBG’s Green Taxonomy.
We will reassess whether to integrate climate into our Risk Appetite Statement and update policies as necessary.
Metrics and
Targets
The focus for 2024 will be to increase the coverage of existing metrics.
We will assess emissions generated by 40-45% of our Corporate Banking portfolio (up from 35.7 % in Annual Report 2023).
We will enhance the measurement approach, inputs and assumptions used for Scope 1, 2 and 3 calculation.
As we start to better understand emissions from our portfolio and enhance the screening of our portfolio against the NBG’s Green
Taxonomy, we will take into consideration whether – and how – to specify additional climate-related targets.
Bank of Georgia’s portfolio scope 1 and 2 GHG emissions intensity is 98 tonnes per million US dollars under management
(tCO
2
e/$mAUM). For context, the mean emissions intensity for five similar-sized commercial banks using the same PCAF-aligned
Joint Impact Model methodology is 156 tCO
2
e/$mAUM. This means Bank of Georgia’s portfolio is relatively less carbon intensive
than some other banks in emerging economies.
EMPOWERING
EMPLOYEES
119
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
120
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Empowering employees
The resilience and success of the Group depends on the continued commitment
of our talented people. We strive to be the employer of choice, providing equal
opportunities for development and ensuring a positive employee experience.
Our employees at a glance
Female
29%
Female
27%
Male
71%
Male
73%
Executive management by gender
JSC Bank of Georgia
Executive management by gender
Group
TOTAL
14
TOTAL
15
Female
40%
Female
51%
Male
60%
Male
49%
Senior Management by gender
JSC Bank of Georgia
Senior Management by gender
Group
TOTAL
104
TOTAL
191
Female
70%
Male
30%
Female
69%
Male
31%
All employees by gender*
JSC Bank of Georgia
All employees by gender
Group
TOTAL
7,435
TOTAL
9,398
* 99.9% of our employees are with permanent contracts.
121
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
We deliver on our strategic objectives and
can make a difference in our customers’
lives through the actions of our people
and their commitment to shared success.
We continue to focus on empowering
our employees by fostering a high-
trust, diverse environment and a strong
feedback culture, equipping employees
with the skills and capabilities for the
future.
Bank of Georgia’s HCM function plays
a critical role in helping us onboard and
retain the right talent, while maintaining
employee engagement and wellbeing.
HCM combines HR expertise with
business knowledge to design and
implement policies and practices in line
with the Groups purpose, values, business
principles and strategic objectives. HCM
reports to the Head of Human Capital
Management, who reports directly to the
CEO. The Supervisory Board of the Bank
and its Nomination, Remuneration, Audit
and Risk Committees oversee all matters
related to the Bank’s employees:
diversity overview provided to the
Nomination Committee;
remuneration and related policies
overview provided to the Remuneration
Committee;
overview of employee grievances
related to ethical issues (if any)
provided to Joint Audit and Risk
Committee; and
key people risk metrics reported
quarterly to the Risk Committee.
Our human capital strategy is focused on
the following key areas:
Tbilisi
71%
Regions
29%
All employees by location*
JSC Bank of Georgia
All employees by age
JSC Bank of Georgia
All employees by age
Group
TOTAL
7,435
* Five employees worked outside of Georgia.
9%
50%
35%
3% 3%
TOTAL
7,435
21-30 years old
31-40 years old
41-50 years old
>50 years old
<21 years old
21-30 years old
31-40 years old
41-50 years old
>50 years old
<21 years old
TOTAL
9,398
10%
48%
35%
4% 3%
Promoting diversity
and equal
opportunities
Attracting,
developing and
retaining top talent
Providing positive
employee experiences
122
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Promoting diversity and equal opportunities
We are committed to the highest ethical
standards in everything we do. We expect
every employee to act in line with our
values and business principles, complying
with applicable laws, regulations, and
internal policies and procedures. We
communicate our expectations of
employee conduct through multiple
channels, including but not limited to:
Our Employee Corporate Handbook,
which defines employee behaviour
standards and procedures. The Handbook
is available to all employees in Georgian
and English, via our intranet.
The Code of Conduct and Ethics – an
integral part of the Handbook which acts
as a employment agreement between
the Bank and its employees. It clearly sets
the expectation that all employees act
legally, ethically and transparently in all
their dealings. Failure to do so may lead
to disciplinary action, up to and including
the termination of employment.
We monitor employee awareness of
internal policies and continue to work on
strengthening internal communications to
clearly explain our policies and procedures
through online, interactive, self-paced
courses.
We maintain an open-door policy where
our people are encouraged to share
their questions, concerns, suggestions or
complaints with their managers, HCM, or
anonymously if they wish. We prohibit any
form of retaliation against an employee
raising a concern or participating in an
investigation.
Whistleblowing and grievance mechanisms
Grievances can be submitted via email,
anonymous hotline call or electronic form.
We are currently reviewing and updating
the Grievance Policy based on global
best practices for handling employee
complaints. In 2023, we had eight cases
reported under the Grievance Policy.
Two of these grievances were provided
anonymously, via WhistleB, and one of
them represented collective concern of
employees. All cases were investigated
and resolved.
GRIEVANCE
WhistleB is an external, independent
whistleblowing reporting channel and
case management tool that allows
employees to report any concern
anonymously or confidentially.
WHISTLEBLOWING
Anti-discrimination and
anti-harassment
We are committed to ensuring inclusion and equal opportunities in our organisation.
We do not tolerate discrimination on any grounds, including gender, marital status,
sexual orientation, race, ethnic origin, nationality, age, disability, political or religious
beliefs. Universal human rights are incorporated into our Handbook, along with our
Anti-discrimination and Anti-harassment, Diversity and Inclusion, and Human Rights
Policies. Bank of Georgia’s Anti-nepotism Policy also underpins fair and transparent
decision making in all employee-related matters.
Diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI)
DEI is about the respect for, and appreciation of, differences in personalities,
professional and educational backgrounds, and identity. We process gender,
age, education, position and employee level, and other information required for
the fulfilment of our talent strategy, and disclose our progress through our ESG
reporting framework with reference to GRI standards. In 2023, we worked on
improving employee data related to diversity, including ethnic and religious groups,
mother tongue and the knowledge of state language. Such analysis will allow us to
offer benefits better tailored to employee needs and more supportive of work-life
balance, contributing to a more family-friendly workplace. Given that ethnic origin
and religious beliefs are special categories of data, according to the Law of Georgia
on Personal Data Protection, we consulted with Personal Data Protection Service, a
state authority of Georgia. At the time of writing, we received the approval of such
data collection from the regulator together with recommendations regarding its
management in compliance with state regulations. We will start collecting data
in 2024.
Gender equality
Since 2022, Bank of Georgia has been a signatory of the UN Women’s Empowerment
Principles to further strengthen its initiatives aimed at supporting women in the
workforce. The Bank has also retained 2XChallenge status since 2020, awarded in
recognition of its efforts to address barriers to the employment of women.
We provide an annual update on diversity matters to the Nomination and
Remuneration Committees.
123
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
We aim to recruit, retain and engage
talented people with different
perspectives and life and career
experiences, providing a safe and inclusive
environment that enables personal and
professional development and teamwork.
We have strong relationships with local
talent pools and continue to upskill local
students through our special, rotation-
based internship programme, Leaderator.
We aim to cultivate a culture of feedback
and lifelong learning and provide a wide
range of development opportunities to
our employees, including development
reviews, personal coaching, and leadership
programmes.
Our engagement strategy extends beyond
our immediate organisational boundaries
to include:
In developing and implementing our talent strategy, we focus on:
Attracting, developing and retaining top talent
Actively engaging with Georgian talents
abroad.
3. Ensuring alignment of our talent
strategy with business objectives by
analysing and anticipating business
needs and gaps in required skills and
competencies.
Active participation in job festivals
and fairs.
1. Attracting, developing and retaining
highly qualified professionals with a
strong work ethic.
Networking with professionals at
events organised by various educational
and professional companies, including
ourselves.
2. Putting the right people in the right
roles.
49% of our employees are 30 or under years old, and our approach has evolved
alongside changing attitudes towards work among younger generations.
When recruiting, we highlight that hybrid work is the new normal, that we are
committed to ensuring DEI, and that work-life balance matters.
Attracting talents
Bank of Georgia is an equal-opportunity
workplace where people from different
backgrounds and experiences come
together, support each other, and
create value for our stakeholders. The
Bank’s Recruitment Policy and practices,
including panel interviews, relevant
control procedures and an online
applicant tracking system, ensures a
fair hiring process. We do not ask for
candidates’ date of birth, gender or
photograph, nor do we collect information
on race, religion, sexual orientation,
disabilities or nationality, to make sure no
candidate or employee is discriminated
against on any grounds. We continuously
develop our acquisition channels, tailoring
them to target segments of diverse
talent while tracking and systematically
improving the candidate experience.
We enrich our employee base in different ways:
One priority is to develop talent internally, and current employees have priority when filling vacancies, especially for
managerial positions.
1
Our Talent Acquisition team actively monitors the labour market and regularly engages with potential candidates in
Georgia and abroad.
2
Collaborative initiatives with educational institutions and industry partners. In 2023, Kutaisi International University and
the International School of Economics at Tbilisi State University joined our network of partners.
3
The use of alumni networks not only enhances our outreach and engagement initiatives but also establishes a valuable
avenue for connecting with experienced professionals, helping us access a pool of talent and expertise.
4
We have implemented an internal and external IT referral programme, actively fostering the identification and
recruitment of highly qualified professionals. This multifaceted strategy cultivates a culture of ongoing learning,
collaboration and inclusivity.
5
We continue to strengthen our Talent Acquisition team members with the skills required to successfully achieve our
recruitment goals. In 2023, we advanced our tech recruiters’ team and ensured their presence at top tech events in
Georgia.
6
124
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Female
69%
Male
31%
Female
65%
Male
35%
New hires by gender
JSC Bank of Georgia
New hires by gender
Group
TOTAL
2,213
TOTAL
2,945
Female
57%
Male
43%
Female
59%
Male
41%
Employees promoted
to managerial positions by gender
Group
Employees promoted to
managerial positions by gender
JSC Bank of Georgia
TOTAL
154
TOTAL
130
Female
70%
Male
30%
Promotions by gender
JSC Bank of Georgia
TOTAL
1,498
New hires by age
JSC Bank of Georgia
15%
17%
64%
3% 1%
TOTAL
2,213
21-30 years old
31-40 years old
41-50 years old
>50 years old
<21 years old
125
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
44.1%
87.0% 19.6%
58.0%
40.2%
84.3% 20.4%
60.2%
29.9%
85.2%
18.5%
54.2%
Internal mobility rate
Employee retention rate Employee turnover rate
Vacancies filled internally
We closely monitor the turnover and retention indicators, validating the impact of various human capital and employee experience
initiatives, and the respective trends confirm the positive dynamics: increase in retention and reduction in turnover versus 2022.
2023
2023 2023
2023
2022
2022 2022
2022
2021
2021 2021
2021
Leaderator: nurturing young talent for future success
BOG Boot Camp: empowering young tech enthusiasts
Summer Internship Programme: bridging academia and industry
Since 2017, Bank of Georgia’s Leaderator
internship programme has been a dynamic
career accelerator for young talent. We
recruit promising undergraduates and
engage them in professional training,
job rotations across departments, and
hands-on experience in ongoing projects.
Leaderator participants are mentored by
Bank of Georgia’s professionals.
Every year, we tailor the programme to
organisational needs and add new tracks
or update existing ones. We have seen a
consistent increase in the representation
of female participants in technology-
related tracks over the past three years.
In 2023, we expanded our offerings to
young talent in the tech industry and
launched the BOG Boot Camp in IT
software development. This nine-month
programme welcomed 12 individuals,
providing intensive training, mentorship
and hands-on experience in database
development.
In 2023, our dedication to offering
practical experience to Georgian students
studying abroad continued through the
Summer Internship Programme. This
initiative connects us with talented
individuals studying outside of Georgia.
In 2023, we attracted 59 potential
candidates (19 in 2022) and selected 12
summer interns (8 in 2022) from leading
universities in different countries.
Total participants
since launch
Hired after programme
completion
376 79%
We regularly monitor the effectiveness of our programmes for young talents. As of 4Q23, Bank of
Georgia was the top-of-mind employer among our target student segments in Georgia, according to a
targeted survey by a third-party research company.
Figures given for JSC Bank of Georgia standalone
126
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Some of the training programmes
are required for employees in specific
positions. For example, based on
feedback from customer satisfaction
surveys, one of our key objectives in
2023 was to improve the qualifications
of our customer-facing employees.
We introduced an annual mandatory
knowledge testing for front-office
positions. Testing results, together with
performance results, serve as criteria
for career advancement and promotion.
Testing results also provide insights into
the topics that should be prioritised for
upcoming training sessions.
A Risks and Compliance programme is
also required for employees in front-
and back-office positions. We aim to
have a strong risk culture, ensuring our
employees understand some of the
principal risks our organisation faces and
their role in managing and mitigating
those risks. The programme includes
mandatory training for all new hires and
mandatory periodic (usually annual)
retraining for existing employees. Training
is online and self-paced, to be completed
within a set timeframe. The Bank’s Risks
and Compliance programme covers
employees of the Bank as well as some of
the Groups subsidiaries.
When we onboard employees, we shift
the focus to their development. Talent
development is an ongoing process that is
critical no matter the tenure. We aspire to
have a learning culture where employees
can access opportunities for lifelong
learning and personal development.
Our learning and development ecosystem
is divided into the following areas:
Developing talent
Professional programmes Management programmes Executive programmes
• Onboarding
• Risks and compliance programme
• Banking products and services
• Software-related programmes
• Communication skills programmes
• High-potential Employee (HiPos)
programme
• Tailored training sessions and
educational content provided
• Management skills programme
• Feedback skills programme
• Leadership development: Executive
coaching programme (individual and
team coaching)
• Financing masters’ programmes and
other professional certifications
• Leadership development: Executive
coaching programme (individual and
team coaching, mentoring sessions)
• Individual business coaching
programme
• Financing masters’ programmes and
other professional certifications
91%
of our employees completed
Risks and Compliance
programme
(86% in 2022)
We strive to achieve 100% completion rate for required trainings. The
completion rate of required trainings was on the agenda of the Joint Audit
and Risk Committee during 2023 as the Board noted that the Bank needed
to improve in this area. In December 2023, the HCM department presented a
report to the Joint Audit and Risk Committee on this issue. The report noted
that HCM was implementing several initiatives to increase the effectiveness
of this training programme, including increasing monitoring and introducing
measures to target employees who do not complete the courses, improving
the user experience of the courses and content, and reviewing the courses to
change the frequency of required retaking where necessary.
Besides required training, we have a comprehensive catalogue of self-paced courses focused on hard and soft skills. On top
of this catalogue, Bank of Georgia runs different leadership and professional development programmes, some of which are
described below.
Leadership training
for new managers:
We support newly appointed managers by offering leadership training, individual coaching, and
personalised training aligned with their personal and professional development needs. In 2023, we
extended participation in this programme to 70 individuals – 73% of them were internally promoted
talents and 66% were women.
Individual coaching for
managers:
Throughout 2023, 242 employees actively participated in individual coaching sessions. 62% were women.
To enhance the coaching experience for senior leadership, we also partnered with a business coaching
platform. Following a successful six-month pilot, we continued this collaborative effort, with plans to
extend coaching opportunities to 32 senior leaders through 2023/24.
In 2023, we expanded the coaching initiative to encompass other targeted groups, including
participants in the HiPos programme and Product Owners.
HiPos programme:
Building on the successful tracking of high-potential and high-performing individuals since 2021, Bank
of Georgia introduced its second programme for HiPos in 2023. This one-year programme involved 22
senior-level individual contributors from 15 departments in the back office, focusing on comprehensive
development activities to support personal and professional growth. 55% of the participants
were women, with an average tenure of 3.2 years with the Bank. Importantly, following the 2021
programme, 83% of the participants experienced position changes, with 46% continuing their career in
managerial or team leader positions at the Bank.
In 2023, we also introduced the programme to front-line senior employees, and aim to select 17
individuals who will undergo mini-MBA certification from a top-tier university in Georgia.
127
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
36 hours
25 hours
53 hours
38 hours
41 hours
23 hours
Per employee
28 hours in 2022
Per male employee
21 hours in 2022
Per new hire
43 hours in 2022
Per senior manager
28 hours in 2022
Per female employee
32 hours in 2022
Per CEO and Deputy CEO
20 hours in 2022
Training data for 2023
Average hours per employee
Training data for 2023 (Group)
Average hours per employee
Total hours of training per employee 30
Total hours of training per new hire 42
Total hours of training per female employee 34
Total hours of training per male employee 21
Total hours of training per senior manager 35
Total hours of training per CEO and Deputy CEO 13
Feedback culture
In our ongoing efforts to foster a feedback culture, we have implemented an integrated performance management approach.
This combines:
The KPI management system, embedded in our human resources management software, includes
managers as well as individual contributors. Within a unified framework, we ensure the system’s
effectiveness and transparency in goal setting and evaluation. This holistic approach not only
facilitates the setting, tracking, and evaluation of annual KPIs and key business objectives (KBOs),
but also enables the seamless translation of individual performance into the annual bonus scheme.
Building on existing performance management, the addition of a 360° development tool in 2023
further strengthened our efforts to support employee development. This tool, aligned with the
Bank’s core values and business principles, includes a comprehensive feedback mechanism from
managers and peers alike.
The KPI management
system
Our 360° development tool
In 2023, we optimised our 360° evaluation system, eliminating manual steps in the evaluation process.
This effort resulted in 98% of eligible employees receiving personalised feedback reports that they
can use for professional development going forward.
Front2IT retraining
programme:
With its second intake in 2023, the Front2IT retraining programme demonstrates our commitment
to employee development and our adaptability to emerging trends in technology. From a pool of 78
applicants, we selected eight employees to transition to three distinct positions within IT operations.
Front2IT is a paid reskilling programme encompassing intensive training and individual mentoring.
Participants engage in real work processes, deepening their practical knowledge in addition to
taking professional courses. Across the past two programme intakes, 183 employees applied and
18 participants were chosen for corresponding job openings in the IT department. Notably, 72%
of successful applicants were women, with an average age of 27 years. The average tenure of
participants was 4.4 years with the Bank.
The programme’s emphasis on career growth has proven highly effective. Within just one year
since launch, six out of nine employees who successfully completed the retraining programme were
promoted.
128
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
For our raw gender pay gap (GPG), the
improvement is observed due to salary
revisions in mass positions where the
majority of employees are women. On
the other hand, we still have positions
with relatively higher salaries where men
represent the majority, e.g. IT, Digital
Banking and credit-related front-office
positions. Another reason for this raw
pay gap is a higher proportion of women
among new hires at entry level and
in lower ranges on managerial levels.
We are committed to ensuring equal
opportunities and developing various
talent development activities to support
professional and career progression of
employees in lower positions.
Our Job Architecture, named as Levelling,
also ensures equal grades for equal work
and contributes to ‘equal remuneration
of female and male employees for equal
work performed’. Levelling was introduced
in 2021, and currently includes each
position and incumbent employed by the
Bank. In 2023, based on position levels’
specifications, we updated employee
promotion criteria. Currently, we are
updating levelling factors, to make them
more specific and more easily applicable
to positions and/or incumbents’
evaluation.
2021 2022 2023
GEPG
1
5% 4% 2%
GPG
2
45% 44% 43%
1. The gender equal pay gap (GEPG) is the difference between the compensation of male and female employees in the same position.
2. Gender pay gap (GPG) measures the difference in the average earnings of male and female employees regardless of the nature of their work (mean pay – female versus male).
Our benefits for supporting employee wellbeing
Along with competitive remuneration, Bank of Georgia’s employee value proposition includes benefits supporting work-life balance
and family-friendly arrangements as well as opportunities for personal and professional development.
Corporate health insurance and night-shift
employees’ medical check-up.
Workplace ergonomics for pregnant women.
HEALTH
Special rates for banking services and financial aid for various life events including marriage, the birth of a
child, or the illness of a family member.
FINANCIAL
WELLBEING
Back-to-work adaptation trainings for those
returning to front-office positions after parental
leave.
Time off in lieu (TOIL) and paid time offs (PTOs)
for special needs in accordance with Georgian
regulations: medical check-ups related to pregnancy,
breastfeeding hour during the first year, monthly
day-off for a legal representative/supporter of a
person with a disability.
Fair remuneration practices and competitive packages
The main principles of the Bank’s Remuneration Policy are:
Competitiveness: Compensation paid by the Bank should be in
line with market practices and competitive when compared with
respective positions in other banks and on the Georgian labour
market.
Flexibility and fairness: To ensure fair remuneration of
employees in similar positions in line with their responsibilities,
qualifications and skills. Our approach and remuneration
practices are gender-neutral, and we are committed to
eliminating any bias and discrimination. Flexibility means our
practices are in line with the objectives of the Bank and can
be adapted as business needs change and the competitive
environment evolves locally and globally.
129
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Educational vacation: short-term educational vacation opportunity to employees attending certain MBA
programmes. The Bank also provides the possibility of co-financing the cost of academic or certification
programmes at foreign universities for professional development in the relevant field (e.g. MBA and CFA
programme).
TIME-AWAY
Maternity leave, newborn adoption leave and
parental leave with salary compensation in addition
to state allowance.
Additional paid time-off: five sick-leave days and five
days-off.
1. Regular live Q&A sessions led by the CEO to discuss strategy, performance and current developments. Five sessions were held in 2023.
2. Held since 2018, these meetings have promoted transparency and a feedback culture. Employees meet with the Chairman and the Senior Independent member as well as
other members every year. Three meetings with the participation of 61 employees were held in 2023.
3. To promote idea sharing and ensure employees are aware of each other’s work, we discuss new products and future plans with our agile teams and the Bank’s Executive
Management Team.
Employees on maternity/
parental leave
by gender
Return-to-work rate
after maternity leave
Retention rate of employees
who returned to work after
maternity/parental leave,
staying for at least 12 months
314 women
1 man
89.5% 83.9%
Parental leave at Bank of Georgia
Providing positive employee experiences
We have a systematic approach for identifying employee needs and concerns, delivering solutions and interventions that help create
more positive experiences at every step of the employee journey. Our Employee Experience Management (EXM) team is responsible
for gathering regular feedback from employees and providing insights on issues and solutions:
In 2023, improving the employee onboarding experience was one of the main priorities of our EXM team. Previously, the onboarding
experience was not structured uniformly across the Bank and employees were often dissatisfied with the ease and pace of
onboarding.
We ensure all our employees can directly and openly communicate with senior leadership and the Supervisory Board of the Bank. We
regularly engage with and listen to our employees through a number of channels:
Analysing responses from regular
surveys to identify pain points for further
research and interviews.
Getting in touch with new hires to ensure
smooth onboarding.
Collecting and analysing employee
sentiment data through focus groups and
individual interviews.
Ongoing deep interviews with
individual employees
Employee satisfaction surveys
Team reviews
CEO vlog on Workplace
1
Entry interviews
Meetings with the Board
2
Exit interviews
Agile quarterly business
reviews
3
130
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
I have trust and confidence
in the Company’s senior
leadership
My manager supports me in
learning and development
I believe the Company is
socially responsible
85% 88% 92%
2022: 86% 2022: 73% 2022: 92%
I would recommend our
Company as a good place
to work
The Company values and
promotes employee diversity
I receive clear and regular
feedback on how well
I do my work
79% 82% 75%
2022: 78% 2022: 81% 2022: 71%
Voice of the employee
To measure the effectiveness of employee empowerment initiatives, we closely track employee engagement and corporate culture
using internal and external surveys:
Employee Engagement survey eNPS
Korn Ferry Engaged Performance
Core indices – 2023
Engagement (Korn Ferry) Enablement (Korn Ferry)
70% 75%
2022: 70% 2022: 73%
56
2022: 53 (eop)
eNPS (eop)
131
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
The increases in eNPS (BOG internal
survey) and Employee Enablement
(Korn Ferry survey) are attributed to key
initiatives that reflect our commitment
to employee growth and wellbeing.
The refinement of promotion criteria
at the Bank level created transparent
and personalised guidelines for every
position, simplifying career paths and
empowering employees with a clear
view of their professional trajectory.
Our business areas actively cultivated a
culture of mutual feedback, enhancing
collaboration and engagement through
improved interpersonal communication.
Furthermore, the comprehensive annual
review of employee pay demonstrates
our dedication to recognising the intrinsic
value of each role and responding to
market dynamics. These concerted
efforts collectively foster a positive and
motivating work environment, aligning
with our corporate ethos of prioritising
employee satisfaction and professional
development.
New employees receive the
training they need to do their
jobs well
I have opportunities
to achieve my career goals
at the Company
79% 73%
2022: 77% 2022: 71%
Measuring culture
In 2023, we also performed Barrett’s value
study, which back in 2019 contributed
to outlining organisational values and
business principles of the Group. The aim
of the study was to calibrate our current
culture and its dynamics in new business
environment following the pandemic and
other recent global developments. The
research was performed by a UK-based
international consulting company in
cooperation with Barrett Value Centre.
The results of the study confirmed our
strong and healthy corporate culture. The
positive dynamic since 2019 was reflected
in increased scores, which are higher
than current benchmarks compared
to industry peers. Deeper analysis of
overall results is expected in 2024, and
respective initiatives will be defined and
implemented to maintain and further
develop our culture of helping people
achieve more of their potential.
Occupational health and safety
Providing a healthy and safe working environment remains a key priority and
an integral part of our culture. We develop a number of preventative actions to
safeguard the Bank every day.
The Bank’s Health and Safety team, reporting to the Deputy COO, is responsible for developing and implementing health and safety
practices across the Bank and covers:
FIRE AND
EMERGENCY
MEDICAL
EMERGENCY
HEALTH AND
SAFETY ISSUES
HEALTH AND SAFETY
PRACTICES
Occupational health and safety management system
The Bank’s Occupational Health and Safety Management System (OHS), which covers all employees and third-parties in our
workspaces, improves our ability to identify and remove hazards and decrease risk at the workplace.
132
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
OHS Risk management
The OHS Risk Assessment Standard defines principles, rules, and responsibilities. We continuously monitor our work spaces to
identify, assess, and mitigate potential risks. The data and results of the risk assessment are reviewed and updated periodically, in
line with existing legal requirements.
Health and safety training and instructions
A mandatory online course on labour safety, and practical training events are held annually for all employees of the Bank. In 2023,
we’ve updated the training and added a new module – ‘Manual Lifting Recommendations’.
Occupational Health and Safety Policy
Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) Risk Assessment Standard
Emergency Evacuation Standard
Fire Safety Standard
Occupational Accidents and Occupational Diseases Investigation/Reporting Standard
Standard for Prevention and Mitigation of Viral Diseases at the Workplace
Manual Handling Procedure
Personal Protective Equipment Procedure
FIRE SAFETY EMERGENCY PREVENTION
AND RESPONSE
WORKPLACE
SAFETY
The online course includes modules on:
Incident response:
We carry out different preventive measures, including:
Securing service centers with armed security police personnel.
Equipping service centers with state-of-the-art security systems.
Equipping cash operating units with bulletproof glass and alarm buttons. Upon activation of
these buttons, operational security police groups respond to the alarm promptly.
In 2023, there were no incidents.
In 2023, the occupational health and safety specialists completed the ‘Managing Safely Course’ and were
awarded with certificates from the Institution of Occupational Safety and Health (IOSH).
The Bank regularly carries out fire and emergency drills and relevant practical training.
In 2023, 120 fire drills were conducted.
Selected employees in major branches of the Bank are trained in First Aid.
The OHS system is based on the following policies and standards:
EMPOWERING
COMMUNITIES
133
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
134
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Within our educational initiatives, we have identified three main objectives and
you can read more about each in this chapter.
Promoting STEM
education
Improving educational
infrastructure
Increasing access to
quality education
Promoting STEM education
Empowering communities
We are committed to being a significant
contributor to the local communities
where we operate, by not only creating
innovative products and services, but also
by driving positive impact through various
community projects and initiatives beyond
our core business. A significant focus
of our community outreach efforts is
education as access to quality education
is one of the main challenges that people
name in various surveys. We believe
that access to high-quality education
opens doors to limitless opportunities,
shaping brighter futures for individuals
and contributing to the prosperity
of countries. By actively engaging in
educational initiatives, we aim to make a
meaningful difference in the lives of those
around us.
Everest Code IT NASA Space Apps
In 2023, Bank of Georgia became
the general sponsor of Everest – the
mathematics Olympiad that has been
famous among Georgian teachers and
students for the past two decades. The
competition, aimed at fostering passion
for mathematics, welcomes participants
from the second to sixth grades.
In cooperation with GITA, school students
in eight techno-parks in Georgia learned
how to code and developed the skills
of the future. The project followed a
P2P model of learning, creating an
environment where students could also
hone their communication skills.
Every year a 48-hour hackathon takes
place in 300 cities worldwide, where
teams come together to brainstorm
and create innovative solutions to global
challenges inspired by NASA’s research.
The hackathon in Georgia is organised
by Startup Bureau, with Bank of Georgia
as the main partner. The project’s main
objective is to spark curiosity, encourage
creativity and help develop problem-
solving skills. Participants get to apply
their knowledge and skills to address
global issues, bridging the gap between
theory and application. The ideas of
the winning projects are sent to an
international competition.
20K+
Participants
c.350
Participants
c.100
Participants selected
15K+
From Georgia’s regions
c.300
From Georgia’s regions
2
Winners
135
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
We believe STEM education is the key
to unlocking the potential of the next
generation as scientists and innovators.
By promoting STEM education, we
want to inspire and prepare young
people in Georgia for the challenges
and opportunities ahead. This is why in
2023 we deepened our partnership with
Komarovi School, one of the few top
schools in Georgia focused on physics and
mathematics, in the following projects:
STEM School is an online, one-year
comprehensive educational programme
for students in the seventh to 10th
grades across Georgia, designed to foster
creativity and learning and encourage
ideas and discovery. Students have a
unique opportunity to work with Komarovi
teachers on different STEM projects and
delve into the professions of the future.
Each year, we cover the programme fees
for 60 students, providing them with
essential equipment and devices required
for the course.
STEM School
c.1,100
Students registered
68%
from Georgia’s regions
65%
from Georgia’s regions
c.100
BOG scholarship holders
100%
from Georgia’s regions
With the same goal of popularising
technical disciplines and natural sciences
in Georgia, STEM Olympiad is an
innovative competition, not only giving
seventh to 11th graders opportunities
to represent their schools, but also
facilitating the practical application of
the knowledge acquired in traditional
subjects such as physics, mathematics,
informatics and engineering.
The competition unfolds in different
stages, offering a comprehensive
evaluation of participants’ skills and
understanding. At the final stage, the ten
top-performing teams compete to solve
practical tasks.
STEM Olympiad
Bank of Georgia X Komarovi School
Up to 400
Participants
136
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
BLACK
SEA
Educational infrastructure – buildings,
classrooms, laboratories and equipment
– matter for learning. Spaces in schools
where children spend most of their time
are critical components of the overall
educational experience – and, when
designed with students in mind, they
have the power to support learning and
wellbeing.
We recognise the importance of a
conducive learning environment, and are
committed to enhancing educational
infrastructure. This includes supporting
the development and improvement
of schools and educational facilities,
ensuring students have access to safe
and supportive spaces for learning.
Since 2020, Bank of Georgia has been
designing Ideathecas. These colourful,
multifunctional libraries in Georgia’s
public schools provide access to books
and technology to students living in
Georgia’s regions, supporting teamwork
and collaboration in bright, open spaces
full of educational resources. In 2023
we also added a STEM corner to our
Ideathecas, highlighting the importance
of mathematics, science and technology,
and encouraging a more hands-on
approach to learning STEM.
Most of our Ideathecas are located in
rural regions that have high poverty rates
and/or are home to ethnic minorities.
22
Ideathecas
Since 2019
10,000+
Students reached
Improving educational infrastructure
8
Regions
2020
Khurvaleti
Ditsi
Tbilisi
Poti
2021
Pankisi
Nikozi
Akhalkalaki
Ozurgeti
Ambrolauri
2022
Jvari town
Chokhatauri
Nabeglavi Village
Erisimedi
Lambalo
Udabno
Sabatlo
2023
Zugdidi
Shindisi
Mukhrani
Bolnisi
Daba Qeda
Akhaltsikhe
137
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Increasing access to quality education
We aim to contribute to a more inclusive and empowered society by improving access to quality education. This includes initiatives to
support underprivileged communities and create opportunities for those who may face educational challenges.
43
Sponsored students
since 2013
15
Partner
universities
5
Georgian
regions
4
Partner universities
For more than a decade Bank of Georgia
has been dedicated to empowering
students to pursue a world-class
educational experience abroad through
three distinguished programmes: the
Fulbright Scholarship programme, the
Chevening Scholarship programme
and the Miami Ad School EU. These
international scholarships aim to assist
young professionals in gaining access
to high-quality education at master’s or
other post-graduate levels.
We believe in boundless potential of young
individuals and recognise that the student
phase of life holds immense significance,
shaping one’s future professional success.
In line with our commitment to support
and empower young people, in 2023
we launched two new scholarships for
local experience – the Bank of Georgia
Scholarship in Partner Universities and
the Giorgi Chakhava Scholarship, both
focusing on undergraduate students within
the country.
Within the framework of the Bank of
Georgia Scholarship, the Bank cooperates
with 15 Georgian universities, through
which students have unique opportunities
to join our partner universities and receive
either full or partial funding for the entire
year. Whether it is in business, science
or the arts, this scholarship is designed
to help students in any field they are
passionate about.
The Giorgi Chakhava Scholarship
supports students interested in
architecture only. Named after the
brilliant architect behind some of the
most iconic buildings, including Bank of
Georgia’s headquarters, this scholarship
supports future architects who have the
passion and leadership to make a real
difference.
For both scholarships, students are
selected based on their academic
performance and leadership potential,
however the final winners are individually
selected by our partner universities.
We firmly believe that investing in the
education of young minds today will
shape a brighter and more promising
future for all.
International scholarships
Local scholarships
Bank of Georgia Scholarship
Giorgi Chakhava Scholarship
138
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Other activities to motivate students
291
Schools
c.1,300
Participants
from
120
Participants
In 2023
400
Participants
In 2023
c.140K
Participants
Since 2021
Economics Olympiad
With the support of Bank of Georgia and in collaboration
with non-governmental organisation GELi, the Economics
Olympiad was organised and held for the first time in Georgia
in 2023. Following the competition, five talented individuals
were selected to participate in the finals of the International
Economics Olympiad held in Slovakia.
Public Speaking Competition
For more than ten years and as part of a partnership between
Bank of Georgia and the English Speaking Union (ESU),
the Public Speaking Competition has promoted the English
language and critical and logical thinking among young people
in Georgia. The event stands as one of the largest international
gatherings in Georgia dedicated to educational empowerment,
effective communication and thoughtful analysis. More than
800 young people between the ages of 16 and 20 have taken
part in the competition, and the selected student has gone on to
the international Public Speaking Competition held in London.
Harvard Business Case Competition
The Harvard Business Case Competition – one of Georgia’s
largest business faculty events – was held in 2023 as a
partnership between TBSC Consulting and Bank of Georgia. This
unique challenge provided students with hands-on experiences
as decision-makers in managerial positions, enhancing their
quick thinking, teamwork and analytical skills. Participants
gained practical insights that have positively impacted their
studies, employment and work processes.
Kings Olympiad
Kings Olympiad is the largest school Olympiad in Georgia in
mathematics, English and Georgian languages. Bank of Georgia
has been its sponsor since 2021 to increase the level of general
education and motivation among students.
Olympiads and competitions
139
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Bank of Georgia teamed up with the
Georgian Football Federation in 2022
for the following four years. Under
this partnership, Georgia hosted the
UEFA U21 Euro 2023 in Tbilisi, Kutaisi
and Batumi in June 2023. In 2024,
the Georgian National Football team
qualified for Euro 2024 for the first time
in history.
The Bank actively continues to support
Georgian Football, a sport cherished by
many Georgian citizens. This commitment
not only fosters the growth of existing
athletes but also sparks enthusiasm
for a healthy lifestyle among future
generations.
Since 2021 Bank of Georgia has been
the partner of the Georgian Basketball
Federation, with numerous projects
executed during this period. In 2022 Tbilisi
successfully hosted the group stage of
Eurobasket, and we assisted in enhancing
the brand of the Georgian Basketball
Federation and the national team by
introducing a new logo and visual identity.
2023 marked a historic moment for
Georgian basketball, as the national team
qualified for the FIBA World Cup for the
first time in the history.
Bank of Georgia has been a partner and the general sponsor of the Georgian National Olympic and Paralympic Committees since
2016. In 2023, Bank of Georgia helped open the Georgian Olympic Committee Museum. The Museum showcases the impressive
achievements of Georgian Olympians, the history of the Olympic Committee, various Olympics and more.
We believe that sport-related
infrastructure projects are essential for
the development of Georgian sport,
inspiring young people to take up sport
and hone their skills. It is therefore crucial
for young athletes to have access to
suitable facilities. As a result, Bank of
Georgia inaugurated a multifunctional,
high-quality sports facility in Tbilisi in
2023, where amateur athletes can play
football, basketball and tennis, and gain
top-notch experience – all free of charge.
Georgian Football
Federation
Georgian Basketball
Federation
Olympic Committee
New street arena
Sports partnerships
Culture
The Georgian National Ballet –
Sukhishvilebi – has been a global
household name for Georgian dance
since 1945. In 2022, the Bank of Georgia
and Sukhishvilebi established a two-
year partnership. As a key component
of this collaboration, we undertook
a comprehensive renovation of their
primary outdoor venue, ‘Takara’. This
venue served as the main location for
the majority of their shows during the
summer of 2023. Almost every day during
this period, a concert was held, drawing in
more than 10,000 attendees.
The protection and promotion of cultural
heritage rank among our priorities, and
therefore, Bank of Georgia proudly serves
as the general partner of Sukhishvilebi.
With the aim of bringing people together
and making literature accessible, we
organised Tbilisi Book Festival in 2023.
Festival brought more than 16,000
visitors together in the centre of Tbilisi
and across more than 60 bookstores.
Visitors discovered new reads, enjoyed
discounts and publishers gain visibility on
their titles. Through exciting speakers and
special offers, we aimed to make reading
even more enjoyable while supporting
literature and encouraging cultural and
educational activities throughout the
country.
Sukhishvilebi
Tbilisi Book Festival
140
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Other initiatives
Bank of Georgia has continued its long-
running partnership with the Caucasus
Nature Fund and the Agency of Protected
Areas, contributing up to US$ 50,000
in 2023 to support the country’s 12
protected areas: Borjomi-Kharagauli,
Lagodekhi, Tusheti (Tusheti National Park
and the protected landscape), Vashlovani,
Mtirala, Javakheti, Kazbegi, Algeti,
Kintrishi, Machakhela, Batsara-Babaneuri
and Pshav-Khevsureti.
Together with the Caucasus Nature Fund
and the Agency of Protected Areas, we
contribute to the protection of unique
species, the preservation of ecological
diversity, and the promotion of protected
areas and tourism. The total protected
area is nearly 520,000 hectares and
includes 11 administrative and visitor
centres, employing around 350 people.
In 2023, we also continued educational
campaigns to promote the unique
biodiversity of these protected areas.
Supporting Georgia’s protected areas since 2010
141
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Non-financial and sustainability
information statement
The statements below reflect our
commitment to, and management
of, employees, communities, the
environment, human rights, anti-bribery
and anti-corruption in the last 12 months
as required by sections 414CA and 414CB
of the Companies Act 2006.
We are actively monitoring developments
including in relation to ESG matters.
In 2023, our focus included the Global
Reporting Initiative (GRI) standards
and the Task Force on Climate-related
Financial Disclosures (TCFD).
Business model
Climate and environment
Our commitment Further detail
Page reference in
this report
Relevant policy or document
available at
bankofgeorgiagroup.com
We continue to deliver relevant banking
products and services in a seamless
digital experience. We aim to be the
main bank in customers’ daily lives by
leveraging the digital and payments
ecosystems, anticipate customers’ needs
and wants and provide best-in-class
customer care and service.
We continue to make progress in
understanding climate related risks
and opportunities, and putting in place
practices to identify, assess, monitor and
manage climate related issues, focusing
on the Bank’s loan portfolio, as the main
risks and impacts are associated with
lending.
Sustainable finance
TCFD report
Climate-related financial
disclosures
(a) The Groups governance
around climate-related risks
and opportunities
(b) how climate-related risks
are identified, assessed and
managed
(c) how processes for
identifying, assessing and
managing climate-related
risks are integrated within
the Groups overall risk
management framework
(d) impact of climate-related
risks and opportunities on the
Groups business, strategy and
financial planning
(e) Targets used by the Group
to assess climate-related risks
and opportunities
Our operational footprint
Environmental Policy
Our purpose and strategy
framework
JSC Bank of Georgia business
model
Empowering individuals
Empowering businesses
Financial overview
18
20
25 – 39
40 – 49
172 – 183
93 – 98
99 – 118
291
102 – 104
111 – 113
111
105 – 107
and 109
114
115 – 116
142
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Our employees
Respect for human rights
Anti-bribery and anti-corruption
Risk management
Strategic and ESG KPIs
We focus on empowering our employees
by fostering a high-trust, diverse
environment and a strong feedback
culture, equipping employees with the
skills and capabilities for the future. We
are committed to providing our colleagues
with a safe and healthy working
environment and an organisational
culture which promotes inclusivity,
diversity, equal opportunities, personal
development and mutual respect.
We want people to enjoy coming to
work and for the workplace to be free
from discrimination, harassment and
victimisation.
We are committed to respecting human
rights wherever we do business. We
support the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights and the ILO’s Core Labour
Standards. We believe that we are
well-positioned to contribute to building
communities where human rights are
valued and respected.
We are committed to zero tolerance
towards bribery and corruption. We have
in place written policies, procedures and
internal controls to comply with anti-
bribery and anti-corruption laws.
Key enablers
S172 statement
Empowering our employees
Working with our suppliers
Sustainable finance
Empowering our employees
Financial inclusion
Anti-bribery and anti-corruption
Risk management
Principal risks and uncertainties
Key performance indicators
Code of Ethics and Conduct
Human Rights Policy
Diversity and Inclusion
Policy
Anti-discrimination and
Anti-harassment Policy
Whistleblowing Policy
Environmental and Social
Policy
Human Rights Policy
Diversity and Inclusion
Policy
Anti-discrimination and
Anti-harassment Policy
Code of Conduct and Ethics
Anti-bribery and
Anti-corruption Policy
Whistleblowing Policy
19
54
120 – 132
19
54 – 57
87 – 91
134 – 140
81 – 82
93 – 98
120 – 132
87 – 91
70 – 71
144 – 148
150 – 169
23 – 24
Social matters
We are committed to being a significant
contributor to the local communities
where we operate, by not only creating
innovative products and services, but also
by driving positive impact through various
community projects and initiatives beyond
our core business.
Key enablers
S172 statement
Financial inclusion
Empowering our
communities
Environmental and Social
Policy
Human Rights Policy
Diversity and Inclusion Policy
Anti-discrimination and
Anti-harassment Policy
143
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
RISK
MANAGEMENT
144
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
The effective management of risk
is key for achieving the Group’s
strategic objectives. Material risks and
uncertainties are key focus areas for
Executive Management and the Board
of Directors. The Board has ultimate
responsibility for risk governance and
management. Our ERM framework
embeds day-to-day accountability
throughout the organisation to ensure we
operate within acceptable risk tolerances,
as set by the Board’s risk appetite, with
our governance structure and three lines
of defence providing a foundation for
continuous oversight.
Risk management
Key components of our ERM framework
Risk governance
Non-executive risk governance
The risk appetite limits are reviewed and approved annually by
the Board of Directors. The Board sets the tone ‘from the top
and is advised by the Risk Committee.
Executive risk governance
Executive Management assesses the effectiveness of the
implementation of the risk management and internal control
policies and procedures.
Roles and
responsibilities
‘Three lines of defence’ model
The Groups ERM framework is based on the industry-
standard ‘three lines of defence’ model for risk management.
Processes and tools
Risk appetite
The Group has processes in place to identify, assess, measure,
manage and report risks to ensure we remain within risk
appetite.
Active risk management:
identification, measurement,
mitigation and reporting
Internal controls
Policies and procedures
The Group continuously develops the control environment in
business processes, including through segregation of duties,
preventive tools integrated in the systems, restrictions of user
rights.
Control activities
Risk management process
Risk identification is performed regularly and
is a joint effort of the business and the risk
management functions. The main goal is to
detect potential risks in a timely manner and
to avoid or mitigate the potential harm those
risks would bring. In case of material internal
or external change, additional ad hoc risk
identification can be performed.
The Board of Directors regularly discusses and
debates key risks and management’s approach
to managing those risks.
Each identified risk is assessed based on its
likelihood and potential financial and non-
financial impacts, before being compared to
our overall risk appetite and specific limits or
triggers. We then prioritise risks and decide
which need immediate risk response strategies,
aligning identified exposures with the Group’s
risk tolerances.
The Group monitors if appropriate actions are
taken in a timely, consistent and systematic
manner. Key risks are escalated to the
appropriate level of authority. Any significant
changes and developments affecting our risks
and respective mitigating actions are reviewed
quarterly – or more often if necessary – by the
Audit and Risk Committees and reported to the
Board of Directors. In addition, monthly risk
reporting provides senior management with the
information they need to manage risks.
Risk-mitigating activities are developed and
implemented to reduce the potential negative
impact of a particular risk. When evaluating
possible mitigating actions, costs and benefits,
residual risks (those that are retained) and
secondary risks (those arising from risk
mitigation itself) are also considered. All key
controls are recorded and regularly reviewed.
When a control is not working effectively,
root causes are analysed and action plans are
developed and implemented to improve the
control design.
Identify
Monitor and report
Assess and measure
Mitigate
1
4
2
3
145
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
The risk appetite framework is a key
component of the ERM framework and
supports effective risk management
by promoting sound risk-taking within
agreed limits. The Group has established
risk appetite limits for principal risks
to ensure it can meet its strategic
objectives and medium-term targets
even during challenging economic and
operating environments. The risk appetite
framework is reviewed and approved
annually by the Board of Directors. A risk
appetite dashboard is presented monthly
to Executive Management and quarterly
to the Risk Committee which reports to
the Board. This process ensures timely
escalation of a breach and remediation
action plan development.
Risk appetite framework
Risk culture is at the heart of the Groups
ERM framework and risk management
practice. A strong culture, starting
with the Board of Directors, supports
the Group in ensuring ethical business
operations and that performance, risk
and reward are aligned.
Our risk culture aims to ensure that
all employees: (i) understand the risks
associated with their individual roles;
(ii) consider risks and consult with the
Risk function during the development
of new products, procedures, policies
and systems; (iii) align risk appetite and
decision making; (iv) identify, escalate
and proactively manage risk matters in
accordance with the ERM framework;
and (v) report and communicate risks
transparently.
To develop risk culture, we focus on giving
employees the awareness and capabilities
to manage risk. We provide a wide range
of training programmes across the risk
disciplines – some mandatory for all
employees, others role-specific or part of
individual development plans. Mandatory
training programmes are accessible
online and ensure we keep our customers,
employees and the whole organisation
safe. Topics covered include operational
risks, business continuity, information
security and data protection, health and
safety, corporate security, business ethics,
and financial crime risks and sanctions
risks. The system allows monitoring at all
levels to ensure completion of mandatory
training programmes. The completion
rate of the risks and compliance training
programme at the end of 2023 was
91%, an increase on 2022. Our goal is
to achieve c.100% completion rate and
we are focused on ensuring a strong risk
awareness among our employees.
Risk culture
The Code of Conduct and Ethics and the
Whistleblowing Policy are the primary
documents governing culture and ethics.
The Code of Conduct and Ethics clearly
sets the expectation that all employees
act legally, ethically and transparently in
all their dealings.
The whistleblowing tool allows employees
to report any concern, anonymously
if they wish so. Responsibility for the
Whistleblowing Policy resides with the
Board who, together with the Audit and
Risk Committees, receive reports on its
operation quarterly.
Through our grievance mechanism,
which is part of our Human Rights
and Grievance Policy, employees can
communicate legitimate concerns about
illegal, unethical or questionable practices
– confidentially, if necessary – without the
risk of retaliation.
Our Code and Whistleblowing Policy
Our Board is responsible for reviewing
and approving the Group’s system of
internal controls and its adequacy and
effectiveness. Controls are reviewed to
ensure effective management of the risks
we face. Certain matters, such as the
approval of major capital expenditures,
significant acquisitions or disposals, and
major contracts, are reserved exclusively
for the Board. The full schedule of
matters reserved for the Board can
be found on our website at https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/
documents For other matters the Board
is often assisted by both the Audit and
Risk Committees.
With respect to internal controls over
financial reporting, including the Group’s
consolidation process, our financial
procedures include a range of system,
transactional and management oversight
controls. The Group prepares detailed
monthly management reports that
include analyses of results, comparisons,
relevant strategic plans, budgets,
forecasts and prior results. These are
presented to and reviewed by Executive
Management.
For other matters the Board is often
assisted by both the Audit and Risk
Committees. With respect to internal
controls over financial reporting,
including the Groups consolidation
process, our financial procedures include
a range of system, transactional and
management oversight controls. The
Group prepares detailed monthly
management reports that include
analyses of results, comparisons, relevant
strategic plans, budgets, forecasts and
prior results. These are presented to and
reviewed by Executive Management. .
For other matters the Board is often
assisted by both the Audit and Risk
Committees. With respect to internal
controls over financial reporting, including
the Groups consolidation process, our
financial procedures include a range of
system, transactional and management
oversight controls. The Group prepares
detailed monthly management reports
that include analyses of results,
comparisons, relevant strategic plans,
budgets, forecasts and prior results.
These are presented to and reviewed
by Executive Management. For
other matters the Board is often
assisted by both the Audit and Risk
Committees. With respect to internal
controls over financial reporting, including
the Groups consolidation process, our
financial procedures include a range of
system, transactional and management
oversight controls. The Group prepares
detailed monthly management reports
that include analyses of results,
comparisons, relevant strategic plans,
budgets, forecasts and prior results.
These are presented to and reviewed by
Executive Management.
For other matters the Board is often
assisted by both the Audit and Risk
Committees. With respect to internal
controls over financial reporting, including
the Groups consolidation process, our
financial procedures include a range of
system, transactional and management
oversight controls. The Group prepares
detailed monthly management reports
that include analyses of results,
comparisons, relevant strategic plans,
budgets, forecasts and prior results.
These are presented to and reviewed by
Executive Management. Each quarter
the CFO and other members of the
Finance team discuss financial reporting
and associated internal controls with
the Audit Committee, which reports
significant findings to the Board. The
Audit Committee also reviews quarterly,
half-year and full-year financial
statements and corresponding results
announcements, and advises the Board.
The external auditor and Internal Audit
attend each Audit Committee meeting,
and the Audit Committee meets them
regularly both with and without the
presence of Executive Management.
Our Audit and Risk Committees monitor
internal controls over operational and
compliance risks. The Bank’s CRO and
CFO, Head of Internal Audit and other
Executive Management Team members
report to the Audit and Risk Committees
on a quarterly basis.
Internal controls
146
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Each year we review the effectiveness
of our risk management processes and
internal controls, with the assistance
of the Audit and Risk Committees. This
review covers all material systems,
including financial, operational and
compliance controls. The latest review
covered the financial year ended
31 December 2023 and obtained
assurance from Executive Management,
Internal and External Audit.
The Board concludes with reasonable
assurance that the appropriate internal
controls and risk management systems
were maintained and operated effectively
during 2023, and that these systems
continued to operate effectively up to the
date of approval of this Annual Report.
The review did not identify any significant
weaknesses or failures in the systems.
We are satisfied that our risk
management processes and internal
control systems comply with the UK
Corporate Governance Code 2018 and
the Financial Reporting Council’s (FRC)
guidance on Risk Management, Internal
Control and Related Financial and
Business Reporting.
Effectiveness review
The Audit and Risk Committees play
key roles in assessing the strength and
effectiveness of the risk management and
internal control systems. Each Committee
has described its work in its Committee
Report, which can be found on pages 214
to 223 for the Audit Committee and 224
to 228 for the Risk Committee.
Committee reports
The Board has undertaken an assessment
of the Group’s prospects to meet its
liabilities by considering its current
financial position and principal risks.
The Groups going concern and viability
statements are on page 170.
Viability statement
All roles below the CEO fall within one of the three lines, and all employees are responsible for understanding and managing risks
within their individual roles and responsibilities.
Revenue-generating, customer-
facing and support functions that are
responsible for identifying, assessing,
managing, monitoring and reporting risks
of products, activities, processes and
systems under their management.
Risk function (under the CRO) responsible
for: developing policies, methods and
procedures; developing and implementing
the risk appetite framework, including
setting the limits; supporting and
challenging first-line risk management;
and providing assurance on regulatory
compliance and effectiveness of key
controls.
Internal Audit responsible for: providing
independent assurance; assessing the
consistency and effectiveness of the
Groups internal control systems; and
reviewing the overall ERM framework
to ensure alignment to regulatory
expectations and industry standards.
Risk management structure
Three Lines
First Line Second Line Third Line
Any key issues identified are escalated to
the Board. The Board also receives regular
reports directly from the head of each
risk function, in which principal risks and
internal control issues are addressed.
In line with the revised UK Code of
Corporate Governance issued in January
2024, specifically Provision 29, the Bank
has established a dedicated working
group led by a steering committee, under
the CFO. The Internal Controls over
Financial Reporting (ICFR) team has
been entrusted with the responsibility
of ensuring compliance with the
requirements by 2026.
As part of our governance framework, the
Board receives quarterly updates from
the ICFR team on the progress of the
project, focusing on our journey towards
compliance with the code. These updates
include comprehensive information on
the project’s advancements in identifying,
assessing, and documenting key risks
andcontrols.
147
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Audit Committee
Credit Committees
Asset and Liability
Management Committee
Environmental and Social
Impact Committee
Risk Committee
Management Board
Supervisory Board of
Bank of Georgia
Bank of Georgia is the principal driver
of the Group’s revenue and operates
in the financial services sector. The
work undertaken by the Bank’s risk
management bodies feeds back
directly to the Group. The main risk
management bodies of the Bank are the
Supervisory Board, Audit Committee,
Risk Committee, Executive Management,
Credit Committees, Asset and Liability
Management Committee (ALCO), and
ESI Committee. The Supervisory Board,
Audit Committee and Risk Committee
mirror the Group Board, the Group
Audit Committee and the Group Risk
Committee.
Executive Management has overall
responsibility for the Bank’s asset, liability
and risk management activities, policies
and procedures.
The Group Internal Audit function is an
internal, independent, objective assurance
and consulting provider. As the third line
of defence, it adds value and improves
the Groups operations through the
assessment of the effectiveness and
adequacy of Group-wide processes,
controls, governance and risk
management. The Chief Auditor reports
to the Audit Committee at least quarterly
on significant risk exposures and control
issues if any are identified through audit
engagements. Furthermore, the Chief
Auditor meets with the Chair of the Audit
Committee on a monthly basis to discuss
resource allocation, performance results,
and address any additional concerns.
Risk management bodies of Bank of Georgia
The Bank has five Credit Committees,
each responsible for managing the Bank’s
risk across loan portfolios in all business
segments.
The Credit Committee comprises three
tiers of subcommittees for retail loans;
one tier for micro loans; three tiers for
SME loans; three tiers for corporate loans;
and one tier for corporate recovery.
Lower-tier subcommittees meet daily,
while higher-tier subcommittees meet as
needed – typically once or twice a week.
Each subcommittee makes its decisions
by a majority vote of its members.
The ALCO is the core asset liability
management (ALM) and financial risk
management body establishing policies
and guidelines with respect to capital
adequacy, market risks, funding and
liquidity risk, interest rate and prepayment
risks and respective limits, money market
general terms, and credit exposure limits.
The ALCO reviews scenario analyses and
stress tests, regularly monitors compliance
with pre-set risk limits and approves
treasury deals.
Responsible for the development and
implementation of the Bank’s ESG
strategy, including its climate risk and
opportunity management strategy. The
Committee manages the Bank’s CE&S
impacts, focusing primarily on those
associated with its lending activities.
Stress testing and scenario analysis
are important risk management tools
providing input for strategic decision
making and planning as they enable
to assess the impact of plausible but
severe stress scenarios relating to the
Groups liquidity and capital positions.
We regularly assess the vulnerabilities of
our portfolios to adverse macroeconomic
factors, financial market stresses and
geo(political) developments. Portfolio
sensitivities are fed into the impact
assessment of profit and loss, liquidity
and capital.
Stress testing
Viability: Scenario assumptions for
all relevant macroeconomic and
financial market variables are set,
and potential impacts are assessed
against the viability of the Group. This
includes reverse stress-testing, where
the Group identifies circumstances
that may lead to business failure. This
type of test is performed at least
annually and reported to the Board of
Directors.
Risk-specific: Depending on the
tendencies of the market, specific
portfolios are tested for various
market-wide scenarios. The impact
of various shocks is assessed against
portfolio quality, profitability, liquidity
and capital.
Idiosyncratic: Conducted on an ad hoc
basis, based on certain idiosyncratic
factors that may arise in the business
over time.
We perform different types of stress tests:
148
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Each business line identifies key risks
that are inherent to their activity and
may significantly influence the Groups
performance or prospects. The principal
risks and uncertainties faced by the Group
are identified through this bottom-up
process. A description of these principal
risks and uncertainties, including outlook,
recent drivers and mitigation efforts, can
be found on pages 150 to 169.
Information compiled from all our
businesses is examined and processed to
identify, assess and manage emerging
risks. This information is presented and
discussed with Executive Management
and the head of each business division,
as appropriate. We also consider wider
macroeconomic risks and escalate these
to the Supervisory Board or Board of
Directors, as appropriate, in regular
presentations.
The Group has identified climate risk as
an emerging risk. We continue to assess
climate-related risks, both transitional and
physical, for our client base and determine
potential impacts on the Group. We are
describing and managing climate-related
risks in line with recommendations from
the TCFD, and more details on the Groups
planned actions can be found on pages 100
to 118.
Principal and emerging risks
Regulatory: Mandated by the NBG,
which also provides the context and
methodology for stress tests.
Stress test methodologies vary by
type and objective. Depending on the
risk type, respective risk management
units are responsible for performing the
analysis. If unacceptably high risks are
identified, risk units adopt measures
to mitigate them and reflect those
measures in their strategic plans.
The ERM department is responsible
for results aggregation, analysis and
reporting.
We consolidated our Risk and Compliance
functions under the CRO to enhance
collaboration and efficiency among
teams.
We continued to improve our capital
and liquidity risk management by
updating the Internal Capital Adequacy
Assessment Process (ICAAP) and Internal
Liquidity Adequacy Assessment Process
(ILAAP) to reflect changes in the financial
landscape, regulatory requirements and
the Bank’s risk profile.
We improved our enterprise risk reporting
processes, increasing focus on key risk
indicators, promoting proactive risk
management and ensuring a more
comprehensive assessment of potential
vulnerabilities.
We revised the Bank’s Model Risk
Management Policy with the help of
a global management consultancy,
McKinsey & Company.
We continued to strengthen climate risk
management capabilities across the
Bank. This involved broadening the scope
of climate-related training, deepening our
knowledge of climate change and climate
policy in Georgia, and reassessing climate
scenarios.
In 2023 we implemented several changes and initiatives to further strengthen our risk management:
Key development in 2023
149
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
PRINCIPAL
RISKS AND
UNCERTAINTIES
150
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Principal risks and uncertainties
In this section we disclose the principal
and emerging risks and uncertainties
most likely to have an impact on our
business model, strategic objectives,
operations, future performance, solvency
and liquidity. We also disclose the
potential impacts as well as the drivers
and outlook associated with these risks
and the actions we take to mitigate them.
The order in which the principal risks and
uncertainties appear does not denote
their priority. It is not possible to fully
mitigate all our risks. Any system of
risk management and internal control
is designed to manage – rather than
eliminate – the risk of failure to achieve
business objectives, and can only provide
reasonable and not absolute assurance
against material misstatement or loss.
The Group is exposed to risks wider
than those listed. Additional risks and
uncertainties, including those the Group
is currently not aware of or deems
immaterial, may also result in decreased
revenues, incurred expenses or other
events that could in turn result in a decline
in the value of the Groups securities. We
disclose the risks we believe are likely to
have the greatest impact on our business,
and which have been discussed in depth
at the Groups recent Board, Audit or Risk
Committee meetings.
Macro and Geopolitical risks
Macro and geopolitical risks are the risks that would lead to the Group being unable to execute its strategy – and therefore result in a
deterioration in its financial position – due to macroeconomic and geopolitical instability affecting the Georgian economy.
Key drivers and
developments
The Groups operations are primarily located in, and most of its revenue is sourced from, Georgia. One of the
Groups subsidiaries – JSC Belarusky Narodny Bank (BNB) – is located in Belarus, but it only accounted for 3.0%
ofthe Groups total equity as at 31 December 2023.
Key sources of macro risk related to Georgia are changes in GDP, inflation, interest rates and exchange rates,
and political events. These factors may have a material impact on our business by affecting the Groups financial
performance and position.
The Georgian economy is expected to grow at 6.0% in 2024 according to Galt & Taggart, while IMF forecasts
Georgia’s real GDP growth at 5.7%. However, the growth outlook is accompanied by downside risks related to
geopolitical instability and tightening of global financial conditions.
Inflation has decreased sharply in Georgia since the beginning of 2023. However, upside inflation risk remains
elevated. In case of a sudden halt of external inflows and the Georgian Lari (GEL) depreciation, inflation may
resurge and require a tight monetary policy response. Tensions in the Middle East following the Hamas attacks
on Israel in 2023 have also contributed to upside inflation risks. If the situation in the Middle East escalates
further, global commodity markets may be affected adversely with harsh inflationary impact on commodity
importers such as Georgia. The unresolved war in Ukraine and related supply disruptions have exacerbated
global commodity price pressures. As a response, the Western central banks continued to hike interest rates in
2023. Emerging markets and developing economies, including Georgia, are particularly vulnerable to tight global
financial conditions as a considerable share of their debt is denominated in foreign currencies. Furthermore,
suchconditions may induce capital outflows and result in depreciation pressures on local currencies.
International sanctions on Russia have been evolving, increasing sanctions compliance risks for the financial
sector. The 2023 Investment Climate Statements of the Department of State of the United States noted that
the NBG and Georgian financial institutions act fully in compliance with the financial sanctions imposed on the
Russian Federation
1
. The NBG thoroughly monitors financial institutions’ compliance with international financial
sanctions during on-site inspections. As at 31 December 2023, the Bank did not have any exposure to the Russian
banks impacted by the US, UK or EU sanctions.
The sanctions on Belarus have also been expanding. In November 2022, the Government of Canada sanctioned
additional individuals and entities, including BNB. BNB did not have exposure to Canada, therefore neither its
operations nor its financial position was significantly affected. The Group actively engaged with Global Affairs
Canada to investigate the reasons. As of today, these are solely due to the fact BNB is located in Belarus,
and the Group is actively seeking delisting of its subsidiary from the Canadian sanctions list, on the basis of
nogrounds existing for sanctioning it under the relevant regulations.
Overall, business and investment conditions are sound in Georgia, with low inflation, reduced public debt and
ample foreign exchange buffers. However, the concerns regarding the integrity of the judicial appointment
process and the capacity of the courts to deliver quality outcomes continue to affect investor confidence in the
court system. This issue was also highlighted by the European Commission that granted Georgia EU candidate
status on the understanding that the relevant steps set out in the Commission recommendation are taken.
Theoutstanding conditions include Georgia pushing back against political polarisation, as well as ensuring a
free and fair 2024 elections. If ongoing tensions escalate, market sentiment and the growth outlook may be
negatively affected.
In 2024, the Group expanded into Armenia through the acquisition of a leading universal bank, Ameriabank.
Despite a robust performance and prudent management of the Armenian economy, it remains exposed to
geopolitical risks and structural challenges. The Armenian economy remains constrained by structural challenges
including low productivity in manufacturing and agriculture, narrow export base and financial dollarisation.
However, strong focus on the IT sector as well as ongoing reforms in the education system can help Armenia
transform into a service-based and export-led economy. Similar to Georgia, the Armenian banking sector is
distinguished by relatively high, albeit decreasing dollarisation, which amplifies external shocks and weakens the
transmission of monetary policy. In Armenia, bank loan and deposit dollarisation stood at 35.6% and 50.5% at
end-2023, respectively (vs. 36.3% and 55.1% at end-2022).
1. https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-investment-climate-statements/georgia/
151
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigation Governance: The Board of Directors receive a regular, quarterly update on global, regional, and local economic
developments and risks from the Bank’s economist. The Board is also regularly updated, sometimes by external
consultants, on major political and geopolitical developments that affect the broader region. Economic analysis
is also regularly presented to the ALCO, with a specific focus on interest rates, exchange rates, inflation and
economic growth outlook.
Monitoring and reporting: The Group continuously monitors macroeconomic conditions and performs stress
and scenario analyses to test its position under adverse economic and geopolitical conditions including adverse
currency movements. We assess the sensitivities of certain portfolios to different macroeconomic factors and
geopolitical scenarios, enabling us to take portfolio-related actions if necessary, including increasing monitoring
and changing our credit risk appetite.
The Group actively monitors the situation around the Russia-Ukraine war and its repercussions for the region,
especially Georgia and Belarus. The Group conducts stress testing analysis to ensure early risk indicators are
identified and mitigation plans implemented in a timely manner.
Georgia’s resilience to external shocks has been supported by a well-diversified economy, prudent monetary
and fiscal policies, a business-friendly environment, and a healthy banking sector. The Belarus market is more
vulnerable to the impact of the Russia-Ukraine war, and we continue to closely monitor the situation.
Mitigation: In accordance with the Georgian legislation, in 2023 loans up to GEL 200,000 were issued only in
Lari. Effective from 1 January 2024, this threshold was increased to GEL 300,000, while borrowers with hedged
currency risk were exempted from this regulation. The threshold was further increased to GEL 400,000 effective
from 1 May 2024. Additionally, the NBG has determined a currency-induced credit risk (CICR) capital buffer that
aims to reduce systemic risks caused by dollarisation. This buffer is created for risk positions denominated in
a currency different from that used to cover those positions. For loans to individuals, the NBG’s payment-to-
income (PTI) and loan-to-value (LTV) requirements are more conservative for foreign currency loans to mitigate
borrower-level credit risk: PTI requirements for foreign currency loans are 5 ppts higher for income below GEL
1,500 and 20 ppts higher for income above GEL 1,500; the LTV requirement for foreign currency mortgage loans
is 15 ppts tighter.
At 31 December 2023, 22.7% of Bank of Georgia’s Retail Banking (RB) gross loans, 43.5% of SME Banking gross
loans, and 73.5% of CB gross loans were denominated in foreign currency. Meanwhile, 4.9% of Retail Banking
gross loans, 1.7% of SME Banking and 37.7% of CB loans were issued in foreign currency, with minimal exposure
to foreign currency risk.
In addition, the Bank’s open currency position limits set by the Supervisory Board are currently more conservative
than those imposed by the NBG. The open currency position on a day-to-day basis is managed by the Treasury
and monitored by the Capital Adequacy and Financial Risk Management (CFRM) unit.
Despite the ongoing war and the sanctions directly or indirectly imposed on BNB, it has demonstrated resilience
and continues to operate with solid liquidity and capital positions. At 31 December 2023, BNB’s Tier 1 and Total
capital adequacy ratios stood at 9.9% and 13.8% respectively, above the National Bank of the Republic of Belarus
(NBRB)’s minimum requirements of 7.0% and 12.5% respectively. In line with the Group’s zero-tolerance policies
with respect to sanctions risk, BNB is operating in compliance with local and international sanctions laws, and
we do not expect further sanction extensions.
Credit risk
Credit risk is the risk that the Group will incur a financial loss because its customers or counterparties fail to meet their contractual
obligations. Credit risk arises mainly in the context of the Bank’s lending activities.
Key drivers and
developments
Expected credit loss (ECL) and, in turn, the Groups cost of credit risk, could increase if an idiosyncratic risk for
any single large borrower materialises, or a sectorial or systemic event causes the default of a substantial group
of borrowers.
The Groups cost of credit risk ratio was 0.7% in 2023 (0.8% in 2022). The ECL on loans and finance lease
receivables posted during the year amounted to GEL 127.1, mainly driven by Retail Banking exposures. As at
31 December 2023 the Stage 3 ratio stood at 2.5%, versus 3.4% as at 31 December 2022.
Mitigation Governance: The Bank has three independent Credit Risk Management departments: Retail Credit Risk
direction; Corporate Credit Risk department; and MSME Credit Risk department. The Credit Risk Management
departments oversee and challenge frontline credit risk management activities. Each department is supported
by the following teams:
Credit Risk Analysis team: responsible for analysing customers’ creditworthiness based on financial
information/credit ratings, sharing analyses with the risk owners and providing recommendations at
underwriting or monitoring stages. It controls compliance with credit limits through regular reporting and
systemic alerts, and ensures compliance with credit risk management procedures.
Portfolio Risk Analysis team: responsible for analysing and monitoring the credit risk position of the Bank
while establishing and maintaining the credit risk framework and policies. It assesses credit risk, reporting to
management and business lines.
The Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) department oversees the Bank-wide credit risk assessment process,
manages quality monitoring policies, continuously monitors the Bank’s credit portfolio quality parameters
using various tools and techniques, and manages risk budgeting, stress testing and scenario analysis. The ERM
department provides regular reports to Executive Management and the Supervisory Board on the Bank’s credit
risk profile and the effectiveness of risk management strategies.
Macro and Geopolitical risks continued
152
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Mitigation
continued
Risk appetite: The credit risk appetite consists of quantitative limits and is specifically designed to mitigate
theoccurrence of excessive credit risk and credit concentrations at various levels within the Bank’s portfolio.
The credit risk profile relative to risk appetite is monitored and reported monthly to Executive Management
andquarterly to the Supervisory Board.
Credit risk identification and assessment: The process of identifying credit risks primarily relies on effective
relationship management and the prudent oversight of customer and portfolio credit. The credit assessment
process is distinct across segments and is further differentiated across various product types to reflect the
specifics of different asset classes. The assessment process depends on transaction complexity: Corporate,
SME and larger Retail loans are assessed individually; unsecured Retail loan decisions are largely automated.
The performance of all models used in credit risk management is monitored in line with the Bank’s model risk
management framework. Please see Model Risk on pages 166 to 167 for more details.
To ensure a robust credit-granting process, the Bank has implemented several measures and frameworks:
Well-defined lending standards: The Bank has established clear standards for granting credit, outlining the
requirements and standards that borrowers must meet. These standards serve as a benchmark for evaluating
the creditworthiness of customers, enabling the identification and assessment of potential risks associated
with extending credit.
Segregation of duties: The credit analysis and approval process involves a clear segregation of duties among
the parties involved. In the case of Corporate, SME clients, the analytics team is involved in credit risk analysis,
while for Retail loans only loan officers and credit risk officers are involved. Credit analysts and loan officers
prepare presentations with key borrower information which are then reviewed by a business credit risk officer,
ensuring all risks and mitigating factors are identified and addressed, and that loans are properly structured.
Multi-tiered loan approval committees: The loan is reviewed and approved by multi-tiered credit committees,
with different loan approval limits to consider a customers overall risk profile. Different committees are
responsible for reviewing credit applications and approving exposures based on the size and risk of a loan.
Loan portfolio quality monitoring and reporting: The Bank actively monitors the credit risk of its loan portfolio.
Processes and controls are in place to ensure macro and micro developments are identified in a timely manner.
Monitoring includes a full assessment against risk appetite limits, supported by a series of key risk and early
warning indicators to identify areas of the portfolio with potentially increasing credit risk. The Bank’s Chief Risk
Officer and Credit Risk Management departments review the credit quality of the portfolio monthly.
Retail and SME loans are subject to periodic reviews, and the Bank monitors exposures to identify customers
with signs of potential financial difficulty. For CB loans above US$ 5 million, the Bank updates the financial
information of borrowers and reviews significant non-financial changes quarterly. Exposures up to US$ 5 million
are monitored semi-annually, or as needed if signs of credit stress are detected.
The Bank strictly adheres to customer exposure limits set by the NBG for CB loans and limits set internally,
monitors the level of concentration in the loan portfolio and the financial performance of its largest borrowers,
and maintains a well-diversified loan book. The Bank’s top ten borrowers accounted for 7.3% of the Groups gross
loans to customers and finance lease receivables at 31 December 2023 (5.9% at 31 December 2022).
The Group provides updates monthly to Executive Management and quarterly to the Board of Directors on the
Groups exposures and loan portfolio quality, and detailed information on the largest CB borrowers. In addition
to these recurring updates, some point-in-time analyses are occasionally performed upon request of the
Supervisory Board’s Risk Committee to monitor exposures in specific sectors and/or single-name exposures.
Collateral valuation: Property and other security arrangements are used to mitigate credit risk across portfolios.
The main forms of collateral in CB and SME Banking are liens over real estate, property, plant, equipment,
inventory, transportation equipment, corporate guarantees, and deposits and securities. The most common form
of collateral in Retail Banking for loans to individuals is a lien over residential property. At 31 December 2023,
83.2% of the Group’s gross loans to customers were collateralised.
The Bank monitors the market value of collateral during reviews of the adequacy of the allowance for ECL.
Whenevaluating collateral for provisioning purposes, the Bank discounts the market value of assets to reflect
the liquidation value of collateral. An evaluation report of the proposed collateral is prepared by the Asset
Evaluation department or a reputable third-party asset appraisal company and submitted to the appropriate
Credit Committee alongside a loan application and a credit risk officer’s report.
Restructuring and collections: The Bank provides solutions to help borrowers experiencing financial difficulties
to meet contractual obligations. Cases are managed on an individual basis by the Collections teams, and
the circumstances of each customer are considered separately. When a customer surpasses an agreed-upon
limit or fails to make a regular monthly payment, the Bank contacts the customer and asks her to remedy the
position. If the issue is not resolved, the Collections teams may initiate a loan restructuring process, modifying
the contractual payment terms to support customers and transfer loans back to the performing category.
For unsecured retail loans overdue for more than 30 days, restructuring alternatives are automatically offered
through digital channels. Helping a customer return to financial health and restoring a normal banking
relationship is always the preferred outcome – however, where a solvent outcome is not possible, insolvency may
be considered as a last resort.
Credit risk continued
153
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigation
continued
Recovery process is initiated when a borrower enters default on their lending facility and the Bank demands
full repayment. The main aim is to negotiate a loan recovery strategy with the borrower by offering acceptable
terms for cash payments, or to negotiate repayment through a collateral sale or repossession. If the Bank and
the borrower cannot agree on acceptable terms, the collateral repossession process is initiated, which may
include court, arbitration or notary procedures.
ECL measurement: The Bank uses the ECL model of IFRS 9 to determine loss allowances, acknowledging its
forward-looking nature. The model follows a conventional approach that involves dividing the estimation of
credit losses into its components: probability of default (PD), loss given default (LGD), and exposure at default
(EAD).
Under IFRS requirements, allowance for credit losses is based on ECL associated with the probability of default
in the next 12 months, unless there has been a significant increase in credit risk since loan origination – in such
cases, allowance is based on ECL over the lifetime of an asset. Allowance for credit losses is based on forward-
looking information, considering past events, current conditions and forecasts of economic parameters.
The Bank uses a three-stage model for ECL measurement:
Stage 1: If, at the reporting date, exposure is not credit impaired and credit risk has not increased significantly
since initial recognition. The Group recognises a credit loss allowance in an amount equal to a 12-month ECL.
Stage 2: If, at the reporting date, exposure is not credit impaired but credit risk has increased significantly
since initial recognition. The Group recognises a credit loss allowance in an amount equal to lifetime ECL.
Stage 3: If, at the reporting date, exposure is credit impaired. The Group recognises a loss allowance in
an amount equal to lifetime ECL, reflecting a PD of 100% for those financial instruments that are credit
impaired.
The Bank determines ECL of financial assets on a collective basis, and for individually significant loans on an
individual basis, when a financial asset or a group of financial assets is impaired. The Bank creates ECL provisions
considering a borrowers financial condition, days past due, changes in credit risk since loan origination,
forecasts of adverse changes in commercial, financial or economic conditions affecting the creditworthiness of
the borrower, and other qualitative indicators such as external market or general economic conditions. If ECL
subsequently decreases, the previously recognised loss is reversed by an adjusted ECL account. Under the Bank’s
internal credit loss allowance methodology, which is based on IFRS requirements, the Bank categorises its loan
portfolio into individually significant and non-significant loans. The Credit Risk Management departments assess
all defaulted significant loans individually. Non-defaulted significant loans are given a collective assessment rate.
For the purpose of collective provisioning, all loans are categorised into homogenous groups (such as mortgage,
consumer and micro loans).
Counterparty risk: By performing banking services – including lending on the inter-bank money market, settling
a transaction on the inter-bank FX market, entering into inter-bank transactions related to trade finance or
investing in securities – the Bank is exposed to the risk of loss due to the failure of a counterparty to meet its
contractual obligations. To manage counterparty risk, the Bank defines limits on an individual basis for each
counterparty based on an external credit rating and overall risk profile, as well as country limits to manage
concentration risk. Counterparty credit risk exposures are monitored daily and any breaches are escalated
in line with escalation policies to the Bank’s Executive Management. As at 31 December 2023, 95.4% of the
Bank’s inter-bank exposure was to ‘Investment Grade’ banks (based on Fitch, Moody’s and Standard and Poor’s
assessments).
Other products: The Bank also offers guarantees and letters of credit which may require that the Bank makes
payments on customers’ behalf. Such payments are collected from customers based on the terms of the
product. The risks related to these products are managed and mitigated with the same policies and controls as
loan-related risks.
Credit risk continued
154
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Liquidity and funding risks
Liquidity risk is the risk that the Group will be unable to meet its payment obligations when they fall due under normal and stress
circumstances.
Funding risk is the risk that the Group will not be able to access stable and diversified funding sources at an acceptable cost.
Key drivers and
developments
The availability of funding in emerging markets is significantly influenced by the level of investor confidence. Any
factors affecting this – including a downgrade in credit ratings, state interventions or debt restructurings in a
relevant industry – could affect the price and/or availability of funding for the Groups companies operating in
any of these markets.
The Groups current liquidity may be affected by unfavourable financial market conditions. If assets held by the
Group to provide liquidity become illiquid or their value drops substantially, the Group may be required – or may
choose – to rely on other sources of funding to finance its operations and future growth. However, only a limited
amount of funding is available on the Georgian inter-bank market, and recourse to other funding sources may
pose additional risks – including the possibility that other funding sources are more expensive and less flexible.
The Group is also exposed to the risk of unexpected, rapid withdrawal of large volumes of deposits by its
customers and/or drawing on off-balance sheet commitments, adversely impacting the Group’s business,
financial position and performance. This may happen in the case of a severe economic downturn or a period of
political, social or economic instability, a major deterioration in consumer confidence, or an erosion of trust in
financial institutions. Furthermore, following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, there was a substantial rise in the
foreign currency deposits of Russian residents in Georgia, which has created a concentration risk.
Mitigation Governance: The governance of funding and liquidity risk management at the Group level is overseen by the
ALCO, which approves the liquidity risk management framework and liquidity risk appetite, and ensures its
implementation throughout the organisation. The Groups funding and liquidity risk governance follows a
three-lines-of-defence structure to set a clear division of responsibilities as well as an independent risk control
challenge process. The Treasury department and the Asset and Liability Management (ALM) unit are the first
line of defence, responsible for managing the Group’s liquidity and funding positions, maintaining access to
funding markets, and managing the liquidity buffer. The CFRM unit serves as the second line of defence and
is responsible for developing and maintaining policies, standards, and guidelines for funding and liquidity risk
management, and developing the risk appetite. Furthermore, the CFRM is responsible for conducting risk profile
reviews and communicating results to the ALCO.
Risk appetite: The Bank has developed a set of risk appetite statements outlining its risk tolerance and defining
its risk appetite in alignment with the principles of liquidity adequacy. The liquidity risk appetite statements are
translated into a range of metrics approved by the Bank’s Supervisory Board and reviewed at least annually,
enabling the identification of potential deviations from the desired risk profile and triggering proactive risk
management actions if these boundaries are breached.
Funding and liquidity management: Liquidity risk is managed through the ALCO-approved liquidity risk
management framework, which models the ability of the Group to meet its payment obligations under both
normal and stress conditions. The framework is reviewed regularly to ensure its appropriateness given the
Groups current and planned activities, and encompasses a set of limits on various liquidity indicators, closely
monitored by the ALCO. Additionally, the Bank has developed a liquidity contingency plan defining risk indicators
for different scenarios and mitigation actions to identify emerging liquidity concerns at an early stage.
The Group conducts a comprehensive assessment of funding risk associated with the balance sheet,
encompassing both quantitative and qualitative analyses of the behavioural characteristics of its assets and
liabilities, along with an examination of funding concentration. The concentration of funds by currency, maturity,
commodity, and counterparty is monitored regularly and, where concentrations do exist, is managed as part of
the planning process and limited by the internal funding and liquidity risk management framework, with analysis
regularly provided to the ALCO.
Liquidity stress testing: The Bank’s ILAAP includes liquidity stress-test/scenario analysis framework to assess
the sufficiency of the Bank’s liquidity buffers to withstand potential liquidity shocks. The framework includes
idiosyncratic, systemic and combined scenarios to test the sensitivity of the Bank’s liquidity position to each of
them. Shocks are designed to include all key liquidity-related items and factors.
Monitoring and reporting: The Bank monitors a range of market and internal early warning indicators on a daily
basis for early signs of liquidity risk in the market or specific to the Bank. Furthermore, the Bank delivers bi-
weekly forecasts and monthly updates on liquidity risk to Executive Management. The liquidity risk is integrated
into the risk profile dashboard, subject to review by the Risk Committee, and is also a topic of discussion
during joint sessions of the Risk and Audit Committees. The reports included EY’s view of the judgments
made by management, compliance with international financial reporting standards and the external auditors
observations and assessment of the effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting.
155
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Liquidity and funding risks continued
Mitigation
continued
Funding and liquidity developments: The Group maintains a diverse funding base comprising short-term sources
of funding (including Retail Banking and CB customer deposits, inter-bank borrowings and borrowings from the
NBG) and longer-term sources (including Retail Banking and CB term deposits, borrowings from international
credit institutions and long-term debt securities). At 31 December 2023 42.2%, 48.0% and 9.8% of the Groups
long-term funding sources were deposits, amounts owned to credit institutions, and debt securities respectively.
The Bank maintains a comfortable buffer on top of the liquidity coverage ratio (LCR) requirement of 100%
mandated by the NBG. A strong LCR enhances the Groups short-term resilience. The Bank also holds a
comfortable buffer on top of the net stable funding ratio (NSFR) requirement of 100%, providing a stable
funding source over a longer time span. This approach is designed to ensure the funding framework is sufficiently
flexible to secure liquidity under a wide range of market conditions. Notably, the LCR and NSFR measures
implemented by the NBG are already more conservative than the minimum levels required under the Basel III
framework. At 31 December 2023 the Bank’s IFRS-based LCR ratio stood at 125.2% (132.4% at 31 December
2022)
1
and its IFRS-based NSFR ratio was 130.4% (131.9% at 31 December 2022)
1
.
Client deposits and notes are key sources of funding and the majority (61.4% as at 31 December 2023) of our
deposits come from a stable retail customer base linked to our strong retail franchise. The Bank uses LCR as a
liquidity risk management tool in accordance with the international standard, implying run-off rates based on
deposit type and concentration to properly account for potential deposit run scenario. The LCR outflow rates
imposed by the NBG are more stringent than those in international standards, corresponding to the severe
stress. At 31 December 2023, 92.0% of the Groups client deposits and notes respectively had contractual
maturities of one year or less (90.3% at 31 December 2022), of which 64.6% and were payable on demand
(66.8% at 31 December 2022).
As of the same dates, the ratio of net loans to client deposits and notes was 98.6% and 92.3% respectively, and
the ratio of net loans to client deposits and notes and DFIs was 89.3% and 83.8% respectively.
The Bank has strong support from the international financial institutions (IFIs) and private asset/fund
managers. The Bank signed a number of new local and foreign currency long-term borrowings 2023 –
approximately US$ 115.1 million in total, part of which was drawn down during 2023. At 31 December 2023 the
Bank had EUR 50 million undrawn long-term facilities from DFIs with maturity of up to 7 years, as well as a
strong pipeline to secure resources needed for the next 12 months.
Capital risk
Capital risk is the risk of failure to deliver on business objectives, or to meet regulatory requirements or market expectations, due to
insufficient capital.
Key drivers and
developments
Bank of Georgia is subject to the NBG’s capital adequacy regulation, based on Basel III guidelines with regulatory
discretion applied by the NBG. Current capital requirements include Pillar 1 requirements, combined buffer
(systemic, countercyclical and conservation buffers) and Pillar 2 buffers (concentration, General Risk Assessment
Programme (GRAPE), CICR, and stress-test buffers). In January 2023, the NBG transitioned to IFRS-based
accounting and introduced a new Pillar 2 buffer, Credit Risk Adjustment (CRA), to account for the difference
between the NBG- and IFRS-based provision levels (higher in the former case). Fully loaded capital adequacy
requirements were introduced in March 2023. In the same month, the FSC at the NBG set the cycle-neutral
countercyclical capital buffer (base rate) at 1%. Banks are required to accumulate neutral countercyclical capital
buffer according to the following schedule: 0.25% by March 15, 2024; 0.5% by March 15, 2025; 0.75% by March 15,
2026; 1% by March 15, 2027.
The Bank maintains capital adequacy ratios, well above the minimum regulatory requirements.
Ratios
31 December
2023
Buffer
above min
requirement
Minimum
Requirement
Common Equity Tier 1 18.2% 3.7% 14.5%
Tier 1 20.0% 3.3% 16.7%
Total capital adequacy 22.1% 2.5% 19.6%
Mitigation Governance: The ALM unit executes daily capital risk management decision making, while the CFRM establishes
the capital risk management framework and challenges its effective implementation. The Bank’s capital position
and capital planning is continuously monitored by the Supervisory Board to ensure prudent management and
timely actions when necessary.
1. In January 2023 the NBG transitioned to IFRS-based accounting. The methodology of calculation of LCR and NSFR ratios was changed. Ratios given for 31 December 2022
are not IFRS-based.
156
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Mitigation
continued
Risk appetite: The Bank has capital risk appetite presented as different types of Bank-level limits and approved
by the ALCO and the Supervisory Board. In the process of limit setting the following aspects are considered:
expectations regarding regulatory requirements for capital adequacy;
existing capital levels and medium-term strategic plans that might potentially impact capital adequacy;
capital distribution policy;
Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment Process (ICAAP) results;
enterprise-wide risk appetite and business strategy; and
recovery plan.
The risk profile relative to risk appetite is monitored and reported monthly to the Bank’s Executive Management
(ALCO) and quarterly to the Supervisory Board.
Capital management: The Bank maintains an actively managed, robust capital base to cover the risks inherent to
its business. Capital risk management is underpinned by a capital management policy outlining key principles of
capital management, monitoring and control, defining roles and responsibilities of the three lines of defence, and
defining capital mitigation plans in line with the risk appetite framework.
The Bank’s ICAAP is approved by the Supervisory Board. Its main aim is to ensure the Bank maintains sufficient
capital levels to cover material risks to capital from both a normative (supervisory) and economic (internal)
perspective. The Bank conducts an internal assessment of material risks annually to evaluate the amount, type,
and distribution of capital necessary to cover these risks.
The Bank actively monitors early-warning indicators as part of the regulatory recovery plan, designed to identify
emerging capital concerns at an early stage so mitigating actions can be taken in a timely manner. The Bank
sets internal capital management buffers above regulatory requirements, both at ALCO and Supervisory Board
levels.
Capital stress testing: Capital stress testing plays a vital role in the Bank’s risk management processes by
allowing the examination of severe but plausible stress scenarios and their impact on the capital position. The
results of capital stress test analyses are used to inform various aspects of the Bank’s risk management and
capital planning processes. Specifically, these outcomes are considered in the following areas:
Capital planning: The findings from stress testing help determine the appropriate level of capital that needs
to be maintained to withstand adverse events and meet regulatory requirements.
Risk appetite statements: By incorporating the results of stress tests, the risk appetite statements ensure the
Bank sets appropriate boundaries and limits for managing capital-related risks.
Capital management buffer: Capital stress test analyses assist in defining the capital management buffer.
Planning and forecasting: The Bank updates capital forecasts twice a month, based on updated business
expectations, portfolio quality forecasts, market conditions, the latest trends and anticipated changes in the
Bank’s medium-term strategy. The Groups capital distribution plans are discussed with and approved by the
ALCO and are continuously monitored and approved by the Board of Directors. The ALM unit is responsible for
initiating and coordinating capital distribution plans and operations on capital elements, such as attraction
of capital instruments. It prepares various scenarios, assesses impact on planned capital and presents to the
ALCO/Board of Directors.
Market risk
Market risk is the risk of financial loss due to fluctuations in fair value or future cash flows of financial instruments due to changes in
market variables.
It arises from mismatches of maturity, currency or interest rates between assets and liabilities, all of which are exposed to market
fluctuations.
Key drivers and
developments
The volatility of GEL may adversely affect the Bank’s financial position. The Bank’s currency risk is calculated as
an aggregate of open positions and limited by the NBG to 20% of regulatory capital.
The Bank has exposure to interest rate risk due to lending at fixed and floating interest rates in amounts and
for periods that differ from those of term borrowings. Interest margins on assets and liabilities having different
maturities may increase or decrease as a result of changes in market interest rates.
Capital risk continued
157
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigation Governance: The governance of market risk management at the Bank is overseen by the ALCO and the
Supervisory Board, which approves the Bank-level market risk appetite and ensures its implementation
throughout the organisation. The Bank’s market risk governance follows a three-lines-of-defence structure to
set a clear division of responsibilities and an independent risk control process. The responsibility for identifying,
measuring, monitoring and controlling market risk lies with the Bank’s respective business units. The CFRM unit
serves as the second line of defence and is responsible for developing and maintaining policies, standards and
guidelines for market risk management, and setting the risk appetite. Furthermore, the CFRM is responsible for
conducting risk profile reviews and communicating results to the ALCO.
Risk appetite: The Bank has currency exchange and interest rate risk appetite presented as different types of
limits approved by the ALCO and the Supervisory Board. In the process of limit setting, the following aspects are
considered:
exchange rate volatility dynamics;
availability of currency instruments on the market;
existing and expected levels of capital;
historical volatility of interest rates;
current interest rate risk profile and medium-term strategic plans that may affect the risk profile; and
business strategy and enterprise-wide risk appetite.
The risk profile relative to risk appetite is monitored and reported monthly to the Bank’s Executive Management
and quarterly to the Supervisory Board.
Market risk management: The general principles of the Bank’s market risk management policy are set by the
ALCO. The ALCO sets limits on market risk exposures by currencies and closely monitors compliance with the
Bank’s risk appetite framework. Exposures and risk metrics are regularly tested for various plausible scenarios.
The Bank’s currency risk is calculated as an aggregate of open positions and is controlled by daily monitoring of
open currency positions and the value-at-risk (VAR) historical simulation method based on 400-business-day
statistical data. In addition, open positions in all currencies except for Lari are limited to a maximum of 1% of the
Bank’s total regulatory capital as defined by the NBG. The open currency position is also limited by the ALCO to
an annual VAR limit of GEL 50 million with a 98.0% tolerance threshold.
To minimise interest rate risk, the Bank monitors its interest rate (re-pricing) gap and maintains an interest
rate margin (net interest income (NII) before impairment of interest-earning assets divided by average interest-
earning assets) sufficient to cover operational expenses and risk premium.
Within limits approved by the Bank’s Supervisory Board, the ALCO approves ranges of interest rates for
different maturities at which the Bank may place assets and attract liabilities. As per a regulatory requirement,
the Bank assesses the impact of interest rate shock scenarios on economic value of equity (EVE) and NII. The
Bank’s EVE sensitivity with respect to Tier 1 capital remains comfortably below the maximum regulatory limit.
At 31 December 2023, the Bank’s EVE ratio stood at 7.6%, below the maximum limit of 15.0%. EVE and NII
sensitivities are further limited by the Supervisory Board risk appetite. In addition, the ALCO sets limits on
EVE and NII ratios by currency with respect to CET1 capital and monitors those monthly. NIM sensitivity is also
analysed by currency and is limited by the Supervisory Board and ALCO levels. The Bank’s interest rate risk
measurement practices were reviewed by an independent consultant as part of the NBG initiated assessment of
the banking sector and were rated as in line with international standards.
In the wake of upward trends in market interest rates, the Bank actively performs various stress tests and
scenario analyses to assess the potential impacts of interest rate shocks on portfolio quality and profitability.
The Bank reviews prior history of early repayments by calculating the weighted average effective rate of early
repayments across each credit product individually, applying the historical rates to the outstanding carrying
amount of each loan product as of the reporting date, and then multiplying the product by its weighted average
effective annual interest rate. This allows the Bank to calculate the expected amount of unforeseen losses in the
case of early repayments.
Market risk continued
158
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Regulatory and legal risk
Regulatory and legal risk is the risk of financial loss, regulatory censure, criminal or civil enforcement action or damage to the Groups
reputation as a result of failure to identify, assess, correctly interpret, comply with or manage regulatory and/or legal requirements.
Key drivers and
developments
The Group is increasingly subject to legal and regulatory requirements, and the competitive landscape in which
we operate may change as a result – the extent and impact of which may not be fully predicted.
Since the Group is listed on the London Stock Exchange’s Main Market for listed securities, it is subject to the UK
Financial Conduct Authority’s regulations and listing rules. The Groups core entity, JSC Bank of Georgia, is also
subject to the laws of Georgia and regulatory oversight of the NBG. Furthermore, Group companies are subject
to relevant laws and regulations in Georgia, and the banking subsidiary in Belarus, BNB, is subject to the laws of
Belarus and regulatory oversight of the NBRB.
Mitigation Governance: The Compliance department serves as a second line of defence and reports directly to the CRO. It is
responsible for establishing the compliance policy, methodologies and minimum standards for the entire Group,
and plays a critical role in instructing, advising, and challenging the first line of defence in managing compliance
risks. It coordinates identification, assessment, documentation, reporting and mitigation of compliance
risks associated with the Bank’s processes and products. The department is focused on promoting a strong
compliance risk culture through trainings and internal communication.
The Legal department reports directly to the Chief Legal Officer. Its principal aim is to ensure the Group’s
activities conform to applicable legislation and that possible losses from the materialisation of legal risks
are minimised. The Legal department is responsible for the application and development of mechanisms for
identifying legal risks in the Group’s activities in a timely manner, planning and implementing all necessary
actions to mitigate identified legal risks.
Compliance risk management framework: The Group maintains compliance policies and procedures enabling the
integration of compliance risk management principles across operations in line with relevant regulations. These
policies set the principles and standards for managing compliance risk across the Group and define key roles and
responsibilities of an independent compliance function. Our compliance risk management framework and policies
are subject to review by the Internal Audit function. Adherence to the policies is mandatory for all employees and,
to increase awareness, the Bank runs a mandatory compliance training programme. Training is easily accessed
online and assigned to each person according to their role. The compliance programme is integrated with our HR
management system and each manager has daily access to their team’s compliance training status. Reminders
are sent regularly to employees who do not complete training in a timely manner. Additionally, relevant process
owners receive quarterly Bank-wide reports and, when needed, escalate issues accordingly.
Monitoring and reporting: The Group places significant importance on measuring and managing compliance and
legal risk. This is achieved through ongoing assessment and reporting to the Audit and Risk Committees and the
Board, enabling consistent monitoring and measurement of adherence to laws and regulations. Furthermore,
compliance and legal risk management are integrated into the Groups strategic planning cycle, ensuring a
comprehensive approach to managing these risks across the organisation.
Regulatory change management: In line with our integrated control framework, we carefully evaluate the
impact of legislative and regulatory changes during our formal risk identification and assessment processes. Our
legislative and regulatory change management system is designed such that changes in laws and regulations
are proactively identified by the Legal and Compliance departments. In addition, we maintain a standardised
process to design and implement appropriate changes by generating workflows, assignments, tasks, and
automated follow-ups.
As part of the regulatory change management process we engage in constructive dialogue with legislative and
regulatory bodies where possible, and seek external advice on potential changes in legislation. We have a formal
link and a coordinated communication process with the NBG. Significant regulatory and legal changes as well as
material regulatory inspections are regularly discussed with the Groups Joint Audit and Risk Committee.
Related party transactions monitoring: The Group ensures related party transactions are identified, assessed
and monitored in line with the requirements of the NBG. The Board receives reports on transactions annually,
while results are communicated to the CRO on a monthly basis.
159
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Conduct risk
Conduct risk is the risk that the conduct of the Group and its employees towards customers will lead to poor or unfair customer
outcomes or adversely affect market integrity, damaging the Group’s reputation and competitive position.
Key drivers and
developments
Conduct risks can impact our customers directly or indirectly and could arise from a number of areas:
insufficient business and strategic planning that does not consider customer needs;
ineffective development, management and monitoring of products, their distribution (including the sales
process, fair value assessment) and post-sales service, including the management of customers in financial
difficulties;
unclear, unfair or untimely customer communications; and
ineffective management and resolution of customers’ complaints or claims.
Mitigation Governance: The Bank assigns various departments and divisions the responsibility for managing, mitigating and
eliminating conduct risk throughout the Bank’s interactions with clients and stakeholders. Collaboration between
the Compliance, Human Capital Management, and Legal functions is essential in establishing a cohesive
conduct risk management framework. These departments work together to support business lines and other
departments in the following ways:
Developing policies and procedures that promote responsible conduct and compliance with applicable laws
and regulations.
Fostering a strong culture of ethics and integrity within the organisation by conducting employee training and
promoting a values-based culture that prioritises responsible behaviour towards clients and stakeholders.
Establishing controls and processes to monitor and manage conduct-related risks, ensuring adequate
measures are in place to prevent misconduct and enhance operational resilience.
Treating customers fairly: Our Code of Conduct and Ethics and the Customer Protection Standard cover all
stages of the product and services lifecycle. They include requirements related to transparent product offerings
and clear and accurate communications to enable customers to make informed decisions. The Customer Rights
Protection unit serves as a second line of defence ensuring the Bank’s processes are compliant with applicable
laws and regulations and in line with internal policies and procedures.
We disclose all features and terms and conditions for our products and services so our customers can make
informed decisions. The Legal function serves as a second line of defence and reviews the Bank’s marketing
communications as well as the compliance of products and services from a legal and regulatory perspective.
Customer claims management: We have a Customer Claims Management procedure to effectively handle
customer complaints and concerns. The Customer Claims Management and Support Centre function reviews
and manages all incoming claims. Claims related to the Code of Conduct and Ethics violations are reviewed by
the Compliance Committee to ensure they are properly handled and remediation plans are in place. Furthermore,
the Compliance department reviews all customer complaints. Recurring claims potentially indicating a systemic
issue and reports received through the whistleblowing platform are investigated and reported quarterly to the
Joint Audit and Risk Committee.
Financial crime risk
Financial crime risk is the risk of knowingly or unknowingly facilitating illegal activity, including money laundering, fraud, bribery and
corruption, tax evasion, sanctions evasion, the financing of terrorism and proliferation, through the Group.
Key drivers and
developments
Financial crime risks continue to evolve globally and the Group faces stringent regulatory and supervisory
requirements to manage these risks. Failure to comply may lead to enforcement action by the regulator, leading
to financial loss and/or damage to the Group’s reputation.
The main sources of financial crime risk are:
an inherent risk related to providing products and services to customers that may expose the Group to
financial crime;
inadequate controls to detect risk and/or reduce the residual impact and likelihood of financial crime risk; and
business activities with an unacceptable level of risk exposure that may not be adequately managed.
Globally, increased volume and speed of transactions together with increasing digital transformation in financial
services are fuelling the following trends in financial crime risk management:
As transactions are being executed more quickly, the Group needs to use more advanced detection techniques
and data to mitigate risks.
The number of identity frauds, account takeovers and fabricated customer accounts is expected to rise
globally. The Group will need to combine the breadth of available information with more advanced data
analytics and machine learning capabilities to mitigate the risk.
Diagnosis products (new and non-traditional) for money laundering. Criminals are more likely to shift their
attention to non-traditional products, including trade finance, securities and transaction laundering, and
crypto-currencies – and the Group will need to implement more advanced technological solutions and
comprehensive policies to prevent and detect money laundering.
160
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Financial crime risk continued
Key drivers and
developments
continued
The financial crime risks related to the use of innovative fintech are not yet fully understood, while the
changing sanctions and regulatory landscape presents execution challenges.
Recent events around the Russia-Ukraine war have raised sanctions compliance risks.
Mitigation Governance: Financial crime risk governance follows a three-lines-of-defence structure to set a clear division of
responsibilities and an independent risk control challenge process. The responsibility for identifying, measuring,
monitoring, and controlling financial crime risk lies with the respective business units within the Group that may
be exposed to the risk of financial crime, sanctions evasion, money laundering and financing of terrorism in the
course of their business activities. The AML and Sanction Compliance department, under the CRO, serves as
the second line of defence and is responsible for developing and maintaining policies, standards, guidelines and
internal compliance systems – monitoring the risks of sanctions evasion, money laundering and financing of
terrorism within the Group and overseeing the processes of risk identification, assessment, and management.
Additionally, an AML/Sanction Compliance Committee has been created for continuous control and oversight of
money laundering, terrorism financing and sanction evasion risks.
The Tax Reporting and Tax Risks Management unit, under the CFO, focuses on effective assessment and
management of tax risks and the Bank’s relationship with the tax authorities, provides practical advice and
ensures tax compliance across the Group.
Monitoring and reporting: The Group’s financial crime risk management programme aims to ensure all business
units, support functions and subsidiaries consider the impact of their activities on the risk profile and take
effective measures to ensure alignment with the Group’s risk-taking approach for financial crime. We aim
to prevent harm to customers and the economy caused by criminals and terrorists, and actively monitor our
exposure to financial crime risks, reporting all issues in a timely and proactive manner.
Continuous risk management and regular reporting to the Risk Committee and the Board facilitate the
recognition and communication of potential financial crime risks. The review and assessment of both
quantitative and qualitative dashboards are conducted to gauge whether the level of financial crime risk is
managed effectively. Financial crime risks are on the regular agenda of the Risk and Audit Committees joint
sessions.
Anti-money laundering: We have an AML/counter-terrorist financing (CTF) framework that reflects a risk-based
approach towards money laundering/financial terrorism (ML/FT) risks. The framework complies with local
legislation, international standards (Financial Action Task Force recommendations) and international financial
sanctions programmes.
To strengthen our ability to detect and prevent financial crime, we continue to enhance our ML/FT risk
management function. We have updated policies and procedures to make our ML/FT risk management activities
more robust, and we have invested significant resources to improve our ML/FT risk management capabilities
– including implementing best practice screening and filtering tools supported by advanced analytics and
transaction monitoring solutions, as well as reinforcing the staff dedicated to the AML function.
Bribery and corruption: Bribery and corruption risks are integral components of our financial crime framework
and are encompassed within the client and third-party due diligence processes as well as the monitoring
measures. We are committed to preventing bribery and corruption by implementing appropriate policies,
processes and effective controls. We expect all our employees to adhere to our Code of Conduct and Ethics. The
Group has zero tolerance towards non-compliance with anti-bribery and anti-corruption policies and procedures.
All employees receive annual mandatory training on anti-bribery and anti-corruption policies and procedures,
including information on how to use the Bank’s anonymous whistleblowing channel
Sanctions compliance: The Group has a robust sanctions compliance policy. It requires strict adherence to the
relevant prohibitions and restrictions provided in the US, UK, EU and other relevant sanctions programmes.
Russia and Belarus were designated by the Group as high-risk jurisdictions, meaning the Group has limited risk
appetite in relation to customers from and transactions related to these countries. In particular customers
from Russia and Belarus are subject to enhanced due diligence measures, while transactions related to these
jurisdictions are subjected to enhanced sanctions screening and transaction monitoring. We have also enhanced
our cooperation with the regulator and other relevant government authorities and partner financial institutions
in Georgia to monitor and mitigate sanctions-related risks at both sector and country levels.
Due diligence: The Group continues to improve customer due diligence practices and transaction monitoring
capabilities, including monitoring supported by risk-based scenarios, handling alerts and reporting suspicious
activities where required. Our Know Your Customer (KYC) procedures for customer screening and transaction
monitoring ensure compliance with international financial and economic sanctions regulations as well as
procedures for verifying customer identity to protect the Group from money laundering and terrorism financing.
High-risk clients – including politically exposed persons and virtual asset service providers, those subject to
adverse media coverage or performing unusual or crypto-currency-related transactions, or those living and
working in countries or sectors with an inherently higher risk of financial crime – undergo additional enhanced
due diligence. To manage risks associated with crypto-currency we have restricted international transactions
related to virtual assets or involving virtual asset service providers. The Group has zero tolerance towards
Russian and Belarusian clients who are involved in crypto-currency-related activities.
161
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigation
continued
Fraud risk: To mitigate fraud risk we have implemented the following measures:
Know Your Employee procedures including screening requirements at recruitment, employment and departure
stages of employment, providing a clear understanding of an employee’s background and actual or potential
conflicts of interest.
Mandatory training for all new employees to increase awareness regarding fraud risk.
Communication channels to inform our customers about fraud risk.
Information security and data protection risks
Information security risk is the risk of loss of confidentiality, integrity, or availability of information, data, or information systems, and
reflects the potential adverse impacts to operations.
Data protection risk is the risk presented by personal data processing – such as accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alteration,
unauthorised disclosure of, or access to, personal data stored or otherwise processed – which may result in financial loss, reputational
damage, or other significant economic or social adverse impacts.
Key drivers and
developments
Information security risk is a top risk for organisations globally – and especially those in financial services.
The Bank remains subject to attempts to compromise its information security. The external threat profile is
continuously changing, and we expect threats to increase, including potential state-sponsored cyber attacks.
Malicious actors focus on the following events:
zero-day attacks, which exploit a previously unknown vulnerability;
brand impersonation attacks, which use sophisticated techniques;
cases where we do not have direct control over the cybersecurity of the systems targeted (such as those of
our customers and third-party service providers), limiting our ability to effectively defend against certain
threats; and
failure by employees to adhere to our policies, procedures and technical controls.
On 1 January 2022, as a result of legislative amendments, the Bank was recognised as one of Georgia’s critical
information system subjects – which means the uninterrupted operation of its information system is essential
to the defence and/or economic security of the country, as well as to the maintenance of state authority and/or
public life. Current legislation imposed a considerable number of obligations on the Bank, leading to the need for
minor amendments to existing procedural documents and established practices.
Mitigation Governance: Information security risk governance follows a three-lines-of-defence structure to set a clear
division of responsibilities as well as an independent risk control challenge process. The Information Security
department represents the first line of defence, following internal policies and procedures regarding information
security, and performing routine risk assessments, vulnerability scans and penetration tests to identify potential
vulnerabilities within our systems and infrastructure. In this manner, the Information Security department
prevents unauthorised access attempts and maintains real-time monitoring to promptly detect and respond to
any potential security incidents.
The Information Security Compliance and Risk Management unit serves as a second line of defence under CRO.
It conducts regular risk assessments associated with third parties and conducts regular monitoring and reporting
of identified risks to the relevant parties. The unit provides oversight, guidance, and support to the Groups
business units, ensuring information security risks are identified, assessed and managed effectively, and monitors
compliance with internal policies and external regulations.
Risk appetite: Information security risk is measured against predefined risk appetite metrics and thresholds.
By establishing risk appetite, we aim to minimise our exposure to data and security breaches to achieve our
main strategic objectives: (i) delivering excellent customer experience; and (ii) maintaining the Groups financial
strength.
The risk profile relative to risk appetite is monitored and reported monthly to Executive Management and
quarterly to the Supervisory Board.
Monitoring and reporting: We use key risk indicators and metrics to track the effectiveness of our information
security programme. Regular analysis of these metrics allows us to identify trends, areas for improvement and
potential risks requiring additional attention.
We provide monthly reports on information security risks and incidents to Executive Management and quarterly
to the Board of Directors. These reports offer a comprehensive overview of the Bank’s security, significant
incidents, risk mitigation efforts and the effectiveness of controls.
The Bank’s Internal Audit function, on a risk-based approach, provides assurance on the adequacy and
effectiveness of our risk management, internal controls and systems. Information security is on the Risk
Committees regular agenda, and we engage external auditors to conduct cybersecurity audits.
Financial crime risk continued
162
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Information security and data protection risks continued
Mitigation
continued
The following controls enable us to mitigate information security and data protection risks:
Zero-day attacks: We regularly monitor zero-day vulnerability announcements that may affect our systems. If
such a vulnerability is detected, the designated team ensures it is attended to as soon as possible. Moreover,
we employ a ‘defence in depth’ approach, meaning we have multiple complementary security layers. If one
mechanism fails, another will be activated immediately to prevent an attack imposing damage.
Customer-targeted phishing: Malicious actors may carry out successful customer-targeted phishing attacks
through fake websites, social networks, emails and other channels. We focus on improving our information
security controls to detect unauthorised access to customers’ accounts, and run awareness-raising campaigns to
help customers and the wider public recognise phishing and respond appropriately.
Supply chain cyber-attack: Malicious actors may gain unauthorised access to our third-party service providers
systems. The Bank focuses on mitigating this risk by:
Integrating information security and data protection due diligence in the selection process to determine the
level of risk posed by a potential third-party service provider.
Ensuring necessary contractual and technical controls are implemented to mitigate identified risks prior to
engaging with third-party service providers.
Monitoring existing third-party service providers at least annually to assess the fulfilment of agreed
information security and data protection requirements. The termination of a relationship is subject to exit
procedures to ensure the protection of the confidentiality, integrity and availability of the Bank’s information.
Failure by employees to adhere to our policies, procedures and technical controls: Employee training is one of the
key components of information security and data protection risk management across the Bank. We continuously
focus on equipping our employees with relevant knowledge and the right tools to prevent, identify, mitigate and
report incidents.
Annual training is mandatory for all employees and includes a tailored course on mitigating information security
risks while working remotely. We provide continuous, role-based data protection training to keep employees
aware of data protection risks and to explain their role in mitigation.
We initiate quarterly phishing campaigns to test our employees’ ability to detect such attacks and respond
appropriately. Periodically, we send awareness emails and share posts on current information security threats
through internal communication channels. Although there have been phishing attempts against employees, there
have been no major incidents.
Finally, we recognise that, regardless of our efforts to enhance information security controls Bank-wide, in
limited cases there may be a justified business need for controlled exceptions to existing policies, procedures and
technical controls. We have improved our approach to information security exception management, which allows
noted flexibility, a holistic view of overall risks resulting from the exceptions, and their proactive management.
Access management: We have role-based access control, contributing to the automation of employee
onboarding and existing employee rotation processes and enabling the restriction of network access based on
the roles of individual users – in line with the principle of least privilege, which the Bank follows. We also conduct
a semi-annual privileged user evaluation process. We monitor and update access rights on an annual basis in
each department.
The Bank does not allow the granting of privileged access rights to third parties without a valid and justified
business need. Even in such cases third parties with privileged access rights are required to use multi-factor
authentication, and the Bank manages and monitors their activities through a privileged access management
solution.
Information security incident response: To successfully mitigate the above-mentioned key risks we have further
aligned our incident response plan with the industry standard and accepted best practices as provided by the
National Institute of Standards and Technology in its Computer Security Incident Handling Guide. We also
conduct continuous breach and attack simulations, allowing us to see our network through the eyes of malicious
actors, verify our defences and security configuration, and continuously monitor and improve our defences. We
have enhanced our capabilities by implementing a vandal-protected backup storage. As a result, neither external
nor malicious internal threat actors can harm the Bank’s core database backup.
We are also in the process of refining our information security incident response plans. We use additional metrics
– such as mean time to detect, mean time to respond and false positive ratio – to better track the performance
of our Security Operations Centre. These metrics are tracked with respect to the entire Security Operations
Centre and each of its team members.
Data protection policies: We maintain a comprehensive set of data privacy policies and standards to ensure we
operate in compliance with applicable privacy regulations and state-of-the-art principles. These policies and
procedures outline privacy principles and standards we observe while processing personal data, and are:
regularly revised to ensure they reflect current legal, regulatory, best practice and internal policy requirements;
annually reviewed and approved by relevant governance bodies; and
aligned with recognised industry standards.
163
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigation
continued
Governance: Effective implementation of the privacy strategy requires a strong organisational structure. We
have the Data Protection Officer (DPO), whose responsibilities include but are not limited to:
providing recommendations to the Bank’s employees to ensure compliance with the requirements of
applicable legislation;
researching data processing procedures within the Bank and evaluating their compliance with applicable
legislation;
advising and assisting business units on privacy matters, particularly when implementing a new process or
product;
liaising with the supervisory authority regarding privacy matters; and
drafting and maintaining internal policies and procedures as well as awareness programmes on privacy
matters.
Privacy matters are considered in all new processes and projects. We are increasingly seeing employees
proactively engaging the DPO and undertaking data privacy impact assessments, which ensure our projects
comply with data protection legislation when they go live.
Transparency: Transparency is a core element of our privacy programme. Customers are informed in simple
language about our privacy practices, including how we collect, use, disclose, transfer and protect their personal
information. Our privacy commitments are reflected in our Privacy Statement.
Reporting: The DPO reports to the Audit Committee at least twice a year on the status of the Bank’s privacy
strategy implementation. As a result, the Bank’s Executive Management and the Supervisory Board remain up to
date on privacy matters at all times
Operational risk
Operational risk is the risk of financial and non-financial loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems,
or from external events.
Operational risk may result in losses emerging from the following events, among others:
internal and external fraud;
business disruption and system failures;
employment practices;
clients, products and business practices;
damage to physical assets and infrastructure; and
execution, delivery and process management.
Key drivers and
developments
Deficiencies or ineffectiveness in operational risk management may result in inaccurate financial, regulatory or
risk reporting, which may have an adverse effect on the accurate and timely visibility of the Group’s risk profile
for our key stakeholders. The trends driving the need to transform risk management, as well as the risks arising
from the above-mentioned events, stem from multiple sources:
Customer expectations of banking products and services will change with the emergence of new technologies
and service models, forcing banks to rethink their business models and deal with new operational risks.
Accelerating digitalisation and automation will make IT and operational resilience more sophisticated. The
speed of change and the need to innovate has spurred the introduction of technologies whose deployment
needs careful management.
Mitigation Governance: Responsibility for the management of operational risks is determined by the ‘three-lines-of-defence
model. The first line of defence is represented by business units responsible for identification and assessment
of operational risks and establishing appropriate controls to mitigate them. The Operational Risk department
is a second line of defence responsible for oversight and risk guidance within the Group. Third line of defence is
internal audit, independently assessing operational risk and events in business processes throughout the Group.
The Operational Risk Committee is the decision-making body overseeing operational risk profile and monitoring
operational risk management programme activities. The Committee reviews key items for risk taking decisions
and monitors the follow-ups of mitigation action plans.
Risk appetite: The Bank has established an operational risk appetite to effectively manage all operational risks.
It defines the level and categories of operational risk the Bank is willing to accept in order to achieve its strategic
objectives.
The risk profile relative to risk appetite is monitored and reported monthly to Executive Management and
quarterly to the Supervisory Board.
Information security and data protection risks continued
164
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Mitigation
continued
Operational risk framework: The Group has implemented policies and procedures and has established an
operational risk framework for anticipating, mitigating, controlling and communicating operational risks and
the overall effectiveness of the internal control environment across the Group. The Operational Risk department
develops and maintains a framework and comprehensive set of policies and standards reviewed and approved
by the relevant governance bodies to ensure they are aligned with recognised industry standards – such as Basel
and the European Banking Authority (EBA) – and made available to all relevant employees through internal
channels. The operational risk framework includes: the risk and control self-assessment (RCSA) programme; key
risk indicators; operational risk event analysis; the scenario analysis programme; risk monitoring and reporting;
business continuity management programme; risk awareness; and training programmes.
Risk and control self-assessment: The RCSA aims to identify and assess operational risks in relation to business
processes and products. Analysis of business processes identifies the impact of operational risk factors,
vulnerabilities and weaknesses in existing processes, and potential threats that might have materialised in the
form of financial or reputational impact for the Bank.
For the assessment of operational risks the Group applies an approach involving a detailed study and analysis
of existing business models, procedures and guidelines regulating business processes, including controls built in
at the system levels. The inherent and residual operational risks are assessed using the following parameters:
likelihood of events; quantitative impacts; and qualitative impacts.
Identified operational risks are classified, aggregated by business lines and business processes, and registered in
the operational risk management system. Identified control functions and existing risk mitigation tools are also
classified and registered in the operational risk management system.
Scenario analysis: The Group maintains a scenario analysis programme as a separate tool to identify, analyse
and measure a range of scenarios, including low probability and high severity events – some of which could result
in severe operational losses.
Scenario analysis involves workshop meetings attended by subject matter experts including senior management,
business management and senior operational risk staff, to develop and analyse the drivers and range of
consequences of potential events. Inputs to the scenario analysis include relevant internal and external loss data,
information from self-assessments, control monitoring framework, forward-looking metrics and root-cause
analyses.
RCSA and Scenario analysis assessment techniques are based on a Loss Distribution Approach (LDA), which
aims to evaluate the potential range of financial loss impact and the likelihood of loss distribution. LDA
calculates the expected loss amount and VAR using the ‘Monte Carlo simulation’ method.
Monitoring and reporting: The Operational Risk department regularly reviews and monitors the assessments
of operational risks. Reviews of risks affecting key business processes are conducted annually and findings are
submitted in the form of reports.
The Management Board and the Operational Risk Committee regularly review and monitor the actual
operational risk profile against the agreed levels of risk tolerance and risk appetite. The Operational Risk
Management Committee monitors the risk profile to ensure appropriate actions are taken regarding breaches of
risk appetite limits.
The department reports quarterly to the Risk Committee. The risk report includes information about the current
risk profile, risk appetite limits and breaches, together with risk-taking activities and mitigation plans.
We have designed internal controls that ensure the Group has efficient and effective operations, safeguards
its assets, produces reliable financial reports and complies with applicable laws and regulations. The Group
continuously develops the control environment in business processes – including through segregation of duties,
preventive tools integrated in the systems, system of limitation and powers, restriction of user’s rights, risk
insurance, among many others.
Business resilience and continuity: The Group has established a business continuity programme appropriate for
the nature, size and complexity of our operations. The programme considers different scenarios to which the
Group may be susceptible, including system and technology failures.
The Group performs business impact analyses and risk assessment, identifying business processes that are
critically important for the banking activity, identification of threats to business activities and risk assessment
of potential financial and reputational impacts related to significant threats.
The Group identify and reassess critical business operations, cyclically or as needed, key internal and external
dependencies, and appropriate resilience levels. The identified plausible disruptive scenarios are assessed for
their financial, operational and reputational impact, and the resulting risk assessment is the foundation for
recovery objectives and measures – and ultimately for continuity and recovery plans.
The Group has established business continuity and disaster recovery plans for each critical business process,
which is a combination of procedures and arrangements aimed at ensuring retention or prompt resumption of
continuation of the Bank’s critical business processes.
The Group continuously performs impact analyses and testing of business continuity plans, training and
awareness programmes, and communication and crisis management programmes.
Operational risk continued
165
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigation
continued
Operational risk analysis: The Group has an operational risk event and loss data management process to identify
and record the operational risk of financial and non-financial events. Internal operational loss data provides
significant information for assessing the Bank’s exposure to operational risk and the effectiveness of internal
controls. Analysis of loss events can provide insight into the causes of large losses and whether control failures
are isolated or systematic.
The Bank applies the method of operational risk events and loss database analysis. The Bank maintains
comprehensive operational risk event data on all material events experienced by the Bank.
Awareness programmes: We conduct awareness campaigns and mandatory training to help employees identify
existing and potential risks. The Groups fraud awareness programme remains a key component of its fraud
control environment, and awareness of fraud risk is supported by mandatory training for all colleagues.
Human capital risk
Human capital risk is the risk of failure to deliver on the Group’s strategic objectives, operational disruption, financial loss and/or
reputational damage as a result of ineffective human capital management.
We are exposed to the following key risks:
failure to recruit, develop and retain employees, including failure to identify a talent pipeline and put the right
people in the right roles;
ineffective leadership, weak performance, employee disengagement and detachment resulting in high
turnover;
inappropriate and unfair remuneration policies;
failure to meet all employee-related legal and regulatory requirements; and
failure to effectively design people processes that ensure equal opportunity and diversity across the Group.
Key drivers and
developments
Employees are one of the key enablers of the success of our business. To be able to learn and innovate quickly,
organisations globally have focused on building rigorous talent management capabilities, including building a
data analytics capability to hire, develop, and retain the best employees and match the right people to the right
roles. Demographic changes have also increased the need to adapt approaches and employee experiences to be
an attractive employer for young talent.
Given our strategic focus on digital capabilities and data/AI-based decision-making, the recruitment and
retention of qualified IT and data science professionals is one of our priorities. It remains challenging to recruit
top talent in these areas due to the scarcity of highly qualified candidates on the local market and the availability
of jobs both locally and globally. Georgia has a relatively limited talent pool which, while developing, may not keep
up with the skills required in a digital and fast-moving organisation.
Mitigation Governance: Human capital risk is identified, assessed, and managed by the Bank’s Human Capital Management
function. It establishes policies, procedures, and frameworks to guide risk management efforts and ensures
compliance with relevant laws and regulations. It also monitors and reports on human capital risks to Executive
Management and the Board.
Risk appetite: We have defined Bank-level human capital risk appetite, which is presented in a form of different
types of limits and is approved by the Supervisory Board. Our human capital risk appetite considers various
factors, including business goals, culture, and workforce dynamics. The risk profile relative to risk appetite is
monitored and reported monthly to Executive Management and quarterly to the Supervisory Board.
Monitoring and reporting: We monitor human capital risk through a series of quantitative and qualitative
indicators, including ongoing deep interviews with individual employees, Bank and team/division level eNPS,
engagement scores, internal mobility, retention, employee turnover measures. We discuss and design action
plans based on the results of different surveys and measures.
Key people risk metrics are reported quarterly to the Risk Committee and monthly to Executive Management.
Also, all violations of ethical principles and standards related to the Code of Conduct and Ethics and Standards
of Professional Conduct for Commercial Banks are reported quarterly to the Audit Committee.
Mitigation: The Group takes the following mitigating actions with respect to human capital risk:
We attract young talent by participating in job fairs and running extensive internships and student
development programmes. We actively partner with leading Georgian business schools and universities to
recruit top talent in different fields. We have a student development programme, Leaderator, which gives
talented undergraduates an opportunity to have a 360° view of the Bank in action, work on real projects, and
receive coaching and support from the Bank’s executives and middle managers. The programme also helps
us attract IT, digital and data science and analytics students as it guarantees high qualification and fast
professional growth within one of the best tech teams in Georgia.
We offer our employees learning and personal development opportunities to enhance their competencies and
skills throughout their careers, and support their career progression. Internal mobility remains a priority in our
talent strategy to ensure having the right person in the right position at any given time. Our Job Architecture,
named as Levelling, provides a clear map of positions within the company and aligns employees accordingly.
It is the basis of internal mobility of our employees – promotions and lateral moves are guided by levelling
factors ensuring recruitment of correct candidates in accordance with required roles and competencies.
Operational risk continued
166
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Mitigation
continued
We develop our leadership pool through various programmes and activities, including through Leadership
Coaching for senior managers in individual and group format, New Managers’ programme – a special
introductory course for employees recently appointed to managerial positions and team leads. We also ensure
professional and personal development of existing managers, conducting regular needs analysis and offering
designed leadership development programmes. Our development programmes are aligned with Performance
Management Process – setting and monitoring KPIs/KBOs, contributing to developing a feedback culture. In
2023, employees from non-managerial pool participated in this process as well. We leverage our leadership
development to mitigate risks associated with the departure or absence of well-qualified and experienced
individuals. Our succession planning process ensures necessary support of our talent pipeline for now and in
the future for key positions, including at the senior manager and executive levels.
We offer competitive remuneration and benefits packages and support work-life balance. We monitor
employee pay trends via labour market compensation surveys in the financial sector. Our remuneration
structure is based on employee performance reviews. Introducing yearly performance management system
via KPIs/KBOs at all levels, including non-managerial ones, enabled further transparency of performance-
based employee annual bonus schemes, and setting and managing clearer and properly aligned expectations.
We continue to fine-tune our job architecture and grading structures by further advancing the job levelling
project to ensure our remuneration system and practices are fair, clear and transparent for employees,
allowing them to plan their career moves and progression. We have forums and communication channels
enabling employee voices to be heard across the organisation, including a CEO vlog on Workplace – regular
live sessions with employees on current developments, Employee Voice meetings with the Board of Directors,
town hall meetings and agile quarterly business reviews (QBRs).
We ensure that HR policies and practices are developed and implemented to support our business activities
and are in line with Georgian legislation and relevant international standards. We regularly review our policies
and procedures to ensure that they reflect best practices, organisational changes, and legal requirements. You
can see some of our HR-related policies on www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com
We offer hybrid working arrangements, giving. We offer hybrid working arrangements, giving the majority of
back-office employees the flexibility to combine working from home with working from the office.
Model risk
Model risk is the risk of potential adverse consequences arising from decisions based on model results that may be incorrect due to the
use of inaccurate assumptions, inappropriate variables, weak algorithms and/or low-quality data.
Key drivers and
developments
As banking operations become more complex and digital, models are becoming more prominent in decision-
making. Increased adoption of statistical, machine-learning models and artificial intelligence (AI) helps us
improve decision-making and gain competitive intelligence. To sustain the benefits of model use in banking
operations it is crucial to have sound model risk assessment frameworks and validation practices in place.
The NBG’s regulation – Managing Risks for Data-based Statistical, Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning
Models – sets additional requirements for model development, validation, monitoring and application. Within the
scope of the regulation, all relevant new and existing models must be in line with the regulatory requirements.
Mitigation The Bank is actively enhancing the model risk management framework, which is continuously reviewed and
refined to adequately address key model risks. The Bank’s Model Risk Management (MRM) Policy defines:
The segregation of roles and responsibilities of those involved in the model development lifecycle, including
ownership of model development, independent oversight and approval.
Key controls with respect to data integrity, model development, validation, implementation, backtesting and
monitoring.
In 2023, as part of the Bank’s engagement with global management consulting company McKinsey & Company,
the MRM framework was revised and refined to align with best practices.
Governance: The Bank’s model risk and control structure is based on the ‘three-lines-of-defence’ approach.
Model Risk Owners in the first line are responsible for model approval and ongoing performance monitoring. The
Bank’s independent Risk function, in the second line, is responsible for validating new models and monitoring
their compliance with regulatory requirements by focusing on the soundness of the algorithms used, the model’s
predictive ability and complexity, sustainability, consistency with business objectives, assumptions, and data
quality.
Monitoring and reporting: The Bank maintains a structured model development lifecycle including recalibration.
All significant new models or material changes to existing significant models are validated by an independent
risk function and authorised by the Chief Risk Officer. Significant model-related issues are reported to the Bank’s
Supervisory Board, and the Bank’s Executive Management is aware of major model risks.
Further, to ensure effective model performance, the Bank has implemented automated processes for the
ongoing monitoring of model performance. Based on the significance of model risk, automated notifications are
generated on a model’s performance for relevant stakeholders cyclically (monthly, quarterly and ad hoc). Model
performance monitoring is carried out by model owners and supervised by model validators, enabling prompt
action to be taken in addressing any issues related to inadequate model performance and identifying and
rectifying control deficiencies or vulnerabilities.
Human capital risk continued
167
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigation
continued
Model risk mitigation: To manage this risk, the Bank employs the following strategies:
Refining or redeveloping models: When necessary, models are refined or redeveloped to account for changes in
market conditions, business assumptions, or processes. This ensures the models remain accurate and aligned
with the evolving landscape.
Adjustments to model outputs: Quantitative adjustments or those based on expert opinion may be applied
to the outputs generated by the models. These help address any known limitations or biases and improve the
accuracy of the results.
Process enhancements: The Bank may introduce enhancements to the processes in which model outputs are
used. By implementing additional controls, validation measures or complementary methodologies, the risk
levels associated with model outputs can be further limited.
By employing these mitigation measures the Bank aims to minimise the impact of model risk and ensure the
models used in its business activities provide reliable and accurate assessments and decisions.
Strategic risk
Strategic risk is the risk that the Group will be unable to execute its business strategy and create value for its stakeholders as a result
of poor decision-making, ineffective resource allocation, or a delayed or ineffective response to changes in the external environment.
Key drivers and
developments
The Group faces strategic risks due to changes in the legal, regulatory, macroeconomic and competitive
environments. The increased economic uncertainty, the emergence of global fintechs and competition in financial
services have changed stakeholder expectations, heightening the need for strategic and forward-looking risk
management.
Mitigation Strategic planning: The Group has a sound corporate governance framework and its strategy is approved by its
Board of Directors. Customer-centricity, people and culture, brand strength and data and AI-driven decision-
making are key enablers of the Groups sustainable value creation. The Group assesses and monitors strategic
risk implications in its day-to-day activities, ensuring they respond appropriately to internal and external factors.
The Group conducts an annual strategic planning process to review its performance against targets, discuss the
internal and external environment, and develop short- and medium-term strategic plans considering potential
financial and non-financial risks. This process is supported by risk appetite statements, a capital plan and a
recovery plan.
In 2024, the Group extended its investments into Armenia through the acquisition of Ameriabank. As we expand
our geographic footprint, we recognise that this introduces new emerging risks that require proactive monitoring
and mitigation. This investment remains exposed to various risks, encompassing political and economic
uncertainties, sanctions implications, foreign currency fluctuations, and regulatory challenges. These factors will
hold particular significance as we provide further disclosures in 2024, especially regarding our collaboration with
Ameriabank.
Monitoring: We conduct annual strategic review sessions involving executive and senior management.
Throughout the year, the performance against key strategic objectives as measured by KPIs is monitored and
assessed by the Executive Management quarterly. The Group takes corrective measures to mitigate risks arising
from significant variance. In addition, Executive Management holds monthly meetings to discuss the competitive
landscape and the Group’s competitive positions, including any changes versus prior periods, and any actions if
required. Key strategic areas and/or projects are periodically discussed in working groups comprising executive,
senior and middle management.
Periodic strategic challenge reviews: Our strategic objectives and/or decisions are regularly discussed with and
challenged by the Board of Directors, including during the Board’s annual strategy sessions.
Reputational risk
Reputational risk is the risk of damage to stakeholder trust and our brand image due to negative consequences arising from internal
actions or external events.
Key drivers and
developments
The Groups operations are subject to inherent reputational risk, with primary drivers identified as: failure of
internal execution; failure to manage cyber and phishing cases; and a difference between the Groups values and
public perceptions and/or opinion.
Mitigation Risk appetite: We acknowledge that reputational risk is an inherent aspect of our operating environment, with
public trust being a crucial consideration when determining the level of reputational risk the organisation is
willing to accept. We have defined Bank-level reputational risk appetite through a quantitative measure.
The risk profile relative to risk appetite is monitored and reported monthly to Executive Management and
quarterly to the Supervisory Board.
Mitigation: To mitigate potential reputational risks, effective systems and controls are in place to ensure high
levels of customer service and compliance. For each material risk identified at any level of the business, the risk is
measured, mitigated and monitored in accordance with our policies and procedures.
Model risk continued
168
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Mitigation
continued
To protect and maintain the strength of our brand the Bank’s marketing team monitors media coverage daily.
The Bank’s legal team ensures marketing communications are fully compliant with internal policies, and reviews
and confirms the compliance of products and services from a legal and regulatory perspective. The Bank
regularly tracks and measures customer satisfaction using both internal and independent external surveys, and
monitors its compliance with risk appetite limits, reporting to Executive Management monthly.
We also engage with our customers on information-security-related matters through multiple channels, including
our website, digital platforms and text messages. We regularly create and share content including articles,
interactive games and questionnaires through various media. We support and contribute to the development
of information security in Georgia by regularly participating in collaborative efforts with our financial industry
peers, law enforcement authorities, regulatory bodies and the Government, to share knowledge and prevent
negative impacts.
To prevent inaccurate or misleading reporting that could damage the Group’s reputation by losing trust of our
stakeholders, we have a well-documented reporting process with strong controls for fairness and transparency.
Oversight from internal and external audits, as well as the Board of Directors ensures our reporting is
trustworthy.
Climate-related risk
Climate-related risk is the risk of financial loss and/or damage to the Group’s reputation as a result of the accelerating transition to a
lower-carbon economy and/or the materialisation of actual physical damage as a result of acute or chronic weather events.
Among other things, transitional and physical risks may impact the performance and financial position of our customers and their
ability to repay loans.
Key drivers and
developments
Key stakeholders including investors and lenders are increasingly demanding more climate-related disclosures,
including climate risk assessment and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reporting. Since 1 January 2021 the
Group, as a premium-listed UK company, has been required to make disclosures in line with the Task Force on
Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) recommendations.
In 2021 Georgia launched its updated Nationally Determined Contribution, published its Fourth National
Communication under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (including updated
Greenhouse Gas Inventory), adopted its Climate Change Strategy (2030) and Action Plan (2021-2023),
and developed its National Energy and Climate Plan (2021-2030) and Long-Term Low Emission Strategy. In
2022 Georgia began to work on a climate change law that will regulate climate-related issues and distribute
responsibilities. These strategies and regulations and their implementation may drive changes across the
Georgian economy and increase the importance of climate change mitigation and adaptation measures for
different sectors.
We recognise climate change as an emerging risk and have integrated climate-related risks, both physical and
transitional, into the overall risk management framework and decision-making processes across the Bank.
Mitigation Governance: The Bank implements climate risk governance through the Environmental and Social Impact
Committee comprising executive and senior management. The Committee is responsible for monitoring the
Bank’s climate, environmental and social risks and impacts arising primarily as a result of our lending activities.
The Committee meets quarterly and reports to the Supervisory Board twice a year.
The Environmental and Climate Risk Management department is a risk function that is part of the Bank’s second
line of defence. It reports progress and performance in the area of environmental, social, and climate-related risk
management to the Environmental and Social Impact Committee, and is responsible for:
developing policies and procedures and ensuring implementation of the Bank’s environmental, social and
climate risk management policies;
monitoring the Bank’s environmental, social, and climate risk profile and performance in relation to the Bank’s
lending activities;
ensuring data consolidation with respect to environmental, social, and climate-related risks associated with
the Bank’s loan book;
spreading ESG awareness throughout the Bank; and
handling environmental, social, and climate-related communications.
Human capital risk continued
169
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mitigation
continued
Climate-related risks mitigation: We have integrated climate-related risks into our risk management framework
and business resilience assessments. We are working on each of the four TCFD pillars: Governance, Strategy, Risk
Management, and Metrics and Targets. We have focused on mitigating climate-related risks by:
reassessing climate scenarios and deepening our knowledge of climate change and climate policy in Georgia;
identifying and addressing sector- and location-specific climate risks for our business clients, as part of loan
appraisal and origination process, as well as the environmental and social risk management process;
collecting relevant data, including on output produced and energy consumed, and calculating Scope 3
financed emissions for some GHG-intensive corporate clients;
calculating Scope 3 financed emissions through the Joint Impact Model in 2023 as a potential solution;
identifying opportunities for greening Georgia’s economy, to help the Bank understand where and how to
offer green financing and to discuss transformational opportunities with clients and lenders;
identifying and reporting on transactions aligned with the NBG’s Green Taxonomy (from January 2023),
including in climate-relevant sectors;
raising climate finance awareness across the Bank by implementing training for bankers and risk managers
from CB and MSME departments; and
facilitating climate-related disclosure. We are actively working to enhance our climate change risk management
and plan to implementing the following actions in 2024:
assessing the materiality of climate risks on the Bank’s portfolios against selected climate change scenarios;
enhancing the methodology on credit portfolio screening for climate-related physical and transition risks;
enhancing the measurement approach, inputs and assumptions used for Scope 1-3 calculation;
developing a climate risk stress-testing framework; and
assessing the financial impacts of climate-related risks on the Bank’s financial position, financial performance
and cash-flows over the medium and long term.
Climate-related risk continued
170
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Going Concern statement
Viability statement
In adopting the going concern basis for
preparing the consolidated financial
statements, the Directors have
considered the Group’s business activities,
strategy and objectives, principal risks
and uncertainties, and the performance
as set out on pages 18 to 20, 150 to
169 and 22 to 24. The Directors have
performed a robust assessment of the
Groups financial forecasts across a range
of scenarios over a 12-month period from
the date the financial statements are
authorised for issue by carrying out stress
testing, incorporating extreme downside
scenario and reverse stress testing, which
involved examining the level of disruption
that may cause the Group to fail.
The Directors confirm that they have a
reasonable expectation that the Group,
as a whole, have adequate resources to
continue in operation for the 12 months
from the date the financial statements
are authorised for issue. Therefore, the
Directors consider it appropriate to adopt
the going concern basis of accounting in
preparing the accompanying consolidated
financial statements.
Provision 31 of the 2018 UK Corporate
Governance Code requires the Board to
make a statement in the Annual Report
and Accounts regarding the viability of
the Group, including an explanation of
how they assessed the prospects of the
Group, the period of time for which they
have made the assessment and why they
consider that period to be appropriate.
In assessing the Group’s viability, the
Board considers a three-year period to
be appropriate as this period is covered
in the Groups strategic planning and
budgeting process and carries a high
level of confidence in assessing viability.
The Board has considered the Groups
current and forecast capital and liquidity
positions over a three-year period which
aligns to management’s 2024-2026
business plan and has evaluated the
results of stress testing and reverse stress
testing as described in this section.
In making its assessment, the Board
has considered the potential impact
of a severe but plausible scenario over
this period, each of which contained a
combination of principal risks. In addition,
the Board reviewed the results of reverse
stress testing, which involved examining
the level of disruption that may cause the
Group to fail.
The Board examined, among others, the
impact of the following risks over the
assessment period:
Severe contraction of the economy.
Significant depreciation of Georgian
Lari against the US dollar.
Increase of unemployment rate.
High and sustained levels of inflation
and increased interest rates (the
NBG’s monetary policy rate, a US Fed
rate, and an ECB rate).
Substantial drop in real estate prices.
Liquidity risk (one-off withdrawal of
customer funds).
Increased operational losses, including
from materialisation of cybersecurity
risk and regulatory fines.
Increased risks related to the Groups
operations in Belarus, leading to a
full write-off of BNB operations,
and the need for capital injection in
Ameriabank.
Applying the stress testing scenarios
to the Group’s capital and liquidity did
not result in a breach of any regulatory
requirements.
The reverse stress testing scenario is
currently deemed to be implausible.
The stress testing also took into
account the availability and the likely
effectiveness of mitigating actions that
could be taken to avoid or reduce the
impact or occurrence of the identified
underlying risks to which the Group
is exposed. These actions included: a
decline in lending activity, a partial
suspension of share buybacks for the
share-based compensation scheme and
a temporary halt in capital distribution.
It also took into account the assumption
that the Group will be able to prolong
or refinance existing borrowings, or
increase the financing from DFIs, on
terms worse than the existing ones after
2025. As mitigating actions in the case
of the reverse stress testing scenario,
we also considered a full suspension
of share buybacks for the share-based
compensation scheme and dividend
distribution, the write-off of the Bank’s
AT1 capital notes and AT1 capital
perpetual subordinated syndicated
facility, a partial use of mandatory
reserves placed at the NBG, the release
of all Pillar 1 and Pillar 2 buffers under
the Basel III capital requirements set by
the NBG.
The Directors have also satisfied
themselves that they have the necessary
evidence to support the statement
in terms of the effectiveness of the
Groups risk management framework
and internal control processes in place to
mitigate risk. Based on these analyses,
the Directors confirm that they have a
reasonable expectation that the Group
will be able to continue in operation and
meet its liabilities as they fall due over the
three-year period from 1 January 2024 to
31 December 2026.
171
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
OVERVIEW
OF FINANCIAL
RESULTS
172
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Overview of financial results
1
Income statement highlights
GEL thousands FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Net interest income 1,615,446 1,182,335 36.6%
Net fee and commission income 434,482 317,491 36.8%
Net foreign currency gain 365,711 466,094 -21.5%
Net other income (adjusted for one-off items) 114,735 36,092 217.9%
Operating income (adjusted for one-off items) 2,530,374 2,002,012 26.4%
Operating expenses (754,053) (641,186) 17.6%
Profit from associates 1,456 754 93.1%
Operating income before cost of risk (adjusted for one-off items) 1,777,777 1,361,580 30.6%
Cost of risk (144,064) (119,068) 21.0%
Net operating income before non-recurring items (adjusted for one-off items) 1,633,713 1,242,512 31.5%
Net non-recurring items 1,038 -100.0%
Profit before income tax expense and one-off items 1,633,713 1,243,550 31.4%
Income tax expense (adjusted for one-off items) (258,971) (111,376) 132.5%
Profit (adjusted for one-off items) 1,374,742 1,132,174 21.4%
One-off items 22,585 311,825 -92.8%
Profit 1,397,327 1,443,999 -3.2%
Basic earnings per share 31.30 30.99 1.0%
Diluted earnings per share 30.43 30.33 0.3%
Balance sheet highlights
GEL thousands Dec-23 Dec-22 Change y-o-y
Liquid assets 9,984,238 10,367,600 -3.7%
Cash and cash equivalents
3,101,824 3,584,843 -13.5%
Amounts due from credit institutions
1,752,657 2,433,028 -28.0%
Investment securities
5,129,757 4,349,729 17.9%
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables 20,232,721 16,861,706 20.0%
Property and equipment 436,955 398,855 9.6%
All remaining assets 1,103,644 1,273,739 -13.4%
Total assets 31,757,558 28,901,900 9.9%
Client deposits and notes 20,522,739 18,261,397 12.4%
Amounts owed to credit institutions 5,156,009 5,266,653 -2.1%
Borrowings from DFIs
2,124,264 1,867,454 13.8%
Short-term loans from central banks
2,101,653 1,715,257 22.5%
Loans and deposits from commercial banks
930,092 1,683,942 -44.8%
Debt securities issued 421,359 645,968 -34.8%
All remaining liabilities 637,615 479,060 33.1%
Total liabilities 26,737,722 24,653,078 8.5%
Total equity 5,019,836 4,248,822 18.1%
Book value per share 114.62 94.07 21.8%
1. Due to the settlement of a legacy claim, the fair value revaluation of the receivable resulted in a one-off other income of GEL 22.6 for FY23. Due to the settlement of the
same legacy claim, FY22 net other income was adjusted for a one-off GEL 391.1 million. The entire legacy claim amount has already been settled. FY22 income tax expense
was adjusted for a one-off GEL 79.3 income tax expense due to an amendment to the corporate taxation model in Georgia. As a result, ROAA and ROAE were adjusted for
both one-off other income and one-off income tax expense where applicable and Cost:income ratios were adjusted for one-off other income where applicable. Comparisons
given in text are with adjusted figures of respective periods.
173
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Key ratios
FY23 FY22
ROAA (adjusted for one-off items) 4.7% 4.4%
ROAE (adjusted for one-off items) 29.9% 32.4%
Reported ROAE 30.4% 41.4%
Net interest margin 6.5% 5.4%
Loan yield 12.5% 11.5%
Liquid assets yield 4.7% 4.3%
Cost of funds 4.7% 4.9%
Cost of client deposits and notes 4.0% 3.6%
Cost of amounts owed to credit Institutions 8.0% 8.9%
Cost of debt securities issued 8.2% 7.1%
Cost:income ratio (adjusted for one-off items) 29.8% 32.0%
Reported cost:income ratio 29.5% 26.8%
NPLs to gross loans 2.3% 2.7%
NPL coverage ratio 69.2% 66.4%
NPL coverage ratio adjusted for the discounted value of collateral 117.6% 128.9%
Cost of credit risk ratio 0.7% 0.8%
NBG (Basel III) CET1 capital adequacy ratio N/A 14.7%
Minimum regulatory requirement
N/A 11.6%
NBG (Basel III) Tier 1 capital adequacy ratio N/A 16.7%
Minimum regulatory requirement
N/A 13.8%
NBG (Basel III) Total capital adequacy ratio N/A 19.8%
Minimum regulatory requirement
N/A 17.2%
IFRS-based NBG (Basel III) CET1 capital adequacy ratio 18.2% N/A
Minimum regulatory requirement
14.5% N/A
IFRS-based NBG (Basel III) Tier 1 capital adequacy ratio 20.0% N/A
Minimum regulatory requirement
16.7% N/A
IFRS-based NBG (Basel III) Total capital adequacy ratio 22.1% N/A
Minimum regulatory requirement
19.6% N/A
174
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Overview of financial results continued
Financial Review
Operating income
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Interest income 2,748,261 2,256,881 21.8%
Interest expense (1,132,815) (1,074,546) 5.4%
Net interest income 1,615,446 1,182,335 36.6%
Fee and commission income 707,765 559,465 26.5%
Fee and commission expense (273,283) (241,974) 12.9%
Net fee and commission income 434,482 317,491 36.8%
Net foreign currency gain 365,711 466,094 -21.5%
Net other income (adjusted for one-off items) 114,735 36,092 217.9%
Operating income (adjusted for one-off items) 2,530,374 2,002,012 26.4%
Net interest margin 6.5% 5.4%
Average interest-earning assets 24,967,791 21,765,305 14.7%
Average interest-bearing liabilities 24,008,840 21,865,374 9.8%
Average net loans and finance lease receivables 18,193,535 16,213,098 12.2%
Average net loans and finance lease receivables, GEL 9,698,415 8,009,664 21.1%
Average net loans and finance lease receivables, FC 8,495,120 8,203,434 3.6%
Average client deposits and notes 19,813,930 15,876,171 24.8%
Average client deposits and notes, GEL 8,554,724 6,172,866 38.6%
Average client deposits and notes, FC 11,259,206 9,703,305 16.0%
Average liquid assets 9,474,612 8,178,417 15.8%
Average liquid assets, GEL 3,419,120 3,305,624 3.4%
Average liquid assets, FC 6,055,492 4,872,793 24.3%
Liquid assets yield
4.7% 4.3%
Liquid assets yield, GEL
8.4% 8.9%
Liquid assets yield, FC
2.6% 1.0%
Loan yield
12.5% 11.5%
Loan yield, GEL
15.6% 15.9%
Loan yield, FC
8.9% 7.2%
Cost of funds
4.7% 4.9%
Cost of funds, GEL
8.8% 9.4%
Cost of funds, FC
1.7% 1.8%
Cost of client deposits and notes
4.0% 3.6%
Cost of client deposits and notes, GEL
8.4% 8.3%
Cost of client deposits and notes, FC
0.7% 0.6%
Cost: income ratio (adjusted for one-off items) 29.8% 32.0%
175
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Net interest income
Interest income amounted to GEL 2,748.3 million, up 21.8% y-o-y. The y-o-y increase in interest income was mostly attributable
to increased loan portfolio coupled with higher loan yield (up 100 bps y-o-y in FY23, on the back of increasing rates in foreign
currency).
Interest expense amounted to GEL 1,132.8 million, up 5.4% y-o-y. The main driver of increased interest expense was a significant
increase in deposit portfolio coupled with a 40 bps increase in cost of deposits, partly offset by reduced interest expense on
amounts owed to credit institutions.
Net interest margin stood at 6.5% (up 110 bps y-o-y).
Net non-interest income
Net fee and commission income amounted to GEL 434.5 million, up 36.8% y-o-y, mainly due to settlement operations and
advisory services.
Net foreign currency (FX) gain has broadly normalised, following last year’s higher activity levels, and amounted to GEL 365.7
million (down 21.5% y-o-y).
Net other income (adjusted for a one-off GEL 22.6 million other income) was GEL 114.7 million, up 3.2x y-o-y, driven by the
significant net gains on the sale of repossessed assets booked in the second and the fourth quarters of 2023.
Overall, the Group generated operating income (adjusted for one-off other income) of GEL 2,530.4 million, up 26.4% y-o-y, driven by
strong income generation across core revenue lines, partly offset by lower net foreign currency gains reflecting a normalising trend.
Operating expenses, cost of risk, profit
GEL thousands FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Salaries and other employee benefits (419,454) (362,019) 15.9%
Administrative expenses (205,368) (164,450) 24.9%
Depreciation, amortisation and impairment (124,723) (111,089) 12.3%
Other operating expenses (4,508) (3,628) 24.3%
Operating expenses (754,053) (641,186) 17.6%
Profit from associates 1,456 754 93.1%
Operating income before cost of risk (adjusted for one-off items) 1,777,777 1,361,580 30.6%
Expected credit loss on loans to customers (124,298) (128,678) -3.4%
Expected credit loss on finance lease receivables (2,762) (3,208) -13.9%
Other expected credit loss and impairment charge on other assets and provisions (17,004) 12,818 NMF
Cost of risk (144,064) (119,068) 21.0%
Net operating income before non-recurring items (adjusted for one-off items) 1,633,713 1,242,512 31.5%
Net non-recurring items 1,038 -100.0%
Profit before income tax expense and one-off items 1,633,713 1,243,550 31.4%
Income tax expense (adjusted for one-off items) (258,971) (111,376) 132.5%
Profit (adjusted for one-off items) 1,374,742 1,132,174 21.4%
One-off other income 22,585 391,100 -94.2%
One-off income tax expense (79,275) -100.0%
Profit 1,397,327 1,443,999 -3.2%
Operating expenses and efficiency
Operating expenses amounted to GEL 754.1 million (up 17.6% y-o-y). The rise in operating expenses was primarily related to
overall business growth and ongoing investments in strategic areas. Additionally, in the fourth quarter of 2023, the Group
incurred expenses related to the acquisition of Ameriabank as well as the consulting projects in IT and several other business
areas (totalling GEL 10.5 million).
For the full year of 2023, the Group delivered positive operating leverage, with the cost:income ratio at 29.8% versus 32.0% for
the full year of 2022.
Cost of risk
The Group maintained a healthy loan portfolio, with the cost of credit risk ratio of 0.7% in FY23 (0.8% in FY22).
Profitability
The Groups profit (adjusted for a one-off) was GEL 1,374.7 million (up 21.4% y-o-y).
ROAE (adjusted for a one-off) was 29.9% (32.4% in FY22).
176
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Overview of financial results continued
Balance sheet highlights
GEL thousands Dec-23 Dec-22 Change y-o-y
Liquid assets 9,984,238 10,367,600 -3.7%
Liquid assets, GEL 4,113,597 3,461,218 18.8%
Liquid assets, FC 5,870,641 6,906,382 -15.0%
Net loans and finance lease receivables 20,232,721 16,861,706 20.0%
Net loans and finance lease receivables, GEL 10,838,243 8,854,286 22.4%
Net loans and finance lease receivables, FC 9,394,478 8,007,420 17.3%
Client deposits and notes 20,522,739 18,261,397 12.4%
Client deposits and notes, GEL 8,829,820 6,692,834 31.9%
Client deposits and notes, FC 11,692,919 11,568,563 1.1%
Amounts owed to credit institutions 5,156,009 5,266,653 -2.1%
Borrowings from DFIs 2,124,264 1,867,454 13.8%
Short-term loans from central banks 2,101,653 1,715,257 22.5%
Loans and deposits from commercial banks 930,092 1,683,942 -44.8%
Debt securities issued 421,359 645,968 -34.8%
Risk-weighted assets (JSC Bank of Georgia standalone) 23,061,905 20,279,424 13.7%
Loan book
Net loans and finance lease receivables amounted to GEL 20,232.7 million at 31 December 2023, up 20.0% y-o-y in nominal terms.
Growth on a constant-currency basis was 19.6% y-o-y. On a constant currency basis, each segment recorded a strong growth of
loan book: Retail Banking up 16.2% y-o-y, SME Banking up 11.4%, and Corporate and Investment Banking up 30.5% y-o-y.
The NPLs to gross loans ratio reduced to 2.3% as at 31 December 2023 (down 40 bps y-o-y).
The positive asset quality trend is reflected in improved Stage 3 loans to gross loans ratio to 2.5% as at 31 December 2023
compared with 3.4% as at 31 December 2022.
Non-performing loans
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted Dec-23 Dec-22 Change y-o-y
NPLs 467,656 471,577 -0.8%
NPLs to gross loans 2.3% 2.7%
NPLs to gross loans, Retail Banking 1.9% 2.1%
NPLs to gross loans, SME Banking 3.6% 3.2%
NPLs to gross loans, Corporate and Investment Banking 1.7% 3.4%
NPL coverage ratio 69.2% 66.4%
NPL coverage ratio adjusted for the discounted value of collateral 117.6% 128.9%
Stage 3 ratio 2.5% 3.4%
Deposits
Client deposits and notes amounted to GEL 20,522.7 million as at 31 December 2023 (up 12.4% y-o-y). On a constant currency
basis, deposits increased by 12.2% y-o-y. The y-o-y growth was driven by both current/demand and time deposits.
Liquidity position
Bank of Georgia continues to operate with comfortable levels of liquidity. At 31 December 2023, the Bank’s IFRS-based liquidity
coverage ratio (LCR) stood at 125.2% (132.4% at 31 December 2022), above the minimum requirement of 100%
1
. The net stable
funding ratio (NSFR) also stood at a high level of 130.4% at 31 December 2023 (131.9% at 31 December 2022). The loan-to-deposit
ratio increased to 98.6% at 31 December 2023 versus 92.3% at 31 December 2022.
Capital position
The Bank continues to operate with robust capital adequacy levels. At 31 December 2023, the Bank’s Basel III CET1, Tier 1 and
Total capital ratios stood at 18.2%, 20.0%, and 22.1%, respectively, all comfortably above the minimum requirements of 14.5%,
16.7% and 19.6%, respectively.
1. In January 2023, the NBG transitioned to IFRS-based accounting. The LCR and NSFR figures for 31 December 2022 are not IFRS-based.
177
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Segment results
1
In the first quarter of 2023 we split the SME Banking segment from Retail Banking and transferred the majority of the Micro
portfolio, where customers had business-related needs, to SME Banking. The remaining Micro portfolio has been transferred to Mass
Retail. The SME segment has grown significantly over the past few years. In addition, the value proposition for business clients has
been different from the value proposition for retail customers, leading to our decision to change the segmentation. The comparative
figures have been restated accordingly to reflect this change.
Retail Banking
2
Income statement highlights
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Interest income 1,323,069 1,166,265 13.4%
Interest expense (532,439) (601,090) -11.4%
Net interest income 790,630 565,175 39.9%
Net fee and commission income 302,555 221,495 36.6%
Net foreign currency gain 197,379 234,425 -15.8%
Net other income 18,471 18,898 -2.3%
Operating income 1,309,035 1,039,993 25.9%
Salaries and other employee benefits (235,601) (193,730) 21.6%
Administrative expenses (133,419) (104,789) 27.3%
Depreciation, amortisation and impairment (97,938) (86,546) 13.2%
Other operating expenses (2,897) (2,082) 39.1%
Operating expenses (469,855) (387,147) 21.4%
Profit from associates 1,391 700 98.7%
Operating income before cost of risk 840,571 653,546 28.6%
Cost of risk (83,847) (164,099) -48.9%
Profit before non-recurring items and income tax 756,724 489,447 54.6%
Net non-recurring items 1,241 -100.0%
Profit before income tax expense and one-off items 756,724 490,688 54.2%
Income tax expense (adjusted for one-off items) (121,126) (43,342) 179.5%
Profit (adjusted for one-off items) 635,598 447,346 42.1%
One-off income tax expense (33,147) -100.0%
Profit 635,598 414,199 53.5%
Balance sheet highlights
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Net loans and finance lease receivables 8,502,529 7,304,874 16.4%
Net loans and finance lease receivables, GEL 6,547,120 5,307,288 23.4%
Net loans and finance lease receivables, FC 1,955,409 1,997,586 -2.1%
Client deposits and notes 12,597,938 10,923,787 15.3%
Client deposits and notes, GEL 4,115,260 2,863,880 43.7%
Client deposits and notes, FC 8,482,678 8,059,907 5.2%
of which:
Time deposits 6,528,765 5,329,886 22.5%
Time deposits, GEL 2,562,840 1,801,029 42.3%
Time deposits, FC 3,965,925 3,528,857 12.4%
Current accounts and demand deposits 6,069,173 5,593,901 8.5%
Current accounts and demand deposits, GEL 1,552,420 1,062,851 46.1%
Current accounts and demand deposits, FC 4,516,753 4,531,050 -0.3%
Assets under management 2,486,547 1,953,970 27.3%
1. In ‘Segment results’, loan and deposit portfolios are given for JSC Bank of Georgia standalone.
2. FY22 income tax expense was adjusted for a one-off GEL 33.1 income tax expense due to an amendment to the corporate taxation model in Georgia. As a result, ROAE was
adjusted for this one-off item. Comparisons given in text are with adjusted figures of respective periods. You can see the unadjusted ROAE at the bottom of ‘Key Ratios’
table.
178
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Overview of financial results continued
Key ratios
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22
ROAE (adjusted for one-off items) 39.6% 31.7%
Net interest margin 6.0% 5.0%
Loan yield 14.1% 13.7%
Loan yield, GEL 16.6% 17.0%
Loan yield, FC 6.4% 5.9%
Cost of funds 4.8% 5.9%
Cost of client deposits and notes 3.0% 2.7%
Cost of client deposits and notes, GEL 8.2% 8.5%
Cost of client deposits and notes, FC 0.8% 0.6%
Cost of time deposits 5.1% 4.3%
Cost of time deposits, GEL 11.2% 11.2%
Cost of time deposits, FC 1.5% 1.0%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits 0.8% 0.6%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits, GEL 2.8% 2.8%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits, FC 0.2% 0.1%
Cost: income ratio 35.9% 37.2%
Cost of credit risk ratio 1.0% 2.2%
ROAE (reported) 39.6% 29.3%
Performance highlights
Operating income amounted to GEL 1,309.0 million (up 25.9% y-o-y). The y-o-y increase was driven by growth in both net interest
income and net fee and commission income, partly offset by the normalisation of net foreign currency gains and lower net other
income.
Operating expenses amounted to GEL 469.9 million (up 21.4% y-o-y). The y-o-y increase in operating expenses was driven by
business growth and continuing investments in strategic areas. In addition, the growth in operating expenses was partly due to
the allocated costs with respect to the acquisition of Ameriabank and ongoing business consulting projects.
The cost of credit risk ratio improved significantly to 1.0% (2.2% in FY22).
Overall, Retail Banking generated a profit of GEL 635.6 million (up 42.1% y-o-y).
Retail Banking’s net loans and finance lease receivables stood at GEL 8,502.5 million (up 16.4% y-o-y) as at 31 December 2023.
On a constant currency basis, the loan book increased by 16.2% y-o-y. Both the y-o-y and the q-o-q growth was mainly driven by
consumer loans, followed by mortgage loans.
77.0% of the loan book was denominated in GEL at 31 December 2023 versus 72.7% at 31 December 2022.
Client deposits and notes stood at GEL 12,597.9 million at 31 December 2023 (up 15.3% y-o-y). On a constant currency basis,
deposits increased by 15.1% y-o-y. The strong y-o-y increase in deposits was mainly driven by time deposits, followed by current
accounts and demand deposits.
The share of GEL-denominated client deposits increased to 32.7% as at 31 December 2023 versus 26.2% at 31 December 2022.
179
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
SME Banking
Income statement highlights
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Interest income 553,281 467,707 18.3%
Interest expense (297,268) (264,914) 12.2%
Net interest income 256,013 202,793 26.2%
Net fee and commission income 40,574 34,792 16.6%
Net foreign currency gain 38,357 43,183 -11.2%
Net other income 6,049 2,503 141.7%
Operating income 340,993 283,271 20.4%
Salaries and other employee benefits (61,641) (57,800) 6.6%
Administrative expenses (25,523) (22,022) 15.9%
Depreciation, amortisation and impairment (12,206) (13,193) -7.5%
Other operating expenses (410) (492) -16.7%
Operating expenses (99,780) (93,507) 6.7%
Profit from associates 65 54 20.4%
Operating income before cost of risk 241,278 189,818 27.1%
Cost of risk (32,316) (8,603) NMF
Profit before income tax expense and one-off items 208,962 181,215 15.3%
Income tax expense (adjusted for one-off items) (34,094) (16,310)
1
109.0%
Profit adjusted for one-off items 174,868 164,905 6.0%
One-off income tax expense (12,475) -100.0%
Profit 174,868 152,430 14.7%
Balance sheet highlights
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Net loans and finance lease receivables 4,550,840 4,064,034 12.0%
Net loans and finance lease receivables, GEL 2,570,051 2,208,103 16.4%
Net loans and finance lease receivables, FC 1,980,789 1,855,931 6.7%
Client deposits and notes 1,876,967 1,508,932 24.4%
Client deposits and notes, GEL 1,197,070 852,922 40.3%
Client deposits and notes, FC 679,897 656,010 3.6%
of which:
Time deposits 84,245 65,626 28.4%
Time deposits, GEL 61,408 41,930 46.5%
Time deposits, FC 22,837 23,696 -3.6%
Current accounts and demand deposits 1,792,722 1,443,306 24.2%
Current accounts and demand deposits, GEL 1,135,662 810,992 40.0%
Current accounts and demand deposits, FC 657,060 632,314 3.9%
1. FY22 income tax expense was adjusted for a one-off GEL 12.5 income tax expense due to an amendment to the corporate taxation model in Georgia. As a result, ROAE was
adjusted for this one-off item. Comparisons given in text are with adjusted figures of respective periods. You can see the unadjusted ROAE at the bottom of ‘Key ratios’
table.
180
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Overview of financial results continued
Key ratios
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22
ROAE (adjusted for one-off items) 22.6% 24.0%
Net interest margin 4.9% 4.3%
Loan yield 11.2% 10.0%
Loan yield, GEL 13.8% 13.5%
Loan yield, FC 7.9% 6.4%
Cost of funds 6.4% 6.1%
Cost of client deposits and notes 1.7% 1.0%
Cost of client deposits and notes, GEL 3.1% 2.4%
Cost of client deposits and notes, FC -0.4% -0.7%
Cost of time deposits 7.7% 6.4%
Cost of time deposits, GEL 10.8% 10.8%
Cost of time deposits, FC 1.2% 0.8%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits 1.4% 0.7%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits, GEL 2.7% 1.9%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits, FC -0.5% -0.7%
Cost:income ratio 29.3% 33.0%
Cost of credit risk ratio 0.7% 0.1%
ROAE (reported) 22.6% 22.2%
Performance highlights
Operating income amounted to GEL 341.0 million (up 20.4% y-o-y). The y-o-y increase was mainly driven by strong net interest
income generation, partly offset by the reduced net foreign currency gain.
Operating expenses were GEL 99.8 million, up 6.7% y-o-y.
The cost of credit risk ratio stood at 0.7% (0.1% in FY22).
Overall, SME Banking generated a profit of GEL 174.9 million (up 6.0% y-o-y).
Net loans and finance receivables stood at GEL 4,550.8 million at 31 December 2023, up 12.0% y-o-y. On a constant currency
basis, the loan book increased by 11.4% y-o-y.
GEL-denominated loans remained broadly stable at 56.5% of total SME Banking loans at 31 December 2023, compared with
54.3% at 31 December 2022.
Client deposits and notes amounted to GEL 1,877.0 million at 31 December 2023, up 24.4% y-o-y. On a constant currency basis,
deposits increased by 24.1% y-o-y.
GEL-denominated deposits represented 63.8% of total SME Banking deposits at 31 December 2023, compared with 56.5% at
31 December 2022.
181
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Corporate and Investment Banking (CIB)
Income statement highlights
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Interest income 803,408 554,135 45.0%
Interest expense (283,171) (177,364) 59.7%
Net interest income 520,237 376,771 38.1%
Net fee and commission income 83,718 49,543 69.0%
Net foreign currency gain 88,369 123,993 -28.7%
Net other income (adjusted for one-off items) 89,035 14,299 522.7%
Operating income (adjusted for one-off items) 781,359 564,606 38.4%
Salaries and other employee benefits (86,237) (80,978) 6.5%
Administrative expenses (27,217) (18,079) 50.5%
Depreciation, amortisation and impairment (5,319) (5,292) 0.5%
Other operating expenses (624) (1,283) -51.4%
Operating expenses (119,397) (105,632) 13.0%
Profit from associates
Operating income before cost of risk (adjusted for one-off items) 661,962 458,974 44.2%
Cost of risk (30,549) 79,461 NMF
Profit before non-recurring items and income tax (adjusted for one-off items) 631,413 538,435 17.3%
Net non-recurring items
Profit before income tax expense and one-off items 631,413 538,435 17.3%
Income tax expense (adjusted for one-off items) (95,274) (44,040) 116.3%
Profit adjusted for one-off items 536,139 494,395 8.4%
One-off other income
1
22,585 391,100 -94.2%
One-off income tax expense (33,653) -100.0%
Profit 558,724 851,842 -34.4%
Balance sheet highlights
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Net loans and finance lease receivables 6,463,690 4,926,264 31.2%
Net loans and finance lease receivables, GEL 1,714,253 1,321,797 29.7%
Net loans and finance lease receivables, FC 4,749,437 3,604,467 31.8%
Client deposits and notes 5,256,172 4,824,646 8.9%
Client deposits and notes, GEL 3,734,682 3,021,179 23.6%
Client deposits and notes, FC 1,521,490 1,803,467 -15.6%
of which:
Time deposits 1,416,400 1,520,701 -6.9%
Time deposits, GEL 1,295,713 1,412,130 -8.2%
Time deposits, FC 120,687 108,571 11.2%
Current accounts and demand deposits 3,839,772 3,303,945 16.2%
Current accounts and demand deposits, GEL 2,438,969 1,609,049 51.6%
Current accounts and demand deposits, FC 1,400,803 1,694,896 -17.4%
Letters of credit and guarantees (off-balance sheet exposures) 1,973,156 1,812,231 8.9%
Assets under management 2,193,090 1,480,894 48.1%
1. Due to the settlement of a legacy claim, the fair value revaluation of the receivable resulted in a one-off other income of GEL 22.6 million posted in FY23. Net other income
was adjusted for these one-offs. Due to the settlement of the same legacy claim, FY22 net other income was adjusted for a one-off GEL 391.1 million. FY22 income tax
expense was adjusted for a one-off GEL 33.7 income tax expense due to an amendment to the corporate taxation model in Georgia. As a result, ROAE was adjusted for
one-off other income and one-off tax expense where applicable and Cost:income ratios were adjusted for one-off other income where applicable. Comparisons given in text
are with adjusted figures of respective periods. You can see the unadjusted ROAE and unadjusted cost: income ratio at the bottom of the ‘Key ratios’ table. You can see the
unadjusted ROAE and unadjusted cost:income ratio at the bottom of the ‘Key ratios’ table.
182
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Overview of financial results continued
Key ratios
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22
ROAE (adjusted for one-off items) 26.0% 39.1%
Net interest margin 6.2% 5.6%
Loan yield 11.5% 9.3%
Loan yield, GEL 14.7% 14.7%
Loan yield, FC 10.3% 7.7%
Cost of funds 4.1% 2.6%
Cost of client deposits and notes 7.2% 6.2%
Cost of client deposits and notes, GEL 9.8% 9.4%
Cost of client deposits and notes, FC 0.3% -0.1%
Cost of time deposits 10.3% 10.4%
Cost of time deposits, GEL 10.7% 11.1%
Cost of time deposits, FC 2.2% 1.1%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits 5.5% 3.9%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits, GEL 9.0% 7.7%
Cost of current accounts and demand deposits, FC 0.1% -0.2%
Cost:income ratio (adjusted for one-off items) 15.3% 18.7%
Cost of credit risk ratio 0.4% -1.0%
Concentration of top ten clients 7.3% 5.9%
ROAE (reported) 27.1% 67.4%
Cost:income (reported) 14.9% 11.1%
Performance highlights
Operating income (adjusted for a one-off GEL 22.6 million other income) amounted to GEL 781.4 million, up 38.4%, driven by
significant growth in every core revenue line, except for the net foreign currency gain that broadly normalised in 2023.
Operating expenses were up 13.0% y-o-y to GEL 119.4 million.
The cost of credit risk ratio was 0.4% in FY23 versus -1.0% in FY22.
Overall, Corporate and Investment Banking posted a profit (adjusted for a one-off GEL 1.5 million net other income) of GEL 536.1
million, up 8.4% y-o-y.
Net loans and finance receivables stood at GEL 6,463.7 million at 31 December 2023 (up 31.2% y-o-y). On a constant currency
basis, the loan book increased by 30.5% y-o-y.
GEL-denominated loans represented 26.5% of total Corporate and Investment Banking loans at 31 December 2023, compared
with 26.8% at 31 December 2022.
The concentration of top ten Corporate and Investment Banking clients was 7.3% of total gross loans at 31 December 2023 (5.9%
at 31 December 2022).
Client deposits and notes amounted to GEL 5,256.2 million at 31 December 2023 (up 8.9% y-o-y). On a constant currency basis,
deposits increased by 9.0% y-o-y.
GEL-denominated deposits stood at 71.1% of total Corporate and Investment Banking deposits at 31 December 2023, compared
with 62.6% at 31 December 2022.
183
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Belarusky Narodny Bank (BNB)
Income statement highlights
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted FY23 FY22 Change y-o-y
Net interest income 48,486 37,511 29.3%
Net fee and commission income 7,379 11,500 -35.8%
Net foreign currency gain 41,606 64,493 -35.5%
Net other income 2,009 1,170 71.7%
Operating income 99,480 114,674 -13.2%
Operating expenses (65,514) (55,432) 18.2%
Operating income before cost of risk 33,966 59,242 -42.7%
Cost of risk 2,648 (25,827) NMF
Net non-recurring items (203) -100.0%
Profit before income tax expense 36,614 33,212 10.2%
Income tax expense (8,477) (7,684) 10.3%
Profit 28,137 25,528 10.2%
Balance sheet highlights
GEL thousands, unless otherwise noted Dec-23 Dec-22 Change y-o-y
Cash and cash equivalents 407,456 640,018 -36.3%
Amounts due from credit institutions 18,759 74,778 -74.9%
Investment securities 70,411 60,361 16.6%
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables 716,905 538,166 33.2%
Other assets 66,636 68,043 -2.1%
Total assets 1,280,167 1,381,366 -7.3%
Client deposits and notes 1,048,512 1,034,124 1.4%
Amounts owed to credit institutions 50,852 172,389 -70.5%
Debt securities issued 6,810 2,745 148.1%
Other liabilities 25,268 20,670 22.2%
Total liabilities 1,131,442 1,229,928 -8.0%
Total equity 148,725 151,438 -1.8%
Total liabilities and equity 1,280,167 1,381,366 -7.3%
During 2023 BNB continued to be focused on its core domestic retail and small business customers.
During a few months of 2023, as a result of the ongoing Russia-Ukraine war, the NBG’s official exchange rate of GEL versus the
Belarusian Ruble (BYN) was not updated due to inactivity on the source platform. On 3 October 2023, the NBG’s official exchange
rate of GEL versus the BYN was reinstated, resulting in a 23.3% depreciation of BYN against GEL. BNB’s performance was adversely
affected by this change in exchange rate.
BNB’s capital ratios, calculated in accordance with the National Bank of the Republic of Belarus’ standards, were above the
minimum requirements at 31 December 2023 – Tier 1 capital adequacy ratio at 9.9% (minimum requirement of 7.0%) and Total
capital adequacy ratio at 13.8% (minimum requirement of 12.5%).
184
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
GOVERNANCE
185
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Governance at a glance
2023 key highlights:
Evaluated Board effectiveness
An externally facilitated Board effectiveness and performance
evaluation was carried out during the year, in accordance with
the requirements of the 2018 UK Corporate Governance Code.
Clare Chalmers Ltd, a specialist consultancy firm, was engaged
to undertake the effectiveness evaluation of the Board, its
Committees, individual Directors and the Chair of the Board.
Further details of the process and its outcome can be found on
page 196.
Progressed succession planning
During the year, succession planning has been a key topic
of discussion. Cecil Quillen was appointed as Chair of the
Remuneration Committee with effect from 1 January 2023. We
also engaged Korn Ferry, an external recruitment consultant,
to assist with the appointment of Andrew McIntyre as a new
Non-executive Director and aid with the future succession of
the succession of the Audit Chair.
Further information on our work on succession planning can be
found on pages 195 and 207 to 209.
Enhanced ESG policies
We remain committed to ensuring a robust ESG strategy and
during the year approved two additional ESG policies: the
Responsible Supply Chain Policy and the Environmental Policy.
Further information on our work on ESG can be found on
pages 60 to 142.
Listened to stakeholders
Board members have undertaken numerous engagement
opportunities with our employees and stakeholders, including:
• AGM held on 19 May 2023
• Multiple investor roadshows
• Three Employee Voice meetings
• Meetings with the National Bank of Georgia (‘NBG’) and
other local stakeholders.
Further details can be found on pages 52 to 59, 189, 252 and
210.
Reviewed diversity
We remain committed to ensuring the Company is an inclusive
organisation reflecting all aspects of diversity. During the year
we reviewed and confirmed the diversity within the Board
membership, including gender and ethnicity as well as broader
characteristics.
Further details on our commitment can be found on pages 186
to 187, 194 and 210 to 212.
186
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
67%
33%
27% 67%
11%
67%
73% 33%
11%
11%
3
1
3
11
45-4940-44 50-54 55-59 60 -64
Governance at a glance continued
2023 in numbers:
We recognise that a Board consisting of individuals with a wide range of
backgrounds and experiences will contribute to the Company’s long-term success.
Board diversity
Composition of the Board
As at 31 December 2023
Gender diversity of the Board
Gender diversity of the Executive
Management Team
Age diversity of the Board
Ethnic diversity of the Board
Chairman (independent upon appointment) - 1
Senior Independent Non-executive Director – 1
Independent Non-executive Directors – 6
Executive Directors – 1
Male – 6
Female – 3
Male – 11
Female – 4
Other – 3
White – 6
187
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
6
1
1
1
1
8
Board independence
Board meeting attendance
Board skills and experience
Details of Board attendance in 2023 are as follows:
Members No. of meetings attended
Mel Carvill* 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
Alasdair Breach* 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
Tamaz Georgadze* 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
Archil Gachechiladze 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
Hanna Loikkanen* 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi* 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
Véronique McCarroll* 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
Jonathan Muir* 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
Cecil Quillen* 8/8 scheduled and 4/4 ad hoc
* Denotes Independent Director.
Director tenure as at 31 December 2023Board independence as at 31 December 2023
Non-independent – 1
Independent – 8
< 1 year – 0
1 year – 1
2 years – 1
3 years – 0
4 years – 1
5 years+ – 6
The Board continues to have a strong mix of experienced individuals able to provide an external perspective on the business and
constructive challenge. The below skills matrix sets out the expertise of the Non-executive Directors:
2
3
6
7
1
7
7
3
4
8
8
6
8
UK corporate governance/listed plc
Corporate memory
Banking sector knowledge
Regulatory experience
Sustainability/ESG
Digital technology
Financial and accounting
Risk management
Information technology and cybersecurity
Strategy, capital markets, investor management
Other stakeholder management
HR, talent management, culture management
UK executive remuneration
188
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
“Strategic leadership and
stakeholder engagement have
been key areas of focus to further
support the long-term sustainable
growth of the Group.
Chairman’s introduction
Dear Shareholders,
On behalf of the Board, I am pleased
to present the Company’s Governance
report for the year ended 31 December
2023.
Corporate governance
We remain committed to upholding high
standards of corporate governance.
We believe maintaining compliance
with the Principles of the UK Corporate
Governance Code 2018 (the ‘Code’), along
with our openness to evolve and improve
our governance framework, contributes
to the long-term success of the Group. In
addition, the Bank complies with the NBG
Corporate Governance Code to ensure
that the highest standards are applied.
Our robust framework of governance, risk
and internal controls supported by the
knowledge, skills and experience of the
Directors and the Executive Management
Team provides us with confidence in the
decisions we make and the strategic
direction we are taking.
This governance statement details how
the Company has complied with the Code
and outlines our governance framework
and the activities of the Board and its
Committees during the year.
Strategic focus
With our purpose – Helping people
achieve more of their potential – at the
heart of everything we do and aligned
with our culture, we continue to be a
leader in the Georgian banking sector,
committed to achieving strong employee
and customer satisfaction, profitability
and shareholder returns.
During the year under review we have
been focused on the Company’s strategic
agenda. We welcomed a number of
external speakers to Board meetings and
our two-day in-person strategy meeting
to provide further insight into wider
geopolitical and macroeconomic factors,
and consider customer and investor
perspectives regarding the strategic
direction of the Group.
The strategy days were a great success,
enabling the Board to delve deeper
into stakeholder views and strategic
discussion. They provide us with the
time to focus on the long-term strategic
direction of the Company required to
optimise sustainability and shareholder
value.
During 2023, the Board considered
a potential opportunity in Armenia
presented by the Executive management
team. We agreed that value could be
derived from exploring this opportunity
in an adjacent high-growth economy
and agreed for management to engage
with the potential target to gauge
detailed information and evaluate the
upside through a thorough due diligence
process. Discussions with key investors
through roadshows and Board meetings
throughout the year highlighted that
there was appetite and support for the
Groups excess capital to be carefully
deployed for international growth.
Following analysis, discussions with
advisers and other key parties, a potential
opportunity to acquire Ameriabank CJSC
(‘Ameriabank’), a leading universal bank
in Armenia, one of the fastest-growing
economies in the region, was identified
as a leading opportunity for international
growth for the Group. Following extensive
due diligence and Board discussions
with the management and external
advisors during 2023 and into 2024,
we unanimously recommended the
conditional acquisition of 100% of shares
of Ameriabank to the shareholders of the
Company. Since year end, at a General
Meeting of the Company on 14 March
2024, 83.60% of issued share capital
voted, with 100.0% votes in favour of the
acquisition. Further information regarding
this transaction can be found on pages 13
to 14.
Board effectiveness
We were pleased to appoint Clare
Chalmers Ltd (the ‘Evaluator’) to
undertake our effectiveness evaluation
for 2023 and welcomed the opportunity
to receive external feedback on our
governance arrangements and Board
dynamics. We found the process was a
useful experience that provided positive
feedback on the Board’s effectiveness as
well as useful suggestions on how we can
optimise performance. The evaluation
process is detailed on page 196 of this
report and further information regarding
the outcomes and action plan can be
found in the Nomination Committee
Report on page 212.
We have already begun to consider and
implement suggestions provided by the
Evaluator, including the introduction
of a Bank-wide Risk Registry. More
information can be found in the Risk
Committee Report on pages 224 to 228.
Succession
During 2023 we continued to execute our
succession plans to comply with the NBG
seven year independence requirement,
with Hanna Loikkanen stepping down as
Chair of the Remuneration Committee
and replaced by Cecil Quillen with effect
from 1 January 2023.
During the year we undertook a search
for an additional Non-executive Director
with the appropriate skills, knowledge and
experience to succeed as Audit Chair in
the future. We were pleased to welcome
Andrew McIntyre as a Non-executive
Director and member of the Audit
Committee and Nomination Committee
as announced to the market on 15 March
2024. Al Breach stepped down as a
Non-executive Director and a member
of the Remuneration Committee, Risk
Committee, and Nomination Committee
on the same date. On behalf of the Board
and the Company, I would like to thank Al
Breach for his significant contributions to
the Company over the years.
Succession planning will remain a key
focus throughout 2024, ensuring we
appropriately refresh the Board – taking
into consideration both the Code and
the new nine-year NBG independence
requirements, as well as taking further
steps towards achieving our target
of 40% of women on the Board by
2025. During succession planning and
Mel Carvill
Chairman of the Board
Directors’ Governance Statement
189
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
appointments we remain conscious of
the importance of achieving the right
blend of skills, experience and diversity to
provide the appropriate level of oversight,
challenge and corporate knowledge.
Further information on succession
planning and the appointment process is
available in the Nomination Committee
report on pages 207 to 209.
Engagement with stakeholders
The Board is focused on achieving the
best outcomes for our stakeholders by
ensuring they are given the opportunity
to raise their voice and for the Board
to listen. We have continued to engage
with our employees through Employee
Voice meetings, and continued to receive
updates on eNPS and the values and
culture survey. Whilst in Georgia, I have
continued to take every opportunity to
liaise with both internal and external
stakeholders including executives, senior
management, employees, external
advisors and senior governmental
regulatory advisors. I also met with
shareholders at the Company’s AGM
and many investors during the investor
roadshow. As a Board we acknowledge
that any opportunity to meet with
stakeholders helps inform the Board’s
decisions and shape the business as we
move forward. As always, my fellow
Directors and I look forward to engaging
with more stakeholders during 2024.
More information on our stakeholder
engagement and how we consider
stakeholders when making key decisions
can be found on pages 52 to 59.
Looking ahead
2024 will be an important year as we
move forward with the integration of
Ameriabank into the Group, embed
succession planning and continue to
enhance our governance, risk and internal
controls frameworks. I look forward to
developing the Board’s agenda for 2024,
incorporating the Evaluator’s suggestions.
I would like to thank the Directors for
their support during 2023 and their
additional commitments and focus as
weexplored and considered the future
ofthe Company.
Mel Carvill
Chairman of the Board
24 April 2024
Section 172 Statement
In discharging its duty to act
in good faith and in a way that
is the most likely to promote
the long-term success of the
Company, Directors must take
into consideration the interests
of the various stakeholders
of the Company. Throughout
this report, we detail how
we have identified and given
consideration to our various
stakeholders. See page 52 for
our Section 172 statement
(which is incorporated to the
Strategic Report), and on how
the Board has engaged with our
stakeholders.
Statement of compliance with the UK Corporate Governance Code
The Board believes good governance enhances performance, reduces risk and promotes the long-term success of the
Company for the benefit of our stakeholders. The Board is committed to ensuring high standards of corporate governance
are maintained, and the Company continues to take steps to enhance and evolve its governance framework and underlying
governance structure in line with best practice. This Governance Report – which forms part of the Directors’ Report – and the
reports of the Board Committees describe how during 2023 the Company has applied the main principles and complied with
the relevant provisions of the Code. The Code is publicly available at the FRC’s website: www.frc.org.uk.
The Board confirms that, for the year ended 31 December 2023, the Company has complied with all provisions of the Code.
TheBoard is aware of the publication of the revised Corporate Governance Code 2024 which will apply to the Company’s
reporting period starting on 1 January 2025, excluding Provision 29 which will apply to the reporting period starting on
1 January 2026. The Board and its committees have received updates from Management, the Company Secretary and the
Company’s External Auditor regarding the changes to the Code and have taken steps to prepare for the proposed changes.
Inparticular, the Audit Committee has undertaken substantial work during 2023 to ensure that the Bank is well positioned
and where needed, has started to implement the documentation and process changes. The Audit Committee members also
oversaw the Company’s feedback to the FRC under the consultation on the proposed changes to the Code.
190
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Board
Group Executive Officer
Audit Committee
See pages 214 to 223
Risk Committee
See pages 224 to 228
Remuneration Committee
See pages 229 to 247
Nomination Committee
See pages 206 to 213
Management Teams
Directors’ Governance Statement continued
Division of responsibilities
Governance structure
The Board is composed of nine Directors,
eight of whom are independent Non-
executive Directors. The Board is assisted
in fulfilling its responsibilities by four
principal committees: Nomination,
Audit, Risk and Remuneration. Their
Terms of Reference are reviewed
annually to ensure they are aligned with
the Code and function effectively. The
relevant committee recommends any
amendments to the Board.
The current Terms of Reference are
available at:
https://www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com/
governance/documents.
Roles and responsibilities
The roles of Chairman, Senior
Independent Director and CEO are held
by separate individuals. Their clearly
defined responsibilities, as well as those
of Non-executive Directors, are set out
in writing and regularly reviewed by the
Board. The division of responsibilities
can be found on our website: https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/storage/
documents/Roles%20and%20
Responsibilities.pdf
Leadership and purpose
The role of the Board
The Board is responsible for the overall
management of the Group and provides
strong leadership and support to the
Executive Management to deliver the
Groups strategic aims. The Board
ensures management strikes the right
balance between delivering on short-term
objectives and ensuring sustainable long-
term growth.
The Board is responsible to shareholders
for creating and delivering sustainable
shareholder value through the effective
oversight of the Company’s business.
The Board recognises its duties under
the UK Companies Act 2006 to promote
the long-term success of the Company,
considering not only the views and
interests of our shareholders but also
our various stakeholders, including
our employees, customers, investors,
regulators, suppliers and communities as
a whole. Each Director understands their
statutory duty to consider and represent
the Company’s various stakeholders in
deliberations and decision-making. More
details about how the Directors have
fulfilled their duties under Section 172
of the Companies Act 2006 can be found
on pages 52 to 59.
The Board retains a schedule of matters
reserved for its decision, to safeguard
the areas material to the delivery of
the Company’s strategy. This ensures
the necessary framework and resources
are in place for the Group to meet
its stated objectives. The Schedule
of Matters Reserved for the Board is
available on our website at: https://www.
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/
documents.
Operation of the Board
The Board, led by the Chair, fosters a
culture of openness and transparent
decision-making. This is supported
by clearly defined roles, and open
communication channels both in and
outside of Board meetings.
Meeting agendas are developed in
conjunction with the Company Secretary,
UK General Counsel, the Chair, Directors
and the CEO, ensuring adequate time is
allocated to all items to support effective
and constructive discussion. The Chair
and CEO receive regular input from the
Non-executive Directors ahead of Board
meetings to ensure any matters raised
by them are included on the agenda. As
a key responsibility of the Non-executive
Directors is to challenge and provide
counsel to management, Board meetings
are chaired efficiently and effectively
to allow the views of all Directors to be
considered.
The Non-executive Directors review
and challenge proposals and
recommendations presented by
management and share their ideas by
drawing on experience gained outside
the Company, providing alternative
suggestions to management where
suitable. To maximise efficiency and the
opportunity for adequate discussion
and challenge, Directors ensure written
materials submitted through the
electronic meeting portal are thoroughly
reviewed in advance, and presenters
are available for questions and further
discussion on key matters both before
and during the meeting. The Board
invites senior management, internal and
external subject matter experts, and
representatives from key teams to attend
Board meetings to present key matters,
answer questions and provide further
detail. This strengthens the Board’s
knowledge and understanding of the
Group, the sector and the macroeconomic
environment.
The Senior Independent Non-executive
Director supports the Chairman by
acting as an intermediary for other Non-
executive Directors and liaising with the
Non-executive Directors outside of the
Board and Committee meetings. The
Chairman meets with the Non-executive
Directors without the CEO present as
required.
191
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Key activities of the Board
during 2023
During the year the Board held eight
meetings and three ad hoc meetings. Six
Board meetings were held in Georgia,
where all Directors attended in person,
with the others held in London and via
video conference. Attendance at these
meetings is set out on page 187.
At each quarterly meeting the Board
receives updates from the CEO, its
committees and the Company Secretary
and is presented with local and regional
macroeconomic and geopolitical updates,
finance reports and competitor analysis.
The Board also reviews the minutes of
previous meetings and receives updates
on matters raised or outstanding.
Throughout the year the Board discusses
and closely monitors the financial
performance and strategic direction of
the Group.
During 2023 the Board received
presentations and deep-dive sessions in
key business areas, including the following
topics:
CSR.
Corporate Banking.
Digital channels and strategy.
ESG.
Human capital development.
IT and data analytics.
Mass Retail Banking.
Recovery Plan.
Regulatory changes.
SME Banking.
Values, culture and principles.
Board effectiveness review.
International opportunities.
A non-exhaustive list of the key Board
activities considered, reviewed and
monitored during the year is set out
below.
Strategy
Reviewed the Company’s
business principles, purpose and
strategy.
Reviewed performance against
strategy.
Received regular updates
from key areas of the Group’s
operations.
Received presentations from
external speakers regarding
the international geopolitical
environment.
Continued to monitor the
ongoing impact of the Russia-
Ukraine war.
Received updates on key projects
Attended a two-day in-person
strategy meeting.
Further information about the
strategy meeting can be found on
page 192.
Financial performance
Reviewed and approved
quarterly, half-year and full-year
results.
Received quarterly Group
financial performance updates.
Declared a final dividend in
respect of the period ended 31
December 2022 of GEL 5.80 per
share, and an interim dividend
in respect of the period ended
30 June 2023 of GEL 3.06 per
ordinary share, in line with the
Company’s dividend and capital
distribution policy.
Approved an increase of up
to GEL 148 million in its share
buyback and cancellation
programme, which commenced
in February 2023.
Approved the launch of a GEL
62 million share buyback and
cancellation programme in the
second half of 2023.
Completed its previous GEL
260.7 million buyback and
cancellation programme, having
repurchased and cancelled
3,254,705 ordinary shares,
representing 6.6% of the
Company’s issued share capital.
Reviewed key financial metrics
including the annual budget and
quarterly forecasts.
Reviewed and approved the
Groups Annual Report and
Accounts.
Reviewed and approved the
Notice of Annual General
Meeting.
Governance, regulation,
and compliance
Conducted an externally
facilitated effectiveness
evaluation of the Board, its
Committees, individual Directors
and the Chairman of the Board.
Discussed Board succession
planning and began recruitment
for the Audit Chair.
Received governance updates
and considered legislative and
governance developments and
their impact on the Company.
Reviewed conflicts of interest.
Reviewed and approved
amended governance
documents including Roles
and Responsibilities, Terms of
Reference, Matters Reserved
for the Board and other Board-
owned policies.
Approved the new Responsible
Supply Chain Policy and the
Environmental Policy.
Culture and engagement
with stakeholders
Received reports about
engagement with shareholders
and other stakeholders, including
reports from the investor
roadshow.
Received the results of employee
and customer surveys.
Discussed employee retention
strategies.
Reviewed the Bank’s equity pay
gap.
Reviewed the Bank’s CSR
initiatives.
Received reports on engagement
with the NBG.
Received reports from the
designated Non-executive
Director for engagement with
the workforce.
Reviewed the findings of
the employee values and
culture survey noting areas of
opportunity.
192
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Board meetings and stakeholder engagement during 2023
February 2023
• Ad hoc meeting
• 4Q22 and FY2022
Preliminary Results
• Strategy meeting
March 2023
• Board meeting
• Approval of FY2022 Annual
Report and the Notice of
Annual General Meeting
Employee Voice meeting
May 2023
• Ad hoc meeting
• 1Q23 Results
• Annual General Meeting
All resolutions were passed
with the requisite majority.
Further details about the
meeting can be found on
https://bankofgeorgiagroup.
com/information/meetings.
June 2023
• Board meeting
Employee Voice meeting
Directors’ Governance Statement continued
Purpose
• To discuss and review the Company’s strategy and performance, considering stakeholder views and
the long-term success of the Company.
Attendees
• The Board.
• External speakers from the banking sector and fintech sector.
Key themes and
discussions
• Review of the Company’s strategy and performance.
• Customer perspectives.
• Investor perspectives.
Outcomes
• The Board agreed that there was appetite and support for the Group’s excess capital to be deployed
for international growth.
Board strategy days
Culture
In February 2023 the Board attended a dedicated two-day in-person strategy meeting.
Aligning with purpose,
values and strategy
People are at the heart of our strategy
and guide everything we do. We aspire
to support them at different stages of
their lives – empowering our customers
with an integrated ecosystem of products
and services, empowering our employees
with a fair and inclusive workplace
and opportunities for personal and
professional growth, and empowering
people in our communities by fostering
financial inclusion and education with our
core products and services, as well as with
our community projects.
Our brand values and business principles
– developed in consultation with the
Board and management, and taking into
consideration eNPS surveys, employee
feedback and the Barrett Organisational
Culture and Values assessment – have
been designed to ensure our purpose
isachieved.
Our brand values
Motivation
Courage
Creation/Action
Encouragement
Our business principles
Fairness
Customer-centricity
Teamwork
Development
Innovation
Operational excellence
193
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
August 2023
• Ad hoc meeting
• Approval of Interim
Dividend
• Launch of buyback and
cancellation programme
• 2Q23 and HY23 Results
September 2023
• Board meeting
Employee Voice meeting
November 2023
• 3Q23 Results
December 2023
• Board meeting
Taking into account employee feedback
– including as raised in the Employee
Voice meetings (see below for details on
this forum) – and how the values and
principles were being embedded to date,
the Board reviewed and considered these
brand values and business principles again
during the period and confirmed that
theyremained appropriate.
Tone from the top
We strive to cultivate a culture of
collaboration and learning, and promote
this throughout the Group by setting
the tone at the top – demonstrating the
Company’s values and principles through
our decisions and actions. In conjunction
with management, the Board ensures the
implementation of appropriate policies and
procedures clearly setting the expectation
that every employee acts ethically and
transparently in all their dealings. This
fosters an environment where business and
compliance are interlinked.
Our CEO has made culture one of his
leadership priorities and is actively
promoting diversity as one of the
cornerstones of culture. The percentage
of women in the Executive Committee
equivalent and direct reports for the
Group was 48.8% as at 31 October
2023 – the date of the most recent FTSE
Women Leaders Review. According to the
statistics in this external report on FTSE
250 companies, the Group is 12
th
overall
and ranked 2
nd
in the banking sector. To
encourage all employees to participate in
the development of the Groups culture,
our CEO writes a vlog for employees,
records video messages, updates the
Group with examples of employees going
the extra mile to inspire, highlights where
employees have shown potential, and
holds live discussions where employees
can ask questions and talk directly with
him. More information on our employee
engagement initiatives can be found on
pages 53 to 54 and 119 to 132, and later in
this report.
In line with the recommendations of
the Code, Hanna Loikkanen has been
appointed as the designated Non-
executive Director to engage with
the workforce. Three Employee Voice
meetings, which aim to support the
exchange of opinions, ideas and views
between the Board and employees –
were held in March, June and September
2023, facilitated by Hanna Loikkanen
and with all Board members invited to
participate. A total of 61 employees from
across the business attended, discussing
the current employee experience,
challenges and opportunities, and how
to increase employee engagement
and the attractiveness of the Bank as
an employer. Employees valued the
opportunity to have face-to-face time
with members of the Board and share
their thoughts on the Company.
Separately, several Board members
provide regular mentoring to members
of the Executive Management team
and senior management on leadership,
employee engagement and culture
creation. The Board regularly make
themselves available to the business and
attend social gatherings with mid and
senior level employees to hear directly from
employees.
Monitoring and measuring
During 2023, the Board continued to
monitor and assess the Group’s culture.
We received regular updates on our
employees to ensure they are listened to
and that outcomes from interactions are
followed up. We also received an update
on the scores from the internal eNPS and
Employee Engagement survey which was
undertaken by Korn Ferry, the details of
which can be found on pages 130 to 131 in
our Empowering employees section. Every
employee is encouraged to participate
in the development of our culture, and
the Board has received updates on the
processes by which the culture is being
shaped. We also receive updates on
NetPromotor Score (‘NPS’) and customer
satisfaction, including how the Company
performs versus its peers.
The Board considers that below activities are effective ways for the Directors and Executive Management to gain insight into the
Groups culture and employee satisfaction.
People Customers External Recognition
Employee Voice
• eNPS
• Employee Engagement scores
• Retention
• Career progression
• Talent development
• Diversity and inclusion
• Whistleblowing and ethics reports
• Completion of mandatory training
• NPS
• Customer satisfaction
• Awards
• Competitor analysis
194
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Composition, succession and evaluation
Diversity
We believe diversity of skills, background,
knowledge, experience, geographic
location, nationality, and gender is
important to effectively govern the
business. The Board and its Nomination
Committee work to ensure the Board
continues to have the right balance
of skills, experience, knowledge and
independence necessary to discharge its
responsibilities in accordance with the
highest standards of governance.
The Board considers the following targets
when reviewing Board composition,
drawing on the FTSE Women Leaders
Review, the Parker Review and the Listing
Rules and Disclosure Guidance and
Transparency Rules:
40% of women on the Board and
leadership teams by the end of 2025;
at least one woman in the Chair,
Senior Independent Director, Chief
Executive Officer or Finance Director
roles by the end of 2025; and
one Director from a minority ethnic
background on the Board by 2024
Compliance with these targets is
discussed further in the Nomination
Committee Report on pages 210 to 212.
In respect of the target outlined in the
second bullet point above, and for the
purposes of LR 9.8.6R(9), the Company
has met this target as our Senior
Independent Director is a woman. We
are proud that in the recently released
2024 FTSE Women Leaders Review for
the FTSE 250, with 48.8% women in the
Executive Committee equivalent and
direct reports, we placed 12th overall
and 2nd for the banking sector. Female
representation on the Board is 33%.
As a FTSE 250 company the Board is
also mindful of the aims of the Parker
Review for companies to have at least
one Director from an ethnic minority
background by 2024. We are pleased to
confirm that the Company has met this
target, with three members of the Board
from a minority ethnic background.
The Company notes the Parker Review
is asking companies to consider
setting a percentage target for senior
management team that will be occupied
by ethnic minority executives in December
2027. Given the majority of the senior
management identify as being from an
ethnic minority background, it is believed
that setting a target for our Group would
be artificial. Further information on
diversity can be found on pages 210 to
212.
As part of the ongoing succession cycle,
the Board takes into consideration all
aspects of diversity during the process for
recruiting new Non-executive Directors.
Our approach to diversity is balanced
with the need to appoint Directors
who can best serve the interests of the
Company and shareholders, as well as
having relevant experience for a banking
business substantially based in Georgia.
Further information on the composition,
evaluation and succession of the Board
can be found on pages 208 to 209.
Diversity and
Inclusion Policy
The Groups Diversity and Inclusion Policy
applies to all employees of the Group, all
functions, all units in the Group and all
subsidiaries, with regard to age, gender,
ethnicity, sexual orientation, disability and
socioeconomic background.
The Board, Audit Committee, Nomination
Committee, Risk Committee and
Remuneration Committee have regard
for the Diversity and Inclusion Policy when
reviewing their composition, succession
planning and future appointments.
More information on the Group’s Diversity
and Inclusion Policy can be found on page
211 in the Nomination Committee Report.
As part of the annual review of Board-
owned policies, in September 2023 the
Board approved the following policies:
Diversity and Inclusion Policy
Anti-discrimination and Anti-
harassment Policy
Human Rights Policy
These policies are clear and easy to follow,
and are based on international best
practice.
We were pleased to see high levels
of engagement with the eNPS and
Employee Engagement survey and
that the scores have increased from
2022. Thisincrease is attributed to the
development of key initiatives including:
the Employee Experience team
gathering regular feedback from
employees and providing insights
intoissues and solutions;
the enhancement of the onboarding
experience to become more structured
and uniform;
the refinement of process and
promotion criteria at the Bank level
which has created transparent
guidelines for every position,
simplifying career paths and
empowering employees with a clear
view of their professional trajectory;
the enhancement of collaboration
and engagement through improved
interpersonal communication; and
the comprehensive annual review of
employee pay to recognise the intrinsic
value of each role and respond to
market dynamics.
These concerted efforts collectively
foster a positive and motivating work
environment, aligning with our corporate
ethos of prioritising employee satisfaction
and professional development.
91% of our employees completed the
Risk and Compliance programme,
an improvement on 86% in 2022. We
recognise that further improvement
is required in this area as we strive for
100% completion to enhance risk culture.
Initiatives to increase the effectiveness of
this training programme are underway,
including improving the user experience
of the courses and content, and reviewing
the courses to change the frequency of
required retaking where necessary.
In 2024, the Board will continue to engage
with our employees, monitor culture,
further improve employee experiences,
and monitor the output from the eNPS,
Employee Engagement surveys and other
appropriate metrics which provide insight
into the Group’s culture.
Directors’ Governance Statement continued
195
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Cecil Quillen
Archil
Gachechiladze
Mariam
Megvinetukhutsesi
Andrew
McIntyre
Hanna Loikkanen
Jonathan
Muir
Mel Carvill
Véronique
McCarroll
Tamaz
Georgadze
Composition and
independence
The Board’s composition is formally
reviewed on an annual basis. We consider
that the overall size and composition
is appropriate, considering the
independence of character and integrity
of all the Directors. Each of our Non-
executive Directors occupies – and/or
has previously occupied – senior positions
in a broad range of relevant associated
sectors, bringing valuable insights to the
Board’s deliberations and contributing
significantly to decision making. No
individual or group of individuals can
dominate the decision-making process
and no undue reliance is placed on any
individual.
The Board has assessed the independence
of the Chairman and each of the seven
Non-executive Directors in line with
Principle G and Provisions 9 and 10 of
the Code. The Board considers that
the Chairman and each Non-executive
Director act in an independent and
objective manner. We consider that our
Non-executive Directors are free from
any business interest or relationship
that could materially interfere with the
exercise of their judgement in accordance
with the Code. Further information on
the review of the Board and Committee
compositions can be found on pages
208to 209.
Time commitment
The Board is satisfied that each
Non-executive Director dedicates
the necessary amount of time to
the Company’s affairs and their role.
Considering the matters above, the Board
believes the Non-executive Directors have
retained their independence and that it
is appropriate to put them forward for
election or re-election at the AGM.
Succession planning
The succession plan for the Board and
its Committees is a continuous process
taking into consideration both short- and
long-term plans for the refreshment and
retirement of Directors. During the year,
in particular, the Board has been mindful
of the NBG independence requirements
that stipulate a Non-executive Director’s
independence is affected when they have
served on the Board more than seven
years. To comply with this rule, Hanna
Loikkanen stepped down as Chair of
the Remuneration Committee and was
replaced by Cecil Quillen with effect from
1 January 2023.
Under the NBG independence
requirement at the time of reviewing
the Directors succession planning,
Jonathan Muir was considered to be
non-independent and unable to Chair
the Audit Committee from July 2024.
Accordingly, during the year we undertook
a search for an additional Non-executive
Director with the appropriate skills,
knowledge and experience to succeed
Jonathan Muir as Audit Chair in the
future and we were pleased to identify
Andrew McIntyre as our preferred
candidate – confirming his appointment
on 15 March 2024 as announced to
the market on the same day. For this
recruitment process, the Committee
engaged Korn Ferry, an executive search
firm to support the Committee and
ensure a broad selection of appropriate
candidates was reviewed. Korn Ferry has
no other connection with Bank of Georgia
or its Directors.
Since year end, Al Breach stepped down
as a Non-executive Director and a
member of the Remuneration Committee,
Risk Committee, and Nomination
Committee on 15 March 2024.
At the end of 2023, the NBG updated
theindependence requirement
increasing this from seven to nine
years. The Committee will take this into
consideration when reviewing succession
planning during 2024.
Additional consideration was given to
the succession of the CEO from different
time horizon perspectives, including
contingency and long-term planning.
Further information on succession
planning and the Director appointment
process can be found on page 209 of the
Nomination Committee Report.
196
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Governance Statement continued
Recognising that there are different
ways an external evaluation can
be conducted, we reflected on the
approach we thought would be most
beneficial and provide the most value,
including interviews and an open
question on views on culture. This
was taken into consideration when
reviewing potential evaluators and the
selection of an appropriate evaluator.
The Evaluator conducted one-to-one
interviews with the members of the
Board and a selection of other regular
meeting attendees, including the CFO,
CRO, the UK General Counsel, Head of
Human Capital Management, Head of
Internal Audit and the EY Audit Partner.
The Evaluator followed the agreed
interview agenda and discussed further
questions and topics as appropriate.
The initial findings of the external
evaluation were discussed with the
Chair and the UK General Counsel
prior to presenting the results to
the Board and its Committees in
September 2023.
Further information regarding the 2023 effectiveness evaluation, the key outcomes and progress made against the agreed action
plan can be found on page 212 of the Nomination Committee Report.
Managing the
agenda and materials
Succession planning Risk and compliance
Additional time for
strategic discussions
Invitations to tender were issued to several
providers and interviews were conducted
with those who offered to provide services.
The Chairman and the Senior Independent
Director considered the experience and
approach of each provider, and a preferred
evaluator was identified. Following
recommendation from the Chairman and
the Senior Independent Director, the Board
appointed Clare Chalmers Ltd as the
external evaluator and agreed the timeline
and process of the evaluation.
On 15 and 16 June 2023, the Evaluator
attended the meetings of the Board,
Audit Committee, Nomination
Committee, Risk Committee and
Remuneration Committee in person
inTbilisi.
Key suggestions were put forward by the
Evaluator for our review and consideration.
The Board and its Committees reviewed
these suggestions, and a schedule of
actions was created to monitor their
implementation and adoption.
The Chair and the UK General Counsel
met with the Evaluator to establish
the evaluation process. The evaluation
focused on Board composition and
culture, Board oversight, stakeholders,
Board efficiency, the Committees, and
Board and Committee papers. A meeting
between the Chairman and the Evaluator
was held to agree the focus and scope of
the evaluation and the framework for the
interview agenda.
The Evaluator conducted a thorough
document review, including but not
limited to the Board and Committee
papers, Board and committee minutes,
Committee Terms of Reference, the
Board calendar and forward agenda
planners, director training materials, the
skills matrix, the outputs of the last Board
evaluation, and the 2022 Annual Report.
In December 2023 the Nomination
Committee reviewed progress to date
against the actions – and will continue to
monitor this throughout 2024.
1. Evaluation design
6. Interviews
7. Analysis, presentations and
discussions
Key outcome topics
2. Selection and appointment of
an independent evaluator
5. Board and Committee
observations
8. Actions
3. Design and scope of evaluation
4. Document review
9. Progress
External effectiveness evaluation
In line with best practice and in accordance with the UK Code and the FRC Guidance on Board Effectiveness, the performance of
the Board, its Committees, the Chairman and the individual Directors is evaluated annually. The evaluation is externally evaluated
every three years and during 2023 was externally facilitated by Clare Chalmers Ltd – the process of which is detailed below. The
Evaluator has no other connection to the Company or the individual Directors and is thereforeindependent.
197
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Board induction, training,
professional development
and independent advice
On appointment each Director
participates in an induction programme
during which they meet members
of senior management and receive
information about the role of the
Board and individual Directors, each
Board Committee and their respective
delegated powers. They are also advised
by the UK General Counsel and Company
Secretary of their legal and regulatory
obligations as a Director of a company
premium-listed on the London Stock
Exchange.
Induction sessions are designed to be
interactive and are tailored to individuals
based on their previous experience and
knowledge. In addition, Directors are
informed of the Company’s strategy and
structure, and how the business operates.
We are committed to ensuring the
continued development of our Directors
so they can build on their expertise
and develop an ever-more detailed
understanding of the Business and the
markets in which Group companies
operate.
All our Directors participated in ongoing
training and professional development
throughout 2023, including briefings and
presentations by the UK General Counsel,
our Company Secretary, members of
management and our professional
advisors. During the year the Directors
received updates on regulatory and
legislative changes, including but not
limited to: the FRC’s minimum standards
for audit committees; the FRC’s
consultation and proposed updates to
the Code; proposed and actual changes
to the UK Listing Regime; the Economic
Crime and Corporate Transparency Act
(‘ECCTA’); changes to the NBG rules
regarding conflicts of interest, persons
closely associated and ESG guidelines;
changes to Georgian data protection
requirements; and proxy advisor voting
guidelines.
Audit Committee members also received
updates on developments in audit and
accounting, including: delayed primary
legislation relating to the audit and
corporate governance reform; mandatory
climate-related financial disclosures; the
FRC’s consultation and proposed updates
to the Code; TCFD reporting; and the
ECCTA.
During the year the Directors also
received training materials on Directors’
duties. All Directors have access to
the advice of the UK General Counsel
and Company Secretary, as well as
independent professional advice at the
Company’s expense, on any matter
relating to their responsibilities.
Audit, risk and internal
control
The Group has a comprehensive system
of risk management and internal controls
in place, designed to ensure risks are
identified, assessed and mitigated, and
that the Groups objectives are attained.
The Board believes risk culture is at the
heart of the Groups risk management
framework. Further information on the
risk framework is available on page 144
and information on the risk culture of the
Group is available on page 145.
The Board recognises its responsibility
to present a fair, balanced and
understandable assessment of the
Groups position and prospects. The
Board has overseen the process for
determining whether the Annual Report
and Accounts present a fair, balanced
and understandable assessment of
the Groups position and performance,
business model and strategy. A statement
on this is made on page 248.
During the year the Audit Committee
has retained focus on the review and
improvement of internal controls,
despite delays to the UK legislation
required to establish the Audit, Reporting
and Governance Authority. Further
information on internal controls can be
found in the Audit Committee Report on
page 222.
The Board is accountable for reviewing and
approving the effectiveness of the internal
controls operated by the Group, including
financial, operational and compliance
controls, and risk management. Further
information on the Groups internal
controls is available on page 145 and
information on the effectiveness review is
available on page 146.
The Board recognises its responsibility in
respect of the Group’s risk management
process and system of internal controls,
and oversees the activities of the Groups
external auditor and risk management
function supported by the Audit and Risk
Committees.
The Groups risk management approach is
further discussed in the risk management
section of the Strategic Report on
pages 143 to 148. For details on the
management of principal risks and
uncertainties please refer to pages 149
to 169. Please refer to pages 214 to 223
for further details on the role of the
Audit Committee and pages 224 to 228
for further details on the role of the Risk
Committee.
Remuneration
The Remuneration Committee ensures
our remuneration policies and practices
supporting the Company’s strategy and
promoting its long-term sustainable
success. Directors exercise independent
judgement and discretion when
authorising remuneration outcomes,
taking account Company and individual
performance and wider circumstances.
The Committee has adopted a formal
and transparent procedure for developing
policy on executive remuneration
and determining Director and senior
management remuneration. No
Director is involved in deciding their own
remuneration outcome.
Detailed information regarding the
Company’s remuneration arrangements
can be found on pages 229 to 247 of the
Directors’ Remuneration Report.
198
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Mel Carvill Archil Gachechiladze
CEO
Hanna Loikkanen
Senior Independent
Non-executive Director
Board of Directors
Date of appointment
March 2022
Date of appointment
February 2018
Date of appointment
January 2019
Committee memberships
N Re
Skills and experience
Mr Carvill has extensive international
experience across a broad range of
companies in the financial sector. He qualified
as a Chartered Accountant at Coopers &
Lybrand and is a Fellow of the Institute
of Chartered Accountants in England and
Wales. He holds an Advanced Diploma in
Corporate Finance, is a Chartered Insurer
and an Associate of the Chartered Insurance
Institute, as well as a Fellow of the Chartered
Institute for Securities and Investment.
Career
Mr Carvill worked at the Generali Group
from 1985 until 2009, holding various
positions including Chief Risk Officer, Head
of Corporate Finance and M&A and of
Strategic Planning. He also served as Head of
Western Europe, Americas and Middle East
at Generali. In 2009 he joined PPF Partners,
a private equity fund investing in Central
Eastern Europe and Asia, where he held the
position of President until 2014, and then
worked for the wider PPF Group, latterly
serving as an advisor. Mr Carvill served on
company boards in European and Asian
markets, including as senior independent
director of Sanne Group plc.
Other appointments
Vice-chairman of Aviva-Cofco Life Insurance
Company Ltd
Director of Clearbank Group Holdings Ltd
Chairman of Financial Services
Opportunities Investment Fund Ltd
Member of the operating board of Genesis
Investment Management LLP
Director of Guernsey Investment Fund
Director of Home Credit B.V.
Committee memberships
Re A N
Skills and experience
Ms Loikkanen has over 25 years of experience
working with financial institutions in
Russia and Eastern Europe. She holds a
master’s degree in Economics and Business
Administration from Aalto University and
has attained a certificate in Corporate
Sustainability Management from Yale SOM.
Career
Ms Loikkanen has worked for Nordea
Finance in various senior management
positions in Poland, the Baltic States and
Scandinavia with a focus on business
development, strategy and business
integration; for SEB in Moscow where she
was responsible for the restructuring of
SEB’s debt capital market operations in
Russia; and for MeritaNordbanken in St
Petersburg where she focused on trade
finance and correspondent banking. In
2004, Ms Loikkanen joined FIM, a Finnish
investment bank, to run their brokerage
and corporate finance operations in Russia.
From 2007 to 2015 Ms Loikkanen worked
at the Moscow office of Swedish asset
management company East Capital,
managing a private equity fund focusing
on investments in financial institutions in
the region. She previously served as an
independent director of BGEO Group PLC,
which included positions on their Nomination
and Risk Committees.
Other appointments
Executive director of OnBoardSolution Oy
Chief Investment Officer at FinnFund
(Finnish Fund for Industrial Cooperation
Ltd)
Non-executive director of VEF AB
Non-executive director of Eastnine AB
Non-executive board member of Caucasus
Nature Fund
Committee memberships
Skills and experience
Mr Gachechiladze has over 20 years of
experience in financial services in both local
and international organisations. He received
his undergraduate degree in Economics from
Tbilisi State University and holds his MBA
with distinction from Cornell University. He is
also a CFA Charterholder and a member of
the CFA Society in the UK.
Career
Mr Gachechiladze held senior positions
between 1998 and 2009 at the World Bank’s
CERMA, KPMG, The European Bank for
Reconstruction and Development (EBRD),
Salford Equity Partners, Lehman Brothers
Private Equity (currently Trilantic Capital
Partners) and TBC Bank. In 2009 he joined
the Bank as Deputy CEO, Corporate Banking
and has since held various roles with the
Bank and the Group, such as Deputy CEO,
Investment Management, CFO of BGEO
Group and Deputy CEO, Corporate and
Investment Banking. Prior to his appointment
as CEO, Mr Gachechiladze served as CEO of
Georgian Global Utilities (formerly part of
BGEO Group PLC).
199
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Andrew McIntyre
Independent Non-executive Director
Tamaz Georgadze
Independent Non-executive Director
Jonathan Muir
Independent Non-executive Director
Date of appointment
March 2024
Committee memberships
A N
Skills and experience
Mr McIntyre is a qualified Chartered
Accountant with broad experience of
financial services businesses operating
around the world. Since retiring from Ernst
& Young in 2016, he has built a portfolio
career, predominantly in the financial services
industry. He holds a master’s degree from
Cambridge University in Medical Sciences
and Music.
Career
Mr McIntyre was a partner at Ernst &
Young from 1988 to 2016, specialising in
international financial services. He was based
in the firm’s London offices during this time,
apart from a period spent in the Zurich office
between 2004 and 2010. At Ernst & Young, he
acted for some of the firm’s largest financial
services clients and held various management
positions, including as a member of the
UK firm’s board. Mr McIntyre is the senior
independent director of C. Hoare & Co. and
is a non-executive director of Lloyds Bank
Corporate Markets plc. He has previously held
board positions at National Bank of Greece
S.A., Ecclesiastical Insurance Group plc and
the Centre for Economic Policy Research.
Other appointments
Senior independent director of C.Hoare
& Co
Non-executive director of Lloyds Bank
Corporate Markets plc
Non-executive director of Target Group
Limited
Trustee and treasurer of the Foundling
Museum
Date of appointment
February 2018
Committee memberships
Re Ri N
Skills and experience
Mr Georgadze has extensive experience with
a wide range of international companies. He
holds two PhDs, one in Economics from Tbilisi
State University and the other in Agricultural
Economics from Justus-Liebig Universität
Gießen, Germany. Mr Georgadze also studied
Law at Justus-Liebig Universität Gießen and
graduated with honours.
Career
Mr Georgadze worked as an aide to the
President of Georgia in the Foreign Relations
Department from 1994 to 1995. He had a
ten-year career at McKinsey & Company in
Berlin, where he served as a Partner from
2009 to 2013. At McKinsey & Company,
he conducted engagements with banks
in Germany, Switzerland, Russia, Georgia
and Vietnam, focusing on strategy, risk
identification and management, deposit and
investment products, operations and sales.
In 2013, Mr Georgadze founded Raisin, which
launched the first global deposit platform
in Europe and he continues to serve as its
CEO. Mr Georgadze previously served as an
independent non-executive director of BGEO
Group PLC, which included positions on their
Audit, Nomination and Risk Committees.
Other appointments
General director at Raisin GmbH
Member of Digital Finance Forum at the
Ministry of Finance of Germany
Member of the main management board of
Bitkom, the German association of
software companies and telco providers
Date of appointment
February 2018
Committee memberships
A N
Skills and experience
Mr Muir has over 30 years’ experience working
as a professional in accounting and finance.
He graduated with first class honours from
St. Andrews University in the UK. He is a
British-qualified Chartered Accountant and
a member of the Institute of Chartered
Accountants of England and Wales.
Career
Mr Muir was a partner at the global audit
and consulting company Ernst & Young
from 1985 to 2000. From 2003 to 2013, he
was Vice President of Finance and Control,
then CFO of TNK-BP, which he joined after
serving as CFO of SIDANCO, one of TNK-BP’s
heritage companies. Mr Muir is an executive
director (CEO) of LetterOne Holdings SA and
is CEO of LetterOne Investment Holdings
SA. LetterOne is an international investment
business consisting of two groups which
target investments in the healthcare, energy,
telecoms and technology, and retail sectors.
Mr Muir previously served as an independent
non-executive director of BGEO Group
PLC including positions on its Audit and
Nomination Committees.
Other appointments
Director of LetterOne Holdings SA and of
LetterOne Investment Holdings SA
200
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Véronique McCarroll
Independent Non-executive Director
Board of Directors continued
Date of appointment
February 2018
Date of appointment
March 2021
Date of appointment
October 2018
Committee memberships
Ri N
Skills and experience
Ms Megvinetukhutsesi has extensive
governance and financial experience. She
received her undergraduate degree in Banking
and Finance from Tbilisi State University and
holds an MSc in Finance and Investments
from the University of Edinburgh.
Career
Ms Megvinetukhutsesi has 20 years’ prior
experience in financial services, including
in banking appointments at the European
Bank for Reconstruction and Development
from 1997 to 2007 and as Deputy CEO at
TBC Bank from 2009 to 2014. Previously she
served as Head of Georgia’s Investors Council
Secretariat from 2015 to 2019, promoting
reforms for improvement of Georgia’s
investment climate. Ms Megvinetukhutsesi
provides consulting services to businesses on
governance and financial management.
Committee memberships
Ri N
Skills and experience
Ms McCarroll has over 30 years’ experience
in financial services, with a strong focus
on corporate and investment banking, risk
management and digital banking. She
graduated from ESSEC (Ecole Supérieure des
Sciences Economiques et Commerciales)
in 1985.
Career
Ms McCarroll started her career with
Banque Indosuez in Capital Markets in 1986,
serving in various front office fixed income
and then market risk management roles.
She was an executive director at Crédit
Agricole CIB, in charge of Strategy and
Business Transformation, and spent 19 years
in consulting firms, helping large banking
clients on risk and finance matters, including
as a Partner at McKinsey & Company, Oliver
Wyman and Andersen/Ernst & Young.
As a Deputy CEO at Orange Bank S.A.,
Ms McCarroll has responsibility for finance,
data office, risk and compliance and SME
subsidiary, having previously headed Strategy
and Innovation for Mobile Finance and Digital
banking across Europe at Orange. She also
teaches Finance at Paris Dauphine University.
Other appointments
Non-executive director of Moonstone
Lending Fund
Deputy CEO – Finance, Risk and
Compliance, Orange Bank S.A.
Committee memberships
Re A N
Skills and experience
Mr Quillen has extensive legal and
commercial experience in Europe and the
US, particularly with respect to regulated
financial institutions and emerging markets.
He received his undergraduate degree
from Harvard and his law degree from the
University of Virginia.
Career
Mr Quillen is a lawyer and a London-based
US partner of global law firm Linklaters LLP,
where he is a leading US capital markets
practitioner in the London market. He works
on a broad spectrum of securities and finance
matters; a particular focus of his practice has
been transactions in the CIS and in central
and eastern Europe. Mr Quillen became
a partner of Linklaters in 1996 and was
resident in the firm’s New York office before
transferring to the London office in 2000.
He is admitted to practice in New York and
the District of Columbia and is a registered
foreign lawyer in England and Wales.
Other appointments
Partner at Linklaters LLP
Officer of the Securities Law Committee of
the International Bar Association
Officer of the Advisory Committee for
Securities Regulation in Europe of the
Practicing Law Institute
Trustee of the University of Virginia Law
School Foundation
Trustee of Harvard Global Foundation and
UK Friends of Harvard University
Trustee of the Dulwich Picture Gallery
Board Committees
Remuneration Committee
Re
Risk Committee
Ri
Nomination Committee
N
Audit Committee
A
Chair of Committee
Cecil Quillen
Independent Non-executive Director
Mariam
Megvinetukhutsesi
Independent Non-executive Director
Mr Al Breach served as an Independent Non-
Executive Director of Bank of Georgia Group
Plc, as a member of the Remuneration, Risk
and Nomination Committees, and served on
the Supervisory Board, until 15 March 2024.
201
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Management Team
Archil Gachechiladze
Executive Director and CEO of Bank of Georgia Group PLC and CEO of Bank of Georgia
See page 198 for his biography
Sulkhan Gvalia
Deputy CEO, Chief Financial Officer
Skills and experience: Sulkhan has extensive experience in banking,
having served in various senior roles at Bank of Georgia, including
Deputy CEO – Chief Risk Officer (2005-2013) and Deputy CEO
– Head of Corporate Banking (2013-2016). Prior to his recent
appointment, Sulkhan was the founder and CEO of E-Space
Limited – the only Georgian company developing electric car
charging infrastructure in Georgia. Sulkhan started his career in
banking at TbilUniversalBank and served as its Deputy CEO before
its acquisition by Bank of Georgia in November 2004.
Education: Sulkhan holds a bachelor’s degree in law from Tbilisi State
University.
Appointed: May 2019
Nutsiko Gogilashvili
Deputy CEO, Mass Retail Banking
Skills and experience: Nutsiko joined Bank of Georgia in 2016 as
Head of Strategic Processes of Corporate and Investment Banking,
responsible for human capital and customer experience initiatives in
the Corporate and Investment Banking business.
Prior to her recent appointment, Nutsiko was Head of Human Capital
Management and Customer Experience during 2019-2022, directly
reporting to the CEO.
Before joining Bank of Georgia, Nutsiko was at TBC Bank where she
held the role of Head of Strategic Planning and Budgeting. Before
taking up this role, during 2011-2014, Nutsiko worked as an analyst at
JP Morgan in London, covering different products.
Education: Nutsiko holds a master’s degree in finance from Bayes
Business School and a bachelor’s degree in economics from Moscow
State Institute of International Relations.
Appointed: September 2022
202
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Management Team continued
Eteri Iremadze
Deputy CEO, Premium Banking
Skills and experience: Eteri was appointed Head of SOLO in May
2019and became Deputy CEO in March 2021, and has been leading
SOLO and WM businesses since April 2021
Eteri joined Bank of Georgia early in her career in 2006 in Corporate
Banking, in various roles, including senior positions. During 2009-2016
she was Head of Blue Chip Corporate Banking Unit, responsible for
structured lending, M&A, significant buyouts and project financing.
Prior to her recent appointment, Eteri spent two years as Head of
Strategic Projects Department at Georgian Global Utilities (formerly
part of BGEO Group PLC).
Education: Eteri holds an MBA from Grenoble Business School and
a bachelor’s degree in economics and commerce from Tbilisi State
University.
Appointed: March 2021
Mikheil Gomarteli
Deputy CEO, Strategic Projects Direction
Skills and experience: Mikheil joined Bank of Georgia in 1997 and served
in various senior and executive roles.
Prior to this appointment, Mikheil was Deputy CEO, leading the
Bank’s Retail Banking business since 2009. Throughout his time with
the Bank, Mikheil has been instrumental to Retail Banking and digital
transformations and was behind many key initiatives launched during
the past few years.
Education: Mikheil holds a bachelor’s degree in economics from Tbilisi
State University.
Appointed: September 2022
Davit Chkonia
Deputy CEO, Chief Risk Officer
Skills and experience: Prior to his current role, Davit served as a senior
advisor and Director of International Business at Bank of Georgia
during 2021-2022. Before joining the Bank, he held senior positions
in local and international organisations. He was Deputy CEO/Chief
Risk Officer at TBC Bank during 2017-2020. Previous to that, Davit
was Director at BlackRock in London, where he advised financial
institutions and regulators on risk management, balance sheet
strategy and regulation, Senior Vice President at PIMCO, responsible
for the risk advisory practice. During 2009-2011, Davit Chkonia worked
at European Resolution Capital.
Education: Davit holds an MBA from the Wharton School of the
University of Pennsylvania and a bachelor’s degree in finance from
San Jose State University.
Appointed: July 2022
203
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Vakhtang Bobokhidze
Co-director of International Business
Skills and experience: Vakhtang joined the Bank in 2005 as a Quality
Control Manager and progressed through a number of positions,
including Analyst-Developer, IT Business Consultant, Director of IT
Department, culminating in his appointment as Deputy CEO in charge
of IT in March 2018. From January 2021 to June 2022 he served as
Deputy CEO in charge of IT, Data Analytics, and Digital Channels.
Education: Vakhtang received his bachelor’s degree in computer
sciences, economics and master’s degree in informatics from Tbilisi
State University.
Appointed: January 2023
Zurab Kokosadze
Deputy CEO, Corporate and Investment Banking
Skills and experience: Zurab became Head of Corporate Banking
in June 2020 and became Deputy CEO, leading Corporate and
Investment Banking direction in March 2021.
Zurab joined Bank of Georgia in 2003 as a Junior Corporate Banker
and has progressed through various positions, being in senior roles
prior to his recent appointment. He served as Head of Corporate
Banking, under Deputy CEO, during 2017-2020.
Education: Zurab holds an MBA from Grenoble Graduate School of
Business and a bachelor’s in business administration from Caucasus
School of Business.
Appointed: March 2021
David Davitashvili
Deputy CEO, Data and Information Technology
Skills and experience: David joined Bank of Georgia in 2006 and
served in various senior roles, including Deputy Chief Operating
Officer, responsible for collections, cash operations, procurement, and
information security, and Head of Internal Audit from 2009 to 2017,
covering both banking and non-banking subsidiaries.
Education: David holds an Executive MBA from Bayes Business School
and a bachelor’s degree and a master’s degree in management and
microeconomics from Tbilisi State University.
Appointed: July 2022
204
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Management Team continued
Levan Gomshiashvili
Chief Marketing and Digital Officer
Skills and experience: Levan was appointed Chief Marketing Officer in
May 2019 and additionally became Chief Digital Officer in February
2023. Levan has extensive experience in marketing, having worked in
different roles, including creative manager and chief marketing officer
in international and local companies. Before joining the Bank, Levan
was the founder of HOLMES&WATSON, a creative agency, where
he served as an Account Manager for clients operating in different
sectors. Levan is also the founder of Tbilisi School of Communication,
an educational facility focused on executive education.
Education: Levan holds a master’s degree in management from the
University of Edinburgh and a bachelor’s degree in management from
Saint Petersburg State University of Economics and Finance.
Appointed: May 2019
Ana Kostava
Chief Legal Officer
Skills and experience: Ana joined Bank of Georgia in April 2018
as Senior Group Lawyer (2018-2020). Prior to that, Ana was an
Associate at Dechert LLP during 2015-2018. Ana has experience
working at the World Trade Organization Appellate Body Secretariat
and European Court of Human Rights. She started her career in law
as Associate at Legal Partners Associated LLC in 2010. Since 2015,
Ana has been an Associate Lecturer at Free University of Tbilisi.
Education: Ana holds an LLM from University of Cambridge and an
LLB from Caucasus University, Caucasus School of Law. She also
holds a Harvard Law School Executive Education Certificate of
Leadership in Corporate Counsel.
Appointed: June 2020
Tornike Kuprashvili
Head of SME Business Banking
Skills and experience: Tornike joined Bank of Georgia in 2014 as a
Principal Corporate Banker and during his 10 year career he has
progressed through the career path within Corporate Banking
business. He held various senior roles in Corporate Banking Business,
including Head of Corporate Rehabilitation and Head of Corporate
Banking Department, directly reporting to Deputy CEO during
2020-2024. Prior to joining Bank of Georgia, Tornike worked at KPMG
Tbilisi office for 3 years as an Audit assistant.
Education: Tornike holds bachelor of business administration from
Caucasus School of Business.
Appointed: April 2024
205
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Elene Okromchedlishvili
Head of Human Capital Management
Skills and experience: Elene joined the Bank in 2017 and held various
positions, including Head of IFRS Reporting Unit responsible for the
Bank’s stand-alone financial statements and those of its subsidiaries,
and Head of Operational Efficiency and Cost management Unit.
Prior to her recent appointment, Elene served as Head of Business
Processes, Lean Transformation and Transactions.
Before joining the Bank, Elene worked at EY, progressing to the
position of senior auditor.
Education: Elene holds an MBA from IE Business School and a
bachelor’s degree in business administration from Free University
Tbilisi.
Appointed: September 2022
Giorgi Gureshidze
Head of Operations
Skills and experience: Prior to this role, Giorgi had a diverse
professional experience during 2017-2023 at Georgia Global Utilities
(GGU – formerly part of BGEO Group PLC) where he held various
positions, including Investment Analyst, Head of Financial Analysis and
Research, and Head of Strategic Projects and Business Development,
before serving as Chief Financial Officer of the company during 2020-
2023. He played an instrumental role in the first Green Eurobond
issuance from the region on the Irish stock exchange in 2020 and
in the sale of GGU, the largest private transaction in Georgia.
Giorgi started his career working as an Auditor at Deloitte and also
worked as an Investor Relations Manager at TBC Bank.
Education: Giorgi holds a bachelor’s degree in Economics and Global
Affairs from Yale University.
Appointed: September 2023
Andro Ratiani
CEO of Digital Area
Skills and experience: Andro started his career in Bank of Georgia in
2002 and re-joined in January 2018 as Head of Innovation. He has
extensive experience in financial services. Previous to Bank of Georgia,
Andro was Director/Global Head of Product Management at IHS
Markit, based in New York, responsible for global and US strategic
technology projects for syndication lending. Before that, he was at
UBS AG Investment Bank and Wealth Management Bank in New York,
and at Wells Fargo.
Education: Andro holds a master’s degree in technology management
from Columbia University and a bachelor’s degree in business
administration from University of Hawaii.
Appointed: February 2021
206
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Nomination Committee Report
Membership of Nomination Committee
Committee membership Date of membership
Mel Carvill (Chair) 10 March 2022
Alasdair Breach* 24 February 2018
Tamaz Georgadze 24 February 2018
Véronique McCarroll 1 October 2018
Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi 12 March 2021
Jonathan Muir 24 February 2018
Hanna Loikkanen 24 February 2018
Cecil Quillen 24 February 2018
* Alasdair Breach resigned as a Non-executive Director and as a member of
the Committee on 15 March 2024.
The skills and experience each member contributes can be
found on pages 198 to 200.
All members of the Committee are independent Non-
executive Directors of the Board. The CEO and other
members of management may be invited to attend
meetings to provide insight into key developments.
Key objectives of the Committee
The Nomination Committee focuses on the following
matters:
Board leadership
Identifies the skills, knowledge and experience required
for effective leadership, managing the balance of the
Board through effective succession planning.
Board Committees
Monitors the size, structure and composition of the
Board’s Committees.
Succession planning
Ensures appropriate Board skills, knowledge, experience
and independence.
Talent pipeline
Monitors senior leadership pipeline and initiatives to
develop and promote internal talent.
Diversity and inclusion
In accordance with the Diversity and Inclusion Policy,
considers the perspectives and attributes of the Board
and senior leadership.
Leading on the promotion of Board dynamics through effective succession
planning, Board evaluations and a robust executive talent pipeline.
Meeting attendance
Details of the members’ attendance at the meetings of the
Committee are as follows:
Committee membership
No. of meetings
attended
Mel Carvill (Chair) 4/4 scheduled
Alasdair Breach 4/4 scheduled
Tamaz Georgadze 4/4 scheduled
Véronique McCarroll 4/4 scheduled
Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi 4/4 scheduled
Jonathan Muir 4/4 scheduled
Hanna Loikkanen 4/4 scheduled
Cecil Quillen 4/4 scheduled
2024 action plan
In the coming year the main areas of focus for the
Committee will be:
Succession planning.
Director induction.
Diversity and inclusion.
Talent pipeline.
Internal Board Evaluation and progression of external
evaluation actions.
Ameriabank structure and board composition.
The Committees Terms of Reference set out its role and
authority, and can be found on the corporate website at
www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/documents
Regular attendees at meetings
CEO, UK General Counsel and Company Secretary.
207
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Mel Carvill
Chair of Nomination
Committee
Dear Shareholders,
I am pleased to present the Nomination
Committee (the ‘Committee’) Report,
providing an overview of the work
of the Committee and its activities
during the year – particularly our role in
ensuring the Board has the right skills,
experience, knowledge and diversity to
deliver our strategy and ensure long-term
sustainable success.
Board and Committee
evaluations
The Committee carefully reviewed and
considered the 2022 Board evaluation
and the progress of actions. In addition,
it carefully considered its external Board
evaluation to ensure it provided the most
impactful outcomes for the Board and its
Committees.
After a tender process we engaged Clare
Chalmers Ltd as our external evaluator
and were pleased with the evaluation
results and areas of opportunity to
improve further. On behalf of the
Committee, we would like to thank Clare
Chalmers Ltd for their guidance.
Information on the progress of the
2022 internal evaluation outcomes can
be found on page 213 and information
regarding the 2023 external evaluation
can be found on pages 212.
Succession planning
We have been cognisant of the additional
independence requirements placed on
us by the NBG and carefully balance
these with the importance of retaining
appropriate corporate memory. When
reviewing and considering succession
planning the Committee takes care to
ensure resignations happen in an orderly
manner to comply with the NBG and
Code independence requirements.
During the year we undertook a search
for an additional Non-executive Director
with the appropriate skills, knowledge
and experience to succeed as Audit
Chair in the future – and were pleased to
identify Andrew McIntyre as our preferred
candidate.
Since year end, and in accordance with
our succession planning procedures,
Andrew McIntyre was appointed as a
Non-executive Director and member of
the Audit Committee and Nomination
Committee on 15 March 2024 and
Alasdair Breach stepped down as a
Non-executive Director and a member
of the Remuneration Committee, Risk
Committee, and Nomination Committee
on the same date. On behalf of the
Committee, I would like to welcome
Andrew McIntyre and thank Alasdair
Breach for his significant contributions to
the Company over the years.
Further information on succession
planning can be found on pages 208 and
information on the Director appointment
process can be found on pages 209.
Diversity and inclusion
Whilst there is always more that can
be done, the Committee is proud of the
work and achievements of the Company
regarding diversity and inclusion. We
remain committed to further enhancing
our female representation on the Board
to 40% by 2025 and are pleased to have
met the new regulatory requirements,
which includes having a female director
in a senior position and a director from
a minority ethnic background. Further
details on this and our commitment to
diversity can be found on pages 210 to
212.
Looking ahead
During 2024, the Committee will focus
on supporting the smooth integration
of Ameriabank CJSC, ensuring an
appropriate structure and board
composition is established for the Group.
The Committee will also continue to
implement succession planning for the
Board and senior management.
I invite you to read more about our work
in the following report.
Mel Carvill
Chair of the Nomination Committee
24 April 2024
The Committee remains focused on succession
planning and ensuring the appropriate balance
of the Board. We were pleased with the
external evaluation process and look forward to
embedding the recommendations during 2024
and beyond.
208
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Key Committee meeting topics during 2023
March June September December
Executive succession
planning;
2022 internal Board
evaluation;
External evaluation
approach;
Independence and re-
election of Directors; and
2022 Nomination
Committee Report.
Skills matrix;
Board succession planning;
Board composition;
Board diversity;
Employee Voice/workforce
engagement update; and
External evaluation process.
Board succession planning;
Board composition;
Workforce diversity;
Employee Voice/workforce
engagement update;
External evaluation results;
and
Corporate governance
review.
Board succession planning;
Board composition; and
External evaluation – action
deep dive.
Key activities during the year
Topic Summary of activity Find out more
Succession planning Reviewed the Board composition with regards to succession
planning.
Page 208
New Non-executive Director
search
Identified the required Board skills and knowledge and
identified a new Non-executive Director.
Page 209
External Board evaluation Identified an external evaluator, identified an appropriate
review process and considered the results of the external
Board evaluation.
Page 209
Workforce engagement Received updates on workforce engagement and the
Employee Voice programme.
Page 210
Board skills and experience
For balanced and effective decision
making, it is important the Board has
a broad range of skills and experience.
The Committee maintains a skills
matrix of the Board to identify areas for
enhancement, allowing the mapping of
the Board’s skills against the evolving
needs of the business and ensuring any
future search for Non-executive Directors
is focused. A summary of the Board skills
matrix can be found on page 187.
Board composition and
succession planning
A key focus during the year was the NBG
independence rules, tenure and potential
future Board retirements, and the impact
on the Board and its Committees. The
Committee remains committed to
ensuring we have a well-balanced Board
with the appropriate skills, knowledge,
experience and diversity to support the
continued growth of the Group. During
2023 the Committee considered the size,
structure, tenure and diversity of the
Board, as well as the skills and experience
of each Director.
Following this review, and taking into
consideration the NBG and Code
independence requirements in place at
the time, it was agreed the Board would
undertake a search of external candidates
with the appropriate skills, knowledge and
experience, retaining a focus on diversity,
to support the Company and ensure a
robust pipeline of potential candidates.
At the end of 2023, the NBG updated the
independence requirement increasing this
from seven to nine years. The Committee
will take this into consideration when
reviewing succession planning during 2024.
All changes to the Board and its
Committees are overseen by the
Committee and strong succession
planning remains a key focus.
Senior management and
talent pipeline
We are committed to talent development
programmes and initiatives within the
Group. We develop the skills of our
existing executive managers and develop
a pipeline of new executive, senior and
middle managers through coaching,
mentoring and leadership programmes.
We continue to expand our programmes
to include employees at lower levels.
Our talent development programmes
are transparent and promote teamwork
and development in line with our business
principles. We aim to nurture managers who:
have the courage to give and seek
honest feedback;
realise ‘a stronger me plus a stronger
you make a stronger us’;
value meritocracy;
encourage dialogue over an
authoritative decision-making style;
and
favour cooperation over individualistic
or ‘heroic’ behaviour.
During 2023 the Bank continued initiatives
to encourage talent development, with a
focus on young talent and those with high
potential.
Bank of Georgia runs Leaderator, the
most-recognised student internship
programme on the market, designed to
provide opportunities for young people to
develop various skills and competencies,
explore business and operational units,
and gain practical experience with real
projects. 376 employees have participated
in Leaderator since its launch in 2017.
Further details regarding Leaderator can
be found in the Empowering employees
section of this report on page 125.
During the year the Committee reviewed
and approved the appointment of
Vakhtang Bobokhidze to Co-director
of International Business and the
appointment of Giorgi Gureshidze as
Head of Operations. In addition, the
Committee received updates on members
of the Executive Management Team and
proposed promotions.
Further information on talent management
can be found in the Empowering employees
section on page 126 to 127.
Nomination Committee Report continued
209
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
During 2023 the Committee received
reports on the talent pipeline across the
Group for senior management positions
and has, alongside the Board, dedicated
time to strengthening the Management
Team as part of the wider strategic
development of the Group.
Board and Committee
changes
To ensure compliance with the
requirements of the NBG and the UK
Code, Hanna Loikkanen stepped down as
Chair of the Remuneration Committee
and was replaced by Cecil Quillen with
effect from 1 January 2023. Cecil Quillen
has been a member of the Remuneration
Committee since 24 February 2018 and
the Committee believes he brings relevant
and necessary skills to the position,
gained through his prior experiences and
roles as detailed on page 200.
Following this review, and as a result of
the required refreshment of the Board
to meet independence requirements, it
was agreed that Andrew McIntyre be
appointed as a Non-executive Director
and member of the Audit Committee and
Nomination Committee with effect from
15 March 2024.
The Committee received the resignation
of Alasdair Breach on 15 March 2024 as
announced to the market on the same
day.
The Committee is pleased to welcome
Andrew McIntyre to the Company and
is looking forward to working with him
to support the continued success of the
Company.
Board appointment process
Engagement of external
recruitment advisor
External recruitment advisor:
Korn Ferry
Key search criteria:
Successful senior executive finance
career, either as a CFO or former
audit partner; technically adept;
experience of UK listed company
environment; relevant geographic
experience; various characteristics,
traits and drivers; appointment to
be in accordance with the Diversity
and Inclusion Policy and to consider
diversity targets; appointment,
experience and character also to
be in accordance with JSC Bank of
Georgia Nomination Policy and the
Georgian Regulatory Framework for
administrators of Commercial Banks.
Following the decision to review Board composition, the Committee agreed the remit
and required skills, experience, independence and diversity of any new appointment.
The Committee, with support from the UK General Counsel and Company Secretary:
The Committee reviewed and considered the appointment
of the preferred candidate and recommended their
appointment to the Board. The Board considered the
recommendation and, following approval of the new Director,
an announcement was released to the market.
Made
recommendation
for Board approval
The Committee undertook a review of Board knowledge,
skills and experience, balanced with tenure and independence
requirements of the NBG and Code. Further information on
the Boards skills can be found on page 187 and information on
Board independence can be found on pages 187 and 210.
Evaluated
Board skills and
requirements:
The Committee agreed to engage an external recruitment
consultant, Korn Ferry, to support the candidate search. The
Committee instructed Korn Ferry with a job profile for the
skills and experience required with a strong focus towards
receipt of diverse candidates. Other than providing employee
engagement research to the Group, Korn Ferry has no
further connection with Bank of Georgia or its Directors.
Undertook a
candidate search:
Following receipt of a list of candidates, the Chair and the
UK General Counsel met with Korn Ferry to create a short-
list of candidates with the appropriate knowledge, skills,
experience and time to undertake the role. The Committee
reviewed the short-list and established an interview panel,
consisting of the Chair and the Audit Committee Chair, to
meet with candidates.
Reviewed the
candidates:
The Chair and Audit Committee Chair met with five
candidates before narrowing our search to the final two.
The Committee then reviewed the knowledge, skills and
experience of the candidates.
Interviewed
candidates:
The candidates were given the opportunity to meet
the Executive Management Team to help their own
understanding of the Group.
Arranged an
Executive
Management Team
meet and greet
Having identified a preferred candidate, the Committee
recommended they attend the next quarterly meeting to
observe and ensure an opportunity for both parties to assess
cultural fit.
Invited the
candidate to
observe a meeting
On appointment our Non-executive Directors are sent a letter of appointment
setting out the terms and conditions of their directorship, including the fees payable
and the expected time commitment. Each Non-executive Director is expected to
commit approximately a minimum of 25-35 days per year to the role. Additional time
commitment is required to fulfil their roles as Board Committee members and/or
Board Committee Chairs, as applicable. The Committee remains satisfied that all
Non-executive Directors dedicate the necessary amount of time to contribute to the
effectiveness of the Board.
210
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Election by shareholders
All Non-executive Directors undertake
a fixed term of three years subject to
annual re-election by shareholders.
The fixed term can be extended and,
consistent with best practice, does not
exceed nine years, subject to defined
circumstances as identified by the
Committee.
Following the Board effectiveness
review, and with careful consideration
of a range of factors including
Directors’ other commitments, the
Committee recommended to the Board
the re-election of Mel Carvill, Archil
Gachechiladze, Tamaz Georgadze, Hanna
Loikkanen, Véronique McCarroll, Mariam
Megvinetukhutsesi, Jonathan Muir and
Cecil Quillen, and the election of Andrew
McIntyre at the 2024 AGM. As Alasdair
Breach resigned as a Director on 15 March
2024, he will not stand for re-election.
Board induction
Each Director, upon appointment,
receives a comprehensive and tailored
induction to the Company, details of
which are set out on page 197.
Andrew McIntyre will undergo a
comprehensive and tailored induction
during 2024 and further information
regarding this will be provided in next
year’s Annual Report.
During the year Committee members
were briefed on recent developments
regarding diversity and inclusion in the UK,
and wider diversity initiatives, and were
provided information on appointment
processes, independence criteria and
review of the NBG requirements.
Workforce engagement
Mel Carvill, Hanna Loikkanen and Mariam
Megvinetukhutsesi undertook a series
of Employee Voice meetings during the
year, engaging with 61 employees. These
meetings, which aim to support the
exchange of opinions, ideas and views
between the Board and employees, are
facilitated by Hanna Loikkanen as the
designated Non-executive Director for
workforce engagement. The Employee
Voice meetings discuss the current
employee experience, challenges and
opportunities, how to increase employee
engagement, and the attractiveness of
the Bank as an employer, and ensure
appropriate time for attendees to raise
any items they deem appropriate. Further
information on workforce engagement
can be found in the Empowering
employees section on pages 119 to 132.
After the Employee Voice meetings,
participants’ feedback is gathered in
an anonymous format and a summary
is presented by the designated Non-
executive Director at the next Committee
meeting for discussion. Overall, employee
feedback has been positive. Employees
have noted that “the environment was
good and pleasant for the meeting,
where everyone could state their opinion
freely and ask questions”; “it was a very
interesting conversation... a very informal
and friendly environment was created
by board members, thank you for this
opportunity.
The Committee believes the designated
Non-executive Director for workforce
engagement, with supplementary
engagement from the wider Board as
required, remains appropriate for the
Company to receive fair and balanced
views across the Bank and continue to
monitor and assess opportunities to
further enhance workforce engagement.
Time commitments and
conflicts of interest
Prior to accepting any external
appointments, Directors are required
to seek the Board’s consent. The Board
believes other external directorships
and positions provide the Directors with
valuable expertise, enhancing their ability
to act as Non-executive Directors of
the Company. The number of external
directorships and positions should,
however, be limited – particularly for
Executive Directors – to ensure they can
dedicate the amount of time necessary to
contribute effectively to the Board.
Independence, tenure and
time commitments
As part of the Board effectiveness review,
the Committee asks Board members to
evaluate their own contribution. For each
Non-executive Director, the Committee
reviews the time commitment required,
considering any external directorships,
their length of service and their
independence of character and integrity.
Based on these reviews the Committee
makes a recommendation to the Board
regarding the suitability of each Non-
executive Director for re-election.
The Board has assessed the independence
of the Chairman and each Non-executive
Director in line with Principle G and Provision
9 of the Code, and is of the opinion that the
Chairman and each Non-executive Director
acts in an independent and objective
manner. We consider that, under the UK
Corporate Governance Code, all of our Non-
executive Directors are independent and
free from any relationship that could affect
their judgement.
As part of a wider assessment, the
Committee considered the extent to
which the length of time on the board
of a predecessor company, BGEO
Group Limited (BGEO), could impact
the independence of the independent
Directors. Hanna Loikkanen was originally
appointed to the Board of BGEO on
24 October 2011, before resigning on
19 December 2013. She was reappointed
to the Board of BGEO on 12 June 2015.
The Committee concluded that the
18-month gap was deducted from any
tenure calculations.
The Committee considered and noted the
following:
There were substantial changes in the
executive management upon demerger
of BGEO in 2018 and since (only one
out of the 11 executive managers have
remained since early 2018 and there
has been two changes of CEO).
There were substantial changes
in the nature of the business and
management personnel upon the
demerger in May 2018.
There are no other factors the Board
considered could impinge on the
independence of the Directors.
The Board also notes that, in respect
of succession and the recruitment of
appropriate members to the Board in our
geographical, geopolitical and market
environment:
Any new Board member must clearly
understand the operating, economic
and political environment in Georgia
and the region to give full and proper
oversight.
The Bank is a regulated company
in Georgia, so Board members
must meet the regulators various
requirements for the Supervisory
Board, and be willing to take
responsibility for an emerging-market-
focused Group.
Considering the matters above, the Board
considers that all current Directors have
retained their independence and strongly
recommends their election or re-election
by shareholders.
The Board believes the mirror-board
structure, where the same members
sit on the Board of the Company and
the Supervisory Board of JSC Bank of
Georgia, with the same roles in the mirror
committees, remains the best structure
for the governance of the Group.
As noted in last year’s report, the
Committee was overseeing an orderly
transition of changes to the Board, in
accordance with the seven-year NBG
independence requirement. Accordingly,
Hanna Loikkanen stepped down as
Remuneration Committee Chair but
remained a member of the Committee
with effect from 1 January 2023.
Diversity, equity and
inclusion
The Board has adopted a Diversity and
Inclusion Policy incorporating a wide
range of factors including, but not
limited to, ethnicity, sexual orientation,
disability and socioeconomic background
– mirroring current best practice, which
was reviewed by the Board in September
2023.
Nomination Committee Report continued
211
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
The Board encourages a diverse
and inclusive work environment. The
Committee will continue to examine ways
the Board can become more diverse, and
the Group is also working to maintain
high levels of female representation at
senior management level. In 2020 we
committed to a target of 33% female
representation on the Board, which
was achieved in 2021 and has been
maintained. During 2023 the Committee
received an update on the following
targets:
40% of women on the Board and
Leadership teams by the end of 2025;
at least one woman in the Chair or
Senior Independent Director role on
the Board, and/or one woman as Chief
Executive or Finance Director by the
end of 2025; and
one Director from a minority ethnic
background on the Board by 2024.
The Committee has continued to
monitor and assess its progress against
these objectives during the year. The
Board has been carefully considering its
composition and intends to have 40% of
women on the Board by the end of 2025.
The Committee noted that the Senior
Independent Director of the Company is
female and the Board remains committed
to meeting this obligation.
Archil Gachechiladze, Tamaz Georgadze
and Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi are
Georgian and identify as being from
other ethnic groups, including Arab. It
is noted that being of minority ethnic
background takes into account many
different aspects, such as country of
birth, nationality, language spoken
at home, skin colour, national and
geographical origin, and religion. Georgia
has its own distinct and ancient language
with its own script, its own religion in the
orthodox church of Georgia, and a unique
geographic location at the intersection of
Europe, Asia and Middle Eastern countries
and cultures.
The Board considers diversity to be
important for the future development
of the business, including the need to
be representative of Georgian society.
During the year the Committee continued
to review the diversity of skills and
experience, gender, social and ethnic
backgrounds, cognitive and personal
strengths throughout the Group,
amongst other factors including merit
and other objective criteria.
The Company notes the Parker Review
is asking companies to consider
setting a percentage target for senior
management team that will be occupied
by ethnic minority executives in December
2027, however given the majority of the
senior management are from an ethnic
minority background, setting a target for
our Group would be artificial.
The Committee noted that, with the
Groups workforce primarily based in
Georgia, its ethnic make-up is different
to that of a UK-based group. The
Board itself is highly diverse in terms of
nationality, with our nine Directors being
citizens of six different countries. The
Committee continues to have regard for
all diversity factors, including gender and
ethnicity, in any future appointments, as
well as the appropriate knowledge, skills
and experience, in accordance with the
Groups Diversity and Inclusion Policy.
Whilst the Committee is pleased with
the progress made in increasing diversity
within senior management positions
and the Board, we recognise there is
always further work to do. We continue
to score highly on gender diversity of the
Executive Committee and direct reports.
The Committee was pleased to note that,
in the 2023 edition of the FTSE Women
Leaders Review, the Company was ranked
12
th
overall and 2
nd
in the banking sector
for female representation in the Executive
Committee and direct reporting positions
– with a combined total of 48.8%. This
reflects some of the talent development
and management processes and
initiatives we have in place, as detailed
below.
Details regarding equal opportunity
and diversity are also provided in the
Empowering employees section on pages
120 to 122.
In September 2023 the Board was
pleased to approve the significantly
improved Diversity and Inclusion
Policy which outlines the Company’s
commitment to ensuring a diverse and
inclusive culture within the Group and
recognises that this is crucial to the
Groups success, innovation, and progress.
The Group has committed to several
principles within this Policy to continue its
transformation.
The Board also approved an Anti-
Discrimination and Anti-Harassment
Policy in September 2023.
Through this Policy the Group commits
to the elimination of discrimination
and harassment of any form within the
Group. The Policy sets out the principles
and guidelines to support the Company
to become a better institution for its
employees, customers and all other
stakeholders.
The Groups work on diversity and
inclusion and anti-discrimination and
anti-harassment is based on, but not
limited to, the following relevant local
legal requirements and international
standards:
United Nations’ Universal Declaration
of Human Rights
Charter of Fundamental Rights of the
European Union
International Labour Organization’s
Fundamental Instruments
Convention on the Elimination of
all forms of Discrimination against
Women
United Nations’ Guiding Principles on
Business and Human Rights
OECD Guidelines for Multinational
Enterprises
United National Global Compact
International Finance Corporation’s
Performance Standards
These policies will be kept under regular
review and updated in accordance with
local legal requirements and international
standards.
The policies can be found on the Groups
website at
https://www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com/
governance/documents.
In accordance with Listing Rule 9.8.6(10), as at the reference date of 31 December 2023, the composition of the Board and executive
management was as follows:
Board and Executive Management gender representation
Number of
Board members
Percentage of
the Board
Number of senior
positions on the Board
(CEO, SID and Chair)
Number in executive
management
Percentage of executive
management
Male 6 66.67% 2 11 73.33
Female 3 33.33% 1 4 26.67
212
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Board and Executive Management ethnic representation
Number of
Board members
Percentage of
the Board
Number of senior
positions on the
Board (CEO, SID
and Chair)
Number in executive
management
Percentage
of executive
management
White British or Other White
(including minority-white groups)
6 66.67% 2 - -
Mixed/Multiple Ethnic Groups - - - - -
Asian/Asian British - - - - -
Black/African/Caribbean/Black British - - - - -
Other Ethnic Group, including Arab 3 33.33% 1 15 100%
Not specified/prefer not to say - - - - -
The information presented in the above tables was collected on a self-reporting basis by the Directors, who were asked to confirm
which of the categories specified in the prescribed tables were most applicable to them.
Board evaluation
Nomination Committee Report continued
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3
Internal Board
evaluation
Internal Board
evaluation
External Board
evaluation
During 2023 the performance and effectiveness of the Board and its committees was reviewed through an externally facilitated
evaluation process conducted by Clare Chalmers Ltd.
The Board undertook a careful approach in ensuring the external evaluation was appropriate and that the evaluator understood the
sector and its challenges. Clare Chalmers Ltd has no connection with the Company or its individual Directors.
In conducting this evaluation, the Board set out to ensure the process not only met the requirements of the Code but also had a
clear focus on enhancing the effectiveness of the Board and its committees. Details of the evaluation process can be found on page
196 and its outcomes are detailed below.
Key outcomes of the 2023 external Board evaluation
Opportunities Actions
Managing the agenda and materials The Board felt it would benefit from updates from other external parties with regards
to shareholder and stakeholder feedback. It was agreed the Board would receive
additional external updates as required.
Succession planning The Board remains focused on succession planning, ensuring Board departures are
appropriately managed and continuing to monitor senior management succession
planning. In addition, the Board felt it would benefit from considering enhancements
to the skills matrix during 2024.
Risk and compliance To consider a consolidated, Bank-wide assurance plan to centralise the work of the
Risk, Compliance, and Internal Audit functions.
Additional time for strategic discussions In addition to the work undertaken in managing the agenda and materials, the Board
felt additional discussion on strategy and further Board strategy sessions would be
positive in supporting the continued growth of the Group. It was agreed the Board
would continue to hold annual strategy days.
Review of Directors’ performance
The performance of the Directors was assessed as part of the external evaluation process. Following careful consideration, the
Committee determined that each Director continued to perform effectively and that each should be recommended for re-election
by shareholders at the 2024 AGM.
Review of Chairs performance
The performance of the Chair was assessed as part of the external evaluation process. Following careful consideration, the
Committee determined that the Chair continued to perform effectively and that he should be recommended for re-election by
shareholders at the 2024 AGM.
213
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Progress on areas of focus from the 2022 internal Board evaluation
In 2022 an internal evaluation of the effectiveness of the Board, its committees, the individual Directors and the Chair was
undertaken. Throughout 2023 the Committee reviewed the key actions arising from the internal evaluation and reviewed the
progress against each. A summary is outlined below:
Opportunities Actions Progress during 2023
Managing the agenda and materials The Board would benefit from additional
time for discussion, supported by more
focused papers and timely receipt of
papers.
During the year Board papers have
become more focused and the quality
has improved. In addition, there has
been a focus on ensuring the timely
delivery of meeting papers to allow
more time for review. The presenters
have also been briefed to focus
on material items of reports and
allow more time for questions and
discussions.
Additional time for strategic discussions The Board felt it would benefit from a
strategy day to ensure appropriate time
to deep-dive on specific items and receive
updates from other speakers. In addition,
the Board thought it would be beneficial to
receive updates on the evolving economies
in Georgia and the region.
A two-day strategy meeting was held
during 2023 and further updates on this
can be found on page 192.
The Board has received updates on the
evolving economies in Georgia and the
region.
Additional risk and compliance reporting The Group has a robust and well-
developed risk and compliance function.
To maintain this in an evolving legal and
regulatory landscape the Board recognised
it was important to continue to receive
updates on the proposed Audit Reporting
and Governance Authority reforms, the
Listing Rule updates regarding diversity,
and the NBG rules on independence.
These suggestions were added to the
Board and committee agendas and
updates are provided on a regular
basis. Additional information on this is
available as follows:
Internal controls – pages 145, 197, 215
and 222.
Diversity – pages 186 to 187, 194, 210
to 212.
Independence – pages 187 and 210.
Updates on legal and regulatory
developments – pages 197.
Review of the Committee’s performance
The Committee undertook an evaluation of its own effectiveness as part of the external review. The Committee was pleased with
the findings, noting its professional and structured processes with discipline and a clear remit under the Chair.
The findings of the review were considered by the Committee at its September 2023 meeting. The Committee was satisfied with the
results of the evaluation and is confident it continues to operate and perform appropriately and fulfil its responsibilities. For more
information on the Board and Committee evaluation and its outcomes see page 196.
214
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Audit Committee Report
Ensuring robust financial reporting and internal controls to support the
long-term success of the Company.
Membership of Audit Committee
Committee membership Date of membership
Jonathan Muir (Chair) 24 February 2018
Hanna Loikkanen 24 February 2018
Cecil Quillen 24 February 2018
The skills and experience each member contributes can be
found on pages 198 to 200.
All members of the Committee are independent Non-
executive Directors of the Board. Committee members
have the right to attend meetings, as well as any other
Non-executive Directors of the Board. Other individuals,
including the CEO, CFO and CRO, and other members of
the Management Team, may be invited to attend meetings
to provide insight into key developments.
In accordance with the Code, we are pleased to confirm
the Committee meets the requirements of comprising at
least three independent Directors. Furthermore, the Board
is satisfied that Jonathan Muir has recent and relevant
financial experience.
The Committee as a whole has competence relevant to
the financial and banking sector in which the Company
operates, and holds the relevant combination of skills and
experience to discharge its responsibilities.
Key objectives of the Committee
The Audit Committee focuses on the following matters:
Financial reporting
Ensures the integrity of the Companys financial and
non-financial reporting.
Ensures disclosures are fair, balanced and
understandable.
Risk management and internal controls
Ensures adequacy and effectiveness of our systems of
internal controls.
Ensures appropriate compliance monitoring.
Ensures appropriate whistleblowing procedures and
monitors any developments.
Reviews procedures for detecting and reporting on fraud.
Internal Audit
Monitors and reviews the effectiveness of the Internal
Audit function.
Approves the Internal Audit plan.
Considers an independent third-party review of the
Internal Audit function.
External Audit
Ensures the Company complies with audit tender and
rotation obligations.
Determines the External Auditor’s remuneration, terms
of engagement, independence, conflicts, and ensures
appropriate qualifications, experiences and resources of the
external auditor.
Reviews the External Auditor’s effectiveness.
Monitors, reviews and approves any non-audit services
and associated fees.
Meeting attendance
Details of the members’ attendance at the meetings of the
Committee are as follows:
Committee membership
No. of meetings
attended
Jonathan Muir (Chair) 4/4 scheduled
5/5 ad hoc*
Hanna Loikkanen 4/4 scheduled
5/5 ad hoc*
Cecil Quillen 4/4 scheduled
5/5 ad hoc*
* There was one ad hoc meeting during the year where the Audit Committee and
Risk Committee met jointly
2024 action plan
In the coming year the main areas of focus for the Committee
will be:
Approving the financial statements for the year ended
31 December 2023.
Reviewing the key areas of financial judgement and
estimates used by management.
Assisting the Board in the review of the effectiveness of
the Groups risk management and internal controls.
Reviewing the performance of the external auditors.
Reviewing the performance of Internal Audit and
monitoring progress of the Internal Audit Plan.
Overseeing plans for compliance with new 2024 UK
Corporate Governance Code, particularly in relation to
Internal Controls.
Providing required reporting and assurance on the
acquisition of Ameriabank.
Ensuring Ameriabank is integrated into the risk, reporting
and internal control framework of the Bank.
Regular attendees at meetings
CEO, CFO, CRO, Head of Internal Audit, CLO, UK General
Counsel, Company Secretary and representatives of
the External Auditor. Invitations to attend meetings are
extended to all Directors.
Collaboration with the Risk Committee
The Committee also works closely with the Risk Committee
to ensure both Committees are updated and aligned on
matters of common interest, to maintain a broad and full
view of the Group’s risk management and internal control
matters. Joint meetings of the Risk and Audit Committees
are held quarterly, with ad hoc meetings scheduled as
required.
The Committees Terms of Reference set out its role and
authority, and can be found on the corporate website at
https://bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/documents.
215
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Dear Shareholders,
I am pleased to report on the activities of
the Audit Committee (the ‘Committee’)
throughout 2023 on behalf of the Board,
and to provide details on how the
Committee operated and discharged its
responsibilities.
Financial statements
The Committees role is to recommend
the financial statements to the Board
and review the Groups financial reporting
and accounting policies, including formal
announcements and trading statements
relating to the Company’s financial
performance. We continued to ensure
the integrity of the Company’s published
financial information, and reviewed the
judgements made by management and
the assumptions and estimates on which
they were based.
The Committee receives a report at each
meeting on specific areas of accounting
and quality of earnings, and where
material judgement has been applied.
These areas are discussed, challenged,
and the opinion of the external auditor
sought before final conclusions on
appropriate treatment are reached. Such
areas in 2023 included Expected Credit
Loss (ECL) provisions and impairments,
impact of sanctions, cost capitalisation
and accounting/valuation for repossessed
assets.
Internal controls
The Committee has reviewed and
challenged management across a
number of areas during 2023, including
the monitoring of the control framework
during the changing environment. This
change in particular focused on the
impact of the Russia-Ukraine war on
inflation, influx of migrants and resultant
change in money flows into Georgia
and the Bank. It has overseen work on
critical areas such as loan loss provisions
and the accounting treatment of key
non-recurring items. The Committee
heard how management assessed
the ECL provision in light of current
economic conditions, and challenged
the assumptions and controls around
the model used to assess their impact.
An update on the ECL provision was
provided at regular Committee meetings,
with further updates provided at ad
hoc meetings to review and approve the
quarterly and annual financial results.
The Committee is responsible for ensuring
the Bank maintains a risk-aware culture.
We receive regular reports on financial
crime risk management, including
fraud risks and sanctions compliance,
information security and data protection
risks, and compliance-related matters,
among others. These will continue to be
areas of focus in 2024.
Internal Audit
During the year the Committee has
continued to oversee the role and
effectiveness of the Internal Audit
function. We have reviewed and approved
the Internal Audit Plan and its execution
for 2023, and approved the Internal
Audit Plan for 2024. We recognise the
importance of the Internal Audit function
to the control environment and have been
working closely with Internal Audit to
further enhance the outputs during the
year. At each meeting, the Committee
also reviews the key results of the Internal
Audit work, challenging management
where appropriate and ensuring that
remediation plans are in place and
executed.
Further information on our work with
Internal Audit is available on pages 218
to 219.
Viability statement
The Committee also received reports and
held regular discussions regarding the
ongoing viability of the Company and its
liquidity status. The Committee continued
to focus on the key issues relevant to the
Groups financial reporting, and worked
with management and EY to review
any changes required in response to
the introduction of new accounting or
regulatory guidance.
Further information on our work and
the process in assessing the viability
statement is available on pages 221 to
222.
External Audit
We oversee the relationship with Ernst
& Young LLP (‘EY’), the Group’s external
auditor, reviewing EY’s effectiveness,
independence, objectivity and compliance
with ethical, professional and regulatory
requirements. We reviewed and approved
the 2023 audit plan and audit fees. We
continue to monitor management’s
responsiveness to the External Auditor’s
findings and recommendations.
Preparation for planned
financial governance
changes
A key legislative and regulatory change
proposed by the UK Government will
result from the measures proposed by
the Department for Business, Energy
The Committee has worked with the
Board and management to ensure robust
operational controls and processes
are embedded.
Jonathan Muir
Chair of Audit Committee
216
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Audit Committee Report continued
& Industrial Strategy, arising from its
consultation into restoring trust in audit
and corporate governance and the
proposed revisions to the UK Corporate
Governance Code, including enhanced
focus on internal controls. The Committee
undertook substantial work during 2023
to review the proposals and ensure that
the Group was well positioned, where
needed, to begin to implement the
documentation and process changes. The
Audit Committee members oversaw the
Company feedback to the FRC under the
consultation on the proposed changes to
the Code.
Acquisition of Ameriabank
CJSC
The Committee undertook extensive
work in respect of the Ameriabank CJSC
(‘Ameriabank’) acquisition to ensure
appropriate due diligence, feasibility,
working capital and reporting. Further
information on the work undertaken by
the Committee is set out on page 223.
During 2024 the Committee will focus on
ensuring appropriate process and control
around reporting and compliance.
Committee composition
Due to the seven year NBG independence
requirement in place during the year, it
was important to identify a potential
Non-executive Director to join the
Committee and aid the succession
planning of the Committee. Following
this process, it was determined that
Andrew McIntyre has the requisite
skills, knowledge and experience to be
appointed as a member, and future Chair
of the Committee. I look forward to
working with Andrew and the experience
he will bring to the Committee.
More information of the appointment
process, led by the Nomination
Committee, is available in the Nomination
Committee Report on pages 209.
Work with the Risk
Committee
We have continued to work closely with
our colleagues on the Risk Committee
on matters including liquidity, adequacy
of capital (including adequate buffers),
Risk Registry, AML and sanction controls,
information security, cybersecurity and
compliance.
The Committee will continue to play
an active role in continuing to oversee
the development of the Groups risk
management and internal control
processes during 2024.
Further detail of the Committees work
during the year is set out in the following
report.
Jonathan Muir
Chair of the Audit Committee
24 April 2024
217
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Key Committee meeting topics during 2023
March June September December
Internal Audit performance.
Internal Audit KPIs and
KBOs.
Internal Audit progress and
findings.
Internal Audit team;
Finance and accounting
update, including on ECL
provisions.
Ongoing litigation update.
2022 Annual Report and
Accounts.
External Auditor report.
Internal Audit progress and
findings.
Internal Audit Plan.
Internal Audit KPIs and
KBOs;
Finance and accounting
update including
remediation of Audit
findings and Impairment of
Assets review.
Ongoing litigation update.
External Auditor update
including subsidiary audits.
Legal and regulatory
developments.
Data protection update.
External Auditor
effectiveness review.
Internal Audit progress and
findings.
Internal Audit Plan.
Finance and accounting
update, including valuation
approach.
Ongoing litigation update.
External Auditor update.
Legal and regulatory
developments.
External Auditor
effectiveness review.
Audit-owned policies.
Committee effectiveness
result.
Audit quality results.
Internal Audit progress and
findings.
Internal Audit Plan.
Finance and accounting
update.
Ongoing litigation update.
External Auditor update.
Legal and regulatory
developments.
NBG data protection
requirements.
External Audit Plan.
Review of FRC
recommendations on the
2022 Annual Report.
Entity rationalisation.
Update on actions in
relation to amendments
to the UK Corporate
Governance Code including
on Internal Controls.
At each of the quarterly meetings the Audit Committee met with the External Audit and Internal Auditor without management
present. During the year there were five ad hoc meetings, one of which was held jointly with the Risk Committee.
Key activities during the year
Topic Summary of activity
Find out more
(where applicable)
External Audit Oversaw the external audit process and a review of
the effectiveness of the external audit.
Pages 219 to 221
Internal Audit Internal Audit Plan.
Internal Audit function review.
KPIs.
Internal Audit progress.
Internal Audit risk assessment and follow-up
methodology.
Internal Audit organisational structure.
Pages 218 to 219
Capital distribution Reviewed the capital distribution proposals in relation
to share buybacks and dividends.
-
AML and sanctions compliance risk
management
Oversaw the enhancement of the Group’s AML and
sanctions compliance risk management in conjunction
with the Risk Committee.
Pages 216 and 219
Regulatory and governance updates Reviewed the latest regulatory developments and the
work undertaken in relation to internal controls, the
Code, NBG, and Accounting Standards.
Page 215
218
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Committee effectiveness
As part of the wider Board and
Committee effectiveness review, an
internally facilitated evaluation of
the Committees effectiveness was
undertaken during 2023. The findings
were considered by the Board at its
September 2023 meeting.
The review concluded the Committee
functioned well and had the appropriate
composition to fulfil its duties, and that
the interaction between the Committee
and the Board was appropriate. The
Committee agreed the practice of
organising joint meetings of the Audit
and Risk Committees continued to be a
success and enhanced effectiveness. The
Committee was pleased with the results
of the evaluation and will continue to
consider areas in which it can improve in
the future to the benefit of the Company.
For more information on the evaluation of
the Board and Committees see pages 196
and 212.
Meetings with the auditors
During the year the Committee met
privately, without management present,
with EY and the Head of Internal Audit.
The Chair of the Committee also held
discussions with the lead audit partner
in advance of meetings. The focus of
these private meetings was to encourage
discussion of any concerns in more detail,
directly with the external auditor and
the Bank’s Head of Internal Audit. In
addition, the Chair of the Committee
has maintained regular dialogue with the
external auditor throughout the year.
One of the Committee’s key
responsibilities is reviewing the integrity
of the financial statements, considering
the appropriateness of accounting
policies and practices, and reviewing
the significant issues and judgements
considered in relation to the financial
statements. The Committee received
detailed reporting from the CFO and
the external auditor in respect of the
key areas of management’s judgements,
reporting and audit during the year.
The Committee and the external
auditor, without management present,
discussed the key areas of audit focus,
the suitability of the accounting policies
adopted, and whether management’s key
reporting estimates and judgements were
appropriate. Considering the external
auditor’s assessment of risk, and using
our own independent knowledge of the
Group, we reviewed and challenged,
where necessary, the actions, estimates
and judgements of management in
relation to the preparation of the
financial statements.
The significant governance and control
matters, financial judgements and
significant issues considered by the
Committee in relation to the financial
statements are addressed below.
Matters considered Action taken by the Audit Committee
Governance Reviewed governance processes and policies.
Reviewed the Terms of Reference of the Committee.
Oversaw the creation of a team responsible for working with KPMG to assess
readiness for internal control reporting under new UK regulations.
Undertook an externally facilitated Committee effectiveness evaluation.
Undertook a review of the effectiveness of the external auditor.
Reviewed control assessments around non-financial disclosures.
Financial reporting Reviewed the appropriateness and disclosure of accounting policies and practices.
Reviewed the Annual Report and Accounts content and advised the Board on
whether the Annual Report and Accounts was fair, balanced and understandable.
Reviewed changes to deferred tax balances and disclosures following announced
changes to the Georgian Tax Code at the end of 2022.
Reviewed the accounting treatment of a number of significant items, including
advisory fees received at G&T, gain on the sale of repossessed assets and change
to interchange fee commission.
Reviewed the Company’s annual and interim financial statements and quarterly
accounts relating to the Company’s financial performance, including a review of
the significant financial reporting policies and judgements contained therein.
Reviewed the stress scenarios of the ongoing economic environment and the
continuing Russia-Ukraine war.
Reviewed and recommended the going concern and viability statements to the
Board for its approval.
Internal Audit Reviewed reports of internal audits and monitored action points and follow-up
actions arising.
Approved the annual Internal Audit Plan and budget for 2022 and 2023.
Approved Internal Audit function KPIs.
Reviewed the Internal Audit satisfaction survey results and issues statistics.
Approved amendments to the Group Internal Audit Charter.
Monitored and reviewed the effectiveness of the Company’s Internal Audit
function, including overseeing an independent review.
Audit Committee Report continued
219
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Matters considered Action taken by the Audit Committee
Litigation Reviewed litigations that could be material to the Company, and whether
provisions for contingent liabilities were required in respect of such cases. For
further information please see Note 22 to the Consolidated Financial Statements
on page 327.
ECL provisions Reviewed the controls around the development of the model used to assist in
determining the appropriate provisions.
Reviewed key inputs of the model, including economic scenarios and management
overlays.
Assessed outputs against peers and industry.
Sought external audit opinion and views on the model and its output.
Reviewed and challenged the judgements used and resolution of any model
deficiencies.
Global sanctions Oversaw the response and controls on additional measures to address the risks
associated with significant inflows of Russian nationals.
Reviewed the assessment of AML and sanctions risk and any impact on the
Company.
Accounting for repossessed assets Agreed the approach for revaluation of repossessed assets.
Group reorganisation Reviewed the approach and accounting provisions for the Group reorganisation.
The Committee also received regular reports on recoveries and loan write-offs, information security strategy, data protection and
cyber risks.
Internal Audit
The Committee is responsible, on
behalf of the Board, for overseeing the
Internal Audit function, which serves
as the Groups independent assurance
over the adequacy and effectiveness
of the systems and processes of risk
management and control across the
Group.
Internal Audit is led by the Head of
Internal Audit, who reports functionally
to the Chair of the Audit Committee and
administratively to the CEO. They have
direct access to the Committee and the
opportunity to discuss matters with the
Committee without other members of
management present.
The Committee also monitors the
staffing of the Internal Audit department,
as well as the team’s qualifications and
experience. The Committee continues
to monitor the effectiveness of the
Internal Audit function and receives
regular updates on internal audits and
remediation actions.
The Committee monitors the scope,
extent and effectiveness of the Groups
Internal Audit function. It reviews and
approves the Internal Audit Policy and
Internal Audit Plan, which is designed
using a risk-based approach aligned with
the Groups overall strategy. Regular
reports are received from Internal Audit
on audit activities, significant findings
and corrective measures and follow-ups.
In certain cases the Committee invites
heads of divisions and departments to
present their responses and mitigating
actions regarding Internal Audit findings.
The Committee considered the quality
of the reporting by Internal Audit to the
Committee and its ability to address
unsatisfactory results. In addition, the
independent assessment of the function
confirmed its independence and many
areas of compliance with international
standards, while identifying areas for
improvement. These formed the basis of
a plan of action to enhance efficiency and
overall effectiveness.
The effectiveness of the Internal Audit
function and its work is continually
monitored using a variety of inputs
reported on a quarterly basis, including
quality of reports, status of completion
of the Audit Plan and execution of
remediation actions. In addition, regular
meetings are held between the Audit
Chair and Head of Internal Audit to
discuss ongoing matters and results. On
this basis, the Committee concluded that
the Internal Audit function is effective
and retains appropriate independence.
External audit
A material responsibility of the
Committee is to oversee the external
audit process on behalf of the Board.
During its oversight and review of the
external audit process the Committee:
approved the annual external audit
plan, which included setting the areas
of responsibility, scope and key risks
identified;
oversaw the audit engagement,
including the degree to which the
external auditor was able to assess key
accounting and audit judgement;
reviewed the findings of the external
audit with the external auditor,
including the level of errors identified;
monitored management’s
responsiveness to the external
auditor’s findings and
recommendations;
reviewed the qualifications, expertise
and resources of the external auditor;
monitored the external auditor’s
independence, objectivity and
compliance with ethical, professional
and regulatory requirements;
reviewed audit fees;
monitored the rotation of key partners
in accordance with applicable
legislation; and
recommended the appointment,
reappointment or removal, as
applicable, of the external auditor.
FRC Minimum Standard
The Committee considered the FRCs
External Audit: Minimum Standard
(the ‘Minimum Standard’) issued
in May 2023 and confirms that
the Committees activities during
the year have been performed in
compliance.
More information on the application
of the Bank’s accounting policies can
be found on pages 275 to 287.
220
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Auditor independence
The Committee has adopted a Non-audit
Services Policy to safeguard the auditor’s
independence and objectivity. The Policy
was reviewed and updated in September
2023.
The provision of non-audit services by
our External Auditors aligns with the
current EU Statutory Audit regime, the
FRC Ethical Standard 2019 (the ‘Ethical
Standard’) and the Code. Any work
other than for the audit or review of
interim statements to be undertaken
by the external auditor now requires
authorisation by the Committee,
except in very narrow circumstances.
The Policy is available on our website
https://bankofgeorgiagroup.com/
governance/documents.
In accordance with the Minimum
Standard and the Code, the Committee
has formally assessed the independence
of EY. This included the review of a report
from EY describing its arrangements
to identify, report and manage any
conflicts of interest, and its policies and
procedures for maintaining independence
and monitoring compliance with relevant
requirements, and the review of the value
of non-audit services provided by EY.
The Committee also reviewed and
discussed EYs independence in respect
on the non-audit services provided for
the acquisition of Ameriabank. The
Committee received an update from EY
confirming their continued independence
and the Committee agreed that it
remained satisfied of EY’s independence.
EY has also confirmed its independence
throughout the year within the meaning
of the regulations on this matter and
in accordance with its professional
standards. As indicated in Note 26 to the
Consolidated Financial Statements on
page 332, the total fees paid to EY for
the year ended 31 December 2023 were
GEL7.210 million, of which GEL 4.620
million related to work other than the
audit of year-end or review of the interim
accounts.
The Committee asserts that engaging
EY on occasions for non-audit work is
the most efficient method of having
those services delivered to the Company,
and does not consider that this work
compromised EY’s independence. Further
information regarding non-audit services
can be found below.
External auditor fees
The total fees paid to EY in the year
ended 31 December 2023 were GEL 7.210
million, of which:
Audit Services
GEL 0.971 million – audit of these
financial statements
GEL 1.048 million – audit of financial
statements of subsidiaries
Non-Audit Services
GEL 0.571 million – audit-related
services
GEL 4.620 million – other non-audit
services
Further disclosure on the remuneration
paid to EY can be found in Note 26 on
page 332.
Non-audit services
A review of the Non-audit Services
Policy has been undertaken, and it was
confirmed that the policy is in accordance
with the FRC Ethical Standard issued in
December 2019, which limits the non-
audit services External Auditor may
provide to the Company.
In all circumstances where it is proposed
to engage the External Auditors to
perform non-audit work in accordance
with this policy, this is subject to the
approval of the Audit Committee after it
has properly assessed potential threats to
the independence of the external auditors
and the safeguards applied in the Ethical
Standard.
EY undertook non-audit services in the form
of assurance work carried out in connection
with the announcement of the Company’s
2023 half-year results. This non-audit
service is of direct benefit to shareholders.
EY also undertook non-audit services in
respect of the acquisition of Ameriabank.
It was considered that EY was best
placed to undertake such services due
to having suitable scale, experience and
independence to be able to execute the
work within the required timeframe
particularly in light of the geopolitical
environment, lack of alternative providers
and historically low non-audit service fees
to date. As the level of costs incurred
in connection with the acquisition was
likely to exceed a 1:1 non-audit fee to
audit fee ratio and the 70% non-audit
services fee cap provision of the Ethical
Standard, EY requested a two-year
waiver from the FRC in respect of US$
950,000 of fees for reporting accounting
work in connection with the Ameriabank
transaction. The waiver was granted by
the FRC.
The Committee recognises and supports
the importance of auditor independence.
It reviewed EY’s performance of non-
audit services during 2023 and is
satisfied that it did not – and will not
– impair its independence. As a result,
the value of non-audit services work
by EY was GEL4.620 million in 2023
(2022: GEL0.012 million), representing
approximately 64.1% of the total fees
paid to EY as set out in Note 26 to the
Accounts on page 332.
Audit tender and lead
partner rotation
EY was appointed as auditor of Bank
of Georgia Group PLC in 2018 and
reappointed by shareholders at the
2023 AGM. The Committee was also
authorised to set the remuneration of the
auditor, with 98.52% and 100% of votes
in favour for each resolution respectively.
Since the rotation of the audit partner
during 2021, Peter Wallace has served as
the lead audit partner for the Company.
The Committee believes this supports the
continuance of EY’s independence.
Although the Group was not required to
put the external audit contract out to
tender before 2027, the NBG transition
rules had required EY to rotate out from
the JSC Bank of Georgia audit following
the 2022 audit. The Chair of the Committee
led a thorough, carefully considered process,
resulting in the identification of a preferred
and second-choice audit firm. However,
due to the impact of the Russia-Ukraine
war, neither was able to effectively support
Bank of Georgia Group PLC audit or accept
the position.
During the process the Bank applied for
and was granted by the NBG a two-
year waiver in respect of the mandatory
audit rotation, allowing EY to remain
in place for the 2023 and 2024 audits
after seeking assurance from EY that it
remained independent.
During 2023 the Company complied
with the Statutory Audit Services for
Large Companies Market Investigation
(Mandatory Use of Competitive
Tender Processes and Committee
Responsibilities) Order 2014.
Auditor reappointment
There are a number of areas the
Committee considers in relation to EY
as the external auditor: its performance;
reappointment and length of service;
effectiveness of the external audit
process; independence and the provision
of non-audit services; objectivity; and
remuneration.
The Committee reviewed and made a
recommendation to the Board in relation
to the continued appointment of EY as
the external auditor. Furthermore, the
Committee approved EY’s remuneration
and terms of engagement for the 2023
financial year.
During the year the Committee reviewed
and approved the external audit plan for
2023 which was presented by EY together
with its key areas of risk and details of the
proposed audit approach.
Audit Committee Report continued
221
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
External auditor
Assurance from the
external auditor covering
independence (further
information available on
page 220) and matters
raised in the FRC’s Annual
Quality Review inspection
reports and remedial
actions taken (if any).
Audit process
Assess delivery of
the Audit Plan and
independent auditor’s
report including the
materiality level set by
the External Auditor and
the process to identify
financial statement risk
and key areas of focus.
Throughout the year
there will be regular
communications between
the external auditor and
both the Committee
and management,
including discussion of
regular papers prepared
by management and
EY. Assurance on the
operation of the audit
quality process at EY is
received and reviewed by
the Committee.
Management
Management will take
part in and receive the
output from a survey
of those involved in the
external audit process.
Furthermore, assurance
on the disclosure process
from the provision of
information to the
auditors is sought from
the CEO and CFO to
ensure disclosures are
appropriate.
Audit Committee
The Committee assesses
the output of the annual
Committee effectiveness
evaluation to identify
any opportunities of
improvement or areas of
concern. In addition, the
Committee will review
the output from the
survey on the external
audit process and discuss
the findings with EY. A
review of the final audit
report is undertaken,
noting key areas of
auditor judgement and
the reasoning behind the
conclusions reached.
The Committee has
regular discussions with
EY without management
present and with
management without EY
present, to discuss the
external audit process.
Outcome
Following consideration of all elements of the audit effectiveness review process – in addition to taking account of the
engagement and communication between the Audit Committee, management and external auditor – the Committee
confirmed it was satisfied that the external audit process provided by EY had been delivered effectively. The Committee
concluded that EY had demonstrated a depth of knowledge and an appreciation of complex issues, whilst providing
constructive, independent and objective challenge to management. The Committee requested that debrief sessions be held
between the external auditor and the finance management teams across the organisation to consider any areas to enhance the
audit process control environment.
The Committee is satisfied that the relationships between the external auditor and management allow for scrutiny of views on both
sides, and is pleased the evaluation highlighted the ability and willingness of the external auditor to challenge management’s views in
a constructive and proportionate manner.
The Committee recommended to the Board that EY be reappointed as auditor of the Company, and the Directors will be
proposing the reappointment and determination of EY’s remuneration at the 2024 AGM.
Going concern
The Group has prepared forecasts,
including various sensitivities, taking
into account the principal risks and
uncertainties identified on pages 149 to
169. Having considered these forecasts
the Directors remain of the view that the
Group has sufficient capital and access
to capital to conduct its business for at
least the next 12 months. The Committee
reviewed the forecasts and the Directors’
expectations based thereon, and agreed
that they were reasonable. Accordingly
the Consolidated Financial Statements
have been prepared on a going concern
basis.
Viability statement
In accordance with provision 31 of the
Code, the Board is required to make a
statement in the Annual Report and
Accounts regarding the Group’s viability
over a specified time horizon. Details on
our work in developing and assessing the
viability statement can be found below.
Developing a robust viability
statement
In collaboration with the Risk Committee,
and considering the FRC guidance, we
spent time considering the timeframe
over which the viability statement should
be made, as well as an assessment of
the period of coverage, which we agreed
should be three years. This period is
considered appropriate as the budget
and business processes are based on a
three-year horizon. It also considers that
uncertainty increases as the time horizon
extends.
External Auditor effectiveness
The Committee and management undertake a formal questionnaire to provide feedback on the external audit process. The
Committee reviews the findings and, where necessary, arranges any follow-up sessions to obtain further information. In addition,
the Committee has an established framework for assessing the effectiveness of the external audit process. This includes:
222
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Stage 1: Risk identification
A review of the principal risks
to viability over the period was
undertaken, including risks that
would impact the solvency and
liquidity of the Group either
separately or jointly.
Stage 3: Scenario sensitivity
analysis
Management undertook stress-
testing to review plausible
circumstances and how this may
affect the business over the long-
term, as well as reverse stress-
testing to consider what level of
disruption may cause the Company
to fail.
Stage 2: Risk assessment
Each identified risk was carefully
reviewed in accordance with our risk
appetite, existing control framework
and the quantum of risk.
Stage 4: Conclusions
The Audit Committee considered
the findings from the analysis. The
conclusion was presented to the
Board to provide the opportunity
for review and challenge.
Assessing the Groups viability
In assessing the Group’s viability over the
three-year time horizon, the Committee
considered different types of information
including:
The Groups business model and
strategic plans.
Current capital position and
projections over the relevant period.
Liquidity and funding profile and
projections over the relevant period.
The Groups risk profile, including any
breaches of risk appetite, and principal
and emerging risks that could have
a significant negative impact on the
Group.
The effectiveness of the Groups risk
management framework and internal
control processes.
Stress-testing and reverse stress-testing.
Our full viability statement can be found
on page 170.
Whistleblowing, conflicts
of interest, anti-bribery and
anti-corruption, and data
protection
The Audit Committee ensures there are
effective procedures in place relating to
whistleblowing. The Whistleblowing Policy
is reviewed annually and allows employees
and stakeholders to anonymously raise
concerns about business practices. The
Group uses an advanced, independent
whistleblowing reporting channel and
case management tool, WhistleB. The
Company has continued to promote the
importance of the whistleblowing process
and procedures to employees.
In line with the Code, responsibility for
the whistleblowing process sits with the
Board. The Audit Committee continues
to monitor the use of the system.
Updates on whistleblowing procedures,
the actions undertaken to promote
the WhistleB platform, and the case
management tools are provided to the
Audit Committee quarterly.
The Audit Committee reviews the Group’s
Anti-bribery and Anti-corruption Policy
and procedures and receives reports
from management on a regular basis
in relation to any actual or potential
wrongdoing.
The Audit Committee received reports
on any Code of Conduct and Ethics
violations. There were 27 claims in the
year ended 31 December 2023. Only one
instance was substantiated which related
to unethical behaviour and misconduct.
The employees were mandated to
familiarise themselves with the Bank’s
corporate guidelines and related rules of
conduct and ethics. There were no other
significant findings during 2023.
The Committee also oversees compliance
with GDPR and receives regular updates
from the Bank’s Personal Data Protection
Officer.
Risk management and
internal controls
Although the Board assumes ultimate
responsibility for the Groups risk
management and internal control
framework, its work is supported by
the Audit Committee and the Risk
Committee. The Audit Committee assists
the Board in fulfilling its responsibility to
review the adequacy and effectiveness of
the controls over financial reporting.
The Committee also monitors the Groups
compliance with corporate governance
policies and procedures related to anti-
bribery and anti-corruption, conflicts of
interest and whistleblowing.
During the year the Committee received
updates on the UK Corporate Governance
reform – in particular on the Audit,
Reporting and Governance Authority
reforms. The Committee has discussed
proposals and started preparations it
envisages would be required, and will
carefully monitor the progress of further
regulatory updates.
With the ongoing Russia-Ukraine war
and wider geopolitical developments, the
Committee kept the evolving sanctions
landscape under review and ensured
the Company remained compliant with
sanctions. The Group’s compliance
programme ensured there were processes
in place to manage these risks and
reviews performed to evaluate sanctions
compliance.
The Committee is supported by a
number of sources of internal assurance
within the Group in order to discharge
its responsibilities. Risks are regularly
reviewed and management provides
updates to the Committee on how they
are managed within particular business
areas. It also receives reports from the
Internal Audit team and reports on any
compliance issues and litigation updates.
The Internal Audit Plans for 2023 and
2024 included a thorough risk heatmap.
The Internal Audit Plan is risk-based and
aligns with the Company’s strategy. We
challenged the reports by management
and Internal Audit and requested data
regarding compliance with key policies and
procedures related to operational risk.
With respect to external assurance, the
Committee reviews the external auditors
reports presented to the Committee,
which include its observations on risk
management and internal financial
controls identified as part of its audit.
Further information on our risk
management and internal controls can be
found in the Risk Committee Report on
pages 224 to 228.
Audit Committee Report continued
223
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Fair, balanced and understandable reporting
The Committee reviewed drafts of this Annual Report and Accounts to consider whether it is fair, balanced and understandable, and
whether it provides the information necessary for shareholders to assess the Groups performance, business model and strategy. The
Committee continued to gain assurance that there is a robust process of review and challenge at different levels within the Group to
ensure balance and consistency. Details of our process is set out below:
1. Audit Committee review
The Committee reviewed the Annual Report throughout the process and actively provided
input and challenge to ensure balance and consistency.
2. Report from the CFO
The Committee received a report from the CFO covering the financial statements within
the Annual Report and Accounts, including any amendments to areas of focus and any new
accounting standards during the period.
3. Fair, balanced and
understandable assessment
A fair, balanced and understandable assessment was prepared by the Management Team
and presented to the Audit Committee. In addition, the overall messages and tone of the
Annual Report was discussed with the Bank’s CEO and CFO, and the Committee considered
other information regarding performance presented to the Board during the period.
4. External audit review
The external auditor presented the results of its audit work to the Committee.
5. Recommendation to
the Board
The Board received and approved the Committees recommendation that a fair, balanced
and understandable statement could be made as detailed within the Directors’ Responsibility
Statement on page 248.
Outcome
Following this review, we believe the 2023 Annual Report and Accounts is representative
of the year and presents an understandable overview providing the necessary information
for shareholders to assess the Group’s position, performance, business model and
strategy.
Acquisition of Ameriabank CJSC
The Committee undertook extensive work in respect of the Ameriabank acquisition to ensure appropriate due diligence, feasibility,
working capital and reporting. The Committee received updates from management regarding their findings during the due diligence
process and the accounting methodology adopted by Ameriabank was reviewed and considered appropriate.
The Committee has also received updates from management regarding financials and the Ameriabank finance team which were
considered to be strong. The Committee has identified areas of opportunity to enhance controls and to align with the Company’s
approach as a UK listed entity.
During 2024 the Committee will focus on ensuring appropriate processes and controls are in place, particularly in respect of
reporting and compliance.
FRC correspondence
During the year the FRC conducted a review of the Company’s 2022 Annual Report and Accounts in accordance with Part 2 of
the FRC Corporate Reporting Review Operating Procedures and wrote a letter to the Company regarding their findings. The
FRC stated that there were ‘no questions or queries’ in relation to the 2022 Annual Report and Accounts which they wished
to raise with the Company. The FRC highlighted certain matters which the Company were invited to consider in relation
to preparation of the 2023 Annual Report and Accounts, to improve on in future reporting for the benefit of the users and
stakeholders. The Committee reviewed the letter from the FRC, and the Company’s response letter, and noted the matters
highlighted to Company for future reporting which have been addressed in the 2023 Annual Report and Accounts.
The FRC’s letter noted that the scope of their review was limited to the 2022 Annual Report and Accounts and did not benefit
from detailed knowledge of the Group’s business. In line with FRC requirements, the letter provides no assurance that the 2022
Annual Report and Accounts are correct in all material respects. The FRC’s role is not to verify the information provided but to
consider compliance with reporting requirements.
224
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Risk Committee Report
Key objectives of the Committee
The Risk Committee focuses on the following matters:
Risk oversight
Provides advice in relation to risk exposures.
Oversees risk management policies, processes and
infrastructure.
Oversees, supports and evaluates the risk management
roles of the senior management team.
Risk appetite
Reviews Group risk appetite in line with the strategy and
the regulatory requirements.
Supports the Board to ensure the risk profile is in line
with the overall strategy, and well managed within a
sound and comprehensive risk appetite framework.
Risk management
Identifies and monitors risk exposure and the risk
management infrastructure.
Assesses the strength and effectiveness of the risk
management and internal control framework.
Assesses the Groups capability to identify, measure and
manage new types of risk.
Assesses, reviews and challenges the emerging and
principal risks facing the Company.
Assesses the adequacy and quality of the Risk
Management function in conjunction with the Audit
Committee.
Oversees risk management policies, processes,
methodologies and infrastructure.
Reviews the principal risks and uncertainties disclosures
in the Half-year and Annual Reports.
Safeguarding the Group by ensuring a robust oversight of the Group’s ERM
framework and risk management activities.
Membership of Risk Committee
Committee membership Date of membership
Véronique McCarroll (Chair) 1 October 2018
1 January 2022 (Chair)
Alasdair Breach* 24 February 2018
Tamaz Georgadze 24 February 2018
Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi 12 March 2021
* Alasdair Breach resigned as a Non-executive Director and as a member of the
Committee on 15 March 2024.
The skills and experience each member contributes can be
found on pages 198 to 200.
All members of the Committee are independent Non-
executive Directors of the Board. Committee members
have the right to attend Committee meetings, as well as
any other Non-executive Directors of the Board. Other
individuals including the Chair of the Board, Group CEO,
CFO, CRO, other representatives of the Groups risk
function, CLO, Internal Audit and External Auditor may
be invited to attend all or part of any meeting if deemed
appropriate and necessary with the agreement of the
Committee Chair. The Bank’s CRO is David Chkonia,
who has full access to the Committee and attends all its
meetings.
Meeting attendance
Details of the members’ attendance at the meetings of the
Committee are as follows
Committee membership
No. of meetings
attended
Véronique McCarroll (Chair) 4/4 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc*
Alasdair Breach 4/4 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc*
Tamaz Georgadze 4/4 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc*
Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi 4/4 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc*
* There was one ad hoc meeting during the year where the Audit Committee and
Risk Committee met jointly.
Regular attendees at meetings
CRO, CEO, UK General Counsel and Company Secretary.
Invitations to attend meetings are extended to all Directors.
2024 focus areas
In the coming year the main areas of focus for the
Committee will be:
Continuing to monitor and review the risks and potential
threats caused by the Russia-Ukraine war, particularly
in relation to compliance, information security and
fluctuations in interest and FX rates, as well as
consideration for longer-term economic impacts.
Updating and enhancing the risk appetite framework,
including new metrics as appropriate in relation to
operational or AML risks.
Creating a Bank-wide Risk Registry to provide a
comprehensive view of risk within the Bank – including
operational, financial, strategic and compliance risk.
Overseeing the integration of recently acquired
Ameriabank in the risk governance framework of the
Group.
Collaboration with the Audit Committee
The Committee also works closely with the Audit
Committee to ensure both Committees are updated and
aligned on matters of common interest, to maintain a broad
and full view of the Group’s risk management matters.
Joint meetings of the Risk and Audit Committees are held
quarterly, with ad hoc meetings scheduled as required.
The Committees Terms of Reference set out its role and
authority, and can be found on the corporate website at
www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/documents
225
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Dear Shareholders,
As the Chair of the Risk Committee (the
‘Committee’), I am pleased to report on
the Company’s Risk Committee activities
and focus during 2023 on behalf of the
Board, and to provide details on how the
Committee operated and discharged its
responsibilities.
Risk oversight
The Committee has assisted the Board in
providing oversight of the Group’s overall
risk exposure profile in what continues to
be a challenging global macroeconomic
environment. The ongoing impact of the
Russia-Ukraine war and wider global
macroeconomic factors have remained a
focus area during 2023 and we received
regular updates via reports from the CRO
– particularly in relation to international
sanctions, liquidity risk and credit risk
exposures in the Bank’s loan book and
customer portfolios.
The Committee reviewed the processes
in place to assess, monitor and mitigate
the risks linked with these events,
together with continuing to monitor
the developments and changes to the
operational risk management framework,
the organisational structure of the
Risk department, the redefinition of
the ERM framework and reporting to
the Committee, as agreed in 2023.
The risk appetite framework is now
well embedded in the Group’s risk
governance and regularly monitored in
line with the Group’s strategy, capital
planning and regulatory requirements.
This year, the Bank reported its Internal
Capital Adequacy Assessment Process
(ICAAP) and Internal Liquidity Adequacy
Assessment Process (ILAAP) reports as
requested by the NBG, which were also
reviewed by the Committee.
The Committee has continued to
support CRO David Chkonia with
the enhancement of the Group’s risk
management framework, including
embedding the three-lines-of-defence
model, developments to the operational
risk management framework and
improving the organisational structure
of the Risk department. The Committee
has been pleased with the developments
as well as the improvements made in
reporting to the Committee through risk
reports and risk dashboards.
Risk management
framework
The Committee confirmed it is pleased
with the ongoing implementation of
and improvements to the Group’s risk
management framework, together with
the Groups operational risk management
framework, which has enabled the
proactive management of the operational
risks of the business and ensured our
operational risk profile remains robust.
During the year the Committee undertook
a deep-dive review of the Corporate
Banking top exposures to review single-
name and specific sector concentration
risk. Special attention was also directed
to the monitoring of liquidity risk in
the light of the international banking
context in the first half of the year, the
enhancement of the of AML screening
and monitoring systems, and consumer
lending risk models and processes. The
Committee recognises the importance
of monitoring other risks such as
information security, climate risks or
cyber risk which may affect the business.
Regulatory requirements
The Bank regularly engages in discussions
on regulatory changes with the NBG
and other stakeholders, such as
government bodies or banking and
business associations, to assess and
manage the impacts of these changes.
The Committee is regularly updated on
regulatory developments and compliance
with the NBG requirements.
Committee effectiveness
evaluation
We were delighted to welcome Clare
Chalmers Ltd as our Evaluator to
undertake an effectiveness evaluation
of the Committee during 2023. We were
pleased with the evaluation results and
the suggestions on how the Committee
can improve further, which we will keep
under review during 2024.
Further detail of the Committees work
during the year is set out in the following
report.
Véronique McCarroll
Chair of the Risk Committee
24 April 2024
Véronique McCarroll
Chair of Risk Committee
The Committee has continued to support
the ongoing enhancement of the Groups
risk management framework, challenging
how the Group assesses, monitors and
mitigates risk.
226
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Key Committee meeting topics during 2023
March June September December
Risk Report.
IFRS-based NBG Basel III
capital requirements.
Unsecured consumer
lending transformation
project.
Risk KPIs and KBOs.
Stress test assumptions,
ICAAP and ILAAP progress.
Risk Report.
AML initiatives and alerts
monitoring dashboard
review in light of the rise in
international sanctions.
Group risk structure.
NBG stress test exercise.
Liquidity risk exposure
profile and potential
deposit outflows scenarios.
ICAAP and ILAAP reports.
Risk Report.
Liquidity Coverage Ratio in
the perspective of new NBG
modelling requirements.
Received an update on the
unsecure consumer lending
transformation project
outcome.
Liquidity risks and Interest
Risk Rate.
Committee Terms
of Reference for
recommendation to the
Board.
Related Party Transaction
(RTP) Policy.
External committee
effectiveness report.
Risk Report.
Liquidity Coverage Ratio.
Corporate loan book deep-
dive analysis, including
specific outlook on top
sector and single-name
exposures.
NBG Review Assessment on
ALM and structural interest
rate risk.
Key activities during the year
Activity Summary of Activity Find out more (where applicable)
RPT Policy Reviewed and considered the RPT Policy
and recommended its approval by the
Board.
-
Organisation structure and operational
risk management framework
Oversaw the continued implementation
of the new organisation structure and
operational risk management framework.
-
Bank-wide Risk Registry In conjunction with the Audit Committee,
considered and agreed to introduce a
Bank-wide Risk Registry to provide a
comprehensive view of risk within the Bank
– including operational, financial, strategic
and compliance risk.
Page 224
AML and sanctions compliance risk
management
Oversaw the enhancement of the Group’s
AML and sanctions compliance risk
management.
Pages 227 to 228
ICAAP/ILAAP Reviewed the development and
documentation of the ICAAP/ILAAP
reports requested by the NBG.
Page 227
Liquidity Risks and Interest Risk Rate Reviewed the liquidity trends, current
liquidity buffer and interest rate risk
exposure.
Page 227
Risk Committee Report continued
227
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Committee effectiveness
The Committee undertakes an annual
review of its effectiveness. During 2023
the performance and effectiveness of
the Board and its Committees were
reviewed through an externally facilitated
evaluation process conducted by Clare
Chalmers Ltd. As part of the process,
Clare Chalmers Ltd reviewed documents
and observed the Committee in person at
the June 2023 meeting held in Tbilisi.
The Committee was presented with
the evaluation report and reviewed the
findings and proposals at the September
2023 meeting. The Committee was
described as a constructive forum
benefiting from the knowledge of its Non-
executive Directors, the Risk team and
external consultants, highlighting that
dynamic discussions take place between
these parties.
Following the evaluation the Committee
and the Audit Committee agreed upon
the creation of a Bank-wide Risk Registry
to provide a comprehensive view of risk
within the Bank – including operational,
financial, strategic and compliance risks.
The Committee will continue to consider
areas where it can improve in the future
to the benefit of the Company.
Reporting to the
Committee
During the year the Committee received
and considered a range of reports, updates
and presentations from the CRO, the
wider Risk team and management. The
Committee is pleased with the continued
increase in quality of reports and the
growing risk culture across the business.
External risks
Prior to each quarterly Committee
meeting the Board considers the
macroeconomic situation and geopolitical
risks, providing context for the
Committees discussions on the Groups
management of risks.
During the year the Committee continued
to receive and discuss updates on political
and geopolitical events relating to the
economies of Georgia’s key trading
partners, as well as the impact those
events may have on the Georgian economy.
Challenges in relation to increased client
inflows were highlighted as potential risks
to some entities using legal channels for
sanction evasion/avoidance, and were
mitigated through heightened monitoring
capabilities in the front and back offices,
increased AML resources and systems for
sanctions screening, and enhanced due
diligence for SWIFT transactions from or
to Russia – with all transactions in online
stopped by default. Georgia continues to
align its regulatory framework with that
of the EU, and during the year these areas
continued to be a focus of monitoring
and review by the Committee to ensure
each of the risks was being mitigated
satisfactorily.
Credit risk
1. Consumer lending
During the year the Committee reviewed
and received updates on the Unsecured
Consumer Lending Transformation
project to redesign the unsecured
consumer risk management process with
the aim of streamlining the collaboration
of all involved directions.
A new set of risk models was developed
by the Bank’s data scientists in
collaboration with McKinsey, providing
the Bank with a best-in-class model
governance framework. The new models
rely on fewer variables, which enables
easier monitoring and greater stability.
Implementation of the new risk band
management methodology is designed
to maintain risk levels and adjust the
underwriting strategy continuously. Risk
levels are aligned with the Bank’s risk
appetite and any deviation in the risk
profile is pre-determined, allowing the
Bank to improve alignment between the
main stakeholders and adjust the policy
to preserve the current risk level.
2. Corporate loan book
The Committee receives regular updates
regarding the Company’s financial risks
and loan book, including profiles of the
businesses with the most significant
exposures; management’s plans to
manage exposures through initiatives
including increasing local currency loans
and de-dollarisation of the portfolio;
analysis of retail borrowers’ debt-bearing
capacity; capital buffers; and capital
adequacy. Reports are discussed at
scheduled meetings and, where necessary,
during informal interim calls with
management. The Committee continues
to monitor the credit risk exposure, sector
and single name concentration of the
corporate loan book, as well as the total
foreign currency share of the retail loan
book.
In December 2023 the Committee,
at its request, reviewed a deep-dive
analysis of the corporate loan book.
The analysis focused on changes to the
concentration of exposures, higher-risk
areas within sectors, watch points and
mitigation levers. The results presented
an analysis of the aggregate corporate
portfolio showing single-name and sector
exposures, as well as a specific analysis
and economic outlook of four sectors:
hotel; residential real estate development;
commercial real estate; and healthcare.
It was assessed that the largest risk
exposures were carefully selected at
origination, and that the Bank had
enough mitigation capabilities to manage
the related risks.
Financial risks
In the first half of the year, the
Committee requested and reviewed a
deep dive analysis on the liquidity risk
exposure of the Bank, in the light of the
international banking context and the
liquidity problems that several banks
had faced in the US and Europe. The
results evidenced the Bank’s solid liquidity
position and healthy balance sheet, with
no major residual interest rate risks linked
to its securities portfolios.
The Committee and the Audit Committee
received updates on the ICAAP and
ILAAP, reviewed the reports and ensured
the Bank’s capital ratios were within the
regulatory requirements. The Committee
also reviews stress testing results,
including internally developed stress-tests
and those using the criteria specified
by the NBG. The NBG stress testing
results demonstrated that the Company
has a suitable buffer in line with the
requirement threshold.
During the year the Bank undertook an
independent consultation review of the
Groups Interest Rate Risk in the Banking
Book (‘IRRBB’), which was initiated by
the NBG in coordination with the ERBD
and performed by an independent
consultant, ALM Vision. The Committee was
pleased that the Bank’s current exposure
to IRRBB was assessed as compliant with
international standards.
Operational risks
Jointly with the Audit Committee, the
Risk Committee reviews the operational
risk profile through a comprehensive
risk heat-map and a description of the
top incidents and key risk scenarios.
Compliance risk and financial crime risk,
including internal and external fraud
risk, remain areas of focus. The Audit
and Risk Committees received a report
considering fraud risks and the actions
being undertaken to mitigate them.
The Committee considered the events
that had caused business disruption,
their root causes, mitigating actions and
remediation plans.
Furthermore, the Committee continued
to review monitoring metrics and agreed
to include an additional metric for
operational risk monitoring, together
with the redesign and implementation
of a new operational risk management
framework implemented in 2023 that
aims to enhance first-line engagement
in the processes and improve operational
risk management governance. The Bank
has also established an Operational Risk
Management Committee to further
improve decision-making processes.
AML and financial
crime risks
AML and sanctions compliance risk
management has been a key focus for the
Committee during 2023. The Committee
has reviewed and discussed the risks and
actions taken by the Bank regarding these
matters. The Committee has overseen
the creation of the Transaction Online
Screening and Global Banking Business
Direction to create a first line of defence
and increase the effectiveness of the
AML function. Improvements have also
228
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
been made to offline monitoring tools,
allowing monitoring to take place more
frequently and improving reporting
in this area. Sanctions training was
enhanced during the year to provide
a general understanding of different
sanctions regimes and the Bank’s internal
methodologies pertaining to client
onboarding and transaction screening.
IT and information
security risks
Strong IT infrastructure is key to
ensuring the Bank is resilient and able
to maintain necessary systems and
processes. During the year the Audit
and Risk Committees worked together
to oversee the development of a risk-
based information security approach,
which included the implementation of a
cyber risk management framework and
maintenance of a cyber risk register.
The Bank has established a cybersecurity
risk management framework to align with
risk methodology and compliance with
the new Georgian laws on information
security, and to develop appropriate
cyber response plans. A key achievement
during the year was the introduction of a
vandal-protected backup storage system
to ensure neither external nor malicious
internal actors can harm the core
database backup in any technological
way.
Following the appointment of a DDoS
mitigation service provider in 2023, which
has the capability to defend the Bank’s
infrastructure from larger DDoS attacks
and keep services available, the Committee
continues to see positive progress of the
cyber response plans with IT and other key
stakeholders actively engaged.
Emerging risks
The Committee continues to monitor
emerging risks, including those related
to climate and ESG, and oversees the
implementation of the TCFD disclosures.
Climate risk analysis is now embedded in
the credit approval request process and
was also included in the corporate loan
book analysis. For more details on climate
action, please see pages 99 to 118 of the
Sustainable Business section.
ERM
The Committee considered a wide range
of risks facing the Group, both principal
and emerging, across all key areas of risk
management. The Committee assists the
Board in setting the Groups Risk Appetite
Statement and updating the Company’s
risk appetite metrics. During the year the
Committee continued to work closely with
the Audit Committee to ensure the risk
management framework and systems
of internal controls operate effectively
and in compliance with the UK Corporate
Governance Code and FRC guidance.
Management reviewed the risk mitigation
tools and control functions and reported
to the Committee and the Audit
Committee on their assessment of the
effectiveness of these controls. The
Committee completed a robust review
of the principal risk disclosures and other
relevant risk management disclosures,
and provided recommendations to the
Board on their inclusion in the Half-year
and Annual Report.
In conjunction with the Audit Committee,
the Committee reviewed the viability
statement as detailed on page 170.
Risk Committee Report continued
229
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Overview
The members of the Remuneration
Committee during the year were as
follows:
Committee
membership
Date of
membership
Cecil Quillen 24 February 2018.
Chair since
1 January 2023.
Al Breach 24 February 2018
Tamaz Georgadze 24 February 2018
Hanna Loikkanen 20 September
2019
Mel Carvill 10 March 2022
Cecil Quillen became Chair of the
Committee on 1 January 2023, having
previously been a member. Al Breach
stepped down from the Board and the
Committee on 15 March 2024.
All members of the Committee are
independent Non-executive Directors of
the Board. The skills and experience that
each member contributes can be found on
pages 198 to 200.
The members’ meeting attendance for
the year is set out below.
Committee
member
No. of meetings
attended
Cecil Quillen
(Chair)
3/3 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc
Al Breach 3/3 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc
Tamaz Georgadze 3/3 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc
Hanna Loikkanen 3/3 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc
Mel Carvill 3/3 scheduled
1/1 ad hoc
In addition to formal meetings held during
the year, the Committee also participated
in various telephone discussions.
There is a standing invitation for other
Board members to attend meetings. The
CEO and other members of management
may be invited to attend meetings to
provide more insight into key issues
and developments. Other attendees at
Committee meetings who provided advice
or assistance on remuneration matters
from time to time include the CEO, the
Head of Human Capital and Employee
Experience Management, Business
Processes and Lean Transformation
Capital Management, the Chief Legal
Officer and the UK General Counsel.
Attendees at Committee meetings do
not participate in discussions or decisions
related to their own remuneration, which
helps avoid conflicts of interest.
The Remuneration Committee is
principally responsible for establishing
and implementing a Remuneration Policy
that rewards fairly and responsibly and
is designed to support the Companys
strategy and promote its long-term
sustainable success. The Committee
takes into account pay and employment
conditions elsewhere in the Group, and
oversees any major changes in employee
remuneration structures.
The Committees terms of reference set
out the Committees role and authority,
and can be found on the corporate
website at https://bankofgeorgiagroup.
com/governance/documents.
The Committee considers outside
guidelines, for example the Investment
Association Principles of Remuneration.
The UK General Counsel attends
events organised by investor bodies,
proxy advisors, accountancy firms, law
firms, regulatory bodies and similar
organisations to keep the Committee up
to date with developing market practice.
Cecil Quillen
Chair of the Remuneration
Committee
What is in this report?
This Directors’ Remuneration Report includes:
The Annual Statement by the Chair of the Remuneration Committee and the Annual
Report on Remuneration describe the implementation of Bank of Georgia Group
PLC Directors’ Remuneration Policy and discloses the amounts earned relating to
the year ended 31 December 2023.
A summary of the current Remuneration Policy approved at the 2022 AGM is set
out on pages 243 to 247, the full text of which can be found on our website at https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/documents.
The report complies with the provisions of the Companies Act 2006 and Schedule
8 of The Large and Medium-sized Companies and Groups (Accounts and Reports)
Regulations 2008. It has been prepared in line with the recommendations of the UK
Corporate Governance Code and the requirements of the Listing Rules.
Directors’ Remuneration Report
230
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Dear Shareholders,
On behalf of the Board, I am pleased
to present the Directors’ Remuneration
Report for the financial year ended
31 December 2023.
The Remuneration Committee received
market and stakeholder updates, set the
KPIs for and considered the remuneration
of the CEO, of the executives and of the
wider workforce. It also underwent an
external evaluation and strengthened its
Terms of Reference.
Shareholders voted 92.83% in support
of the Remuneration Report at the 2023
AGM. The Committee discussed the
feedback from engagement with specific
investors on remuneration matters and
on our remuneration structure. The
Board appreciates such engagement
and, as ever, continues to be available to
stakeholders on such matters.
Remuneration Structure
The Committee believes the Director’s
Remuneration Policy (the ‘Policy’) is
in the best interests of the Group.
It is consistent with the regulatory
requirement of the National Bank
of Georgia (‘NBG’), and has very
strong alignment with the interests of
shareholders.
The structure dictates that a high
proportion of the salary, and all
performance-related pay, is in deferred
shares (no cash bonus). This creates
strong medium- to long-term alignment
with shareholders. Nil-cost options
are allocated at the time of grant,
rather than vesting, which ensures
maximum alignment with shareholders.
Performance-related deferred shares
are subject to an extensive malus and
clawback regime.
The key elements of the Policy are as
follows:
In accordance with the NBG’s
requirements, share salary is fixed in
monetary value in the contract, which
is translated into deferred shares.
Vesting and holding periods are set out
in the Policy and are over a total period
of five years for salary shares.
Performance-based remuneration is
capped at a maximum of 100% of
salary (cash and share salary).
The vesting and holding periods for
discretionary performance-based
remuneration result in shares being
released over a period of eight years
from the beginning of the work year
– an increase from the six-year period
under the previous Policy.
Pension entitlements for Executive
Directors and senior management are
in line with the Georgian workforce, at
0-2% contribution by the Bank with
a further 0-2% contribution by the
Georgian Government.
Shareholding guidelines require
Executive Directors to build and
maintain a shareholding requirement
equivalent to 200% of total salary,
to be built up and maintained for
two years post-employment. Given
the high proportion of remuneration
in deferred shares, and the length of
deferral, Executive Directors who have
been with the Company more than
a couple of years will naturally hold a
higher amount than the shareholding
guidelines at any particular time.
No cash bonus and no LTIP.
There is an increased focus on clawback
and malus in the forthcoming changes to
the UK Corporate Governance Code to
be effective from 2025. We believe that
this is an area in which the Company is
already ahead of market practice and
so is able to disclose early ahead of the
forthcoming Code:
Malus and clawback provisions are
extensive, and were expanded further
in 2022 – see page 246 for a summary.
Clawback applies for two years from
date of vesting, an increase from one
year under the previous Policy.
There are additional ‘bad leaver
provisions in the Executive Directors
contract, allowing for the forfeiture
of all unvested discretionary deferred
shares in certain circumstances.
The period of two years is appropriate
as it allows enough time for matters to
come to light and be considered. Malus
and clawback were not utilised in the last
reporting period. The Executive Director’s
contract includes the malus and clawback
provisions.
Context of remuneration
The Committee considered market
updates on remuneration proposals,
market practice, proxy advisors’ updates
and reports and policies.
Following previous feedback from a
major shareholder, we disclose the total
shareholdings of top management in
this report. Also, further to feedback in
previous years, there is a higher overall
weighting for financial KPIs than for non-
financial KPIs for the CEO’s performance-
related pay.
Given the importance of ESG matters
to stakeholders, the Committee selected
KPIs for the CEO relating to material
ESG matters. The Company identified
financial inclusion as a key material ESG
area given our position as a systemic bank
in an emerging economy. This year we
have introduced two additional financial
inclusion metrics: sCoolApp Monthly
Active Users and the number of self-
employed borrower clients. See pages 86
to 91 in the Sustainable Business section
for further information on financial
inclusion and the reasons for selection as
a material area of focus.
The Groups purpose is helping people
achieve more of their potential, and
KPIs are chosen to reflect sustainable
growth so the Company can support
its customers. This is underpinned by a
structure that defers remuneration, in
shares, for up to eight years.
The Groups values, identified by an
employee engagement exercise, are
motivation, courage, creation/action
and encouragement. Our business
principles, identified by a management
team exercise based on the outcome
of the employee engagement exercise,
are teamwork, development, fairness,
customer-centricity, operational
excellence, and innovation. The CEO is
held accountable for these values and
principles by the Net Promoter Score
(NPS) and Employee Net Promoter Score
(eNPS) KPIs.
The Committee set the KPIs for the
CEO for 2023 early in the year, including
threshold, target and maximum levels for
each and weightings for each. Relevant
KPIs were also cascaded to each member
of senior management who also had
additional KPIs in accordance with their
roles and responsibilities.
Terms of Reference
The Committee reviewed its Terms of
Reference and made recommendations
for changes to the Board. These included
adding wording, in accordance with best
practice, that remuneration policies
and practices should be, amongst other
matters, (i) linked to the successful
delivery of the Group’s long-term
strategy and linked to Environmental,
Social and Governance related targets
where appropriate, and (ii) open to the
use of discretion to override formulaic
outcomes and/or to recover or withhold
sums or share awards under appropriate
circumstances.
Workforce remuneration
matters
During the year, the Committee
considered the results of market
comparisons to salaries in the Bank,
including at entry positions, mass
positions and senior positions. Further,
a position levelling and job ranking
exercise was carried out by the Human
Capital Management department and
the Committee noted that work was
ongoing to make levelling factors more
specific and applicable to performance
evaluations.
Progress was also made in the review of
front office compensation packages to
resolve any gaps with the market.
231
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
The Committee discussed equal pay
gap and raw gender pay gap data.
Work is ongoing to continue various
talent development activities to support
professional and career progression of
employees in lower positions.
The Committee considered minor
amendments to workforce remuneration
policies for employees of the Bank.
The policies cover fixed and variable
remuneration as well as benefits.
Employees can be awarded deferred
shares via the Employee Equity
Compensation Plan on a discretionary
basis. The alignment with the Groups
values and its long-term sustainable
success is enhanced by this scheme.
The Committee considered and approved
an overview of the employee bonuses for
2023. These are divided along business
lines and comprise both cash bonuses and
share bonuses.
Year on year, for 2023 the average cash
salary increased by 23.5%, the average
deferred share salary decreased by 5.2%
and the average employee total bonus
increased by 10.1%.
Hanna Loikkanen is a member of the
Remuneration Committee and designated
Non-executive Director to engage with
the workforce. She facilitated three
informal discussions known as ‘Employee
Voice’ to engage with the workforce. All
Board members are invited to participate
in these meetings, which aim to facilitate
the exchange of opinions, ideas and views
between the Board and the workforce
and allow the workforce to raise matters
(including remuneration). Further
information on the output from these
meetings can be found in the Directors
Governance Statement on page 210.
The Committee also considered the
performance of senior management
against each of their KPIs (which
were each weighted) and their overall
performance and approved the
discretionary awards. Remuneration for
senior management is predominantly in
deferred shares.
2023 performance-based
remuneration for Executive
Director
2023 was another successful year
during which the Group, led by the CEO,
continued to deliver on our strategic
priorities. Focus on customer needs and
product quality translated into profit
before tax of GEL 1,634 million (adjusted
for one-offs) and an ROAE of 29.9%
(adjusted for one-offs). Cost:income
ratio was a historical low at 29.8%. The
continued strength of the loan portfolio
translated into a lower cost of credit risk
ratio of 0.7%.
The Group closed the year with a Net
Promoter Score of 59.3, highlighting its
dedication to customer satisfaction and
an Employee Net Promoter Score of 55.6.
As stated in the ‘Further stakeholder
considerations’ section above we have
expanded the accountability of the CEO
for “Developing ESG in line with the
Groups material areas of focus”, with four
different metrics measured and disclosed
in the KPI table below in this report.
The Committee considered the personal
contribution of the CEO to the fulfilment
of the Groups strategy and to the
overall corporate performance. The
Group achieved excellent results under
his leadership and in part through his
initiatives.
During 2023 the CEO executed the
strategy set by the Board for careful
deployment of surplus capital in a
thorough and efficient manner. He
carried out thorough due diligence and
negotiations and presented to the Board
the attractively accretive acquisition of
Ameriabank. This was achieved with no
dilution for shareholders and the Group
continued to implement its capital
distribution policy.
Shareholders received a final dividend for
2022 in July following the 2023 AGM. An
interim dividend of GEL 3.06 per share
was paid in October 2023. In February
2023, the Board approved an increase of
up to GEL 148 million in its share buyback
and cancellation programme. In August
2023, the Board approved the launch
of a GEL 62 million share buyback and
cancellation programme. As disclosed in
the Preliminary Financial Results release,
for full year 2023 the Board intends to
recommend to shareholders at the AGM
a final dividend of GEL 4.94 per share. In
addition, the Board has also approved an
extension of the buyback and cancellation
programme by an additional GEL 100
million. The Committee noted that the
market cap increased 47% during 2023
from GBP 1,237 million at FY 2022 to
GBP 1,817 million at FY 2023.
Each KPI was considered against the
threshold, target and maximum level and
in accordance with these calculations
Mr Gachechiladze was awarded 97.0% of
his maximum opportunity, which was paid
in deferred shares. The Remuneration
Committee concluded that the level
of deferred share award as calculated
against the KPIs remained appropriate
and it did not exercise discretion.
The level of award is considered to be
appropriate as it reflected his very strong
performance against all KPIs including
financial metrics, strategic and ESG
metrics, the experience of shareholders
in terms of value creation (through the
buybacks, dividends and the share price
movement) and the wider stakeholder
experience of the Company (including the
increase to the employees’ salaries and
bonuses).
You can read the KPI calculations and
disclosures, and notes on each KPI, in
the section entitled ‘Basis for determining
Mr Gachechiladzes discretionary deferred
share remuneration in respect of 2023’
later in this Report.
Remuneration Committee
effectiveness review and
priorities for 2024
An independent evaluator, Clare
Chalmers Ltd (the ‘Evaluator’) undertook
an external review of the Committee in
2023. They reviewed Committee papers,
interviewed members of the Committee,
management and others and observed
the Committee meeting in person.
The Evaluator noted that the Committee
changed its Chair at the beginning of
year, and credit was given to the outgoing
Chair for her efforts in engagement with
shareholders. I was judged as Chair to be
aware of the major issues and UK listing
context. The Committee was observed
as having good discussions on the issues
and aiming to strike a balance between
different stakeholders. Those members of
the Board who are not members of the
Committee expressed to the Evaluator
that feedback to the Board is good.
In 2024, the Committees priority will
be to consider and consult on a new
Remuneration Policy, which will be put
to shareholders at the 2025 AGM in
accordance with the three-year cycle.
Cecil Quillen
Chair of the Remuneration Committee
24 April 2024
232
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Annual Report on Remuneration
Shareholder context
Below are the shareholder voting figures for the most recent Directors’ Remuneration Report (2022), as presented at our AGM on
19 May 2023:
Resolution Votes for % Votes against % Total votes cast Votes withheld
Approval of the Directors
Remuneration Report 34,832,255 92.82 2,692,899 7.18 37,525,154 408
The Directors’ Remuneration Policy was last approved by shareholders at our AGM on 20 June 2022. The Policy received the following
votes from shareholders:
Resolution Votes for % Votes against % Total votes cast Votes withheld
Approval of the Directors
Remuneration Policy 26,378,680 67.62 12,629,820 32.38 39,008,500 250
In response to the significant minority of votes against the Policy, the Committee undertook an extensive shareholder engagement
exercise covering 50% of our shareholder base, with focus on those who voted against the Policy (as well as including many who did
not). We extensively disclosed on the process, the results and action taken in the previous year’s Annual Report. You can read more
about this in the ‘Shareholder Engagement and response’ section in the Chair’s Letter of the Directors’ Remuneration Report 2022
at https://bankofgeorgiagroup.com/reports/annual.
How the Remuneration Committee addressed the factors in provision 40 of the
UK Code
The Remuneration Committee pays close attention to the requirements of the UK Corporate Governance Code (‘the Code’) in
determining the Policy and its structure. This includes the factors set out in provision 40 of the Code:
Principle Approach
Clarity
The rationale is clear: the Executive Director and senior management are incentivised towards the
medium- to long-term success of the Company. Targets for annual bonuses are aligned to the Groups
strategic priorities. This provides clarity to shareholders and other stakeholders on the relationship
between the successful delivery of the Group’s strategy and remuneration paid.
Simplicity
The Policy is designed to retain simplicity while complying with all relevant regulatory requirements and
meeting shareholder expectations. Remuneration elements include fixed pay (base salary comprising cash
salary and deferred salary shares, pension and benefits) and variable pay (discretionary deferred shares
and no cash bonus).
Risk
By its nature, having such a high proportion of the remuneration in shares deferred over several years,
the structure drives the CEO and senior management to mitigate reputational and behavioural risks or
short-termism in their actions and decisions, and avoids conflicts of interest. The Policy also has minimum
shareholding and post-employment shareholding requirements.
Predictability
The Policy describes the purpose, operation and maximum potential of each remuneration element and
illustrates a range of potential outcomes for Executive Directors. Weighted KPIs and ranges for the
targets of KPIs are used in the financial year’s performance review.
Proportionality
Outcomes reward performance proportionately by reference to performance targets, although the
Remuneration Committee retains its discretion to adjust the award as it considers appropriate. For
further considerations on proportionality, see the ‘CEO’s pay and comparators – peers’ section on page
237, which includes a list of possible peers. The CEO’s performance-based remuneration is subject to
extensive malus and clawback provisions.
Alignment to
culture
A high proportion of remuneration paid in deferred shares rather than cash promotes alignment with the
culture and long-term success of the Company. Further, the CEO’s performance KPIs include: (i) Employee
Net Promoter Score; and (ii) developing ESG in line with the Groups material areas of focus.
See the Chair’s Letter for further explanation of the alignment to the Groups purpose and values.
Advisors
The Committee was not advised by remuneration consultants during 2023 or 2024 to date. The Committee received additional
advice on compliance from Baker & McKenzie LLP, the Groups legal advisors, and is of the view that this advice was objective and
independent.
233
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Single total figure of remuneration for the sole Executive Director (audited)
The table below sets out the remuneration earned by the Company’s Executive Director, Archil Gachechiladze, in respect of his
employment with the Company for the years ended 31 December 2023 and 31 December 2022.
Mr Gachechiladzes current service agreements provide for salary in the form of cash and deferred shares. In addition, he is eligible
to receive discretionary deferred share remuneration up to a maximum of 100% of total salary. The current Policy has applied since
1 January 2022.
For 2023, 80.2% of Mr Gachechiladzes remuneration as set out in the table below is in the form of deferred shares. Deferred shares will
vest in tranches, with vesting and holding periods of up to eight years from the start of the work year in accordance with the Policy.
Cash salary
1
(US$)
Deferred
share salary
2
(US$)
Taxable
benefits
3
(US$)
Pension
benefits
4
(US$)
Dividend
equivalents
5
(US$)
Total
fixed pay
(US$)
Discretionary
deferred
share
remuneration
6
(US$)
Total
variable pay
(US$)
Single
total figure
(US$)
2023 370,000 2,200,000 62,597 3,400 722,386 3,358,383 2,492,902 2.492,902 5,851,285
2022 370,000 2,200,000 58,054 3,400 282,676 2,914,130 2,490,343 2,490,343 5,404,473
Notes:
1. Expressed in US Dollars but paid in British Pounds and Lari, as applicable, converted into the respective currency as at the date of payment. Accordingly, there may be
variations in the numbers above and those provided in the accounts.
2. Deferred share salary. The figures show the value of the underlying nil-cost options over BOGG shares granted in respect of the 2023 and 2022 work years. For 2023,
Mr Gachechiladze was awarded 71,694 BOGG shares, the number of shares were calculated by reference to US$ 30.6859 share price which is the average share price of
the five working days before 25 December 2022. For 2022 Mr Gachechiladze was awarded 106,034 BOGG shares, the number of shares was calculated by reference to a
US$ 20.7481 share price (which is the average share price of the five working days before 25 December 2021). For each award, the shares vest on the first anniversary of
the start of the work year but are subject to holding periods so that 40% is released on the second anniversary, and 20% is released on each of the third, fourth and fifth
anniversaries, of the start of the work year, all subject to the terms of his service agreement.
3. Benefits. The figures show the gross taxable value of Mr Gachechiladze’s health, life and personal accident insurance and tax equalisation payments.
4. Pensions. The figures show the aggregate employer contributions for the relevant years into the Group’s defined contribution pension scheme. Under the Groups defined
contribution pension scheme, normal retirement age is 65. Mr Gachechiladze receives up to 2% employer contribution, in line with other Georgian employees.
5. Dividend equivalents. The figure shows the dividend value paid in respect of nil-cost options exercised in the relevant year. The difference in dividend equivalents is a result of
total number of deferred shares held and of the Group’s dividend growth and not of a change in Policy or in the application of Policy.
6. Discretionary deferred share remuneration. The figures show the value of the underlying nil-cost options over BOGG shares granted in respect of bonus awards in the
relevant year. For 2023 Mr Gachechiladze was awarded 51,462 shares. The number of shares were calculated by reference to the closing share price on 12 February 2024
(the working day before the meeting) which was US$48.4416 (based on the official share price of GBP 38.40 per share converted into Dollars using an exchange rate of
1.2615, being the official exchange rate published by the Bank of England on the same date). For 2022 Mr Gachechiladze was awarded 74,962 BOGG shares. For 2022 the
number of shares were calculated by reference to the closing share price on 9 February 2023 (the working day before the meeting) which was US$ 33.2214 (based on the
official share price of GBP 27.30 per share converted into Dollars using an exchange rate of 1.2169, being the official exchange rate published by the Bank of England on the
same date). In each cash the discretionary remuneration is deferred and any discretionary deferred shares will vest as follows: 40% vests immediately, and 15% will vest on
each of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth anniversaries of the start of the work year; each tranche is subject to a further two-year holding period and so are released on the
fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth anniversaries of the start of the work year. The awards are subject to the leaver provisions as described in the Policy available at https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/documents. The means of determining the number of shares underlying this remuneration and the terms and conditions are described
in the Policy. The basis for determining Mr Gachechiladze’s 2023 discretionary award is described on pages 234 to 235.
7. Mr Gachechiladze was reimbursed for reasonable business expenses, on provision of valid receipts in line with Company policy.
8. No money or other assets are received or receivable by Mr Gachechiladze in respect of a period of more than one financial year. The Company does not operate an LTIP.
9. The number of shares awarded pursuant to the deferred share salary and discretionary deferred share remuneration is fixed on grant. No discretion has been exercised as a
result of share price appreciation or depreciation. Discretionary deferred shares are subject to one-year targets which are satisfied pre-grant. No amounts were recovered or
withheld in 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 or 2023. The values reported at grant are not attributable to share price appreciation.
It is notable that the deferred share salary is released over a five-year period, and discretionary deferred share remuneration vests in
tranches over a total vesting and holding period of eight years from the start of the work year, during which actual share prices will
also vary.
The following table sets out details of total remuneration for the CEO, Mr Gachechiladze, for the period from 28 January 2019 (effective
date of appointment) to 31 December 2023, and his discretionary compensation as a percentage of maximum opportunity.
Note that 2019 was not a complete year, that in 2020 part of his cash salary was voluntarily reduced, and that variations in share
price affect the total figure of remuneration for 2019, 2020 and 2021 – these years used a share salary of 75,000 deferred shares for
a complete year and a maximum discretionary opportunity of 75,000 deferred shares plus cash salary equivalent in deferred shares.
The cash value of the maximum discretionary deferred remuneration varied according to the last closing share price before the date
of relevant Remuneration Committee meeting.
2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
Single total figure of remuneration (US$) 3,558,415
1
1,561,020 3,886,930 5,404,473
4
5,851,285
Discretionary compensation as a percentage of
maximum opportunity (%) 100% 0%
2
97.0%
3
96.9% 97.0%
Notes:
1. 2019 was not a complete year as Mr Gachechiladze was appointed from 28 January 2019.
2. Mr Gachechiladze did not receive a bonus for the 2020 work year after the NBG informed the Remuneration Committee that, as the Bank had utilised the Pillar 2 or conservation
buffers, no bonus should be granted – please see the Chair’s Letter in the Directors’ Remuneration Report of the Annual Report and Accounts 2021 for further information. For 2020,
the approved discretionary deferred share award, which considered KPIs disclosed in the 2020 Directors’ Remuneration Report and subsequently approved by shareholders, was 67%
of maximum opportunity (but was not paid, as per the previous sentence). Mr Gachechiladze’s 2020 cash salary (and that of executive management) was voluntarily reduced by 20%
from 1 March 2020 to 31 December 2020, and the amount donated to charity by Mr Gachechiladze – half of the remaining cash salary for that period – has not been taken into account
and has been retained in the above amount.
3. The increase in remuneration in 2021 compared to 2020 is attributable partly to the reinstatement of the normal cash salary as per Note 2, partly to the bonus being paid, and
partly to variations in share price. Share salary and bonus were calculated in accordance with the share price at the time; for each of 2019, 2020 and 2021, share salary would have
been 75,000 shares for a complete year, and for 2022 and 2023 was cash converted into deferred shares in accordance with the approved Policy and NBG requirements.
4. Share salary and bonus were calculated using a cash value converted into deferred shares in accordance with the amounts in and terms of the approved Policy and NBG
requirements.
234
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Basis for determining Mr Gachechiladzes discretionary deferred share remuneration in
respect of 2023
Mr Gachechiladzes KPIs included both financial and non-financial components. They largely track the Group’s published KPIs as he is
expected to deliver on the Groups key strategic, financial and ESG priorities.
The following table sets out the financial KPIs set for Mr Gachechiladze in respect of 2023, and his performance against them. The
table below provides further explanation of each KPI.
The financial KPIs were selected to reflect key financial metrics for our investors and the sustainable health of our business. The
Remuneration Committee ensures targets set are relevant drivers of required annual performance. KPIs also take into account
stakeholders of the Group and its culture, alongside non-financial strategic priorities, and were disclosed in last year’s Annual Report.
To improve accountability, we have included four metrics within the Developing ESG KPI to help measure our key initiative of
financial inclusion in Georgia: Digital Transactional Monthly Active Users, Payments Monthly Active Users, sCool App Monthly Active
Users and Self-employed borrower clients.
KPI with weighting %
(Numbering refers to the notes below the table)
Threshold
(25%)
Target
(70%)
Max
(100%) Achievement
Weighted
performance
outcome (see
corresponding
notes below
for further
explanation)
Financial KPIs – 60%
1. ROAE (15%)
20+% is the medium term target, in line with strategy,
although the KPI has been made more challenging
20.0% 23.5% 26.5% 29.9%
See note 1 below
15.0%
2. Cost:income ratio (15%) 36.9% 34.9% 32.9% 29.8%
See note 2 below
15.0%
3. COR (15%)
Cost of credit risk ratio
1.4% 1.2% 0.9% 0.7%
See note 3 below
15.0%
4. PBT (15%)
Profit before tax
GEL 1,110mln GEL 1,210mln GEL 1,310mln GEL 1,634mln
See note 4 below
15.0%
Non-financial KPIs – 20%
5. NPS (6%)
Net Promoter Score
40.0 45.0 60.0 59.3
See note 5 below
5.9%
6. eNPS (6%)
Employee Net Promoter Score
46.0 54.0 62.0 55.6
See note 6 below
4.6%
7. Developing ESG in line with the
Group’s material areas of focus (8%)
• Transactional MAU
• Payments MAU
• sCoolApp MAU
• Self-employed borrower clients
1,000,000
1,100,000
50,000
50,000
1,100,000
1,200,000
70,000
57,000
1,170,000
1,300,000
100,000
64,000
1,182,399
1,248,713
89,641
54,705
See note 7 below
2.0%
1.7%
1.8%
1.1%
KPI total:
6.6%
Individual KPIs 20%
8. Individual Key Business Objectives Below Met Exceeded Exceeded
See note 8 below
20%
Total
97.0%
Further information on each KPI (corresponding to the numbering in the table above):
1. Return on Average Equity (ROAE): 29.9% achieved (adjusted for one-offs). ROAE reported was 30.4%. ROAE is a long-standing
metric of the Company and a key indicator of profitability for shareholders. Our communicated medium-term target remains
20%+. ROAE was 32.4% in 2022, 25.8% in 2021, 13.0% in 2020 and 26.1% in 2019 (adjusted for one-offs in 2022 and 2019). The
Committee notes that the achievement of 29.9% represents a high result.
2. Cost:income ratio: 29.8% achieved (adjusted for one-offs). Unadjusted cost:income ratio was 29.5%. Cost:income was 32.0% in
2022 (adjusted for one-offs), 37.2% in 2021, 39.7% in 2020 and 37.8% in 2019 (adjusted for one-offs).
3. Cost of Credit Risk ratio (COR): 0.7% achieved. The Group has maintained strong loan portfolio quality and its costs of credit risk
ratio was below its guided normalised range of 1.0-1.2%. Cost of credit risk ratio was 0.8% in 2022, 0.0% in 2021, 1.8% in 2020
and 0.9% in 2019.
4. Profit before tax (PBT): GEL 1,634 million achieved (adjusted for one-offs). PBT reported was 1,656 million. PBT was GEL 1,244
million in 2022 (adjusted for one-offs), GEL 802 million in 2021, GEL 316 million in 2020 and GEL 573 million in 2019 (adjusted for
one-offs). PBT is an important measure of overall performance for any business.
5. Net Promoter Score (NPS): 59.3 achieved in the fourth quarter 2023. NPS is based on external research and is one of the
key metrics for measuring customer satisfaction. Based on external research by IPM Georgia, surveying a random sample of
235
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
customers with face-to-face interviews. The Bank believes that satisfaction feeds customer loyalty, which in turn impacts the
sustainable profitability and the long-term success of the Group. NPS was 58.4 in 2022, 55 in 2021, 46 in 2020 and 37 in 2019.
6. Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS): 55.6 achieved. Employee NPS is calculated by the response to a confidential survey of
employees. It is based on the question, “On a scale of 0-10, how likely are you to recommend Bank of Georgia as a place to
work?” Responses of 9 and 10 are counted as promoters; 7 and 8 are neutral; and 0-6 are detractors. eNPS is calculated as the
percentage of promoters minus the percentage of detractors. eNPS was 52.9 in 2022, 61 in 2021, 58 in 2020 and 46 in 2019.
This metric feeds into profitability of the Bank through higher retention rates and thus lower recruitment requirements. It also
supports the Bank in the recruitment of the best talent, which is crucial in a small market like Georgia. To ensure employee
engagement and open lines of communication, the CEO held town halls and periodic live sessions with employees and maintained
a CEO vlog on Workplace.
7. Developing ESG in line with the Groups material areas of focus: Following a materiality assessment to gain a multi-stakeholder
perspective, and then a mapping of topics by importance to stakeholders and to business, three pillars were identified for
the Bank’s most material ESG impact areas: employee engagement, sustainable financial inclusion, and education/financial
education. Two metrics were originally identified in respect of sustainable financial inclusion: Digital MAU (also called digital
transactional monthly active users in this Annual Report) and Payments MAU and added as KPIs. Two further metrics were added
as KPIs in 2023 to reflect other areas of society: the sCool App for school students MAU and Self-employed borrower clients. The
results are disclosed in the table above.
Please see the Sustainable Business section on the importance of financial inclusion for individuals and businesses in our
emerging economy, on pages 86 to 91.
8. Individual Key Business Objectives (‘KBOs’): Outperformance achieved. The CEO’s KBOs were (i) the strategic deployment of
excess capital including careful international growth where merited and (ii) enhancement of the relationship with the Regulator.
The Board reviewed the strategy in February 2023 following discussions with key investors through roadshows and meetings
with the Board throughout the year, which had highlighted that there was appetite and support for the Groups excess capital
to be deployed for international growth. Archil Gachechiladze’s subsequent implementation of the strategy during 2023 was
carried out in a thorough and efficient manner. He presented several potential targets to board meetings that were carefully and
appropriately chosen for strategic growth in underserved emerging markets. These were weighed against the merits of other
deployment of capital, including additional returns to shareholders. He carried out thorough due diligence and negotiations and
presented to the Board the attractively accretive acquisition of Ameriabank. Ameriabank is a leading universal bank in Armenia,
a neighbouring country to Georgia with a similarly high GBP growth rate. It is a leading franchise in the local market with further
upside to grow, especially in the retail and SME segments, and to increase in digitalisation.
Mr Gachechiladze led the negotiations, ultimately resulting in an acquisition price of 0.65x net asset value as at 31 October 2023
implying a 2.6x price-to-earnings ratio. Further the cost of the acquisition was achieved with the Groups surplus capital and with
no dilution for shareholders. Importantly, the Companys dividend and capital distribution policy and payout ratio of 30-50% did
not change. This model implementation of his main Individual KBO was outstanding.
Additionally, Mr Gachechiladze worked carefully with the regulator to enhance our relationship in 2023. Our main entity, Bank of
Georgia, is classified as a systemically important financial institution in its jurisdiction. We are aware of our responsibilities and,
whilst working in a fully compliant manner with all respective regulations, we also remain committed to achieving a constructive
relationship with the regulator. Closely working with the regulator throughout the international expansion project, as well
as in constructive dialogue on many regulatory changes that the Georgian banking sector has implemented during the year,
Mr Gachechiladze has assisted the Group in achieving the desirable outcomes.
Overall, the CEO outperformed against most of the KPIs. The Committee considered the outstanding personal contribution of the
CEO to the overall corporate performance and noted the Group achieved excellent results under his leadership and in part through
his initiatives.
As well as the stakeholder matters covered by KPIs, the Committee also noted the wider stakeholder picture. Shareholders received
a final dividend for 2022 in July following the 2023 AGM. An interim dividend of GEL 3.06 per share was paid in October 2023. In
February 2023, the Board approved an increase of up to GEL 148 million in its share buyback and cancellation programme. In August
2023, the Board approved the launch of a GEL 62 million share buyback and cancellation programme. As disclosed in the Preliminary
Financial Results release, for full year 2023 the Board intends to recommend to shareholders at the AGM a final dividend of GEL 4.94
per share. In addition, the Board has also approved an extension of the buyback and cancellation programme by an additional GEL
100 million. The Committee noted that the market cap increased 47% during 2023 from GBP 1,237 million at FY 2022 to GBP 1,817
million at FY 2023.
From an employee perspective, the Committee was pleased to note that the average employee bonus for 2023 increased by 10.1%
year-on-year, the average cash salary increased by 23.5% while the average employee deferred share salary (which is paid to the
more senior managers) decreased by 5.2%. The change in total remuneration for the CEO was minimal (0.1% increase for bonus,
with cash salary and deferred shares salary each unchanged at 0.0%).
In accordance with the results of the KPIs as determined above, taking into account Mr Gachechiladze’s outstanding performance,
the Remuneration Committee awarded the CEO 97% of the maximum deferred share opportunity, which was paid in deferred
shares. This level of award is considered to be appropriate for performance but also as it reflected the experience of shareholders in
terms of value creation (through the buybacks, dividends and the increase in share price) and the wider experience of stakeholders of
the Company (including the increases to the employees’ salaries and bonuses).
Alignment with shareholders is built into the structure by the award being entirely in deferred shares, which have a total vesting and
holding period of eight years from the beginning of the work year. The discretionary deferred shares in relation to Mr Gachechiladze’s
2023 performance-based remuneration are awarded in accordance with the Policy. There is no cash bonus and the Company does
not operate an LTIP. The Remuneration Committee concluded that the level of deferred share award as calculated against the KPIs
remained appropriate and did not exercise discretion. As the number of deferred discretionary shares to be awarded is determined in
shares and fixed on the grant date, share price appreciation/depreciation did not impact the Remuneration Committees decision to
increase the number of shares to be awarded to Mr Gachechiladze for the 2023 financial year.
236
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Percentage change in remuneration of Directors and employees
The following table details the percentage change in the remuneration awarded to Directors, compared with the average
percentage change in the per capita remuneration awarded to the Groups employees, in line with the requirements of the
Companies (Directors’ Remuneration Policy and Directors’ Remuneration Report) Regulations 2019. Given the small number of
employees employed by the Bank of Georgia Group PLC entity (fewer than five), we instead make a comparison against the Group.
A comparison of full-time UK employees in compliance with the requirements of the Companies (Directors’ Remuneration Policy and
Directors’ Remuneration Report) Regulations 2019 is included in the notes to the table.
The ‘Single total figure of remuneration’ table on page 233 includes an explanation of cash salary, deferred share salary, taxable
benefits and discretionary deferred remuneration of the Executive Director in the notes to the table.
Year-on-year change in pay for Directors compared to the Group’s employees as a whole for FY2023
Executive Director Non-Executive Directors
Average
employee
Archil
Gachechiladze
3
Mel
Carvill
5
Hanna
Loikkanen
6
Al
Breach
7
Jonathan
Muir
Tamaz
Georgadze
8
Cecil
Quillen
Véronique
McCarroll
9
Mariam
Meghvinetukhutsesi
10
Total cash salary 23.5% 0.0% 29.9% -3.6% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 4.6% 0.0% 0.0%
Total deferred
share salary
1
-5.2% 0.0%
Taxable benefits 0.5% 7.8%
Total bonus
2
10.1% 0.1%
Year-on-year change in pay for Directors compared to the Group’s employees as a whole for FY2022
Executive
Director
Non-Executive Directors
Average
employee
Archil
Gachechiladze
3
Neil Janin
4
Mel
Carvill
5
Hanna
Loikkanen
6
Al
Breach
7
Jonathan
Muir
Tamaz
Georgadze
8
Cecil
Quillen
Véronique
McCarroll
9
Mariam
Meghvinetukhutsesi
10
Total cash salary 26.3% 0.0% (77.0)% 100% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% (6.6)% 0.0% 7.9% 41.6%
Total deferred
share salary
1
28.9% 30.5%
Taxable benefits 14.1% 1748.3%
Total bonus
2
27.6% 39.0%
Year-on-year change in pay for Directors compared to the Group’s employees as a whole for FY2021
Executive
Director
Non-Executive Directors
Average
employee
Archil
Gachechiladze
3
Neil Janin
4
Hanna
Loikkanen
6
Al
Breach
7
Jonathan
Muir
Tamaz
Georgadze
8
Cecil
Quillen
Véronique
McCarroll
9
Mariam
Meghvinetukhutsesi
10
Total cash salary (5.7)% 20% 0.0% 2.7% (3.4)% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
Total deferred
share salary
1
89.9% 35%
Taxable benefits 1.9% 229.2%
Total bonus
2
66.0% NMF
Year-on-year change in pay for Directors compared to the Group’s employees as a whole for FY2020
Executive Director Non-Executive Directors
Average
employee
Archil
Gachechiladze
3
Neil Janin
4
Hanna
Loikkanen
6
Al
Breach
7
Jonathan
Muir
Tamaz
Georgadze
8
Cecil
Quillen
Véronique
McCarroll
9
Total cash salary (2.8)% (16.7)% 0.0% 6.5% (1.8)% (0.6)% (0.6)% (0.6)% 7.2%
Total deferred
share salary
1
(27.3)% (22.4)%
Taxable benefits (4.4)% (42.8)%
Total bonus
2
(43.1)% NMF
Notes:
1. The number of salary shares for Mr Gachechiladze was constant at 75,000 shares per annum for 2019, 2020 and 2021 share prices, with share prices at 31 December 2019
(US$ 21.466), 31 December 2020 (US$ 16.652) and 31 December 2021 (US$ 22.480) used for the deferred shares salary comparison, but in accordance with the 2022 Policy
and NBG requirements the deferred share salary is based on a fixed cash value for 2022 onwards.
2. Total bonus in each case is discretionary deferred share remuneration for Mr Gachechiladze, which was not granted for 2020 (hence NMF), and deferred discretionary share
remuneration and/or any cash bonus in the case of other employees of the Group.
3. Mr Gachechiladze’s 2020 cash salary was voluntarily reduced by 20% from 1 March 2020 to 31 December 2020 (as was the cash salary of senior management). The amount
was contributed to charity by Mr Gachechiladze – half of the remaining cash salary for that period – has not been taken into account. The increase in cash salary in 2021
compared to 2020 is therefore fully attributable to the reinstatement of the normal cash salary. Mr Gachechiladze was appointed on 28 January 2019 and therefore for the
FY2020 table (which shows the changes from 2019) his 2019 remuneration was scaled up pro rata to a full year for comparison reasons. Mr Gachechiladze did not receive
a bonus for FY2020 after the NBG informed the Remuneration Committee that, as the Bank had utilised the Pillar 2 or conservation buffers, no bonus should be granted –
please see the Chair’s Letter in the Directors’ Remuneration Report of the Annual Report and Accounts 2021 for further information.
4. Neil Janin stepped down from the PLC Board on 10 March 2022 and from the JSC Board on 31 March 2022.
237
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
5. Mel Carvill was appointed to the PLC Board on 10 March 2022. JSC Bank of Georgia fees include those paid for Supervisory Board member services performed pending
official approval from the NBG and technical registration, which was confirmed on 1 July 2022.
6. Hanna Loikkanen was appointed to the Remuneration Committee on 20 September 2019, and as its Chair on 26 September 2020. She stepped down as Chair on 1 January
2023, but remained a member of the Committee.
7. Al Breach stepped down as Chair of the Remuneration Committee on 26 September 2020 but remained a member of the Committee.
8. Tamaz Georgadze stepped down as Chair of the Risk Committee on 31 December 2021 but remained a member of the Risk Committee.
9. Véronique McCarroll was appointed to the JSC Board on 11 February 2019. She was appointed as Chair of the Risk Committee on 1 January 2022.
10. Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi was appointed to the PLC Board, and as a member of the Risk Committee and the Nomination Committee, on 12 March 2021. She was
appointed to the JSC Board, and as a member of its Risk Committee and Nomination Committee, on 6 May 2021.
11. Cecil Quillen was appointed as Chair of the Remuneration Committee on 1 January 2023.
12. The Company has fewer than five UK (parent company) employees and the percentage changes could be considered distortive. Year-on-year changes for UK employees
from 2019 to 2020 for cash salary was 1.8% and for bonus was 29.6%; year-on-year changes from 2020 to 2021 for cash salary was -4.0% and bonus was -2.9%; year-on-
year changes from 2021 to 2022 for cash salary was 12.2% and bonus was -4.4%; year-on-year changes from 2022 to 2023 for cash salary was 7.1% and bonus was 10.0%;
deferred share salary and taxable benefits are not applicable for all years.
CEO’s pay and comparators – peers
It is noted that the Group has fewer than 250 UK employees and is therefore not required to disclose ratios of the CEO’s pay
against UK pay – indeed, given in fact has fewer than five UK employees, to do so would be distortionary. Instead, the Committee
benchmarked the CEO’s remuneration against FTSE 250 and FTSE small cap companies in financial services. Moreover, CEO pay
was benchmarked against comparable peer financial services companies in emerging markets (in particular other former Soviet
republics and South Africa), comparable listed companies in financial services in the UK, and all UK-listed companies based in
Georgia: Halyk Savings Bank of Kazakhstan JSC; OTP Bank Nyrt; Moneta Money Bank a.s.; Erste Group Bank AG; Capitec Bank
Holdings; Investec Plc; FirstRand Ltd; Raiffesen Bank International AG; Virgin Money UK PLC; One Savings Bank PLC; Close Brothers
Group PLC; Nationwide Building Society; Georgia Capital PLC and TBC Bank Group PLC.
The delayed receipt of the majority of salary and of all performance-based remuneration (in deferred shares vesting and being
released across several years) means that the time value of money and also the risk of salary and performance-based remuneration
not vesting (due to malus but also due to shares lapsing in the event of early termination under certain circumstances) were
factored in.
The view of the Board and the Committee is that the Companys CEO must fit a number of important criteria and that there are
very few candidates globally who could satisfy these criteria. Our CEO must be of high overall calibre, with significant international
training and experience, and in particular sufficient banking expertise effectively to run a systemically significant financial institution.
The CEO must be able to communicate with and lead Georgian colleagues, interact effectively with Georgian regulators and play
a role in the Company and in the larger national community which is commensurate with the Company’s significant role in the
Georgian economy. At the same time, the CEO must be an internationally credible investor-facing figure who can lead a premium-
listed FTSE 250 constituent of the London Stock Exchange.
The relevant candidate pool for a role such as this is understandably significantly limited and the number of persons who could
meet both these Georgian and international criteria is very small. Such persons are in very high demand and command competitive
compensation. We aim to achieve fair and competitive remuneration commensurate with the size, nature and complexity of the
business and the roles, whilst ensuring compliance with institutional and regulatory policies.
The Committee carried out further research in early 2023, seeking to assess CEO compensation at comparable organisations, to the
extent practicable, although relevant available information is limited and often non-public for many such organisations. We have
also assessed relative compensation levels on the basis of recruitment approaches, over the past few years, to senior management
talent from organisations in surrounding countries, where remuneration packages for financial roles can be more generous and
significantly higher, for persons with relevant experience, than those which the Company provides.
238
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Further details of fixed and discretionary deferred share compensation granted during
2023 (audited)
The following table details nil-cost options over BOGG shares granted to Mr Gachechiladze in 2023.
Deferred share salary Discretionary deferred share remuneration
Number of underlying shares and
basis on which award was made
71,694 granted for the 2023 work year on
the basis of the Policy available at https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/
documents
74,962 granted for the 2022 work year on
the basis of the Policy available at https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/reports/annual
Type of interest Nil-cost option Nil-cost option
Cost to Group US$ 2,200,000 US$ 2,490,343
Face value US$ 2,200,000
Cash payments equal to the dividends paid
on the underlying shares will be made upon
vesting (if applicable)
US$ 2,490,343
Cash payments equal to the dividends paid
on the underlying shares will be made upon
vesting (if applicable)
Percentage of award receivable if
minimum performance achieved
100% of the award will be receivable, since it
is part of salary set out in the service contract
and accordingly is not subject to performance
measures or targets over the vesting period.
100% of the award will be receivable, since it
is based on 2022 performance (and is not an
LTIP award) and accordingly is not subject to
performance measures or targets over the
vesting period.
Exercise price Nil. The options form part of the Executive
Director’s salary under the Policy and so no
payment is required upon exercise. There has
been no change in exercise price.
Nil. The options form part of the Executive
Director’s performance-based remuneration
under the Policy and so no payment is required
upon exercise. There has been no change in
exercise price.
Vesting period 100% of award vested in 2024 but is subject
to holding periods so that 40% is released in
2025, and 20% is released in each of 2026,
2027 and 2028.
40% immediately and 15% on each of the
third, fourth, fifth and sixth anniversaries of
the work year. Each tranche is subject to a
further two-year holding period.
Performance measures None. See the Policy available at https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/
documents
See the Policy available at https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/
documents
Notes: Figures calculated as described in Note 2 of the ‘Single total figure of remuneration’ for the Executive Director.
Single total figure of remuneration for Non-executive Directors (audited)
The table below sets out the remuneration received by each Non-executive Director for 2022 and 2023.
Bank of Georgia Group
PLC fees
(US$)
JSC Bank of Georgia fees
(US$)
Pension Related Benefits
(US$)
Total
(US$)
2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023
Mel Carvill
1
83,934 103,587 157,735 210,313 241,669 313,900
Neil Janin
2
19,582 52,578 72,160
Alasdair Breach 53,405 53,405 96,391 96,391 149,796 149,796
Tamaz Georgadze
3
53,405 53,405 96,391 96,391 149,796 149,796
Hanna Loikkanen
4
71,582 68,516 129,022 124,934 200,604 193,450
Véronique McCarroll
5
48,932 48,932 96,204 96,204 145,136 145,136
Mariam Meghvinetukhutsesi
6
46,835 46,835 87,631 87,631 1,437 1,722 135,903 136,188
Jonathan Muir 53,405 53,405 96,391 96,391 149,796 149,796
Cecil Quillen
7
56,471 59,537 100,479 104,567 156,950 164,104
Total 487,551 487,622 912,822 912,822 1,437 1,722 1,401,810 1,402,166
Notes:
1. Mel Carvill was appointed to the PLC Board on 10 March 2022. JSC Bank of Georgia fees in 2022 included fees paid for Supervisory Board member services performed
pending official approval from the NBG and technical registration, which was confirmed on 1 July 2022.
2. Neil Janin stepped down from the PLC Board on 10 March 2022 and from the JSC Board on 31 March 2022.
3. Tamaz Georgadze stepped down as Chair of the Risk Committee on 1 January 2022 but remained a member of the Committee.
4. Hanna Loikkanen stepped down as Chair of the Remuneration Committee on 1 January 2023 but remained a member of the Committee.
5. Véronique McCarroll was appointed as Chair of the Risk Committee on 1 January 2022, having previously been a member.
6. Georgian law requires that the JSC Bank of Georgia provides pension contributions for Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi, as a Georgian resident, into the mandatory Georgian
government pension scheme at a level of 2% of her fee. This pension scheme applies only to JSC Bank of Georgia and does not apply to Bank of Georgia Group PLC.
7. Cecil Quillen was appointed as Chair of the Remuneration Committee on 1 January 2023, having previously been a member.
8. The maximum amount for Non-executive Director base fees, including the Chairman, as provided for in BOGG PLC’s Articles of Association, is GBP 750,000. This does not
affect JSC fees. The Non-executive Directors do not receive any taxable benefits or variable remuneration.
239
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Payments to former Directors and payments for loss of office
No payments were made to former Directors or in respect of loss of office during the year ended 31 December 2023.
Total Shareholder Return (‘TSR’)
We note the group demerged and relisted as two separate businesses with separate listed shares in May 2018. The following graph
compares the TSR of Bank of Georgia Group PLC with the companies comprising the FTSE 250 index and the FTSE All Share index,
for the period since BOGG’s listing on the Premium segment of the LSE on 21 May 2018 until 31 December 2023.
Feb 19
Jan 19
Dec 18
Nov 18
Oct 18
Sep 18
Aug 18
Jul 18
Jun 18
May 18
Dec 19
Nov 19
Oct 19
Sep 19
Aug 19
Jul 19
Jun 19
May 19
Apr 19
Mar 19
Oct 21
Sep 20
Aug 20
Jul 20
Jun 20
May 20
Apr 20
Mar 20
Feb 20
Jan 20
Dec 21
Nov 21
Oct 21
Sep 21
Aug 21
Jul 21
Jun 21
May 21
Apr 21
Mar 21
Feb 21
Jan 21
Dec 21
Nov 21
Oct 22
Sep 22
Aug 22
Jul 22
Jun 22
May 22
Apr 22
Mar 22
Feb 22
Jan 22
Dec 22
Oct 23
Sep 23
Aug 23
Jul 23
Jun 23
May 23
Apr 23
Mar 23
Feb 23
Jan 23
Dec 23
Nov 23
Nov 22
Bank of Georgia Group PLC FTSE 250 (rebased) FTSE All Share (rebased)
20
70
120
170
220
270
Relative importance of spend on pay
The following table shows the difference in remuneration paid to all employees of the Group between 2022 and 2023, as well as the
difference in value of distribution paid to shareholders by way of dividends and buybacks between 2022 and 2023.
Remuneration paid to all
employees of the Group
Distributions to
shareholders by way of
dividends and buybacks
Year ended 31 December 2023 (US$) 169,438,514 216,330,023
Year ended 31 December 2022 (US$) 131,910,967 106,060,435
Percentage change 28.4% 104.0%
Notes:
1. Difference in remuneration paid to all employees of the Group was for reasons including salary and bonus increases, growth in number of employees and growth due to GEL
appreciation against the US Dollar.
2. The Company did not make any other significant distributions in 2022 and 2023. In 2022 US$ 38,660,254 was for buybacks and cancellation and US$ 67,400,181 for dividends.
In 2023 US$ 65,397,932 was for buybacks and cancellation and US$ 150,932,091 for dividends. Figures are converted into US$ using an average US$/GEL exchange rate.
240
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Directors’ interests in shares (audited)
The following table sets out the respective holdings of the Company’s shares of each Director as at 31 December 2023 and 2022.
As at 31 December 2022 As at 31 December 2023
Number of
BOGG shares
held directly
Number of
vested but
unexercised
BOGG shares
held under
option through
deferred share
salary and
discretionary
deferred share
compensation
(all nil-cost
options with no
performance
conditions)
Number of
unvested and
unexercised
held under
option BOGG
shares through
deferred share
salary and
discretionary
deferred share
compensation
(all nil-cost
options with no
performance
conditions)
Total number
of interests in
BOGG shares
Number of
BOGG shares
held directly
Number of
vested but
unexercised
BOGG shares
held under
option through
deferred share
salary and
discretionary
deferred share
compensation
(all nil-cost
options with no
performance
conditions)
Number of
unvested and
unexercised
held under
option BOGG
shares through
deferred share
salary and
discretionary
deferred share
compensation
(all nil-cost
options with no
performance
conditions)
Total number
of interests in
BOGG shares
Mel Carvill
1
N/A N/A N/A N/A
Archil
Gachechil-
adze
2
209,225 N/A 414,753 623,978 399,505 N/A 318,702 718,207
Alasdair
Breach
3
30,000 N/A N/A 30,000 30,000 N/A N/A 30,000
Tamaz
Georgadze 5,000 N/A N/A 5,000 5,000 N/A N/A 5,000
Hanna
Loikkanen N/A N/A N/A N/A
Véronique
McCarroll N/A N/A N/A N/A
Mariam
Megvinet-
Ukhutsesi 4,102 N/A N/A 4,102 4,102 N/A N/A 4,102
Jonathan Muir N/A N/A N/A N/A
Cecil Quillen 2,900 N/A N/A 2,900 2,900 N/A N/A 2,900
Notes:
1. As at 2023 year-end, MDB Ltd, a PCA of Mel Carvill, held 19,018 ordinary shares.
2. On 3 January 2023, Mr Gachechiladze received 71,694 nil-cost options over ordinary shares in respect of deferred salary shares for the 2023 work year. On 22 February 2023,
Mr Gachechiladze exercised options in respect of 106,688 shares, of which 23,045 were withheld to satisfy tax liabilities. The net gain of these options was US$2,730,108.
On 23 March 2023, Mr Gachechiladze exercised options in respect of 106,034 shares, of which 22,904 were withheld to satisfy tax liabilities. The net gain of these options
was US$2,600,306. On 31 March 2023, Mr Gachechiladze received 74,962 nil-cost options over ordinary shares in respect of discretionary deferred shares for the 2022 work
year. On 8 June 2023, Mr Gachechiladze exercised options in respect of 29,985 shares, of which 6,477 were withheld to satisfy tax liabilities. The net gain of these options was
US$898,711. On 19 March 2024 Mr Gachechiladze exercised options in respect of 162,893 shares, of which 35,185 were withheld to satisfy tax liabilities and on 20 March 2024,
Mr Gachechiladze received 45,785 nil-cost options over ordinary shares in respect of the deferred salary shares for the 2024 work year. These will be reported in the 2024
Annual Report and Accounts and are not included in the table above, which is as at 31 December 2023. As at the last practicable date of 17 April 2024, Mr Gachechiladzes
total number of share interests is 728,807.
3. At 2023 year-end, Gemsstock Fund, which Mr Breach manages, held 1,255,318 beneficial holdings in ordinary shares or economic interests in financial instruments with a
similar economic effect. This is not included in the table.
As at 31 December 2023, Mr Gachechiladze’s total vested and unvested and direct shareholding was 718,207 shares, representing
approximately 1.6% of the share capital of BOGG. Mr Gachechiladzes connected persons do not have any interests in the shares of
the Company.
The Policy is heavily weighted towards remuneration in deferred salary shares and discretionary compensation in deferred shares.
The Policy and the long vesting periods, even for salary shares, naturally results in the Executive Director and our Executive
Management team holding a significant number of unvested shares and achieves a delay between performance and vesting. This
is reinforced further by formal guidelines on shareholding and on post-employment shareholding in the Policy (200% of total salary
to be built up within five years). Further, Mr Gachechiladze is expressly contractually bound to build up and to hold this level for two
years post-employment. As at 31 December 2023, Mr Gachechiladze met the shareholding requirement.
There are no shareholding requirements for Non-executive Directors, and they are not awarded incentive shares. Changes in
shareholding for PLC Directors between 31 December 2023 and the last practicable date of 17 April 2024 are as shown in the notes
to the table above.
241
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Executives’ interests in shares
In response to a shareholder feedback request to show our Executive Management team’s level of total shareholding, to
demonstrate their level of alignment with shareholders, below we disclose the shareholdings of our top executives as at 31 December
2023 (unvested shares vest in tranches over several years):
Total vested and unvested and direct
shareholding in number of shares
Archil Gachechiladze 718,207
Sulkhan Gvalia 290,304
Davit Chkonia 84,297
David Davitashvili 57,913
Nutsiko Gogilashvili 34,202
Eteri Iremadze 101,674
Zurab Kokosadze 100,265
Zurab Masurashvili 36,373
Mikheil Gomarteli 396,990
Vakhtang Bobokhidze 174,723
Levan Gomashiavili 24,293
Ana Kostava 19,017
Elene Okromchedlishvili 5,278
Giorgi Gureshidze 0
Andro Ratiani 1,294
Details of Non-executive Directors’ terms of appointment
The Company has entered into letters of appointment with each Non-executive Director. The letters of appointment require them to
provide one month’s notice prior to termination and, for the majority of current Non-executive Directors (Hanna Loikkanen, Tamaz
Georgadze, Jonathan Muir and Cecil Quillen) are effective from 24 February 2018 – with Véronique McCarroll’s letter of appointment
being effective from 1 October 2018, Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi’s from 12 March 2021, Mel Carvill’s from 10 March 2022 and Andrew
McIntyres from 15 March 2024. Al Breach resigned on 15 March 2024. Each Non-executive Director is put forward for election at
each AGM following his or her appointment. Continuation of a Non-executive Director’s employment is conditional on his or her
continued satisfactory performance and re-election by shareholders at each AGM.
A succession plan adopted by the Board provides for a tenure of six years on the Bank of Georgia Group PLC Board. Upon the expiry
of such a tenure, the Board will consider if the appointment of the relevant Non-executive Director will cease at the next AGM. If the
Board determines that, in order to maintain the balance of appropriate skills and experience it requires, it is important to retain a
Non-executive Director beyond the relevant six-year period, the Board may offer the Non-executive Director a letter of appointment
for an additional one-year term. Such a ‘reappointment’ may be renewed no more than twice, and the usual six-year tenure
extended to a maximum of nine years, if circumstances were to warrant such extension.
Remuneration Committee effectiveness review
An external review of the Committee was undertaken in 2023 by Clare Chalmers Ltd. Further details of the overall evaluation
process including the selection of the Evaluator, are set out on pages 196 and 212. The Evaluator attended a Committee meeting
in person and separately interviewed each of the members of the Committee as well as members of management involved in
informing and advising the Committee (including the Head of Human Capital Management and the UK General Counsel). The
Evaluator noted that the Committee changed its Chair at the beginning of the year, and credit was given to the outgoing Chair for
her efforts in engagement with shareholders. The new Chair was judged to be aware of the major issues and UK listing context. The
Committee was observed as having good discussions on the issues and aiming to strike a balance between different stakeholders.
Those members of the Board who are not members of the Committee expressed to the Evaluator that feedback provided to the
Board by the Committee is good. The Evaluator recommended early engagement with shareholders on the Remuneration Policy, and
the Committee will take this into account this year ahead of the Policy to be put forward for shareholder approval at the 2025 AGM.
242
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Implementation of Remuneration Policy for 2024
Details of how the current Policy will be implemented for the 2024 financial year are set out below. There will be no significant
change in the way the Policy will be implemented in 2024, and no significant deviations from the procedure for the implementation
of the Policy as set out in the Policy.
For Archil Gachechiladze:
Fixed pay
Total cash salary
(combined BOGG and Bank)
US$ 370,000
Total deferred share salary
(combined BOGG and Bank)
US$ 2,200,000 in deferred shares
Pension The Executive Director and the Company each contribute 0-2% and the Georgian Government
contributes between 0-2% of total remuneration from the Bank, all in line with Georgian
legislation and with the pension arrangements for the Georgian workforce.
Benefits Details of the benefits received by Executive Director are on page 245.
There are circumstances in which unvested deferred shares may lapse, and very limited circumstances in which such shares may vest
immediately (i.e. when an Executive Director’s employment is terminated without cause) and these are summarised in the Policy.
Discretionary deferred share remuneration
Opportunity Maximum is 100% of total salary (total cash salary and total deferred share salary as explained in
the table and notes to the Policy) in deferred shares.
Deferral terms The Remuneration Committee will determine whether an award is merited, based on an Executive
Director’s achievement of the KPIs set for the work year and the performance of the Group
during the work year. If Mr Gachechiladze is awarded discretionary deferred shares, 40% will vest
immediately and 15% will vest on each of the third, fourth, fifth and sixth anniversaries of the
start of the work year. Each tranche will be subject to a further holding period of two years. This
decision will be set out in the 2024 Director’s Remuneration Report.
Upon vesting, Mr Gachechiladze will receive (in addition to the vested shares) cash payments equal
to the dividends paid (if any) on the underlying shares between the date the award was made and
the vesting date.
Performance measures The Remuneration Committee has set Mr Gachechiladze’s KPIs for 2024:
1. Return on average equity (ROAE)
2. Cost:income ratio
3. Cost of credit risk ratio (COCR)
4. Profit before tax (PBT)
5. Lowest team member performance
6. NPS
7. eNPS
8. ESG/impact metrics
9. Individual Key Business Objectives
See the Policy available at https://bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/documents, for details of malus and clawback, and of
provisions regarding lapse of shares in the event of termination of the contracts (natural malus).
243
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
For Non-executive Directors:
The table below shows the fee structure for Non-executive Directors for 2024. Non-executive Directors’ fees are determined by the
Board.
Component Purpose and link to strategy Operation Opportunity
Base cash fee
The fee for the Board is
competitive enough to attract
and retain individuals.
The Chairman receives a fee that
reflects the extra time committed
and responsibility.
The Senior Independent Non-
executive Director receives a
higher base fee, which reflects
the extra time commitment and
responsibility.
Cash payment on a
quarterly basis.
The amount of remuneration may be
reviewed from time to time by the Board.
Fees may also be amended and varied
if there are genuinely unforeseen and
exceptional circumstances which
necessitate such review. In such
circumstances, any significant increase
shall be the minimum reasonably required.
The maximum aggregate BOGG PLC fees
for all Non-executive Directors which may
be paid by the PLC itself is GBP 750,000,
which is consistent with the PLC’s Articles
of Association.
Cash fee for each
Committee
membership
Additional fee to compensate for
additional time spent discharging
Committee duties.
Cash payment on a
quarterly basis.
The amount of remuneration for the
membership may be reviewed from time
to time by the Board.
The Chairman does not receive
Committee fees.
The Board intends to review the amount of remuneration during the year.
Where required by Georgian Law, Non-Executive Directors resident in Georgia will receive pension contributions of 2% of fees
payable to the Georgian National Pension fund.
Summary of Directors’ Remuneration Policy
The Remuneration Policy was approved at the AGM on 16 June 2022. To comply with NBG requirements, as disclosed in the 2021
Annual Report, the amendments to the Policy are deemed effective as of 1 January 2022. It is intended that approval of the
Remuneration Policy will be sought at three-year intervals, unless amendments to the Policy are required, in which case further
shareholder approval will be sought. No changes are proposed for 2024. The full Policy is available at https://bankofgeorgiagroup.
com/governance/documents.
It is a provision of this Policy that the Group will honour all pre-existing obligations and commitments that were entered into prior
to this Policy taking effect. The terms of those pre-existing obligations and commitments may differ from the terms of the Policy
and may include (without limitation) obligations and commitments under service agreements (as detailed in the information below),
deferred share remuneration schemes and pension and benefit plans.
The Remuneration Committee retains its discretion under the Policy to make minor amendments to the Policy for regulatory,
exchange control, tax or administrative purposes or to take account of a change in legislation without obtaining prior shareholder
approval.
The tables in this section provide a summary of the Directors’ Remuneration Policy.
Remuneration Policy table for Executive Directors
Cash salary Purpose and link to strategy
To reflect the role and required duties, skills, experience
and individual contribution to the Group, and to encourage
commitment to the Group and recruit and retain high-
calibre talent.
Operation
Fixed in the Executive Director’s service agreements.
The level of cash salary is reviewed when a service
agreement is up for renewal or if there is a significant
change in circumstances, and the Executive Director and
Remuneration Committee agree to consequent changes
to their agreements.
Opportunity
The level of cash salary in the Executive
Directors’ service agreements will be no more
than the Remuneration Committee considers
reasonable, based on his or her duties, skills
and experience.
The total amount payable to the current
CEO and sole Executive Director,
Mr Gachechiladze, is US$ 370,000 per
annum.
Performance measures
N/A
244
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Deferred share
salary
Purpose and link to strategy
To closely align the Executive Directors’ and shareholders’
interests, and to promote long-term value creation and
share price growth.
Operation
Awarded annually in the form of nil-cost options in respect
of the work year, and released over five years from the
start of the year in which the salary is earned, as follows:
100% of the deferred share salary vests on the first
anniversary of the start of the work year and is subject
to holding periods so that 40% is released on the second
anniversary, and 20% is released on each of the third,
fourth and fifth anniversaries of the start of the relevant
work year. Upon vesting, the Executive Director also
receives cash payments equal to the dividends paid on the
underlying shares between the date the award was made
and the vesting date.
Lapse provisions (natural malus) for an incomplete year
are built into the deferred share salary. Extended malus
and clawback provisions do not apply to the deferred
share salary as the awards attach to salary already
earned.
Opportunity
The value of deferred share salary for
Mr Gachechiladze is fixed at the equivalent of
US$ 2,200,000 per annum, to be awarded in
deferred shares. The number of shares shall
normally be calculated using the average
price of the shares over the five working days
prior to 25 December of the year immediately
preceding the year of award.
Performance measures
N/A
Discretionary
deferred shares
Purpose and link to strategy
In the context of overall Group performance, to motivate
and reward an Executive Director in relation to his or
her contribution to the achievement of the KPIs set for
him or her by the Remuneration Committee towards the
beginning of the year.
Performance-based remuneration is solely in the form
of deferred shares (no cash), designed to closely align
the interests of an Executive Director with shareholders,
avoid inappropriate risk-taking for short-term gain, and
encourage long-term commitment to the Group.
Operation
The Remuneration Committee will determine annually
the number of shares to be awarded, based on the
Executive Director’s achievement of his or her KPIs set for
the work year and the performance of the Group during
that year. Awards are made annually entirely in the form
of nil-cost options over shares based on performance
against the targets. There is no contractual right to
discretionary deferred shares and the Remuneration
Committee reserves the right to award no discretionary
deferred share remuneration if the Group’s performance is
unsatisfactory.
Discretionary deferred shares will vest as follows: 40%
vests immediately, and 15% will vest on each of the
third, fourth, fifth and sixth anniversaries of the start of
the work year. Each tranche will be subject to a further
holding period of two years (effectively, discretionary
deferred shares are released over eight years from the
beginning of the work year).
Upon vesting, the Executive Director also receives cash
payments equal to the dividends paid on the underlying
shares between the date the award was made and the
vesting date.
Extended malus and clawback applies as per the notes to
the Policy table approved at the 2022 AGM.
Opportunity
The maximum discretionary deferred shares
that may be awarded in respect of the
previous work year is capped at 100% of total
salary (which includes cash and deferred
share salaries), as set out in the notes to the
Policy table approved at the 2022 AGM.
Performance measures
KPIs for the Executive Director are set near
the start of each work year and reflect the
Executive Director’s targeted contribution
to the Group’s overall key strategic and
financial objectives for the work year. KPIs
may also include non-tangible factors such
as self-development, mentoring and social
responsibility.
245
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Pension Purpose and link to strategy
The Group complies with pension requirements set by the
Georgian Government.
Operation
Pension provision will be in line with Georgian pension
legislation, which may change from time to time. There
is no provision for the recovery or withholding of pension
payments.
Opportunity
In line with current Georgian legislation,
the Executive Director and the Bank each
contribute 0-2% of total remuneration from
the Bank, and the Georgian Government
may contribute a further small amount
(0-2% depending on income levels). Pension
contributions will only increase above this
level if mandated by Georgian legislation or if
mandated by any other applicable legislation.
The same arrangement applies to employees
across the Group in Georgia.
Performance measures
N/A
Benefits Purpose and link to strategy
Non-cash benefits are in line with Georgian market
practice and designed to be sufficient to attract and
retain high-calibre talent.
Operation
Benefits consist of: life insurance; health insurance;
incapacity/disability insurance; directors’ and officers’
liability insurance; physical examinations; tax gross-ups
and tax equalisation payments; company car and driver;
mobile phone costs; personal security arrangements (if
requested by the Executive Director); assistance with
completing tax returns (where required); relocation costs
for Executive Director; and close family and legal costs.
Other benefits may be provided from time to time if
considered reasonable and appropriate.
Opportunity
There is no prescribed maximum on the value
of benefits payable to an Executive Director.
The maximum amount payable depends
on the cost of providing such benefits to
an employee in the location at which the
Executive Director is based.
Performance measures
N/A
Shareholding
guidelines
Purpose and link to strategy
To ensure Executive Directors build and hold a significant
shareholding in the Group over the long term, and to align
Executive Directors’ interests with those of shareholders.
To ensure departing Executive Directors make long-term
decisions and maintain an interest in the ongoing success
of the Group, post-employment.
Operation
Executive Directors are required to build and then
maintain a shareholding with 200% equivalent of total
salary (which includes cash and deferred share salaries),
with such amount to be built up within a five-year period
from appointment as an Executive Director. All beneficially
owned shares, as well as unvested (net of tax) and vested
deferred share salary and discretionary deferred shares,
count towards the Required Shareholding (as such,
awards are not subject to any performance conditions
after grant).
Executive Directors are to retain the lower of the
Required Shareholding or the Executive Director’s actual
shareholding at the time employment ceases, for a
period of two years from the date on which employment
ceases, unless the Remuneration Committee determines
otherwise. It is noted that a good leaver may hold
substantially higher than this in unvested shares alone.
In very exceptional circumstances, for example in the
event of a serious conflict of interest, the Remuneration
Committee has the discretion to vary or waive the
Required Shareholding, but must explain any exercise of its
discretion in the Group’s next Remuneration Report.
It should be emphasised that there is no present intention
to use this discretion.
Opportunity
N/A
Performance measures
N/A
246
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Directors’ Remuneration Report continued
Malus and clawback, and shareholding guidelines
Discretionary deferred shares are subject to malus and clawback for Executive Directors in the following circumstances:
misconduct in the performance or substantial failure to perform duties by the Executive, or material breach of applicable
regulations and/or the Bank’s internal policies;
significant financial losses, serious failure of risk management or serious damage to the reputation of BOGG or the Bank caused
by misconduct or gross negligence (including inaction) of the Executive;
material misstatement or material errors in the financial statements that relate to the area of responsibility of the Executive or
can be attributed to action or inaction of the Executives performance of their duties;
deliberately misleading BOGG or the Bank in relation to financial performance;
failure to continue to meet the fitness and properness criteria for an Executive of the Bank;
material increase with respect to the required regulatory capital of the Bank that can be attributed to the action or inaction of
the Executive;
misconduct that contributed to the imposition of material regulatory or other similar sanctions;
payments based on erroneous or misleading data, for which malus and clawback apply to discretionary deferred remuneration
awarded for the year in question; and
significant increases in the Bank’s regulatory capital requirements (for clawback to apply such failures/problems are to have been
caused by or attributable to the actions or inactions of the Executive).
The Remuneration Committee has the right to withhold the release of already-awarded discretionary deferred share remuneration
if mandated by the needs of preservation of the Bank’s regulatory capital.
The above provisions form part of Mr Gachechiladze’s service contract. The Group has also amended the Executive Equity
Compensation plan to allow shares to be lapsed, including to zero, or clawed back in accordance with the provisions in the Executive
Director’s contracts.
Clawback is for up to two years from vesting and, for Mr Gachechiladze, the Group also has unusually strong malus provisions where
unvested discretionary deferred shares lapse when the service contract is terminated under certain circumstances, including for
‘Cause’ such as gross misconduct, failure to perform duties, material breach of obligations and/or unethical behaviour. This may be
several years’ worth of discretionary deferred shares.
The shareholding guidelines, to build and then maintain a shareholding with a 200% equivalent of total salary and then to maintain
such for two years post-employment, are set as express provisions in Mr Gachechiladzes contract.
247
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Remuneration Policy table for the Non-executive Directors
Chairman’s and
Non-executive
Directors’ fees
Purpose and link to strategy
To attract and retain high-performing Non-executive
Directors with the requisite skills, knowledge, experience,
independence and other attributes to add value to the
Group.
To reflect the responsibilities and time commitment
dedicated by Non-executive Directors.
Operation
All fees are paid in cash on a quarterly basis. Fees may
be reviewed from time to time by the Board (but not
necessarily changed), considering the time commitment,
responsibilities and technical skills required to make a
valuable contribution to the Board – with reference to
comparators, benchmarking, results of the annual review
and other guidance. Fees may also be amended and
varied if there are genuinely unforeseen and exceptional
circumstances necessitating such review and, in such
circumstances, any significant increase shall be the
minimum reasonably required. The Board reserves the
right to structure Non-executive Directors’ fee differently
at its absolute discretion.
Non-executive Directors receive a base fee. Additional
Committee fees are payable to compensate for time
spent discharging Bank and Committee duties.
There is no remuneration in the form of deferred share
salary or discretionary deferred shares or any variable or
performance-linked remuneration or incentives.
Non-executive Directors are reimbursed for reasonable
business expenses, including travel and accommodation,
which are incurred in the course of carrying out duties
under their letters of appointment, on provision of valid
receipts.
Opportunity
The maximum aggregate BOGG PLC fees
for all Non-executive Directors which may be
paid for PLC fees under the PLC’s Articles of
Association is GBP 750,000.
A specific maximum has not been set for the
individual base cash fee.
The Senior Independent Non-executive
Director receives a higher base fee, which
reflects the extra time commitment and
responsibility.
The Chairman receives a fee that reflects the
extra time commitment and responsibility.
The Chairman does not receive Committee
fees.
Performance measures
N/A
Service agreements
At the date of this Annual Report, Mr Gachechiladze is the sole Executive Director of the Company. Mr Gachechiladze has a service
agreement with an effective date of 28 January 2019 with the Company for an indefinite term (subject to annual re-election at the
AGM), which is terminable by either party on four months’ notice unless for cause where notice served by the Company shall have
immediate effect.
Mr Gachechiladze also has a service agreement with JSC Bank of Georgia with an effective date of 1 January 2022 (as per the NBG
Code requirements, signed 22 June 2022 after the Policy had been approved at AGM) for an employment term of three years from
the effective date, which is terminable by the JSC Bank of Georgia with immediate effect and by the Executive Director on not less
than four months’ notice.
Non-executive Directors’ letters of appointment
Each Non-executive Director is required to submit himself or herself for annual re-election at the AGM. The letters of appointment
for Non-executive Directors provide for a one-month notice period, although the Group may terminate the appointment with
immediate effect without notice or pay in lieu of notice if the Non-executive Director has committed any serious breach or non-
observance of his or her obligations to the Group, is guilty of fraud or dishonesty, brings the Company or him/herself into disrepute,
or is disqualified as acting as a Non-executive Director, among other circumstances. Upon termination, the only remuneration a
Non-executive Director is entitled to is accrued fees as at the date of termination, together with reimbursement of properly incurred
expenses incurred prior to the termination date.
The service agreements and letters of appointment are available for inspection at the Company’s registered office.
Signed on behalf of the Remuneration Committee and the Board of Directors
Cecil Quillen
Chair of the Remuneration Committee
24 April 2024
248
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Statement of Directors’ Responsibilities
The Directors are responsible for
preparing the Annual Report and
consolidated and separate financial
statements in accordance with applicable
law and regulations.
Company law requires us to prepare
financial statements for each financial
year. As required, we have prepared
the accompanying consolidated and
separate statements in accordance with
UK-adopted international accounting
standards (IFRS).
Directors cannot approve the
consolidated and separate financial
statements contained within this Annual
Report unless they are satisfied they are
a true and fair reflection of the state of
affairs of Bank of Georgia Group PLC
(the ‘Company’) and the Group, and of
the profit or loss of the Company and the
Group for that period.
Under the Financial Conduct Authority’s
Disclosure Guidance and Transparency
Rules, Group financial statements are
required to be prepared in accordance
with UK-adopted international
accounting standards (IFRS).
In preparing the accompanying
consolidated and separate financial
statements, Directors are required to:
select suitable accounting policies and
apply them consistently;
make judgements and estimates that
are reasonable, relevant and reliable;
state whether applicable accounting
standards have been followed,
subject to any material departures
disclosed and explained in the financial
statements; and
prepare the financial statements on
a going-concern basis, unless it is
inappropriate to presume that the
Company and Group will continue in
business.
Directors are also responsible for
keeping adequate accounting records
that sufficiently show and explain the
Company’s and the Groups transactions,
to disclose with reasonable accuracy at
any time the financial position of the
Company and the Group, and to enable
us to ensure that the consolidated and
separate financial statements comply
with the Companies Act 2006. The
Directors are responsible for such internal
control as they determine necessary
to enable the preparation of financial
statements that are free from material
misstatement, whether due to fraud or
error, and have general responsibility for
taking reasonable steps to safeguard the
assets of the Company and to prevent
and detect fraud and other irregularities.
Under applicable law and regulations,
the Directors are also responsible for
preparing a Strategic Report, Directors’
Report, Directors’ Remuneration Report
and Corporate Governance Statement
that each comply with that law and
those regulations. Legislation in the
UK governing the preparation and
dissemination of financial statements
may differ from legislation in other
jurisdictions.
The Directors are also responsible for
the maintenance and integrity of the
Company’s website.
Each of the Directors whose names and
functions are listed in Board of Directors
on pages 198 to 200 – confirm that, to
the best of their knowledge:
the consolidated and separate
financial statements, prepared
in accordance with UK-adopted
international accounting standards
(IFRS), give a true and fair view of the
assets, liabilities, financial position and
profit or loss of the Company and the
Group taken as a whole; and
the Annual Report, including the
Strategic Report, includes a fair review
of the development and performance
of the business and the position of the
Company and the Group, together
with a description of the principal risks
and uncertainties they face.
The Directors consider the Annual
Report and Accounts, taken as a whole,
are fair, balanced, and understandable,
and give shareholders the information
needed to assess the Group’s position
and performance, business model and
strategy.
By order of the Board
Mel Carvill
Chair
24 April 2024
Archil Gachechiladze
CEO
24 April 2024
249
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Directors’ Report
The Directors present their Annual
Report and the audited Consolidated
Financial Statements for the year ended
31 December 2023.
Strategic Report
The Strategic Report on pages 4 to 183
was approved by the Board of Directors
on 24 April 2024 and signed on its behalf
by Archil Gachechiladze, Chief Executive
Officer.
Management Report
This Directors’ Report, together with
the Strategic Report on pages 4 to 183,
forms the Management Report for the
basis of the Disclosure Guidance and
Transparency Rules 4.1.5R.
Information contained elsewhere in the Annual Report
Information required to be included in this Directors’ Report can be found elsewhere in the Annual Report as indicated in the table
below, and is incorporated into this report by reference:
Information Location in the Annual Report
Future developments, including research and development activities pages 4 to 183
Going Concern Statement page 170
Viability Statement page 170
Risk management pages 144 to 148
Principal risks and uncertainties pages 149 to 169
Directors’ Governance Statement pages 184 to 197
The Board of Directors pages 198 to 200
Nomination Committee Report pages 206 to 213
Audit Committee Report pages 214 to 223
Risk Committee Report pages 224 to 228
Related-party disclosures Note 33 on page 359
Climate-related financial disclosures pages 100 to 114
GHG emissions pages 115 to 118
Energy consumption page 82
Energy-efficient action pages 82 to 85
Employee matters, including employee engagement
pages 119 to 132 and Nomination
Committee Report page 210
Environmental matters pages 60 to 142
Share capital Note 23 on pages 328 to 329
Engagement with suppliers, customers and others in a business relationship with the Company pages 52 to 59
Information on the Groups financial risk management objectives and policies, and its exposure
to credit risk, foreign currency risk and financial instruments Note 30 on pages 335 to 350
250
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Information to be disclosed
in accordance with the
Listing Rule 9.8.4R
The following information, required to be
disclosed in accordance with Listing Rule
9.8.4R, is not applicable unless stated
otherwise:
the amount of interest capitalised
during the period under review and
details of any related tax relief;
information in relation to the
publication of unaudited financial
information;
any arrangements under which a
Director has waived emoluments,
or agreed to waive any future
emoluments, from the Group;
details of any non-pre-emptive issues
of equity for cash by the Group;
any non-pre-emptive issues of equity
for cash by the Group or by any
unlisted major subsidiary undertaking;
parent participation in a placing by a
listed subsidiary;
any contract of significance in which a
Director of Bank of Georgia Group PLC
is or was materially interested; and
any waiver of dividends by a
shareholder.
Articles of Association
The Articles of Association of Bank of
Georgia Group PLC may only be amended
by a special resolution at a general
meeting of the shareholders. The process
for the appointment and removal of
Directors is included in the Company’s
Articles of Association, available at:
https://www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com/
governance/documents.
Share capital and rights
attaching to the shares
Details of the movements in share capital
during the year are provided in Note 23 to
the Consolidated Financial Statements
on pages 328 to 329 of this Annual
Report.
As at 31 December 2023 there was
a single class of 45,766,293 ordinary
shares of one pence each in issue, each
with one vote – of which 57,191 ordinary
shares were held in treasury pending
cancellation. As of 17 April 2024 there
was a single class of 45,590,314 ordinary
shares, of which 115,000 ordinary
shares were held in treasury pending
cancellation.
The rights and obligations attaching to
the Company’s ordinary shares are set
out in its Articles of Association. Holders
of ordinary shares are entitled, subject
to any applicable law and the Company’s
Articles of Association, to:
have shareholder documents made
available to them, including notice of
any general meeting;
attend, speak and exercise voting
rights at general meetings, either in
person or by proxy; and
participate in any distribution of
income or capital.
Under the terms of a demerger
agreement between the Company
and Georgia Capital PLC, the latter
has agreed that for so long as its
percentage holding in the Company
(directly or indirectly) is greater than
9.9% of the voting rights exercisable at
the Company’s general meetings, these
voting rights will be exercised in general
meetings of the Company in accordance
with votes cast by all other shareholders.
This agreement was put in place to
ensure Georgia Capital PLC will not be
able to influence the voting outcomes of
the Company’s shareholder resolutions
at general meetings. Votes will be
made in accordance with the following
mechanism:
on a resolution proposed to a general
meeting, all shareholders of the
Company (other than JSC Georgia
Capital and its concert parties) will be
entitled to vote at their discretion on a
poll vote (each an ‘Initial Vote’); and
following the closing of the Initial
Vote(s), the poll will reopen as soon
as possible for the sole purpose of
enabling the shares held by JSC
Georgia Capital (or its concert parties)
to be voted in each case proportionally
(calculated to two decimal places)
in accordance with the votes cast on
each resolution on an Initial Vote (the
‘Proportional Voting Mechanism’).
As the latest practicable date before
Annual Report released of 17 April 2024,
the ‘Effective Rule 9 Threshold’ (as
defined in the Company’s 2018 listing
prospectus and in summary being the
level of holding of the Company’s shares
carrying voting rights above which a
mandatory offer would be triggered
under Rule 9 of the Takeover Code once
the shares held by Georgia Capital
are removed from the denominator) is
10,966,545 shares – representing 24.05%
of the Company’s issued share capital.
The latest Effective Rule 9 Threshold
is available on the FAQ section of our
website. There are no other restrictions
on exercising voting rights, except in
situations where the Company is legally
entitled to impose such a restriction
– for example, under the Articles of
Association where amounts remain
unpaid in the shares after request, or
the holder is otherwise in default of an
obligation to the Company. The Company
is not aware of any arrangements
between shareholders that may result in
restrictions on the transfer of securities or
voting rights.
The Company is permitted to make market
purchases of its own shares provided it is
duly authorised by its members in a general
meeting, and subject to and in accordance
with section 701 of the Companies Act
2006. Authority was given by special
resolution at the AGM of the Company on
19 May 2023 for the Group to purchase up
to 4,711,853 shares – approximately 10%
of the Group’s shares. This authority will
expire at the conclusion of the Company’s
AGM in 2024 or, if earlier, the close of
business on 19 June 2024.
A renewal of the authority to make
market purchases will be sought from
shareholders at each AGM. Purchases
of ordinary shares will be made within
guidelines established from time to
time by the Board. Any purchase of
ordinary shares would be made only out
of the available cash resources of the
Company. Ordinary shares purchased by
the Company may be held in treasury or
cancelled.
During 2023 Apex Group Fiduciary
Services Limited, acting as a trustee
of the BOG Group Employee Trust,
purchased 172,951 ordinary shares
with a nominal value of one pence per
share – representing 0.4% of the issued
share capital as at 31 December 2023.
In addition, acting as a trustee of the
Rubicon Executive Equity Compensation
Trust, Apex Group Fiduciary Services
Limited purchased 585,864 ordinary
shares with a nominal value of one pence
per share – representing 1.3% of the
issued share capital as at 31 December
2023. The trusts hold the shares for
the purpose of satisfying awards to
beneficiaries.
At the 2023 AGM the Directors were
given the power to (a) allot shares up
to a maximum nominal amount of GBP
157,046.07, representing approximately
one third of the Company’s issued share
capital as at 23 March 2023; and (b) allot
equity securities up to an aggregate
nominal amount of GBP 157,046.07, in
connection with an offer by way of a
rights issue: (i) to holders of shares in
proportion (as close as practicable) to
their existing holdings; and (ii) to holders
of other equity securities as required
by the rights of those securities or, if
the Directors consider it necessary,
as permitted by the rights of those
securities, such amount to be reduced
Directors’ Report continued
251
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
by the aggregate nominal amount of
shares allotted or rights to subscribe for
or to convert any securities into shares
granted under paragraph (a), and subject
to the Directors having the right to make
such exclusions or other arrangements as
they may deem necessary or expedient
in relation to treasury shares, fractional
entitlements, record dates or legal,
regulatory or practical problems in, or
under the laws of, any territory.
These authorities will expire at the
conclusion of the 2024 AGM – or, if earlier,
at the close of business on 19 August 2024
– and approval will be sought at that
meeting to renew a similar authority for a
further year. None of the ordinary shares
carry any special rights regarding control
of the Company.
There are no restrictions on transfers of
shares, other than:
certain restrictions which may from
time to time be imposed by law or
regulations such as those relating
to insider dealing or pursuant to
the Company’s Inside Information
Disclosure Policy;
pursuant to the Company’s Securities
Dealing Policy and Code, whereby the
Directors and designated employees
require approval to deal in the
Company’s shares or cannot deal at
certain times; and
where a person with an interest in the
Company’s shares has been served
with a disclosure notice and has
failed to provide the Company with
information concerning interests in
those shares.
Results and dividends
The Group made a profit before taxation
and one-offs of GEL 1,633.71 million for
the year ended 31 December 2023. The
Groups profit after taxation for the year
was GEL 1,397.33 million.
The Company may by ordinary resolution
declare dividends provided that no
such dividend shall exceed the amount
recommended by the Company’s
Directors. The Directors may also pay
such interim dividends as appear to
be justified by the profits of the Group
available for distribution. As Bank of
Georgia Group PLC is a holding company,
the Group relies primarily on dividends
and other statutorily (if any) and
contractually permissible payments from
its subsidiaries to generate the funds
necessary to meet its obligations and pay
dividends to its shareholders.
In the AGM of 19 May 2023, shareholders
approved the Board recommended a final
dividend of GEL 5.80 per ordinary share in
respect of the period ended 31 December
2022, payable to ordinary shareholders of
the Group on 14 July 2023. On 17 August
2023, the Board declared an interim
dividend of GEL 3.06 in respect of the
period ended 30 June 2023, payable to
shareholders on 27 October 2023.
In June 2023, the Company completed
its GEL 260.7 million buyback and
cancellation programme. The Board of
Directors approved a further GEL 62
million share buyback in August 2023.
The distributions are consistent with the
Groups capital and distribution policy,
announced in September 2021, to target
a dividend/share buyback payout ratio in
the range of 30-50% of annual profits.
The Board believes these to be in the
best interests of the Company and its
shareholders.
The Board intends to recommend a final
dividend in respect of the year ended
31 December 2023 of GEL 4.94 per
ordinary share.
Equity Settled Option Plan
The Group operates two employee
benefit trusts (EBTs) – one for Executive
Management and the other for
employees below the executive level (the
‘ESOP’) – which hold ordinary shares
on-trust for the benefit of employees
and former employees of the Group and
their dependents, and which are used in
conjunction with the Groups employee
share schemes. Whilst ordinary shares
are held in the EBT, the voting rights in
respect of these ordinary shares may be
exercised by the trustees of the EBT.
In accordance with ESOP documentation,
Apex Group Fiduciary Services Limited
has waived its right to receive any
dividends. This waiver will remain in
place indefinitely, unless otherwise
instructed by the Company. The
Company has committed that new
shares issued in satisfaction of deferred
share compensation from the time of
the Company’s listing on the premium
segment of the London Stock Exchange
will not exceed 10% of Bank of Georgia
Group PLC’s ordinary share capital over
any ten-year period.
Powers of Directors
The Directors may exercise all powers
of the Company subject to applicable
legislation and regulations and the
Company’s Articles of Association.
Conflicts of interest
In accordance with the Companies Act
2006, the Directors have adopted a policy
and procedure for the disclosure and
authorisation (if appropriate) of conflicts
of interest. These have been followed
during 2023.
The Company’s Articles of Association
also contain provisions to allow the
Directors to authorise potential conflicts
of interest so that a Director is not in
breach of their duty under Company Law.
Directors’ remuneration
Directors’ fees are determined by the
Remuneration Committee from time to
time and must be in accordance with
the Directors’ Remuneration Policy last
approved by shareholders in 2022. The
fees paid to the Non-executive Directors
in 2023, pursuant to their letters of
appointment, are shown on page 238.
The fees paid to our sole Executive
Director for the period 1 January 2023 to
31 December 2023, pursuant to his service
agreements, are shown on page 233.
Directors’ interests
The Directors’ beneficial interests in
ordinary shares of Bank of Georgia Group
PLC as at 31 December 2023 are shown
on page 240, together with any changes
in those interests between the financial
year-end and the date on which this
Directors’ Report was approved by the
Board.
Company Secretary
Computershare Company Secretarial
Services Limited is the appointed
Company Secretary to Bank of Georgia
Group PLC.
Computershare is a global company
delivering governance solutions to
listed and private companies through
professional expertise and innovative
technologies.
Re-election of Directors
In line with the UK Corporate Governance
Codes recommendations all Directors
seek re-election annually. Accordingly, all
Directors who wish to continue on the
Board will stand for election or re-election
in 2024.
The Board will set out in its Notice of
Annual General Meeting the qualifications
of each Director and support for re-
election as applicable.
252
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Annual General Meeting
The Notice of Annual General Meeting
is circulated to all shareholders at least
20 working days prior to such meeting.
All shareholders are invited to attend the
AGM, where there is an opportunity to ask
the Chairman and the Chairs of the Board
Committees questions.
Shareholders are also invited to submit
questions ahead of the AGM by email
and responses are provided ahead of the
proxy voting deadline where practicable.
As recommended by the UK Corporate
Governance Code, all resolutions
proposed at the 2024 AGM will be voted
on separately – and the voting results
will be announced to the LSE and made
available on the Company’s website as
soon as practicable after the meeting.
These will include all votes cast for and
against and those withheld, and all
proxies lodged prior to the meeting.
For further information on shareholder
and stakeholder engagement see pages
52 to 59.
Directors’ responsibilities
Statements explaining the responsibilities
of the Directors for preparing the Annual
Report and consolidated and separate
financial statements can be found on
page 248 of this Annual Report.
A further statement is provided confirming
that the Board considers the Annual
Report, taken as a whole, to be fair,
balanced and understandable and provides
the information necessary for shareholders
to assess the Company’s position and
performance, business model and
strategy. Further information on the fair,
balanced and understandable statement
assessment can be found on page 223.
Indemnity
Subject to applicable legislation, every
current and former Director or other officer
of the Company (other than any person
engaged by the Company as auditor)
shall be indemnified by Bank of Georgia
Group PLC against (broadly) any liability
in relation to Bank of Georgia Group PLC,
other than (broadly) any liability to the
Company or a member of the Group, or
any criminal or regulatory fine. In addition,
the Company has put in place Directors
and Officers’ indemnity insurance.
Significant agreements
Bank of Georgia Group PLC is not party
to any significant agreements that take
effect, alter or terminate upon a change
of control of the Company. The Company
is not aware of any agreements between
holders of its ordinary shares that may
result in restrictions on the transfer of its
ordinary shares or on voting rights.
Presence outside of Georgia
We have our registered office in London
(see page 273) and additional offices in
Budapest, Istanbul and Tel Aviv, as well as
the BNB Bank in Belarus and Ameriabank
CJSC in Armenia.
Political donations
The Group did not make any political
donations or expenditure during 2023.
Authority to make political donations and
incur political expenditure will be put to
shareholder vote at the 2024 AGM.
Code of Conduct and Ethics
The Board has adopted a Code of
Conduct and Ethics relating to the lawful
and ethical conduct of the business,
supported by the Groups core values.
The Code of Conduct and Ethics has
been communicated to all Directors
and employees, and all are expected to
observe high standards of integrity and
fair dealing in relation to customers, staff
and regulators in the communities in
which the Group operates.
Our Code of Conduct and Ethics is
available on our website at: https://www.
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/
documents.
Independent auditors
The NBG granted an extension in respect
of the local mandatory audit rotation to
allow EY to continue as auditor of Bank
of Georgia Group PLC for the 2024 audit.
A resolution to reappoint EY as auditor of
Bank of Georgia Group PLC will be put to
shareholders at the 2024 AGM.
Major interests in shares
As at 31 December 2023 the following
interests in the ordinary share capital of
the Company have been notified to the
Directors:
Shareholder
No. of voting
rights
% of voting
rights
JSC Georgia Capital 9,009,849 19.71%
M&G PLC 2,214,571 4.84%
Dimensional Fund Advisors (DFA) LP 1,877,694 4.11%
JP Morgan Asset Management (UK) Ltd 1,846,062 4.04%
BlackRock Investment Management (UK) 1,637,535 3.58%
Vanguard Group Inc 1,524,432 3.33%
Source: Georgeson, Computershare
Notes:
1. JSC Georgia Capital will exercise its voting rights at the Group’s general meetings in accordance with the votes cast by all other Group shareholders, as long as JSC Georgia
Capital’s percentage holding in Bank of Georgia Group PLC is greater than 9.9%.
For the period 1 January 2024 up to
and including 17 April 2024 (the latest
practicable date for inclusion in this
report), there have been no further
notifications pursuant to DTR 5.
It should be noted that these holdings are
likely to have changed since the Company
was notified. However, notification of
any change is not required until the next
notifiable threshold is crossed.
The respective regulatory filings
by shareholders are available on
the Company’s website at https://
bankofgeorgiagroup.com/news/
regulatory and the LSE website at
https://www.londonstockexchange.com.
Directors’ Report continued
253
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Post-balance-sheet events
On 19 February 2024, the Company
announced that it and its subsidiary, JSC
Bank of Georgia, had conditionally agreed
to acquire 100% of the total issued share
capital of Ameriabank CJSC, a leading
universal bank in Armenia. At a General
Meeting of the Company held on 14 March
2024, 83.60% of issued share capital
voted, with 100.0% votes in favour of the
acquisition. Having received all necessary
shareholder and regulatory approvals as
of 29 March 2024, the acquisition was
completed on 3 April 2024 after which
the Company acquired 60% and JSC
Bank of Georgia acquired 30% of issued
share capital. ERBD retained a 10%
shareholding in Ameriabank’s total issued
share capital, subject to the Shareholders’
Put and Call Option Agreement as
disclosed in the class 1 circular published
by the Company on 19 February 2024.
Al Breach stepped down as a Non-
executive Director and a member of
the Remuneration Committee, Risk
Committee and Nomination Committee
with effect from 15 March 2024.
Andrew McIntyre was appointed as a
Non-executive Director and member of
the Audit Committee and Nomination
Committee with effect from 15 March
2024.
On 8 April 2024, the Company changed
its registered office to 29 Farm Street,
London, United Kingdom, W1J 5RL
Further information regarding the events
after the reporting period can be found in
Note 35 on pages 361 to 362.
Statement of disclosure of
information to the External
Auditor
We confirm that, so far as we are aware,
there is no relevant audit information of
which the Company’s auditor is unaware
– and we have taken all steps that we
reasonably believe should be taken as
Directors to make ourselves aware of
any relevant audit information and to
establish that the Company’s statutory
auditor is aware of such information.
The Directors’ Report on pages 248
to 253 was approved by the Board of
Directors on 24 April 2024 and signed
on its behalf:
By order of the Board
Computershare Company Secretarial
Services Limited
Company Secretary
24 April 2024
254
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
FINANCIAL
STATEMENTS
255
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Independent Auditors Report
To the Members of Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Opinion
In our opinion:
Bank of Georgia Group plc’s (the ‘Group’) group financial statements and Parent Company financial statements (the ‘financial
statements’) give a true and fair view of the state of the Groups and of the Parent Companys affairs as at 31 December 2023
and of the Groups profit for the year then ended;
the Group financial statements have been properly prepared in accordance with UK adopted international accounting standards;
the Parent Company financial statements have been properly prepared in accordance with UK adopted international accounting
standards as applied in accordance with section 408 of the Companies Act 2006; and
the financial statements have been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the Companies Act 2006.
We have audited the financial statements of Bank of Georgia Group Plc (the ‘Company’ or ‘Parent Company’) and its subsidiaries
(the ‘Group’) for the year ended 31 December 2023 which comprise:
Group
Consolidated statement of financial position as at
31 December 2023
Consolidated income statement for the year then ended
Consolidated statement of comprehensive income for the year
then ended
Consolidated statement of changes in equity for the year then
ended
Consolidated statement of cash flows for the year then ended
Related notes 1 to 35 to the financial statements, including a
summary of significant accounting policies
Information marked as ‘audited’ within the Directors’
Remuneration Report
Parent company
Statement of financial position as at 31 December 2023
Statement of changes in equity for the year then ended
Statement of cash flows for the year then ended
Related notes 1 to 35 to the financial statements including a
summary of significant accounting policies
The financial reporting framework that has been applied in their preparation is applicable law and UK adopted international
accounting standards and as regards the Parent Company financial statements, as applied in accordance with section 408 of the
Companies Act 2006.
Basis for opinion
We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing (UK) (ISAs (UK)) and applicable law. Our responsibilities
under those standards are further described in the Auditor’s responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements section of our
report. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
Independence
We are independent of the Group and Parent Company in accordance with the ethical requirements that are relevant to our audit
of the financial statements in the UK, including the FRC’s Ethical Standard as applied to listed public interest entities, and we have
fulfilled our other ethical responsibilities in accordance with these requirements.
The non-audit services prohibited by the FRC’s Ethical Standard were not provided to the Group or the Parent Company and we
remain independent of the Group and the Parent company in conducting the audit.
Conclusions relating to going concern
In auditing the financial statements, we have concluded that the directors’ use of the going concern basis of accounting in the
preparation of the financial statements is appropriate. Our evaluation of the directors’ assessment of the Group and Parent
company’s ability to continue to adopt the going concern basis of accounting included;
Evaluating the appropriateness of management’s key assumptions made in the Group’s forecasts. In assessing the reasonableness
of management’s assumptions, incorporating a consideration of the principal risks and uncertainties facing the Group including the
potential longer-term impacts of the ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine, as well as appropriate mitigating factors.
Assessing the level of liquidity available to the Group to support its ongoing needs and projected compliance with capital
requirements and external debt covenants for a period of 12 months from the date of authorisation of the financial statements.
Evaluating the reasonableness of management’s adverse forecast scenarios and associated stress testing, and their impact on
the Groups liquidity and capital positions and compliance with external debt covenants.
Obtaining the reverse stress test performed by management and assessing the plausibility of management actions available to
mitigate the impact of the reverse stress test.
Assessing the adequacy of the going concern disclosures provided within the financial statements by evaluating whether they
were consistent with management’s assessment and in compliance with the relevant reporting requirements.
256
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Full scope
components
94%
Specified
procedures
components
0%
Other
procedures
6%
Full scope
components
97%
Specified
procedures
components
0%
Other
procedures
3%
Full scope
components
96%
1%
Specified
procedures
components
Other
procedures
3%
Profit before tax Revenue Total assets
Independent Auditors Report continued
To the Members of Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Based on the work we have performed, we have not identified any material uncertainties relating to events or conditions that,
individually or collectively, may cast significant doubt on the Group and Parent Company’s ability to continue as a going concern for
a period of twelve months from when the financial statements are authorised for issue.
In relation to the Group and Parent Company’s reporting on how they have applied the UK Corporate Governance Code, we have
nothing material to add or draw attention to in relation to the directors’ statement in the financial statements about whether the
directors considered it appropriate to adopt the going concern basis of accounting.
Our responsibilities and the responsibilities of the directors with respect to going concern are described in the relevant sections
of this report. However, because not all future events or conditions can be predicted, this statement is not a guarantee as to the
Groups ability to continue as a going concern.
Overview of our audit approach
Audit scope We performed an audit of the complete financial information of four components and specified audit
procedures on balances for a further two components.
The components where we performed full or specific audit procedures accounted for 94% of profit
before tax, 97% of Revenue and 97% of Total assets.
Key audit matters Allowance for Expected Credit Loss and application of IFRS 9 ‘Financial Instruments’.
Measurement of fair value of investment properties.
Materiality Overall Group materiality of GEL 83m which represents 5% of profit before tax.
An overview of the scope of the Parent Company and Group audits
Tailoring the scope
Our assessment of audit risk, our evaluation of materiality and our allocation of performance materiality determine our audit scope
for each company within the Group. Taken together, this enables us to form an opinion on the consolidated financial statements. We
take into account size, risk profile, the organisation of the Group and effectiveness of group-wide controls, changes in the business
environment, the potential impact of climate change and other factors such as recent Internal audit results when assessing the level
of work to be performed at each company.
In assessing the risk of material misstatement to the Group financial statements, and to ensure we had adequate quantitative
coverage of significant accounts in the financial statements, of the twenty-three reporting components of the Group, we selected
six components covering entities within the United Kingdom, Georgia and Belarus, which represent the principal business units
within the Group.
Of the six components selected, we performed an audit of the complete financial information of four components (‘full scope
components’) which were selected based on their size or risk characteristics. For the remaining two components (‘specified
procedures components’), we performed specified audit procedures on specific accounts within that component that we considered
had the potential for the greatest impact on the significant accounts in the financial statements either because of the size of these
accounts or their risk profile.
The reporting components where we performed audit procedures accounted for 94% (2022: 98%) of the Group’s profit before
tax, 97% (2022: 97%) of the Group’s Revenue and 97% (2022: 98%) of the Groups Total assets. For the current year, the full scope
components contributed 94% (2022: 87%) of the Group’s profit before tax less non-recurring items, 97% (2022: 93%) of the Group’s
Revenue and 95% (2022: 92%) of the Groups Total assets. We also instructed two locations to perform specified procedures over
cash at bank balances.
Of the remaining seventeen components that together represent 6% of the Group’s profit before tax, none are individually greater
than 2% of the Group’s profit before tax. For these components, we performed other procedures, analytical reviews and testing of
consolidation journal entries and intercompany eliminations to respond to any potential risks of material misstatement to the Group
financial statements.
The charts below illustrate the coverage obtained from the work performed by our audit teams.
257
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Changes from the prior year
As part of the current year audit, we have assigned JSC BGEO Group as a full scope component. Previously it was a specific scope
component, the change in assigned scope was due to its increase in size relative to the Group.
Involvement with component teams
In establishing our overall approach to the Group audit, we determined the type of work that needed to be undertaken at each
of the components by us, as the primary audit engagement team, or by component auditors from other EY global network firms
operating under our instruction. Of the four full scope components, audit procedures were performed on all four of these directly
by the primary audit team. For the two specific scope components, where the work was performed by component auditors, we
determined the appropriate level of involvement to enable us to determine that sufficient audit evidence had been obtained as a
basis for our opinion on the Group as a whole.
The Group audit team continued to follow a programme of planned visits that has been designed to ensure that the Senior
Statutory Auditor visits component teams and holds meetings with these teams and the client. During the current year’s audit cycle,
visits were undertaken by the primary audit team to the component teams in Georgia. These visits involved discussing the audit
approach with the component team and any issues arising from their work, meeting with local management, and reviewing relevant
audit working papers on risk areas. The primary team interacted regularly with the component teams where appropriate during
various stages of the audit, reviewed relevant working papers and were responsible for the scope and direction of the audit process.
The programme of our visit to a component team located in Belarus was impacted by travel restrictions due to the war in Ukraine.
For this location, oversight of the work was performed remotely through detailed review of component team audit work.
This, together with the additional procedures performed at Group level, gave us appropriate evidence for our opinion on the Group
financial statements.
Climate change
Stakeholders are increasingly interested in how climate change will impact the Group. The Group has determined that climate-
related risk is an emerging risk as described on page 148 of the Risk Management section of the Annual Report. This is explained on
pages 100 to 118 in the required Task Force On Climate Related Financial Disclosures and on pages 149 to 170 in the principal risks
and uncertainties. All of these disclosures form part of the ‘Other information,’ rather than the audited financial statements. Our
procedures on these unaudited disclosures therefore consisted solely of considering whether they are materially inconsistent with
the financial statements or our knowledge obtained in the course of the audit or otherwise appear to be materially misstated, in line
with our responsibilities on ‘Other information’.
In planning and performing our audit we assessed the potential impacts of climate change on the Group’s business and any
consequential material impact on its financial statements.
There are no significant judgements or estimates relating to climate change in the notes to the financial statements.
Our audit effort in considering the impact of climate change on the financial statements was focused on evaluating management’s
assessment of the impact of climate risk, physical and transition, their climate commitments, the effects of material climate risks
disclosed on pages 168 and 169 and the and the Risk management in Note 30; and whether these have been appropriately reflected
in the asset values and liabilities recognised. As part of this evaluation, we performed our own risk assessment, supported by our
climate change specialists, to determine the risks of material misstatement in the financial statements from climate change.
We also challenged the Directors’ considerations of climate change risks in their assessment of going concern and viability and
associated disclosures. Where considerations of climate change were relevant to our assessment of going concern, these are
described above.
Based on our work we have not identified the impact of climate change on the financial statements to be a key audit matter or to
impact a key audit matter.
Key audit matters
Key audit matters are those matters that, in our professional judgment, were of most significance in our audit of the financial
statements of the current period and include the most significant assessed risks of material misstatement (whether or not due to
fraud) that we identified. These matters included those which had the greatest effect on: the overall audit strategy, the allocation of
resources in the audit; and directing the efforts of the engagement team. These matters were addressed in the context of our audit
of the financial statements as a whole, and in our opinion thereon, and we do not provide a separate opinion on these matters.
258
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Independent Auditors Report continued
To the Members of Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Allowance for Expected Credit Loss (‘ECL’) and application of IFRS 9 ‘Financial instruments’
Expected credit loss allowance related to Loans to customers of GEL 328m (2022: GEL 326m), Note 9
Risk Our response to the risk
The ECL provision is calculated using a combination of a
collective provisioning model and specific loan provisions based
on discounted cash flow analyses and regression-based forward-
looking estimates.
The allowance for expected credit loss is highly judgemental
and changes in assumptions could have a material impact on
reported profits.
Both collective and specific provisioning depend on a number of
assumptions and judgements including:
allocation of loans to stage 1, 2, 3 or Purchased and
Originated Credit-Impaired (‘POCI’) using criteria set in
accordance with IFRS 9 ‘Financial Instruments’;
accounting interpretations and modelling assumptions used
to build and run the models for calculating the expected
credit loss (‘ECL’);
inputs and assumptions used to estimate the impact of
multiple economic scenarios, including weightings applied;
estimation of probability of default (‘PD’), loss given default
(‘LGD’) and exposure at default (‘EAD’), including the
valuation of collateral; and
measurement of individually assessed provisions, including
expected future cash flows and the valuation of collateral.
There are also risks related to:
the accuracy and completeness of underlying loan data used
in the ECL model; and
the accuracy and adequacy of financial statement
disclosures.
As a consequence of the judgement involved in establishing
the allowance, there is a greater risk of misstatement in ECL
charges, either by fraud or error, including through the potential
override of controls by management.
Information on the impairment of loans to customers is included
in Note 9, Loans to Customers and Note 30, Risk Management,
to the consolidated financial statements.
We obtained an understanding, performed walkthroughs
and evaluated the design and operating effectiveness of
key controls across the processes relevant to the ECL. This
includes controls over data accuracy and completeness, credit
monitoring, allocation of borrowers into their respective
impairment stages, individual provisioning and production of
journal entries and disclosures.
Using our credit risk specialists, we assessed and challenged
the Groups IFRS 9 provisioning methodology to determine
whether the accounting standard had been complied with
consistently and any changes made to the methodology were
appropriate.
Using our credit risk specialists, we tested the assumptions,
inputs and formulae used in the ECL model to confirm that
the model was consistent with the stated methodology. This
included assessing the appropriateness of the model design
and formulae used, and recalculating the PD, LGD and EAD,
on a sample basis.
Our credit risk specialists performed a detailed review and
testing of the changes made in the models. We performed
a recalculation of the ECL on a sample basis, including
procedures over staging and underlying risk parameters.
We assessed the appropriateness of the macroeconomic
scenarios used by management and tested whether they had
been properly applied in the ECL calculations.
We tested the completeness and accuracy of key data inputs
used in the ECL model by reconciling loans and advances
between the underlying source systems and the ECL model.
We challenged the criteria used to allocate assets to
stage 1, 2, 3 or POCI in accordance with IFRS 9, including
management overlays applied specifically to determine
SICR and staging. For a sample of loans, we independently
assessed whether they had been allocated to the appropriate
stage, considering potential indicators of significant increase
in credit risk or default and challenged management as to the
rationale for movements between stages.
We performed procedures to address the existence and
valuation of collateral for loans where expected cash flows
from collateral were impacting the estimation of loan
losses. Involving our valuation specialists, we assessed the
reasonableness of valuation methodology of collaterals.
We evaluated the adequacy and appropriateness of
disclosures related to ECL for compliance with the
requirements of IFRS.
Key observations communicated to the Audit Committee
Although the estimation of the expected credit loss is by nature highly judgemental, based on the results of our audit procedures,
we concluded that the ECL provision is appropriate as at 31 December 2023. Specifically, we highlighted the following to the Audit
Committee:
We considered the overall valuation and treatment of collateral to be materially reasonable.
Staging, inputs and assumptions are appropriately applied to the ECL calculation.
Financial statements disclosures on loans and receivables and the ECL allowance are in compliance with the requirements of
IFRS 9.
259
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Valuation of investment properties
Investment property of GEL 124m (2022: GEL 167m) Note 15
Risk Our response to the risk
The Group applies the fair value model for its investment
property. The Group engaged a professional valuer to determine
the fair value for a selection of its investment properties. Real
estate valuations are inherently uncertain and subject to an
estimation process.
The Groups real estate properties are located primarily in
Georgia, where the secondary market is relatively illiquid,
which increases the judgement involved in determining these
valuations.
Information on the valuation of investment properties is included
to Note 3, Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, Note 15,
Investment Properties, Note 31, Fair Value Measurements, to the
consolidated financial statements.
We engaged our Real Estate specialists to evaluate a sample of
the Groups real estate valuations. The specialists’ assessment
included evaluation of the competence and objectivity of the
external valuers engaged by the Group, analysis of the methods
and assumptions used and testing of the data provided by the
valuers.
In respect of properties, which were not subject to individual
valuation by the external valuer, we assessed management’s
assumptions relating to changes in the prices of such properties
for the reporting period. We corroborated these by reviewing
the market overview reports prepared by external valuers, and
by reference to our understanding of the Group’s real estate
portfolio and observable market information.
We reviewed the presentation and disclosure of investment
properties in the financial statements are in accordance with
relevant accounting standards.
Key observations communicated to the Audit Committee
Based on the results of our audit procedures, we concluded that:
The valuation of investment properties as at 31 December 2023 is reasonable, including management’s specialist valuations and
relevant adjustments.
The financial statements disclosures are appropriate and in compliance with relevant accounting standards.
Our application of materiality
We apply the concept of materiality in planning and performing the audit, in evaluating the effect of identified misstatements on
the audit and in forming our audit opinion.
Materiality
The magnitude of an omission or misstatement that, individually or in the aggregate, could reasonably be expected to influence the
economic decisions of the users of the financial statements. Materiality provides a basis for determining the nature and extent of
our audit procedures.
We determined materiality for the Group to be GEL 83m (2022: GEL 62m), which is 5% (2022: 5%) of Group of profit before tax.
We believe that profit before tax provides us with the most appropriate measure for the users of the financial statements given the
Group is profit making; it is consistent with the wider industry and is the standard for listed and regulated entities and we believe it
reflects the most useful measure for users of the financial statements.
We determined materiality for the Parent Company to be GEL 83m (2022: GEL 62m), which is the lower of GEL 110m (2% of equity)
and the Group materiality. We believe that equity reflects the most useful measure for users of the financial statements as the
Parent Company’s primary purpose is to act as a holding company with investments in the Groups subsidiaries, not to generate
operating profits and therefore a profit based measure is not relevant.
Performance materiality
The application of materiality at the individual account or balance level. It is set at an amount to reduce to an appropriately low level
the probability that the aggregate of uncorrected and undetected misstatements exceeds materiality.
On the basis of our risk assessments, together with our assessment of the Group’s overall control environment, our judgement
was that performance materiality was 50% (2022: 50%) of our planning materiality, namely GEL 41.5m (2022: GEL 31m). We have
set performance materiality at this percentage due to various considerations including the past history of misstatements, the
effectiveness of the control environment and other factors affecting the entity and its financial reporting.
Audit work at component locations for the purpose of obtaining audit coverage over significant financial statement accounts is
undertaken based on a percentage of total performance materiality. The performance materiality set for each component is based
on the relative scale and risk of the component to the Group as a whole and our assessment of the risk of misstatement at that
component. In the current year, the range of performance materiality allocated to components was GEL 12.5m to GEL 36.5m (2022:
GEL 4m to GEL 29m).
260
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Independent Auditors Report continued
To the Members of Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Reporting threshold
An amount below which identified misstatements are considered as being clearly trivial.
We agreed with the Audit Committee that we would report to them all uncorrected audit differences in excess of GEL 4.15m
(2022: GEL 3m), which is set at 5% of planning materiality, as well as differences below that threshold that, in our view, warranted
reporting on qualitative grounds.
We evaluate any uncorrected misstatements against both the quantitative measures of materiality discussed above and in light of
other relevant qualitative considerations in forming our opinion.
Other information
The other information comprises the information included in the annual report set out on pages 3 to 253, other than the financial
statements and our auditor’s report thereon. The directors are responsible for the other information contained within the annual
report.
Our opinion on the financial statements does not cover the other information and, except to the extent otherwise explicitly stated in
this report, we do not express any form of assurance conclusion thereon.
Our responsibility is to read the other information and, in doing so, consider whether the other information is materially inconsistent
with the financial statements or our knowledge obtained in the course of the audit or otherwise appears to be materially misstated.
If we identify such material inconsistencies or apparent material misstatements, we are required to determine whether this gives
rise to a material misstatement in the financial statements themselves. If, based on the work we have performed, we conclude that
there is a material misstatement of the other information, we are required to report that fact.
We have nothing to report in this regard.
Opinions on other matters prescribed by the Companies Act 2006
In our opinion, the part of the directors’ Remuneration Report to be audited has been properly prepared in accordance with the
Companies Act 2006.
In our opinion, based on the work undertaken in the course of the audit:
the information given in the strategic report and the directors’ report for the financial year for which the financial statements are
prepared is consistent with the financial statements and those reports have been prepared in accordance with applicable legal
requirements;
the information about internal control and risk management systems in relation to financial reporting processes and about
share capital structures, given in compliance with rules 7.2.5 and 7.2.6 in the Disclosure Rules and Transparency Rules sourcebook
made by the Financial Conduct Authority (the FCA Rules), is consistent with the financial statements and has been prepared in
accordance with applicable legal requirements; and
information about the Company’s corporate governance statement and practices and about its administrative, management
and supervisory bodies and their committees complies with rules 7.2.2, 7.2.3 and 7.2.7 of the FCA Rules.
Matters on which we are required to report by exception
In the light of the knowledge and understanding of the Group and the Parent Company and its environment obtained in the course
of the audit, we have not identified material misstatements in:
the strategic report or the directors’ report; or
the information about internal control and risk management systems in relation to financial reporting processes and about share
capital structures, given in compliance with rules 7.2.5 and 7.2.6 of the FCA Rules.
We have nothing to report in respect of the following matters in relation to which the Companies Act 2006 requires us to report to
you if, in our opinion:
adequate accounting records have not been kept by the Company, or returns adequate for our audit have not been received from
branches not visited by us; or
the Parent Company financial statements and the part of the Directors’ Remuneration Report to be audited are not in
agreement with the accounting records and returns; or
certain disclosures of directors’ remuneration specified by law are not made; or
we have not received all the information and explanations we require for our audit; or
a Corporate Governance Statement has not been prepared by the Company.
261
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Corporate Governance Statement
We have reviewed the directors’ statement in relation to going concern, longer-term viability and that part of the Corporate
Governance Statement relating to the Group and Company’s compliance with the provisions of the UK Corporate Governance Code
specified for our review by the Listing Rules.
Based on the work undertaken as part of our audit, we have concluded that each of the following elements of the Corporate
Governance Statement is materially consistent with the financial statements or our knowledge obtained during the audit:
Directors’ statement with regards to the appropriateness of adopting the going concern basis of accounting and any material
uncertainties identified set out on page 170;
Directors’ explanation as to its assessment of the Company’s prospects, the period this assessment covers and why the period is
appropriate set out on page 170;
Director’s statement on whether it has a reasonable expectation that the Group will be able to continue in operation and meets
its liabilities set out on page 170;
Directors’ statement on fair, balanced and understandable set out on page 248;
Board’s confirmation that it has carried out a robust assessment of the emerging and principal risks set out on pages 150 to 170;
The section of the annual report that describes the review of effectiveness of risk management and internal control systems set
out on page 197; and
The section describing the work of the audit committee set out on pages 215 to 223.
Responsibilities of directors
As explained more fully in the directors’ responsibilities statement set out on page 248, the directors are responsible for the
preparation of the financial statements and for being satisfied that they give a true and fair view, and for such internal control as
the directors determine is necessary to enable the preparation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement,
whether due to fraud or error.
In preparing the financial statements, the directors are responsible for assessing the Group and Parent Company’s ability to
continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going concern basis of
accounting unless the directors either intend to liquidate the Group or the Parent Company or to cease operations, or have no
realistic alternative but to do so.
Auditor’s responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements
Our objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material
misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an auditor’s report that includes our opinion. Reasonable assurance is a
high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs (UK) will always detect a material
misstatement when it exists. Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or in the
aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial
statements.
Explanation as to what extent the audit was considered capable of detecting
irregularities, including fraud
Irregularities, including fraud, are instances of non-compliance with laws and regulations. We design procedures in line with our
responsibilities, outlined above, to detect irregularities, including fraud. The risk of not detecting a material misstatement due to
fraud is higher than the risk of not detecting one resulting from error, as fraud may involve deliberate concealment by, for example,
forgery or intentional misrepresentations, or through collusion. The extent to which our procedures are capable of detecting
irregularities, including fraud is detailed below.
However, the primary responsibility for the prevention and detection of fraud rests with both those charged with governance of the
company and management.
We obtained an understanding of the legal and regulatory frameworks that are applicable to the Group and determined that the
most significant are relevant regulations of the UK Listing Authority (‘UKLA’), as well as the various Georgian legal and regulatory
requirements applying to the components of the Group, of which the most material are the regulations of the National Bank of
Georgia.
262
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Independent Auditors Report continued
To the Members of Bank of Georgia Group PLC
We understood how Bank of Georgia Group plc is complying with those frameworks by making enquiries of management,
internal audit, and those responsible for legal and compliance matters. We also reviewed correspondence between the Group
and its regulators; reviewed minutes of the Board and its committees; and gained an understanding of the Group’s approach
to governance, demonstrated by the Board’s approval of the Groups governance framework and the Board’s review of the
Groups risk management framework (‘RMF’) and internal control processes. We assessed the susceptibility of the Groups
financial statements to material misstatement, including how fraud might occur by considering the controls that the Group has
established to address risks identified by the entity, or that otherwise seek to prevent, deter or detect fraud. We also considered
areas of significant judgement, complex transactions, performance targets, economic or external pressures and the impact
these have on the control environment. Where this risk was considered to be higher, we performed audit procedures to address
each identified fraud risk which included management, internal audit and legal enquiries, testing of internal control, journal entry
testing, analytical procedures, tests of detail and focused testing as referred to in the Key Audit Matters section above. These
procedures were designed to provide reasonable assurance that the financial statements were free from fraud or error.
Based on this understanding we designed our audit procedures to identify non-compliance with such laws and regulations.
Our procedures involved inquiries of Group legal counsel, money laundering reporting officer, internal audit, certain senior
management executives and focused testing. We also performed inspection of key regulatory correspondence from the relevant
regulatory authorities.
We assessed the susceptibility of the Groups financial statements to material misstatement, including how fraud might occur
by considering the controls that the Group has established to address risks identified by the entity, or that otherwise seek to
prevent, deter or detect fraud. We also considered areas of significant judgement, complex transactions, performance targets,
economic or external pressures and the impact these have on the control environment. Where this risk was considered to be
higher, we performed audit procedures to address each identified fraud risk which included management, internal audit and legal
enquiries, testing of internal control, journal entry testing, analytical procedures, tests of detail and focused testing as referred
to in the Key Audit Matters section above. These procedures were designed to provide reasonable assurance that the financial
statements were free from fraud or error.
The Group operates in the banking industry which is a highly regulated environment. As such, the Senior Statutory Auditor
considered the experience and expertise of the engagement team to ensure that the team had the appropriate competence and
capabilities which included the use of specialists where appropriate.
A further description of our responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements is located on the Financial Reporting Council’s
website at https://www.frc.org.uk/auditorsresponsibilities. This description forms part of our auditor’s report.
Other matters we are required to address
Following the recommendation from the audit committee, we were appointed by the company on 25 January 2018 to audit the
financial statements for the year ending 31 December 2017 and subsequent financial periods.
The period of total uninterrupted engagement including previous renewals and reappointments is 7 years, covering the years
ending 31 December 2017 to 31 December 2023.
The audit opinion is consistent with the additional report to the Audit Committee.
Use of our report
This report is made solely to the company’s members, as a body, in accordance with Chapter 3 of Part 16 of the Companies Act
2006. Our audit work has been undertaken so that we might state to the Company’s members those matters we are required to
state to them in an auditor’s report and for no other purpose. To the fullest extent permitted by law, we do not accept or assume
responsibility to anyone other than the Company and the Company’s members as a body, for our audit work, for this report, or for
the opinions we have formed.
Peter Wallace (Senior statutory auditor)
for and on behalf of Ernst & Young LLP, Statutory Auditor
London
24 April 2024
263
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Consolidated Statement of Financial Position
As at 31 December 2023 (Thousands of Georgian Lari)
Notes 2023
2022
2021
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents
6
3, 101,824
3,584,843
1,520,562
Amounts due from credit institutions
7
1, 752,657
2, 433,028
1, 931,390
Investment securities
8
5, 129, 757
4,349 ,729
2,595,66 4
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
9
20,232, 721
16,861, 706
16, 168, 973
Accounts receivable and other loans
10
4 7 ,562
397 ,990
3,680
Prepayments
37 ,511
43,612
4 0,878
Foreclosed Assets*
12
271,712
119 , 924
3,216
Right-of-use assets
11
138,695
117 ,387
80, 186
Investment properties
15
124 ,068
166,546
226,849
Property and equipment
13
436, 955
398,855
378,808
Goodwill
16
41,253
33,351
33,351
Intangible assets
14
167 ,862
1 4 9,4 4 1
14 4,251
Income tax assets
17
2,520
864
292
Other assets*
18
245,072
215,058
255,245
Assets held for sale
27 ,389
29,566
46,731
Total assets
31,757 ,558
28, 901,900
23,430,07 6
Liabilities
Client deposits and notes
19
20,522,739
18,261,397
14,038,002
Amounts owed to credit institutions
20
5, 156,009
5,266,653
4,318,4 45
Debt securities issued
21
421,359
645,968
1,518,685
Lease liability
11
141, 934
114 ,470
8 7, 6 6 2
Accruals and deferred income
129 ,355
106,366
80, 157
Income tax liabilities
17
199 ,058
99 ,533
110,868
Other liabilities
18
167 ,268
158,691
183,3 49
Total liabilities
26,737 ,722
24,653,078
20,337 ,168
Equity
23
Share capital
1,506
1,563
1,618
Additional paid-in capital
465,009
506,30 4
492,243
Treasury shares
(71)
(83)
(75)
Capital redemption reserve
112
55
Other reserves
21,385
14 ,564
(3,223)
Retained earnings
4,510,780
3, 709 , 170
2,588, 463
Total equity attributable to shareholders of the Group
4, 998,721
4 ,231,573
3 ,079,026
Non-controlling interests
21, 115
17 ,249
13,882
Total equity
5,019 ,836
4,248,822
3,092,908
Total liabilities and equity
31,757 ,558
28,901, 900
23,430,07 6
The financial statements on pages 263 to 362 were approved by the Board of Directors and signed on its behalf by:
Archil Gachechiladze
Chief Executive Officer
Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Registered No. 10917019
24 April 2024
* To improve the quality and understandability of its consolidated statement of financial position, the Group has revisited the presentation of foreclosed assets, inventories
and other assets. Further details are disclosed in Note 3
The accompanying Notes on pages 271 to 362 are an integral part of these financial statements.
264
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Consolidated Income Statement
For the year ended 31 December 2023 (Thousands of Georgian Lari)
Notes 2023
2022
2021
Interest income calculated using EIR method
2,734,208
2,236,307
1,822,307
Other interest income
14,053
20,57 4
28,737
Interest income
2,748,261
2,256,881
1,851,04 4
Interest expense
(1, 112,568)
(1,056,829)
(882,474)
Deposit insurance fees
(20,24 7)
(17 ,717)
(14,629)
Net interest income
24
1,615,4 46
1,182,335
953, 941
Fee and commission income
707,765
559,465
390,829
Fee and commission expense
(273,283)
(241, 974)
(158,398)
Net fee and commission income
25
434,482
3 1 7, 4 9 1
232,431
Net foreign currency gain
365,711
466,094
109 ,099
Net gains/(losses) on extinguishment of debt
564
(8,717)
(2,892)
One-off other income from settlement of legacy claim
10
22 ,585
391, 100
Net other gains/(losses)
28
114, 171
44,809
73,098
Operating income
2, 552,959
2,393,112
1,365,677
Salaries and other employee benefits
26
(419,454)
(362,019)
(281,087)
Administrative expenses
26
(205,368)
(164 ,450)
(129 ,524)
Depreciation, amortisation and impairment
11, 13, 14
(124, 723)
(111,089)
(93,618)
Other operating expenses
(4,508)
(3,628)
(3,723)
Operating expenses
(754,053)
(641, 186)
(507 , 952)
Profit/(loss) from associates
1,456
754
(3,781)
Operating income before cost of risk
1,800,362
1,752,680
853,944
Expected credit loss on loans to customers
27
(124,298)
(128,678)
(1,452)
Expected credit loss on finance lease receivables
27
(2 ,762)
(3,208)
(4 ,9 5 0)
Other expected credit loss
27
2 , 5 49
(16, 189)
9,899
Impairment charge on other assets and provisions
27
(19 ,553)
29 ,007
(54, 909)
Cost of risk
(144 ,064)
(119 ,068)
(51,412)
Net operating income before non-recurring items
1,656,298
1,633,612
802,532
Net non-recurring items
1,038
(590)
Profit before income tax expense
1,656,298
1,634 ,650
801, 942
Income tax expense
17
(258, 971)
(190,651)
(74,824)
Profit for the year
1,397 ,327
1, 443,999
727 ,118
Total profit attributable to:
– shareholders of the Group
1,391,277
1,439 ,507
723,806
– non-controlling interests
6,050
4, 49 2
3,312
1,397 ,327
1, 443,999
727 ,118
Basic earnings per share:
23
31.2967
3 0.9 94 6
15.2240
Diluted earnings per share:
23
30.4252
30.3328
14.8801
The accompanying Notes on pages 271 to 362 are an integral part of these financial statements.
265
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Consolidated Statement of Comprehensive Income
For the year ended 31 December 2023 (Thousands of Georgian Lari)
2023
2022
2021
Profit for the year
1,397 ,327
1, 443,999
727 ,118
Other comprehensive (loss)/income
Other comprehensive (loss)/income to be reclassified to profit or loss in subsequent
years, net of tax:
Net change in fair value on investments in debt instruments measured at fair value
through other comprehensive income (FVOCI)
25, 000
29 ,232
(39,573)
– Realised gain on financial assets measured at FVOCI
(8,330)
(7 ,921)
(30,0 4 4)
Change in allowance for expected credit losses on investments in debt instruments
measured at FVOCI reclassified to the consolidated income statement
1,04 6
6,568
(1,643)
– Loss from currency translation differences
(4 1, 176)
(18,278)
(7 , 184)
Net other comprehensive (loss)/income not to be reclassified to profit or loss in
subsequent years, net of tax
(23,460)
9 ,601
(78, 44 4)
Other comprehensive loss not to be reclassified to profit or loss in subsequent years:
– Net gain (loss) on investments in equity instruments designated at FVOCI
1,7 76
(1,369)
884
Net other comprehensive income/(loss) to be reclassified to profit or loss in subsequent
years, net of tax
1 ,7 76
(1,369)
884
Other comprehensive (loss)/income for the year, net of tax
(21,684)
8,232
(77 ,560)
Total comprehensive income for the year
1,375,643
1,452,231
649 ,558
Total comprehensive income attributable to:
– shareholders of the Group
1,369 ,869
1,447 ,816
6 46 ,74 9
– non-controlling interests
5 ,7 74
4 , 41 5
2,809
1,375,643
1,452,231
649 ,558
The accompanying Notes on pages 271 to 362 are an integral part of these financial statements.
266
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Attributable to shareholders of the Group
Additional Capital Non-
Share paid-in Treasury Other redemption Retained controlling Total
capitalcapitalsharesreservesreserve
earnings
Total
interestsequity
31 December 2020
1,618
526,634
(54)
71,227
1, 939 , 122
2,538,547
11,368
2 ,5 49,9 15
Profit for the year
723,806
723,806
3,312
727 , 118
Other comprehensive income for
the year
(74,430)
(2,627)
(77 ,057)
(503)
(77 ,560)
Total comprehensive income for
the year
(74,430)
721, 179
6 46 , 74 9
2,809
649,558
Increase in equity arising from
share-based payments
45,289
18
45,307
45,307
Purchase of treasury shares
under share-based payments
(79 ,680)
(39)
(79 ,719)
(79 ,719)
Dividends to shareholders
of the Group (Note 23)
(71,838)
(7 1,838)
(7 1,838)
Increase in share capital of
subsidiaries
(20)
(20)
20
Dividends of subsidiaries to
non-controlling shareholders
(315)
(315)
31 December 2021
1,618
492,243
(75)
(3,223)
2 ,588,463
3,079,026
13,882
3,092,908
Profit for the year
1,439 ,507
1,439 ,507
4 , 492
1,443, 999
Other comprehensive income for
the year
17 ,876
(9 ,567)
8,309
(77)
8,232
Total comprehensive income for
the year
17 ,876
1,429 , 940
1,447,816
4 ,415
1,452,231
Increase in equity arising from
share-based payments
82,288
27
82,315
82 ,315
Purchase of treasury shares
under share-based payments
(68,227)
(35)
(68,262)
(68,262)
Dividends to shareholders
of the Group (Note 23)
(19 6,514)
(19 6,514)
(196,514)
Increase in share capital of
subsidiaries
(89)
(89)
19
(70)
Purchase of treasury shares
(112,719)
(112,719)
(112, 719)
Cancellation of treasury shares
(55)
112 ,719
55
(112, 719)
Dividends of subsidiaries to
non-controlling shareholders
(1,06 7)
(1,067)
31 December 2022
1,563
506,30 4
(8 3)
14 ,564
55
3,709 , 170
4 ,231,573
17 ,249
4,248,822
Profit for the year
1,391,277
1,39 1,277
6,050
1,397 ,327
Other comprehensive income for
the year
6, 787
(28, 195)
(21,408)
(2 76)
(21,684)
Total comprehensive income for
the year
6,787
1,363,082
1,369 ,869
5 ,7 74
1,375,643
Increase in equity arising from
share-based payments
72 ,009
46
72,055
518
72 ,573
Purchase of treasury shares
under share-based payments
(106,295)
(32)
(106,327)
(106,327)
Dividends to shareholders
of the Group (Note 23)
(396,627)
(396,627)
(396,627)
Increase in share capital of
subsidiaries
34
34
38
72
Non-controlling interests arising
on acquisition of subsidiary
241
241
Purchase of treasury shares
(7 ,009)
(164 ,847)
(171,856)
(171,856)
Cancellation of treasury shares
(57)
16 4,845
57
(164 ,845)
Dividends of subsidiaries to
non-controlling shareholders
(2,705)
(2,7 05)
31 December 2023
1,506
4 65,009
(7 1)
21,385
112
4,510,780
4, 998,721
21, 115
5,019 ,836
The accompanying Notes on pages 271 to 362 are an integral part of these financial statements.
Consolidated Statement of Changes in Equity
For the year ended 31 December 2023 (Thousands of Georgian Lari)
267
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Consolidated Statement of Cash Flows
For the year ended 31 December 2023 (Thousands of Georgian Lari)
Notes 2023
2022
2021
Cash flows from operating activities
Interest received
2,711,08 7
2,299,639
1,866,371
Interest paid
(1, 130,065)
(1,0 18, 118)
(898,342)
Fees and commissions received
6 16,371
522,586
380,264
Fees and commissions paid
(235,775)
(241, 97 4)
(158,398)
Net cash inflow from real estate
9 ,601
7 , 111
2 7, 6 7 7
Net realised gain from foreign currencies
355,473
453,998
134 ,851
Recoveries of loans to customers previously written off
9
4 7,0 2 9
84 ,542
81,329
Cash received from/(paid for) derivatives
(235)
Other income received
10
381,746
11,799
8,651
Salaries and other employee benefits paid
(346,880)
(279 ,7 04)
(235, 780)
General and administrative and operating expenses paid
(200,534)
(171,389)
(140, 191)
Cash flows from operating activities before changes in operating assets
and liabilities
2,208,053
1,668,490
1,066, 197
Net (increase)/decrease in operating assets
Amounts due from credit institutions
624, 130
(902,255)
(25,839)
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
(3,662,4 87)
(2,332,9 75)
(2 ,750,486)
Prepayments and other assets*
11,775
(6,912)
(19,417)
Foreclosed assets*
159 ,204
(11, 700)
(5, 907)
Net increase/(decrease) in operating liabilities
Amounts due to credit institutions
(103,488)
1,019 ,092
1,090,386
Debt securities issued
(45,504)
(73,772)
9 1,775
Client deposits and notes
2 ,213,868
5,509 ,461
5 20,03 4
Other liabilities
23, 913
94 ,581
826
Net cash flows from/(used in) operating activities before income tax
1,429,464
4, 964, 010
(32,431)
Income tax paid
(161, 102)
(202,558)
(4 , 6 49)
Net cash flows from/(used in) operating activities
1,268,362
4,7 61,452
(37 ,080)
Cash flows from/(used in) investing activities
Net (purchases) sales of investment securities
(7 47 ,379)
(1,80 7 ,355)
(86,798)
Purchase of investments in associates
(642)
Purchase of investments in subsidiaries
(3,716)
Proceeds from sale of investment properties and assets held for sale
4 7, 9 5 0
92 ,690
124,805
Proceeds from sale of property and equipment and intangible assets
550
3,658
1,822
Purchase of property and equipment and intangible assets
(155,370)
(121,666)
(97 ,575)
Dividends received
232
401
Net cash flows used in investing activities
(858,375)
(1,832,673)
(57,345)
Cash flows (used in) from financing activities
Repurchase of debt securities issued
21
(20, 980)
(617,194)
(28,825)
Repayment of the principal portion of the debt securities issued
21
(230, 995)
(31,581)
(46,706)
Proceeds from Tier 2 notes issued
21
78, 921
Proceeds from Additional Tier 1
20
148, 120
Cash payments for the principal portion of the lease liability
11
(32, 151)
(25, 980)
(29 ,518)
Dividends paid
(398, 156)
(196,948)
(71,985)
Purchase of treasury shares under share-based payments
(106,327)
(68,262)
(79 ,719)
Purchase of treasury shares
(171,856)
(112,719)
Net cash used in financing activities
(881,544)
(904,564)
(256,753)
Effect of exchange rates changes on cash and cash equivalents
(11,280)
40,400
(99 ,263)
Effect of expected credit losses on cash and cash equivalents
(182)
(3 3 4)
48
Net increase/(decrease) in cash and cash equivalents
(483,019)
2,06 4,281
(450,393)
Cash and cash equivalents, beginning of the year
6
3,584,8 43
1,520,562
1,97 0, 955
Cash and cash equivalents, end of the year
6
3,101,824
3,584,843
1,520,562
* To improve the quality and understandability of its consolidated statement of cash flows, the Group has revisited the presentation of foreclosed assets, inventories and
other assets. Further details are disclosed in Note 3.
268
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Bank of Georgia Group PLC has elected for the exemption not to present the separate income statement in accordance with section
408 of the Companies Act 2006. The Company’s individual balance sheet shows the Company’s profit and loss for the financial year
determined in accordance with this Act.
In 2023 the Company completed an internal reorganisation process intended to optimise its subsidiaries’ holding structure. The
reorganisation resulted in the extinguishment of its outstanding loan towards the subsidiary as well as receipt of additional
investment in the subsidiary through dividend in specie distribution recognised as part of profit or loss. The reorganisation did not
have any economic substance and was accounted as a common control transaction with no effect on the Group’s consolidated
financialstatements.
Notes 2023 2022 2021
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents 6 50,970 10,850 384
Investments in subsidiaries 2 5,451,902 4,981,658 4,981,658
Other assets 8,426 177 104
Total assets 5,511,298 4,992,685 4,982,146
Liabilities
Interest-bearing loans and borrowings 16,987 1,675,941 2,064,708
Other liabilities 5,748 802 46
Total liabilities 22,735 1,676,743 2,064,754
Equity
Share capital 23 1,506 1,563 1,618
Additional paid-in capital 592,075 599,084 599,084
Treasury shares (2)
Capital redemption reserve 112 55
Retained earnings 2,160,240 2,010,537 2,176,026
Net profit/(loss) for the period 2,734,632 704,703 140,664
Total equity 5,488,563 3,315,942 2,917,392
Total liabilities and equity 5,511,298 4,992,685 4,982,146
The financial statements on pages 263 to 362 were approved by the Board of Directors and signed on its behalf by:
Archil Gachechiladze
Chief Executive Officer
Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Registered No. 10917019
24 April 2024
The accompanying Notes on pages 271 to 362 are an integral part of these financial statements.
Separate Statement of Financial Position
As at 31 December 2023 (Thousands of Georgian Lari)
269
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Share
capital
Additional
paid-in
capital
Treasury
shares
Capital
redemption
reserve
Retained
earnings
Total
equity
31 December 2020 1,618 599,084 2,245,890 2,846,592
Total comprehensive income 140,664 140,664
Dividends to shareholders of the Group (Note 23) (69,864) (69,864)
31 December 2021 1,618 599,084 2,316,690 2,917,392
Total comprehensive income 705,284 705,284
Dividends to shareholders of the Group (Note 23) (194,015) (194,015)
Purchase of treasury shares (112,719) (112,719)
Cancellation of treasury shares (55) 112,719 55 (112,719)
31 December 2022 1,563 599,084 55 2,715,240 3,315,942
Total comprehensive income 2,734,632 2,734,632
Dividends to shareholders of the Group (Note 23) (390,155) (390,155)
Purchase of treasury shares (7,009) (164,847) (171,856)
Cancellation of treasury shares (57) 164,845 57 (164,845)
31 December 2023 1,506 592,075 (2) 112 4,894,872 5,488,563
The accompanying Notes on pages 271 to 362 are an integral part of these financial statements.
Separate Statement of Changes in Equity
For the year ended 31 December 2023 (Thousands of Georgian Lari)
270
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
2023 2022 2021
Net cash flows used in operating activities
Interest income received 5,772 1,499 156
Fees and commissions paid (750) (714) (759)
Salaries and other employee benefits paid (2,785) (3,064) (3,408)
General and administrative expenses paid (5,349) (2,269) (3,134)
Net cash flows from/(used in) operating activities before income tax (3,112) (4,548) (7,145)
Income tax paid (2,053)
Net cash flows used in operating activities (5,165) (4,548) (7,145)
Net cash flows from investing activities
Dividends received 607,539 322,717 70,185
Net cash flows from investing activities 607,539 322,717 70,185
Net cash (used in)/from financing activities
Borrowings received 7,128
Dividends paid (390,155) (194,015) (69,864)
Purchase of treasury shares (171,856) (112,719)
Net cash flows (used in)/from financing activities (562,011) (306,734) (62,736)
Effect of exchange rates changes on cash and cash equivalents (243) (969) (119)
Net increase/(decrease) in cash and cash equivalents 40,120 10,466 185
Cash and cash equivalents, beginning of the year 10,850 384 199
Cash and cash equivalents, end of the year 50,970 10,850 384
The accompanying Notes on pages 271 to 362 are an integral part of these financial statements.
Separate Statement of Cash Flows
For the year ended 31 December 2023 (Thousands of Georgian Lari)
271
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
1. Principal activities
Bank of Georgia Group PLC (‘BOGG’) is a public limited liability company incorporated in England and Wales with registered number
10917019. BOGG holds 99.56% of the share capital of JSC Bank of Georgia (the ‘Bank’) as at 31 December 2023, representing the
Bank’s ultimate parent company. Together with the Bank and other subsidiaries, the Group makes up a group of companies (the
‘Group’) and provides banking, leasing, brokerage and investment management services to corporate and individual customers. The
shares of BOGG (‘BOGG Shares’) are admitted to the premium listing segment of the Official List of the UK Listing Authority and
admitted to trading on the London Stock Exchange PLC’s Main Market for listed securities, effective 21 May 2018. The Bank is the
Groups main operating unit and accounts for most of the Groups activities.
JSC Bank of Georgia was established on 21 October 1994 as a joint stock company (JSC) under the laws of Georgia. The Bank
operates under a general banking licence issued by the National Bank of Georgia (‘NBG’; the Central Bank of Georgia) on
15 December 1994.
The Bank accepts deposits from the public and extends credit, transfers payments in Georgia and internationally, and exchanges
currencies. Its main office is in Tbilisi, Georgia. At 31 December 2023, the Bank has 189 operating outlets in all major cities of Georgia
(31 December 2022: 211, 31 December 2021: 211). The Bank’s registered legal address is 29a Gagarini Street, Tbilisi 0160, Georgia.
BOGG’s registered legal address is 29 Farm Street, London, W1J 5RL, United Kingdom.
As at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, the following shareholders owned more than 3% of the total
outstanding shares of BOGG. Other shareholders individually owned less than 3% of the outstanding shares.
Shareholder
31 December 31 December 31 December
2023 2022 2021
JSC Georgia Capital**
19.71%
20.60%
19.90%
M&G Investment Management Ltd
4.84%
4.10%
2.86%
Dimensional Fund Advisors (DFA) LP
4.11%
3.67%
3.13%
JP Morgan Asset Management
4.04%
2.60%
1.17%
BlackRock Investment Management (UK)
3.58%
2.31%
1.57%
Vanguard Group Inc
3.33%
3.20%
2.42%
Gemsstock Ltd
2.57%
2.47%
0.04%
Others
57.82%
61.05%
68.91%
Total*
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
* For the purposes of calculating percentage of shareholding, the denominator includes total number of issued shares, which includes shares held in the trust for the
share-based compensation purposes of the Group.
** JSC Georgia Capital will exercise its voting rights at the Group’s general meetings in accordance with the votes cast by all other Group Shareholders, as long as JSC Georgia
Capital’s percentage holding in Bank of Georgia Group PLC is greater than 9.9%.
As at 31 December 2023, the members of the Board of Directors of BOGG owned 760,209 shares or 1.7% (31 December 2022:
665,980 shares or 1.4%, 31 December 2021: 516,116 shares or 1.0%) of BOGG. Interests of the members of the Board of Directors of
BOGG were as follows:
Shareholder
31 December 31 December 31 December
2023,
shares
2022,
shares
2021,
shares
held held held
Neil Janin*
N/A
N/A
32,880
Mel Carvill*
N/A
Archil Gachechiladze
718,207
623,978
442,234
Al Breach
30,000
30,000
30,000
Tamaz Georgadze
5,000
5,000
5,000
Hanna Loikkanen
Jonathan Muir
Cecil Quillen
2,900
2,900
2,900
Véronique McCarroll
Mariam Megvinetukhutsesi
4,102
4,102
3,102
Total
760,209
665,980
516,116
* Neil Janin stepped down from the Board in 2022 and was replaced by Mel Carvill.
272
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
2. Basis of preparation
General
In accordance with the exemption permitted under section 408 of the Companies Act 2006, the separate income statement
of BOGG is not presented as part of these financial statements. BOGG’s income for the year is disclosed within the separate
statement of financial position and the separate statement of changes in equity.
The financial statements of Bank of Georgia Group PLC are prepared in accordance with international accounting standards
in conformity with the requirements of the Companies Act 2006 and prepared in accordance with UK-adopted international
accounting standards as at 31 December 2023.
These financial statements are prepared under the historical cost convention except for:
the measurement at fair value of financial assets and investment securities, derivative financial assets and liabilities and
investment properties;
the measurement of inventories at lower of cost and net realisable value; and
the measurement of non-current assets classified as held for sale at lower of cost and fair value less costs to sell.
The financial statements are presented in thousands of Georgian Lari (GEL), except per-share amounts and unless
otherwise indicated.
Going concern
In adopting the going concern basis for preparing the consolidated financial statements, the Directors have considered the Groups
business activities, objectives and strategy, principal risks and uncertainties in achieving its objectives, and performance. The
Directors have performed a robust assessment of the Groups financial forecasts across a range of scenarios over 12 months from
the date the financial statements are authorised for issue, by carrying out stress testing, incorporating extreme downside scenario
and reverse stress testing, which involved examining the level of disruption that may cause the Group to fail. Based on this, the
Directors confirm that they have a reasonable expectation that the Company and the Group, as a whole, have adequate resources
to continue in operational existence for the 12-months from the date the financial statements are authorised for issue. Furthermore,
management is not aware of any material uncertainties that may cast significant doubt upon the Group’s ability to continue as a
going concern for the foreseeable future. Therefore, the financial statements continue to be prepared on the going concern basis.
Impact of climate-related risks on the Groups financial position and performance
As described in Note 30 to the financial statements, the Group has identified Climate Risk as an emerging risk. However, qualitative
analysis of the impact of climate change and low-carbon transitions on traditional banking risk and on the sectors in which our
clients are active lead us to believe that there is currently no material short (less than 2 years) to medium (2 to 5 years) term impact
of climate change expected. The Group continues to refine its assessment of such risks and will reassess whether the impact of
climate-related risks on its financial position and performance need to be considered in future reporting periods.
273
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
2. Basis of preparation continued
Subsidiaries and associates
The consolidated financial statements as at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021 include the following
subsidiaries and associates:
Proportion of voting rights and
ordinary share capital held
31 December 31 December 31 December Country of Date of Date of
Subsidiaries 2023 2022 2021
incorporation
Address
Industry
incorporation acquisition
BGEO Group Limited
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
United
29 Farm Street, Holding
14/10/2011
Kingdom London, W1J 5RL Company
JSC BGEO Group
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
29a Gagarini
Investment
28/5/2015
Street, Tbilisi, 0105
Þ JSC Idea
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
3 Pushkin Street,
Insurance
26/12/2018
Tbilisi, 0105
Þ JSC Bank of
99.56%
99.55%
99.55%
Georgia
29a Gagarini
Banking
21/10/1994
Georgia Street, Tbilisi, 0105
Þ Bank of Georgia
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
United
29 Farm Street, Information
17/8/2010
Representative Kingdom London, W1J 5RL sharing and
Office UK market research
Limited
Þ Tree of Life
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
3 Pushkin Street,
Charitable
25/8/2008
Foundation Tbilisi 0105 activities
NPO (formerly
known as Bank of
Georgia Future
Foundation,
NPO)
Þ Bank of Georgia
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Hungary
1054
Budapest,
Representative
18/6/2012
Representative Szabadság tér 7; office
Office Hungary Bank Center
Þ
Representative
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Turkey
Süleyman Seba
Representative
25/12/2013
Office of JSC Caddesi No:48 office
Bank of Georgia A Blok Daire 82
in Turkey Akaretler Beşiktaş
34357
Istanbul
Þ
Georgia Financial
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Israel
7 Menahem Begin,
Information
9/2/2009
Investments, LLC Ramat Gan 52681 sharing and
market research
Þ
Benderlock
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Cyprus
Arch. Makariou III
Investments
12/5/2009
13/10/2009
Investments 58, IRIS TOWER,
Limited 8th floor, Flat/
Office 702 P.C.
1075,
Nicosia
Þ JSC Belarusky
99.98%
99.98%
99.98%
Belarus
Nezavisimosty
Banking
16/4/1992
3/6/2008
Narodny Bank Avenue 87A, Minsk,
220012
Þ
BNB Leasing,
99.90%
99.90%
99.90%
Belarus
Nezavisimosty
Leasing
30/3/2006
3/6/2008
LLC Avenue 87A, room
3, Minsk, 220012
Þ
Georgian Leasing
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
3-5 Kazbegi
Leasing
29/10/2001
31/12/2004
Company, LLC Street,Tbilisi
Þ
Prime Leasing
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
Didube-Chughureti
Leasing
27/1/2012
21/1/2015
district, Ak. Tsereteli
Avenue №114, Tbilisi
Þ JSC BG Financial
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
79 David
Investment
7/8/2015
Agmashenebeli
Avenue, 0102,
Tbilisi
Þ JSC Galt &
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
79 David
Brokerage
19/12/1995
28/12/2004
Taggart Agmashenebeli and asset
Avenue, 0102,
Tbilisi
management
Þ
Branch
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Azerbaijan
1C Mikayil Mushvig,
Representative
28/12/2013
Office of ‘BG Kempinski Hotel office
Kapital’ JSC Badamdar, 6th
in Azerbaijan floor, Yasamal.
AZ1006,
Baku
Galt and
Þ
100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
Georgia
Krtsanisi district,
Representative
22/9/2023
Taggart SPV Pushkin street N3, office
2 LLC* Tbilisi
Galt and
Þ
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Cyprus
Arch. Makariou III
Investments
3/7/2006
Taggart 58, IRIS TOWER,
Holdings 8th floor, Flat/
Limited Office 702 P.C.
1075,
Nicosia
Þ
BG Capital
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Belarus
5A-3Н, K.Chornogo
Brokerage
19/2/2008
(Belarus), lane, Minsk, 220012
LLC
274
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
Proportion of voting rights and
ordinary share capital held
31 December 31 December 31 December Country of Date of Date of
Subsidiaries 2023 2022 2021
incorporation
Address
Industry
incorporation acquisition
Þ JSC Digital Area
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
79 David
Digital
8/6/2018
(former JSC Agmashenebeli
Polymath Group)
Avenue, 0102,
Tbilisi
Þ JSC Extra area
100.00%
99.34%
98.68%
Georgia
79 David
Digital
22/5/2019
Agmashenebeli
Avenue, 0102,
Tbilisi
Þ
Easy Box LLC
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
41, Pekini Street,
Transportation
22/12/2020
Tbilisi
Þ JSC Optimo
100.00%
100.00%
0.00%
Georgia
41, Pekini Street,
Digital
8/11/2022
Global Tbilisi
Þ
OPTIMO, FE
100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
Uzbekistan
Mirabadski District,
Digital
31/8/2023
LLC** 81-38, Tashkent
Þ JSC Delivery***
81.38%
25.75%
0.00%
Georgia
6 A. Andronikashvili
Digital
14/12/2017
8/11/2022
Street II Dead End,
Tbilisi
Þ
El. Biletebi
83.34%
0.00%
0.00%
Georgia
Aleksandre Kazbegi,
Digital
11/12/2008
29/9/2023
LLC**** N29, apartment N6,
Tbilisi
Þ Ticketing Area
100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
Georgia
41, Pekini Street,
Digital
6/7/2023
LLC***** Tbilisi
Þ
Solo, LLC
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
79 David
Trade
22/4/2015
Agmashenebeli
Avenue, 0102,
Tbilisi
Þ JSC United
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
74a Chavchavadze
Registrar
29/5/2006
Securities Registrar Avenue, Tbilisi, 0162
of Georgia
Þ JSC Express
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
1b, Budapest
Investments
29/10/2007
Technologies Street, Tbilisi, 0160
Þ JSC Georgian
99.41%
99.41%
99.41%
Georgia
221
Nutsubidze
Card processing
17/1/1997
20/10/2004
Card Street, Tbilisi, 0168
Direct Debit
Þ
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
Luxemburg 25,
Electronic
7/3/2006
Georgia, LLC Tbilisi, 0160 payment
services
Þ LLC Didi Digomi
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
80-82,
Communication
23/4/2007
Research Center D.Agmashenebeli services
Street, Tbilisi, 0102
Þ Metro Service +,
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
74a Chavchavadze
Business
10/5/2006
LLC Avenue, Tbilisi, 0162 servicing
Premium Compliance
100.00%
100.00%
100.00%
Georgia
Kazbegi Street 3-5,
Various
17/2/2012
Advisory, LLC Tbilisi
Proportion of voting rights and ordinary share
capital held
31 December 31 December 31 December Country of Date of Date of
Associates 2023 2022 2021
incorporation
Address
Industry
incorporation acquisition
JSC Credit info
21.08%
21.08%
21.08%
Georgia
2 Tarkhnishvili
Financial
14/2/2005
14/2/2005
Street, Tbilisi intermediation
JSC Tbilisi Stock
24.04%
24.04%
24.04%
Georgia
72 Vazha-Pshavela
Financial
8/5/2015
23/12/2016
Exchange Avenue, Tbilisi intermediation
* JSC BG Financial established a new company – LLC Galt and Taggart SPV 2 on 22 September 2023 and has increased its capital by GEL 304,900.
** OPTIMO, FE LLC was established on 31 August 2023, in the Republic of Uzbekistan. Authorised capital amounts to 1,224,150,000 UZS, which is equivalent to 264,874 GEL.
*** JSC Digital Area invested US$ 1,108,535 in JSC Delivery in 2023 and owns an 81.38% stake.
**** JSC Digital Area bought 83.34% worth of shares in El. Biletebi LLC in 2023 and total investment amounts to GEL 1,200,000.
***** JSC Digital Area established a new company, LLC Ticketing Area, on 6 July 2023 and has increased its capital by GEL 1,000,000.
2. Basis of preparation continued
275
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
3. Summary of significant accounting policies
Basis of consolidation
The Consolidated Financial Statements comprise the financial statements of the Group and its subsidiaries as at 31 December 2023.
The Group consolidates a subsidiary when it controls it. Control is achieved when the Group is exposed, or has rights, to variable
returns from its involvement with the investee and has the ability to affect those returns through its power over the investee.
Specifically, the Group controls an investee if and only if the Group has:
power over the investee (i.e. existing rights that give it the current ability to direct the relevant activities of the investee);
exposure, or rights, to variable returns from its involvement with the investee; and
the ability to use its power over the investee to affect its returns.
Consolidation of a subsidiary begins when the Group obtains control over the subsidiary and ceases when the Group loses control
of the subsidiary. Income and expenses of a subsidiary acquired or disposed of during the year are included in the statement of
comprehensive income from the date the Group gains control until the date the Group ceases to control the subsidiary.
Profit or loss and each component of other comprehensive income are attributed to the equity holders of the parent of the Group
and to the non-controlling interests, even if this results in the non-controlling interests having a deficit balance. When necessary,
adjustments are made to the financial statements of subsidiaries to bring their accounting policies into line with the Group’s
accounting policies. All intra-group assets and liabilities, equity, income, expenses and cash flows relating to transactions between
members of the Group are eliminated in full on consolidation.
A change in the ownership interest of a subsidiary, without a loss of control, is accounted for as an equity transaction.
Business combinations and goodwill
For each business combination, the Group elects whether to measure the non-controlling interests in the acquiree at fair value or at
the proportionate share of the acquirees identifiable net assets. Acquisition-related costs are expensed as incurred and included in
administrative expenses.
Investments in associates
Associates are entities in which the Group generally has between 20% and 50% of the voting rights, or is otherwise able to exercise
significant influence over, but which it does not control or jointly control. Investments in associates are accounted for under the
equity method and are initially recognised at cost, including goodwill. Subsequent changes in the carrying value reflect the
post-acquisition changes in the Group’s share of net assets of the associate. The Group’s share of its associates’ profits or losses
is recognised in the consolidated income statement, and its share of movements in reserves is recognised in other comprehensive
income. However, when the Groups share of losses in an associate equals or exceeds its interest in the associate, the Group does
not recognise further losses, unless the Group is obliged to make further payments to, or on behalf of, the associate.
Common control transactions
The Group generally accounts for common control transaction at cost. Those transactions involving the acquisition of investment in
a subsidiary, associate or joint venture are accounted at the fair value of the consideration given. When the purchase consideration
does not correspond to the fair value of the investment acquired the investment is accounted at fair value with the corresponding
effect recognised in the acquirer’s standalone income statement.
Accounting for common control transactions has no effect on the Group’s consolidated financial statements.
Investments in subsidiaries and associates in parent company financial statements
For the purposes of parent company financial statements, investments in subsidiaries and associates are accounted at cost less
any impairment. Dividends from a subsidiary or an associate are recognised in the parent company financial statements when the
parent’s right to receive the dividend is established.
Fair value measurement
The Group measures financial instruments, such as trading and investment securities, certain loans to customers, derivatives and
non-financial assets such as investment properties, at fair value at each balance sheet date. Also, fair values of financial instruments
measured at amortised cost are disclosed in Note 31.
The Group uses valuation techniques that are appropriate in the circumstances and for which sufficient data is available to measure
fair value, maximising the use of relevant observable inputs and minimising the use of unobservable inputs.
All assets and liabilities for which fair value is measured or disclosed in the financial statements are categorised within the fair value
hierarchy, described as follows, based on the lowest level input that is significant to the fair value measurement as a whole:
Level 1 − Quoted (unadjusted) market prices in active markets for identical assets or liabilities.
Level 2 − Valuation techniques for which the lowest level input that is significant to the fair value measurement is directly or
indirectly observable.
Level 3 − Valuation techniques for which the lowest level input that is significant to the fair value measurement is unobservable.
For assets and liabilities that are recognised in the financial statements on a recurring basis, the Group determines whether
transfers have occurred between levels in the hierarchy by reassessing categorisation (based on the lowest level input that is
significant to the fair value measurement as a whole) at the end of each reporting period.
276
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
Financial assets and liabilities
Classification and measurement for financial assets and liabilities
The Group classifies all of its financial assets based on the business model for managing the assets and the asset’s contractual
terms, measured at either:
fair value through profit or loss (FVTPL);
fair value through other comprehensive income (FVOCI) with recycling to profit or loss upon disposal for debt instruments;
FVOCI without recycling to profit or loss for equity instruments; or
amortised cost.
Financial liabilities, other than loan commitments and financial guarantees, are measured at amortised cost or at FVTPL if they are
held for trading.
Embedded derivatives are not separated from a host financial asset. Instead, financial assets are classified based on the business
model and their contractual terms.
All derivative instruments are measured at FVTPL.
Measurement of financial instruments at initial recognition
When financial instruments are recognised initially, they are measured at fair value, adjusted, in the case of instruments not at
FVTPL, for directly attributable fees and costs.
The best evidence of the fair value of a financial instrument at initial recognition is normally the transaction price. If the Group
determines that the fair value at initial recognition differs from the transaction price, then:
if the fair value is evidenced by a quoted price in an active market for an identical asset or liability (i.e., a Level 1 input) or based on
a valuation technique that uses only data from observable markets, the Group recognises the difference between the fair value at
initial recognition and the transaction price as a gain or loss;
in all other cases, the initial measurement of the financial instrument is adjusted to defer the difference between the fair value at
initial recognition and the transaction price. After initial recognition, the Group recognises that deferred difference as a gain or
loss only to the extent that it arises from a change in a factor (including time) that market participants would take into account
when pricing the asset or liability.
Subsequent measurement of financial instruments
Financial instruments measured at amortised cost
The Group measures amounts due from credit institutions, loans to customers and other financial assets at amortised cost if both
of the following conditions are met:
The financial asset is held within a business model with the objective to hold financial assets in order to collect contractual
cash flows.
The contractual terms of the financial asset give rise on specified dates to cash flows that are solely payments of principal and
interest (SPPI) on the principal amount outstanding.
The details of these conditions are outlined below.
Business model
The Group determines its business model at the level that best reflects how it manages groups of financial assets to achieve its
business objective. The business model is not assessed on an instrument-by-instrument basis, but at a higher level of aggregated
portfolios per instrument type and is based on the following observable factors:
The risks that affect the performance of the business model (and the financial assets held within that business model) and, in
particular, the way those risks are managed.
How managers of the business are compensated (for example, whether the compensation is based on the fair value of the assets
managed or on the contractual cash flows collected).
How financial assets held within particular business model are evaluated and reported to key management personnel.
The expected frequency, value and timing of sales are also important aspects of the assessment. The business model assessment
is based on reasonably expected scenarios without taking ‘worst case’ or ‘stress case’ scenarios into account. If cash flows after
initial recognition are realised in a way that is different from the Group’s original expectations, the Group does not change the
classification of the remaining financial assets held in that business model, but incorporates such information when assessing
newly originated or newly purchased financial assets going forward.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
277
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
There are three business models available under IFRS 9:
Hold to collect: It is intended to hold the asset to maturity to earn interest, collecting repayments of principal and interest form
the counterparty.
Hold to collect and sell: This model is similar to the hold to collect model, except that the entity may elect to sell some or all of the
assets before maturity as circumstances change or to hold the assets for liquidity purposes.
Other: All those models that do not meet the ‘hold to collect’ or ‘hold to collect and sell’ qualifying criteria.
Solely Payments of Principal and Interest (SPPI)
If a financial asset is held in either a ‘hold to collect’ or a ‘hold to collect and sell’ business model, then the Group assesses whether
contractual cash flows are SPPI on the principal amount outstanding at initial recognition to determine the classification. The SPPI
test is performed on an individual instrument basis.
Contractual cash flows that represent SPPI on the principal amount outstanding are consistent with basic lending arrangements.
Interest is consideration for the time value of money and the credit risk associated with the principal amount outstanding
during a particular period of time. It can also include consideration for other basic lending risks (e.g. liquidity risk) and costs
(e.g. administrative costs) associated with holding the financial asset for a particular period of time, and a profit margin that is
consistent with a basic lending arrangement.
In assessing whether the contractual cash flows are SPPI, the Group considers whether the contractual terms of the financial asset
contain a term that could change the timing or amount of contractual cash flows arising over the life of the instrument which could
affect whether the instrument is considered to meet the SPPI test.
If the SPPI test is failed, such financial assets are measured at FVTPL with interest earned recognised in other interest income.
Debt instruments at FVOCI
The Group measures debt investment securities at FVOCI when both of the following categories are met:
The instrument is held within a business model, the objective of which is achieved by collecting contractual cash flows, selling
financial assets and holding such financial instruments for liquidity management purposes.
The contractual terms of the financial asset meet the SPPI test.
FVOCI debt investment securities are subsequently measured at fair value with gains and losses arising due to changes in fair
value recognised in OCI. Interest income and foreign exchange gains and losses are recognised in profit or loss in the same manner
as for financial assets measured at amortised cost. On derecognition, cumulative gains or losses previously recognised in OCI are
reclassified from OCI to profit or loss.
Equity instruments at FVOCI – option
Upon initial recognition, the Group may elect to classify irrevocably its equity instruments as equity instruments at FVOCI when they
meet the definition of equity under IAS 32
Financial Instruments: Presentation
and are not held for trading. Such classification is
determined on an instrument-by-instrument basis.
The Group does not recycle gains and losses on these equity instruments to profit or loss nor does it make impairment assessment
for these instruments. Dividends received are recognised in profit or loss.
Financial assets at FVTPL
Groups of financial assets for which the business model is other than ‘hold to collect’ and ‘hold to collect and sell’ are measured
at FVTPL.
Derivatives recorded at FVTPL
The Group enters into derivative transactions with various counterparties. These include interest rate swaps, forwards and other
similar instruments. Derivatives are recorded at fair value and carried as assets when their fair value is positive and as liabilities
when their fair value is negative. Net changes in the fair value of derivatives are included in Net other gains/(losses), excluding gain/
loss on foreign exchange derivatives which are presented in net foreign currency gain. From the beginning of 2019, the Group enters
into certain cross-currency swap agreements to match its funding costs in certain currencies with the income generated from
lending activities in these currencies. As a result, the Group economically hedges the interest rate risk, however, no hedge accounting
under IFRS 9 is applied. Net changes in the fair value of such derivative financial instruments, which are presented in net foreign
currency gain, excludes unwinding of the locked-in interest differential which is presented as part of interest expense to reflect risk
management objective of the Group.
Financial guarantees, letter of credits and other financial commitments
The Group enters into the financial guarantee contracts whereby it is required to make specified payments to reimburse the holder
for a loss it incurs because a specified debtor fails to make payment when due. Financial guarantees, letter of credits and other
financial commitments are initially recognised in the financial statements at fair value, being the premium received. Subsequent
to initial recognition, the Groups liability under each guarantee is measured at the higher of the amount initially recognised, less
cumulative amortisation recognised in the consolidated income statement and an expected credit loss (ECL) provision.
278
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
Non-financial guarantees
The Group enters into non-financial guarantee contracts whereby it is required to compensate to the holder in case another party
fails to meet its contractual obligations. Non-financial guarantees are initially recognised in the financial statements at fair value,
being the premium received, amortised on a straight-line basis over the life of the contract. Subsequent to initial recognition the
Groups liability under non-financial guarantee is measured at the amount that represents the best estimate of the expenditure
required to settle the present obligation. The estimate takes into account the probability of another party defaulting on its
obligations as well as available collateral under the guarantee contracts and is recognised in the consolidated income statement as
part of other expected credit.
Cash and cash equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents consist of cash on hand, amounts due from central banks, excluding obligatory reserves with central
banks, and amounts due from credit institutions that mature within 90 days of the date of origination, and are free from
contractual encumbrances and readily convertible to known amounts of cash. The Group also holds cash in nominal ownership
on behalf of its clients. The Group does not control this cash nor does it have the potential to produce economic benefits to the
Group, therefore asset recognition criteria is not met in such cases. Respectively, the Group does not recognise these amounts in its
consolidated statement of financial position.
Borrowings
The Group classifies issued financial instruments or their components as liabilities, where the substance of the contractual
arrangement results in the Group having an obligation either to deliver cash or another financial asset to the holder, or to satisfy
the obligation other than by the exchange of a fixed amount of cash or another financial asset for a fixed number of own equity
instruments. Such instruments include amounts due to credit institutions and amounts due to customers (including promissory
notes issued). The Group initially recognises these liabilities at the fair value of the consideration received less directly attributable
transaction costs. After initial recognition, borrowings are subsequently measured at amortised cost, using the effective interest
rate (EIR) method. Gains and losses are recognised in the consolidated income statement when the borrowings are derecognised as
well as through the amortisation process.
Issued Additional Tier 1 instruments with perpetual maturity and discretionary interest payments are classified as financial liabilities
when the instruments are not convertible into equity and the Group does not have an unconditional right to avoid delivering cash upon
a predetermined trigger event that is beyond the control of both the issuer and the holder of the instrument. Such instruments are
measured at amortised cost with respective interest presented as part of interest expense in the consolidated income statement.
If the Group purchases its own debt, it is removed from the statement of financial position and the difference between the carrying
amount of the liability and the consideration paid is recognised in the consolidated income statement.
Subordinated debt
Subordinated debt represents long-term funds attracted by the Bank on the international financial markets or domestic market.
The holders of subordinated debt would be subordinate to all other creditors to receive repayment of debt in case of the Bank’s
liquidation. Subordinated debt is carried at amortised cost.
Leases
The Group as a lessee
The Groups main leasing activities include the leases of service centres, ATM spaces and warehouses. A non-cancellable lease period
is up to ten years. Lease payments are fixed in most cases. The contracts do not generally carry extension or termination options for
the lease term and do not impose any covenants.
Recognition of right-of-use asset and lease liability
The Group recognises a right-of-use asset and a lease liability at the lease commencement date at an initial amount of the lease
liability adjusted for lease payments made at or before the commencement date. The right-of-use asset is subsequently depreciated
using the straight-line method over the lease term.
The lease liability is initially measured at the present value of the future lease payments excluding payments for VAT, discounted
using the Groups incremental borrowing rate (IBR). The lease liability is subsequently measured at amortised cost using the IBR.
Recognition exemptions
The Group applies the recognition exemptions on lease contracts for which the lease term ends within 12 months as of the date
of initial application, and lease contracts for which the underlying asset is of low value. The Group recognises the lease payments
associated with these leases as an occupancy and rent expense on a straight-line basis over the lease term and presents them as
part of General and administrative expenses.
Modifications of lease contracts
If the lease contract is modified by either changing the scope of the lease, or the consideration for a lease that was not part of the
original terms and conditions of the lease, the Group determines whether the modification results in:
a separate lease; or
a change in the accounting for the existing lease.
For the lease modifications that are not accounted as separate leases, the Group re-measures the lease liability either by recognising
gain or loss relating to the partial or full termination of the lease or through adjusting respective right-of-use asset.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
279
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
The Group as a lessor
At the inception of the lease, the Group classifies each of its leases as either an operating lease or a finance lease.
Finance lease
The Group classifies leases that transfer substantially all the risks and benefits incidental to ownership of the lease item to the
lessee as finance leases. All other leases are classified as operating leases. The Group recognises finance lease receivables in
the Consolidated Statement of Financial Position at a value equal to the net investment in the lease, starting from the date of
commencement of the lease term. In calculating the present value of the minimum lease payments, the Group uses the interest rate
implicit in the lease as a discount factor. Initial direct costs are included in the initial measurement of the finance lease receivables.
Lease payments received are apportioned between the finance income and the reduction of the outstanding lease receivable.
Finance income is based on a pattern reflecting a constant periodic rate of return on the net investment outstanding.
Operating lease
The Group presents assets subject to operating leases in the consolidated statement of financial position according to the nature of
the asset. Lease income from operating leases is recognised in the consolidated income statement on a straight-line basis over the
lease term as net other income.
Impairment of financial assets
Overview of the ECL principles
The Group records an allowance for ECL for all loans and other debt financial assets not held at FVTPL, together with loan
commitments and financial guarantee contracts, in this section all referred to as ‘financial assets’.
The allowance is based on the ECL associated with a probability of default (PD) in the next 12 months unless there has been a
significant increase in credit risk since origination, in which case the allowance is based on the ECL over the life of the asset (lifetime
ECL). If the financial asset meets the definition of purchased or originated credit-impaired (POCI), the allowance is based on the
change in the lifetime ECL.
The Group applies the simplified approach for trade, lease and other receivables and contract assets and records lifetime ECLs
on them.
In order to calculate ECL, the Group first evaluates whether objective evidence of impairment exists for loans that are individually
significant. It then collectively assesses loans that are not individually significant and loans which are significant but for which there
is no objective evidence of impairment available under the individual assessment.
Staged approach to the determination of ECLs
The Group has established a policy to perform an assessment, at the end of each reporting period, of whether a financial asset’s
credit risk has increased significantly since initial recognition, by considering the change in the risk of default occurring over the
remaining life of the financial instrument. Based on the above process, the Group groups its financial instruments into Stage 1,
Stage 2, Stage 3 and POCI, as described below:
Stage 1: The Group recognises a credit loss allowance at an amount equal to 12-month ECL. This represents the portion of
lifetime ECL from default events that are expected within 12 months of the reporting date, assuming that credit risk has not
increased significantly after initial recognition. For those financial assets with a remaining maturity of less than 12 months, a PD
is used that corresponds to the remaining maturity.
Stage 2: The Group recognises a credit loss allowance at an amount equal to lifetime expected credit losses (LTECL) for
those financial instruments which are considered to have experienced a significant increase in credit risk since initial recognition.
This requires the computation of ECL based on lifetime probability of default (LTPD) that represents the PD occurring over
the remaining lifetime of the financial instrument. Allowance for credit losses are higher in this stage because of an increase in
credit risk and the impact of a longer time horizon being considered compared with 12 months in Stage 1. Financial instruments
in Stage 2 are not yet deemed to be credit-impaired.
Stage 3: If the financial instrument is credit-impaired, it is then moved to Stage 3. The Group recognises a loss allowance at an
amount equal to lifetime ECL, reflecting a PD of 100% for those financial instruments that are credit-impaired.
Unless POCI, newly originated assets are classified as Stage 1 and remain in that stage unless there is considered to have been a
significant increase in credit risk since initial recognition, at which point the asset is reclassified to Stage 2.
POCI assets are financial instruments that are credit-impaired on initial recognition. POCI assets are recorded at fair value at
original recognition and interest income is subsequently recognised based on a credit adjusted EIR (CAEIR). CAEIR takes into
account all contractual terms of the financial asset and ECLs. ECLs are only recognised or released to the extent that there is a
subsequent change in the ECLs where ECLs are calculated based on lifetime ECL. Once the financial asset is recognised as POCI,
it retains this status until derecognised.
Key judgements and estimates used in ECL calculation are disclosed in Note 4.
280
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
Derecognition of financial assets and liabilities
Derecognition of financial assets
The Group derecognises a financial asset (or, where applicable, a part of a financial asset or part of a group of similar financial
assets) where:
the rights to receive cash flows from the asset have expired; or
the Group has transferred its rights to receive cash flows from the asset, or retained the right to receive cash flows from
the asset, but has assumed an obligation to pay them in full without material delay to a third party under a ‘pass-through’
arrangement; and
the Group either (a) has transferred substantially all the risks and rewards of the asset, or (b) has neither transferred nor
retained substantially all the risks and rewards of the asset, but has transferred control of the asset.
Derecognition and modification of financial assets
The Group sometimes renegotiates or otherwise modifies the contractual cash flows of financial assets. When this happens,
the Group assesses whether or not the new terms are substantially different to the original terms, based on qualitative and
quantitative criteria. The Group derecognises a financial asset, such as a loan to a customer, when the terms and conditions have
been renegotiated to the extent that, substantially, it becomes a new loan, except in cases when renegotiation of contractual
terms happens due to financial difficulties of the borrower. Once the financial asset is derecognised, the difference is recognised as
a derecognition gain or loss, to the extent that an impairment loss has not already been recorded. The newly recognised loans are
classified as Stage 1 for ECL measurement purposes, unless the new loan is deemed to be POCI.
The Group applies derecognition of the financial asset if any of the following criteria are met:
Change in currency of the loan.
Change in interest rate type.
Introduction of an equity feature.
Change in counterparty.
If the terms are not substantially different, or the renegotiation is due to the financial difficulties of the borrower, such renegotiation
or modification does not result in derecognition, and the Group recalculates the gross carrying amount based on the revised
cash flows of the financial asset and recognises a modification gain or loss in interest income. The new gross carrying amount is
calculated by discounting the modified cash flows at the original EIR.
Forbearance and modified loans
The Group sometimes makes concessions or modifications to the original terms of the loans as a response to the borrower’s
financial difficulties, rather than taking possession or otherwise enforcing collection of collateral. The Group considers a loan
forborne when such concessions or modifications are provided as a result of the borrowers present or expected financial difficulties
and the Group would not have agreed to them if the borrower had been financially healthy. Forbearance may involve extending
the payment arrangements and the agreement of new loan conditions. Once the terms have been renegotiated, any impairment
is measured using the original EIR as calculated before the modification of terms. Once the asset has been identified as forborne,
the assets are classified in Stage 3. The decision as to how long the asset remains in the forborne category is determined on a
case-by-case basis for commercial and SME loans, when a minimum six consecutive payments are required for the rest of the loans
to exit from the forbearance category and transfer to Stage 2. Once the loan is transferred to Stage 2, the Group continues to
reassess whether there has been a significant increase in credit risk, however, such assets remain in Stage 2 for a minimum 12-month
probation period before being transferred to Stage 1.
Derecognition of financial liabilities
The Group derecognises a financial liability when the obligation under the liability is discharged, cancelled or expires.
Where an existing financial liability is replaced by another from the same lender on substantially different terms, or the terms
of an existing liability are substantially modified, such an exchange or modification is treated as a derecognition of the original
liability and the recognition of a new liability, and the difference in the respective carrying amounts is recognised in the consolidated
income statement.
Foreclosed assets
All repossessed land and buildings were previously classified as Investment Properties at initial recognition given these assets were
managed with a view of capital appreciation or earning a rental income. Commencing from 2022, the Group updated its property
management strategy and decided to move the majority of the realisations of such properties at a quicker pace. Respectively,
all repossessed collaterals, including land and buildings, are now classified either as Investment Properties or Foreclosed Assets
depending the Groups intention in respect of recovery of these assets.
Foreclosed assets are valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value.
The majority of the Group’s foreclosed assets consists of the real estate assets repossessed during recovery of defaulted loans. Such
assets are specific and not ordinarily interchangeable, respectively the Group applies specific identification of their individual costs.
Realisation gain/loss from above assets are included under Net other gains/(losses) in the Groups consolidated income statement.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
281
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
Non-current assets held for sale
The Group classifies non-current assets and disposal groups as held for sale if their carrying amounts will be recovered principally
through a sale transaction rather than through continuing use. Non-current assets and disposal groups classified as held for sale are
measured at the lower of their carrying amount and fair value less costs to sell.
Assets and liabilities classified as held for sale are presented separately from other assets and liabilities in the statement of
financial position.
Taxation
The Group calculates the current income tax expense in accordance with the regulations in force in the respective territories in which
BOGG and its subsidiaries operate.
Deferred tax assets and liabilities are calculated in respect of temporary differences using the liability method. Deferred income
taxes are provided for all temporary differences arising between the tax bases of assets and liabilities and their carrying values for
financial reporting purposes.
The Group recognises a deferred tax asset only to the extent that it is probable that taxable profit will be available against which
the deductible temporary differences can be utilised. Deferred tax assets and liabilities are measured at tax rates that are expected
to apply to the period when the asset is realised or the liability is settled, based on tax rates that have been enacted or substantively
enacted at the reporting date.
Deferred tax liabilities are provided on temporary differences arising on investments in subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures,
except where the timing of the reversal of the temporary difference can be controlled and it is probable that the temporary
difference will not reverse in the foreseeable future.
Georgia and Belarus also have various operating taxes that are assessed on the Groups activities. These taxes are included as a
component of other operating expenses.
Uncertain tax positions
The Group reassesses uncertain tax positions at the end of each reporting period. The assessment is based on the interpretation of
the tax laws that have been enacted or substantively enacted by the end of reporting period and any known court or other rulings
on such issues. Liabilities are recorded for income tax positions that are determined as more likely than not to result in additional tax
levied if the positions were to be challenged by the tax authorities. Liabilities for penalties, interest and taxes other than on income
are recognised based on the best estimate of the expenditure required to settle the obligations at the end of the reporting period.
Investment properties
The Group recognises investment property initially at cost, including transaction costs, and subsequently remeasured at fair value
reflecting market conditions at the end of the reporting period. Fair value of the Groups investment property is determined on the
basis of various sources including reports of independent appraisers, who hold a recognised and relevant professional qualification
and who have recent experience in valuation of property of similar location and category.
Gains and losses resulting from changes in the fair value of investment property as well as earned rental income are recorded in the
income statement within net other income.
Property and equipment
The Group records property and equipment at cost less accumulated depreciation and any accumulated impairment in value.
Depreciation of an asset commences from the date the asset is ready and available for use. Depreciation is calculated on a straight-
line basis over the following estimated useful lives:
Years
Office buildings and service centres
Up to 100
Furniture and fixtures
3-20
Computers and equipment
5-10
Motor vehicles
2-7
The assets’ residual values, useful lives and methods are reviewed, and adjusted as appropriate, at each financial year-end.
Assets under construction are stated at cost and are not depreciated until the time they are available for use and reclassified to
their respective group of property and equipment.
Leasehold improvements are depreciated over the shorter life of the related leased asset and the expected lease term.
Costs related to repairs and renewals are charged when incurred and included in other operating expenses, unless they qualify for
capitalisation.
Goodwill impairment
Goodwill is reviewed for impairment annually, or more frequently if events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying
amount may be impaired.
282
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
For the purpose of impairment testing, goodwill acquired in a business combination is, from the acquisition date, allocated to each
of the Group’s cash-generating units, or groups of cash-generating units, that are expected to benefit from the synergies of the
combination, irrespective of whether other assets or liabilities of the Group are assigned to those units or groups of units. Each unit
or group of units to which the goodwill is so allocated:
represents the lowest level within the Group at which the goodwill is monitored for internal management purposes; and
is not larger than a segment as defined in IFRS 8 Operating Segments.
Impairment is determined by assessing the recoverable amount of the cash-generating unit (or group of cash-generating units), to
which the goodwill relates. Where the recoverable amount of the cash-generating unit (or group of cash-generating units) is less
than the carrying amount, an impairment loss is recognised. Impairment losses cannot be reversed in future periods.
Intangible assets
The Groups intangible assets include computer software and licences.
Intangible assets acquired separately are initially measured at cost and subsequently carried at cost less any accumulated
amortisation and any accumulated impairment losses. The economic lives of intangible assets are assessed to be finite and
amortised over four to 15 years and assessed for impairment whenever there is an indication that the intangible asset may be
impaired. Amortisation periods and methods for intangible assets are reviewed at least at each financial year-end.
Costs associated with maintaining computer software programmes are recorded as an expense as incurred. Software development
costs (relating to the design and testing of new or substantially improved software) are recognised as intangible assets.
Provisions
The Group recognises provisions when it has a present legal or constructive obligation as a result of past events, and it is probable
that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation and a reliable estimate of the
amount of obligation can be made.
Share-based payment transactions
Employees (including senior executives) of the Group receive share-based remuneration, whereby they render services and receive
equity instruments of the Group (‘equity-settled transactions’) as consideration for the services provided.
Equity-settled transactions
The cost of equity-settled transactions with employees is measured by reference to the fair value at the date on which they are
granted. The awards of shares in monetary terms are measured by reference to the monetary value (as awarded) adjusted for the
time value of money where necessary.
The cost of equity-settled transactions is recognised together with the corresponding increase in equity as part of additional paid-
in capital, over the period in which the performance and/or service conditions are fulfilled, ending on the date when the relevant
employee is fully entitled to the award (‘the vesting date’). The subsequent holding period does not imply any employment service
provision from the share recipient side, therefore it does not affect the expense recognition period. The consolidated income
statement charge or credit for the period represents the movement in cumulative expense recognised as at the beginning and end of
that period.
Where the terms of an equity-settled award are modified, the Group recognises the minimum expense as if the terms had not been
modified. An additional expense is recognised for any modification that increases the total fair value of the share-based payment
arrangement, or is otherwise beneficial to the employee as measured at the date of the modification.
Where a new equity-settled award is designated as a replacement of a cancelled equity-settled award, the replacement of equity
instruments are accounted for as a modification.
Where the Group cancels an equity-settled award, it is treated as if it has vested on the date of cancellation, and any expense
not yet recognised for the award is recognised immediately. However, if a new award is substituted for the cancelled award, and
designated as the replacement award on the date that it is granted, the cancelled and the new awards are treated as if they were a
modification of the original award, as described in the previous paragraph.
Equity
Share capital
Ordinary shares are classified as equity. External costs directly attributable to the issue of new shares, other than on a business
combination, are shown as a deduction from the proceeds in equity.
Additional paid-in capital
Any excess of the fair value of consideration received over the par value of shares issued is recognised as additional paid-in capital.
Further, the effects of share-based payments are also recognised as part of the additional paid-in capital.
Treasury shares
Where BOGG or its subsidiaries purchase BOGG’s shares, the consideration paid, including any attributable transaction costs,
net of income taxes, is deducted from total equity as treasury shares until they are cancelled or reissued. Where such shares
are subsequently sold or reissued, any consideration received is included in equity. Treasury shares are stated at par value, with
adjustment of premiums against additional paid-in capital.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
283
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
Dividends
The Group recognises dividends as liabilities and deducts them from equity at the reporting date only if they are declared before
or on the reporting date and do not require further approval. Dividends are disclosed when they are proposed before the reporting
date or proposed or declared after the reporting date but before the consolidated financial statements are authorised for issue. All
expenses associated with dividend distribution are added to the dividend amount and recorded directly through equity.
Contingencies
Contingent liabilities are not recognised in the consolidated statement of financial position but are disclosed, unless the possibility
of any outflow in settlement is remote. A contingent asset is not recognised in the consolidated statement of financial position but
disclosed when an inflow of economic benefits is probable.
Income and expense recognition
Revenue is recognised to the extent that it is probable that the economic benefits will flow to the Group and the revenue can be
reliably measured. The following specific recognition criteria must also be met before revenue and expense are recognised:
Interest and similar income and expense
For all financial instruments measured at amortised cost and interest-bearing securities, interest income or expense is recorded at the EIR.
For financial instruments in Stage 1 and Stage 2, the Group calculates interest income by applying the EIR to the gross carrying
amount. Interest income for financial assets in Stage 3 is calculated by applying the EIR to the amortised cost (i.e. the gross carrying
amount less credit loss allowance). For financial instruments classified as POCI only, interest income is calculated by applying
a credit adjusted EIR to the amortised cost of these POCI assets. The Group presents interest revenue calculated using the EIR
method separately in the income statement.
Fee and commission income
The Group earns fee and commission income from a diverse range of services it provides to its customers. Fee and commission
income are recognised when the Group satisfies a performance obligation. Fee income can be divided into the following categories:
Fee income earned from services that are provided over a certain period of time
The Group recognises fees income for the provision of services over a period of time over that period. These fees include commission
incomes and asset management, custody, package services on bundled products and other management and advisory fees.
Loan commitment fees for loans that are likely to be drawn-down and other credit-related fees are deferred (together with any
incremental costs), and recognised as an adjustment to the EIR on the loan.
Customer loyalty programme
Customer loyalty programme points accumulated in the business are treated as deferred revenue and recognised in revenues
gradually as they are earned. The Group recognises gross revenue earned from customer loyalty programmes when the performance
obligation is satisfied, i.e. when the customer redeems the points.
Performance obligations satisfied at a point in time
Fees and commissions earned from providing transaction-type services such as settlement, brokerage, cash and currency conversion
operations are recognised when the service has been completed, provided such fees and commissions are not subject to refund or
another contingency beyond the control of the Group. Fees from currency conversion operations represent additional commission
(other than currency dealing revenue recognised in net foreign currency gain) charged on currency conversion service provided to
customers on cards used abroad.
Dividend income
Dividend revenue is recognised when the Group’s right to receive the payment is established.
Non-recurring items
The Group separately classifies and discloses those income and expenses that are non-recurring by nature. The Group defines
non-recurring income or expense as an income or expense triggered by, or originated from, an economic, business or financial
event that is not inherent to the regular and ordinary business course of the Group and is caused by uncertain or unpredictable
external factors that cannot be reasonably expected to occur in the future, and thus should not be taken into account when making
projections of future results.
Functional, reporting currencies and foreign currency translation
The consolidated financial statements are presented in Georgian Lari, which is the Group’s presentation currency. BOGG’s and the
Bank’s functional currency is Georgian Lari. Each entity in the Group determines its own functional currency and items included in
the financial statements of each entity are measured using that functional currency.
Transactions in foreign currencies are initially recorded in the functional currency, converted at the rate of exchange ruling at the
date of the transaction. Monetary assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies are retranslated into functional currency
at the functional currency rate of exchange ruling at the reporting date.
Gains and losses resulting from the translation of foreign currency transactions are recognised in the consolidated income
statement as gains less losses from foreign currencies – translation differences. Non-monetary items that are measured in terms of
historical cost in a foreign currency are translated using the exchange rates as at the dates of the initial transactions. Non-monetary
items measured at fair value in a foreign currency are translated using the exchange rates at the date when the fair value was
determined. When a gain or loss on a non-monetary item is recognised in other comprehensive income, any exchange component of
that gain or loss is recognised in other comprehensive income. Conversely, when a gain or loss on a non-monetary item is recognised
in profit or loss, any exchange component of that gain or loss is recognised in the income statement.
284
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
Differences between the contractual exchange rate of a certain transaction and the NBG exchange rate on the date of the
transaction are included in gains less losses from foreign currencies (dealing). The official NBG exchange rates at 31 December 2023,
31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021 were:
Lari to GBP
Lari to US$
Lari to EUR
Lari to BYN
31 December 2023
3.4228
2.6894
2.9753
0.8162
31 December 2022
3.2581
2.702
2.8844
1.073
31 December 2021
4.1737
3.0976
3.504
1.2101
As at the reporting date, the assets and liabilities of the entities whose functional currency is different from the presentation
currency of the Group are translated into Georgian Lari at the rate of exchange ruling at the reporting date and their income
statements are translated at the average exchange rates for the year. The exchange differences arising on the translation are taken
to other comprehensive income.
Any goodwill arising on the acquisition of a foreign operation and any fair value adjustments to the carrying amounts of assets and
liabilities arising on the acquisition are treated as assets and liabilities of the foreign operations, and translated at the rate at the
reporting date.
Adoption of new or revised standards and interpretations
Amendments effective from 1 January 2023
IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts
In May 2017, the IASB issued
IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts
, which sets out the accounting requirements for contractual rights and
obligations that arise from insurance contracts issued and reinsurance contracts held. The Group evaluated whether its contracts
contain insurance risk, focusing on performance guarantees and concluded that there are no material contracts in scope of IFRS
17 considering practical expedients available. The amendment had no material impact on the Groups consolidated financial
statements.
Deferred Tax related to Assets and Liabilities arising from a Single Transaction – Amendments to IAS 12
In May 2021 the Board issued
Amendments to IAS 12, ‘Deferred Tax related to Assets and Liabilities arising from a Single
Transaction’
, that clarify how companies account for deferred tax on transactions such as leases and decommissioning obligations.
The amendments narrowed the scope of the recognition exemption in paragraphs 15 and 24 of IAS 12 so that it no longer applies to
transactions that, on initial recognition, give rise to equal taxable and deductible temporary differences. The amendment had no
material impact on the Groups consolidated financial statements.
Disclosure of Accounting Policies – Amendments to IAS 1 and IFRS Practice Statement
2
. In February 2021, the IASB issued
amendments to
IAS 1
and
IFRS Practice Statement 2 Making Materiality Judgements
, in which it provides guidance and examples to
help entities apply materiality judgements to accounting policy disclosures. The amendments aim to help entities provide accounting
policy disclosures that are more useful by replacing the requirement for entities to disclose their ‘significant’ accounting policies with
a requirement to disclose their ‘material’ accounting policies and adding guidance on how entities apply the concept of materiality in
making decisions about accounting policy disclosures.
The amendment had no material impact on the Group’s consolidated financial statements.
Definition of Accounting Estimates – Amendments to IAS 8.
In February 2021, the IASB issued amendments to IAS 8, in which it
introduces a definition of ‘accounting estimates. The amendments clarify the distinction between changes in accounting estimates
and changes in accounting policies and the correction of errors. Also, they clarify how entities use measurement techniques and
inputs to develop accounting estimates.
The amendment had no material impact on the Group’s consolidated financial statements.
International Tax Reform – Pillar Two Model Rules
– Amendments to IAS 12.
The amendments to IAS 12 have been introduced in
response to the OECD’s BEPS Pillar Two rules and include:
A mandatory temporary exception to the recognition and disclosure of deferred taxes arising from the jurisdictional
implementation of the Pillar Two model rules; and
Disclosure requirements for affected entities to help users of the financial statements better understand an entity’s exposure to
Pillar Two income taxes arising from that legislation, particularly before its effective date.
The mandatory temporary exception – the use of which is required to be disclosed – applies immediately. The remaining disclosure
requirements apply for annual reporting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2023, but not for any interim periods ending on or
before 31 December 2023. The amendments had no impact on the Groups consolidated financial statements.
Reclassifications
To improve the quality and understandability of its consolidated statement of financial position and consolidated statement of cash
flows, the Group has revisited the presentation of foreclosed assets, inventories and other assets. The Group considered it more
appropriate to present foreclosed assets separately from other assets and present inventories within other assets. Comparative
amounts were reclassified in line with the updated presentation.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
285
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
The following reclassifications were made to year ended 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021 consolidated statement
of financial position and consolidated statement of cash flows to conform to the year ended 31 December 2023
presentation requirements:
As previously
Consolidated Statement of Financial Position for the year ended 31 December 2022
reported
Reclassification
As reclassified
Foreclosed Assets
119,924
119,924
Inventories
17,096
(17,096)
Other assets
317,886
(102,828)
215,058
As previously
Consolidated statement of cash flows for the year ended 31 December 2022
reported
Reclassification
As reclassified
Net (increase) decrease in operating assets
Prepayments and other assets
(18,612)
11,700
(6,912)
Foreclosed assets
(11,700)
(11,700)
As previously
Consolidated Statement of Financial Position for the year ended 31 December 2021
reported
Reclassification
As reclassified
Foreclosed Assets
3,216
3,216
Inventory
11,514
(11,514)
Other assets
246,947
8,298
255,245
As previously
Consolidated statement of cash flows for the year ended 31 December 2021
reported
Reclassification
As reclassified
Net (increase) decrease in operating assets
Prepayments and other assets
(25,324)
5,907
(19,417)
Foreclosed assets
(5,907)
(5,907)
Standards issued but not yet effective
The new and amended standards and interpretations that are issued, but not yet effective, up to the date of issuance of the
Groups consolidated financial statements are disclosed below. The Group intends to adopt these new and amended standards and
interpretations, if applicable, when they become effective.
IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements
In January 2020 and July 2020, the IASB issued amendments to IAS 1 ‘Presentation of Financial Statements: Classification of
Liabilities as Current or Non-Current’. They clarify that the classification of liabilities as current or non-current should be based
on rights that are in existence at the end of the reporting period. The amendments also clarify that classification is unaffected by
expectations about whether an entity will exercise its right to defer settlement of a liability and make clear that settlement refers to
the transfer to the counterparty of cash, equity instruments, other assets or services. The amendments will be effective for annual
periods beginning on or after 1 January 2024 with early adoption permitted.
The Group is assessing the potential effect of the amendment on its consolidated financial statements.
Amendments to IFRS 16: Lease Liability in a Sale and Leaseback
In September 2022, the IASB issued amendments to IFRS 16 to specify the requirements that a seller-lessee uses in measuring the
lease liability arising in a sale and leaseback transaction, to ensure the seller-lessee does not recognise any amount of the gain or loss
that relates to the right of use it retains. The amendments are effective for annual reporting periods beginning on or after 1 January
2024 and must be applied retrospectively to sale and leaseback transactions entered into after the date of initial application of
IFRS 16. Earlier application is permitted and that fact must be disclosed.
The Group is assessing the potential effect of the amendment on its consolidated financial statements.
Supplier Finance Arrangements – Amendments to IAS 7 and IFRS 7
In May 2023, the IASB issued amendments to
IAS 7 Statement of Cash Flows
and
IFRS 7 Financial Instruments: Disclosures
to
clarify the characteristics of supplier finance arrangements and require additional disclosure of such arrangements. The disclosure
requirements in the amendments are intended to assist users of financial statements in understanding the effects of supplier
finance arrangements on an entitys liabilities, cash flows and exposure to liquidity risk. The amendments will be effective for annual
reporting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2024. Early adoption is permitted, but will need to be disclosed.
The amendments are not expected to have a material impact on the Group’s financial statements.
Lack of Exchangeability – Amendments to IAS 21
IASB has published ‘Lack of Exchangeability’ (Amendments to IAS 21) that contains guidance to specify when a currency is
exchangeable and how to determine the exchange rate when it is not. The amendments are applicable for annual reporting periods
beginning on or after 1 January 2025. Earlier application is permitted.
The amendments are not expected to have a material impact on the Group’s financial statements.
286
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
Non-current Liabilities with Covenants – Amendments to IAS 1
On 31 October 2022, the IASB published
Non-current Liabilities with Covenants (Amendments to IAS 1)
to clarify how conditions
with which an entity must comply within 12 months after the reporting period affect the classification of a liability. The amendments
are effective for reporting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2024. The amendments are applied retrospectively in accordance
with IAS 8 and earlier application is permitted.
The amendments are not expected to have a material impact on the Group’s financial statements.
Interest Rate Benchmark Reform
The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (‘FCA’) announced on 5 March 2021 that publication of main Libor currency interest rate
benchmark settings including EUR LIBOR would cease at the end of 2021, while the publication of the most widely used US dollar
Libor settings would be extended until 30 June 2023. As a result, the Bank initiated the transition programme for those contracts
that reference Ibors to alternative rate products. As at 31 December 2023, the transitioning to alternative benchmark rates for all
material contracts was substantially completed.
The below table provides a summary of financial contracts disaggregated by significant interest rate benchmark at the reporting
date that are yet to transition to an alternative benchmark rate:
Balance at Balance at
31 December 31 December
Currency 2023 2022
Financial assets
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
US$
70
631,180
Financial liabilities
Amounts owed to credit institutions
US$
373,769
515,129
Debt securities issued
US$
267,113
267,702
Business combination
On 25 May 2023, the Group acquired 45.63% of the voting shares in JSC Delivery, an online grocery shopping platform in Georgia.
The Group had previously held 34.37% shares in the company and accounted for the shareholding as an investment in associate.
Following the above transaction the shareholding was increased to 80% resulting in the Group obtaining control over the entity. The
company was acquired with the purposes of entering the quick-commerce market.
The Group has simultaneously formed an agreement with one of the non-controlling interests (NCI) whereby the parties agreed on
the sale/purchase of the additional 15.58% shareholding held by the NCI. As a result, the Group has recognised respective liability for
NCI forward at the date of business combination.
The Group has elected to measure the remaining non-controlling interests in the acquiree at proportionate share of the net
assets acquired.
Assets acquired and liabilities assumed
The fair values of the identifiable assets and liabilities of JSC Delivery as at the date of acquisition were:
Fair value
recognised on
acquisition
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents
468
Inventories
302
Property and equipment
263
Intangible assets
182
Other assets
64
1,279
Liabilities
Trade payables
(353)
Other liabilities
(1)
(354)
Total identifiable net assets at fair value
925
Non-controlling interest measured at proportionate share of net assets
(41)
Fair value of Investment in Associate derecognised
(2,309)
NCI Forward liability
(1,270)
Goodwill arising on acquisition
5,765
Purchase consideration
3,070
On 29 September 2023, the Group additionally acquired 80% of El. Biletebi LLC, an e-tickets selling platform with the purpose
to enter the e-tickets market. The Group has elected to measure the remaining non-controlling interests in the acquiree at
proportionate share of the net assets acquired.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
287
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
3. Summary of significant accounting policies continued
Assets acquired and liabilities assumed
The fair values of the identifiable assets and liabilities of El. Biletebi LLC as at the date of acquisition were:
Fair value
recognised on
acquisition
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents
595
Property and equipment
19
Intangible assets
745
Other assets
582
1,941
Liabilities
Advances received
(706)
Trade payables
(31)
(737)
Total identifiable net assets at fair value
1,204
Non-controlling interest measured at proportionate share of net assets
(241)
Goodwill arising on acquisition
2,137
Purchase consideration
3,100
4. Significant accounting judgements and estimates
Estimates involved in measurement of investment properties, assets held for sale and foreclosed assets
Fair values of investment properties, assets held for sale and foreclosed assets are determined by independent, professionally
qualified appraisers. Fair value is determined using a combination of the internal capitalisation method (also known as discounted
future cash flow method) and the sales comparison method.
The Group performs valuation of its investment properties, assets held for sale and foreclosed assets with a sufficient regularity
to ensure that the carrying amount does not differ materially from that which would be determined using fair value and respective
measurement principles at the end of the reporting period.
The last valuation was performed in 2022. Results of this valuation are presented in Note 15, while valuation inputs and techniques
are presented in Note 31. The Group’s properties are spread across the different parts of the country. While the secondary market
in Georgia provides adequate market information for fair value measurements for small and medium-sized properties; valuation
of large properties involves application of various observable and unobservable inputs to determine adjustments to the available
comparable sale prices. These estimates and assumptions are based on the best available information, however, actual results could
be different.
Allowance for financial assets
IFRS 9 requires management to make a number of judgements, assumptions and estimates based on management’s knowledge and
historical experience that affect the allowance for ECL. A summary of the key judgements made by management is set out below.
Definition of default, credit-impaired and cure (Note 30)
The Groups definition of default is based on quantitative and qualitative criteria. The definition may differ across products. The
definition is consistent with the definition used for internal credit risk management purposes and it corresponds with internal
financial instrument risk classification rules. A counterparty is classified as defaulted at the latest when payments of interest,
principal or fees are overdue for more than 90 days or when bankruptcy, fraud, insolvency proceedings of enforced liquidation have
commenced, or there is other evidence that the payment obligations will not be fully met. The determination of whether a financial
instrument is credit-impaired focuses on default risk, without taking into consideration the effects of credit risk mitigations such as
collateral or guarantees.
An instrument is classified as credit-impaired if the counterparty is defaulted and/or the instrument is POCI.
Once the financial asset is classified as credit-impaired (except for POCIs) it remains as such unless all past due amounts have been
rectified or there is general evidence of credit recovery. A minimum period of six consecutive months’ payment is applied as the exit
criteria to financial assets restructured due to credit risk other than corporate loan portfolio and debt instruments measured at
FVOCI, where exit criteria are determined as an exit from bankruptcy or insolvency status, disappearance of liquidity problems or
existence of other general evidence of credit recovery assessed on individual basis.
For other credit-impaired financial instruments, the exit criteria is determined as repayment of the entire overdue amount other
than through refinancing or foreclosure.
Once a credit-impaired financial asset meets the default exit criteria, it remains in Stage 2 at least for the next 12 consecutive
months. In case no default status is assigned during the 12 consecutive months, it is transferred to Stage 1 if its credit risk is not
significantly higher than at origination date.
288
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
4. Significant accounting judgements and estimates continued
Significant increase in credit risk (SICR)
SICR is not a defined term per IFRS 9, and is determined by management, based on their experience and judgement. In assessing
whether the credit risk has significantly increased, the Group has identified a series of qualitative and quantitative criteria based
on undertaking the holistic analysis of various factors including those which are specific to a particular financial instrument or to a
borrower as well as those applicable to particular sub-portfolios. These criteria are:
A significant increase in credit risk, expressed in the relative and/or absolute increase in the risk of default since initial recognition.
SICR is determined based on comparison between credit risk ratings (internal or external) as of the origination date and credit
risk ratings as of the reporting date for each financial asset individually. Thresholds are determined separately for corporate,
retail, SME and other financial instrument portfolios, depending on initial grade assigned at origination. The threshold applied
depends on the original credit quality of the borrowers. Higher threshold is set for those instruments with a low PD at origination.
The table below summarises SICR thresholds (the actual thresholds are applied on a more granular level):
SICR threshold
Loan portfolio type
Rating type
Initial rating
(notches)
Commercial loans
Internal
2-4+
5-12
Commercial loans
Internal
5-7+
1-5
Micro and SME loans
External
A-C
5-8
Mortgage loans
External
A-C
6-8
Consumer loans
External
A-C
4-10
Gold – pawn loans
External
A-C
6-10
Micro and SME loans, Mortgage, Consumer, Gold – pawn loans
External
D-E
1-5
Existence of forecast of adverse changes in commercial, financial or economic conditions that adversely affect the
creditworthiness of the borrower.
Modification of the contractual terms due to financial problems of the borrower other than default.
The days past due on individual contract level breached the threshold of 30 days.
Other qualitative indicators, such as external market indicators of credit risk or general economic conditions, which indicate that
the level of risk has increased significantly since origination.
The above noted SICR indicators are identified at the financial instrument level in order to track changes in credit risk since the initial
recognition date.
Measurement of ECLs
ECL reflects an unbiased, probability-weighted estimate based on a combination of the following principal factors: PD, loss given
default (LGD), and exposure at default (EAD), which are further explained below:
PD estimation:
The Group estimates PD based on a combination of rating model calibration results and a migration matrices
approach which is further adjusted for macroeconomic expectations for a minimum three years onwards for all portfolios, to
represent the forward-looking estimators of the PD parameters. The migration matrix is built in a way to reflect the weighted
average yearly migration over the historical data period. The risk groups are determined in a way to ensure intra-group homogeneity
and differentiation of expected PD levels. For loan portfolios other than corporate loans, PD is further adjusted considering the time
since financial instrument origination. The models incorporate both qualitative and quantitative information and, where practical,
build on information from top rating agencies, Credit Bureau or internal credit rating systems. Since Stage 3 financial instruments
are defaulted, the PD in this case is equal to 100%.
EAD:
The EAD represents an estimate of the exposure to credit risk at the time of a potential default occurring during the life of a
financial asset. It represents the cash flows outstanding at the time of default, considering expected repayments, interest payments
and accruals discounted at the EIR. To calculate EAD for a Stage 1 financial instrument, the Group assesses the possible default
events within 12 months for the calculation of the 12 months ECL. For Stage 2 and POCI financial instruments, the EAD is considered
for events over the lifetime of the instruments. The Group determines EAD differently for products with repayment schedules and
those without repayment schedules. For financial instruments with repayment schedules, the Group estimates forward-looking
EAD using the contractual cash flow approach with further corrections for expected prepayments and overdue days. For products
without the repayment schedules such as credit cards, credit lines and financial guarantees, the Group estimates the forward-
looking EAD using the limit utilisation approach. Under the above approach EAD is calculated using the expected utilisation rate
based on historical data of actual draw-down amounts.
LGD
: LGD is defined as the likely loss in case of a counterparty default. It provides an estimation of the exposure that cannot
be recovered in a default event and therefore captures the severity of a loss. The determination of the LGD takes into account
expected future cash flows from collateral and other credit enhancements, or expected payouts from bankruptcy proceedings for
unsecured claims, and where applicable, time to realisation of collateral and the seniority of claims. The Group segments its financial
instruments into homogeneous portfolios, based on key characteristics that are relevant to the estimation of future cash flows. The
applied data is based on historically collected loss data and involves a wider set of transaction characteristics (e.g. product type,
wider range of collateral types). Based on this information, the Group estimates the recovery rate (other than through collateral),
cure rate and probability of re-default. Recovery through collateral is further considered in LGD calculations individually for each
financial instrument.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
289
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
4. Significant accounting judgements and estimates continued
Assets considered in the ECL calculations
IFRS 9 requires cash flows expected from collateral and other credit enhancements to be reflected in the ECL calculation. The
treatment and reflection of collateral for IFRS 9 purposes is in line with general risk management principles, policies and processes
of the Group. Collateral, unless repossessed, is not recorded on the Group’s statement of financial position. The fair value of
collateral affects the calculation of ECLs. It is generally assessed at inception and reassessed on an annual basis for all material
exposures.
Management Overlays and improvements to the ECL methodology
In prior periods the Group applied a number of management overlays to the existing ECL methodology due to the unprecedented
nature of the COVID-19 pandemic and the uncertainties associated with it. Such overlays related to staging of COVID-19
restructured loans as well as cure and recovery rates. Given a reasonable time has passed for the statistics to properly reflect the
effects of COVID-19, the Group decided to remove respective management overlays which positively affected overall ECL of the
Group. In addition, management re-estimated collateral realisation period for LGD calculations resulting in an increase of ECL. This
together with the removal of management overlays and other minor improvements to the methodology resulted in the decrease of
ECL by GEL 21.4 million for the Group in 2022.
Forward-looking information
Under IFRS 9, the allowance for expected credit losses is based on reasonable and supportable forward-looking information
obtainable without undue cost or effort, which takes into consideration past events, current conditions and forecasts of future
economic conditions.
To incorporate forward-looking information into the Group’s allowance for expected credit losses, the Group uses the
macroeconomic forecasts provided by the NBG for Group companies operating in Georgia, while data used by Belarusky Narodny
Bank (BNB) is provided by a non-governmental research centre operating in Belarus. Macroeconomic variables covered by these
forecasts and which the Group incorporated in its ECL assessment model include GDP growth, foreign exchange rate and inflation
rate. These forward-looking macroeconomic variables are generally updated on a semi-annual basis for Georgian companies and on
a quarterly basis for BNB.
The determination of the probability-weighted ECL requires evaluating a range of diverse and relevant future economic conditions.
To accommodate this requirement, the Group uses three different economic scenarios in the ECL calculation: an upside (weight
0.25), a base case (weight 0.50) and a downside (weight 0.25) scenario relevant for each respective portfolio. A weight is calculated
for each scenario by using a probabilistic economic model that considers recent information as well as historical data provided by
the NBG.
The Group considers these forecasts to represent its best estimate of the possible outcomes, based on reliable available information.
Forward-looking variable assumptions
The most significant period end assumptions used for ECL estimate as at 31 December 2023 per geographical segments are set out
below. The scenarios ‘base, ‘upside’ and ‘downside’ were used for all portfolios.
Georgia
ECL Assigned As at 31 December 2023 Assigned As at 31 December 2022 Assigned As at 31 December 2021
Key drivers scenario weight
2024
2025
2026
weight
2023
2024
2025
weight
2022
2023
2024
GDP growth in %
Upside
25%
6.50%
5.50%
5.00%
25%
6.00%
5.00%
5.00%
25%
6.00%
5.00%
4.50%
Base case
50%
5.00%
4.50%
5.00%
50%
4.00%
5.50%
5.00%
50%
5.00%
4.00%
4.50%
Downside
25%
3.00%
4.00%
5.00%
25%
2.00%
4.00%
5.00%
25%
2.00%
4.00%
5.00%
GEL/US$ exchange rate
Upside
25%
3.00%
2.00%
0.00%
25%
2.00%
0.00%
0.00%
25%
4.00%
2.00%
2.00%
Base case
50%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
50%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
50%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
Downside
25%
-15.00%
0.00%
5.00%
25%
-15.00%
5.00%
5.00%
25%
-10.00%
2.00%
3.00%
CPI inflation rate in %
Upside
25%
3.25%
3.00%
3.00%
25%
5.00%
3.00%
3.00%
25%
5.50%
3.00%
3.00%
Base case
50%
3.60%
3.10%
3.00%
50%
5.30%
3.10%
3.00%
50%
7.00%
2.50%
3.00%
Downside
25%
5.00%
4.00%
3.00%
25%
9.00%
6.00%
3.00%
25%
8.00%
4.00%
3.00%
290
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
4. Significant accounting judgements and estimates continued
Belarus
ECL Assigned As at 31 December 2023 Assigned As at 31 December 2022 Assigned As at 31 December 2021
Key drivers scenario weight
2024
2025
weight
2023
2024
weight
2022
2023
GDP growth in %
Upside
25%
3.77%
3.13%
10%
2.66%
4.26%
25%
2.92%
5.01%
Base case
50%
1.95%
0.49%
50%
0.31%
0.50%
50%
0.56%
1.24%
Downside
25%
0.14%
-2.15%
40%
-2.05%
-3.26%
25%
-1.80%
-2.52%
BYN/US$ exchange rate %
Upside
25%
0.66%
0.62%
10%
0.71%
0.65%
25%
0.56%
0.52%
Base case
50%
1.00%
1.23%
50%
2.53%
1.65%
50%
2.44%
1.37%
Downside
25%
1.31%
1.77%
40%
4.09%
2.41%
25%
4.05%
1.98%
CPI inflation rate in %
Upside
25%
-0.09%
-0.52%
10%
0.38%
-0.58%
25%
-0.07%
-0.85%
Base case
50%
1.94%
1.82%
50%
2.20%
1.66%
50%
1.83%
1.38%
Downside
25%
3.86%
4.01%
40%
3.93%
3.76%
25%
3.63%
3.46%
All other parameters held constant, increase in GDP growth and decrease in foreign exchange rate and inflation would result in
a decrease in ECL, with opposite changes resulting in ECL increase. GDP growth input has the most significant impact on ECL,
followed by foreign exchange rate and inflation. Retail portfolio ECL is less affected by foreign exchange rate inputs due to larger
share of GEL-denominated exposures. However, retail portfolio ECL is affected by inflation, which does not have a significant
impact on corporate ECL.
The table below shows the sensitivity of the recognised ECL amounts to the forward-looking assumptions used in the model. For
these purposes, 100% weight is assigned to each macroeconomic scenario separately and respective ECL is recalculated.
Sensitivity of ECL to forward-looking assumptions:
Key drivers
As at 31 December 2023
ECL coverage by scenarios
Reported ECL
Reported ECL coverage
Upside
Base case
Downside
Commercial loans
100,378
1.43%
1.37%
1.40%
1.44%
Residential mortgage loans
22,750
0.50%
0.49%
0.50%
0.51%
Micro and SME loans
71,661
1.76%
1.74%
1.76%
1.78%
Consumer loans
131,633
2.80%
2.75%
2.79%
2.86%
Gold – pawn loans
1,390
0.93%
0.92%
0.92%
0.93%
Key drivers
As at 31 December 2022
ECL coverage by scenarios
Reported ECL
Reported ECL coverage
Upside
Base case
Downside
Commercial loans
91,557
1.72%
1.58%
1.70%
1.81%
Residential mortgage loans
30,055
0.72%
0.71%
0.71%
0.73%
Micro and SME loans
63,502
1.66%
1.61%
1.65%
1.70%
Consumer loans
135,450
3.76%
3.70%
3.74%
3.84%
Gold – pawn loans
5,441
3.31%
3.30%
3.30%
3.31%
Key drivers
As at 31 December 2021
ECL coverage by scenarios
Reported ECL
Reported ECL coverage
Upside
Base case
Downside
Commercial loans
159,215
2.87%
2.82%
2.84%
2.86%
Residential mortgage loans
33,038
0.82%
0.80%
0.81%
0.85%
Micro and SME loans
74,441
1.99%
1.93%
1.96%
2.13%
Consumer loans
136,035
4.56%
4.46%
4.54%
4.70%
Gold – pawn loans
2,075
1.25%
1.25%
1.25%
1.26%
Aggregation of financial instruments for collective assessment
For the purpose of a collective evaluation of impairment, financial instruments are grouped within homogeneous pools as follows:
corporate loan portfolio is grouped on the basis of loan repayment source type; and retail loan portfolio is grouped on the basis of
credit risk characteristics such as an asset type, collateralisation level, repayment source type and other relevant factors. As for SME
and micro loan portfolios, financial instruments are grouped based on asset type, overdue buckets, collateralisation level and other
relevant factors.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
291
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
4. Significant accounting judgements and estimates continued
Determination of expected life for revolving facilities
For revolving products, the expected life of financial instruments is determined either with reference to the next renewal date
or with reference to the behavioural expected life of the financial instrument estimated based on the empirical observation of
the lifetime.
Write-offs
The Group writes off financial assets when there is no reasonable expectation of recovery. The need for write-off of corporate loans
is assessed individually, for mortgages and other loans secured by real estate, the number of overdue days after which the balances
are considered to be irrecoverable and are to be written off comprised 1,460 days, while other non-secured portfolio is written-off
after 150 days overdue. If the amount to be written off is greater than the accumulated loan loss allowance, the difference is first
treated as an ECL expense. Any subsequent recoveries are credited to ECL expense.
Backtesting of ECL calculation model
In order to monitor the quality and reliability of the Group’s ECL calculation model, the Group periodically performs backtesting
and benchmarking procedures, whereby model outcomes are compared with actual results, based on internal experience as well
as externally observed results. For PD, the Group uses statistical modelling to derive a predicted distribution of the number of
defaults. The observed number of defaults is then compared with this distribution, allowing the Group to derive a statistical level
of confidence in the model. For LGD, the backtesting compares observed losses with predicted LGDs. If any statistically significant
deviations or shortcomings in parameterisations are observed, the relevant models are redefined and recalibrated. Any changes in
the model as a result of backtesting procedures are accounted as changes in accounting estimates with prospective application.
Impact of climate-related risks on accounting judgements and estimates
Climate, and the impact of climate on the Group’s balance sheet is considered as an area of accounting estimate and judgement
through the uncertainty of future events and the impact of that uncertainty on the Group’s assets and liabilities. While the
effects of climate change are a source of uncertainty, as at 31 December 2023 management does not consider climate to have
a qualitatively material impact on its financial statements. The Group has assessed the impact of climate risk on its financial
statements as disclosed below.
The estimated areas of impact, limited to a qualitative assessment, were expected credit loss and the impact on lending portfolios
including physical risk on the mortgage lending portfolio and forward-looking cash flows that impact the recoverability of certain
assets. Transition risk is managed through reviews of clients by the Group’s Risk function which includes an ongoing process of
identifying clients susceptible to climate transition risks.
The Group Climate Risk team has performed a top-down qualitative assessment of the impact of climate risk on the IFRS 9 ECL
provision. This assessment has mostly been focused across corporate and mortgage portfolios. The portfolios identified as most
susceptible to climate risks were identified as mining and quarrying, heavy metals and construction, the concentration of which is
not signficant for the overall Group loan exposure. The assessment of the portfolios is undertaken by considering the maturity profile
of the exposures which is relatively shorter term compared to long-term climate impact. The above assessment did not result in any
material effect on the Groups consolidated financial statements.
While some indicators that are more influenced by climate change (e.g. energy prices) are factored into the current PD models where
they have demonstrated statistical relevance, the Group currently does not use a specific climate risk related scenario in addition
to the existing economic scenarios applied to derive the weighted-average ECL. The reason for this is lack of sufficient historical
data and limitations in the risk assessments. Where climate factors have impacted the economy in the recent past or present, these
impacts are implicitly embedded in the Groups IFRS 9 ECL models through the projected macroeconomic indicators (e.g. inflation
rates) and individual analysis of corporate loan related cash flows.
It should also be noted that the Group is currently working on a corporate plan in respect of its response to climate risks, with the
commitment to transition away or limit certain high carbon sector financing while introducing more green finance products.
Based on the best information available at the time these consolidated annual financial statements were prepared, the Group sees
no additional climate change risk having a substantial impact on its equity, financial situation and results in 2024. However, as the
matter is constantly changing, the Group is working on developing methodologies to better measure potential loan loss in line with
the new management needs, best practice and regulators’ requirements.
5. Segment information
The Group disaggregated revenue from contracts with customers by products and services for each of the segments, as the Group
believes it best depicts how the nature, amount, timing and uncertainty of revenue and cash flows are affected by economic factors.
For management purposes, the Group is organised into the following operating segments based on products and services as follows:
RB Retail Banking (excluding Retail Banking of BNB) – principally provides consumer loans, mortgage loans, overdrafts, credit
cards and other credit facilities, funds transfers and settlement services, and the handling of customers’ deposits for both
individuals and legal entities. The Retail Banking business targets the mass retail, mass affluent and high-net-worth client
segments.
SME SME Banking (excluding SME Banking of BNB) – principally provides SME loans, micro loans, consumer and mortgage
loans, funds transfers and settlement services, and the handling of customers’ deposits for legal entities. The SME
Banking business targets small and medium-sized enterprises and micro businesses.
292
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
5. Segment information continued
CIB Corporate Investment Banking – comprises Corporate Banking and Investment Management operations in Georgia.
Corporate Banking principally provides loans and other credit facilities, funds transfers and settlement services, trade
finance services, documentary operations support and handles saving and term deposits for corporate and institutional
customers. The Investment Management business principally provides brokerage services through Galt & Taggart.
BNB Comprising JSC Belarusky Narodny Bank mainly, principally providing retail and corporate banking services in Belarus.
Management monitors the operating results of its segments separately for the purpose of making decisions about resource
allocation and performance assessment. Segment performance, as explained in the table below, is measured in the same manner as
profit or loss in the consolidated income statement.
Transactions between operating segments are on an arm’s length basis in a similar manner to transactions with third parties.
During the financial year, the Groups operations were primarily concentrated in Georgia, except for BNB, which operates in Belarus.
No revenue from transactions with a single external customer or counterparty amounted to 10% or more of the Groups operating
income in 2023, 2022 or 2021.
In the first quarter of 2023 the SME Banking segment was split from Retail Banking and the majority of the Micro portfolio, where
customers had business-related needs, was transferred to SME Banking. The remaining Micro portfolio has been transferred to
Mass Retail. The SME segment has grown significantly over the past few years. In addition, the value proposition for business
clients has been different from the value proposition for retail customers, leading to our decision to change the segmentation.
The comparative figures have been restated accordingly to reflect this change. 2021 amounts have not been restated due to the
unavailability of necessary data and impracticability of restatement.
The following table presents the income statement and certain asset and liability information regarding the Group’s operating
segments as at and for the year ended 31 December 2023:
Corporate
Retail Investment Group
Banking
SME
Banking
BNB
Eliminations
Total
Net interest income
790,630
256,013
520,237
48,486
80
1,615,446
Net fee and commission income
302,555
40,574
83,718
7,379
256
434,482
Net foreign currency gain
197,379
38,357
88,369
41,606
365,711
Net gains/(losses) on extinguishment of debt
184
52
107
221
564
Other income from settlement of legacy claim
22,585
22,585
Net other gains/(losses)
18,287
5,997
88,928
1,788
(829)
114,171
Operating income
1,309,035
340,993
803,944
99,480
(493)
2,552,959
Operating expenses
(469,855)
(99,780)
(119,397)
(65,514)
493
(754,053)
Profit from associates
1,391
65
1,456
Operating income before cost of risk
840,571
241,278
684,547
33,966
1,800,362
Cost of risk
(83,847)
(32,316)
(30,549)
2,648
(144,064)
Net operating income before non-recurring
items
756,724
208,962
653,998
36,614
1,656,298
Net non-recurring items
Profit before income tax
756,724
208,962
653,998
36,614
1,656,298
Income tax expense
(121,126)
(34,094)
(95,274)
(8,477)
(258,971)
Profit for the year
635,598
174,868
558,724
28,137
1,397,327
Assets and liabilities
Total assets
14,247,054
5,969,620
10,366,433
1,280,167
(105,716)
31,757,558
Total liabilities
12,479,270
5,137,430
8,095,296
1,131,442
(105,716)
26,737,722
Other segment information
Property and equipment
81,636
8,403
2,823
5,273
98,135
Intangible assets
40,937
5,919
2,681
7,031
56,568
Capital expenditure
122,573
14,322
5,504
12,304
154,703
Depreciation, amortisation and impairment
(97,938)
(12,206)
(5,319)
(9,260)
(124,723)
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
293
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
5. Segment information continued
The following table presents the income statement and certain asset and liability information regarding the Group’s operating
segments as at and for the year ended 31 December 2022:
Corporate
Retail Investment Group
Banking
SME
Banking
BNB
Eliminations
Total
Net interest income
565,175
202,793
376,771
37,511
85
1,182,335
Net fee and commission income
221,495
34,792
49,543
11,500
161
317,491
Net foreign currency gain
234,425
43,183
123,993
64,493
466,094
Net gains/(losses) on extinguishment of debt
(1,943)
(730)
(5,740)
(304)
(8,717)
Other income from settlement of legacy claim
391,100
391,100
Net other gains/(losses)
20,841
3,233
20,039
1,474
(778)
44,809
Operating income
1,039,993
283,271
955,706
114,674
(532)
2,393,112
Operating expenses
(387,147)
(93,507)
(105,632)
(55,432)
532
(641,186)
Profit from associates
700
54
754
Operating income before cost of risk
653,546
189,818
850,074
59,242
1,752,680
Cost of risk
(164,099)
(8,603)
79,461
(25,827)
(119,068)
Net operating income before non-recurring
items
489,447
181,215
929,535
33,415
1,633,612
Net non-recurring items
1,241
(203)
1,038
Profit before income tax
490,688
181,215
929,535
33,212
1,634,650
Income tax expense
(76,489)
(28,785)
(77,693)
(7,684)
(190,651)
Profit for the year
414,199
152,430
851,842
25,528
1,443,999
Assets and liabilities
Total assets
13,231,085
5,432,635
9,006,313
1,381,366
(149,499)
28,901,900
Total liabilities
11,662,975
4,682,905
7,226,769
1,229,928
(149,499)
24,653,078
Other segment information
Property and equipment
67,285
6,167
2,304
2,241
77,997
Intangible assets
28,252
5,567
1,965
4,886
40,670
Capital expenditure
95,537
11,734
4,269
7,127
118,667
Depreciation, amortisation and impairment
(86,546)
(13,193)
(5,292)
(6,058)
(111,089)
The following table presents the income statement and certain asset and liability information regarding the Group’s operating
segments as at and for the year ended 31 December 2021:
Corporate
Retail Investment Group
Banking
Banking
BNB
Eliminations
Total
Net interest income
582,531
331,706
39,676
28
953,941
Net fee and commission income
178,928
47,869
5,476
158
232,431
Net foreign currency gain (loss)
58,139
37,619
13,341
109,099
Net gains/(losses) on extinguishment of debt
(456)
(1,333)
(1,103)
(2,892)
Net other gains/(losses)
26,325
45,312
2,345
(884)
73,098
Operating income
845,467
461,173
59,735
(698)
1,365,677
Operating expenses
(389,915)
(79,060)
(39,675)
698
(507,952)
Profit from associates
(3,781)
(3,781)
Operating income before cost of risk
451,771
382,113
20,060
853,944
Cost of risk
(72,351)
22,662
(1,723)
(51,412)
Net operating income before non-recurring items
379,420
404,775
18,337
802,532
Net non-recurring items
20
(78)
(532)
(590)
Profit before income tax
379,440
404,697
17,805
801,942
Income tax expense
(32,956)
(38,473)
(3,395)
(74,824)
Profit for the year
346,484
366,224
14,410
727,118
Assets and liabilities
Total assets
14,865,640
7,683,923
980,920
(100,407)
23,430,076
Total liabilities
13,017,394
6,573,918
846,263
(100,407)
20,337,168
Other segment information
Property and equipment
48,095
3,103
2,031
53,229
Intangible assets
37,144
2,921
4,992
45,057
Capital expenditure
85,239
6,024
7,023
98,286
Depreciation, amortisation and impairment
(80,127)
(8,551)
(4,940)
(93,618)
294
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
6. Cash and cash equivalents
2023
2022
2021
Cash on hand
1,024,048
1,052,055
751,063
Current accounts with central banks, excluding obligatory reserves
713,212
805,503
126,627
Current accounts with credit institutions
652,244
965,046
414,214
Time deposits with credit institutions with maturities of up to 90 days
712,786
762,590
228,683
Cash and cash equivalents, gross
3,102,290
3,585,194
1,520,587
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss
(466)
(351)
(25)
Cash and cash equivalents, net
3,101,824
3,584,843
1,520,562
As at 31 December 2023, GEL 975,099 (2022: GEL 1,453,844, 2021: GEL 419,324) was placed on current and time deposit accounts
with internationally recognised OECD banks and central banks that are the counterparties of the Group in performing international
settlements. The Group earned between 0.00%-10.35% interest per annum on these deposits (2022: up to 11.10%, 2021: up to
0.07%). Management does not expect any losses from non-performance by the counterparties holding cash and cash equivalents,
and there are no material differences between their book and fair values.
As at 31 December 2023, cash and cash equivalents held by BOGG of GEL 50,970 (2022: GEL 10,850, 2021: GEL 384) is represented
by placements on current accounts with Georgian and OECD banks.
7. Amounts due from credit institutions
2023
2022
2021
Obligatory reserves with central banks
1,746,288
2,354,470
1,898,052
Time deposits with maturities of more than 90 days
15,721
28,939
Restricted cash
7,263
68,155
4,730
Amounts due from credit institutions, gross
1,753,551
2,438,346
1,931,721
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss
(894)
(5,318)
(331)
Amounts due from credit institutions, net
1,752,657
2,433,028
1,931,390
Obligatory reserves with central banks represent amounts deposited with the NBG and the National Bank of the Republic of Belarus
(the ‘NBRB’). Credit institutions are required to maintain cash deposits (obligatory reserve) with the NBG and with the NBRB, the
amount of which depends on the level of funds attracted by the credit institution. The Groups ability to withdraw these deposits
is restricted by regulation. The Group earned up to 0.00% interest on obligatory reserves with NBG and NBRB for the years ended
31 December 2023 (2022: 0.00%, 2021: 0.00%).
8. Investment securities
2023
2022
2021
Investment securities measured at FVOCI – debt instruments
4,424,160
3,960,299
2,586,083
Investment securities designated as at FVOCI – equity investments
8,004
10,893
9,581
Investment securities measured at FVTPL – debt instruments
435
Investment securities measured at FVTPL – equity instruments
6,852
Investment securities measured at FV
4,439,451
3,971,192
2,595,664
2023
2022
2021
Investment securities measured at amortised cost
691,119
381,735
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss
(813)
(3,198)
Investment securities measured at amortised cost, net
690,306
378,537
2023
2022
2021
Ministry of Finance of Georgia treasury bonds
1,891,684
1,470,473
1,312,001
Ministry of Finance of Georgia treasury bills
155,955
176,483
82,196
Foreign treasury bills
1,645,286
1,062,095
Foreign treasury bonds
54,151
92,817
79,156
Certificates of deposit of central banks
10,855
17,675
39,410
Other debt instruments
666,229
1,140,756
1,073,320
Investment securities measured at FVOCI – debt instruments
4,424,160
3,960,299
2,586,083
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
295
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
8. Investment securities continued
2023
2022
2021
Ministry of Finance of Georgia treasury bonds
77,367
119,918
Foreign treasury bonds
12,230
Other debt instruments
613,752
249,587
Investment securities measured at amortised cost – debt instruments, gross
691,119
381,735
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss
(813)
(3,198)
Investment securities measured at amortised cost – debt instruments, net
690,306
378,537
Pledged treasury bonds 2023
2022
2021
For short-term loans from the NBG
1,375,687
709,597
490,592
For repo-operations with commercial banks
380,065
For deposits of Ministry of Finance of Georgia
97,109
220,480
For cash kept by the NBG at the Group’s premises under cash custodian services
14,720
Total
1,375,687
1,186,771
725,792
Pledged treasury bills 2023
2022
2021
For cash kept by the NBG at the Group’s premises under cash custodian services
24,180
Total
24,180
Pledged corporate bonds 2023
2022
2021
For short-term loans from the NBG
127,685
121,592
For deposits of Ministry of Finance of Georgia
205,079
109,109
Total
127,685
326,671
109,109
Other debt instruments measured at FVOCI – debt instruments as at 31 December 2023 mainly comprises bonds issued by the
European Bank for Reconstruction and Development of GEL 326,916 (2022: GEL 531,351, 2021: GEL 521,394), GEL-denominated
bonds issued by the International Finance Corporation of GEL 203,617 (2022: GEL 56,523, 2021: GEL 203,351), GEL-denominated
bonds issued by the Netherlands Development Finance Company of GEL Nil (2022: GEL 131,126, 2021: GEL 163,593), GEL-
denominated bonds issued by the Black Sea Trade and Development Bank of GEL Nil (2022: GEL 200,913, 2021: GEL 65,407),
US$-denominated bonds issued by the National Bank Of Uzbekistan of GEL Nil (2022: GEL 12,230, 2021: GEL Nil) and
GEL-denominated bonds issued by the Asian Development Bank of GEL 30,594 (2022: GEL 107,835, 2021: GEL 61,609).
Foreign treasury bonds and bills measured at FVOCI – debt instruments comprise of US Treasury Notes in the amount of GEL
1,621,219 (2022: GEL 1,062,095, 2021: GEL Nil), Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Lithuania treasury bonds in the amount of GEL
Nil (2022: GEL Nil, 2021: GEL 15,992), United Kingdom treasury bonds in the amount of GEL Nil (2022: GEL 32,516, 2021: GEL Nil),
Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Belarus treasury bonds in the amount of GEL 54,151 (2022: GEL 60,301, 2021: GEL 63,164) and
US treasury bills in the amount of GEL 24,068 (2022: GEL Nil, 2021: GEL Nil).
For the period ended 31 December 2023 net gains on derecognition of investment securities comprised GEL 12,520 (2022: GEL 7,921,
2022: GEL 30,044) which is included in net other income.
As at 31 December 2023, allowance for ECL on investment securities measured at FVOCI comprised GEL 7,684 (2022: GEL 7,086,
2021: GEL 3,145).
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
2023
2022
2021
Commercial loans
7,017,617
5,315,666
5,554,184
Consumer loans
4,699,969
3,602,054
2,981,305
Residential mortgage loans
4,557,525
4,193,204
4,022,058
Micro and SME loans
4,073,022
38,25,663
3,731,756
Gold – pawn loans
150,228
164,554
165,417
Loans to customers at amortised cost, gross
20,498,361
17,101,141
16,454,720
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss
(327,812)
(326,005)
(404,804)
Loans to customers at amortised cost, net
20,170,549
16,775,136
16,049,916
Finance lease receivables, gross
73,487
95,348
124,952
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss
(11,315)
(8,778)
(5,895)
Finance lease receivables, net
62,172
86,570
119,057
Total loans to customers and finance lease receivables
20,232,721
16,861,706
16,168,973
296
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
As at 31 December 2023, loans to customers carried at GEL 954,695 (2022: GEL 1,092,475, 2021: GEL 1,125,955) were pledged for
short-term loans from the NBG.
Expected credit loss
Movements of the gross loans and respective allowance for expected credit loss/impairment of loans to customers by class are
provided in the table below, within which the new financial asset originated or purchased and the assets repaid during the year
include the effects from revolving loans and increase of exposure to clients, where existing loans have been repaid with new
contracts issued during the year. All new financial assets are originated either in Stage 1 or POCI category. Utilisation of additional
tranches on existing financial assets are reflected in Stage 2 or Stage 3 if the credit risk of the borrower has deteriorated since
initiation. Currency translation differences relate to loans issued by the subsidiaries of the Group whose functional currency is
different from the presentation currency of the Group, while foreign exchange movement relates to foreign currency denominated
loans issued by the Group. Net other changes in gross loan balances includes the effects of changes in accrued interest. Net other
measurement of ECL includes the effect of changes in ECL due to post-model adjustments, changes in PDs and other inputs, as well
as the effect from ECL attributable to changes in accrued interest.
Commercial loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
4,511,821
611,307
176,588
15,950
5,315,666
New financial asset originated or purchased
6,382,411
62,180
8
15,820
6,460,419
Transfer to Stage 1
218,262
(218,262)
Transfer to Stage 2
(408,616)
413,869
(5,253)
Transfer to Stage 3
(9,314)
(35,720)
45,034
Assets derecognised due to pass-through arrangement
(165,947)
(418)
(164)
(166,529)
Assets repaid
(4,279,698)
(318,744)
(96,967)
(10,324)
(4,705,733)
Resegmentation
76,352
(56)
2,959
79,255
Impact of modifications
(755)
733
(143)
9
(156)
Foreign exchange movement
105,029
4,490
(375)
83
109,227
Net other changes
60,821
111
(10,563)
664
51,033
Write-offs
(11,502)
(11,502)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
8,723
957
9,680
Unwind of discount
(2,224)
416
(1,808)
Currency translation differences
(113,478)
(3,701)
(4,756)
(121,935)
Balance at 31 December 2023
6,376,888
515,789
101,365
23,575
7,017,617
Individually assessed
92,801
21,497
114,298
Collectively assessed
6,376,888
515,789
8,564
2,078
6,903,319
Balance at 31 December 2023
6,376,888
515,789
101,365
23,575
7,017,617
Commercial loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
19,215
23,530
44,247
4,565
91,557
New financial asset originated or purchased
31,952
697
1
32,650
Transfer to Stage 1
3,811
(3,811)
Transfer to Stage 2
(5,004)
6,393
(1,389)
Transfer to Stage 3
(994)
(1,406)
2,400
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(1,777)
4,522
17,549
20,294
Assets derecognised due to pass-through arrangement
(529)
(9)
(538)
Assets repaid
(13,364)
(12,030)
(29,709)
(1,325)
(56,428)
Resegmentation
1,102
(1,224)
870
748
Impact of modifications
(1)
17
(149)
3
(130)
Foreign exchange movement
(14)
103
(641)
127
(425)
Net other measurement of ECL
(20,005)
16,327
17,249
4,195
17,766
Income statement (releases)/charges
(4,823)
9,579
6,181
3,000
13,937
Write-offs
(11,502)
(11,502)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
8,723
957
9,680
Unwind of discount
(2,224)
416
(1,808)
Currency translation differences
(272)
82
(1,296)
(1,486)
Balance at 31 December 2023
14,120
33,191
44,129
8,938
100,378
Individually assessed
39,561
8,936
48,497
Collectively assessed
14,120
33,191
4,568
2
51,881
Balance at 31 December 2023
14,120
33,191
44,129
8,938
100,378
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
297
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,925,906
169,566
69,657
28,075
4,193,204
New financial asset originated or purchased
1,527,164
32
14,796
1,541,992
Transfer to Stage 1
268,798
(268,798)
Transfer to Stage 2
(320,140)
352,400
(32,260)
Transfer to Stage 3
(17,355)
(33,670)
51,025
Assets repaid
(1,081,098)
(45,148)
(37,682)
(11,487)
(1,175,415)
Impact of modifications
530
137
(83)
(185)
399
Foreign exchange movement
11,210
(150)
(263)
165
10,962
Net other changes
(7,727)
(147)
1,571
451
(5,852)
Write-offs
(2,534)
(263)
(2,797)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
1,385
543
1,928
Unwind of discount
215
94
309
Currency translation differences
(6,950)
(170)
(85)
(7,205)
Balance at 31 December 2023
4,300,338
174,052
50,946
32,189
4,557,525
Individually assessed
168
2,092
2,260
Collectively assessed
4,300,338
174,052
50,778
30,097
4,555,265
Balance at 31 December 2023
4,300,338
174,052
50,946
32,189
4,557,525
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
8,862
2,601
14,085
4,507
30,055
New financial asset originated or purchased
8,396
8,396
Transfer to Stage 1
4,415
(4,415)
Transfer to Stage 2
(2,766)
9,962
(7,196)
Transfer to Stage 3
(3,612)
(1,152)
4,764
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(1,133)
(5,845)
5,016
(1,962)
Assets repaid
(1,516)
(747)
(8,701)
(3,395)
(14,359)
Impact of modifications
19
5
1,049
43
1,116
Foreign exchange movement
(1)
(3)
(46)
28
(22)
Net other measurement of ECL
(8,690)
1,632
3,842
3,318
102
Income statement (releases)/charges
(4,888)
(563)
(1,272)
(6)
(6,729)
Write-offs
(2,534)
(263)
(2,797)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
1,385
543
1,928
Unwind of discount
215
94
309
Currency translation differences
(2)
(2)
(12)
(16)
Balance at 31 December 2023
3,972
2,036
11,867
4,875
22,750
Individually assessed
50
271
321
Collectively assessed
3,972
2,036
11,817
4,604
22,429
Balance at 31 December 2023
3,972
2,036
11,867
4,875
22,750
298
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,475,839
200,463
146,517
2,844
3,825,663
New financial asset originated or purchased
2,729,133
606
1,502
1,685
2,732,926
Transfer to Stage 1
147,013
(147,013)
Transfer to Stage 2
(308,580)
333,045
(24,465)
Transfer to Stage 3
(20,855)
(115,231)
136,086
Assets repaid
(2,273,519)
(81,401)
(65,161)
(1,572)
(2,421,653)
Resegmentation
(75,858)
88
(3,141)
(78,911)
Impact of modifications
(86)
616
(2,971)
(7)
(2,448)
Foreign exchange movement
27,031
1,678
2,494
7
31,210
Net other changes
25,537
677
6,187
130
32,531
Write-offs
(36,568)
(70)
(36,638)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
7,998
124
8,122
Unwind of discount
2,316
56
2,372
Currency translation differences
(15,785)
(1,998)
(2,369)
(20,152)
Balance at 31 December 2023
3,709,870
191,530
168,425
3,197
4,073,022
Individually assessed
29,131
29,131
Collectively assessed
3,709,870
191,530
139,294
3,197
4,043,891
Balance at 31 December 2023
3,709,870
191,530
168,425
3,197
4,073,022
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
20,078
5,448
37,317
659
63,502
New financial asset originated or purchased
16,897
128
17,025
Transfer to Stage 1
4,627
(4,627)
Transfer to Stage 2
(5,665)
11,372
(5,707)
Transfer to Stage 3
(2,902)
(6,647)
9,549
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(754)
(4,692)
29,591
24,145
Assets repaid
(7,515)
(3,001)
(18,747)
(524)
(29,787)
Resegmentation
(1,093)
1,226
(868)
(735)
Impact of modifications
2
19
(1,241)
(7)
(1,227)
Foreign exchange movement
129
149
1,179
(1)
1,456
Net other measurement of ECL
(12,661)
6,463
30,543
596
24,941
Income statement (releases)/charges
(8,935)
262
44,427
64
35,818
Write-offs
(36,568)
(70)
(36,638)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
7,998
124
8,122
Unwind of discount
2,316
56
2,372
Currency translation differences
(139)
(172)
(1,204)
(1,515)
Balance at 31 December 2023
11,004
5,538
54,286
833
71,661
Individually assessed
14,564
14,564
Collectively assessed
11,004
5,538
39,722
833
57,097
Balance at 31 December 2023
11,004
5,538
54,286
833
71,661
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
299
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Consumer loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,243,191
213,875
121,992
22,996
3,602,054
New financial asset originated or purchased
4,547,920
5,818
833
17,964
4,572,535
Transfer to Stage 1
289,459
(289,423)
(36)
Transfer to Stage 2
(473,300)
524,075
(50,775)
Transfer to Stage 3
(72,199)
(110,688)
182,887
Assets repaid
(3,179,954)
(107,858)
(69,753)
(12,030)
(3,369,595)
Resegmentation
(494)
(32)
517
(9)
Impact of modifications
699
(11)
(12,180)
(600)
(12,092)
Foreign exchange movement
5,109
65
524
89
5,787
Net other changes
(508)
(1,333)
21,566
595
20,320
Write-offs
(113,820)
(2,408)
(116,228)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
25,870
1,376
27,246
Unwind of discount
4,199
530
4,729
Currency translation differences
(34,164)
(259)
(355)
(34,778)
Balance at 31 December 2023
4,325,759
234,229
111,469
28,512
4,699,969
Individually assessed
(1)
2,464
2,463
Collectively assessed
4,325,760
234,229
109,005
28,512
4,697,506
Balance at 31 December 2023
4,325,759
234,229
111,469
28,512
4,699,969
Consumer loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
40,598
19,309
67,956
7,587
135,450
New financial asset originated or purchased
128,968
702
380
130,050
Transfer to Stage 1
19,103
(19,094)
(9)
Transfer to Stage 2
(23,869)
54,205
(30,336)
Transfer to Stage 3
(49,393)
(21,319)
70,712
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(2,120)
(24,929)
26,592
(457)
Assets repaid
(41,913)
(8,393)
(41,821)
(4,886)
(97,013)
Resegmentation
(9)
(2)
(2)
(13)
Impact of modifications
13
(7)
(5,235)
(122)
(5,351)
Foreign exchange movement
13
4
34
(4)
47
Net other measurement of ECL
(29,175)
17,623
59,529
5,681
53,658
Income statement (releases)/charges
1,618
(1,210)
79,844
669
80,921
Write-offs
(113,820)
(2,408)
(116,228)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
25,870
1,376
27,246
Unwind of discount
4,199
530
4,729
Currency translation differences
(269)
(55)
(161)
(485)
Balance at 31 December 2023
41,947
18,044
63,888
7,754
131,633
Individually assessed
1,062
1,062
Collectively assessed
41,947
18,044
62,826
7,754
130,571
Balance at 31 December 2023
41,947
18,044
63,888
7,754
131,633
300
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
147,525
8,613
8,416
164,554
New financial asset originated or purchased
103,553
401
103,954
Transfer to Stage 1
11,660
(11,660)
Transfer to Stage 2
(16,775)
18,268
(1,493)
Transfer to Stage 3
(2,147)
(2,800)
4,947
Assets repaid
(106,379)
(3,676)
(2,124)
(112,179)
Resegmentation
(335)
(335)
Foreign exchange movement
(2)
(1)
(48)
(51)
Net other changes
(19)
(48)
(746)
(813)
Write-offs
(5,438)
(5,438)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
(13)
(13)
Unwind of discount
549
549
Balance at 31 December 2023
137,416
8,696
4,116
150,228
Collectively assessed
137,416
8,696
4,116
150,228
Balance at 31 December 2023
137,416
8,696
4,116
150,228
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
70
32
5,339
5,441
Transfer to Stage 1
32
(32)
Transfer to Stage 2
(19)
184
(165)
Transfer to Stage 3
(2)
(8)
10
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(1)
(1)
Assets repaid
(24)
(8)
1,007
975
Net other measurement of ECL
(13)
(143)
33
(123)
Income statement (releases)/charges
(26)
(8)
885
851
Write-offs
(5,438)
(5,438)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
(13)
(13)
Unwind of discount
549
549
Balance at 31 December 2023
44
24
1,322
1,390
Collectively assessed
44
24
1,322
1,390
Balance at 31 December 2023
44
24
1,322
1,390
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
301
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Commercial loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
4,934,312
374,933
226,925
18,014
5,554,184
New financial asset originated or purchased
4,574,787
34,779
693
6,969
4,617,228
Transfer to Stage 1
202,422
(202,422)
Transfer to Stage 2
(773,437)
803,734
(30,297)
Transfer to Stage 3
(5,553)
(98,586)
104,139
Assets derecognised due to pass-through arrangement
(23,721)
(20)
(83)
(23,824)
Assets repaid
(4,092,938)
(217,064)
(83,154)
(9,763)
(4,402,919)
Resegmentation
194,578
2,622
(6,567)
190,633
Impact of modifications
1,330
1,983
184
2
3,499
Foreign exchange movement
(512,131)
(89,055)
(24,259)
(1,843)
(627,288)
Net other changes
45,923
1,454
6,277
(653)
53,001
Write-offs
(55,962)
(55,962)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
42,501
2,865
45,366
Unwind of discount
(1,921)
359
(1,562)
Currency translation differences
(33,751)
(1,051)
(1,888)
(36,690)
Balance at 31 December 2022
4,511,821
611,307
176,588
15,950
5,315,666
Individually assessed
159,486
13,603
173,089
Collectively assessed
4,511,821
611,307
17,102
2,347
5,142,577
Balance at 31 December 2022
4,511,821
611,307
176,588
15,950
5,315,666
Commercial loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
14,338
6,893
135,061
2,923
159,215
New financial asset originated or purchased
23,237
166
230
2,997
26,630
Transfer to Stage 1
4,323
(4,323)
Transfer to Stage 2
(6,172)
12,308
(6,136)
Transfer to Stage 3
(485)
(1,503)
1,988
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(2,382)
(3,448)
28,233
22,403
Assets derecognised due to pass-through arrangement
(62)
(34)
(96)
Assets repaid
(10,492)
(4,325)
(59,872)
(3,151)
(77,840)
Resegmentation
5,404
(27)
(997)
4,380
Impact of modifications
30
104
1
2
137
Foreign exchange movement
(921)
(1,696)
(10,613)
(883)
(14,113)
Net other measurement of ECL
(6,810)
20,460
(25,291)
(547)
(12,188)
Income statement (releases)/charges
5,670
17,716
(72,491)
(1,582)
(50,687)
Write-offs
(55,962)
(55,962)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
42,501
2,865
45,366
Unwind of discount
(1,921)
359
(1,562)
Currency translation differences
(793)
(1,079)
(2,941)
(4,813)
Balance at 31 December 2022
19,215
23,530
44,247
4,565
91,557
Individually assessed
37,492
4,493
41,985
Collectively assessed
19,215
23,530
6,755
72
49,572
Balance at 31 December 2022
19,215
23,530
44,247
4,565
91,557
302
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
3,629,369
259,970
104,514
28,205
4,022,058
New financial asset originated or purchased
1,466,957
14
13,524
1,480,495
Transfer to Stage 1
403,540
(403,398)
(142)
Transfer to Stage 2
(375,932)
443,567
(67,635)
Transfer to Stage 3
(45,171)
(49,817)
94,988
Assets repaid
(901,792)
(57,945)
(49,096)
(10,849)
(1,019,682)
Resegmentation
(603)
(603)
Impact of modifications
179
37
(2,949)
(169)
(2,902)
Foreign exchange movement
(254,899)
(20,553)
(10,022)
(2,527)
(288,001)
Net other changes
8,928
(2,211)
348
155
7,220
Write-offs
(4,445)
(730)
(5,175)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
3,937
357
4,294
Unwind of discount
182
109
291
Currency translation differences
(4,670)
(98)
(23)
(4,791)
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,925,906
169,566
69,657
28,075
4,193,204
Individually assessed
2,940
2,940
Collectively assessed
3,925,906
169,566
66,717
28,075
4,190,264
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,925,906
169,566
69,657
28,075
4,193,204
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
9,703
3,803
17,039
2,493
33,038
New financial asset originated or purchased
14,452
2,403
16,855
Transfer to Stage 1
5,673
(5,608)
(65)
Transfer to Stage 2
(3,236)
15,977
(12,741)
Transfer to Stage 3
(7,463)
(1,484)
8,947
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(1,807)
(10,903)
6,767
(5,943)
Assets repaid
(1,731)
(961)
(11,220)
(2,103)
(16,015)
Impact of modifications
4
1
937
64
1,006
Foreign exchange movement
(244)
(122)
(1,652)
(498)
(2,516)
Net other measurement of ECL
(6,487)
1,898
6,399
2,412
4,222
Income statement (releases)/charges
(839)
(1,202)
(2,628)
2,278
(2,391)
Write-offs
(4,445)
(730)
(5,175)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
3,937
357
4,294
Unwind of discount
182
109
291
Currency translation differences
(2)
(2)
Balance at 31 December 2022
8,862
2,601
14,085
4,507
30,055
Individually assessed
576
576
Collectively assessed
8,862
2,601
13,509
4,507
29,479
Balance at 31 December 2022
8,862
2,601
14,085
4,507
30,055
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
303
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
3,280,149
293,473
151,499
6,635
3,731,756
New financial asset originated or purchased
2,953,940
7,854
1,859
2,435
2,966,088
Transfer to Stage 1
337,049
(337,049)
Transfer to Stage 2
(442,020)
501,877
(59,857)
Transfer to Stage 3
(50,683)
(106,474)
157,157
Assets repaid
(2,142,937)
(125,830)
(71,105)
(5,917)
(2,345,789)
Resegmentation
(224,709)
(4,680)
5,034
(224,355)
Impact of modifications
194
139
(2,627)
(36)
(2,330)
Foreign exchange movement
(275,010)
(27,918)
(17,669)
(350)
(320,947)
Net other changes
51,417
168
7,865
38
59,488
Write-offs
(37,629)
(98)
(37,727)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
11,875
79
11,954
Unwind of discount
1,262
58
1,320
Currency translation differences
(11,551)
(1,097)
(1,147)
(13,795)
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,475,839
200,463
146,517
2,844
3,825,663
Individually assessed
39,448
39,448
Collectively assessed
3,475,839
200,463
107,069
2,844
3,786,215
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,475,839
200,463
146,517
2,844
3,825,663
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
28,177
6,556
39,584
124
74,441
New financial asset originated or purchased
38,841
81
97
281
39,300
Transfer to Stage 1
7,921
(7,921)
Transfer to Stage 2
(8,873)
20,802
(11,929)
Transfer to Stage 3
(8,295)
(7,503)
15,798
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(962)
(9,903)
29,077
18,212
Assets repaid
(13,663)
(3,065)
(24,514)
(496)
(41,738)
Resegmentation
(5,935)
(129)
541
(5,523)
Impact of modifications
10
(24)
(1,147)
16
(1,145)
Foreign exchange movement
(1,071)
(114)
(3,448)
(67)
(4,700)
Net other measurement of ECL
(15,929)
6,764
18,514
762
10,111
Income statement (releases)/charges
(7,956)
(1,012)
22,989
496
14,517
Write-offs
(37,629)
(98)
(37,727)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
11,875
79
11,954
Unwind of discount
1,262
58
1,320
Currency translation differences
(143)
(96)
(764)
(1,003)
Balance at 31 December 2022
20,078
5,448
37,317
659
63,502
Individually assessed
10,552
10,552
Collectively assessed
20,078
5,448
26,765
659
52,950
Balance at 31 December 2022
20,078
5,448
37,317
659
63,502
304
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Consumer loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
2,635,438
215,026
107,642
23,199
2,981,305
New financial asset originated or purchased
3,313,393
7,566
969
15,493
3,337,421
Transfer to Stage 1
344,640
(344,445)
(195)
Transfer to Stage 2
(534,425)
608,146
(73,721)
Transfer to Stage 3
(121,557)
(167,897)
289,454
Assets repaid
(2,357,992)
(102,236)
(64,593)
(12,241)
(2,537,062)
Resegmentation
30,506
2,058
1,578
34,142
Impact of modifications
1,152
(84)
(24,515)
(1,236)
(24,683)
Foreign exchange movement
(86,830)
(4,100)
(1,319)
(610)
(92,859)
Net other changes
33,406
(79)
31,671
1,021
66,019
Write-offs
(171,142)
(4,431)
(175,573)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
22,074
879
22,953
Unwind of discount
4,252
922
5,174
Currency translation differences
(14,540)
(80)
(163)
(14,783)
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,243,191
213,875
121,992
22,996
3,602,054
Individually assessed
2,650
2,650
Collectively assessed
3,243,191
213,875
119,342
22,996
3,599,404
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,243,191
213,875
121,992
22,996
3,602,054
Consumer loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
57,083
19,410
58,731
811
136,035
New financial asset originated or purchased
131,916
1,199
478
4,325
137,918
Transfer to Stage 1
26,886
(26,872)
(14)
Transfer to Stage 2
(36,429)
72,075
(35,646)
Transfer to Stage 3
(61,445)
(37,845)
99,290
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(3,821)
(29,191)
48,501
15,489
Assets repaid
(41,829)
(8,884)
(38,047)
(3,763)
(92,523)
Resegmentation
531
156
456
1,143
Impact of modifications
121
(12)
(10,792)
122
(10,561)
Foreign exchange movement
(191)
(60)
(763)
(63)
(1,077)
Net other measurement of ECL
(32,188)
29,344
90,779
8,785
96,720
Income statement (releases)/charges
(16,449)
(90)
154,242
9,406
147,109
Write-offs
(171,142)
(4,431)
(175,573)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
22,074
879
22,953
Unwind of discount
4,252
922
5,174
Currency translation differences
(36)
(11)
(201)
(248)
Balance at 31 December 2022
40,598
19,309
67,956
7,587
135,450
Individually assessed
1,054
1,054
Collectively assessed
40,598
19,309
66,902
7,587
134,396
Balance at 31 December 2022
40,598
19,309
67,956
7,587
135,450
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
305
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
152,787
10,116
2,514
165,417
New financial asset originated or purchased
122,438
1
54
122,493
Transfer to Stage 1
17,460
(17,460)
Transfer to Stage 2
(24,040)
25,642
(1,602)
Transfer to Stage 3
(7,251)
(2,757)
10,008
Assets repaid
(112,603)
(6,938)
(4,054)
(123,595)
Resegmentation
228
(45)
183
Foreign exchange movement
(33)
(4)
4
(33)
Net other changes
(1,461)
13
2,196
748
Write-offs
(635)
(635)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
(25)
(25)
Unwind of discount
1
1
Balance at 31 December 2022
147,525
8,613
8,416
164,554
Individually assessed
4,337
4,337
Collectively assessed
147,525
8,613
4,079
160,217
Balance at 31 December 2022
147,525
8,613
8,416
164,554
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
1,823
11
241
2,075
Transfer to Stage 1
27
(27)
Transfer to Stage 2
(16)
149
(133)
Transfer to Stage 3
(2,502)
(6)
2,508
Assets repaid
(18)
(6)
(30)
(54)
Net other measurement of ECL
756
(89)
3,412
4,079
Income statement (releases)/charges
(1,753)
21
5,757
4,025
Write-offs
(635)
(635)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
(25)
(25)
Unwind of discount
1
1
Balance at 31 December 2022
70
32
5,339
5,441
Individually assessed
4,337
4,337
Collectively assessed
70
32
1,002
1,104
Balance at 31 December 2022
70
32
5,339
5,441
306
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Commercial loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
4,491,078
382,118
241,821
8,376
5,123,393
New financial asset originated or purchased
4,357,093
34,815
3,202
10,032
4,405,142
Transfer to Stage 1
231,287
(229,399)
(1,888)
Transfer to Stage 2
(373,532)
394,553
(21,021)
Transfer to Stage 3
(13,813)
(52,529)
66,342
Assets derecognised due to pass-through arrangement
(28,338)
(2,048)
(124)
(30,510)
Assets repaid
(3,479,338)
(159,200)
(102,689)
(144)
(3,741,371)
Resegmentation
109,367
35,325
2,164
146,856
Impact of modifications
686
258
152
(22)
1,074
Foreign exchange movement
(361,065)
(27,796)
(9,555)
(380)
(398,796)
Net other changes
13,629
(806)
3,810
79
16,712
Write-offs
(4,574)
(4,574)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
47,192
69
47,261
Unwind of discount
2,959
4
2,963
Currency translation differences
(12,742)
(358)
(866)
(13,966)
Balance at 31 December 2021
4,934,312
374,933
226,925
18,014
5,554,184
Individually assessed
203,431
9,566
212,997
Collectively assessed
4,934,312
374,933
23,494
8,448
5,341,187
Balance at 31 December 2021
4,934,312
374,933
226,925
18,014
5,554,184
Commercial loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
33,823
8,157
136,572
4
178,556
New financial asset originated or purchased
20,591
1,973
312
3,481
26,357
Transfer to Stage 1
2,934
(2,932)
(2)
Transfer to Stage 2
(2,904)
11,116
(8,212)
Transfer to Stage 3
(1,769)
(374)
2,143
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(1,373)
(6,710)
10,153
2,070
Assets derecognised due to pass-through arrangement
(138)
(74)
(70)
(282)
Assets repaid
(9,412)
(3,694)
(67,366)
(80)
(80,552)
Resegmentation
192
298
490
Impact of modifications
11
(2)
12
(14)
7
Foreign exchange movement
(942)
(141)
(5,254)
10
(6,327)
Net other measurement of ECL
(26,543)
(648)
21,578
(551)
(6,164)
Income statement (releases)/charges
(19,353)
(1,188)
(46,706)
2,846
(64,401)
Write-offs
(4,574)
(4,574)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
47,192
69
47,261
Unwind of discount
2,959
4
2,963
Currency translation differences
(132)
(76)
(382)
(590)
Balance at 31 December 2021
14,338
6,893
135,061
2,923
159,215
Individually assessed
126,724
2,837
129,561
Collectively assessed
14,338
6,893
8,337
86
29,654
Balance at 31 December 2021
14,338
6,893
135,061
2,923
159,215
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
307
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
3,287,844
314,215
168,476
25,849
3,796,384
New financial asset originated or purchased
1,549,472
238
103
13,615
1,563,428
Transfer to Stage 1
428,840
(407,795)
(21,045)
Transfer to Stage 2
(344,981)
588,640
(243,659)
Transfer to Stage 3
(158,425)
(129,954)
288,379
Assets repaid
(975,730)
(94,131)
(73,544)
(9,287)
(1,152,692)
Resegmentation
5,514
970
6,484
Impact of modifications
988
670
143
(283)
1,518
Foreign exchange movement
(155,793)
(11,366)
(9,238)
(1,648)
(178,045)
Net other changes
(6,450)
(1,472)
(590)
300
(8,212)
Write-offs
(5,750)
(561)
(6,311)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
993
205
1,198
Unwind of discount
244
17
261
Currency translation differences
(1,910)
(45)
2
(2)
(1,955)
Balance at 31 December 2021
3,629,369
259,970
104,514
28,205
4,022,058
Individually assessed
277
277
Collectively assessed
3,629,369
259,970
104,237
28,205
4,021,781
Balance at 31 December 2021
3,629,369
259,970
104,514
28,205
4,022,058
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
8,652
11,410
25,236
3,311
48,609
New financial asset originated or purchased
29,065
3
4
887
29,959
Transfer to Stage 1
15,750
(12,962)
(2,788)
Transfer to Stage 2
(5,679)
46,641
(40,962)
Transfer to Stage 3
(18,908)
(5,725)
24,633
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(5,562)
(37,935)
22,414
(21,083)
Assets repaid
(2,621)
(2,674)
(12,902)
(1,763)
(19,960)
Resegmentation
21
1
22
Impact of modifications
438
(198)
240
Foreign exchange movement
(470)
101
(1,732)
(409)
(2,510)
Net other measurement of ECL
(10,545)
4,943
7,211
1,004
2,613
Income statement (releases)/charges
1,051
(7,607)
(3,684)
(479)
(10,719)
Write-offs
(5,750)
(561)
(6,311)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
993
205
1,198
Unwind of discount
244
17
261
Balance at 31 December 2021
9,703
3,803
17,039
2,493
33,038
Individually assessed
7
7
Collectively assessed
9,703
3,803
17,032
2,493
33,031
Balance at 31 December 2021
9,703
3,803
17,039
2,493
33,038
308
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
2,649,107
439,405
177,471
3,471
3,269,454
New financial asset originated or purchased
3,303,744
17,798
1,152
7,599
3,330,293
Transfer to Stage 1
384,411
(377,752)
(6,659)
Transfer to Stage 2
(571,845)
678,669
(106,824)
Transfer to Stage 3
(108,524)
(112,029)
220,553
Assets repaid
(1,987,068)
(282,948)
(96,106)
(4,718)
(2,370,840)
Resegmentation
(247,911)
(40,492)
(2,790)
(5)
(291,198)
Impact of modifications
319
210
(4,384)
(11)
(3,866)
Foreign exchange movement
(180,781)
(27,138)
(9,910)
(271)
(218,100)
Net other changes
44,191
(1,777)
6,684
73
49,171
Write-offs
(40,195)
(214)
(40,409)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
12,628
686
13,314
Unwind of discount
265
23
288
Currency translation differences
(5,494)
(473)
(386)
2
(6,351)
Balance at 31 December 2021
3,280,149
293,473
151,499
6,635
3,731,756
Individually assessed
23,466
23,466
Collectively assessed
3,280,149
293,473
128,033
6,635
3,708,290
Balance at 31 December 2021
3,280,149
293,473
151,499
6,635
3,731,756
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
26,157
20,571
55,560
64
102,352
New financial asset originated or purchased
58,476
804
92
81
59,453
Transfer to Stage 1
20,352
(18,841)
(1,511)
Transfer to Stage 2
(14,284)
35,909
(21,625)
Transfer to Stage 3
(13,914)
(7,459)
21,373
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(4,218)
(18,652)
27,259
4,389
Assets repaid
(16,879)
(7,632)
(26,573)
(968)
(52,052)
Resegmentation
(1,280)
(476)
(182)
(1,938)
Impact of modifications
2
(7)
(2,180)
1
(2,184)
Foreign exchange movement
(1,020)
(184)
(2,826)
(79)
(4,109)
Net other measurement of ECL
(25,153)
2,557
17,767
530
(4,299)
Income statement (releases)/charges
2,082
(13,981)
11,594
(435)
(740)
Write-offs
(40,195)
(214)
(40,409)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
12,628
686
13,314
Unwind of discount
265
23
288
Currency translation differences
(62)
(34)
(268)
(364)
Balance at 31 December 2021
28,177
6,556
39,584
124
74,441
Individually assessed
10,613
10,613
Collectively assessed
28,177
6,556
28,971
124
63,828
Balance at 31 December 2021
28,177
6,556
39,584
124
74,441
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
309
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Consumer loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
1,904,182
194,366
100,950
8,515
2,208,013
New financial asset originated or purchased
2,747,021
7,001
1,718
19,540
2,775,280
Transfer to Stage 1
270,620
(253,910)
(16,710)
Transfer to Stage 2
(367,600)
489,718
(122,118)
Transfer to Stage 3
(134,641)
(123,558)
258,199
Assets repaid
(1,849,334)
(100,322)
(65,394)
(4,297)
(2,019,347)
Resegmentation
110,449
3,487
706
5
114,647
Impact of modifications
246
82
(9,482)
(46)
(9,200)
Foreign exchange movement
(51,792)
(1,590)
(688)
(223)
(54,293)
Net other changes
12,381
(215)
13,559
(373)
25,352
Write-offs
(72,832)
(415)
(73,247)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
19,405
148
19,553
Unwind of discount
397
345
742
Currency translation differences
(6,094)
(33)
(68)
(6,195)
Balance at 31 December 2021
2,635,438
215,026
107,642
23,199
2,981,305
Individually assessed
1,481
1,481
Collectively assessed
2,635,438
215,026
106,161
23,199
2,979,824
Balance at 31 December 2021
2,635,438
215,026
107,642
23,199
2,981,305
Consumer loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
40,597
25,533
46,641
1,030
113,801
New financial asset originated or purchased
153,477
1,570
546
251
155,844
Transfer to Stage 1
33,951
(26,256)
(7,695)
Transfer to Stage 2
(26,684)
75,148
(48,464)
Transfer to Stage 3
(57,627)
(20,176)
77,803
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(12,239)
(40,279)
53,664
1,146
Assets repaid
(47,437)
(11,239)
(36,001)
(1,449)
(96,126)
Resegmentation
548
83
182
813
Impact of modifications
(2)
(1)
(5,036)
5
(5,034)
Foreign exchange movement
(153)
(37)
(643)
(29)
(862)
Net other measurement of ECL
(27,338)
15,067
30,779
925
19,433
Income statement (releases)/charges
16,496
(6,120)
65,135
(297)
75,214
Write-offs
(72,832)
(415)
(73,247)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
19,405
148
19,553
Unwind of discount
397
345
742
Currency translation differences
(10)
(3)
(15)
(28)
Balance at 31 December 2021
57,083
19,410
58,731
811
136,035
Individually assessed
585
585
Collectively assessed
57,083
19,410
58,146
811
135,450
Balance at 31 December 2021
57,083
19,410
58,731
811
136,035
310
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost, gross:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
97,775
3,879
1,730
103,384
New financial asset originated or purchased
170,198
1,117
219
171,534
Transfer to Stage 1
10,556
(10,148)
(408)
Transfer to Stage 2
(21,129)
23,266
(2,137)
Transfer to Stage 3
(3,856)
(2,531)
6,387
Assets repaid
(123,964)
(6,222)
(3,071)
(133,257)
Resegmentation
22,581
710
(80)
23,211
Foreign exchange movement
(18)
(6)
(3)
(27)
Net other changes
644
51
128
823
Write-offs
(253)
(253)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
3
3
Unwind of discount
(1)
(1)
Balance at 31 December 2021
152,787
10,116
2,514
165,417
Collectively assessed
152,787
10,116
2,514
165,417
Balance at 31 December 2021
152,787
10,116
2,514
165,417
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
40
16
172
228
New financial asset originated or purchased
497
138
635
Transfer to Stage 1
34
(10)
(24)
Transfer to Stage 2
85
(85)
Transfer to Stage 3
(2)
(4)
6
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(24)
(24)
Assets repaid
(177)
(27)
(24)
(228)
Resegmentation
519
94
613
Net other measurement of ECL
936
(281)
447
1,102
Income statement (releases)/charges
1,783
(5)
320
2,098
Write-offs
(253)
(253)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
3
3
Unwind of discount
(1)
(1)
Balance at 31 December 2021
1,823
11
241
2,075
Collectively assessed
1,823
11
241
2,075
Balance at 31 December 2021
1,823
11
241
2,075
The contractual amounts outstanding on all loans to customers that have been written off during the reporting period but are still
subject to enforcement activity was GEL 138,972 (2022: GEL 188,545, 2021: GEL 95,469).
Collateral and other credit enhancements
The amount and type of collateral required depends on an assessment of the credit risk of the counterparty. Guidelines are
implemented regarding the acceptability of types of collateral and valuation parameters.
The main types of collateral obtained are as follows:
For commercial lending, charges over real estate properties, equipment and machinery, corporate shares, inventory, trade
receivables, third-party corporate guarantees and personal guarantees of shareholders.
For retail lending, mortgages over residential properties, cars, gold and jewellery, third-party corporate guarantees and personal
guarantees of shareholders.
Management requests additional collateral in accordance with the underlying agreement and monitors the market value of
collateral obtained during its review of the adequacy of the allowance for expected credit loss/impairment of loans.
It is the Groups policy to dispose of repossessed properties in an orderly fashion or to hold them for capital appreciation or earning
rentals, as appropriate in each case. In general, the Group does not occupy repossessed properties for business use.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
311
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Without taking into account the discounted value of collateral, the ECL for credit-impaired loans would be as follows:
ECL without
taking into
account the
discounted
ECL for credit- value of
2023 impaired loans collateral
Commercial loans
53,067
118,367
Residential mortgage loans
16,742
56,851
Micro and SME loans
55,119
152,430
Consumer loans
71,642
105,437
Gold – pawn loans
1,322
3,290
Total
197,892
436,375
ECL without
taking into
account the
discounted
ECL for credit- value of
2022 impaired loans collateral
Commercial loans
48,812
187,653
Residential mortgage loans
18,592
67,534
Micro and SME loans
37,976
131,404
Consumer loans
75,543
103,597
Gold – pawn loans
5,339
6,947
Total
186,262
497,135
ECL without
taking into
account the
discounted
ECL for credit- value of
2021 impaired loans collateral
Commercial loans
137,984
231,968
Residential mortgage loans
19,532
93,804
Micro and SME loans
39,708
140,929
Consumer loans
59,542
87,891
Gold – pawn loans
241
1,802
Total
257,007
556,394
Concentration of loans to customers
As at 31 December 2023, the concentration of loans granted by the Group to the ten largest third-party borrowers comprised
GEL 1,507,812 accounting for 7% of the gross loan portfolio of the Group (2022: GEL 1,017,629 and 6% respectively, 2021:
GEL 1,375,536 and 8% respectively). An allowance of expected credit loss of GEL 13,524 (2022: GEL 8,209, 2021: GEL 2,770)
was established against these loans.
As at 31 December 2023, the concentration of loans granted by the Group to the ten largest third-party group of borrowers
(borrower and its related parties) comprised GEL 2,414,054 accounting for 12% of the gross loan portfolio of the Group (2022:
GEL 1,736,614 and 10% respectively, 2021: GEL 2,136,228 and 13% respectively). An allowance of expected credit loss of GEL 3,599
(2022: GEL 17,392, 2021: GEL 7,386) was established against these loans.
312
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
As at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, loans were principally issued within Georgia, and their
distribution by industry sector was as follows:
2023
2022
2021
Individuals
11,445,733
10,011,378
9,184,255
Real estate
1,608,487
1,024,364
1,025,298
Manufacturing
1,477,204
1,065,693
1,377,023
Trade
1,476,325
1,135,693
1,189,036
Hospitality
975,621
828,577
946,224
Electricity, gas and water supply
665,454
458,415
384,554
Financial intermediation
401,116
291,778
244,215
Construction
377,857
512,345
379,813
Service
306,465
302,442
307,602
Transport and communication
273,071
190,175
234,512
Mining and quarrying
160,261
148,489
183,270
Other
1,330,767
1,131,792
998,918
Loans to customers, gross
20,498,361
17,101,141
16,454,720
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss
(327,812)
(326,005)
(404,804)
Loans to customers, net
20,170,549
16,775,136
16,049,916
Loans have been extended to the following types of customers:
2023
2022
2021
Individuals
11,445,733
10,011,378
9,184,255
Private companies
9,050,061
7,086,069
7,257,993
State-owned entities
2,567
3,694
12,472
Loans to customers, gross
20,498,361
17,101,141
16,454,720
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss
(327,812)
(326,005)
(404,804)
Loans to customers, net
20,170,549
16,775,136
16,049,916
Finance lease receivables
2023
2022
2021
Minimum lease payments receivable
91,182
120,740
168,508
Less – Unearned finance lease income
(17,695)
(25,392)
(43,556)
73,487
95,348
124,952
Less – Allowance for expected credit loss/impairment loss
(11,315)
(8,778)
(5,895)
Finance lease receivables, net
62,172
86,570
119,057
The difference between the minimum lease payments to be received in the future and the finance lease receivables represents
unearned finance income.
As at 31 December 2023, finance lease receivables carried at GEL 0 were pledged for inter-bank loans received from several credit
institutions (2022: GEL 16,965, 2021: 67,556).
As at 31 December 2023, the concentration of investment in the five largest lease receivables comprised GEL 18,436 or 25% of total
finance lease receivables (2022: GEL 20,515 or 22%, 2021: GEL 22,417 or 18%). An allowance of GEL 474 (2022: GEL 973, 2021: GEL
956) was established against these lease receivables.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
313
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Future minimum lease payments to be received after 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021 are as follows:
2023
2022
2021
Within 1 year
48,985
51,944
76,407
From 1 to 2 years
10,136
22,480
35,929
From 2 to 3 years
7,639
18,109
24,390
From 3 to 4 years
2,053
7,613
14,996
From 4 to 5 years
3,169
3,036
3,159
More than 5 years
19,200
17,559
13,627
Minimum lease payment receivables
91,182
120,740
168,508
Movements of the gross finance lease receivables and respective allowance for expected credit loss/impairment of finance lease
receivables are as follows:
Finance lease receivables, gross
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
59,531
6,451
14,155
15,211
95,348
New financial asset originated or purchased
28,851
10,525
39,376
Transfer to Stage 1
9,296
(8,702)
(594)
Transfer to Stage 2
(17,459)
21,451
(3,992)
Transfer to Stage 3
(1,597)
(10,139)
11,736
Assets repaid
(37,236)
(3,603)
(5,285)
(6,389)
(52,513)
Impact of modifications
(221)
138
(83)
Foreign exchange movement
2,285
198
117
(804)
1,796
Net other changes
987
(2)
(148)
(59)
778
Write-offs
(3,429)
313
(3,116)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
66
66
Unwind of discount
23
284
307
Currency translation differences
(7,420)
(426)
(626)
(8,472)
Balance at 31 December 2023
37,017
5,228
12,161
19,081
73,487
Individually assessed
384
384
Collectively assessed
37,017
5,228
11,777
19,081
73,103
Balance at 31 December 2023
37,017
5,228
12,161
19,081
73,487
Finance lease receivables, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2022
852
258
3,588
4,080
8,778
New financial asset originated or purchased
1,375
1,375
Transfer to Stage 1
275
(262)
(13)
Transfer to Stage 2
(663)
782
(119)
Transfer to Stage 3
(542)
(434)
976
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(142)
238
291
387
Assets repaid
(558)
(184)
(3,122)
(2,394)
(6,258)
Impact of modifications
(2)
(2)
Foreign exchange movement
50
37
4
91
Net other measurement of ECL
353
(56)
5,307
1,565
7,169
Income statement (releases)/charges
146
121
3,324
(829)
2,762
Write-offs
(316)
313
(3)
Recoveries of amounts previously written off
66
66
Unwind of discount
23
284
307
Currency translation differences
179
106
(880)
(595)
Balance at 31 December 2023
1,177
485
5,805
3,848
11,315
Individually assessed
158
158
Collectively assessed
1,177
485
5,647
3,848
11,157
Balance at 31 December 2023
1,177
485
5,805
3,848
11,315
314
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Finance lease receivables, gross
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
81,174
17,584
16,612
9,582
124,952
New financial asset originated or purchased
47,812
12,081
59,893
Transfer to Stage 1
25,182
(19,801)
(5,381)
Transfer to Stage 2
(26,267)
33,605
(7,338)
Transfer to Stage 3
(3,139)
(15,782)
18,921
Assets repaid
(60,440)
(8,077)
(5,299)
(6,537)
(80,353)
Impact of modifications
278
278
Foreign exchange movement
865
(66)
86
885
Net other changes
339
10
213
85
647
Write-offs
(2,724)
(2,724)
Unwind of discount
105
105
Currency translation differences
(6,273)
(1,022)
(1,040)
(8,335)
Balance at 31 December 2022
59,531
6,451
14,155
15,211
95,348
Individually assessed
1,245
1,245
Collectively assessed
59,531
6,451
12,910
15,211
94,103
Balance at 31 December 2022
59,531
6,451
14,155
15,211
95,348
Finance lease receivables, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2021
1,126
763
2,810
1,196
5,895
New financial asset originated or purchased
1,537
1,537
Transfer to Stage 1
1,686
(1,044)
(642)
Transfer to Stage 2
(1,241)
2,013
(772)
Transfer to Stage 3
(188)
(1,253)
1,441
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(1,513)
586
2,104
1,177
Assets repaid
(664)
(299)
(1,645)
(1,856)
(4,464)
Foreign exchange movement
64
(3)
5
66
Net other measurement of ECL
27
(487)
611
4,741
4,892
Income statement (releases)/charges
(292)
(487)
1,102
2,885
3,208
Write-offs
(480)
(480)
Unwind of discount
105
105
Currency translation differences
18
(18)
51
(1)
50
Balance at 31 December 2022
852
258
3,588
4,080
8,778
Individually assessed
352
352
Collectively assessed
852
258
3,236
4,080
8,426
Balance at 31 December 2022
852
258
3,588
4,080
8,778
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
315
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
9. Loans to customers and finance lease receivables continued
Finance lease receivables, gross
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
67,346
53,276
18,750
139,372
New financial asset originated or purchased
90,739
465
3,107
94,311
Transfer to Stage 1
34,761
(34,715)
(46)
Transfer to Stage 2
(43,879)
57,480
(13,601)
Transfer to Stage 3
(3,925)
(33,434)
37,359
Assets repaid
(60,625)
(23,912)
(4,116)
(122)
(88,775)
Impact of modifications
20
20
Foreign exchange movement
(641)
(47)
(66)
(249)
(1,003)
Net other changes
(535)
(7)
20
6,833
6,311
Write-offs
(21,232)
(21,232)
Unwind of discount
10
13
23
Currency translation differences
(2,087)
(1,057)
(931)
(4,075)
Balance at 31 December 2021
81,174
17,584
16,612
9,582
124,952
Individually assessed
2,746
2,746
Collectively assessed
81,174
17,584
13,866
9,582
122,206
Balance at 31 December 2021
81,174
17,584
16,612
9,582
124,952
Finance lease receivables, ECL:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Balance at 31 December 2020
649
1,109
2,618
4,376
New financial asset originated or purchased
1,570
256
1,826
Transfer to Stage 1
684
(683)
(1)
Transfer to Stage 2
(976)
2,371
(1,395)
Transfer to Stage 3
(85)
(1,975)
2,060
Impact on ECL of exposures transferred between stages
during the year
(12)
1,036
2,151
3,175
Assets repaid
(461)
(467)
(361)
(1,289)
Net other measurement of ECL
(207)
(78)
328
1,195
1,238
Income statement (releases)/charges
513
204
3,038
1,195
4,950
Write-offs
(2,704)
(2,704)
Unwind of discount
10
13
23
Currency translation differences
(36)
(550)
(152)
(12)
(750)
Balance at 31 December 2021
1,126
763
2,810
1,196
5,895
Individually assessed
1,236
1,236
Collectively assessed
1,126
763
1,574
1,196
4,659
Balance at 31 December 2021
1,126
763
2,810
1,196
5,895
The Group writes off the finance lease receivable balance when it takes possession of the underlying asset. The difference between
the gross and ECL balances at the time of write-off represents the value of the repossessed asset.
316
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
10. Accounts receivable and other loans
In 2016 the Group disbursed a loan to a client with the purpose to finance the purchase of an industrial asset from one of the
Bank’s defaulted borrowers. As part of the overall financing package, the Group entered into the dual option agreement with the
shareholders of the new borrower over the shares in the new borrower. A dispute arose over the terms of the concluded option
agreement. The outstanding legacy claim was settled at the end of 2022 and the Group recognised GEL 391,100 one-off income with
the respective receivable estimated at fair value in its consolidated financial statements. On 9 January 2023 the Group received part
of the settlement in the amount of GEL 371,922. As for the outstanding receivable, it has been remeasured at fair value (since the
final amount to be received is based in part on profitability of the industrial asset) and the Group recognised additional GEL 22,585
one-off income in its consolidated financial statements in 2023. The receivable was fully settled on 31 January 2024. The Group does
not expect any material tax consequences from this settlement in the foreseeable future.
11. Right-of-use assets and lease liabilities
2023
2022
2021
Right-of-use assets
138,695
117,387
80,186
Lease liability
141,934
114,470
87,662
Administrative expenses include occupancy and rent expenses on lease contracts where the recognition exemptions have been applied:
2023
2022
2021
Short-term leases
(4,872)
(4,672)
(3,982)
Leases of low-value assets
(2,264)
(1,585)
(1,908)
(7,136)
(6,257)
(5,890)
Movement in liabilities arising from financing activities
Movement in
liabilities arising
from financing
activities
Carrying amount at 1 January 2021
95,635
Cash payments for the principal portion of the lease liability
(29,518)
Change in accrued interest
342
Additions
42,242
Other movements*
(21,039)
Carrying amount at 31 December 2021
87,662
Cash payments for the principal portion of the lease liability
(25,980)
Change in accrued interest
1,151
Additions
70,553
Other movements*
(18,916)
Carrying amount at 31 December 2022
114,470
Cash payments for the principal portion of the lease liability
(32,151)
Change in accrued interest
(665)
Additions
64,120
Other movements*
(3,840)
Carrying amount at 31 December 2023
141,934
* Other movement mainly includes translation effect of foreign currency contracts and cancelled lease contracts .
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
317
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
11. Right-of-use assets and lease liabilities continued
The movements in right-of-use assets were as follows:
Office buildings
and service Computers and
centres
equipment
Total
Cost
31 December 2022
181,227
2,333
183,560
Additions
64,385
64,385
Disposals
(16,785)
(16,785)
Currency translation differences
(5,284)
(559)
(5,843)
31 December 2023
223,543
1,774
225,317
Accumulated depreciation
31 December 2022
65,073
1,100
66,173
Depreciation charge
32,601
315
32,916
Disposals
(11,100)
(11,100)
Currency translation differences
(1,051)
(316)
(1,367)
31 December 2023
85,523
1,099
86,622
Net book value
31 December 2022
116,154
1,233
117,387
31 December 2023
138,020
675
138,695
Office buildings
and service Computers and
centres
equipment
Total
Cost
31 December 2021
127,080
2,631
129,711
Additions
74,231
74,231
Disposals
(19,135)
(19,135)
Currency translation differences
(949)
(298)
(1,247)
31 December 2022
181,227
2,333
183,560
Accumulated depreciation
31 December 2021
48,661
864
49,525
Depreciation charge
25,406
345
25,751
Disposals
(8,838)
(8,838)
Currency translation differences
(156)
(109)
(265)
31 December 2022
65,073
1,100
66,173
Net book value
31 December 2021
78,419
1,767
80,186
31 December 2022
116,154
1,233
117,387
Office buildings
and service Computers and
centres
equipment
Total
Cost
31 December 2020
115,970
2,749
118,719
Additions
42,728
42,728
Disposals
(31,478)
(31,478)
Currency translation differences
(140)
(118)
(258)
31 December 2021
127,080
2,631
129,711
Accumulated depreciation
31 December 2020
34,995
516
35,511
Depreciation charge
21,628
388
22,016
Disposals
(7,906)
(7,906)
Currency translation differences
(56)
(40)
(96)
31 December 2021
48,661
864
49,525
Net book value
31 December 2020
80,975
2,233
83,208
31 December 2021
78,419
1,767
80,186
318
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
12. Foreclosed Assets
Foreclosed Assets 2023
2022
2021
At 1 January
119,924
3,216
5,989
Additions
239,872
128,170
2,587
Disposals
(77,324)
(8,063)
(5,168)
Write-down
(2,114)
(3,399)
(192)
Transfers to property and equipment
(3,516)
Transfers to investment property
(3,428)
Currency translation differences
(1,702)
At 31 December
271,712
119,924
3,216
13. Property and equipment
The movements in property and equipment were as follows:
Office
buildings Computers Leasehold
and service Furniture and Motor improve- Assets under
centres and fixtures equipment vehicles ments
construction
Total
Cost
31 December 2022
235,249
193,103
279,259
8,729
29,084
4,755
750,179
Additions
20,485
25,363
28,301
4,573
1,644
17,769
98,135
Transfers
2,557
2,059
8,507
(13,123)
Transfers to investment properties
(641)
(641)
Transfers to assets held for sale
(1,363)
(1,363)
Transfers from foreclosed assets
3,516
3,516
Transfers (to) from other assets
934
(1,421)
(7,714)
(207)
(29)
(243)
(8,680)
Disposals
(26)
(273)
(3,070)
(660)
(222)
(4,251)
Write-offs
(208)
(73)
(284)
(2,979)
(1,088)
(4,632)
Business combination
62
171
66
51
350
Currency translation differences
(2,661)
(452)
(2,128)
(141)
(402)
(34)
(5,818)
31 December 2023
258,050
216,174
296,805
12,076
35,654
8,036
826,795
Accumulated impairment
31 December 2022
2,557
36
98
8
2,699
Impairment charge
19
770
789
31 December 2023
2,557
55
98
8
770
3,488
Accumulated depreciation
31 December 2022
31,325
121,415
177,260
4,615
14,010
348,625
Depreciation charge
5,120
11,825
32,364
1,647
4,839
55,795
Transfers to investment properties
(225)
(1)
(226)
Transfers to assets held for sale
(1,065)
(1,065)
Transfers to other assets
(996)
(5,526)
(203)
(6,725)
Disposals
(10)
(199)
(2,465)
(443)
(217)
(3,334)
Write-offs
(542)
(812)
(85)
(1,967)
(770)
(4,176)
Business combination
13
31
15
42
101
Currency translation differences
(1,272)
(211)
(966)
(29)
(165)
(2,643)
31 December 2023
33,873
131,304
199,886
5,517
16,542
(770)
386,352
Net book value
31 December 2022
201,367
71,652
101,901
4,106
15,074
4,755
398,855
31 December 2023
221,620
84,815
96,821
6,551
19,112
8,036
436,955
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
319
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
13. Property and equipment continued
Office
buildings Computers Leasehold
and service Furniture and Motor improve- Assets under
centres and fixtures equipment vehicles ments
construction
Total
Cost
31 December 2021
216,897
188,890
252,861
6,911
29,328
1,680
696,567
Additions
171
10,853
32,951
2,860
119
31,043
77,997
Transfers
23,333
32
414
3,804
(27,583)
Transfers to investment properties
769
769
Transfers to other assets
(1,571)
(2,135)
(265)
(231)
(4,202)
Disposals
(3,011)
(135)
(1,507)
(489)
(27)
(1)
(5,170)
Write-offs
(29)
(4,750)
(2,513)
(241)
(4,053)
(146)
(11,732)
Currency translation differences
(2,881)
(216)
(812)
(47)
(87)
(7)
(4,050)
31 December 2022
235,249
193,103
279,259
8,729
29,084
4,755
750,179
Accumulated impairment
31 December 2021
2,557
36
98
8
2,699
31 December 2022
2,557
36
98
8
2,699
Accumulated depreciation
31 December 2021
28,859
113,399
154,941
4,095
13,766
315,060
Depreciation charge
4,278
13,814
28,737
1,076
4,369
146
52,420
Transfers
(13)
13
Transfers to investment properties
(155)
(155)
Transfers to other assets
(916)
(2,479)
(230)
(3,625)
Disposals
(795)
(183)
(998)
(176)
(25)
(2,177)
Write-offs
2
(4,598)
(2,473)
(130)
(4,029)
(146)
(11,374)
Currency translation differences
(851)
(114)
(468)
(20)
(71)
(1,524)
31 December 2022
31,325
121,415
177,260
4,615
14,010
348,625
Net book value
31 December 2021
185,481
75,455
97,822
2,808
15,562
1,680
378,808
31 December 2022
201,367
71,652
101,901
4,106
15,074
4,755
398,855
Office
buildings Computers Leasehold
and service Furniture and Motor improve- Assets under
centres and fixtures equipment vehicles ments
construction
Total
Cost
31 December 2020
216,795
178,481
231,436
6,768
34,275
4,732
672,487
Additions
2,056
11,958
31,048
986
10
7,171
53,229
Transfers
6,408
3
976
2,493
(9,880)
Transfers to investment properties
(9,175)
(9,175)
Transfers to assets held for sale
2,245
2,245
Transfers to other assets
(998)
(8,647)
(183)
(9,828)
Disposals
(764)
(433)
(1,719)
(224)
(46)
(3,186)
Write-offs
(71)
(1)
(602)
(7,416)
(8,090)
Currency translation differences
(668)
(50)
(232)
(17)
(34)
(114)
(1,115)
31 December 2021
216,897
188,890
252,861
6,911
29,328
1,680
696,567
Accumulated impairment
31 December 2020
2,557
36
98
8
2,699
31 December 2021
2,557
36
98
8
2,699
Accumulated depreciation
31 December 2020
25,216
102,137
133,958
3,833
16,793
281,937
Depreciation charge
4,201
12,916
24,699
931
4,416
47,163
Transfers to investment properties
(238)
(238)
Transfers to other assets
(1,224)
(2,643)
(3,867)
Disposals
(51)
(318)
(910)
(85)
(1,364)
Write-offs
5
(51)
3
(576)
(7,416)
(8,035)
Currency translation differences
(274)
(61)
(166)
(8)
(27)
(536)
31 December 2021
28,859
113,399
154,941
4,095
13,766
315,060
Net book value
31 December 2020
189,022
76,308
97,380
2,927
17,482
4,732
387,851
31 December 2021
185,481
75,455
97,822
2,808
15,562
1,680
378,808
320
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
14. Intangible assets
The movements in intangible assets were as follows:
Software and
licence
Other
Total
Cost
31 December 2022
247,943
27,449
275,392
Additions
56,537
31
56,568
Disposals
(8,321)
(8,321)
Write-offs
(1,258)
(1,258)
Currency translation differences
(3,560)
(3,560)
31 December 2023
291,341
27,480
318,821
Accumulated impairment
31 December 2022
2,358
2,358
Impairment charge
2,201
2,201
31 December 2023
4,559
4,559
Accumulated amortisation
31 December 2022
117,629
5,964
123,593
Amortisation charge
32,844
178
33,022
Disposals
(7,815)
(7,815)
Write-offs
(1,261)
(1,261)
Currency translation differences
(1,139)
(1,139)
31 December 2023
140,258
6,142
146,400
Net book value
31 December 2022
127,956
21,485
149,441
31 December 2023
146,524
21,338
167,862
Software and
licence
Other
Total
Cost
31 December 2021
219,073
27,286
246,359
Additions
40,506
164
40,670
Disposals
(7,331)
(7,331)
Write-offs
(2,889)
(1)
(2,890)
Currency translation differences
(1,416)
(1,416)
31 December 2022
247,943
27,449
275,392
Accumulated impairment
31 December 2021
Impairment charge
2,358
2,358
31 December 2022
2,358
2,358
Accumulated amortisation
31 December 2021
96,311
5,797
102,108
Amortisation charge
30,392
168
30,560
Disposals
(5,683)
(5,683)
Write-offs
(2,889)
(1)
(2,890)
Currency translation differences
(502)
(502)
31 December 2022
117,629
5,964
123,593
Net book value
31 December 2021
122,762
21,489
144,251
31 December 2022
127,956
21,485
149,441
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
321
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
14. Intangible assets continued
Software and
licence
Other
Total
Cost
31 December 2020
177,012
26,944
203,956
Additions
44,715
342
45,057
Disposals
(741)
(741)
Write-offs
(1,385)
(1,385)
Currency translation differences
(528)
(528)
31 December 2021
219,073
27,286
246,359
Accumulated amortisation
31 December 2020
72,532
5,618
78,150
Amortisation charge
26,090
179
26,269
Disposals
(747)
(747)
Write-offs
(1,385)
(1,385)
Currency translation differences
(179)
(179)
31 December 2021
96,311
5,797
102,108
Net book value
31 December 2020
104,480
21,326
125,806
31 December 2021
122,762
21,489
144,251
15. Investment properties
2023
2022
2021
At 1 January
166,546
226,849
231,241
Additions
4,882
5,871
83,912
Disposals
(38,175)
(54,713)
(68,713)
Net gains from revaluation of investment property
756
7,421
437
Transfers to assets held for sale
(10,756)
(16,955)
(28,390)
Transfers from (to) property and equipment
415
(924)
8,937
Transfers from foreclosed assets
3,428
Currency translation differences
(3,028)
(1,003)
(575)
At 31 December
124,068
166,546
226,849
Investment properties are stated at fair value. The fair value represents the price that would be received to sell an asset in an orderly
transaction between market participants at the measurement date. As at 31 December 2023, the fair values of the properties
are based on valuations performed by accredited independent valuers. Refer to Note 31 for details on fair value measurements of
investment properties.
322
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
16. Goodwill
Movements in goodwill were as follows:
2023
2022
2021
Cost
1 January
57,745
57,745
57,745
Business combination
7,902
At 31 December
65,647
57,745
57,745
Accumulated impairment
1 January
24,394
24,394
24,394
At 31 December
24,394
24,394
24,394
Net book value:
1 January
33,351
33,351
33,351
Business combination
7,902
At 31 December
41,253
33,351
33,351
Impairment test for goodwill
Goodwill acquired through business combinations with indefinite lives have been allocated to two individual cash-generating units
(CGUs), for impairment testing: Corporate Banking and Retail Banking.
The carrying amount of goodwill allocated to each of the CGUs is as follows:
2023
2022
2021
Retail Banking
23,386
23,386
23,386
Corporate Banking
17,867
9,965
9,965
Total
41,253
33,351
33,351
Key assumptions used in value-in-use calculations
The recoverable amounts of the CGUs have been determined based on a value-in-use calculation, using cash flow projections based
on financial budgets approved by senior management covering a one to three-year period. Discount rates were not adjusted for
either a constant or a declining growth rate beyond the three-year periods covered in financial budgets. For the purposes of the
impairment test, a 3% permanent growth rate has been assumed when assessing the future operating cash flows of the CGU
beyond the three-year period covered in financial budgets.
The following discount rates were used by the Group for Corporate Banking and Retail Banking:
Corporate Banking
Retail Banking
2023
2022
2021
2023
2022
2021
Discount rate
5.3%
4.3%
3.9%
6.6%
8.4%
8.1%
Discount rates
Discount rates reflect management’s estimate of return required in each business. This is the benchmark used by management to
assess operating performance and to evaluate future investment proposals. Discount rates are calculated by using pre-tax weighted
average cost of capital (WACC).
For the Retail Banking and Corporate Banking CGUs, the following additional assumptions were made:
stable, business as usual growth of loans and deposits;
no material changes in cost/income structure or ratio; and
stable, business as usual growth of trade finance and other documentary businesses.
Sensitivity to changes in assumptions
Management believes that reasonable possible changes to key assumptions used to determine the recoverable amount for each
CGU will not result in an impairment of goodwill. The excess of value-in-use over carrying value is determined by reference to the net
book value as at 31 December 2023. Possible change was taken as +/-3% in discount rate and growth rate.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
323
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
17. Taxation
The corporate income tax expense in the income statement comprises:
2023
2022
2021
Current income benefit/(expense)
(324,452)
(137,430)
(111,652)
Deferred income tax benefit/(expense)
65,481
(53,221)
36,828
Income tax expense
(258,971)
(190,651)
(74,824)
The income tax rate applicable to most of the Groups income is the income tax rate applicable to subsidiaries’ income, which ranges
from 15% to 25% (2022: from 15% to 25%, 2021: from 15% to 25%).
On 12 June 2018, an amendment to the current corporate taxation model applicable to financial institutions, including banks and
insurance businesses, became effective. The change implied a zero corporate tax rate on retained earnings and a 15% corporate tax rate
on distributed earnings starting from 1 January 2023. On 16 December 2022, an amendment to the corporate tax code was passed into
law abolishing the expected transition to taxation on distributed earnings from 1 January 2023. According to the amendment, which
became effective from 1 January 2023, existing taxation rules for financial institutions, including banks, are to be maintained. At the
same time, the existing corporate tax rate for banks increased from 15% to 20% from 2023 going forward. In addition, with effect from
2023, taxable interest income and deductible ECLs on loans to customers will be defined as per IFRS, instead of local NBG regulations.
Transition differences in ECLs and interest income will be taxed one-off at 15% and 20% respectively.
The change had an immediate impact on deferred tax asset and deferred tax liability balances attributable to previously recognised
temporary differences arising from prior periods. As at 31 December 2022, deferred tax assets and liabilities balances were
remeasured, in line with the updated legislation. The change resulted in a material one-off deferred tax charge as previously the
Bank recognised deferred taxes only to the extent they were expected to realise before 1 January 2023.
The effective income tax rate differs from the statutory income tax rates. As at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and
31 December 2021, a reconciliation of the income tax expense based on statutory rates with the actual expense is as follows:
For the six months ended
2023
2022
2021
Profit before income tax expense
1,656,298
1,634,650
801,942
Statutory tax rate in Georgia
20%
15%
15%
Theoretical income tax expense at average tax rate
(331,260)
(245,198)
(120,291)
Non-taxable income
76,934
115,636
50,671
Non-deductible expenses
(4,520)
(3,229)
(2,931)
Correction of prior year declarations
(2,342)
(2,846)
(15)
Tax at the domestic rates applicable to profits in each country
(1,007)
(1,991)
(2,401)
Effects from changes in tax legislation
110
(53,074)
Tax deductible expenses
7,030
Other
(3,916)
51
143
Income tax expense
(258,971)
(190,651)
(74,824)
Applicable taxes in Georgia and Belarus include corporate income tax (profit tax), individuals’ withholding taxes, property tax and
value added tax, among others. However, regulations are often unclear or non-existent and few precedents have been established.
This creates tax risks in Georgia and Belarus, substantially more significant than typically found in countries with more developed tax
systems. Management believes that the Group is in substantial compliance with the tax laws affecting its operations. However, the
risk remains that relevant authorities could take differing positions with regard to interpretative issues.
As at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, income tax assets and liabilities consist of the following:
2023
2022
2021
Current income tax assets
2,056
224
109
Deferred income tax assets
464
640
183
Income tax assets
2,520
864
292
Current income tax liabilities
185,440
20,258
85,270
Deferred income tax liabilities
13,618
79,275
25,598
Income tax liabilities
199,058
99,533
110,868
324
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
17. Taxation continued
Deferred tax assets and liabilities as at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, and their movements for the
respective years, are as follows:
Origination and reversal of Origination and reversal of Origination and reversal of
temporary differences temporary differences temporary differences
In the income In the income In the income
2020
statement
2021
statement
2022
statement
2023
Tax effect of deductible temporary
differences:
Amounts due to credit institutions
193
193
(30)
163
Investment securities
294
294
(489)
(195)
Investment properties
59
108
167
1,954
2,121
(2,121)
Insurance premiums receivables
Allowances for impairment and provisions
for other losses
Tax losses carried forward
Property and equipment
2,385
29
2,414
(182)
2,232
(1,072)
1,160
Intangible assets
Assets held for sale
465
465
(127)
338
Lease liability
6,006
(2,236)
3,770
19,389
23,159
5,012
28,171
Accruals and deferred income
7,205
12,539
19,744
18,388
38,132
5,393
43,525
Other assets and liabilities
67
368
435
3,845
4,280
1,439
5,719
Deferred tax assets
15,722
10,808
26,530
44,346
70,876
8,005
78,881
Tax effect of taxable temporary differences:
Amounts due to credit institutions
2,228
59
2,287
1,660
3,947
(651)
3,296
Debt securities issued
1,624
(932)
692
1,259
1,951
(414)
1,537
Cash and cash equivalents
Investment securities
Loans to customers and finance lease
receivables
54,066
(24,192)
29,874
30,697
60,571
(57,006)
3,565
Client deposits and notes
176
(176)
104
104
Property and equipment
9,021
(3,121)
5,900
37,342
43,242
4,309
47,551
Right-of-use assets
5,510
(2,294)
3,216
20,606
23,822
3,719
27,541
Investment properties
340
625
965
7,822
8,787
(1,277)
7,510
Intangible assets
Assets held for sale
1,540
(1,055)
485
(485)
Accruals and deferred income
293
(180)
113
(113)
Other assets and liabilities
3,166
5,246
8,412
(1,221)
7,191
(6,260)
931
Deferred tax liabilities
77,964
(26,020)
51,944
97,567
149,511
(57,476)
92,035
Net deferred tax liabilities
(62,242)
36,828
(25,414)
(53,221)
(78,635)
65,481
(13,154)
The Group has not recognised a deferred tax liability for its receivable under settlement discussed in Note 10, as the receivable is
originated in a subsidiary subject to income tax only on distributed profits and the Group does not expect to use these proceeds
for distribution.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
325
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
18. Other assets and other liabilities
Other assets comprise:
2023
2022
2021
Receivables from remittance operations
138,833
86,742
35,041
Inventories
20,969
17,096
11,514
Other receivables
15,932
17,365
17,534
Derivatives margin
12,129
21,053
18,586
Derivative financial assets
10,942
39,270
135,079
Investments in associates
10,699
11,606
10,079
Operating tax assets
7,725
4,809
8,169
Assets purchased for finance lease purposes
2,019
2,140
13,093
Investment securities at FVTPL
2,660
2,146
Other
41,293
29,542
18,487
Other assets, gross
260,541
232,283
269,728
Less – Allowance for impairment of other assets
(15,469)
(17,225)
(14,483)
Other assets, net
245,072
215,058
255,245
Other liabilities comprise:
2023
2022
2021
Payables for remittance operations
59,079
24,671
8,457
Creditors
34,038
29,562
25,814
Derivative financial liabilities
25,779
59,020
7,865
Accounts payable
12,731
5,605
7,708
Provisions
6,304
5,127
6,993
Other taxes payable
4,244
6,504
12,498
Dividends payable to non-controlling shareholders
3,555
2,379
1,746
Advances received
2,034
838
268
Derivatives margin
98,844
Other
19,504
24,985
13,156
Other liabilities
167,268
158,691
183,349
The table below shows the fair values of derivative financial instruments, recorded as assets or liabilities, together with their
notional amounts. The notional amount, recorded gross, is the amount of a derivative’s underlying asset or liability, reference rate
or index and is the basis upon which changes in the value of derivatives are measured. The notional amounts indicate the volume of
transactions outstanding at the year-end and are not indicative of the credit risk.
2023
Notional Fair value
amount
Asset
Liability
Foreign exchange contracts
Forwards and swaps – domestic
1,099,787
2,703
3,712
Forwards and swaps – foreign
3,776,221
8,239
22,067
Interest rate contracts
Forwards and swaps – foreign (IR)
Options – foreign (IR)
Total derivative assets/liabilities
4,876,008
10,942
25,779
2022
2021
Notional Fair value Notional Fair value
amount
Asset
Liability
amount
Asset
Liability
Foreign exchange contracts
Forwards and swaps – domestic
1,392,118
5,688
2,873
1,065,639
931
3,141
Forwards and swaps – foreign
4,615,758
33,234
56,147
5,678,727
131,321
3,339
Interest rate contracts
Forwards and swaps – foreign (IR)
1,209
348
1,129
296
Options – foreign (IR)
7,434
2,531
1,385
Total derivative assets/liabilities
6,009,085
39,270
59,020
6,752,929
135,079
7,865
326
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
19. Client deposits and notes
The amounts due to customers include the following:
2023
2022
2021
Current accounts
12,198,454
11,002,863
6,997,946
Time deposits
8,324,285
7,258,534
7,040,056
Client deposits and notes
20,522,739
18,261,397
14,038,002
Held as security against letters of credit and guarantees
334,092
121,753
117,379
At 31 December 2023, amounts due to customers of GEL 1,955,839 (10%) were due to the ten largest customers (2022: GEL
2,107,058 (12%), 2021: GEL 1,953,107 (14%)).
Amounts due to customers include accounts with the following types of customers:
2023
2022
2021
Individuals
12,907,914
11,188,080
8,501,021
Private enterprises
7,120,507
6,382,083
4,914,845
State and state-owned entities
494,318
691,234
622,136
Client deposits and notes
20,522,739
18,261,397
14,038,002
The breakdown of customer accounts by industry sector is as follows:
2023
2022
2021
Individuals
12,907,914
11,188,080
8,501,021
Financial intermediation
1,451,014
1,261,530
1,280,955
Trade
1,367,858
1,158,977
853,307
Construction
1,140,925
796,019
664,695
Service
822,284
709,442
345,130
Transport and communication
639,882
513,099
418,243
Manufacturing
492,647
759,005
444,095
Government services
445,880
682,809
613,710
Real estate
344,279
232,508
214,082
Hospitality
108,103
173,639
70,375
Electricity, gas and water supply
76,384
186,517
112,244
Other
725,569
599,772
520,145
Client deposits and notes
20,522,739
18,261,397
14,038,002
20. Amounts owed to credit institutions
Amounts due to credit institutions comprise:
2023
2022
2021
Short-term loans from the NBG
2,101,653
1,715,257
1,413,333
Borrowings from international credit institutions
1,794,696
1,439,136
1,839,921
Time deposits and inter-bank loans
130,382
777,638
226,015
Correspondent accounts
431,232
660,767
170,410
4,457,963
4,592,798
3,649,679
Non-convertible subordinated debt
562,520
537,794
668,766
Additional Tier 1
135,526
136,061
Amounts due to credit institutions
5,156,009
5,266,653
4,318,445
During the year ended 31 December 2023, the Group paid up to 9.36% on US$ borrowings from international credit institutions
(2022: up to 7.52%, 2021: up to 4.18%). During the year ended 31 December 2023, the Group paid up to 11.82% on US$ subordinated
debt (2022: up to 10.73%, 2021: up to 7.75%).
Some long-term borrowings from international credit institutions are received upon certain conditions (the ‘Lender Covenants’)
that the Group maintains different limits for capital adequacy, liquidity, currency positions, credit exposures, leverage and others. At
31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, the Group complied with all the Lender Covenants of the significant
borrowings from international credit institutions.
On 31 August 2023, the Bank signed a US$ 100 million loan agreement with Japan International Cooperation Agency as lender with
maturity of five years, which was fully utilised as at 31 December 2023.
On 13 September 2023, the Bank signed a loan agreement with Asian Development Bank as lender with maturity of five years in the
amount of the GEL equivalent of US$ 100 million, which was fully utilised as at 31 December 2023.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
327
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
20. Amounts owed to credit institutions continued
On 31 May 2022, the Bank signed a US$ 50 million Additional Tier 1 Capital Perpetual Subordinated Syndicated Facility with the
European Bank for Reconstruction and Development and Swedfund International AB as lenders. The amount was fully utilised as at
31 December 2022.
In June 2022, the Bank repaid the outstanding US$ 70 million of its initial US$ 90 million subordinated loan facility from the
International Finance Corporation, out of which US$ 42 million qualified as Tier II capital.
21. Debt securities issued
Debt securities issued comprise:
2023
2022
2021
Additional Tier 1 capital notes issued
267,112
267,702
306,239
Tier 2 notes issued
83,158
Eurobonds and notes issued
226,725
932,260
Local bonds
6,810
44,520
151,703
Certificates of deposit
64,279
107,021
128,483
Debt securities issued
421,359
645,968
1,518,685
Changes in liabilities arising from financing activities
Additional Tier
Eurobonds and 1 capital notes Tier 2 notes
notes issued issued issued
Carrying amount at 31 December 2020
1,019,120
323,320
Repurchase of debt securities issued
(28,825)
Repayment of the principal portion of the debt securities issued
(46,706)
Other movements
(11,329)
(17,081)
Carrying amount at 31 December 2021
932,260
306,239
Repurchase of debt securities issued
(617,194)
Repayment of the principal portion of the debt securities issued
(31,581)
Other movements
(56,760)
(38,537)
Carrying amount at 31 December 2022
226,725
267,702
Repurchase of debt securities issued
(20,980)
Repayment of the principal portion of the debt securities issued
(230,995)
Proceeds from Tier 2 notes issued
78,921
Other movements
25,250
(590)
4,237
Carrying amount at 31 December 2023
267,112
83,158
22. Commitments and contingencies
Legal
Sai-invest
As at 31 December 2023, the Bank was engaged in litigation with Sai-Invest LLC (‘Sai-Invest’) in relation to a deposit pledge in the
amount of EUR 7 million for the benefit of LTD Sport Invest’s loans owing to JSC Bank of Georgia. Sai-Invest LLC has challenged
the validity of the deposit pledge in the Georgian courts, and its challenge has been substantially sustained in the Court of Appeal,
a determination which the Bank believes to be erroneous and without merit, and which the Bank has appealed to the Supreme
Court. The matter is currently under review by the Supreme Court, and the timeline as to when the judgement is to be expected is
not available. The Bank’s management is of the opinion that the probability of incurring material losses on this claim is low, and,
accordingly, no provision has been made in these consolidated financial statements.
328
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
22. Commitments and contingencies continued
Financial commitments and contingencies
As at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, the Group’s financial commitments and contingencies comprised
the following:
2023
2022
2021
Credit-related commitments
Financial and performance guarantees issued*
1,918,997
1,717,308
1,686,913
Letters of credit
77,545
116,309
71,676
Undrawn loan facilities
1,014,951
869,061
809,481
3,011,493
2,702,678
2,568,070
Less – Cash held as security against letters of credit and guarantees (Note 19)
(334,092)
(121,753)
(117,379)
Less – Provisions
(6,304)
(5,127)
(6,993)
Operating lease commitments
Not later than 1 year
1,808
1,975
1,875
Later than 1 year but not later than 5 years
2,293
2,592
2,486
Later than 5 years
451
986
4,101
5,018
5,347
Capital expenditure commitments
7,559
6,790
4,539
* Out of total guarantees issued as at 31 December 2023 financial and performance guarantees of the Group comprised GEL 1,162,825 (31 December 2022: GEL 988,094,
31 December 2021: GEL 1,030,122) and GEL 756,172 (31 December 2022: GEL 729,214, 31 December 2021: GEL 656,791), respectively.
The Group discloses its undrawn loan facility balances based on the contractual terms and existing practice in regards to
disbursement of these amounts. The balances are disclosed as commitments if the Group has an established practice of disbursing
undrawn amounts without any subsequent approval.
23. Equity
Share capital
As at 31 December 2023 issued share capital comprised 45,766,293 (31 December 2022: 47,498,982 31 December 2021: 49,169,428)
common shares of BOGG, all of which were fully paid. Each share has a nominal value of one (1) British penny. Shares issued and
outstanding as at 31 December 2023 are described below:
Number of Share
ordinary shares Capital
31 December 2020
49,169,428
1,618
31 December 2021
49,169,428
1,618
Buyback and cancellation of own shares
(1,670,446)
(55)
31 December 2022
47,498,982
1,563
Buyback and cancellation of own shares
(1,732,689)
(57)
31 December 2023
45,766,293
1,506
In the second half of 2022, the Group commenced a share buyback and cancellation programme in amount of GEL 112,700 to reduce
its share capital and consistent with its dividend and capital distribution policy to target a dividend/share buyback payout ratio in
the range of 30-50% of annual profits. The Group appointed Numis Securities Limited to manage the programme and purchase
shares in the open market. The share buyback and cancellation programme was completed by the end of 2022 with purchased and
cancelled ordinary shares of 1,670,446.
On 16 February 2023, the Group’s Board of Directors approved a GEL 147,984 share buyback and cancellation programme. The share
buyback and cancellation programme was completed by June 2023 with purchased and cancelled ordinary shares of 1,584,259.
On 17 August 2023, the Group’s Board of Directors approved a GEL 62,000 share buyback and cancellation programme.
Treasury shares
Treasury shares are held by the Group solely for the purpose of future employee share-based compensation.
The number of treasury shares held by the Group as at 31 December 2023, comprised 2,155,535 (31 December 2022: 2,516,151,
31 December 2021: 2,268,446), with a nominal amount of GEL 71 (31 December 2022: GEL 83, 31 December 2021: GEL 75).
Dividends
Shareholders are entitled to dividends in pounds sterling.
In 2023, 2022 and 2021 the Group distributed dividends on the shares vested and exercised during 2023, 2022 and 2021, respectively.
On 17 August 2023, the Board of Directors of Bank of Georgia Group PLC declared an interim dividend for 2023 of Georgian Lari
3.06 per share. The currency conversion period was set to be for the period 2 October to 6 October 2023, with the official GEL:GBP
exchange rate of 3.2559, resulting in a GBP-denominated final dividend of 0.9398 per share. Payment of the total GEL 134,078
interim dividends was received by shareholders on 27 October 2023.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
329
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
23. Equity continued
On 19 May 2023, the shareholders of Bank of Georgia Group PLC declared a final dividend for 2022 of Georgian Lari 5.80 per share.
The currency conversion period was set to be for the period 26 June to 30 June 2023, with the official GEL:GBP exchange rate of
3.3360, resulting in a GBP-denominated final dividend of 1.7386 per share. Payment of the total GEL 262,549 final dividends was
received by shareholders on 14 July 2023.
On 16 August 2022, the Board of Directors of Bank of Georgia Group PLC declared an interim dividend for 2022 of Georgian Lari
1.85 per share. The currency conversion period was set to be for the period 3 October to 7 October 2022, with the official GEL:GBP
exchange rate of 3.1671, resulting in a GBP-denominated final dividend of 0.5841 per share. Payment of the total GEL 84,418 interim
dividends was received by shareholders on 20 October 2022.
On 20 June 2022, the shareholders of Bank of Georgia Group PLC declared a final dividend for 2021 of Georgian Lari 2.33 per share.
The currency conversion period was set to be for the period 27 June to 1 July 2022, with the official GEL:GBP exchange rate of
3.5858, resulting in a GBP-denominated final dividend of 0.6498 per share. Payment of the total GEL 112,096 final dividends was
received by shareholders on 11 July 2022.
On 17 August 2021, the Board of Directors of Bank of Georgia Group PLC declared an interim dividend for 2021 of Georgian Lari 1.48
per share. The currency conversion period was set to be 18 to 22 October 2021, with the official GEL:GBP exchange rate of 4.3219,
resulting in a GBP-denominated final dividend of 0.3424 per share. Payment of the total GEL 71,838 interim dividends was received
by shareholders on 5 November 2021.
Nature and purpose of other reserves
Unrealised gains and losses on investment securities
This reserve records fair value changes on investment securities.
Unrealised gains and losses from dilution or sale/acquisition of shares in existing subsidiaries
This reserve records unrealised gains and losses from dilution or sale/acquisition of shares in existing subsidiaries.
Foreign currency translation reserve
The foreign currency translation reserve is used to record exchange differences arising from the translation of the financial
statements of subsidiaries with functional currency other than GEL.
Movements on this account during the years ended 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021 are presented in
the statements of other comprehensive income.
The movements in foreign currency translation reserve were as follows:
Foreign
currency
translation
reserve
31 December 2020
(56,876)
Loss from currency translation differences
(3,949)
31 December 2021
(60,825)
Loss from currency translation differences
(9,451)
31 December 2022
(70,276)
Loss from currency translation differences
(8,344)
31 December 2023
(78,620)
Earnings per share
2023
2022
2021
Basic earnings per share
Profit for the year attributable to ordinary shareholders of the Group
1,391,277
1,439,507
723,806
Weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding during the year
44,454,395
46,443,820
47,543,881
Basic earnings per share
31.2967
30.9946
15.2240
2023
2022
2021
Diluted earnings per share
Effect of dilution on weighted average number of ordinary shares:
Dilutive unvested share options
1,273,359
1,013,330
1,098,682
Weighted average number of ordinary shares adjusted for the effect of dilution
45,727,754
47,457,150
48,642,563
Diluted earnings per share
30.4252
30.3328
14.8801
330
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
24. Net interest income
2023
2022
2021
Interest income calculated using EIR method
2,734,208
2,236,307
1,822,307
From loans to customers
2,315,010
1,917,053
1,614,647
From investment securities
356,945
297,528
199,802
From amounts due from credit institutions
76,633
47,864
18,312
Net (losses)/gains on modification of financial assets
(14,380)
(26,138)
(10,454)
Other interest income
14,053
20,574
28,737
From finance lease receivable
13,962
20,574
28,727
From other assets
91
10
Interest income
2,748,261
2,256,881
1,851,044
On client deposits and notes
(796,724)
(569,436)
(497,742)
On amounts owed to credit institutions
(290,198)
(426,950)
(297,953)
On debt securities issued
(45,305)
(84,990)
(112,431)
Interest element of cross-currency swaps
25,276
29,402
30,632
On lease liability
(5,617)
(4,855)
(4,980)
Interest expense
(1,112,568)
(1,056,829)
(882,474)
Deposit insurance fees
(20,247)
(17,717)
(14,629)
Net interest income
1,615,446
1,182,335
953,941
25. Net fee and commission income
2023
2022
2021
Settlements operations
539,537
446,092
307,471
Currency conversion operations
49,370
34,546
15,783
Guarantees and letters of credit
45,323
35,283
34,402
Advisory
33,089
4,241
5,981
Cash operations
24,790
26,896
14,439
Brokerage service fees
8,759
7,676
6,912
Other
6,897
4,731
5,841
Fee and commission income
707,765
559,465
390,829
Settlements operations
(229,251)
(197,089)
(134,390)
Cash operations
(20,315)
(27,211)
(9,626)
Currency conversion operations
(10,146)
(6,403)
(2,571)
Brokerage service fees
(5,587)
(5,079)
(4,894)
Guarantees and letters of credit
(239)
(323)
(724)
Advisory
(301)
(316)
(653)
Other
(7,444)
(5,553)
(5,540)
Fee and commission expense
(273,283)
(241,974)
(158,398)
Net fee and commission income
434,482
317,491
232,431
Revenue from customers
In 2023, the Group recognised GEL 584,860 revenue from contracts with customers in the income statement, including fee and
commission as well as net other income (2022: GEL 481,375, 2021: GEL 341,873).
Contract assets and liabilities
As at 31 December 2023, the Group has recognised GEL 60,165 of revenue-related contract liabilities (2022: GEL 50,451, 2021:
GEL 40,878). Accounts receivables are recognised when the right to consideration becomes unconditional. Deferred revenue is
recognised as revenue as we perform under the contract.
The Group does not adjust the promised amount of consideration for the effects of a significant financing component if the Group
expects, at contract inception, that the period between when the Group transfers a promised good or service to a customer and
when the customer pays for that good or service will be one year or less.
In 2023, the Group recognised GEL 48,303 revenue (2022: GEL 38,495, 2021: GEL 10,619) that relates to carried-forward contract
liabilities and was previously included in the deferred income.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
331
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
25. Net fee and commission income continued
Transaction price allocated to the remaining performance obligations
The following table includes revenue expected to be recognised in the future related to performance obligations that are unsatisfied
at the reporting date:
In 1 year
In 2 years
In 3 years
In 3 to 5 years
In 5 to 10 years
Total
As at 31 December 2023
55,733
2,428
1,325
594
87
60,167
As at 31 December 2022
47,793
2,466
128
46
18
50,451
As at 31 December 2021
39,292
1,119
388
76
3
40,878
26. Salaries and other employee benefits, and general
and administrative expenses
Salaries and other employee benefits
2023
2022
2021
Salaries and bonuses
(405,764)
(350,758)
(272,148)
Social security costs
(7,899)
(6,818)
(5,107)
Pension costs
(5,791)
(4,443)
(3,832)
Salaries and other employee benefits
(419,454)
(362,019)
(281,087)
In 2023, salaries and bonuses include GEL 72,055 of the Equity Compensation Plan costs (2022: GEL 82,025, 2021: GEL 45,307),
associated with the existing share-based compensation scheme approved by the Group (Note 29).
The average number of staff employed by the Group for the years ended 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December
2021, comprised:
2023
2022
2021
The Bank
6,981
6,324
6,012
BNB
802
654
540
Other
1,072
1,041
1,035
Average total number of staff employed
8,855
8,019
7,587
General and administrative expenses
2023
2022
2021
Repairs and maintenance
(56,343)
(47,943)
(40,257)
Marketing and advertising
(44,645)
(35,316)
(23,264)
Legal and other professional services
(31,551)
(17,396)
(14,682)
Operating taxes
(13,397)
(13,539)
(13,393)
Office supplies
(10,097)
(8,571)
(6,562)
Communication
(7,808)
(7,959)
(6,440)
Corporate hospitality and entertainment
(7,361)
(6,181)
(2,022)
Occupancy and rent
(7,136)
(6,257)
(5,890)
Travel expenses
(7,093)
(5,387)
(3,808)
Personnel training and recruitment
(6,956)
(4,304)
(1,895)
Security
(4,369)
(3,219)
(3,461)
Insurance
(3,553)
(3,945)
(3,685)
Other
(5,059)
(4,433)
(4,165)
General and administrative expenses
(205,368)
(164,450)
(129,524)
Increase in expenses related to legal and other professional services was partly attributable to the transaction costs incurred in
relation to the acquisition of Ameriabank as well as the consulting projects in IT and several other business areas (totalling GEL
10.5 million).
332
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
26. Salaries and other employee benefits, and general
and administrative expenses continued
Auditor remuneration
Auditor remuneration comprises:
2023
2022
2021
Fees payable for the audit of the Company’s current year Annual Report
971
770
635
Fees payable for other services:
Audit of the Company’s subsidiaries
1,048
905
968
Total audit fees
2,019
1,675
1,603
Audit-related assurance services:
Review of the Company’s and subsidiaries’ interim accounts
539
397
366
Other assurance services
32
32
31
Total audit-related fees
571
429
397
Non-audit services:
Other assurance services
4,620
12
12
Total other services fees
4,620
12
12
Total fees
7,210
2,116
2,012
The figures shown in the above table relate to the fees of Ernst & Young LLP (‘EY’) and its associates. In 2023, fees paid to other
auditors not associated with EY in respect of the audit of the Parent and Groups subsidiaries were GEL 1,031 (2022: GEL 247, 2021:
GEL 273), and in respect of other services of the Group were GEL 1,605 (2022: GEL 579, 2021: GEL 823). In 2023 other non-audit
assurance services are related to the acquisition of Ameriabank.
27. Cost of risk
The table below shows ECL charges on financial instruments and provision for guarantees for the year recorded in the
income statement:
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Individual
Collective
Individual
Collective
Individual
Collective
POCI
Total
Cash and cash equivalents
(182)
(182)
Amounts due from credit institutions
4,260
4,260
Investment securities measured at
amortised cost – debt instruments
3,284
3,284
Investment securities measured at FVOCI –
debt instruments
(1,937)
(1,937)
Loans to customers at amortised cost
17,054
(8,060)
(446)
(129,119)
(3,727)
(124,298)
Loans to customers at FVTPL
Finance lease receivables
(146)
(121)
(92)
(3,232)
829
(2,762)
Accounts receivable and other loans
(81)
(81)
Other financial assets
(3,854)
(1)
(3,855)
Financial and performance guarantees
284
(2)
24
5
311
Letter of credit to customers
15
15
Other financial commitments
721
13
734
For the year ended 31 December 2023
23,353
(8,170)
(4,449)
(132,347)
(2,898)
(124,511)
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Individual
Collective
Individual
Collective
Individual
Collective
POCI
Total
Cash and cash equivalents
(334)
(334)
Amounts due from credit institutions
(5,179)
(5,179)
Investment securities measured at
amortised cost – debt instruments
(2,387)
(2,387)
Investment securities measured at FVOCI –
debt instruments
(3,896)
(3,896)
Loans to customers at amortised cost
21,327
(15,433)
53,195
(177,169)
(10,598)
(128,678)
Finance lease receivables
292
487
784
(1,886)
(2,885)
(3,208)
Accounts receivable and other loans
(255)
(255)
Other financial assets
(4,205)
(4,205)
Financial and performance guarantees
(437)
6
32
2
(397)
Letter of credit to customers
(33)
65
32
Other financial commitments
140
292
432
For the year ended 31 December 2022
5,288
(14,648)
53,821
(179,053)
(13,483)
(148,075)
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
333
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
27. Cost of risk continued
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Individual
Collective
Individual
Collective
Individual
Collective
POCI
Total
Cash and cash equivalents
48
48
Amounts due from credit institutions
66
66
Investment securities measured at
amortised cost – debt instruments
763
763
Investment securities measured at FVOCI –
debt instruments
1,090
1,090
Loans to customers at amortised cost
(2,059)
28,901
4,632
(31,291)
(1,635)
(1,452)
Finance lease receivables
(513)
(204)
(264)
(2,774)
(1,195)
(4,950)
Accounts receivable and other loans
(117)
(117)
Other financial assets
(2,621)
(2,621)
Financial and performance guarantees
6,599
53
3,733
(7)
10,378
Letter of credit to customers
1,543
328
1,871
Other financial commitments
(1,136)
(443)
(1,579)
For the year ended 31 December 2021
(117)
3,780
28,307
8,429
(34,072)
(2,830)
3,497
In addition, in 2023 the ECL charge includes GEL 500 (2022: GEL 16,105) cost incurred by the Group through synthetic agreement
to accelerate the recovery process related to one of its defaulted borrowers. Such cost is not reflected in the ECL movement, but
recorded directly through consolidated income statement.
Impairment charge on other assets and provisions comprise:
2023
2022
2021
Litigation provision reversal/(charge)
(2,946)
46,645
(35,584)
Impairment (charge)/reversal on assets held for sale
(4,550)
(4,296)
(3,805)
Other impairment charge
(12,057)
(13,342)
(15,520)
Impairment charge on other assets and provisions
(19,553)
29,007
(54,909)
28. Net other gains/(losses)
2023
2022
2021
Net real estate gains/(losses)
91,868
20,498
33,206
Net gains/(losses) on derecognition of financial assets measured at fair value through
other comprehensive income
12,520
7,921
30,044
Net gains/(losses) on financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
(660)
(2,710)
760
Net gains/(losses) from revaluation of investment property
756
7,421
437
Net other gains/(losses)
9,687
11,679
8,651
Net other gains/(losses)
114,171
44,809
73,098
During 2021-2023, the Group repossessed significant movable and immovable assets from its defaulted group of borrowers via
public auction as a result of bankruptcy proceedings of the borrower at a deep discount. The properties were classified as Foreclosed
Assets and measured at the lower of cost and net realisable value. The Group managed to realise large properties at then current
market prices in 2023 and recorded the respective real estate gain in an amount of GEL 81,327 in its consolidated financial
statements.
334
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
29. Share-based payments
Executives’ Equity Compensation Plan (EECP) and Employees’ Equity Compensation Plan
In 2015, the Group set up the Executive Equity Compensation Trustee – Sanne Fiduciary Services Limited (the ‘Trustee’) which acts as
the trustee of the Group’s EECP. In 2023, the Trustee has repurchased 585,864 shares (2022: 695,750 shares, 2021: 699,998 shares).
In 2019, the Group set up the Groups Employee Equity Compensation Trustee – Sanne Fiduciary Services Limited (the ‘Trustee’)
which acts as the trustee of Employees’ Equity Compensation Plan. In 2023, the Trustee has repurchased 172,951 shares (2022:
319,231 shares, 2021: 485,820 shares).
Share-based payment transactions fixed in monetary terms
In 2022, the Group introduced the new remuneration policy for the Management Board and Key Material Risk Taker (MRT)
employees. Under the new policy, part of the fixed component of the remuneration is fixed in monetary terms at the date of the
contract and shall be paid by award of the number of shares equivalent to the fixed monetary value as at the date of the award.
Such awards vest immediately following the award year and are subject to up to a four-year holding period. For the CEO, annual
remuneration paid in shares is fixed every three years, whereas for other members of the Management Board and MRTs the
remuneration is set on an annual basis. As for the variable share remuneration, it is awarded annually in the form of nil-cost options
over the shares of BOGG PLC and is also fixed in monetary terms at the date of the contract. Such awards are subject to vesting
and holding periods.
The awards of shares in monetary terms are accounted as equity-settled transactions and are measured by reference to the
monetary value (as awarded) adjusted for the time value of money where necessary. The cost of equity-settled transactions is
recognised together with the corresponding increase in equity as part of additional paid-in capital, over the period in which the
service conditions are fulfilled, ending on the date when the relevant employee is fully entitled to the award (the ‘vesting date’).
In February 2023, BOGG’s Remuneration Committee resolved to award 241,500 ordinary shares of Bank of Georgia Group PLC to
the members of the Management Board and 74,520 ordinary shares of Bank of Georgia Group PLC to the Group’s 18 executives.
Shares awarded to the Management Board are subject to five-year vesting and two-year holding periods, while those awarded to
the other 18 executives are subject to three-year vesting periods with continuous employment being the only vesting condition for
both awards. The Group considers 9 February, 10 May and 20 October 2023 as the grant dates. The Group estimates that the fair
value of the shares awarded on 9 February, 10 May and 20 October 2023 were Georgian Lari 87.65, 99.04 and 106.31 per share.
In January 2022, BOGG’s Remuneration Committee resolved to award 350,017 ordinary shares of Bank of Georgia Group PLC to the
members of the Management Board and 54,851 ordinary shares of Bank of Georgia Group PLC to the Groups 13 executives. Shares
awarded to the Management Board are subject to two-year vesting and two-year holding periods, while those awarded to the
other 13 executives are subject to three-year vesting periods with continuous employment being the only vesting condition for both
awards. The Group considers 31 January 2022 as the grant date. The Group estimates that the fair value of the shares awarded on
31 January 2022 was Georgian Lari 59.98 per share.
In March 2021, BOGG’s Remuneration Committee resolved to award 20,100 ordinary shares of Bank of Georgia Group PLC to the
members of the Management Board and 176,218 ordinary shares of Bank of Georgia Group PLC to the Groups 46 executives. Shares
awarded to the Management Board and to the other 46 executives are subject to three-year vesting with continuous employment
being the only vesting condition for both awards. The Group considers 11 March 2021 as the grant date. The Group estimates that
the fair value of the shares awarded on 11 March 2021 was Georgian Lari 50.12 per share.
In 2023, Management Board members signed fixed contingent share-based compensation agreements, with fixed contract values
of GEL 16,248. The Group considers 1 January 2023 as the grant dates for the awards. The Group estimated the value of the shares
was Georgian Lari 82.91 per share, based on the five working day average share price before 25 December 2022, respectively. The
awards will be subject to one-year vesting and three-year holding periods.
In 2023, the Group’s other executive members signed fixed contingent share-based compensation agreements, with fixed contract
values of GEL 4,149. The Group considers 1 January 2023, 1 April 2023, 27 April 2023, 1 May 2023 and 1 June 2023 as the grant
dates for the awards. The Group estimated the value of the shares were Georgian Lari 82.91, 78.44, 76.77, 76.61 and 79.99 per share
respectively, based on the five working day average share price before the 25 December 2022. The awards will be subject to one-year
vesting and three-year holding periods.
In 2022, Management Board members signed fixed contingent share-based compensation agreements, with fixed contract values
of GEL 46,168. The Group considers 1 January 2022 and 30 June 2022 as the grant dates for the awards. The Group estimated the
value of the shares were Georgian Lari 64.10 and 60.77 per share respectively, based on the five working day average share price
before 25 December 2021, respectively. The awards will be subject to one-year vesting and three-year holding periods.
In 2022, the Groups other executive members signed fixed contingent share-based compensation agreements, with fixed contract
values of GEL 4,493. The Group considers 1 January 2022 and 1 July 2022 as the grant dates for the awards. The Group estimated
the value of the shares were Georgian Lari 64.10 and 60.76 per share respectively, based on the five working day average share price
before 25 December 2021, respectively. The awards will be subject to one-year vesting and three-year holding periods.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
335
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
29. Share-based payments continued
In 2021, key executive members signed fixed contingent share-based compensation agreements with the total of 10,000 ordinary
shares of BOGG. The awards will be subject to three-year vesting periods. The Group considers 1 March 2021 as the grant dates for
the awards. The Group estimated that the fair value of the shares awarded on 1 March 2021 was Georgian Lari 45.89 per share.
In 2021, the Group’s other executive members signed fixed contingent share-based compensation agreements, with fixed contract
values of GEL 2,065. The Group considers 1 May 2021 and 1 October 2021 as the grant dates for the awards. The Group estimated
the value of the shares was Georgian Lari 51.57 and 66.12 per share, respectively, based on the five working day average share price
before the grant dates of 1 May 2021 and 1 October 2021, respectively. The awards will be subject to one-year vesting and three-year
holding periods.
The Bank grants share compensation to its non-executive employees. In February 2023, January 2022 and March 2021, the
Supervisory Board of the Bank resolved to award 157,146, 212,327 and 188,694 ordinary shares, respectively, to its certain
non-executive employees. All these awards are subject to three-year vesting periods, with continuous employment being the only
vesting condition for all awards. The Group considers 9 February 2023, 31 January 2022 and 11 March 2021 as the grant dates of
these awards, respectively. The Group estimated that the fair values of the shares awarded on 9 February 2023, 31 January 2022
and 11 March 2021 were Georgian Lari 87.65, 59.98 and 50.12 per share, respectively.
Summary
Fair value of the shares granted at the measurement date is determined based on available market quotations.
The weighted average fair value of share-based awards at the grant date amounted to Georgian Lari 84.87 per share in year ended
31 December 2023 (31 December 2022: Georgian Lari 62.25 per share, 31 December 2021: Georgian Lari 50.93).
The Groups total share-based payment expenses for the year ended 31 December 2023 amounted to GEL 72,055 (31 December
2022: GEL 82,025, 31 December 2021: GEL 45,307) and are included in ‘salaries and other employee benefits’ as ‘salaries and
bonuses’. Below is the summary of the share-based payments-related data:
2023
2022
2021
Total number of equity instruments awarded
724,296
1,405,389
434,770
– Among them, to the Management Board
437,461
1,071,053
30,100
Weighted average value at grant date, per share (GEL in full amount)
84.87
62.25
50.93
Value at grant date, total (GEL)
61,469
87,481
22,143
Total expense recognised during the year (GEL)
(72,055)
(82,025)
(45,307)
During 2023 BOGG Directors exercised 242,707 (2022: 70,646) shares with a fair value of GEL 20,827 (2022: 3,602). The weighted
average share price was GEL 85.81 per share (2022: 50.99). During 2021 BOGG Directors did not exercise any shares.
30. Risk management
Introduction
Risk is inherent in the Groups activities, but it is managed through a process of ongoing identification, measurement and monitoring,
subject to risk limits and other controls. This process of risk management is critical to the Group’s continuing profitability and each
individual within the Group is accountable for the risk exposures relating to his or her responsibilities. The Group is exposed to credit
risk, liquidity risk and market risk, the latter being subdivided into trading and non-trading risks. It is also subject to operational risks.
The independent risk control process does not include business risks such as changes in the environment, technology and industry.
They are monitored through the Group’s strategic planning process.
Risk management structure
The Bank’s risk management framework and risk appetite framework policies are based on the three lines of defence model and
reflect the requirements of the Corporate Governance Code adopted by the NBG. The three lines of defence model enhances the
understanding of risk management and control by clarifying roles and responsibilities within the Bank’s different risk management
bodies and business units in order to increase the effective management of risk and control.
Audit Committee
The Audit Committee assists the Board in relation to the oversight of the Group’s financial and reporting processes. It monitors
the integrity of the financial statements and is responsible for governance around both the Internal Audit function and external
auditor, reporting back to the Board. It reviews the effectiveness of the policies, procedures and systems in place related to, among
other operational risks, compliance, IT and internal security (including cybersecurity), and works closely with the Risk Committee in
connection with assessing the effectiveness of the risk management and internal control framework.
Risk Committee
The Risk Committee assists the Board in relation to the oversight of risk. It reviews the Group’s risk appetite in line with strategy,
identifies and monitors risk exposure and the risk management infrastructure, oversees the implementation of strategy to address
risk, and in conjunction with the Audit Committee, assesses the strength and effectiveness of the risk management and internal
control framework.
336
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
30. Risk management continued
Management Board
The Management Board has overall responsibility for the Bank’s asset, liability and risk management activities, policies and
procedures. In order to effectively implement the risk management system, the Management Board delegates individual risk
management functions to each of the various decision-making and execution bodies within the Bank.
Credit Committees
The Bank has five Credit Committees, each responsible for supervising and managing the Bank’s credit risks in respect of loans and
counterparty credit exposures. Each Credit Committee comprises tiers of subcommittees and approves individual loan transactions.
Lower tier subcommittees meet on a daily basis, whereas higher tier ones meet as needed, typically one or two times a week. Each
of the subcommittees of the Credit Committees makes its decisions by a majority vote of its members.
Bank Asset and Liability Management Committee
The Bank’s Asset and Liability Management Committee (‘ALCO’) is the core asset liability management (ALM) and risk management
body that establishes policies and guidelines with respect to capital adequacy, market risks and respective limits, funding liquidity
risk and respective limits, interest rate and prepayment risks and respective limits, money market general terms and credit exposure
limits. ALCO designs and implements respective risk management and stress testing models, regularly monitors compliance with the
pre-set risk limits, and approves treasury deals with non-standard terms.
Internal Audit
The Internal Audit function is responsible for the audit of the Group’s risk management, internal control and corporate governance
processes, with the aim of reducing the levels of operational and other risks, auditing the Groups internal control systems and
detecting any infringements or errors on the part of the Group’s departments and divisions. It examines both the adequacy and
the Groups compliance with those procedures. The Groups Internal Audit department discusses the results of all assessments with
management, and reports its findings and recommendations to the Audit Committee.
Risk measurement and reporting systems
The Bank applies a variety of risk metrics to measure its exposures, ranging from operational indicators to forward-looking/
statistical model-based approaches and stress scenarios.
The Bank has established risk appetite limits for its principal risks, which are approved by the Supervisory Board. Monitoring and
controlling of these risks are performed with reference to these limits. They reflect the business strategy and market environment
in which the Bank operates and they set the boundaries for the level of risk the Bank is willing to take in pursuit of its strategic
objectives. The Bank continuously monitors the landscape to ensure that any significant changes in the underlying assumptions and/
or conditions are identified and adapted in a timely manner.
Information compiled from all the businesses is examined and processed in order to analyse, control and identify early risks. This
information is presented and explained to the Management Board, and the head of each business division. The reports include
aggregate credit exposures, liquidity ratios and changes to the risk profile. Senior management assesses the appropriateness of the
ECL on a monthly basis. The Management Board receives a comprehensive credit risk report and ALCO report. These reports are
designed to provide all the necessary information to assess and conclude on the risks of the Bank.
For all levels throughout the Bank, specifically tailored risk reports are prepared and distributed in order to ensure that all business
divisions have access to extensive, relevant and up-to-date information.
A daily briefing is given to the Management Board and all other relevant employees of the Group on the utilisation of market limits,
proprietary investments and liquidity, plus any other risk developments.
Risk mitigation
As part of its overall risk management, the Group uses derivatives and other instruments to manage exposures resulting from
changes in interest rates, foreign currencies, equity risks, credit risks and exposures arising from forecast transactions. While these
are intended for hedging, they do not qualify for hedge accounting.
The Group actively uses collateral to reduce its credit risks (see below for more detail).
Excessive risk concentration
Concentrations arise when a number of counterparties are engaged in similar business activities, or activities in the same
geographic region, or these counterparties represent related parties to each other, or have similar economic features that would
cause their ability to meet contractual obligations to be similarly affected by changes in economic, political or other conditions.
Concentrations also involve combined, aggregate exposures of large and significant credits compared with the total outstanding
balance of the respective financial instrument. Concentrations indicate the relative sensitivity of the Group’s performance to
developments affecting a particular industry or geographical location.
In order to avoid excessive concentrations of risks, the Group’s policies and procedures include specific guidelines to focus on,
maintaining a diversified portfolio of financial assets. Identified concentrations of credit risks or liquidity/repayment risks are
controlled and managed accordingly.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
337
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
30. Risk management continued
Credit risk
Credit risk is the risk that the Group will incur a loss because its customers fail to discharge their contractual obligations. The Group
manages and controls credit risk by setting limits on the amount of risk it is willing to accept for individual counterparties and for
geographical, industry, product and currency concentrations, and by monitoring exposures in relation to such limits.
The Group has established a credit quality review process to provide an early identification of possible changes in the
creditworthiness of counterparties, including regular collateral revisions. Counterparty limits are established by the use of a credit
risk classification system, which assigns each counterparty a risk rating. Risk ratings are subject to regular revision.
The credit quality review process allows the Group to assess the potential loss as a result of the risks to which it is exposed and take
corrective action. The maximum credit exposure is limited to the carrying value of respective instruments and notional amounts of
guarantees and commitments provided.
Derivative financial instruments
Credit risk arising from derivative financial instruments is, at any time, limited to those with positive fair values, as recorded in the
statement of financial position.
Credit-related commitment risks
The Group makes available to its customers guarantees and letters of credit which may require that the Group make payments on
their behalf. Such payments are collected from customers based on the terms of the guarantee and letter of credit. They expose the
Group to similar risks to loans and these are mitigated by the same control processes and policies.
Credit quality per class of financial assets
The credit quality of financial assets is managed by the Group through internal and external credit ratings used in ECL calculations.
For corporate loan portfolios, the Group runs an internal rating model in which its customers are rated from 1 to 7 using internal
grades. The models incorporate both qualitative and quantitative information and, in addition to information specific to each
borrower, utilising supplemental external information that could affect the borrowers behaviour. It is the Groups policy to maintain
accurate and consistent risk ratings across the credit portfolio. This facilitates focused management of the applicable risks and
the comparison of credit exposures across all lines of business, geographic regions and products. The rating system is supported
by a variety of financial analytics to provide the main inputs for the measurement of counterparty risk. All internal risk ratings are
tailored to the various categories and are derived in accordance with the Group’s rating policy. Attributable risk ratings are assessed
and updated regularly.
For Retail, Micro and SME loans, the Group uses external ratings provided by Credit Bureau.
The Groups treasury, trading and inter-bank relationships and counterparties comprise financial services institutions, banks and
broker-dealers. For these, where external ratings provided by rating agencies are available, the Group Credit Risk department uses
such external ratings. For those where external ratings are not available internal ratings are assigned.
The table below shows internal and external grades used in ECL calculating.
External Rating Grades
Internal Rating Description*
Internal Rating Grades
Credit Bureau
Standard & Poor’s
High grade
Aaa
1
A
AAA
Aa1
2+
B
AA+
Aa2
2
C1
AA
Aa3
2-
C2
AA-
A1
3+
C3
A+
A2
3
A
A3
3-
A-
Baa1
4+
BBB+
Baa2
4
BBB
Standard grade
Baa3
4-
BBB-
Ba1
5+
D1
BB+
Ba2
5
D2
BB
Ba3
5-
D3
BB-
B1
6+
B+
B2
6
B
Low grade
B3
6-
E1
B-
Caa1
7+
E2
CCC+
Caa2
7
E3
CCC
Caa3
7-
CCC-
Ca
CC
C
* Grades are not supposed to be linked to each other across the rating categories above.
338
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
30. Risk management continued
The table below shows the credit quality by class of asset in the statement of financial position, presented in gross amounts, based
on the Groups credit rating system.
A defaulted financial asset that is past due more than 90 days is assessed as a non-performing loan or as determined on an
individual basis based on other available information regarding financial difficulties of the borrower.
Other financial assets include receivables from remittance operations and other receivables.
Cash and cash equivalents, excluding cash on hand
Stage 1
Total
High grade
1,097,876
1,097,876
Standard grade
654,907
654,907
Low grade
32,398
32,398
Not rated
293,061
293,061
Balance at 31 December 2023
2,078,242
2,078,242
Amounts due from credit institutions
Stage 1
Total
High grade
1,734,224
1,734,224
Not rated
19,327
19,327
Balance at 31 December 2023
1,753,551
1,753,551
Investment securities measured at amortised cost – debt instruments
Stage 1
Total
High grade
415,713
415,713
Standard grade
160,758
160,758
Not rated
114,648
114,648
Balance at 31 December 2023
691,119
691,119
Investment securities measured at FVOCI – debt instruments
Stage 1
Total
High grade
2,277,147
2,277,147
Standard grade
2,058,495
2,058,495
Not rated
88,518
88,518
Balance at 31 December 2023
4,424,160
4,424,160
Commercial loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
4,388,581
68,175
339
4,457,095
Standard grade
1,389,821
58,796
755
1,449,372
Low grade
133,487
372,006
505,493
Not rated
464,999
16,812
1
481,812
Defaulted
Non-performing
101,364
22,481
123,845
Balance at 31 December 2023
6,376,888
515,789
101,365
23,575
7,017,617
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
3,346,499
11,608
4,209
3,362,316
Standard grade
714,568
45,712
3,689
763,969
Low grade
86,008
116,000
6,839
208,847
Not rated
153,263
732
131
154,126
Defaulted
Non-performing
37,77
1
16,214
53,985
Other
13,175
1,107
14,282
Balance at 31 December 2023
4,300,338
174,052
50,946
32,189
4,557,525
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
2,480,970
29,931
316
2,511,217
Standard grade
1,012,833
73,925
228
1,086,986
Low grade
75,930
76,380
242
152,552
Not rated
140,137
11,294
48
151,479
Defaulted
Non-performing
167,506
2,364
169,870
Other
871
47
918
Balance at 31 December 2023
3,709,870
191,530
168,425
3,197
4,073,022
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
339
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
30. Risk management continued
Consumer loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
2,693,767
7,996
2,406
2,704,169
Standard grade
1,179,793
50,968
3,069
1,233,830
Low grade
233,382
173,992
4,607
411,981
Not rated
218,817
1,273
90
220,180
Defaulted
Non-performing
91,584
16,090
107,674
Other
19,795
2,340
22,135
Balance at 31 December 2023
4,325,759
234,229
111,469
28,512
4,699,969
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
65,002
48
65,050
Standard grade
40,495
733
41,228
Low grade
17,381
7,915
25,296
Not rated
14,538
273
14,811
Defaulted
Non-performing
2,566
2,566
Other
1,277
1,277
Balance at 31 December 2023
137,416
8,696
4,116
150,228
Finance lease receivables
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
5,832
80
4,274
10,186
Standard grade
2,731
381
1,697
4,809
Low grade
475
1,261
2,161
3,897
Not rated
27,979
3,506
31,485
Defaulted
Non-performing
12,161
10,392
22,553
Other
557
557
Balance at 31 December 2023
37,017
5,228
12,161
19,081
73,487
Accounts receivable
Stage 1
Total
Not rated
52,696
52,696
Balance at 31 December 2023
52,696
52,696
Other financial assets
Stage 1
Total
Not rated
154,765
154,765
Balance at 31 December 2023
154,765
154,765
Financial and performance guarantees issued
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
997,529
997,529
Standard grade
347,015
257
347,272
Low grade
264,715
161,350
426,065
Not rated
140,467
8
140,475
Defaulted
Non-performing
1,915
1,915
Other
5,741
5,741
Balance at 31 December 2023
1,749,726
161,615
7,656
1,918,997
Letters of credit
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
69,260
69,260
Standard grade
7,546
7,546
Low grade
307
307
Not rated
432
432
Balance at 31 December 2023
77,545
77,545
Undrawn loan facilities
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
668,644
215
12
668,871
Standard grade
240,974
1,203
242,177
Low grade
23,791
6,757
1
30,549
Not rated
71,305
278
71,583
Defaulted
Non-performing
1,764
7
1,771
Balance at 31 December 2023
1,004,714
8,453
1,776
8
1,014,951
340
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
30. Risk management continued
Cash and cash equivalents, excluding cash on hand
Stage 1
Stage 3
Total
High grade
1,372,649
1,372,649
Standard grade
610,846
610,846
Low grade
18,466
18,466
Not rated
531,178
531,178
Balance at 31 December 2022
2,533,139
2,533,139
Amounts due from credit institutions
Stage 1
Stage 3
Total
High grade
2,396,898
2,396,898
Standard grade
11,871
11,871
Not rated
29,577
29,577
Balance at 31 December 2022
2,438,346
2,438,346
Investment securities measured at FVOCI – debt instruments
Stage 1
Stage 3
Total
High grade
2,337,628
2,337,628
Standard grade
1,546,907
1,546,907
Not rated
76,381
1,619
78,000
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,960,916
1,619
3,962,535
Commercial loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
2,484,436
78,817
2,563,253
Standard grade
1,466,457
123,274
310
1,590,041
Low grade
238,808
391,875
1,187
631,870
Not rated
322,120
17,341
3,605
343,066
Defaulted
Non-performing
169,661
14,453
184,114
Other
3,322
3,322
Balance at 31 December 2022
4,511,821
611,307
176,588
15,950
5,315,666
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
3,020,624
22,479
4,103
3,047,206
Standard grade
657,117
37,241
4,446
698,804
Low grade
107,484
108,764
3,402
219,650
Not rated
140,681
1,082
141,763
Defaulted
Non-performing
53,073
13,650
66,723
Other
16,584
2,474
19,058
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,925,906
169,566
69,657
28,075
4,193,204
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
2,026,620
43,580
347
2,070,547
Standard grade
1,022,762
67,959
361
1,091,082
Low grade
145,066
75,782
45
220,893
Not rated
281,391
13,142
10
207
294,750
Defaulted
Non-performing
135,965
1,658
137,623
Other
10,542
226
10,768
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,475,839
200,463
146,517
2,844
3,825,663
Consumer loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
2,003,630
13,253
2,412
2,019,295
Standard grade
872,122
39,737
1,763
913,622
Low grade
202,919
159,751
2,021
364,691
Not rated
164,520
1,134
103
165,757
Defaulted
Non-performing
70,885
11,279
82,164
Other
51,004
5,521
56,525
Balance at 31 December 2022
3,243,191
213,875
121,992
22,996
3,602,054
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
341
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
30. Risk management continued
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
61,635
195
61,830
Standard grade
43,456
1,077
44,533
Low grade
39,509
7,339
46,848
Not rated
2,925
2
493
3,420
Defaulted
Non-performing
1,318
1,318
Other
6,605
6,605
Balance at 31 December 2022
147,525
8,613
8,416
164,554
Finance lease receivables
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
17,702
4,495
22,197
Standard grade
694
694
Not rated
41,829
1,262
5,101
48,192
Defaulted
Non-performing
3,814
11,909
15,723
Other
5,240
3,302
8,542
Balance at 31 December 2022
59,531
6,451
14,155
15,211
95,348
Accounts receivable
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Not rated
400,111
400,111
Balance at 31 December 2022
400,111
400,111
Other financial assets
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
Not rated
104,107
104,107
Balance at 31 December 2022
104,107
104,107
Financial and performance guarantees issued
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
1,049,817
103
1,049,920
Standard grade
241,914
4,357
246,271
Low grade
223,983
20,097
244,080
Not rated
163,278
111
163,389
Defaulted
Other
13,648
13,648
Balance at 31 December 2022
1,678,992
24,668
13,648
1,717,308
Letters of credit
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
76,091
76,091
Standard grade
39,671
39,671
Not rated
547
547
Balance at 31 December 2022
116,309
116,309
Undrawn loan facilities
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
498,164
306
498,470
Standard grade
259,919
6,168
266,087
Low grade
7,719
7,829
15,548
Not rated
87,136
82
1
87,219
Defaulted
Non-performing
1,537
1
1,538
Other
199
199
Balance at 31 December 2022
852,938
14,385
1,736
2
869,061
342
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
30. Risk management continued
Cash and cash equivalents, excluding cash on hand
Stage 1
Total
High grade
480,889
480,889
Standard grade
78,953
78,953
Low grade
134
134
Not rated
209,548
209,548
Balance at 31 December 2021
769,524
769,524
Amounts due from credit institutions
Stage 1
Total
Standard grade
1,903,301
1,903,301
Not rated
28,420
28,420
Balance at 31 December 2021
1,931,721
1,931,721
Investment securities measured at FVOCI – debt instruments
Stage 1
Total
High grade
1,031,369
1,031,369
Standard grade
1,464,107
1,464,107
Low grade
13,804
13,804
Not rated
79,948
79,948
Balance at 31 December 2021
2,589,228
2,589,228
Commercial loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
2,815,718
11,769
2,827,487
Standard grade
1,318,613
166,392
1,485,005
Low grade
369,056
176,236
7,131
552,423
Not rated
430,925
20,536
3,524
454,985
Defaulted
Non-performing
212,134
10,883
223,017
Other
11,267
11,267
Balance at 31 December 2021
4,934,312
374,933
226,925
18,014
5,554,184
Residential mortgage loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
2,751,165
67,134
2,163
2,820,462
Standard grade
616,665
84,564
4,284
705,513
Low grade
112,440
106,454
5,083
223,977
Not rated
149,099
1,818
150,917
Defaulted
Non-performing
31,140
3,767
34,907
Other
73,374
12,908
86,282
Balance at 31 December 2021
3,629,369
259,970
104,514
28,205
4,022,058
Micro and SME loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
1,733,636
103,160
308
1,837,104
Standard grade
932,109
90,631
1,588
1,024,328
Low grade
108,045
69,942
561
178,548
Not rated
506,359
29,740
11
536,110
Defaulted
Non-performing
115,794
2,125
117,919
Other
35,694
2,053
37,747
Balance at 31 December 2021
3,280,149
293,473
151,499
6,635
3,731,756
Consumer loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
1,415,629
23,339
858
1,439,826
Standard grade
758,684
54,826
1,640
815,150
Low grade
272,104
135,897
2,259
410,260
Not rated
189,021
964
267
190,252
Defaulted
Non-performing
41,757
1,141
42,898
Other
65,618
17,301
82,919
Balance at 31 December 2021
2,635,438
215,026
107,642
23,199
2,981,305
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
343
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
30. Risk management continued
Gold – pawn loans at amortised cost
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
58,481
295
58,776
Standard grade
41,990
2,606
44,596
Low grade
19,639
7,215
26,854
Not rated
32,677
32,677
Defaulted
Non-performing
1,003
1,003
Other
1,511
1,511
Balance at 31 December 2021
152,787
10,116
2,514
165,417
Finance lease receivables
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
POCI
Total
High grade
8,585
3,221
11,806
Standard grade
8,337
2,733
11,070
Low grade
8,515
5,850
14,365
Not rated
55,737
5,780
61,517
Defaulted
Non-performing
605
605
Other
16,007
9,582
25,589
Balance at 31 December 2021
81,174
17,584
16,612
9,582
124,952
Accounts receivable
Stage 1
Total
Not rated
6,097
6,097
Balance at 31 December 2021
6,097
6,097
Other financial assets
Stage 1
Total
Not rated
52,575
52,575
Balance at 31 December 2021
52,575
52,575
Financial and performance guarantees issued
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Total
High grade
307,607
24,337
331,944
Standard grade
91,528
7,799
99,327
Low grade
58,376
3,334
61,710
Not rated
1,193,179
9
1,193,188
Defaulted
Other
744
744
Balance at 31 December 2021
1,650,690
35,479
744
1,686,913
Letters of credit
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Total
High grade
67,925
67,925
Standard grade
1,743
1,743
Low grade
410
410
Not rated
1,598
1,598
Balance at 31 December 2021
71,676
71,676
Undrawn loan facilities
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Total
High grade
581,310
1,415
582,725
Standard grade
121,376
3,011
124,387
Low grade
12,986
4,561
17,547
Not rated
83,653
240
9
83,902
Defaulted
Non-performing
5
5
Other
909
915
Balance at 31 December 2021
799,325
9,227
923
809,481
Types of collateral the Group accepts include real estate and movable properties as well as financial assets (deposits, shares and
guarantees) and other registered liens. Measurement and processing of collateral is governed by generally acceptable standards
and collateral-specific instructions. These transactions are structured under legally verified standard agreements where the pledges
are secured through public registry where eligible. The following table shows the ratio of the loan portfolio to the market value of
collateral held by the Group in respect of the portfolio. As at 31 December 2023, up to 80.1% of the collateral held has been revalued
within the last two years (2022: 78.6%, 2021: 76.0%). For residential mortgage loans, in cases where the collateral for a loan may not
be officially registered until its construction is complete, the respective loan is shown as unsecured, even though it is usually secured
by the corporate guarantee of the construction company.
344
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
30. Risk management continued
As at 31 December 2023
Total gross Loan-to-value %
carrying Less than More than
amount
Unsecured
50%
50-80%
80-90%
90-100%
100-200%
200-300%
300-400%
400%
Commercial loans
7,017,617
837,104
1,235,492
1,618,714
297,635
370,658
1,454,192
531,632
133,244
538,946
ECL coverage
1.43%
0.62%
0.55%
0.42%
0.21%
2.63%
2.11%
4.45%
2.41%
2.54%
Residential
mortgage loans
4,557,525
105,607
1,097,126
1,997,629
613,407
533,097
175,455
9,783
5,224
20,197
ECL coverage
0.50%
2.22%
0.00%
0.24%
0.73%
0.78%
3.56%
1.23%
2.28%
2.09%
Micro and
SME loans
4,073,022
241,068
885,575
1,131,643
358,909
314,671
981,784
82,058
26,254
51,060
ECL coverage
1.76%
6.03%
0.01%
0.57%
0.79%
1.23%
3.85%
3.02%
4.57%
4.75%
Consumer loans
4,699,969
2,266,702
815,573
919,577
330,004
257,059
87,651
8,396
4,722
10,285
ECL coverage
2.80%
5.16%
0.01%
0.38%
0.83%
1.10%
5.61%
3.85%
4.36%
1.62%
Gold – pawn loans
150,228
4,362
49,324
93,706
1,083
790
941
22
ECL coverage
0.93%
N/A
0.02%
0.06%
0.24%
16.25%
27.72%
76.09%
N/A
81.82%
Loans to customers
at amortised cost,
gross
20,498,361
3,450,481
4,038,128
5,716,887
1,693,661
1,476,568
2,699,872
632,810
169,444
620,510
As at 31 December 2022
Total gross Loan-to-value %
carrying Less than More than
amount
Unsecured
50%
50-80%
80-90%
90-100%
100-200%
200-300%
300-400%
400%
Commercial loans
5,315,666
714,675
1,037,528
900,866
158,713
245,750
1,243,415
340,917
70,694
603,108
ECL coverage
1.72%
2.79%
0.56%
1.18%
0.82%
1.56%
3.14%
1.18%
1.31%
1.01%
Residential
mortgage loans
4,193,204
120,439
981,034
1,859,064
532,412
441,719
230,274
8,114
2,665
17,483
ECL coverage
0.72%
2.45%
0.01%
0.38%
1.00%
1.45%
3.07%
4.42%
1.43%
4.06%
Micro and
SME loans
3,825,663
405,004
885,724
966,056
278,684
280,462
800,119
73,083
30,447
106,084
ECL coverage
1.66%
4.73%
0.02%
0.41%
0.92%
1.48%
2.92%
3.42%
4.59%
5.88%
Consumer loans
3,602,054
1,794,035
629,846
694,153
217,045
174,755
83,286
4,926
1,196
2,812
ECL coverage
3.76%
6.79%
0.03%
0.51%
1.36%
1.59%
4.58%
7.69%
0.92%
1.53%
Gold – pawn loans
164,554
1
8,589
58,481
94,082
2,044
1,338
19
ECL coverage
3.31%
N/A
50.54%
0.07%
0.30%
13.65%
35.87%
N/A
N/A
84.21%
Loans to customers
at amortised cost,
gross
17,101,141
3,034,154
3,542,721
4,478,620
1,280,936
1,144,730
2,358,432
427,040
105,002
729,506
As at 31 December 2021
Total gross Loan-to-value %
carrying Less than More than
amount
Unsecured
50%
50-80%
80-90%
90-100%
100-200%
200-300%
300-400%
400%
Commercial loans
5,554,184
670,741
474,531
1,396,633
167,960
238,995
1,193,148
814,879
197,306
399,991
ECL coverage
2.87%
1.51%
1.43%
0.69%
1.04%
2.71%
2.50%
10.60%
1.87%
1.17%
Residential
mortgage loans
4,022,058
94,513
715,692
1,556,323
651,029
519,179
440,231
11,085
4,739
29,267
ECL coverage
0.82%
4.19%
0.02%
0.09%
0.66%
1.19%
3.41%
9.24%
2.15%
3.32%
Micro and
SME loans
3,731,756
429,366
725,310
933,874
272,270
328,758
835,894
90,748
34,841
80,695
ECL coverage
1.99%
5.89%
0.10%
0.27%
0.66%
1.65%
3.11%
4.59%
2.43%
9.47%
Consumer loans
2,981,305
1,560,864
443,343
514,287
178,141
143,989
132,295
3,634
731
4,021
ECL coverage
4.56%
8.07%
0.07%
0.36%
1.02%
1.43%
2.67%
11.23%
2.60%
3.13%
Gold – pawn loans
165,417
1
4,182
37,427
118,095
4,568
1,128
16
ECL coverage
1.25%
N/A
0.02%
4.83%
0.09%
2.47%
2.48%
N/A
N/A
75.00%
Loans to customers
at amortised cost,
gross
16,454,720
2,755,485
2,363,058
4,438,544
1,387,495
1,235,489
2,602,696
920,346
237,617
513,990
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
345
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
30. Risk management continued
Carrying amount per class of financial assets whose terms have been renegotiated
During the year, the Group modified the contractual cash flows on certain loans and advances to customers. All such loans had
previously been transferred to at least Stage 2, with a loss allowance measured at an amount equal to lifetime ECLs.
The following table provides information on financial assets that were modified while they had a loss allowance measured at an
amount equal to lifetime ECL:
Financial assets modified during 2023:
Amortised Net gain/(loss)
cost before arising from
modification modification
Commercial loans
710,073
599
Residential mortgage loans
44,848
(131)
Micro and SME loans
168,593
(2,362)
Consumer loans
287,667
(12,791)
Gold – pawn loans
Loans to customers
1,211,181
(14,685)
Finance lease receivables
839
138
Total loans to customers and finance lease receivables
1,212,020
(14,547)
Financial assets modified during 2022:
Amortised Net gain/(loss)
cost before arising from
modification modification
Commercial loans
621,067
2,169
Residential mortgage loans
73,863
(3,081)
Micro and SME loans
173,382
(2,524)
Consumer loans
305,726
(25,835)
Gold – pawn loans
Loans to customers
1,174,038
(29,271)
Finance lease receivables
Total loans to customers and finance lease receivables
1,174,038
(29,271)
Financial assets modified during 2021:
Amortised Net gain/(loss)
cost before arising from
modification modification
Commercial loans
437,979
388
Residential mortgage loans
132,638
530
Micro and SME loans
243,217
(4,185)
Consumer loans
271,896
(9,446)
Gold – pawn loans
Loans to customers
1,085,730
(12,713)
Finance lease receivables
Total loans to customers and finance lease receivables
1,085,730
(12,713)
The gross carrying value of loans that have previously been modified (when they were in Stage 2 or 3) which are now categorised as
Stage 1, with loss allowance measured at an amount equal to 12 months expected losses, are shown in the table below:
Financial assets modified since initial recognition, as at 31 December 2023
Gross carrying Corresponding
amount ECL
Commercial loans
96,127
(255)
Residential mortgage loans
63,193
(51)
Micro and SME loans
39,912
(98)
Consumer loans
14,217
(49)
Gold – pawn loans
Loans to customers
213,449
(453)
Finance lease receivables
Total loans to customers and finance lease receivables
213,449
(453)
346
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
30. Risk management continued
Financial assets modified since initial recognition, as at 31 December 2022
Gross carrying Corresponding
amount ECL
Commercial loans
10,100
(24)
Residential mortgage loans
72,919
(104)
Micro and SME loans
40,925
(129)
Consumer loans
19,482
(204)
Gold – pawn loans
Loans to customers
143,426
(461)
Finance lease receivables
Total loans to customers and finance lease receivables
143,426
(461)
Financial assets modified since initial recognition, as at 31 December 2021
Gross carrying Corresponding
amount ECL
Commercial loans
19,521
(121)
Residential mortgage loans
81,892
(231)
Micro and SME loans
35,301
(347)
Consumer loans
25,063
(633)
Gold – pawn loans
Loans to customers
161,777
(1,332)
Finance lease receivables
Total loans to customers and finance lease receivables
161,777
(1,332)
The geographical concentration of the Groups assets and liabilities is set out below:
2023
CIS and
other foreign
Georgia
OECD
countries
Total
Assets:
Cash and cash equivalents
1,523,046
975,099
603,679
3,101,824
Amounts due from credit institutions
1,733,898
18,759
1,752,657
Investment securities
2,368,874
2,332,754
428,129
5,129,757
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
19,532,803
699,918
20,232,721
All other assets
1,314,511
150,031
76,057
1,540,599
26,473,132
3,457,884
1,826,542
31,757,558
Liabilities:
Client deposits and notes
14,880,493
1,138,532
4,503,714
20,522,739
Amounts owed to credit institutions
2,369,365
2,257,129
529,515
5,156,009
Debt securities issued
273,923
147,436
421,359
Lease liability
128,725
13,209
141,934
All other liabilities
396,104
87,254
12,323
495,681
18,048,610
3,630,351
5,058,761
26,737,722
Net balance sheet position
8,424,522
(172,467)
(3,232,219)
5,019,836
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
347
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
30. Risk management continued
2022
2021
CIS and CIS and
other foreign other foreign
Georgia
OECD
countries
Total
Georgia
OECD
countries
Total
Assets:
Cash and cash equivalents
1,508,225
1,453,844
622,774
3,584,843
836,325
419,324
264,913
1,520,562
Amounts due from credit
institutions
2,358,551
54,175
20,302
2,433,028
1,922,671
8,719
1,931,390
Investment securities
1,798,172
2,436,465
115,092
4,349,729
1,477,367
970,901
147,396
2,595,664
Loans to customers and finance
lease receivables
16,339,883
521,823
16,861,706
15,524,427
644,546
16,168,973
All other assets
1,473,703
120,271
78,620
1,672,594
977,703
178,765
57,019
1,213,487
23,478,534
4,064,755
1,358,611
28,901,900
20,738,493
1,568,990
1,122,593
23,430,076
Liabilities:
Client deposits and notes
13,017,449
966,722
4,277,226
18,261,397
11,180,811
894,192
1,962,999
14,038,002
Amounts owed to credit
institutions
2,622,787
2,142,083
501,783
5,266,653
1,609,565
2,619,885
88,995
4,318,445
Debt securities issued
312,053
333,915
645,968
450,155
1,061,203
7,327
1,518,685
Lease liability
101,402
13,068
114,470
84,875
2,787
87,662
All other liabilities
275,030
81,893
7,667
364,590
309,068
55,291
10,015
374,374
16,328,721
3,524,613
4,799,744
24,653,078
13,634,474
4,630,571
2,072,123
20,337,168
Net balance sheet position
7,149,813
540,142
(3,441,133)
4,248,822
7,104,019
(3,061,581)
(949,530)
3,092,908
Liquidity risk and funding management
Liquidity risk is the risk that the Group will be unable to meet its payment obligations when they fall due under normal and stress
circumstances. To limit this risk, management has arranged diversified funding sources in addition to its core deposit base, manages
assets with liquidity in mind, and monitors future cash flows and liquidity on a regular basis. This incorporates an assessment of
expected cash flows and the availability of high-grade collateral which could be used to secure additional funding if required.
The Group maintains a portfolio of highly marketable and diverse assets that can be easily liquidated in the event of an unforeseen
interruption of cash flow. The Group also has committed lines of credit that it can access to meet liquidity needs. In addition, the Group
maintains a cash deposit (obligatory reserve) with the NBG, the amount of which depends on the level of customer funds attracted.
The liquidity position is assessed and managed by the Group primarily on a standalone Bank basis, based on certain liquidity ratios
established by the NBG. Banks are required to maintain a liquidity coverage ratio, which is defined as the ratio of high-quality liquid
assets to net cash outflow over the next 30 days. The order requires that, absent a stress-period, the value of the ratio be no lower
than 100%. The liquidity coverage ratio as at 31 December 2023 was 125.2% (2022: 132.4%, 2021: 124.0%).
The Bank holds a comfortable buffer on top of Net Stable Funding Ratio (NSFR) requirement of 100%, which came into effect on
1 September 2019. A solid buffer over NSFR provides stable funding sources over a longer time span. This approach is designed to
ensure that the funding framework is sufficiently flexible to secure liquidity under a wide range of market conditions. NSFR as at
31 December 2023 was 130.4%, (2022: 131.9%, 2021: 132.5%), all comfortably above the NBG’s minimum regulatory requirements.
The Group also matches the maturity of financial assets and financial liabilities and regularly monitors negative gaps compared with
the Bank’s standalone total regulatory capital calculated per NBG regulation.
The table below summarises the maturity profile of the Groups financial liabilities based on contractual undiscounted repayment
obligations, expect for other liabilities, which are presented at carrying amounts due to the short-term nature of these liabilities.
Repayments that are subject to notice are treated as if notice were to be given immediately. However, the Group expects that many
customers will not request repayment on the earliest date the Bank could be required to pay, and the table does not reflect the
expected cash flows indicated by the Bank’s deposit retention history.
Financial liabilities Less than 3 3 to 12 1 to 5 Over
As at 31 December 2023 months months years
5 years
Total
Client deposits and notes
8,491,287
10,559,684
1,963,380
73,382
21,087,733
Amounts owed to credit institutions
2,777,202
569,441
1,773,329
836,493
5,956,465
Debt securities issued
406
204,747
452,747
83,158
741,058
Lease liability
9,077
27,435
100,420
26,499
163,431
Other liabilities
151,734
13,032
2,369
133
167,268
Total undiscounted financial liabilities
11,429,706
11,374,339
4,292,245
1,019,665
28,115,955
348
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
30. Risk management continued
Financial liabilities Less than 3 3 to 12 1 to 5 Over
As at 31 December 2022 months months years
5 years
Total
Client deposits and notes
8,278,805
8,366,525
1,946,856
342,592
18,934,778
Amounts owed to credit institutions
3,300,204
623,612
1,310,937
654,002
5,888,755
Debt securities issued
7,843
343,014
411,265
762,122
Lease liability
7,633
22,444
77,028
16,756
123,861
Other liabilities
142,655
14,856
1,062
118
158,691
Total undiscounted financial liabilities
11,737,140
9,370,451
3,747,148
1,013,468
25,868,207
Financial liabilities Less than 3 to 12 1 to 5 Over
As at 31 December 2021 3 months months years
5 years
Total
Client deposits and notes
5,301,533
7,317,413
1,657,540
352,824
14,629,310
Amounts owed to credit institutions
1,815,989
628,686
1,870,941
610,949
4,926,565
Debt securities issued
37,678
310,707
1,432,079
1,780,464
Lease liability
6,145
16,729
66,981
10,992
100,847
Other liabilities
177,528
3,788
2,015
18
183,349
Total undiscounted financial liabilities
7,338,873
8,277,323
5,029,556
974,783
21,620,535
The table below shows the contractual expiry by maturity of the Groups financial commitments and contingencies.
Less than 3 3 to 12 1 to Over
months months 5 years
5 years
Total
31 December 2023
1,349,928
636,409
1,009,256
27,560
3,023,153
31 December 2022
1,280,906
625,011
778,275
30,294
2,714,486
31 December 2021
1,010,650
663,865
885,895
17,546
2,577,956
The Group expects that not all guarantees or commitments will be drawn before expiry of the commitment.
The maturity analysis does not reflect the historical stability of current accounts. Their liquidation has historically taken place over a
longer period than indicated in the tables above. These balances are included in amounts due in less than three months in the tables
above. Perpetual Tier 1 capital notes are presented in ‘Over 5 years’ category given the fact that management does not consider
them to be repaid earlier than that.
Market risk
Market risk is the risk that the fair value or future cash flows of financial instruments will fluctuate due to changes in market
variables such as interest rates, foreign exchanges, and equity prices. The Group classifies exposures to market risk into either
trading or non-trading portfolios. Trading and non-trading positions are managed and monitored using sensitivity analysis.
Interest rate risk
Interest rate risk arises from the possibility that changes in interest rates will affect future cash flows or the fair values of financial
instruments. The following table demonstrates the sensitivity to a reasonably possible change in interest rates, with all other
variables held constant, on the Group’s consolidated income statement.
The sensitivity of the consolidated income statement is the effect of the assumed changes in interest rates on the net interest
income for the year, based on the floating rate non-trading financial assets and financial liabilities held at 31 December 2023.
Changes in basis points are calculated as standard deviations of daily changes in floating rates over the last month multiplied by
respective floating rates. During the years ended 31 December 2023, 2022 and 2021, sensitivity analysis did not reveal any significant
potential effect on the Groups equity.
Currency
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of other
Increase of net interest comprehensive
in basis points income income
2023 2023 2023
GEL
22
6,541
2,289
EUR
8
707
2
US$
12
813
101
Currency
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of other
Decrease of net interest comprehensive
in basis points income income
2023 2023 2023
GEL
22
(6,541)
(2,289)
EUR
8
(707)
(2)
US$
12
(813)
(101)
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
349
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
30. Risk management continued
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of other
Increase of net interest comprehensive
in basis points income income
Currency 2022 2022 2022
GEL
14
2,432
1,348
EUR
24
3,732
107
US$
21
1,624
1,022
Currency
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of other
Decrease in of net interest comprehensive
basis points income income
2022 2022 2022
GEL
14
(2,432)
(1,348)
EUR
24
(3,732)
(107)
US$
21
(1,624)
(1,022)
Currency
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of other
Increase of net interest comprehensive
in basis points income income
2021 2021 2021
GEL
53
6,733
5,516
EUR
2
238
US$
5
355
Currency
Sensitivity
Sensitivity of other
Decrease of net interest comprehensive
in basis points income income
2021 2021 2021
GEL
53
(6,733)
(5,516)
EUR
2
(238)
US$
5
(355)
Currency risk
Currency risk is the risk that the value of a financial instrument will fluctuate due to changes in foreign exchange rates. The
Management Board has set limits on positions by currency based on the NBG regulations. Positions are monitored daily.
The tables below indicate the currencies to which the Group had significant exposure at 31 December 2023 on its monetary assets
and liabilities. The analysis calculates the effect of a reasonably possible movement of the currency rate against the Georgian Lari,
with all other variables held constant on the income statement. The reasonably possible movement of the currency rate against
the Georgian Lari is calculated as a standard deviation of daily changes in exchange rates over the 12 months. A negative amount
in the table reflects a potential net reduction in income statement or equity, while a positive amount reflects a net potential
increase. During the years ended 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, sensitivity analysis did not reveal any
significant potential effect on the Group’s equity.
Currency
2023
2022
2021
Change in Change in Change in
currency Effect on profit currency Effect on profit currency Effect on profit
rate in % before tax rate in % before tax rate in % before tax
EUR
8.8%
(323)
13.4%
1,251
8.6%
209
US$
4.9%
14,415
10.9%
806
6.4%
1,027
Prepayment risk
Prepayment risk is the risk that the Group will incur a financial loss because its customers and counterparties repay or request
repayment earlier than expected, such as fixed rate mortgages when interest rates fall, or other credit facilities, for similar reasons.
The Group calculates the effect of early repayments by calculating the weighted average rates of early repayments across each
loan product individually, applying these historical rates to the outstanding carrying amount of respective products as at the
reporting date and multiplying by the weighted average effective annual interest rates for each product. The model does not make a
distinction between different reasons for repayment (e.g. relocation, refinancing or renegotiation) and takes into account the effect
of any prepayment penalties on the Group’s income.
350
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
30. Risk management continued
The estimated effect of prepayment risk on net interest income of the Group for the years ended 31 December 2023, 31 December
2022 and 31 December 2021, is as follows:
Effect on net
interest income
2023
(71,177)
2022
(51,899)
2021
(52,552)
Operational risk
Operational risk is the risk of loss arising from systems failure, human error, fraud or external events. When controls fail to perform,
operational risks can cause damage to reputation, have legal or regulatory implications, or lead to financial loss. The Group cannot
expect to eliminate all operational risks, but through a control framework and by monitoring and responding to potential risks,
the Group is able to manage the risks. Controls include effective segregation of duties, access, authorisation and reconciliation
procedures, staff education and assessment processes, including the use of Internal Audit.
Operating environment
Most of the Group’s business is concentrated in Georgia. As an emerging market, Georgia does not possess a well-developed
business and regulatory infrastructure that would generally exist in a more mature market economy. Operations in Georgia may
involve risks that are not typically associated with those in developed markets (including the risk that the Georgian Lari is not freely
convertible outside the country, and that Georgia has undeveloped debt and equity markets). However, over the last few years the
Georgian Government has made a number of developments that positively affect the overall investment climate of the country,
specifically implementing the reforms necessary to create banking, judicial, taxation and regulatory systems.
This includes the adoption of a new body of legislation (including a new tax code and procedural laws). In the view of the Board,
these steps contribute to mitigating the risks of doing business in Georgia.
The existing tendency aimed at the overall improvement of the business environment is expected to persist. The future stability of
the Georgian economy is largely dependent upon these reforms and developments, and the effectiveness of economic, financial
and monetary measures undertaken by the Government. However, the Georgian economy is vulnerable to market downturns and
economic slowdowns elsewhere in the world.
Emerging risks
Information compiled from all the businesses is examined and processed in order to analyse, control and identify emerging risks.
The Group has identified climate risk as an emerging risk. Climate risk was identified as an emerging risk in 2021 following our first
climate materiality assessment. Climate risk is an evolving risk practice and we are examining risk drivers that may be material for
certain sectors. Climate-related risk is the risk of financial loss and/or damage to the Group’s reputation as a result of accelerating
transition to a lower-carbon economy as well as the materialisation of actual physical damage as a result of acute or chronic
weather events. Among other things, transitional and physical risks may impact the performance and financial position of our
customers and their ability to repay their loans.
The Bank conducted a qualitative analysis to understand how, under different scenarios, the transition and physical effects of
climate change can drive credit, liquidity, capital, market, operational and reputational risk for the Bank over ‘short-term’ (i.e. one
to two years) to ‘very long-term’ (i.e. over seven years) time horizons. Risks are perceived to be low over the coming years. However,
reputational risks can occur if our climate action lacks ambition and credibility. We are conducting a more quantitative approach in
2024 to conduct materiality over multiple reference scenarios in addition to modelling impacts on capital and portfolios. Moreover,
the Bank conducted a qualitative analysis of the transition and physical risks for the sectors in which our corporate and MSME
clients are active. The results of this analysis showed that although both strong climate policy (transition risks) and untamed
climate change (physical risks) can negatively affect borrowers’ repayment capacity and value of collateral in the future (from
2030 and beyond), risks over the next years are expected to be low for our commercial portfolio and are not likely to affect current
expectations of credit loss. Our current baseline is a climate policy supportive of low carbon transition and low and minimal exposure
to physical risks. Indirect costs from loss of competitiveness are minimal in our view. A more ambitious transition drive, supported by
policies that would increase the cost of capital, would have an overall negative impact on our current portfolio for carbon intensive
sectors. Climate risks are currently managed at the deal level through an enhanced due diligence approach whereby borrowers
within certain sectors are viewed as higher risk against our Heatmaps. Those deemed higher risk are offered additional guidance on
mitigating options.
Our current assessment of climate risk is backward looking and takes into account only weather-related events from immediate
proceeding years. In 2024 we are undertaking a forward-looking view whereby climate scenarios will impact the likelihood and
intensity of weather-related events on our portfolio. Overall, many of the effects of climate change will be longer term in nature,
with an inherent level of uncertainty, and have no effect on accounting judgments and estimates for the current period. As a result,
there are no additional notes provided in the financial statements. Potential impacts of climate-related risks will be subject to
further analysis in the future.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
351
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
31. Fair value measurements
Fair value hierarchy
For the purpose of fair value disclosures, the Group has determined classes of assets and liabilities on the basis of the nature,
characteristics and risks of the asset or liability. The following tables show analysis of assets and liabilities measured at fair value or
for which fair values are disclosed by level of the fair value hierarchy:
At 31 December 2023 Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Total
Assets measured at fair value
Total investment properties
124,068
124,068
Land
4,844
4,844
Residential properties
87,758
87,758
Non-residential properties
31,466
31,466
Investment securities
7,726
4,424,206
7,519
4,439,451
Other assets – derivative financial assets
10,942
10,942
Assets for which fair values are disclosed
Cash and cash equivalents
3,101,824
3,101,824
Amounts due from credit institutions
1,752,657
1,752,657
Investment securities measured at amortised cost – debt instruments
692,781
692,781
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
19,476,015
19,476,015
Liabilities measured at fair value
Other liabilities – derivative financial liabilities
25,779
25,779
Liabilities for which fair values are disclosed
Client deposits and notes
20,469,692
72,620
20,542,312
Amounts owed to credit institutions
3,735,221
1,416,771
5,151,992
Debt securities issued
270,524
148,134
418,658
Lease liability
13,209
130,236
143,445
At 31 December 2022 Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Total
Assets measured at fair value
Total investment properties
166,546
166,546
Land
9,008
9,008
Residential properties
112,890
112,890
Non-residential properties
44,648
44,648
Investment securities
5,285
3,960,360
5,547
3,971,192
Other assets – derivative financial assets
39,270
39,270
Other assets – investment securities at FVTPL
2,660
2,660
Assets for which fair values are disclosed
Cash and cash equivalents
3,584,843
3,584,843
Amounts due from credit institutions
2,433,028
2,433,028
Investment securities measured at amortised cost – debt instruments
385,800
385,800
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
16,266,826
16,266,826
Liabilities measured at fair value
Other liabilities – derivative financial liabilities
59,020
59,020
Liabilities for which fair values are disclosed
Client deposits and notes
18,228,352
18,228,352
Amounts owed to credit institutions
4,033,727
1,209,141
5,242,868
Debt securities issued
490,559
151,808
642,367
Lease liability
13,068
104,670
117,738
352
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
31. Fair value measurements continued
At 31 December 2021 Level 1
Level 2
Level 3
Total
Assets measured at fair value
Total investment properties
226,849
226,849
Land
11,762
11,762
Residential properties
152,167
152,167
Non-residential properties
62,920
62,920
Investment securities
5,823
2,586,152
3,689
2,595,664
Other assets – derivative financial assets
135,079
135,079
Other assets – investment securities at FVTPL
2,146
2,146
Assets for which fair values are disclosed
Cash and cash equivalents
1,520,562
1,520,562
Amounts due from credit institutions
1,931,390
1,931,390
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
15,787,725
15,787,725
Liabilities measured at fair value
Other liabilities – derivative financial liabilities
7,865
7,865
Liabilities for which fair values are disclosed
Client deposits and notes
14,013,500
14,013,500
Amounts owed to credit institutions
3,635,353
683,092
4,318,445
Debt securities issued
1,310,806
280,109
1,590,915
Lease liability
35
3,574
90,760
94,369
The following is a description of the determination of fair value for financial instruments which are recorded at fair value using
valuation techniques. These incorporate the Group’s estimate of assumptions that a market participant would make when valuing
the instruments.
Derivative financial instruments
Derivative financial instruments valued using a valuation technique with market observable inputs are mainly interest rate swaps,
currency swaps, forward foreign exchange contracts and option contracts. The most frequently applied valuation techniques
include forward pricing and swap models, using present value calculations, as well as standard option pricing models. The models
incorporate various inputs including the credit quality of counterparties, foreign exchange spot and forward rates, interest rate
curves and implied volatilities.
Trading securities and investment securities
Trading securities and a certain part of investment securities are quoted equity and debt securities. Investment securities valued using
a valuation technique or pricing models consist of unquoted equity and debt securities. These securities are valued using models which
sometimes only incorporate data observable in the market and at other times use both observable and non-observable data. The
non-observable inputs to the models include assumptions regarding the future financial performance of the investee, its risk profile, and
economic assumptions regarding the industry and geographical jurisdiction in which the investee operates.
Assets and liabilities not measured at fair value but for which fair value is disclosed
The fair values in the level 2 and level 3 of the fair value hierarchy are estimated using the discounted cash flows valuation technique.
Current interest rates for new instruments with similar credit risk, currency and remaining maturity is used as discount rate in the
valuation model.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
353
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
31. Fair value measurements continued
Fair value hierarchy
Movements in Level 3 financial instruments measured at fair value
The following tables show a reconciliation of the opening and closing amounts of Level 3 financial assets which are recorded at
fair value:
At 31 December Purchase of At 31 December Purchase of At 31 December Purchase of At 31 December
2020 securities 2021 securities 2022 securities 2023
Level 3 financial assets
Equity investment securities
2,076
1,613
3,689
1,858
5,547
1,972
7,519
Movements in Level 3 non-financial assets measured at fair value
All investment properties are Level 3. Reconciliations of their opening and closing amounts are provided in Note 15.
Impact on fair value of Level 3 financial instruments measured at fair value of changes to key assumptions
The following table shows the impact on the fair value of Level 3 instruments of using reasonably possible alternative assumptions:
2023
2022
2021
Effect of Effect of Effect of
reasonably reasonably reasonably
possible possible possible
Carrying alternative Carrying alternative Carrying alternative
amount assumptions amount assumptions amount assumptions
Level 3 financial assets
Equity investment securities
7,519
+/- 1120
5,547
+/- 826
3,689
+/- 549
In order to determine reasonably possible alternative assumptions, the Group’s adjusted key unobservable model inputs are
as follows:
For equities, the Group adjusted the price-over-book-value multiple by increasing and decreasing the ratio by 10%, which is
considered by the Group to be within a range of reasonably possible alternatives based on the price-over-book-value multiples used
across peers within the same geographic area of the same industry.
Description of significant unobservable inputs to valuations of non-financial assets
The following tables show descriptions of significant unobservable inputs to Level 3 valuations of investment properties:
Significant
Valuation unobservable Weighted Other key Weighted
2023 technique
inputs
MIN
MAX
average
information
MIN
MAX
Average
Investment 124,068
property
Land
4,844
Development
4,505
Market
Price per
0.012
2.220
1.033
Square
32
20,000
4,026
land approach square metres,
metre land
Agricultural
339
Market
Price per
0.001
0.709
0.337
Square
310
140,000
19,296
land approach square metres,
metre land
Residential
87,758
Market
Price per
0.049
5.466
1.004
Square
18
3,170
225
properties approach square metres,
metre building
Non-residential 31,466
properties
31,466
Market
Price of the
22.870
3,838.861
1,321.071
Square
50
23,884
2,684
approach property metres,
Land
Square
32
3,000
984
metres,
Building
* Price, rate and cost of unobservable inputs in this table are presented in Georgian Lari (‘GEL’), unless otherwise indicated.
354
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
31. Fair value measurements continued
Set out below is an overview of all financial instruments other than those for which the carrying amount is a reasonable
approximation of fair value held by the Group as at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021:
At 31 December 2023
Amortised cost
FVOCI
FVTPL
Financial assets
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
20,232,721
Accounts receivable and other loans
47,562
Equity instruments
7,880
6,976
Debt instruments
690,306
4,424,160
435
Foreign currency derivative financial instruments
10,942
Total
25,825,070
4,432,040
18,353
Financial liabilities
Client deposits and notes
20,522,739
Amounts owed to credit institutions
5,156,009
Debt securities issued
421,359
Lease liability
141,934
Trade and other payables (in other liabilities)
113,647
Foreign currency derivative financial instruments
25,779
Total
26,355,688
25,779
At 31 December 2022
At 31 December 2021
Amortised cost
FVOCI
FVTPL
Amortised cost
FVOCI
FVTPL
Financial assets
Loans to customers and finance lease
receivables
16,861,706
16,168,973
Accounts receivable and other loans
397,990
3,680
Equity instruments
10,893
9,581
Debt instruments
378,537
3,960,299
2,586,083
Interest rate contracts
348
2,827
Foreign currency derivative financial
instruments
38,922
132,252
Investment securities at FVTPL
2,660
2,146
Total
23,656,104
3,971,192
41,930
19,624,605
2,595,664
137,225
Financial liabilities
Client deposits and notes
18,261,397
14,038,002
Amounts owed to credit institutions
5,266,653
4,318,445
Debt securities issued
645,968
1,518,685
Lease liability
114,470
87,662
Trade and other payables (in other
liabilities)
68,721
56,223
Interest rate contracts
1,385
Foreign currency derivative financial
instruments
59,020
6,480
Total
24,357,209
59,020
20,019,017
7,865
Fair value of financial instruments that are carried in the financial statements not at fair value
Set out below is a comparison by class of the carrying amounts and fair values of the Group’s financial instruments that are carried
in the financial statements. The table does not include the fair values of non-financial assets and non-financial liabilities, fair values
of other smaller financial assets and financial liabilities fair values of which are materially close to their carrying values.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
355
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
31. Fair value measurements continued
At 31 December 2023
Unrecognised
Carrying value
Fair value
gain/(loss)
Financial assets
Investment securities measured at amortised cost – debt instruments
690,306
692,781
2,475
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
20,232,721
19,476,015
(756,706)
Financial liabilities
Client deposits and notes
20,522,739
20,542,312
(19,573)
Amounts owed to credit institutions
5,156,009
5,151,992
4,017
Debt securities issued
421,359
418,658
2,701
Lease liability
141,934
143,445
(1,511)
Total unrecognised change in unrealised fair value
(768,597)
At 31 December 2022
At 31 December 2021
Carrying Fair Unrecognised Fair Unrecognised
value value
gain/(loss)
Carrying value
value gain/(loss)
Financial assets
Investment securities measured at
amortised cost – debt instruments
378,537
385,800
7,263
Loans to customers and finance lease
receivables
16,861,706
16,266,826
(594,880)
16,168,973
15,787,725
(381,248)
Financial liabilities
Client deposits and notes
18,261,397
18,228,352
33,045
14,038,002
14,013,500
24,502
Amounts owed to credit institutions
5,266,653
5,242,868
23,785
4,318,445
4,318,445
Debt securities issued
645,968
642,367
3,601
1,518,685
1,590,915
(72,230)
Lease liability
114,470
117,738
(3,268)
87,662
94,369
(6,707)
Total unrecognised change in unrealised
fair value
(530,454)
(435,683)
The following describes the methodologies and assumptions used to determine fair values for those financial instruments which are
not already recorded at fair value in the consolidated financial statements.
Assets for which fair value approximates carrying value
For financial assets and financial liabilities that are liquid or have a short-term maturity (less than three months), it is assumed that
the carrying amounts approximate to their fair value. This assumption is also applied to demand deposits, savings accounts without
a specific maturity, and variable rate financial instruments.
Fixed rate financial instruments
The fair value of fixed rate financial assets and liabilities carried at amortised cost are estimated by comparing market interest
rates when they were first recognised with current market rates offered for similar financial instruments. The estimated fair value of
fixed interest-bearing deposits is based on discounted cash flows using prevailing money-market interest rates for debts with similar
credit risk and maturity. For financial assets and financial liabilities maturing in less than a year, it is assumed that the carrying
amounts approximate to their fair value.
356
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
32. Maturity analysis of financial assets and liabilities
The table below shows an analysis of financial assets and liabilities according to their contractual maturities, except for current
accounts and credit card loans as described below. See Note 30 ‘Risk management’ for the Groups contractual undiscounted
repayment obligations.
At 31 December 2023
On Up to Up to Up to Up to Up to Over
demand 3 months 6 months 1 year 3 years 5 years
5 years
Total
Financial assets
Cash and cash equivalents
2,417,513
684,311
3,101,824
Amounts due from credit
institutions
1,733,898
18,759
1,752,657
Investment securities
1,499,313
2,661,776
462,614
228,000
242,779
32,823
2,452
5,129,757
Loans to customers and finance
lease receivables
1,190
2,870,703
1,353,016
2,754,708
5,372,193
2,964,992
4,915,919
20,232,721
Accounts receivable and other loans
1,546
45,630
184
202
47,562
Total
5,653,460
6,262,420
1,815,814
2,982,910
5,614,972
2,997,815
4,937,130
30,264,521
Financial liabilities
Client deposits and notes
5,306,925
3,164,462
1,509,643
8,895,604
1,075,055
517,532
53,518
20,522,739
Amounts owed to credit institutions
476,646
2,297,284
87,969
424,409
810,610
554,167
504,924
5,156,009
Debt securities issued
406
25,135
13,388
294,075
5,197
83,158
421,359
Lease liability
9,024
8,855
16,762
55,277
31,107
20,909
141,934
Total
5,783,571
5,471,176
1,631,602
9,350,163
2,235,017
1,108,003
662,509
26,242,041
Net
(130,111)
791,244
184,212
(6,367,253)
3,379,955
1,889,812
4,274,621
4,022,480
Accumulated gap
(130,111)
661,133
845,345
(5,521,908)
(2,141,953)
(252,141)
4,022,480
At 31 December 2022
On Up to Up to Up to Up to Up to Over
demand 3 months 6 months 1 year 3 years 5 years
5 years
Total
Financial assets
Cash and cash equivalents
2,853,938
730,905
3,584,843
Amounts due from credit institutions 2,396,574
733
2,257
2,885
8,986
1,291
20,302
2,433,028
Investment securities
953,357
2,315,414
536,088
217,956
142,195
182,498
2,221
4,349,729
Loans to customers and finance
lease receivables
4,204
2,087,706
1,238,926
2,103,947
4,575,809
2,420,979
4,430,135
16,861,706
Accounts receivable and other loans
2,057
375,736
35
1,518
18,644
397,990
Total
6,210,130
5,510,494
1,777,306
2,326,306
4,745,634
2,604,768
4,452,658
27,627,296
Financial liabilities
Client deposits and notes
5,406,670
2,812,580
1,298,966
6,963,532
1,229,394
283,703
266,552
18,261,397
Amounts owed to credit institutions
701,207
2,599,102
168,560
396,759
677,401
363,797
359,827
5,266,653
Debt securities issued
7,816
51,107
281,519
109,683
195,843
645,968
Lease liability
6,899
7,161
14,146
46,624
26,963
12,677
114,470
Total
6,107,877
5,426,397
1,525,794
7,655,956
2,063,102
870,306
639,056
24,288,488
Net
102,253
84,097
251,512
(5,329,650)
2,682,532
1,734,462
3,813,602
3,338,808
Accumulated gap
102,253
186,350
437,862
(4,891,788)
(2,209,256)
(474,794)
3,338,808
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
357
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
32. Maturity analysis of financial assets and liabilities continued
At 31 December 2021
On Up to Up to Up to Up to Up to Over
demand 3 months 6 months 1 year 3 years 5 years
5 years
Total
Financial assets
Cash and cash equivalents
1,291,890
228,672
1,520,562
Amounts due from credit institutions
1,893,732
8,003
7,744
9,652
3,540
8,719
1,931,390
Investment securities
1,162,051
1,282,493
7,478
12,486
39,734
88,776
2,646
2,595,664
Loans to customers and finance
lease receivables
2,966
3,046,387
926,061
1,976,611
4,005,985
2,281,105
3,929,858
16,168,973
Accounts receivable and other loans
261
1,608
9
1,802
3,680
Total
4,350,900
4,567,163
941,292
1,990,899
4,055,371
2,373,421
3,941,223
22,220,269
Financial liabilities
Client deposits and notes
2,455,123
2,783,998
1,177,931
6,048,073
852,196
454,304
266,377
14,038,002
Amounts owed to credit institutions
170,410
1,638,683
221,013
355,637
996,956
526,697
409,049
4,318,445
Debt securities issued
37,515
16,364
233,824
1,008,104
222,878
1,518,685
Lease liability
6,198
5,782
10,355
35,238
22,808
7,281
87,662
Total
2,625,533
4,466,394
1,421,090
6,647,889
2,892,494
1,226,687
682,707
19,962,794
Net
1,725,367
100,769
(479,798)
(4,656,990)
1,162,877
1,146,734
3,258,516
2,257,475
Accumulated gap
1,725,367
1,826,136
1,346,338
(3,310,652)
(2,147,775)
(1,001,041)
2,257,475
The Groups capability to discharge its liabilities relies on its ability to realise equivalent assets within the same period of time.
In the Georgian marketplace, where most of the Group’s business is concentrated, many short-term credits are granted with
the expectation of renewing the loans at maturity. As such, the ultimate maturity of assets may be different from the analysis
presented above. To reflect the historical stability of current accounts, the Group calculates the minimal daily balance of current
accounts over the past two years and includes the amount in the ‘Up to 1 year’ category in the table above. The remaining current
accounts are included in the ‘On demand’ category. To match the coverage of short-term borrowings from the NBG with the
investment securities pledged to secure it, those securities are included in the ‘On demand’ category. Considering credit cards have
no contractual maturities, the above allocation per category is done based on the statistical coverage rates observed.
The Groups principal sources of liquidity are as follows:
deposits;
borrowings from international credit institutions;
inter-bank deposit agreements;
debt issues;
proceeds from sale of securities;
principal repayments on loans;
interest income; and
fees and commissions income.
As at 31 December 2023, client deposits and notes amounted to GEL 20,522,739 (2022: GEL 18,261,397, 2021: GEL 14,038,002) and
represented 77% (2022: 74%, 2021: 69%) of the Group’s total liabilities. These funds continue to provide a majority of the Group’s
funding and represent a diversified and stable source of funds. As at 31 December 2023, amounts owed to credit institutions
amounted to GEL 5,156,009 2023 (2022: GEL 5,266,653, 2021: GEL 4,318,445) and represented 19% (2022: 21%, 2021: 21%) of total
liabilities. As at 31 December 2023, debt securities issued amounted to GEL 421,359 (2022: GEL 645,968, 2021: GEL 1,518,685) and
represented 2% (2022: 3%, 2021: 7%) of total liabilities.
In the Board’s opinion, liquidity is sufficient to meet the Groups present requirements.
358
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
32. Maturity analysis of financial assets and liabilities continued
The table below shows an analysis of assets and liabilities according to when they are expected to be recovered or settled, except
for current accounts which are included in the ‘Up to 1 year’ category in the table above, noting that respective contractual maturity
may expand over significantly longer periods:
At 31 December 2023
Less than More than
1 year
1 year
Total
Cash and cash equivalents
3,101,824
3,101,824
Amounts due from credit institutions
1,733,898
18,759
1,752,657
Investment securities
4,851,703
278,054
5,129,757
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
6,979,617
13,253,104
20,232,721
Accounts receivable and other loans
47,562
47,562
Prepayments
30,633
6,878
37,511
Foreclosed assets
271,712
271,712
Right-of-use assets
138,695
138,695
Investment properties
124,068
124,068
Property and equipment
436,955
436,955
Goodwill
41,253
41,253
Intangible assets
167,862
167,862
Income tax assets
2,520
2,520
Other assets
238,560
6,512
245,072
Assets held for sale
27,389
27,389
Total assets
17,013,706
14,743,852
31,757,558
Client deposits and notes
18,876,634
1,646,105
20,522,739
Amounts owed to credit institutions
3,286,308
1,869,701
5,156,009
Debt securities issued
38,929
382,430
421,359
Lease liability
34,641
107,293
141,934
Accruals and deferred income
90,762
38,593
129,355
Income tax liabilities
185,440
13,618
199,058
Other liabilities
167,268
167,268
Total liabilities
22,679,982
4,057,740
26,737,722
Net
(5,666,276)
10,686,112
5,019,836
At 31 December 2022
At 31 December 2021
Less than More than Less than More than
1 year
1 year
Total
1 year
1 year
Total
Cash and cash equivalents
3,584,843
3,584,843
1,520,562
1,520,562
Amounts due from credit institutions
2,402,449
30,579
2,433,028
1,909,479
21,911
1,931,390
Investment securities
4,022,815
326,914
4,349,729
2,464,508
131,156
2,595,664
Loans to customers and finance lease
receivables
5,434,783
11,426,923
16,861,706
5,952,025
10,216,948
16,168,973
Accounts receivable and other loans
379,346
18,644
397,990
3,680
3,680
Prepayments
40,020
3,592
43,612
39,276
1,602
40,878
Foreclosed assets
119,924
119,924
3,216
3,216
Right-of-use assets
117,387
117,387
80,186
80,186
Investment properties
166,546
166,546
226,849
226,849
Property and equipment
398,855
398,855
378,808
378,808
Goodwill
33,351
33,351
33,351
33,351
Intangible assets
149,441
149,441
144,251
144,251
Income tax assets
224
640
864
109
183
292
Other assets
206,176
8,882
215,058
246,563
8,682
255,245
Assets held for sale
29,566
29,566
46,731
46,731
Total assets
16,100,222
12,801,678
28,901,900
12,182,933
11,247,143
23,430,076
Client deposits and notes
16,481,748
1,779,649
18,261,397
12,465,125
1,572,877
14,038,002
Amounts owed to credit institutions
3,865,628
1,401,025
5,266,653
2,385,743
1,932,702
4,318,445
Debt securities issued
340,442
305,526
645,968
287,703
1,230,982
1,518,685
Lease liability
28,206
86,264
114,470
22,335
65,327
87,662
Accruals and deferred income
73,660
32,706
106,366
53,346
26,811
80,157
Income tax liabilities
20,258
79,275
99,533
85,270
25,598
110,868
Other liabilities
157,948
743
158,691
182,070
1,279
183,349
Total liabilities
20,967,890
3,685,188
24,653,078
15,481,592
4,855,576
20,337,168
Net
(4,867,668)
9,116,490
4,248,822
(3,298,659)
6,391,567
3,092,908
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
359
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
33. Related party disclosures
In accordance with IAS 24 ‘Related Party Disclosures’, parties are considered to be related if one party has the ability to control the
other party or exercise significant influence over the other party in making financial or operational decisions. In considering each
possible related party relationship, attention is directed to the substance of the relationship, not merely the legal form.
Related parties may enter into transactions which unrelated parties might not, and transactions between related parties may not
be effected on the same terms, conditions and amounts as transactions between unrelated parties.
All transactions with related parties disclosed below have been conducted on an arm’s length basis.
The volumes of related party transactions, outstanding balances at the year-end, and related expenses and income for the year are
as follows:
At 31 December 2023
At 31 December 2022
At 31 December 2021
Key Key Key
management management management
Associates
personnel*
Associates
personnel*
Associates
personnel*
Loans outstanding at 1 January, gross
9,819
12,050
10,646
Loans issued during the year
5,663
7,090
8,944
Loan repayments during the year
(4,993)
(7,246)
(6,531)
Other movements
547
(2,075)
(1,009)
Loans outstanding at 31 December, gross
11,036
9,819
12,050
Less: allowance for impairment at
31 December
(110)
(67)
(27)
Loans outstanding at 31 December, net
10,926
9,752
12,023
Interest income on loans
556
745
644
Expected credit loss
(40)
(200)
Deposits at 1 January
243
12,633
202
31,127
166
32,619
Deposits received during the year
1,796
9,696
9,212
36
21,490
Deposits repaid during the year
(6,715)
(15,773)
(32,337)
Other movements
(2,263)
41
(11,933)
9,355
Deposits at 31 December
2,039
13,351
243
12,633
202
31,127
Interest expense on deposits
(863)
(959)
(1,368)
* Key management personnel includes members of BOGG’s Board of Directors and key executives of the Group.
Details of Directors’ emoluments are included in the Remuneration Report on pages 229 to 247. Compensation of key management
personnel comprised the following:
2023
2022
2021
Salaries and other benefits
17,443
11,841
12,915
Share-based payments compensation
50,861
58,208
25,048
Social security costs
381
Total key management compensation
68,685
70,049
37,963
Key management personnel do not receive cash-settled compensation, except for fixed salaries. The major part of the total
compensation is share-based (Note 29). The number of key management personnel at 31 December 2023 was 23 (31 December
2022: 23, 31 December 2021: 21).
As at 31 December 2023 interest rates on loans issued to key management personnel comprised 16.8% and 4.5% (31 December 2022:
17.9% and 4.5%, 31 December 2021: 28.8% and 4.0%) for GEL and FC denominated loans, respectively. As at 31 December 2023
interest rates on deposits placed by key management personnel comprised 13.5% and 0.0% (as at 31 December 22: 13.5% and 0.0%,
as at 31 December 21: 14.2% and 0.0%) for GEL and FC denominated deposits, respectively.
360
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
34. Capital adequacy
The Group maintains an actively managed capital base to cover risks inherent to the business. The adequacy of the Group’s capital is
monitored using, among other measures, the ratios established by the NBG in supervising the Bank.
During the year ended 31 December 2023, the Bank and the Group complied in full with all its externally imposed capital
requirements.
The primary objectives of the Group’s capital management are to ensure that the Bank complies with externally imposed capital
requirements and that the Group maintains strong credit ratings and healthy capital ratios in order to support its business and
to maximise shareholder value. The Group manages its capital structure and makes adjustments to it in light of the changes in
economic conditions and the risk characteristics of its activities. In order to maintain or adjust the capital structure, the Group may
adjust the amount of dividend payment to shareholders, return capital to shareholders or issue capital securities. No changes were
made in the objectives, policies and processes from the previous years.
NBG (Basel III) capital adequacy ratio
In December 2017, the NBG adopted amendments to the regulations relating to capital adequacy requirements, including
amendments to the regulation on capital adequacy requirements for commercial banks, and introduced new requirements on the
determination of the countercyclical buffer rate, on the identification of systematically important banks, on determining systemic
buffer requirements and on additional capital buffer requirements for commercial banks within Pillar 2. The NBG requires the Bank
to maintain a minimum total capital adequacy ratio of risk-weighted assets, computed based on the Bank’s standalone special-
purpose financial statements prepared in accordance with NBG regulations and pronouncements, based on Basel III requirements.
In January 2023, the NBG transitioned to IFRS-based accounting and introduced a new Pillar 2 buffer – Credit Risk Adjustment
(CRA) buffer, to account for the difference between the NBG-based and the IFRS-based provision levels (higher in the former case).
As at 31 December 2023, 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, the Bank’s capital adequacy ratio on this basis was as follows:
IFRS-based NBG (Basel III) capital adequacy ratio
As at
31 December
2023
Tier 1 capital
4,603,352
Tier 2 capital
499,018
Total capital
5,102,370
Risk-weighted assets
23,061,905
Tier 1 capital ratio
20.0%
Total capital ratio
22.1%
Min. requirement for Tier 1 capital ratio
16.7%
Min. requirement for Total capital ratio
19.6%
As at 31 December 2022 and 31 December 2021, the Bank’s capital adequacy were as follows:
NBG (Basel III) capital adequacy ratio
As at As at
31 December 31 December
2022 2021
Tier 1 capital
3,388,048
2,691,000
Tier 2 capital
618,232
784,800
Total capital
4,006,280
3,475,800
Risk-weighted assets
20,279,424
17,977,949
Tier 1 capital ratio
16.7%
15.0%
Total capital ratio
19.8%
19.3%
Min. requirement for Tier 1 capital ratio
13.8%
13.6%
Min. requirement for Total capital ratio
17.2%
17.7%
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
361
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
35. Events after the reporting period
On 15 March 2024, the Group’s Board of Directors approved a GEL 100 million extension of the share buyback and cancellation
programme. The shares will be purchased in the open market. The purpose of the buyback is to reduce the surplus capital, and the
cancellation of the treasury shares will be executed on a monthly basis.
Business combinations
On 31 March 2024, with reference to Share Purchase Agreement (‘SPA’) dated 18 February 2024, the Group acquired 90% of the
share capital of Ameriabank CJSC, one of the leading banks operating in Armenia, from selling shareholders IMAST Group (CY)
Limited (owning 48.82% shares in Ameriabank CJSC), European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (owning 17.71% shares
in Ameriabank CJSC out of which 7.71% shares were acquired and remaining 10% is subject to put/call option), Asian Development
Bank (owning 13.92% shares in Ameriabank CJSC), ESPS Holding Limited (owning 12.05% shares in Ameriabank CJSC) and Afeyan
Foundation for Armenia Inc. (owning 7.5% shares in Ameriabank CJSC). The acquisition is financed by cash consideration of US$
276,989 thousand (approximately GEL 746,569 thousand) out of which US$ 21,031 thousand which equals to approximately GEL
56,686 thousand, is deferred and is due in six months after the completion date. The remaining 10% of share capital retained
by European Bank for Reconstruction and Development is subject to a put/call option. Price of the put/call option is US$ 30,777
thousand (approximately GEL 82,955 thousand) with interest accrued till the exercise date at a rate of 6-month SOFR + 3.5% p.a.
subject to offset by any dividends paid to EBRD till exercise date. The Group can exercise call option anytime up to 3 years after
completion, while put option can be exercised by EBRD in 3 years after completion. After the acquisition the Group shall account for
as acquired the entire issued share capital of Ameriabank CJSC, with ownership split between BOG JSC with a 30% shareholding
and BOGG a 70% shareholding (including the present ownership of 10% shares subject to the put/call).
The Group analysed the terms of the put/call option to assess whether the Group has obtained present ownership rights over the shares
subject to option at the acquisition date. The Group has concluded that the shares subject to option shall be accounted for as acquired
(no NCI will be recognised) and the option shall be recorded as a financial liability forming a part of the consideration transferred.
The acquisition will enable the Group’s expansion in the Armenian market and is expected to provide significant strategic,
commercial and financial benefits to the Group as outlined below:
The Armenian economy and banking sector have certain attractive characteristics similar to those in the Groups principal
operating country, Georgia, and the Board considers this as an attractive market for expansion that fits very well with the
current footprint. Armenia is a neighbouring country with a high-growth economy of similar size to Georgia. The overall Armenian
economy is less leveraged compared with the Georgian economy, creating a supportive environment for further banking sector
growth in coming years. The Armenian banking sector is financially prudent with low market share concentration levels offering
scope for further consolidation.
Ameriabank CJSC is one of the leading universal banks in Armenia with prudent risk policies and a strong profitability track
record and has an attractive franchise with significant upside potential from leveraging the Groups customer focus and digital
capabilities. Ameriabank CJSC has a leading market position in Armenia based on the loan portfolio size and a particularly
strong foothold in the corporate segment. The market share in retail segment is also increasing boosted by improving digital
offerings. The Group believes that Ameriabank CJSC has significant growth potential and further scope to improve commercial
performance, particularly in retail. This is expected to be achieved by combining Ameriabank CJSC’s existing franchise strengths
with the Groups expertise. Besides, Ameriabank CJSC has a well-regarded and experienced management team who agreed to
stay on after the acquisition (for at least 24 months).
The acquisition offers multiple strategic benefits to the Group allowing it to diversify its revenue streams, unlock further growth
potential and increase scale. Considering the Group has achieved leading market shares in Georgia, an expansion geographically
unlocks further growth potential beyond the local Georgian market. The acquisition also has strong financial rationale that fulfils
strict internal financial criteria set by the Group and is expected to result in significant value creation for shareholders.
The acquisition-date fair value of the total purchase consideration and its components are as follows:
In thousands of GEL
Cash consideration payment
689,883
Deferred consideration
56,686
Present value of redemption liability for put option
82,955
Total purchase consideration
829,524
Acquisition-related transaction costs of GEL 6,965 thousand were expensed as general and administrative expenses in 2023.
Additionally, GEL 17,713 thousand acquisition-related cost was expensed as general and administrative expenses in 2024.
362
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
35. Events after the reporting period continued
The purchase consideration is based on the book value of Ameriabank CJSC based on balance sheet as at 30 October 2023 prepared
under IFRS. However, in accordance with IFRS 3 ‘Business Combinations’, the Group must account for business acquisitions based on fair
values of the identifiable assets acquired, and liabilities assumed. These two different approaches can lead to differences; and, as set
out in the table below, the excess of the net fair value of the acquirees identifiable assets and liabilities over cost (‘negative goodwill’)
is immediately recorded in profit or loss for the year. Details of the assets and liabilities acquired and negative goodwill arising from the
acquisition are as follows:
In thousands of GEL
Attributed fair
value
Cash and cash equivalents
679,965
Amounts due from credit institutions
735,733
Investment securities
1,179,372
Loans to customers and finance lease receivables
6,558,768
Foreclosed assets
5,259
Right-of-use assets
85,508
Property and equipment
74,213
Intangible assets
103,089
Income tax assets
17,054
Other assets
112,578
Client deposits and notes
(6,125,166)
Amounts owed to credit institutions
(757,763)
Debt securities issued
(831,851)
Lease liability
(85,508)
Accruals and Deferred Income
(42,349)
Income tax liabilities
(78,800)
Other liabilities
(169,397)
Fair value of identifiable net assets of subsidiary acquired
1,460,705
Total purchase consideration
829,524
Negative goodwill arising from the acquisition
(631,181)
The fair values of assets and liabilities acquired are based on discounted cash flow models. The fair value of the identifiable net assets of
GEL 1,460,705 thousand is provisional given it is based on February 2024 valuation which will be updated as at acquisition date.
The valuation of identifiable intangible assets was performed by an independent professional appraiser. Based on the appraisal
report, the following items are included in the purchase price allocation:
brand name valued at GEL 29,495 thousands; and
customer relationships valued at GEL 34,516 thousands.
The negative goodwill is primarily attributable to the scarcity of potential buyers in Armenian market considering the value of
the net assets acquired. Additionally, the Group is a UK listed financial institution which gave the Management further ability to
negotiate the deal.
At acquisition, the carrying amount of loans to customers and finance lease receivables classified as POCI by the Group in the
consolidated financial statement is GEL 75,726. The remaining amount of GEL 6,483,042 thousand represents the gross carrying amount
of stage 1 loans to customers and finance lease receivables.
Additional Tier 1 Notes
On 9 April 2024, Bank of Georgia Group PLC’s subsidiary, JSC Bank of Georgia successfully priced a USD 300 million offering of 9.5%
perpetual subordinated callable additional tier 1 notes (the ‘Notes’). The Notes are denominated in USD and settled on 16 April 2024.
The Notes are being issued in accordance with Reg S/Rule 144A and sold at an issue price of 100%.
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements continued
(Thousands of Georgian Lari)
363
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
ADDITIONAL
INFORMATION
364
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Global Reporting Initiative (GRI)
content index
Bank of Georgia Group PLC has reported the information cited in this GRI content index for the period (1 January 2022 -31 December
2022) with reference to the GRI Standards.
GRI indicator Description Report section or other documentation
GRI 2: General Disclosures 2021
The organisation and its reporting practices
2-1 Organisational details About Us (page 2)
2-2 Entities included in the organisation’s sustainability
reporting
Sustainable Business (page 61)
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(pages 272 to 274)
2-3 Reporting period, frequency and contact point Sustainable Business (page 61)
2-4 Restatements of information Not applicable
2-5 External assurance We have not sought external assurance for
sustainability reporting
Activities and workers
2-6 Activities, value chain, and other business relationships About us (page 2)
Our purpose and strategy framework (page 18)
JSC Bank of Georgia business model (page 20)
2-7 Employees Sustainable Business (page 120)
2-8 Workers who are not employees Sustainable Business (page 120)
Governance
2-9 Governance structure and composition Directors’ Governance Statement (pages 188 to 197)
Board of Directors (pages 198 to 200)
2-10 Nomination and selection of the highest governance body Nomination Committee Report (pages 206 to 213)
2-11 Chair of the highest governance body Directors’ Governance Statement (pages 188 to 190)
Board of Directors (pages 198 to 200)
2-12 Role of the highest governance body in overseeing the
management of impacts
Sustainable Business (Page 61; pages 102 to 193)
Directors’ Governance Statement (pages 188 to 197)
2-13 Delegation of responsibility for managing impacts Sustainable Business (pages 61; pages 92 to 98; pages 102
to 193)
Directors’ Governance Statement (pages 188 to 197)
2-14 Role of the highest governance body in sustainability
reporting
Section 172 Statement (page 59)
Sustainable Business (page 61; page 102; page 103)
Directors’ Governance Statement (pages 118 to 197)
2-15 Conflicts of interest Director’s Governance Statement (page 191)
Nomination Committee Report (page 210)
Audit Committee Report (pages 220 and 222)
Directors’ Remuneration Report (page 229)
Directors’ Report (page 251)
2-16 Communication of critical concerns Sustainable Business (page 90; page 122)
Risk Management (page 145)
Audit Committee Report (page 222)
2-17 Collective knowledge of the highest governance body TCFD (page 103)
Governance (page 187)
2-18 Evaluation of the performance of the highest governance
body
Directors’ Governance Statement (pages 196 to 212)
2-19 Remuneration policies Directors’ Remuneration Report (pages 243 to 247)
2-20 Process to determine remuneration Directors’ Remuneration Report (pages 229 to 247)
2-21 Annual total compensation ratio Directors’ Remuneration Report (page 237; page 239)
365
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
GRI indicator Description Report section or other documentation
GRI 2: General Disclosures 2021 (continued)
Strategy, Policies and Practices
2-22 Statement on sustainable development strategy Chairman’s Statement (page 15)
Sustainable Business (pages 62 to 64)
2-23 Policy commitments https://bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/documents
Sustainable Business (pages 61 to 142)
2-24 Embedding policy commitments Sustainable Business (pages 61 to 142)
Risk Management (pages 144 to 148)
Principal Risks and Uncertainties (pages 150 to 169)
Directors’ Governance Statement (pages 188 to 197)
2-25 Processes to remediate negative impacts Sustainable Business (pages 67 to 80)
Principal Risks and Uncertainties (pages 150 to 169)
2-26 Mechanisms for seeking advice and raising concerns Sustainable Business (page 122)
https://bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/documents
2-27 Compliance with laws and regulations Principal Risks and Uncertainties (page 158)
2-28 Membership associations Sustainable Business (page 65)
Stakeholder Engagement
2-29 Approach to stakeholder engagement Section 172(1) statement (pages 52 to 57)
Directors’ Governance Statement (pages 178 to 183)
GRI 3: Material Topics
GRI 3: Material Topics
3-1 Process to determine material topics Sustainable Business (pages 62 to 63)
3-2 List of material topics Sustainable Business (page 63)
Topic-specific disclosures
GRI indicator Description Report section or other documentation
GRI 200: Economic
GRI 201: Economic Performance 2016
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Our Purpose and Strategy Framework
(page 18)
Our Key Enablers (page 19)
JCS Bank of Georgia Business model
(page 20)
Strategy and Performance (pages 25 to 51)
Sustainable Business (pages 61 to 142)
201-1 Direct economic value generated and
distributed
Overview of Financial Results (pages 172
to 183)
201-2 Financial implications and other risks and
opportunities due to climate change
Sustainable Business (pages 93 to 117)
GRI 203: Indirect Economic Performance 2016
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 61 to 64)
203-2 Significant indirect economic impacts Sustainable Business (pages 134 to 140)
366
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Global Reporting Initiative (GRI)
content index continued
GRI indicator Description Report section or other documentation
GRI 200: Economic (continued)
GRI 205: Anti-corruption 2016
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 70 to 71)
Principal Risks and Uncertainties
(pages 160 and 161)
205-3 Confirmed incidents of corruption and
actions taken
Sustainable Business (pages 70 to 71)
Principal Risks and Uncertainties (pages 160
to 161)
GRI 400: Social
GRI 401: Employment 2016
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 120 to 132)
401-1 New employee hires and employee turnover Sustainable Business (pages 124 to 125)
401-3 Parental leave Sustainable Business (page 129)
GRI 404: Training and Education 2016
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 125 to 127)
404-1 Average hours of training per year per
employee
Sustainable Business (page 127)
404-3 Percentage of employees receiving
regular performance and career
development reviews
Sustainable Business (page 127)
GRI 405: Diversity and Equal Opportunity 2016
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (page 122)
https://bankofgeorgiagroup.com/
governance/documents
405-1 Diversity of governance bodies and
employees
Sustainable Business (page 122)
Governance at a glance (page 186)
405-2 Ratio of the basic salary and
remuneration of women to men
Sustainable Business (page 128)
GRI 418: Customer Privacy 2016
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 72 to 77)
Principal Risks and Uncertainties (pages 159
to 163)
418-1 Substantiated complaints concerning
breaches of customer privacy and losses
of customer data
Sustainable Business (page 76)
Non-GRI Disclosures
Customer protection
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 77 to 80)
Topic-specific indicator NPS Sustainable Business (page 8)
Customer experience
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Strategy and Peformance (page 19)
Sustainable Business (page 78)
Topic-specific indicator NPS Strategy and Performance (page 19)
Financial inclusion and empowerment
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 87 to 91)
Topic-specific indicator Digital MAU
Volume of payment transactions
in BOG’s acquiring
Payment MAU
sCoolApp MAU
Number of Self-employed Borrowers
Strategy and Performance (pages 23 to 24)
367
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
GRI indicator Description Report section or other documentation
Non-GRI Disclosures (continued)
Product innovation
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Strategy and Performance (pages 27; 43)
Topic-specific indicator Digital MAU
Digital DAU
Digital DAU/MAU
Share of products sold digitally
Number of transactions in Busienss mBank
and iBank
Strategy and performance (pages 28; 43)
Ethical business
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 67 to 80)
Topic-specific indicator Number of ethics-related concerns received Sustainable Business (page 80)
Climate, environmental, and social management of loan portfolio
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 93 to 97)
Topic-specific indicator % exposure to carbon-related assets in loan
portfolio;
% exposure to fossil fuel and coal-related
assets in loan portfolio
Sustainable Business (page 108)
Human rights
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Sustainable Business (pages 111 to 112)
Sustainable Business (pages 134 to 137)
Topic-specific indicator eNPS Sustainable Business (page 130)
Risk management
GRI 3: Material topics 2021 3-3 Management of material topics Risk Management (pages 144 to 148)
Topic-specific indicator Risk indicators Principal Risks and Uncertainties (pages 150
to 169)
368
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
References
The Bank, BOG, or
Bank of Georgia
JSC Bank of Georgia
The Group Bank of Georgia Group PLC and its group companies as a whole
The Company Bank of Georgia Group PLC
The Board The Board of Directors of Bank of Georgia Group PLC
The Code The UK Corporate Governance Code published in 2018
The Directors Members of the Board of Directors
Supervisory Board Supervisory Board of the Bank
Executive Management Team Executive Management and Executive Management Team are used interchangeably throughout
the report. Both represent Management Team of the Group as presented on the Groups website
https://bankofgeorgiagroup.com/governance/people/management; in some contexts related to
Bank of Georgia, it refers to Management Team of the Bank as presented on the Bank’s website at
https://bankofgeorgia.ge/en/about/management
We/our/us References to ‘we, ‘our’ or ‘us’ are primarily references to the Group throughout this Report.
However, the Group comprises and operates through its subsidiaries which are legal entities
with their own relevant management and governance structures (as set out in relevant parts of
this Report). In that regard, when using ‘we, ‘our’ or ‘us’ in the context of the banking business in
Georgia, we refer to JSC Bank of Georgia. Likewise, ‘we’, ‘our’ or ‘us’ in the context of Georgian
capital markets and investment banking activities, we refer to JSC Galt & Taggart, unless
otherwise specifically indicated in this Annual Report
369
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Glossary
Alternative performance
measures (APMs)
In this announcement the management
uses various APMs, which they believe
provide additional useful information for
understanding the financial performance
of the Group. These APMs are not
defined by International Financial
Reporting Standards, and also may
not be directly comparable with other
companies who use similar measures.
We believe that these APMs provide
the best representation of our financial
performance as these measures are used
by management to evaluate the Group’s
operating performance and make day-
today operating decisions;
Strategic terms
Active merchant
At least one transaction executed within
the past month;
Monthly active user –
retail or business (MAU)
Number of customers who satisfied pre-
defined activity criteria within the past
month;
Monthly active digital user
(Digital MAU)
A user with at least one login within past
month in BOG APP/iBank/sCoolApp;
Digital daily active user
(Digital DAU)
Average daily number of retail customers
who logged into our BOG APP/iBank/
sCoolApp at least once within the past
month;
Payment MAU
Number of Bank’s retail customers who
made at least one payment with a BOG
card within the past month;
Ratio definitions
Basic earnings per share
Profit for the year attributable to
shareholders of the Group divided by the
weighted average number of outstanding
ordinary shares over the same year;
Book value per share
Total equity attributable to shareholders
of the Group divided by ordinary shares
outstanding at year end; net ordinary
shares outstanding equals total number
of ordinary shares outstanding at year
end less number of treasury shares at
year end;
Constant currency basis
Changes assuming constant exchange
rate. To calculate the y-o-y growth
without the currency exchange rate
effect, we used the exchange rates
of relevant currencies to GEL as of
31 December 2022;
Cost of deposits
Interest expense on client deposits and
notes of the period divided by monthly
average client deposits and notes;
Cost of funds
Interest expense of the year divided
by monthly average interest-bearing
liabilities;
Cost of credit risk
Expected loss/impairment charge for
loans to customers and finance lease
receivables for the year divided by
monthly average gross loans to customers
and finance lease receivables over the
same year;
Cost:income ratio
Operating expenses divided by operating
income;
Gross loans to customers
Throughout this Annual Report are
presented net of ECL on contractually
accrued interest income;
Interest-bearing liabilities
Amounts owed to credit institutions,
client deposits and notes, and debt
securities issued;
Interest earning assets
(excluding cash)
Amounts due from credit institutions,
investment securities (but excluding
corporate shares) and net loans to
customers and finance lease receivables;
Leverage (times)
Total liabilities divided by total equity;
Liquid assets
Cash and cash equivalents, amounts due
from credit institutions and investment
securities;
Liquidity coverage ratio (LCR)
High-quality liquid assets (as defined
by NBG) divided by net cash outflow
over the next 30 days (as defined by
NBG). Calculations are made for Bank
of Georgia standalone, based on IFRS;
Loan yield
Interest income from loans to customers
and finance lease receivables divided by
monthly average gross loans to customers
and finance lease receivables;
NBG (Basel III) Common Equity
Tier 1 (CET1) capital adequacy
ratio
Common Equity Tier 1 capital divided
by total risk-weighted assets, both
calculated in accordance with the
requirements of the National Bank of
Georgia. Calculations are made for Bank
of Georgia standalone, based on IFRS;
NBG (Basel III) Tier 1 capital
adequacy ratio
Tier 1 capital divided by total risk-
weighted assets, both calculated in
accordance with the requirements of the
National Bank of Georgia. Calculations
are made for Bank of Georgia standalone,
based on IFRS;
NBG (Basel III) Total capital
adequacy ratio
Total regulatory capital divided by total
risk-weighted assets, both calculated in
accordance with the requirements of the
National Bank of Georgia. Calculations
are made for Bank of Georgia standalone,
based on IFRS;
Net interest margin (NIM)
Net interest income for the year
divided by monthly average interest
earning assets excluding cash and cash
equivalents and corporate shares for the
same year;
Net stable funding ratio (NSFR)
Available amount of stable funding (as
defined by NBG) divided by the required
amount of stable funding (as defined by
NBG). Calculations are made for Bank of
Georgia standalone, based on IFRS;
Net loans
In all sections of the Annual Report,
except for the consolidated audited
financial statements, net loans are
defined as gross loans to customers and
finance lease receivables less allowance
for expected credit loss;
Non-performing loans (NPLs)
The principal and/or interest payments
on loans overdue for more than 90 days;
or the exposures experiencing substantial
deterioration of their creditworthiness
and the debtors assessed as unlikely
to pay their credit obligation(s) in full
without realisation of collateral;
NPL coverage ratio
Allowance for expected credit loss of
loans to customers and finance lease
receivables divided by NPLs;
NPL coverage ratio adjusted for
discounted value of collateral
Allowance for expected credit loss of
loans and finance lease receivables
divided by NPLs (discounted value of
collateral is added back to allowance
for expected credit loss);
One-off items
Significant items that do not arise during
ordinary course of business;
Operating leverage
Percentage change in operating income
less percentage change in operating
expenses;
370
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Glossary continued
Return on average total assets
(ROAA)
Profit for the year divided by monthly
average total assets for the same year;
Return on average total equity
(ROAE)
Profit for the year attributable to
shareholders of BOGG divided by
monthly average equity attributable to
shareholders of BOGG for the same year;
Weighted average number of
ordinary shares
Average of daily outstanding number of
shares less daily outstanding number of
treasury shares;
Weighted average diluted
number of ordinary shares
Weighted average number of ordinary
shares plus weighted average dilutive
number of shares known to management
during the same year;
NMF
Not meaningful.
Executive management
functions
CEO
Chief Executive Officer
CFO
Chief Financial Officer
CLO
Chief Legal Officer
CMO
Chief Marketing Officer
CRO
Chief Risk Officer
371
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
Strategic Report Governance Financial Statements Additional Information
Shareholder information
Our website
All shareholders and potential shareholders can gain access to the Annual Report, presentations to investors, key financial
information, regulatory news, share and dividend data, AGM documentation and other significant information about Bank of
Georgia Group PLC at http://www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com.
Our registered address
Bank of Georgia Group PLC
29 Farm Street
London W1J 5RL
United Kingdom
Annual General Meeting
The Annual General Meeting of Bank of Georgia Group PLC (the ‘AGM’) will be held at Baker & McKenzie LLP, 280 Bishopsgate,
London EC2M 4RB. Details of the date, time and business to be conducted at the AGM is contained in the Notice of AGM, which will
be available on the Group’s website: https://www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com/information/meetings.
Shareholder enquiries
Bank of Georgia Group PLC’s share register is maintained by Computershare Investor Services PLC. Any queries about the
administration of holdings of ordinary shares, such as change of address or change of ownership, should be directed to the
address or telephone number immediately below. Holders of ordinary shares may also check details of their shareholding, subject
to passing an identity check, by visiting the Registrar’s website: www.investorcentre.co.uk or by calling the Shareholder Helpline on
+44 (0)370 873 5866.
Computershare Investor Services PLC
The Pavilions, Bridgwater Road
Bristol BS99 6ZZ
United Kingdom
Contact information
Bank of Georgia Group PLC Investor Relations
E-mail: ir@bog.ge
Forward-looking statements
Certain statements in this Annual Report and Accounts contain forward-looking statements, including, but not limited to,
statements concerning expectations, projections, objectives, targets, goals, strategies, future events, future revenues or
performance, capital expenditures, financing needs, plans or intentions relating to acquisitions, competitive strengths and
weaknesses, plans or goals relating to financial position and future operations and development. Although Bank of Georgia Group
PLC believes that the expectations and opinions reflected in such forward-looking statements are reasonable, no assurance can
be given that such expectations and opinions will prove to have been correct. By their nature, these forward-looking statements
are subject to a number of known and unknown risks, uncertainties and contingencies, and actual results and events could differ
materially from those currently being anticipated as reflected in such statements. Important factors that could cause actual results
to differ materially from those expressed or implied in forward-looking statements, certain of which are beyond our control, and
certain of which include, among other things, those described in ‘Principal risks and uncertainties’ included in this Annual Report
and Accounts, see pages 149 to 169. No part of these results or report constitutes, or shall be taken to constitute, an invitation or
inducement to invest in Bank of Georgia Group PLC or any other entity and must not be relied upon in any way in connection with
any investment decision. Bank of Georgia Group PLC undertakes no obligation to update any forward-looking statements, whether
as a result of new information, future events or otherwise, except to the extent legally required. Nothing in this document should be
construed as a profit forecast.
372
Annual Report 2023 Bank of Georgia Group PLC
www.bankofgeorgiagroup.com
BANK OF GEORGIA GROUP PLC Annual Report 2023