0001181431-09-022488 4 1 20090430 20090504 20090504 Brattlof Paul W. 0001456897 4 34 001-16417 09793711 P. O. BOX 781609 SAN ANTONIO TX 78278 NuStar Energy L.P. 0001110805 4610 742956831 DE 1231 2330 NORTH LOOP 1604 WEST SAN ANTONIO TX 78248 2109182000 2330 NORTH LOOP 1604 WEST SAN ANTONIO TX 78248 VALERO L P 20020110 SHAMROCK LOGISTICS LP 20000331 4 1 rrd241118.xml FORM 4 TAX WITHHELD FOR 4/30/09 RESTRICTED UNIT VESTING