0001181431-12-057753 4 1 20121106 20121108 20121108 Shoaf Thomas R 0001328855 4 34 001-16417 121191281 P.O. BOX 696000 SAN ANTONIO TX 78269-6000 NuStar Energy L.P. 0001110805 4610 742956831 DE 1231 2330 NORTH LOOP 1604 WEST SAN ANTONIO TX 78248 2109182000 2330 NORTH LOOP 1604 WEST SAN ANTONIO TX 78248 VALERO L P 20020110 SHAMROCK LOGISTICS LP 20000331 4 1 rrd359983.xml TRADE FOR TAXES RELATED TO VESTING